I gather from this interview with Cardinal Burke that any correction will consist of some kind of document correcting the errors in AL and that the document will go into the Church's official record alongside AL. I get the impression that he isn't expecting a response from Pope Francis and that the real purpose of the Correction is not just for our time but will be a source of reference for some future Pope, Synod or Council who can use it to assert that what AL is permitting has never been part of the Deposit of Faith held to be true always and everywhere in the universal Church. The Cardinal asks that we pray for him. I fear that he will be silenced, with the debacle in Malta being used to justify it. Thank God the Vatican can't have the interviews removed from YouTube. We must pray not just for the Cardinal but for the Pope, Bishops and the whole Church.
Fatima your post seems to agree with my post! So why the forthright statement........... I for one will stay with the clear unchanging moral teachings of Christ and his Church. As if I am not? ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- What part of my post are you finding hard to follow? From reading your post it doesn't seem to be .............." In this scripture passage we see the ugliness of deception and also how our yes for yes and our no for no are necessary for truth! Or............. Deception is truly a grave sin in the eyes of God. Or...............The Holy Spirit working through St Peter shows how God will deal with those who try to decieve the Holy Father. So the only thing it could be is .............Let us continue to pray that Our Holy Father will recieve the strength of the Holy Spirit to out those who are trying to decieve him Our Lords Vicar and Our Lords Church".
Just wondering if the Vatican has landed yet. Two weeks is a long time to be falling without a landing.
As if we haven't heard enough, the Vatican has invited a pro-abort, pro population control 'expert' Paul Ehrlich, to present a paper at a Vatican-run conference. This dreadful man predicted that large numbers of people would have died by the 1990s - basically he's a failure. Why on earth are they inviting this evil fraud? https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/v...population-bomb-author-to-speak-at-biological Also from the article: In 2015, Professor Margaret Archer, president of the Pontifical Academy of Social Sciences, slammed the Centre for Family and Human Rights Institute (C-Fam), an American pro-life research institute that monitors the United Nations, after it raised concerns about abortion and population control proponents being given a platform at a Vatican conference on climate change. “I am appointed by the Pope and responsible directly to him. I’m afraid that leaves you and your cohort out in the cold,” she told the organization at that time. This hellish woman was appointed by the Pope? Why? And why are institutes named for St John Paul II being closed down when they are often at the forefront of teaching about the sacredness of life, and the Theology of the Body? These are rhetorical questions, by the way....
SgCatholic, I've seen five views of Pope Francis on the Forum: 1) Yes, Pope Francis has made some confusing statements during interviews, at times, but what he has written and taught is in line with the Teaching of the Church. 2) Pope Francis is overly influenced by neo-modernists in the Church and has allowed confusing statements to be included in the text and footnotes of his writings. This begs for clarification. 3) Same situation as (2) but Pope Francis fully intended the confusing texts to be included. 4) Pope Francis is a heretic. 5) Pope Francis is evil. I believe Josephite is referring to (2). Safe in the Flames of the Sacred Heart!
Here we go again.... more fallout from Pope Francis ambiguous document. Malta’s bishops tell the remarried: take Communion if you feel at peace with God by Dan Hitchens posted Friday, 13 Jan 2017 Archbishop Charles Scicluna of Malta (CNS) The bishops say that avoiding sex may be 'humanly impossible' Malta’s bishops have said that remarried people should receive Communion if they think they are at peace with God. In a new document, Criteria for the Application of Chapter VIII of Amoris Laetitia, the bishops say that if “a separated or divorced person who is living in a new relationship manages, with an informed and enlightened conscience, to acknowledge and believe that he or she are [sic] at peace with God, he or she cannot be precluded from participating in the sacraments of Reconciliation and the Eucharist”. St John Paul II and Benedict XVI reaffirmed the Church’s perennial teaching that divorced and remarried Catholics cannot receive Communion, except possibly when they endeavour to live “as brother and sister”. However, the Maltese bishops say that avoiding sex with a new partner may be “impossible”. The new document underlines divisions among the world’s bishops over the Church’s traditional teaching. Since Amoris Laetitia was published in April, the bishops of Poland and Costa Rica, several North American bishops, and others, have reiterated the traditional teaching, while others have diverged from it. In November, the diocese of San Diego said that remarried Catholics may “conclude that God is calling them to return to full participation in the life of the Church and the Eucharist.” Earlier this week Cardinal Raymond Burke said that, if the San Diego interpretation were to become universal, “then the Church’s teaching on marriage is finished.” The Maltese bishops claim that Amoris Laetitia encourages a new practice because of footnote 351. This, in reference to the integration of people in “irregular situations”, says: “In certain cases, this can include the help of the sacraments.” Although Pope Francis has said he cannot remember this footnote, it has provoked much debate. Some have argued that it reaffirms John Paul’s teaching in Familiaris Consortio: “Reconciliation in the sacrament of Penance which would open the way to the Eucharist, can only be granted to those who, repenting of having broken the sign of the Covenant and of fidelity to Christ, are sincerely ready to undertake a way of life that is no longer in contradiction to the indissolubility of marriage. “This means, in practice, that when, for serious reasons, such as for example the children’s upbringing, a man and a woman cannot satisfy the obligation to separate, they ‘take on themselves the duty to live in complete continence, that is, by abstinence from the acts proper to married couples.’” However, the Maltese bishops say that couples should instead “examine the possibility of conjugal continence”. The bishops refer to “complex situations where the choice of living ‘as brothers and sisters’ becomes humanly impossible”. Four cardinals, including Cardinal Burke, have asked Pope Francis to clarify that Amoris Laetitia does not encourage divergence from the Church’s traditional teaching. One, Cardinal Walter Brandmüller, has said: “Whoever thinks that persistent adultery and the reception of Holy Communion are compatible is a heretic and promotes schism.”
Thats the $64,000 question! It is obvious (to me) that he is being decieved. Maybe some cunning and decietful person or persons in authority in the church, thought that if Cardinal Jorge Bergoglio was to become pope, they would be able to easy manipulate him and take advantage of his good nature! When looking at facts we see.......... * Many people are ghost writing for our Holy Father! * Many people are also spokepersons for our Holy Father! * Our Holy Father is not a noted theologian! * When our Holy Father speaks he states many things simplisticly, hap hazardously and even dangerously and precariously, because I think he is trying to emphasize the plight of the poor which is a cause that is close to his heart! I am applying all of the above to help me understand and differentiate his sincerity as the vicar of Christ, while also juxtaposing the sorry state of affairs currently within the church! I will probably get slammed, as being the perverbal ostrich for my above deductions but there you have it!
Listening to the interview with Cardinal Burke, it is clear to me that he asks us to be charitable and kind when we speak about the concerns we have over AL. If we truly want to support the serious undertaking of these Cardinals, I still feel convinced we the lay folk have to take Cardinal Burkes advice and pray and immerse ourselves in the faithful practice of our Holy Faith. I Julia, can state I hold most dear the Catholic teaching on the indissolubility of holy matrimony as well as holy orders, and will, with the Grace of God continue to share my long held belief with anyone who disputes that Truth. These four Cardinals are the known Cardinals who represent many more Cardinals and Bishops who are equally concerned about the outcome of AL in practise within communities. And thank God, the men who have been placed by God in the order of Grace to take up this challenge are manning their posts admirably. We the lay have a duty of care and responsibility to man our posts and pray and make sacrifice to bring us through the crisis intact, as well as our Cardinals, Bishops and Priests. Cardinal Burke reminds me so much of Father John O'Connor RIP, and it breaks my heart to think that he could indeed suffer the same fate. Which is why I beg all who care for and love our Holy Faith to pray, sacrifice, and love all concerned; but be most charitable out of respect for Cardinal Burke when we express our genuine concerns if we feel the need to articulate our feelings.
Thank you for this viewpoint Josephite. I hesitate to comment very often on these things because in my heart I do not "know" which of Mario's above numbered popular MOG opinions (TY for summing them up so nicely Mario!) is actually true. The only one I firmly believe to NOT be true is #1. Prophesy indicates so many evil things, which I am at peace over because I know that God has not abandoned us and we will eventually be rescued. However, the role of the pope is difficult to discern. Thank you for presenting opinion #2
https://canonlawblog.wordpress.com/2017/01/13/the-maltese-disaster/ The Maltese disaster The bishops of Malta, in a document that can only be called disastrous, repeatedly invoking Pope Francis’ Amoris laetitia, have directly approved divorced and remarried Catholics taking holy Communion provided they feel “at peace with God”. Unlike, say, the Argentine document on Amoris which, one could argue, left just enough room for an orthodox reading, however widely it also left the doors open for abuse by others, the Maltese bishops in their document come straight out and say it: holy Communion is for any Catholic who feels “at peace with God” and the Church’s ministers may not say No to such requests. In my view the Maltese bishops have effectively invited the Catholics entrusted to them (lay faithful and clergy alike!) to commit a number of objectively gravely evil acts. That their document was, moreover, published in L’Osservatore Romano, exacerbates matters for it deprives Vatican representatives of the ‘plausible deniability’ that they could have claimed (and might soon enough wish they could claim), as it becomes known that the Maltese bishops went beyond what even Amoris, if interpreted narrowly, seemed to permit. For now, I make just a few points. 1. The Maltese bishops have fallen completely for the canonically and ecclesiologically false view that an individual’s assessment of his or her own readiness to receive holy Communion (see c. 916) controls a minister’s decision to administer the sacrament (see c. 915). In Malta now, anyone who approaches for the sacraments should be recognized as being “at peace with God”. Objective evidence to the contrary is simply no longer relevant. Canon 916 is thus eviscerated, Canon 915 is effectively repudiated. 2. The Maltese bishops do not seem to know what the word “conjugal” means. They think that non-married people can practice “conjugal” virtues and that they can decide about whether to engage in “conjugal” acts. Nonsense and, coming from bishops, inexcusable nonsense at that. Non-married people can have sex, of course, but Catholic pastoral integrity does not hold such sexual acts on par with the physically identical, but truly conjugal, acts as performed by married persons. 3. The Maltese bishops, by extending their document to the sacrament of Reconciliation, have basically instructed their priests not to withhold absolution from divorced-and-remarried Catholics who refuse to repent of their “public and permanent adultery” (CCC 2384) even to the point of abstaining from sexual (nb: sexual not “conjugal”) relations. Incredibly, such a directive raises the specter of green-lighting sacrilegious confessions and the commission of solicitation in confession. No priest should want either on his conscience, let alone both. 4. The Maltese bishops even managed to take swipes at Baptism and Confirmation by opening the door to divorced-and-remarried Catholics serving as godparents contrary to the expectations of Canon 874 § 1, 3º. See CLSA New Comm (2001) 1062-1063. There are other serious problems with the Maltese document but the above should suffice to show why it is, quite simply, a disaster.
In Malta now, anyone who approaches for the sacraments should be recognized as being “at peace with God”. AL doesn’t concern a danger for the faith...Card. Müller View attachment 5987
Kumbaya. I have a feeling some form of universal salvation is coming next. Isn't the servant of servants full of mercy?
! The next step in the great unraveling of Church teaching on marriage. A very slippery slope- O see from where we have fallen! This is from parts of no.115 and 116 in Veritatis Splendor by St. John Paul II: ...Each of us knows how important is the teaching which represents the central theme of this Encyclical and which is today being restated with the authority of the Successor of Peter. Each of us can see the seriousness of what is involved, not only for individuals but also for the whole of society, with the reaffirmation of the universality and immutability of the moral commandments, particularly those which prohibit always and without exception intrinsically evil acts. In acknowledging these commandments, Christian hearts and our pastoral charity listen to the call of the One who "first loved us" (1Jn 4:19). God asks us to be holy as he is holy (cf. Lev 19:2), to be — in Christ — perfect as he is perfect (cf. Mt 5:48). The unwavering demands of that commandment are based upon God's infinitely merciful love (cf. Lk 6:36), and the purpose of that commandment is to lead us, by the grace of Christ, on the path of that fullness of life proper to the children of God. 116. We have the duty, as Bishops, to be vigilant that the word of God is faithfully taught. My Brothers in the Episcopate, it is part of our pastoral ministry to see to it that this moral teaching is faithfully handed down and to have recourse to appropriate measures to ensure that the faithful are guarded from every doctrine and theory contrary to it. In carrying out this task we are all assisted by theologians; even so, theological opinions constitute neither the rule nor the norm of our teaching. Its authority is derived, by the assistance of the Holy Spirit and in communion cum Petro et sub Petro, from our fidelity to the Catholic faith which comes from the Apostles. As Bishops, we have the grave obligation to be personally vigilant that the "sound doctrine" (1 Tim 1:10) of faith and morals is taught in our Dioceses.... All I can do is weep! Where is Peter? O Mary conceived without sin, pray for us who have recourse to you! Lord Jesus, Head of the Church, save us!
The following is what I read today. It is from an encyclical of Pope Clement XIII in 1761 In Dominico Argo (On Instruction in the Faith) : "In the Lord's field, for the tending of which Divine Providence placed Us as overseer, there is nothing which demands as much vigilant care and unremitting labor in its cultivation than guarding the good seed of Catholic teaching which the Apostles received from Jesus Christ and handed on to Us. If in laziness this is neglected, the enemy of the human race will sow weeds while the workers sleep. Then weeds will be found which should be committed to the flames rather than good grain to store in the barns. However, St. Paul strongly encourages Us to protect the faith that the saints handed on to Us.[1] He told Timothy to preserve the sacred trust[2] because dangerous times were coming[3] when evil and deceitful men would exist in the Church of God.[4] The insidious tempters would use their work to try to infect unwary minds with errors which are hostile to evangelical truth. It often happens that certain unworthy ideas come forth in the Church of God which, although they directly contradict each other, plot together to undermine the purity of the Catholic faith in some way. It is very difficult to cautiously balance our speech between both enemies in such a way that We seem to turn Our backs on none of them, but to shun and condemn both enemies of Christ equally. Meanwhile the matter is such that diabolical error, when it has artfully colored its lies, easily clothes itself in the likeness of truth while very brief additions or changes corrupt the meaning of expressions; and confession, which usually works salvation, sometimes, with a slight change, inches toward death." The entire document can be found here http://www.papalencyclicals.net/Clem13/c13indom.htm
Mario, It is extremely sad, I feel the same sorrow as you. I don't know what to do! but pray and sacrifice. It seems the holy doctrines of truth of the Holy Bride of Christ (Our Holy Catholic Church) are being torn assunder by the hour. Peter slept as Our Lord agonised alone in the garden of Gethsemane and perspiration fell from Our Lord as great drops of blood! August Queen of the Heavens, heavenly sovereign of the Angels Thou who from the beginning received from God the power and the mission to crush the head of satan, Humbly we beseech Thee to send thy Holy Legions, So that under Thy command and through Thy power, They may pursue the demons everywhere, Combat them, suppress their boldness and drive them back into the abyss. Amen Oh who is like unto God! Mary Thou shall always be our Queen, our Mother and our Hope. Holy Angels and Archangels defend us, guard us and protect us. Amen. May St Joseph and St Michael, the great defenders of the Holy Catholic Church rouse our Shepards from their sleep and us from our Sleep also. Amen.
https://www.lifesitenews.com/opinion/2-2-can-make-5-papal-confidante-denies-the-certainty-of-catholic-faith ‘2 + 2 can make 5’? Papal confidante denies the certainty of Catholic faith Matthew McCusker January 13, 2017 (Voice of the Family) – Rev Antonio Spadaro S.J., editor-in-chief of La Civiltà Cattolica and confidante of Pope Francis, stirred controversy when he stated on Twitter last week: Theology is not #Mathematics. 2 + 2 in #Theology can make 5. Because it has to do with #God and real #life of #people... — Antonio Spadaro (@antoniospadaro) January 5, 2017 "Two and two makes four” is frequently used as an example of a statement which is obviously true and “Two and two can make five” as an example of an obvious untruth. It is often used in the context of the abuse of power by those who would impose falsehood on others in order to strengthen that power and impose their ideology. The most famous example of this kind of usage is probably that of George Orwell who wrote, in Nineteen Eighty-Four, that: In the end the Party would announce that two and two, made five and you would have to believe it. It was inevitable that they should make that claim sooner or later: the logic of their position demanded it. Not merely the validity of experience, but the very existence of external reality, was tacitly denied by their philosophy. Orwell’s words could almost be used as a commentary on Rev Antonio Spadaro’s statement. Spadaro is a vocal defender of the Apostolic Exhortation Amoris Laetitia, which many commentators consider to stand in direct contradiction on very many points, to the teaching of the Catholic Church. It is because of these contradictions, according to a natural interpretation of the text, that four cardinals privately requested clarification from Pope Francis as to the meaning of a number of these passages. Pope Francis made it clear to the cardinals that he was not going to answer their dubia, prompting them to bring their questions to the attention of the universal Church. Since the publication of the dubia, figures close to Pope Francis, such as Antonio Spadaro, have made it clear that they do not expect an answer to be forthcoming. Defenders of the above propositions in Amoris Laetitia are in the unenviable position of having at one and the same time to assent (or at least publicly profess to assent) both to the teaching of the Catholic Church and to statements in Amoris Laetitia that, according to any reasonable interpretation, would naturally seem to contradict that doctrine. However for the intellect to assent, at the same time, to two contradictory propositions is contrary to its own nature, which is to know the truth. It is impossible for two contradictory propositions to be true at the same time; this is the law of non-contradiction. Those who attempt to adhere both to the Catholic faith and these propositions in Amoris Laetitia are forced to violate this first principle of human reasoning, without which it is impossible for human beings to assent to anything as certain. If two contradictory propositions are both held to be true at the same time then this necessarily implies a denial of the existence of an objective truth that can be certainly known by human reason and thus the existence of propositions that can be affirmed as true or false. It is little surprise then to see that a member of the “party” defending Amoris Laetitia is now announcing that, in theology, two and two can make five, because, to borrow Orwell’s words “it was inevitable that they should make that claim sooner or later: the logic of their position demanded it.” Theology is a more certain science than mathematics Rev. Antonio Spadaro’s central claim is that whereas in mathematics two and two always make four, such is not necessarily the case in theology. While Spadaro does not explain his position in more detail the obvious conclusion to draw is that one cannot reach the same kind of certainty in theological questions as one can in mathematics. He seems to imply that whereas mathematics is an objective science in which there is always a right and a wrong answer, theology is more subjective and its conclusions need not be regarded as always true or false. This position is wholly false. Theology is a science which has God as its primary object, and divine revelation as its secondary object. St Thomas tells us, in the first question of the Summa Theologica, that theology has a “greater certitude” than any other science.[1] Mathematics, and other similar speculative sciences, “derive their certitude from the natural light of human reason, which can err.” Theology on the other hand “derives its certitude from the light of divine knowledge, which cannot be misled.” Thus the Church can call upon Catholics to give full and certain assent to everything that the Church defines and teaches as being revealed by God, and reject everything that stands in contradiction to it. Catholics are called, with the assistance of divine grace, to persevere in the practice of the theological virtue of faith, “whereby, inspired and assisted by the grace of God, we believe that the things which He has revealed are true; not because of the intrinsic truth of the things, viewed by the natural light of reason, but because of the authority of God Himself who reveals them, and Who can neither be deceived nor deceive.”[2] Agnosticism and Modernism In Nineteen Eighty-Four George Orwell identifies the denial of “not merely the validity of experience, but the very existence of external reality” as being at the root of the Party’s assertion that “two plus two made five.” This is of relevance to us in the context of our discussion concerning the objective nature of theology. The heresy of modernism denies the ability of the human intellect to assent with certainty to the truth of any reality beyond the sensory order. For the adherent of modernism “human reason is confined entirely within the field of phenomena, that is to say, to things that are perceptible to the senses, and in the manner in which they are perceptible; it has no right and no power to transgress these limits."[3] In this system human reason is “incapable of lifting itself up to God, and of recognising his existence, even by means of visible things.”[4] It is therefore impossible for man to give absolute assent to any doctrine concerning God or the supernatural order. Therefore while modernism does not deny the validity of sensory experience or the existence of an external reality per se, it does deny the validity of sensory experience in assisting us in adhering with certainty to conclusions about external reality beyond sensory phenomena. Thus it makes it impossible to affirm that any theological proposition is certainly true, and thus, once these premises are accepted, anything might be true in theology – even a proposition on the same level of absurdity as “two and two makes five.” Divine revelation is for our salvation In the first article of the first question of the Summa Theologica St Thomas Aquinas explains the true nobility of the science of theology: It was necessary for man’s salvation that there should be a knowledge revealed by God besides philosophical science built up by human reason. Firstly, indeed, because man is directed to God, as to an end that surpasses the grasp of his reason: ‘The eye hath not seen, O God, besides Thee, what things Thou hast prepared for them that wait for Thee’ (Isaiah 64:4). But the end must first be known by men who are to direct their thoughts and actions to the end. Hence it was necessary for the salvation of man that certain truths which exceed human reason should be made known to him by divine revelation.[5] These truths are a gift from God to enable us to enjoy eternal happiness with Him. Let us honour God by adhering to them with certain and unwavering faith. Notes: [1] St Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologica, I. q.1 a.5. [2] First Vatican Council, Dogmatic Constitution on the Catholic Faith. [3] Pope St Pius X, Pascendi dominici gregis, (1908), No. 6. [4] Pascendi, No. 6. [5] Summa Theologica, I. q.1 a.1.