If the Vatican statement can be taken at face value, it implies that Pope Francis wishes to shaft Chinese Catholics. If it is not to be taken at face value, it is either gross incompetence or an outright lie. I think nobody will mind my saying that we owe David a debt of gratitude for bringing this Vatican betrayal to our attention.
. I wonder also, are these Chinese Bishops who are classified as patriots to China on record at all regarding the 2 child policy of China? or their forced abortion policy? Or even its problems with gendercide? I have never seen any statements either way concerning this but it seems to me that it would be very important. Chinese officials know well what their policies have wrought them regarding this. They are facing huge problems in their demographics precisely because of these evil communist policies. http://www.cardinalkungfoundation.org/ar/ChineseCatholicPatrioticAsso.php
mmmm should I believe Cardinal Zen who represented millions of persecuted Christians who died or were imprisoned fro their Faith under the Communists or a Media spokesman for the present Vatican? Not a difficult choice. Cardinal Zen of course; with all my heart. You should be thoroughly ashamed of yourself David. You will answer at the Judgement Seat of God for this. 'I was hungry and imprisoned...'
Looks like the one child policy is not a problem because, according to Asia News: http://www.asianews.it/news-en/The-...ide-in-favour-of-illegitimate-ones-42896.html "This is the second time in three months that the Holy See made the resignation demand on Bishop Zhuang, who was secretly ordained in 2006 with Vatican approval. However, he is only recognized as priest by the Chinese government, which on the other hand is in full support of the excommunicated Bishop Huang Bingzhang, a long-time member in the National People’s Congress, China’s parliament." "Bishop" Huang Bingzhang was excommunicated in 2011: http://www.asianews.it/news-en/The-...ates-the-resistance-of-bishops-and-22121.html How times have changed.
Hopefully this isn't a preview of how the future underground Church, in general, will be considered and treated.....but then at that point there won't be any guessing as to just which side anybody is on.
This is an unconscionable betrayal. God bless this brave Chinese bishop. God sees all. And as PBXVI says God wins in the end!
No need to guess how Amoris Laetitia will be interpreted by them. The Pope says he would love to visit China. Maybe he fancies having his photo taken on the great wall. Then again, maybe not, because he isn't a fan of walls.
“Very grave trials await the Church. What we have suffered so far is almost nothing compared to what is going to happen. The enemies of the Church are symbolized by the ships which strive their utmost to sink the flagship. Only two things can save us in such a grave hour: devotion to Mary and frequent Communion. Let us do our very best to use these two means and have others use them everywhere.” St. John Bosco “Remain, all of you, in the refuge of my Immaculate Heart, and you will find your peace and interior serenity. My beloved sons, the storm which I foretold at Fatima has now unleashed its fury for the purification of the Church and all the world. This is the hour of the Father’s mercy which, through the love of the Son’s divine Heart, is made manifest at the moment when everyone’s suffering is at its greatest.” To the Priests, Fr. Gobbi, #171ab
A deeper analysis of the "time is greater than space" hypothesis, with much the same conclusions as ourselves: “Time is greater than space” as an illustration of the intellectual vacuity of today’s clerical culture Posted on January 30, 2018 by Bonald Is being a priest a hard job? Catholic laymen get different impressions, because it can be as hard as one wants it to be. Priests with initiative find limitless opportunities for projects relevant to their duties and work themselves to exhaustion. On the other hand, lazy priests will have little to prod them. Is theology a difficult subject? As difficult as you want it to be. There are problems of formidable intricacy and subtlety waiting for those who find them, but if you want to stick with slogans, virtue-signaling, and post-modern nonsense, you can do that instead. The pro-Francis theologians are entering Sokal hoax territory. Behold, the new and improved Pontifical Academy for Life. A reflection on Amoris Laetitia has been posted on the website of the Pontifical Academy for Life in which its author, a new member of the academy, proposes that the term “intrinsically evil” is outdated. Hypothesizing on the moral theology of Amoris Laetitia and Pope Francis’ principle that “time is greater than space” mentioned in his 2013 apostolic exhortation Evangelii Gaudium, Professor Gerhard Höver argues that changes in perception, “namely, space and time,” have an “effect on specific theologies, such as the theological view of marriage and the family.” One might wonder whether anything can be evil if nothing is intrinsically evil. Things that are accidentally evil are evil in virtue of some combination of their accidents, and if that combination is not intrinsically evil, well, the question “What’s wrong with that?” has to terminate somewhere. But let’s leave that to the side and just marvel at how our shepherds go around speaking as if Pope Francis’ bit of silly, pretentious, postmodern gibberish “time is greater than space” is some profound insight. What the hell is “time is greater than space” even supposed to mean? Deacon Jim Russell gathers Pope Francis’ invocations of this phrase together with relevant context and tries to make sense of them here. In some contexts, it’s just a warning against short-term thinking. Usually, though, Francis explains his slogan to mean that “initiating processes” is more important than “controlling spaces”. At the most generous, one could treat this like a folk proverb such as “the best things come to those who wait” or “birds of a feather flock together”, a bit of folk wisdom pithily expressed and not meant to provide a general principle or even to explain the extent of its own validity. In emergencies, “space control” can be more important than initiating “processes” that will only bear fruit far in the future, and only provided the immediate space control is successful. As I said, the slogan “time is greater than space” could at best serve as a reminder that the pursuit of some type of control at the current time is sometimes counterproductive. However, this slogan lacks the distinct excellence of a proverb; proverbs are memorable and easily understood by everyone, and Francis’ use of language is neither colloquial nor precise. In general, “time is greater than space” is a false dichotomy. Processes can’t proceed unless there is some “space” in which they are allowed to operate, and power over social spaces is sought precisely in order to initiate or protect the operation of some “process” that one favors. This dichotomy is also an inaccurate description of the real disputes. Traditionalist Catholics don’t object to the neo-modernists’ processes simply for being processes. They object to them because they judge them to be processes toward the normalization of sin and heresy. Similarly, one has no trouble finding traditionalists grumbling about Francis or liberal bishops using their power over Catholic spaces to suppress “processes” that traditionalists approve of. “Space” and “time” in the senses used here are morally neutral in themselves. What matters is to what ends they are being used. As usual, Francis doesn’t argue for his silly principle; he just attaches negative but logically unrelated descriptions to those who perform the behavior he doesn’t like. For example “Giving priority to space means madly attempting to keep everything together in the present, trying to possess all the spaces of power and of self-assertion…” It might, or it might not. What if I prioritize maintaining order in a region of space but do so calmly and methodically rather than madly? What if my priority is not to possess all the spaces of power but just one that is key to my purposes? Francis seems to be a slave to his mental associations, making it difficult for him to think logically. It’s the same reason we always see him attributing negative spiritual qualities (e.g. rigidity or pride) to his critics. “Time is greater than space” is just in every way a mind-bogglingly stupid thing to say. Yes, I know I’m being rude. I’m angry that a religious body with a two thousand year theological tradition can be reduced to such flimflam. We should expect better. Related 2016: the year of the Left's greatest triumphWith 96 comments I am not confusedWith 39 comments Pope Francis endorses my interpretation of "more Catholic than the pope"With 19 comments Filed under: Uncategorized | « The plausibility of theism; notes on the history of philosophy 2 Responses JMSmith, on January 30, 2018 at 9:48 pm said: Airheads used to feign profundity with talk about “becoming” and “being,” saying that the former is decidedly superior. I think this came out of existentialism. As a practical matter, such talk was just a worthless promissory note, so that no matter how crappy things are, we must have faith that they are becoming better. Smelly hippies were for obvious reasons all about becoming. Their being smelly hippies was (they would have you believe) entirely beside the point. Focus on the future, man! I wonder if Herr Höver has really thought his doctrine through. If we discard the notion of intrinsic evil, it will certainly be easier to edit the seven deadly sins, but it will also make it impossible to accuse the past of sins it did not know. If the sin of adultery can fade out of existence in time, then the sin of racism must have faded in. Without the notion of “intrinsic evils,” there can be no moral growth, just moral change or moral adjustments. Sin is just maladjustment. I’m angry, too. Kristor, on January 30, 2018 at 10:31 pm said: I second that emotion. What a load of nonsense. I have not read theology journals in years. Back in the day, they were usually pretty careful. I suppose that by now they must all have been subject to invasion of the pomos with their gibberish. Invasion of the pomos: that’s Invasion of the Mind Snatcher I include two relevant comments.
I am glad you got over it Denis, it was a very, very ad one/ We get offered free shots at the hospital but I didn't take it. I have grown suspicious/
Whoever wrote that article went to a great deal of trouble to arrive at his conclusion: “Time is greater than space” is just in every way a mind-bogglingly stupid thing to say. Yes, I know I’m being rude. I’m angry that a religious body with a two thousand year theological tradition can be reduced to such flimflam. We should expect better. Imagine all the effort and ink he would have spared himself had he simply stated the obvious............that this is a case of the Vatican resorting to a common political tactic: "if we can't blind them with science, we'll dazzle them with BS". Take heart, Degaulle, and remember that Jesus ate with sinners.
Well, I was just informed by my little teenage sister last night that the priest teaching her Confirmation class said that sex outside of marriage is sometimes merely a venial sin. He also told her that we should go to confession because it makes us feel good. This same priest has also said that before Vatican II the Church taught no salvation outside the Church meant only Catholics went to Heaven and that V2 changed all that and now everyone can go to Heaven. This type of catechesis is why we have horribly catechesized youth. Priests should know better.
Went to the Vatican yesterday. It was the least crowded I have ever seen it. There were some Japanese and middle eastern people there, talking a lot of selfies. It seemed more of a tourist attraction than a place of pilgrimage. There was NO line for confession, maybe three people— I think I was the only lay person. Same with the Adoration Chapel. It made me very sad.
It's like a phrase that a teenager reads and become obsessed with trying to show how smart he is by using it to show off. It means absolutely nothing!! Utterly embarrassing that this phrase is in an encyclical because it is like saying 'space is less than time'!
And who said this? Simplicity has to do with the language we use. It must be one that people understand, lest we risk speaking to a void. Preachers often use words learned during their studies and in specialized settings which are not part of the ordinary language of their hearers. These are words that are suitable in theology or catechesis, but whose meaning is incomprehensible to the majority of Christians. … Simplicity and clarity are two different things. Our language may be simple but our preaching not very clear. It can end up being incomprehensible because it is disorganized, lacks logical progression or tries to deal with too many things at one time.” (§ 158)
I would love to get to Italy again soon. This time I would like to see the Holy House of Loreto, Assisi and maybe Sicily. I would avoid Rome; it would make me so sad at the moment. What a shame. I have been thinking of going to Lourdes too.