Brian, I translated an Italian document using Google which discusses the conference in which Andrea Grillo and Archbishop Castellucci talked about changes to the mass. In the document they discuss an actual earthquake which occurred in Italy in 2012 and effected a parish which then celebrated mass in the parish halls, then an analogy is made to this earthquake in the following statement: There is, in essence, another "earthquake". What allows us to abandon some celebratory styles, some "pretensions" that accompany us for a long time, some "acquired rights" that actually impoverish our celebration instead of exalting and respecting it. I am not certain that the Google translation is 100% but the statement is a bit worrisome.
I just do not understand this. Many of the statements convey sentiments that are highly interpretative. What does On the contrary, just living deeply with these "human actions" allows you to enter into the mystery of the Passover of Christ mean?. Just asking the question, shows they are on an entirely different page. The liturgy they are talking about is the Sacrifice of the Mass. Are we not on Calvary's Hill at the consecration ? Why are we told to give each other the sign of peace, most especially at that time; and/or to await until the last communicant has received, before kneeling. These are all serious impediments to our entering into the mystery of the Passover of Christ. What can be more meaningful to helping effect real participation in the Sacrifice is effective preaching; not bland pious utterances. On the contrary We need priests that (a) pray a Holy Mass, (b) promote confession and above all (c) instruct the faithful not to receive the Lord unworthily. God Bless
Here is another good article from Steven O'Reilly with literally the same bottom line to his previous post above. Does the Prophet Malachi speak to our time and the issues of Amoris Laetitia? https://romalocutaest.com/2017/11/0...o-our-time-and-the-issues-of-amoris-laetitia/ November 5, 2017 (Steven O’Reilly) – I went to Mass this Sunday morning with my wife at our parish Church. My ears perked up as I listened to the first reading, which was taken from Malachi (1:14B – 2:2B, 8-10). As given on the USCCB website, the reading is as follows (emphasis added): A great King am I, says the LORD of hosts, and my name will be feared among the nations. And now, O priests, this commandment is for you: If you do not listen, if you do not lay it to heart, to give glory to my name, says the LORD of hosts, I will send a curse upon you and of your blessing I will make a curse. You have turned aside from the way, and have caused many to falter by your instruction; you have made void the covenant of Levi, says the LORD of hosts. I, therefore, have made you contemptible and base before all the people, since you do not keep my ways, but show partiality in your decisions. Have we not all the one father? Has not the one God created us? Why then do we break faith with one another, violating the covenant of our fathers? (USCCB: Malachi (1:14B – 2:2B, 8-10)) As I sat in the pew, hearing the words read aloud that the priests were said to have “turned aside from the way and have caused many to falter by your instruction,” it brought to my mind the debate over Amoris Laetitia and communion for the divorced and remarried. Curious that these thoughts entered my mind, I resolved to read these verses in context upon my return home. The lines from the First Reading are drawn from Malachi chapter 1 (verse 14b) and chapter 2 (verses 2:2B, 8-10). In chapter 1 of Malachi, coincidentally, the Lord is angry with the priests for offering “polluted bread” (cf Malachi 1:7), and “blind”, “lame and sick” (cf. Malachi 1:8) sacrificial offerings on the altar of the Lord. In brief, the priests allowed, condoned and committed sacrilege at the altar of the Lord. However, this was not included in the reading as presented in mass. It is also unfortunate that the first reading ended with verse 10 because the prophet Malachi continues on in the verses which immediately follow to list other offenses against God, specifically divorce and remarriage: (11) Judah has broken faith; an abominable thing has been done in Israel and in Jerusalem. Judah has profaned the LORD’s holy place, which he loves, and has married a daughter of a foreign god. (12) May the LORD cut off from the man who does this both witness and advocate from the tents of Jacob, and anyone to bring an offering to the LORD of hosts! (13) This also you do: the altar of the LORD you cover with tears, weeping, and groaning, Because the Lord no longer takes note of your offering or accepts it favorably from your hand. (14) And you say, “Why?”— Because the LORD is witness between you and the wife of your youth With whom you have broken faith, though she is your companion, your covenanted wife. (15) Did he not make them one, with flesh and spirit? And what does the One require? Godly offspring! You should be on guard, then, for your life, and do not break faith with the wife of your youth. (16) For I hate divorce, says the LORD, the God of Israel, And the one who covers his garment with violence, says the LORD of hosts. You should be on guard, then, for your life, and you must not break faith. (17) You have wearied the LORD with your words, yet you say, “How have we wearied him?” By saying, “All evildoers are good in the sight of the LORD, And he is pleased with them,” or “Where is the just God?” (USCCB: Malachi 2: 11-17) The Lord is clear in Malachi: “The Lord is witness between you and the wife of your youth with whom you have broken faith, though she is your companion, your covenanted wife… do not break faith with the wife of your youth. For I hate divorce” (cf Malachi 2:14-16). Hearing the reading at Mass, and then reading it in a fuller context, I cannot help but think it providential that we have these words before us now at this moment of Church history as debate rages over Amoris Laetitia and whether the divorced and remarried (without annulment or at least adhering to the conditions specified in Familiaris Consortio 84) can receive communion. The two chapters of Malachi speak of pastors who have turned away from the truth and lead others to ‘falter by their instruction’ and condone sacrilegious offerings, and the Lord – who “hates divorce” – warning all to “not break faith” with one’s spouse (cf Malachi 2:15). Reading Malachi verse 2:17, I could not help but think of all of those who concoct Rube Goldberg-like situations to somehow rationalize communion for the divorced and remarried (see here): ” You have wearied the LORD with your words, yet you say, “How have we wearied him?” By saying, “All evildoers are good in the sight of the LORD, And he is pleased with them,” or “Where is the just God?”” (Malachi 2:17). Two thoughts came to mind. The first, smiling, I wondered if the verse “you have wearied the Lord with your words” might apply to the excessive length and confusing ambiguity of Amoris Laetitia. But, on a more serious note (though I would not discount the first!), I thought of Amoris Laetitia 303: “Yet conscience can do more than recognize that a given situation does not correspond objectively to the overall demands of the Gospel. It can also recognize with sincerity and honesty what for now is the most generous response which can be given to God, and come to see with a certain moral security that it is what God himself is asking amid the concrete complexity of one’s limits, while yet not fully the objective ideal.” (Amoris Laetitia 303) The ambiguity of the statement above has encouraged some to do that of which the Lord complains in Malachi (cf 2:17) regarding “breaking faith” (e.g., divorce and remarriage), i.e., saying the Lord is pleased with those who are doing something that is evil (see here and here and here). Thus, personally, I do see in these chapters of Malachi a providential reminder to Catholics at this moment, as we await the “formal correction” (see The Coming Storm) – which I expect before the end of November. That reminder is: pastors must not (1) stray from the way of truth, or (2) cause others to falter by their instruction, or (3) say with regard to those who “break faith” with their spouse through divorce and marry another that “all evildoers are good in the sight of the Lord” (see here and here) or (4) permit sacrilegious communions at the altar of the Lord (e.g., divorced and remarried, “ecumenical” communion received by non-Catholics). Pope Francis often beats up on rigid “doctors of the law”, but here these “doctors” are reproached by God precisely for not instructing others in the truth and for not preserving the altar of the Lord from sacrilege. I – for one -would be interested to hear Pope Francis provide an extended commentary on Malachi chapters one and two. But, it seems to me, this warning in Malachi should be taken to heart by the pope, the cardinals, bishops and priests. Silence is not an option. Let us pray Pope Francis remembers the Lord’s words to Peter: “Simon, Simon, behold Satan hath desired to have you, that he may sift you like wheat. But I have prayed for thee, that thy faith fail not: and thou being once converted, confirm thy brethren” (Luke 22:31-32).
Douay-Rheims: "What is it that hath been? the same thing that shall be. What is it that hath been done? the same that shall be done. Nothing under the sun is new, neither is any man able to say: Behold this is new: for it hath already gone before in the ages that were before us."
But how do we know that Jesus actually said “render unto Caesar what is caesars and unto God what is God’s?”. I mean they didn’t have tape recorders then did they?” ( sarcasm off) The head of the Jesuits actually made the remark about the reliability of the Bible in the above terms thereby not only calling into question the de fide existence of Satan but also the infallibility and inerrancy of scripture. This is the head of the Jesuits. Not some Parish priest of some small backwater Parish. How he wasn’t summoned into the Vatican and given a stern rebuke and an opportunity to publicly correct himself I do not know.
Perhaps because the Vatican agree with him. There was a time when I would listen with great respect to anything a Bishop or someone like the Head of the Jesuits would say. There was a reason for this; they were all singing from the same hymn sheet. No longer. I often feel homesick in my heart to have Padre Pio or Mother Angelica or Bishop Sheen still alive so I could have a good long heart to heart with them.
We have Cardinal Sarah, Cardinal Burke and Bishop Athanasius Schneider, to name but a few. The difference is that such men are outsiders and outliers now.
Yes, they the heart and future of the Church, we are too. May God preserve them and us. It can be lonely being a life raft.
This total scepticism is a form of narcissism, whereby one only believes oneself. Eventually, such people will stop even believing themselves and enter the nihilist stage.
Could anyone imagine St. Paul preaching today Roman's Chapter 1 It is 180 degrees from what is being preached from the Vatican and all their minion cardinals, bishops and priests throughout the world who are embracing sodomy .
https://onepeterfive.com/papal-promises-maneuvers-revelations-cardinals-sistach-meisner/ Papal Promises and Maneuvers: the Revelations of Cardinals Sistach and Meisner Maike Hickson November 8, 2017 8 Comments Many of our readers might already be aware that in spite of his own exhortations in favor of open-hearted dialogue, Pope Francis himself was responsible for steering some of the discussions during the two family synods, especially with regard to the question of divorced and “remarried” couples. The most prominent example of these kinds of papal maneuvers is what Archbishop Bruno Forte had revealed less than a year after the 2015 Synod of Bishops on the Family, in May of 2016. Steve Skojec then reported, as follows: Archbishop Forte has in fact revealed a “behind the scenes” [moment] from the Synod: “If we speak explicitly about communion for the divorced and remarried,” said Archbishop Forte, reporting a joke of Pope Francis, “you do not know what a terrible mess we will make. So we won’t speak plainly, do it in a way that the premises are there, then I will draw out the conclusions.” [emphasis added] Archbishop Bruno Forte is of course also the same man who is said to have written the highly controversial mid-term report of the 2014 Synod on the Family which had stressed the “positive aspects” of homosexual relationships. It is also worthwhile here to remember Edward Pentin’s own book The Rigging of a Vatican Synod? Here we would like to introduce for your consideration two more important disclosures which were published some time ago, but which we believe merit further reflection. The first of these comes from Cardinal Lluís Martínez Sistach, the retired Bishop of Barcelona. Sistach had been appointed by Pope Francis to participate in both the 2014 and the 2015 Synods on the Family. In February of 2017, in an article in L’Osservatore Romano, Sistach supportively discussed Amoris Laetitia and gave his thoughts on how to put it into practice. It was within this context that the Spanish cardinal mentioned a conversation he had had with Pope Francis during the 2015 Synod — including a discussion of divorced and “remarried” couples. In this conversation, the pope gave Sistach the recommendation not to talk so much about their possible access to the Sacraments, but, rather to talk about their “integration” in more general and somewhat abstract terms (perhaps, so as not to disquiet the synod fathers). Cardinal Sistach recounted the occasion as follows: This greater potential “integration” [sic] of the divorced and “remarried” includes different forms, which could extend to the celebration of the Sacraments of Penance and the Eucharist. Remember that this new orientation during the Synod – to talk about greater “integration” rather than about receiving absolution and the Eucharist – was introduced in the synodal assembly in mid-October 2015. After the coffee break, as I walked back into the classroom, I had the privilege to converse with the Pope, who told me it was better to talk about integration. I immediately prepared a proposal with this new orientation with respect to the content of paragraph number 85 of the final document that we were looking at in groups, and I distributed it to my friends (cardinals) in the different groups. In my own linguistic [Spanish-speaking] group, in sets of three we prepared a new proposal speaking of “integration”, and within the group three similar proposals were formulated, then from all three together we prepared one formulation, which was approved by the group and was then included in the final document, and therefore our work [that day] became part of the final draft of Amoris Laetitia. I think it was a very positive change in orientation; rather than focusing on the ability of our brothers and sisters to be able to go to confession and receive Holy Communion, we agreed to talk about greater “integration” in the Christian community. And we know that in order for greater integration to be achieved, it takes an accompaniment and discernment which are the instruments of this integration. [emphasis added] This revelation gives us yet another glimpse at the way in which Pope Francis tried to convey his own clear intent, and thereby to steer the discussions at the Synod in the direction he wished. He had applied this same method ahead of the second family synod when, in December of 2014, he gave an interview to the Argentine newspaper La Nacion. He then said: In the case of divorcees who have remarried, we posed the question, what do we do with them? What door can we allow them to open? This was a pastoral concern: will we allow them to go to Communion? Communion alone is no solution. The solution is integration [sic – not conversion?]. [emphasis added] What followed is not speculation, but history. The papal letter of approval – later, in September of 2016, to be sent to the Argentine bishops of the Buenos Aires region with regard to their admittance of divorced and “remarried” couples to the Sacraments – has made it clear by now what was in Pope Francis’ mind all along. And it seems he also made use of the collaboration of Cardinal Sistach to calm concerns during the 2015 synod itself. Let us now turn to the second revelation. In the case of another cardinal – this time Cardinal Joachim Meisner – Pope Francis applied the same method of calming down and re-orienting a troubled prelate. As was revealed by Cardinal Meisner himself – even before the 2014 Synod on the Family – Pope Francis had assured Meisner that he [the pope] was a “son of the Church” and that, should there arise any doubt about a teaching concerning divorced and “remarried” couples, he surely would consult with the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. As Cardinal Meisner then, in December of 2013, told the German radio station Deutschlandfunk in an interview: When I last visited with Pope Francis, I was able to speak very freely with the Holy Father about all kinds of things. And I also told him that, in his teaching in the form of interviews and short speeches, some questions do indeed remain open which should really be better explained for those who are uninformed. The pope looked at me with big eyes and asked me to give an example. And my answer was then that, during his flight back from Rio to Rome, he was asked about the problem of the divorced and remarried couples. And that is when the pope responded and very simply said: the divorced may go to Holy Communion, the divorced and remarried not. In the Orthodox Church [however], one may marry two times. So far his statement. And then he spoke about mercy which – according to my words, this is how I told him – in our country [Germany] it is always being interpreted as a replacement for all kinds of failures of men. And the pope responded then very energetically that he is, after all, a son of the Catholic Church and that he does not say anything different from what the Church teaches. And mercy has to be identical with the truth, otherwise it does not deserve the name mercy. And additionally, he then said explicitly, if there are any remaining open theological questions, then the important Congregation for the Faith is there to clarify and to formulate that [matter] in detail. [emphasis added] Being of good faith, the dear cardinal good-heartedly and trustingly added his own comments in that 2013 German interview: That is to say, the Congregation [for the Faith], you always have to remember, […] still has the first place. And one may not simply declare its Prefect [Cardinal Gerhard Müller] to be a private man, simply because he had been once the member of a bishops’ conference. Cardinal Meisner was later to lose that trust however, which came to light when he, together with another three cardinals, issued five dubia concerning Amoris Laetitia. Moreover, as we all know rather well, under Pope Francis, the influence of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith has been progressively minimized, and the pope himself did not even pass on to Cardinal Gerhard Müller the full final version of Amoris Laetitia for the cardinal’s final review before its publication and papal promulgation. And Cardinal Müller has now been altogether removed from his former office. Does anyone have any doubts why we have lost so much trust in the papal promises and in his tendentious maneuvers? Andrew Guernsey contributed to this report.
https://www.gloria.tv/article/8YLcN6n4JThNDDi3qGECFpw6b The Secret Commission Exists Despite Vatican Denials The blog Anonimi della Croce which broke the story in March, insists that a secret “ecumenical Mass commission” exists despite a Vatican denial. It knows that it is made up of prelates and theologians from Italy, the U.S., Finland, Sweden and Switzerland. The blog points out that the denial of the Vatican is playing on words, “Let them call it however they want: confidential commission, working table, research group, working group.”
http://www.catholicherald.co.uk/new...ises-pope-for-creating-liquid-society-church/ Prominent Catholic writer criticises Pope for creating ‘liquid society’ Church Nick HallettWednesday, 8 Nov 2017 (CNS photo/Paul Haring) Vittorio Messori said Pope Francis is in danger of undermining the 'stability and firmness' of Church doctrine A prominent Catholic writer has accused Pope Francis of turning the Church into a “liquid society” where uncertainty is the only certainty. Vittorio Messori, who came to prominence after interviewing Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger in 1984 for the book The Ratzinger Report, said the Pope is in danger of making the same mistake as Protestants by reinterpreting doctrine and undermining the “stability and firmness of the Catholic Church”. In an article for Italian magazine Il Timone, translated by the National Catholic Register, Messori started by criticising a “disconcerting interview” with the Jesuit superior general Fr Arturo de Sosa. He accused Fr de Sosa of effectively “‘liquefying’ the Gospel itself” by saying Jesus’s words were not recorded on tape and “we don’t know exactly what he said”, meaning we can “adapt” the Gospel according to the times. He then accused Pope Francis of having a similar attitude, especially when the Pontiff criticises a “Catholic temptation” to have “rigid” rules rather than judging on a “case by case basis”. The old Jesuit tradition of “discernment”, Messori added, has been twisted so it now means to “freely interpret even dogma, depending on the situation, as has happened in some official documents containing [the Pope’s] signature, which have aroused perplexity (to use a euphemism) in some cardinals.” Messori said “in all humility” that such an approach seems “wrong and damaging to the Church and the faith”. “In a ‘liquid world’ where everything becomes uncertain, precarious, provisional, it is precisely the stability and firmness of the Catholic Church that all humanity needs, and not only believers,” he added. “Those rocks of dogma, to which the superior general of the Society of Jesus is allergic, could and should become firm ground in a society that flatters itself and tends towards mushy chaos.” More than ever, the Church needs the “full clarity of the Catechism” rather than the “ever-changing ‘in my opinion’”. He said that Protestantism has gone down this road, “and history has shown what it has led to, but unfortunately, as usual, history is not magistra vitae [life’s teacher].” As well as the Ratzinger Report, Messori also published a best-selling interview with Pope John Paul II, and has been described as the “most translated” author in the Catholic world.
http://m.ncregister.com/blog/edward-pentin/messori-pope-francis-is-creating-a-liquid-society-church Messori: Pope Francis is Creating a ‘Liquid Society’ Church Posted by Edward Pentin on Tuesday Nov 7th, 2017 at 7:20 PM Famed Italian author criticizes the Holy Father for mirroring modern society by turning the Church into a place where “everything is unstable and changeable.” The prominent Italian Catholic writer Vittorio Messori has expressed concern that Pope Francis is turning the Catholic Church into a kind of “liquid society” in which uncertainty and change are the only certainties. Writing in the latest edition of the Italian Catholic magazine Il Timone, Messori took as a point of reference the Polish Jewish sociologist Zygmut Bauman who first introduced the idea of “liquid modernity.” Bauman observed that the general trait of individualistic modern man is to flow through his own life like a tourist, changing places, jobs, spouses, values and even sexual orientation and gender. Bauman said the modern tendency is to exclude oneself from traditional networks of support, while at the same time freeing oneself from the restrictions or requirements those networks impose. This trend towards such unbridled individualism has created societies in which “everything is unstable and changeable,” Messori noted, and referred to the “rapid change” not only in sexual behaviour but also in politics where legislators have given up on long term governance. Quoting Bauman, he said it is becoming acceptable that “change” is the “only permanent thing” and that “uncertainty” has become the “only certainty.” But he said this attitude has also afflicted the area of religion and the believer is now “disturbed by the fact that even the Catholic Church — which was an age-old example of stability — seems to want to become ‘liquid’ as well.” Messori, who came to prominence in 1984 when he interviewed Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger for the book The Ratzinger Report, pointed to a recent “disconcerting interview” with the Jesuits’ superior general, Father Arturo Sosa. He said Father Sosa effectively “’liquefied’ the Gospel itself” when he said that as Jesus’ words were not recorded on tape, “we don’t know exactly what he said” so it’s possible to “adapt” the Gospel according to times, needs and people. The Italian author then criticized the Pope for being susceptible to the same attitude, quoting him in a recent interview warning against a “Catholic temptation” to have uniform or “rigid” rules instead of judging and acting “on a case by case basis.” Messori, who published the 1995 bestselling book-interview with Pope St. John Paul II Crossing the Threshold of Hope, said the Pope’s frequent use of the term “discernment” is an old tradition of the Society of Jesus. But until now, it did not additionally mean to "freely interpret even dogma, depending on the situation, as has happened in some official documents containing his signature, which have aroused perplexity (to use a euphemism) in some cardinals.” Messori said that in “all humility,” to have such an approach seemed to him “wrong and damaging to the Church and the faith” and that for him “the opposite would be right.” He said “in a ‘liquid world’ where everything becomes uncertain, precarious, provisional, it is precisely the stability and firmness of the Catholic Church that all humanity needs, and not only believers.” “Those rocks of dogma, to which the superior general of the Society of Jesus is allergic, could and should become firm ground in a society that flatters itself and tends towards mushy chaos,” he said. One of the symbols of the Catholic Church, he added, is a “robust oak, held firmly to the ground by strong roots.” But is it, he asked, “really helpful to replace the oak with a rod that folds in any direction, with any breath of air, every human desire or fashion?” Perhaps, he added, it is time to rediscover and apply to the whole Church the “ancient and beautiful” motto of the Carthusians: Stat crux dum volvitur orbis [The Cross is steady while the world turns]. Messori said that “more than ever” the “firm clarity of the Catechism is needed, rather than the ever-changing ‘in my opinion,’ and the “infinite opinions which the world is full of.” Protestantism followed this path, he said, “and history has shown what it has led to, but unfortunately, as usual, history is not magistra vitae [life’s teacher].”
I wonder, could they not be living in God's wrath now and yet be blind to it because God has darkened their minds, hardened their hearts and given them over to their desires? Paul speaks much about this very thing.
Spanish cardinal: ‘Never in history’ has Church faced such ‘severe test’ as today https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/s...ry-has-church-perhaps-been-harassed-as-in-thi