Heresy is primarily a sin of words and intellect,rather than action: Catholic Dictionary Term HERESY Definition Commonly refers to a doctrinal belief held in opposition to the recognized standards of an established system of thought. Theologically it means an opinion at variance with the authorized teachings of any church, notably the Christian, and especially when this promotes separation from the main body of faithful believers. In the Roman Catholic Church, heresy has a very specific meaning. Anyone who, after receiving baptism, while remaining nominally a Christian, pertinaciously denies or doubts any of the truths that must be believed with divine and Catholic faith is considered a heretic. Accordingly four elements must be verified to constitute formal heresy; previous valid baptism, which need not have been in the Catholic Church; external profession of still being a Christian, otherwise a person becomes an apostate; outright denial or positive doubt regarding a truth that the Catholic Church has actually proposed as revealed by God; and the disbelief must be morally culpable, where a nominal Christian refuses to accept what he knows is a doctrinal imperative. Objectively, therefore, to become a heretic in the strict canonical sense and be excommunicated from the faithful, one must deny or question a truth that is taught not merely on the authority of the Church but on the word of God revealed in the Scriptures or sacred tradition. Subjectively a person must recognize his obligation to believe. If he acts in good faith, as with most persons brought up in non-Catholic surroundings, the heresy is only material and implies neither guilt nor sin against faith. (Etym. Latin haeresis, from the Greek hairesis, a taking, choice, sect, heresy.)" Apostasy, of which the Holy Father has also been accused by some here, consists of : Apostasy a fide, or perfidiæ Perfidiæ is the complete and voluntary abandonment of the Christian religion, whether the apostate embraces another religion such as Paganism, Judaism, Mohammedanism, etc., or merely makes profession of Naturalism, Rationalism, etc." Pope Francis has neither abandoned Christianity nor disavowed any of its doctrines, and until he does so he is neither a heretic nor an apostate,regardless of any other unwise actions he may take.
Josephite, your voice IS like a little child's, but there are others whose voices are not at all like yours.
On the contrary, his material heresy has been well documented repeatedly here and elsewhere. That he is a material heretic is beyond debate among orthodox Catholics. He has not yet been declared a formal heretic by the college of cardinals, but he is, demonstrably, a material heretic.
Divide and conquer won't work around here. You accuse us of slander, and of being dishonest and dishonourable. These are serious accusations and would be more effective if you were more specific and provided some evidence and examples of where this is so. Nothing here is being invented, but is commentary upon documentation of opinion from sources that simply cannot be dismissed. It is not as if the situation lacks precedent. Had the general population been totally meek and passive during the Arian Crisis, and gone along with their 'betters' in the hierarchy of the time, Christianity would almost have disappeared from the face of the Earth. On the contrary, they held on grimly for the true Faith until the small minority of true bishops, led by Athanasius, overturned the heretics. There is no specific heresy at the moment, but a very close sailing to the wind. Nevertheless, there are very many questionable prudential decisions being taken by this papacy and its allies with which people have every right to disagree. Although, due to a lack of direct answers, Amoris Laetitia and its footnote may not be heretical from the Pope's point of view, I strongly suspect that the bishops in Argentina, Malta, Braga and so on that are actually opting for the liberal interpretation may not have that defense. Pope Francis knows that if he remains silent, the most he can be really accused of is the weakness of not resisting heresy. This was the charitable verdict of St. Athanasius upon Pope Julius during the Arian Crisis. Surely, it is the duty of those who adhere to the perennial teaching of the Church to warn of equivocations that will certainly cause immeasurable damage to the Church and its people? You may have no fear of schism on our part. We're going nowhere, but staying in the exact same place as Catholics of all times and places until 2013. There have been wicked popes before. Acknowledging this does not make anyone a sedevacantist, as you appear to suspect. It is Pope Francis that has taken it upon himself to take issue with the Lord Jesus Christ Himself.
Hi Cynthia, This is the ultimate battle between good and evil. Satanism or moral relativism vs God and objective morality. The New World Order or Jesus Christ definition of heaven and right and wrong. Unfortunately, PF is on the side of the globalists and against objective morality. Whether he is knowing or unknowing that he is on the side of evil is not my concern. My concern is the countless souls being lost and the side he is on which is satan's side.
I don’t know about the Dominicans as a whole, but I can definitely testify that a parish in Columbus OH I attended for 2 years is run by Dominican priests. This parish is the most faithful, orthodox novus ordo parish I’ve ever attended. The ordinary is sung in Latin, polyphony music, gorgeous church, the people use the altar rail, no altar girls. Very faithful, orthodox sermons
The example of sanctions that you provide deals with formal heresy. To accuse, in good faith and with substantial evidence, another of material, or even formal heresy could hardly be necessarily construed as itself heresy? That would imply that a prosecutor acting in good faith who loses a trial could be accused of wrongful prosecution. The same would apply to accusations of apostasy. Still, the key word is 'formal'. This is not a formal setting and has no judicial authority. It is a forum of concerned orthodox Catholics trying, via their collective abilities of both faith and reason, to cope with and understand the undeniable confusion being created by this papacy in a multitude of issues. From time to time, in a moment of frustration or outrage, someone may shoot a little bit injudiciously from the lip/hip, but this would be a clear example of the person who '...has not been diligent (prudently weighing the issues involved)'. I can think of no regular here who has been 'formally guilty of heresy, apostasy or schism', or sedevacantism, for that matter. If someone wanders into material versions of these, they would be quickly corrected and would be grateful to be so. The greatest wish of everyone here, as far as I can see and I include myself, is to stay faithful to the Holy Roman and Apostolic Catholic Church and for all their straying loved ones and indeed all humanity to hop on board. We are just concerned about the captain of the ship. These concerns are very clearly and comprehensively discussed throughout this thread. They cannot be easily dismissed.
Modern Catholic Dictionary by Fr. John A. Hardon, S.J. HERETIC. A person professing heresy. Ecclesiastical law distinguishes between a formal heretic, as one who is sinfully culpable, and a material heretic, who is not morally guilty for professing what may be objectively heretical doctrine.
David, I like you have disagreements with many of the posters of MOG. Its a good thing though. Each of us see views that are different than our own, which should at least cause us to question our own beliefs. God Bless You and keep posting. PS: I've tried my hardest to believe as you do about our current Pope. In my opinion, he is falling in line with the Jesuits described by Malachi Martin 30-40 yrs ago.
Hi Praetorian. I am pretty new here and love all the views posted here. Although I disagree with 99.9555% of David's feelings about the current Pope. I do tend to agree that the "Truth" is a difficult path, and that dogma has developed over time. I did not think this way until this Pope was elected. His election has caused me to question things I never thought I would question. I always wonder.... What if this Pope, Cardinals and Bishops made "with God's divine approval" that a Dogma you and most Catholics "know" as Truth is no longer Dogma. Is it "Truth"? I only ask this because I think I've seen that the leaders of The Church have introduced, pushed, furthered, encouraged etc.... man's views and said they were approved by God. I firmly believe that the majority of us on this site agree 95% of the time(earlier I posted 99%, but now feel different) but have different ways of looking at what Jesus said. God Bless Everyone On This Site.
Hello kristian. Thank you for your comments but let me just say that the forum is actually not a good place to get to know Pope Francis! Sadly, most posters are very negative about the Pope and many who are positive about him have either departed the forum or been removed. This means your current negative feelings about the Pope are likely to increase because a one-sided presentation of anything is not helpful for discernment. You will actually learn much more about Francis if your regularly read his Santa Marta homilies. This would result in an increase in your faith and trust in God. The bottom line is that truth is to be found in the person of Jesus. The intellect is involved but we have to listen to that gentle voice within us, the Holy Spirit, to lead us to the Son.
Indeed, Mac. Unfortunately that gentle voice is so often silenced by a million other things, especially our own ego.
That's a double-edged sword. How can you be so sure that it's not your own ego that is talking? Or another spirit, entirely? Since this spirit being spoken of, or at least some of his followers, seems to be opposing the direct words of Christ in the Gospels (but, then, who had a tape-recorder, eh?), might it not be the same spirit who tempted Christ in the desert? Or, are we to accept that perhaps Pope Francis, unlike even Christ, is immune from such temptation? On the other hand, maybe this spirit is telling us that we may go back to the rule of Moses. Like in Moses' time, our hearts have become too hardened for these difficult, 'rigid' rules. That's another way of saying that the Crucifixion, the Resurrection and Pentecost (at the core of which was the (true) Holy Spirit) didn't work. I have a memory of a mystic from the Middle Ages who conjured up a heresy of three ages, the age of the Father-Old Testament, that of the Son-up to the time of this mystic, and the age of the Spirit from then on. Old heresies never die-they just go back to Hell for a while and return when it is opportune. Beware, David, that you are not feeding into the modernist version of this Christ-contradicting spirit.
I hope neither yourself, nor Praetorian mind my stepping in, but I have a few free moments. God is Truth. There is no other source of Truth (indeed there is no other source of anything). God is Immutable, Unchanging and Unchangeable. [If God could change, it would necessarily imply that one or other, or both, of these now two different versions of God was not God. It would also mean two different Gods, thus multi-theism. Such change is obviously completely illogical and incoherent]. Therefore, Truth is Immutable, Unchanging and Unchangeable. No mere creature, not even all the Cardinals and Bishops since the beginning of the Church acting in unison can effect this in the slightest way, because this is the first Truth about Truth. In attempting to change Truth, one does not change the Truth, but oneself. If 'this Pope, Cardinals and Bishops' did as you say, the only thing that would truly change is themselves and that they would have made a false Church.
I honestly don't know anything about the Dominicans and I could be mistaken that they were the other Order (along with the Jesuits) mentioned in the video. I'm sure that there are good, orthodox Jesuits who are doing their best to live and preach the Gospel but don't get noticed or appointed to elite schools or key posts in the church. There could well be more good Jesuits than we realise who wouldn't have voted Fr. Sosa to be their Superior General had they been aware of his peculiar beliefs. Every Jesuit doesn't get a vote. Each community sends a delegate to the gathering in Rome where the Superior General is elected, so I suppose all Jesuits can't be blamed for electing him. Fr. Sosa was also very well placed to get name recognition which makes a difference in any ballot: "In 2014, Father Sosa joined the General Curia community and took on the role of Delegate for Interprovincial Roman Houses of the Society of Jesus in Rome, which include: the Pontifical Gregorian University, the Pontifical Biblical Institute, the Pontifical Oriental Institute, the Vatican Observatory, Civiltà Cattolica, as well as international Jesuit colleges in Rome." http://gc36.org/gc36-new-father-general/
David, we are not negative towards the Pope, but his actions and words and choices are very concerning to us. His play on words tend to confuse and mislead the flock entrusted to him by our Lord. I pray for Pope Francis everyday that he lead his flock according to our heavenly Father's will.