Yes, he was letting Cardinal Sarah know that his predecessors hadn't implemented what Vatican 11 wanted. I was thinking of this paragraph, particularly the text I have underlined: Here it can be added that, in the light of the motu proprio, “fideliter” of § 3 of the canon implies a threefold fidelity: in primis, to the original text; then to the particular language in which it is translated, and finally to the comprehension of the text by the recipients If there are to be blessings of homosexual unions, and perhaps eventually adulterous unions, some kind of liturgy will be used and I doubt it will be restricted to a few psalms. Does that give Bishops the right to use some kind of "inclusive" language which they and the recipients of the text at a gay marriage ceremony (one German priest said we don't call it a Sacrament) comprehend?
https://onepeterfive.com/is-the-vat...to-remove-catholic-teaching-on-homosexuality/ UPDATE: On Twitter, Michael Giedraitis says that this language — “they do not choose their inclination — appeared in the original 1994 version of the Catechism.
Yes, they’ve put out a correction. But the fact that mistranslation is still on the Vatican website is still very troubling. View attachment 7423 View attachment 7422
Welcome Kristian You have found a place of clarity here amidst the sea of delusion that is plaguing the Church. Contrary to David's post which was trying to lead you away from this site, I would advise you to stay so you will not founder in these confusing times. The answer is not as complicated as it may seem Kristian. Dogmas can evolve, but they can never contradict what has come before. They can lead us to a fuller understanding, but not the opposite understanding. Anyone who tells you otherwise is leading you astray.
I have more and more been coming to the conclusion that there are two churches forming up. One the existing Catholic Church and one a false church in every sense of the word. This forum is made up predominantly of a faithful remnant loyal to what the Church has always taught. This is the true Church. Then there are those who are adopting a Nu-church stance. They want a church that condones and blesses homosexuality, adultery, and other clearly grave sins. A worldly church. Sad as it is to say I think Nu-church people do not share the Catholic faith anymore. They are not Catholic now and perhaps they never were. All they do when they come here is try to poison the well. They may not realize that is what they are doing, but it is what they are doing nonetheless. This is not my forum, and I truly respect Padraig's opinion and his running of it, but I think this site is being formed as a safe haven for the faithful remnant and people who try to sow a false Gospel have no place here. That is just my personal opinion. Error has no rights. These false "catholics" may share our buildings, but not our faith.
I don't doubt your honesty, Praetorian but the irony of what you say above needs a response. Yes, there is a separation developing in the Catholic world. The critical matter to discern is which is the authentic one. The Christian Church has had this problem from the beginning. The 'Nu-churches' have always failed in the long term because they separated themselves from the Pope, often with good intentions. The current situation is no different in principle to previous attempts to find a 'purer' faith.
On the contrary, this time it’s the pope leading the Nuchurch into schism while Catholics stay faithful to the 2000 year constant teachings of Christ. These days will be shortened lest even the elect be lead astray.
In their attempts to change what they saw as wrong in the Church, St Francis of Assisi and Martin Luther took different paths! One was lead by the Holy Spirit the other was lead by satan. In St Francis time the church was wealthy and many abuses of greed and position afflicted the Church hierarchy. St Francis heard Our Lord say.... 'rebuild my church' and after taking this literally for a few years, rebuilding churches that were in ruins or in dire need of repair, he realised that it was poverty of spirit and purity of Gods word, that God was calling him to and so he rebuilt the church from within! and with Gods leading! by bringing back a deep sense of the cross and a love of poverty and humility, he preached in rags to the eager ears of the hungry for truth, catholic faithful. In Martin Luther's time he saw many abuses of greed and position afflicting the Church hierarchy but instead of doing as St Francis did, he turned away from Our Lord Jesus’ instituted Church and decided to trash all that was holy in Our Lords teachings of scripture! and the magisterium of Our Lords Church! and he allowed himself to be lead by satan and departrd from truth entirely! In our current time, I believe, we the members of the MoG Forum, are taking a leaf out of St Francis book by doing what we can within the church!..... With our concern and prayer, Jesus is once again leading us to poverty, to sacrifice and to humiliations to stay any heresies, liberties or excesses that we witness taking hold of our Lords most precious Priests and Bishops. I believe none of us have left the true faith, as Martin Luther or others have done! Praise God we will stay the course! St Joseph and St Michael pray for us. Amen!
We're not doing anything, except staying in the exact same place we always were. We're not the separators, but the ones being separated from by people who, in their objections and change from our position, directly traceable back to Christ Himself, are effectively 'protesting' what we stand for. It is incredible to think that for two millenia since Christ, and for two before Him, sodomy had been always an abomination, and not just for Judeo-Christians and that this radical change has really occurred in only the last ten years or so, but how universal and unquestionable this has become. The majority of people can so easily be brainwashed, manipulated or coerced. Political events could be directed in such a way that our chastisement, at least in Europe, will be in the form of subjection to Sharia Law. This will probably mean the lukewarm Christians and the out-and-out atheists submitting to Mohammedanism, but it will certainly sort out the homosexualists and feminists in a way that will make them long for the days of Christian dominance. The remnant of faithful Christians would not find it easy under Mohammedan rule, but, frankly, this would not be so suppressive as what the liberals have in store for us. The Mohammedans sometimes get stirred up and attempt to force-convert Christians, but the passion fades and disappears for long periods. The liberals never seem to let up. Goodness, we're between a rock and a hard place when I'm starting to look optimistically upon the Mohammedan invasion! "Low cards are what I've got But I'll play this hand whether I like it or not I'm sworn to uphold the laws of God You could put me out in front of a firing squad". (Dylan)
There is a very simple test as to which would be the New False 'Church' 'and which would be the Church itself. Which , adheres to the authentic Teachings of the Church for the last 2,000 years? It is just as simple as that. Its not complicated. It's not Rocket Science , its just as simple as that.
02 feb "Humanae Vitae" Under Siege. But It Will Have To Go Over Wojtyla and Caffarra's Dead Bodies Fifty years after its publication, Paul VI’s encyclical “Humanae Vitae” against artificial contraception is now solidly in the overhaul shop, as Settimo Cielo documented in the previous post. And it is evident that Pope Francis’s intention is to bring about the reversal - which means in practice to legitimize contraceptives - in the most soothing manner, as if this were a matter of a natural and proper evolution, devoid of rupture, in perfect continuity with the preceding magisterium of the Church and with the “true” profound dynamic of the encyclical itself. But if one looks just a bit behind it, this artifice does not by any means appear easy to realize. There are words of Francis’s predecessors that rise up like mountains against a change of the doctrine of “Humanae Vitae.” They are words that the proponents of change take care not to cite. But there they are, irremovable. There is in particular an address by John Paul II of November 12, 1988 that should suffice on its own to block the way. Twenty years had gone by since the publication of “Humanae Vitae,” and Pope Karol Wojtyla took the opportunity to defend it as the be-all and end-all, carving into stone words like the following: “This is not a matter of a doctrine invented by man: it has been inscribed by the creating hand of God within the very nature of the human person, and has been confirmed by him in revelation. Bringing it into question, therefore, is equivalent to refusing God himself the obedience of our intelligence. It is equivalent to preferring the light of our reason to the light of divine wisdom, thus falling into the darkness of error and ultimately undermining other fundamental mainstays of Christian doctrine. In front of him were bishops and theologians from all over the world, meeting in Rome for a major congress on none other than “Humanae Vitae.” And John Paul II wanted precisely to identify and refute the reasons that had led so many theologians and pastors to reject what Paul VI taught in that encyclical. * The first of these reasons - he said - concerns a mistaken understanding of the role of conscience: “During these years, following the contestation of ‘Humanae Vitae,’ the Christian doctrine of moral conscience has itself been brought into question, accepting the idea of conscience as creator the moral norm. In this way has been radically broken that bond of obedience to the holy will of the Creator in which man’s very dignity consists. Conscience, in fact, is the ‘place’ in which man is illuminated by a light that does not stem from his created and always fallible reason, but from the very wisdom of the Word, in which all has been created. ‘Conscience,’ as Vatican II wonderfully writes, ‘is the most secret core and sanctuary of a man. There he is alone with God, Whose voice echoes in his depths’ (Gaudium et Spes, 16). From this - he continued - is unleashed a bad understanding of the Church’s magisterium: “Since the Magisterium of the Church has been instituted by Christ the Lord to illuminate the conscience, […] one cannot, therefore, say that a believer has undertaken a diligent search for the truth if he does not take into account what the Magisterium teaches: if, equating it to any other source of knowledge, he sets himself up as its judge; if, in doubt, he follows instead his own opinion or that of theologians, preferring it to the certain teaching of the Magisterium.” Just as the binding force of the moral norm is also undermined: “Paul VI, qualifying the contraceptive act as intrinsically illicit, intended to teach that the moral norm is such as not to admit exceptions: no personal or social circumstance has ever been able to, can, or will be able to render such an act ordered in itself. The existence of particular norms in reference to the intra-worldly activity of man, endowed with such obligatory force as to exclude always and in any case the possibility of exceptions, is a constant teaching of the Magisterium of the Church that cannot be brought into question by the Catholic theologian.” The error is so grave - John Paul II continued - that it brings into doubt the holiness of God: “Here one touches upon a central point of the Christian doctrine concerning God and man. On close inspection what is brought into question in rejecting that teaching is the very idea of the holiness of God. In predestining us to be holy and immaculate in his sight, he has created us ‘in Christ Jesus for good works, which God prepared beforehand, that we should walk in them’ (Eph 2:10): those moral norms are simply the demand, from which no historical circumstance can dispense, of the holiness of God who participates in the concrete, and indeed not in the abstract, in the individual human person.” It nullifies the cross of Christ: “Not only that, but this negation renders vain the cross of Christ (cf. 1 Cor 1:17). In becoming flesh, the Word entered fully into our everyday existence, which is articulated in concrete human acts; in dying for our sins, he re-created us in the original holiness that must express itself in our everyday intra-worldly activity.” And finally, it involves the loss of man: “And again: that negation implies, as a logical consequence, that there is no truth about man that is exempt from the flux of historical becoming. The nullification of the mystery of God, as always, ends up in the nullification of the mystery of man, and the non-recognition of the rights of God, as always, ends up in the negation of the dignity of man.” * In closing this address, John Paul II urged the professors of moral theology in the seminaries to transmit with absolute fidelity the message of “Humanae Vitae.” And in particular he entrusted this task to the Pontifical Institute for Studies on Marriage and Family, which he founded in Rome a few years earlier and which in that very year, 1988, had created its first foreign branch, in Washington. The head of the institute at that time was a theologian named Carlo Caffarra, who was also a consultant for the congregation for the doctrine of the faith headed at the time by Joseph Ratzinger, as well as being one of pope Wojtyla’s closest coworkers in matters concerning life and family. And Caffarra’s mind and pen are easily recognizable in the text of the address cited above. Caffarra was archbishop of Bologna from 2003 to 2015, and was one of the four cardinals who in 2016 submitted to Pope Francis five “dubia” on the correct interpretation of “Amoris Laetitia,” the postsynodal exhortation that is being used today as the source of a paradigm shift in the interpretation of “Humanae Vitae”: Francis has never responded to the “dubia,” nor to the request to give an audience to the proponent cardinals, sent to him in a letter from Caffarra in the spring of 2017. Caffarra died Last September 6, and even since then the pope has refrained from any gesture of understanding and esteem for him, even on October 1 when he went on a visit to Bologna. As for the pontifical institute that still bears the name of John Paul II, Pope Francis refounded it last year with a new name: “For Marriage and Family Sciences,” and above all with a new grand chancellor in the person of Monsignor Vincenzo Paglia, engrossed in “rethinking” the encyclical “Humanae Vitae” and therefore in legitimizing contraceptives, because - he says - “the norms are there to enliven human beings, not to operate robots.” * (The address cited above is in any case not the only one in which John Paul II reproposed and defended the teaching of “Humanae Vitae.” Another can be recalled from June 5, 1987, addressed to participants in a study meeting on the natural regulation of fertility. And even more important are the references to “Humanae Vitae” that he included in the exhortation “Familiaris Consortio” of 1981 and in the encyclical “Veritatis Splendor” of 1993).
Very, very enlightening interview on the Vatican deal with Communist China. Go to 2:55, but if you don´t have time to watch the whole thing (definitely worth it) go to 15:40 for the new regulations that are now in practice.
What you mention here of the two Churches struck me as very close to the reflexions on Benedict XVI abdication by Agamben. This is from the comments section in the Amazon entry of the book: “Agamben points out that Pope Benedict had published an article approving the position of a Donatist heretic named Tyconius that the church, like the person of Jesus, is "bipartite." In the Church's case, the bipartite division is, pace Augustine, between the good and devout followers of Christ and the dark and damned sinners. At the end of time, the two bodies will be disclosed, but the end of time is being restrained, according to Tyconius, Augustine and Pope Benedict, in Agamben's reading, by the Church [which is the ‘Katechon’ as long as the popes are faithful to it].” And this is an excerpt from the book in the same line: "The history of the end (which does not coincide with the end of history) is therefore presented in Paul as a mystery, that is to say, as a sacred drama in which the salvation and damnation of human beings is at stake, a drama that can be seen and understood (as happens for the initiated) or seen and not understood (this is the case of the damned)." https://www.amazon.com/Mystery-Evil...071YS79DX/ref=cm_cr_arp_d_product_top?ie=UTF8 What’s amazing is that Agamben is a non catholic secular philosopher, follower of Foucault and other similar post modern thinkers , though from reading this ideas he may have grown closer to the Church if not fully embraced the faith in recent years.
Ah, the fickle press and their beloved "Pope of the people".....given a chance to attack the position of the papacy they'll gladly accommodate. AP Exclusive: Despite denial, Pope got abuse victim's letter VATICAN CITY (AP) — Pope Francis received a victim's letter in 2015 that graphically detailed how a priest sexually abused him and how other Chilean clergy ignored it, contradicting the pope's recent insistence that no victims had come forward to denounce the cover-up, the letter's author and members of Francis' own sex- abuse commission have told The Associated Press. The fact that Francis received the eight-page letter, obtained by the AP, challenges his insistence that he has "zero tolerance" for sex abuse and cover-ups. It also calls into question his stated empathy with abuse survivors, compounding the most serious crisis of his five-year papacy. The scandal exploded last month when Francis' trip to South America was marred by protests over his vigorous defense of Bishop Juan Barros, who is accused by victims of covering up the abuse by the Rev. Fernando Karadima. During the trip, Francis callously dismissed accusations against Barros as "slander," seemingly unaware that victims had placed him at the scene of Karadima's crimes. On the plane home, confronted by an AP reporter, the pope said: "You, in all good will, tell me that there are victims, but I haven't seen any, because they haven't come forward." MORE: https://www.yahoo.com/news/ap-exclusive-despite-denial-pope-got-abuse-victims-090653836.html
St Francis renewed and reunited the Church with a deeper understanding of the faith - his reverence to the Church was noteworthy, as is the case with all the saints. He brought the Nativity and Epiphany to our homes. Luther tore the Church apart with a violence not seen in the whole history of the Church, and eradicated the Crèche from Christian homes, among other things.