The Vatican Has Fallen

Discussion in 'Church Critique' started by padraig, Dec 31, 2016.

  1. AED

    AED Powers

    I share in all these feelings and hopes and fears. I think we just keep praying for him. And beg God's mercy on him and on us and on the Bride of Christ who is staggering beneath the weight of this terrible cross.
     
  2. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    https://dwightlongenecker.com/a-response-to-fr-weinandys-letter/

    A Response to Fr Weinandy's Letter

    By Fr. Dwight Longenecker

    This morning America magazine publishes an oily letter from Mgr. John Strynkowski–Fr Weinandy’s predecessor as executive director of the Secretariat for Christian Doctrine at the U.S.C.C.B.

    Like so much put out by the Jesuits today is is….well… Jesuitical. It makes bland points, poses as serious, but is shallow, hides behind gentle, patronizing language and adopts a lofty, self righteous tone. Bleh.

    But maybe I’m being harsh and judgmental…

    [​IMG]

    You can read the letter here and make up your own mind.

    What gets me is not the content, but the tone churchy people use these days. It can only be described as sentimental mumbo jumbo. Its become a kind of new Catholic orthodoxy. In the old days prelates inveighed in magisterial tones against heresy, wickedness, dissent and apostasy. They spelled out their disagreements clearly and logically.

    Nowadays it’s all the language of “fraternal affection” laced with “deep concern” . things are “noted with sadness”. One never comes out and accuses anyone of anything clearly. Instead there are a lot of “perhaps” and “could be” and “possibly” and “could be construed as”. There are no statements of objective truth instead we have “many people agree” or “after consensus it was decided.”

    It all tumbles around in ambiguity and is as slippery as an octopus in oil. Then when they are criticized they say, “Point to something we have said which is not orthodox!” Nothing you have said is unorthodox, but then nothing you have said is orthodox either–because all of it was subjective, sentimental, lukewarm ambiguity.

    For more on this technique read the posts by my “guest blogger” Fr Harvey Nicolaitan SJ…

    The paragraph that tickled me most was this one:

    Your fifth concern is that bishops feel that the pope is not open to criticism and indeed resents it. What is your source for this? Indeed, there has been much criticism of the pope, but he has remained silent. I am not aware of anything that he has said in public to indicate that he resents criticism.

    Clearly Monsignor has not come across the delightful collection of Pope Francis’ public insults to those who disagree with him. It was collected by an English blogger and is called Pope Francis’ Bumper Book of Insults. This is a pope who publicly insults his critics and attacks them with with name calling but when they respectfully and properly ask him to clarify his comments he ignores them.

    This is a pope who takes the high road and calls for dialogue with everyone….except the members of his own flock who would like to sit down and talk. Pope Francis calls for synodality, consensus and consultation but (from what I hear from the few sources I have in Rome) rules with an increasingly autocratic style.

    But he’s the pope and we are called to pray for him and thank God for the gifts he brings the church, and one of the best gifts he’s given the church so far is to relieve us of the temptation towards any kind of ultramontanism.
     
  3. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

    Ouch! That's the best put-down I've read all year.

    If it weren't for my strong desire to cling to the barque, I would be searching out the SSPX. At Saturday's vigil Mass, the priest told us about the Pharisees making the faith a burden for the believers. All good except that he conveniently skipped over the part that had just been read out about doing what they say and not what they do. Then he used the parish retreats of old when the preachers put the fear of God in us to let us know how the Church has turned over a new leaf. He went on to tell us that Jesus swept aside all those commandments when He said that the Sabbath was made for man and not man for the Sabbath. The "personal relationship with Jesus" line was his grand finale. How did Catholics manage to live the faith before that became the catchphrase to turn the Commandments into optional extras? In the midst of all this, he bemoaned the low Mass attendance. Why would people bother to observe the Third Commandment if their personal relationship with Jesus is telling them that the Sabbath God made for them is best spent at a football match or in a shopping centre?

    In contrast, the African priest at Sunday Mass gave a very orthodox sermon on the Epistle. I don't know whether we get the pick of the bunch of African priests but I thank God for them. If they can escape the clutches of the German moneybags, Africa will save the Church from all this diabolical disorientation we are enduring.
     
  4. HeavenlyHosts

    HeavenlyHosts Powers

    Hmmmmm
    Very compelling
    But in my mind I still wonder
    Was there an autopsy?
    Thanks for posting this ETA
     
  5. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    http://www.catholicworldreport.com/...candal-a-brief-defense-of-fr-thomas-weinandy/



    Superstition, Dissent, and Scandal? A brief defense of Fr. Thomas Weinandy

    Some pundits from both progressive and orthodox quarters have been quick to criticize and even condemn Fr. Weinandy and his missive to the Pope. Thus, a brief defense of Fr. Weinandy is in order.

    November 5, 2017 Dr. Michael Sirilla Print


    View attachment 7047

    Left: Fr. Thomas Weinandy, OFM Cap. (CNS); top right: Fr. James Martin, S.J. (Wikipedia); bottom right: Msgr. John Strynkowski (YouTube)

    Fr. Thomas Weinandy, OFM Cap., is owed a debt of gratitude for his courage and forthrightness in making public his letter to Pope Francis respectfully criticizing and encouraging the Holy Father to fulfill his principal charge: to secure the unity of Christ’s Church in faith, charity, and holiness.


    Weinandy’s letter comes at a time marked by widespread doctrinal confusion in the Church to a degree heretofore unknown in living memory. Ours is a time when the fierce and beautiful truth of Christ’s saving Gospel is being eclipsed and the Church is undergoing balkanizing fissures threatening her very stability. His letter is important because it comes from a man with a distinguished career as a faithful Catholic theologian and a doctrinal guardian for the Church in the United States. In it, Fr. Weinandy identifies five problematic areas, indicates how he thinks the Holy Father is involved in them, and encourages the Holy Father to fulfill his mandate from Christ. After receiving no response of any substance he made the letter public and in doing so has edified the faithful by reaffirming the solemn duty of the papal office, the truth and relevance of Christ’s doctrines to the spiritual life, and the need for the Holy Father to make wise episcopal appointments.


    Some pundits from both progressive and orthodox quarters have been quick to criticize and even condemn Fr. Weinandy and his missive to the Pope. The condemnations I am aware of seem unjust and libelous (more on those in a moment). The criticisms seem to come either from an unreasonable eagerness to defend every word and deed of the Holy Father or from a fear of scandalizing the faithful by publicly expressing disagreement with the Pope (on account of his behavior or his non-definitive and problematic teachings). Thus, a brief defense of Fr. Weinandy is in order.


    “Superstition” and “dissent”

    In his opinion piece in America magazine online titled “Dissent, Now & Then: Thomas Weinandy and the meaning of Jesuit discernment,” Fr. James Martin, SJ, claims that Weinandy “dissented from Pope Francis’ teachings” – something Martin finds ironic since Weinandy led the committee that scrutinized Sr. Elizabeth Johnson’s Quest for a Living God and found it wanting, doctrinally. Martin also charges Weinandy with the sin of superstition and he expresses acute fear about the way Weinandy asked for a sign from God before composing his letter.


    First, a couple of points on the matter of superstition. The sin of superstition has a very precise meaning in Catholic moral teaching: it is a vice contrary to the virtue of religion in which a person “offers divine worship either to whom he ought not, or in a manner he ought not” (Aquinas, Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 92, a. 1). The three classic species of this vice are idolatry, making a compact (explicitly or implicitly) with demons for divination, and performing ritualistic observances contrary to reason, for example, using religious ceremonies not approved by the Church. Weinandy’s account of his prayerful discernment doesn’t fall under any of these species or the genus of the vice of superstition. The prudence in asking God for a sign in particular cases is surely a matter of debate, but a simple act of asking God for a sign is not something immoral per se (see, for example, Isaiah 7, where Ahaz is instructed by Isaiah to ask God for a sign; or the instances of this in the New Testament, such as when the Apostles sought a sign from God in selecting a replacement for Judas in Acts 1:26 or when God himself provided signs for the faithful, such as in Luke 2:34, etc.).


    When it comes to dissent, the CDF’s 1990 document, Donum Veritatis (Instruction on the Ecclesial Vocation of the Theologian, hereafter “DV”), explains that dissent is “public opposition to the Magisterium of the Church” and it “must be distinguished from the situation of personal difficulties treated above” (a. 32). That is to say, “dissenting” is an act distinct in kind from one in which a person expresses difficulties with magisterial teachings. It is clear from a fair reading of his letter that Weinandy has not opposed Francis’ magisterium; rather, he asks the Pope to correct five matters of concern:


    (1) the well-known ambiguities in “Amoris Laetita” (hereafter, “AL”) chap. 8;

    (2) those statements of the Pope which seem to demean the importance of Church doctrine;

    (3) the Pope’s appointment of bishops who have supported and defended those who “hold views counter to Christian belief”;

    (4) the Pope’s emerging brand of “synodality” that has resulting in fracturing the unity of faith and praxis in the Church; and

    (5) the atmosphere of fear of retribution brought about in no small part by the actions of the Pope and his surrogates.


    Say what you will about Fr. Weinandy’s concerns, but not one of them amounts to anything approaching dissent. Asking for clarification of ambiguous statements in a magisterial document hardly constitutes dissent. And his second concern is actually about preserving respect for the teachings of the Magisterium. What magisterial doctrine is Fr. Weinandy even calling into question let alone opposing? In fact, it is precisely his concern for the Church’s doctrine and its importance for the salvation of souls that clearly motivated him to implore the Pope to make a course correction. As the former chief of doctrine for the Church in the United States, Weinandy is a man sensitive to the potential for pastoral disaster caused by the rejection of sound doctrine. So much for Fr. Martin’s preposterous condemnation of Fr. Weinandy’s “dissent” and “superstition.”


    Monsignor Strynkowski’s response

    Fr. Weinandy has also been impugned by Msgr. John Strynkowski, one of his predecessors at the position of the Secretariat of Christian Doctrine at the USCCB. In an America article (“An open letter to Father Weinandy, from his predecessor, on ‘Amoris Laetitia’ and Pope Francis”), Strynkowski attempts to redress each of Weinandy’s five concerns, prefacing his remarks by claiming that AL is “an act of ordinary Magisterium, and thus enjoys presumption as having been guided by the Spirit of the Lord.” To be sure, Weinandy knows that even non-definitive magisterial teachings “are not without divine assistance and call for the adherence of the faithful” (DV, a. 17). The Church’s indefectibility would be imperiled by a substantive amount of errors in such teaching.


    And yet this does not preclude all possibility of error in non-infallible magisterial statements, as the CDF points out in DV, 24: “It could happen that some Magisterial documents might not be free from all deficiencies.” Some claims found in AL reaffirm infallibly defined doctrine; others are not magisterial in the strict sense. Still others appear to run contrary to infallible dogma. The Holy Spirit guarantees that any error in non-definitive magisterial teachings will not destroy the Church. Situations like these, thankfully, are painful and rare but such is our lot. And publicly identifying problems in non-definitive teachings (such as critical ambiguity) in no way entails a failure to recognize God’s assistance to those who exercise magisterial authority. It is beyond facile for Strynkowski to imply otherwise.


    Most of Strynkowski’s criticisms are not worth dwelling on at length as they are brief and dubious and, thus, easily dismissed. The sheer number of articles, open letters, books, episcopal statements, and press releases displaying a conflicting variety of theological interpretations of AL on the pastoral care of divorced and remarried Catholics living in more uxorio suffices to belie Strynkowski’s bald assertion that most bishops and theologians do not agree with Weinandy’s perception of ambiguity in chapter 8 of AL. The Holy Father frequently signals that he is no fan of dogma which he regularly portrays as antithetical to mercy and pastoral accompaniment. The Pope’s record of episcopal appointments, promotions, and firings speaks for itself. Weinandy charitably exercised restraint by not including a laundry list of well-known problematic bishops and I will follow suit.



    Con’t
     
    Mac likes this.
  6. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    Con’t


    For evidence that Pope Francis has promoted a range of problematic “doctrinal and moral options within the Church” under the rubrics of a flawed “synodality” we need look no further than the current balkanization of the Church under his leadership where what is a mortal sin in Poland and Philadelphia is permissible in Germany and Malta regarding Communion for divorced Catholics living in more uxorio with their civil partner. Finally, while there are plenty of instances of the Holy Father not welcoming but perhaps resenting criticism (some of which are plausibly deniable), the recent humiliation of Cardinal Sarah suffices to show why there is an atmosphere of fear among bishops and theologians who dare to disagree with Pope Francis.

    Scandalizing the faithful?

    This leaves us with the final and, in my estimation, the most important point of criticism, one shared by Catholics of varying dispositions – lay and expert, progressive and orthodox alike. Some faithful Catholic thinkers have publicly expressed concerns that the publication of Fr. Weinandy’s letter might scandalize the faithful—but without specifying exactly how. For his part, Msgr. Strynkowski closes his letter by warning Fr. Weinandy that “Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, as Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, urged that dissent from ordinary Magisterium should be disclosed privately to church authority—see ‘Donum Veritatis’ (No. 30).”


    Aside from the false suggestion that Fr. Weinandy is dissenting from Church teaching (refuted above), the striking fact in Strynkowski’s parting shot is that Ratzinger and “Donum Veritatis” said no such thing! In his prepared remarks delivered publicly in 1990 at a press conference upon the release of DV, Ratzinger is on the record as saying precisely the opposite. Here is what he actually said:


    Taken out of context, in fact, they [namely, articles 29 through 31 of DV] can give rise to the impression that the Instruction allows the theologian the sole option of submitting divergent opinions to the magisterial authorities in secret…. It is quite obvious that the Instruction is not proposing ‘secret’ communications but dialogue which remains on an ecclesial and scientific plane and avoids distortions at the hand of the mass media…. In actuality, the point is precisely to use arguments instead of pressure as a means of persuasion”. (Emphasis added. Cited in the July 5, 1990 issue of the USCCB publication Origins and in the book The Nature and Mission of Theology [Ignatius Press, 1995], p 117.)


    This citation comes from a section of Ratzinger’s public address entitled “The Magisterium, the university, and the mass media,” in which he specifies the precise and narrowly-circumscribed limits of the directive regarding the mass media. One should avoid using the media as a means to exert political pressure on the Church; yet one may use media outlets to pursue reasoned argumentation in the light of faith. The entire section of his press release comments are worth reading through carefully several times. It bears emphasizing: The Church and the CDF do not prohibit faithful Catholics from expressing grave concerns about the Church and the Magisterium in public fora. But when using public media, the Church requires the faithful to mount charitable and reasoned arguments rather than rhetoric of political machination, the latter being a hallmark of the kind of dissent that was ongoing from Humanae Vitae up to the publication of DV in 1990. DV explains exactly when and why, “the theologian should avoid turning to the ‘mass media’” by adding this qualification, “for it is not by seeking to exert the pressure of public opinion that one contributes to the clarification of doctrinal issues and renders service to the truth” (30).


    This explains the paradox that puzzles folks such as Fr. Martin: the theologians scrutinized under Fr. Weinandy’s tenure at the USCCB were actually dissenting from Church doctrine and some of them used the media as a tool to manipulate the faithful. Whereas those who publicly express problems with Pope Francis’ pontificate, like Fr. Weinandy himself, are not dissenting but are serving the truth of the Gospel by contributing to the clarification of doctrinal issues. The difference is stark and should be obvious to all.


    In his letter to Pope Francis, Fr. Weinandy adheres faithfully to the Church’s directives by expressing cogent reasons for the five principal issues he raises with the Pope. He is clearly concerned for the success of Francis’ pontificate, the Gospel of Christ, and the good of souls. It has been pointed out correctly that letters like Weinandy’s also fall under the duties specified in canon 212 of the 1983 Code of Canon Law:


    §3. According to the knowledge, competence, and prestige which they possess, they have the right and even at times the duty to manifest to the sacred pastors their opinion on matters which pertain to the good of the Church and to make their opinion known to the rest of the Christian faithful, without prejudice to the integrity of faith and morals, with reverence toward their pastors, and attentive to common advantage and the dignity of persons. (Emphasis added)




    Here we see the Church stating that sometimes the faithful have a duty to make known publicly (“to the rest of the Christian faithful”) their opinions on matters pertaining “to the good of the Church.” When the integrity of Church’s moral and sacramental teachings is threatened, this duty ought to be engaged. For his part, Fr. Weinandy has fulfilled this mandate and has respected the directives of DV and CIC can. 212 “to a T.”


    With respect to scandal, in the current crisis what actually scandalizes souls — in the strict sense of providing the occasion for sin — is the sense of many faithful Catholics that the Holy Father is promoting a pastoral policy that no longer requires all divorced and remarried Catholics living in more uxorio to repent of adultery and commit to live in strict continence in order to receive the sacraments of Reconciliation and Communion. If this sense is mistaken, it is easily redressed: the Holy Father can simply answer the dubia! The real scandal here is the occasioning of thoughts and desires to commit the objectively grave sins of active divorce and adultery and material sacrilege.


    What scandalizes souls is not the reasoned and charitable criticism of the Pope (see Gal 2:11) but the silence of bishops and theologians who do not respectfully, charitably, and publicly express grave concerns about this confusion and who do not reaffirm the Church’s perennial doctrine and practice regarding marriage and reception of the Eucharist. At the very least, the publication of Fr. Weinandy’s letter mitigates these and other scandals. I have treated at length the conditions for a morally licit public correction of a pope in another article, but the bottom line is that subordinates have a duty to fraternally correct their superiors (even the Pope) out of charity and in public when the faith is publicly endangered (see Aquinas, Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 33, a. 4 where he treats of St. Paul publicly correcting St. Peter as recounted in Gal 2:11). In his exhortation to the Holy Father, Fr. Weinandy has met all of the criteria established by the Church’s tradition and by her moral and canonical directives.


    A final thought: The “irony meter” broke when Fr. Weinandy was asked to resign as a doctrine consultant for the USCCB because he expressed criticisms and grave concerns in a respectfully-written letter in which he points out, among other things, that the Holy Father has contributed to an atmosphere where the faithful fear being punished for expressing criticisms and grave concerns. May courageous bishops support Fr. Weinandy out of true Christian charity for the Holy Father and for the faithful; may they reaffirm Christ’s moral teachings and implore the Holy Father to boldly and unambiguously strengthen the brethren in the fullness of the faith of Christ.
     
  7. padraig

    padraig Powers

    Yes he can be a real puzzle.. maybe because tens of millions of people are praying for him, that there is a real war going on for his soul?
     
  8. sunburst

    sunburst Powers

    Hi Padraig,
    Sorry to get off topic but I couldn't resist;) This movie was filmed at the beginning of the street where I grew up close to the train station, the home is still in the family and I still pass by the statue of "Hachiko" whenever I visit. It is a movie based on a true story about the loyalty of this Akita to his Master. If you ever get the chance, take some time to watch the movie it is good and wholesome.
    I don't think one should ever attack ones dog:cautious:

     
    Mac, Praetorian, josephite and 3 others like this.
  9. padraig

    padraig Powers

    I already watched it twice. Not a dry eye in the house. A wonderful testimony to the loyalty of an animal. I still hope there will be dogs in heaven.

    https://nerdnomads.com/hachiko_the_dog

     
    Mac, sunburst, David Healy and 3 others like this.
  10. padraig

    padraig Powers

    http://www.catholicherald.co.uk/com...is-the-church-desperately-needs-good-priests/


    I am a great king, says the Lord of Hosts, and my name is feared throughout the nations. And now, priests, this warning is for you. If you do not listen, if you do not find it in your heart to glorify my name, says the Lord of Hosts, I will send the curse on you and curse your very blessing. But you, you have strayed from the way; you have caused many to stumble by your teaching. You have destroyed the covenant of Levi, says the Lord of Hosts. And so I in my turn have made you contemptible and vile in the eyes of the whole people in repayment for the way you have not kept to my paths but have shown partiality in your administration.


    Have we not all one Father? Did not one God create us? Why, then, do we break faith with one another, profaning the covenant of our ancestors?

    As Father Weinandy has pointed out in his open letter to the Pope:


    'I have often asked myself: “Why has Jesus let all of this happen?” The only answer that comes to mind is that Jesus wants to manifest just how weak is the faith of many within the Church, even among too many of her bishops. Ironically, your pontificate has given those who hold harmful theological and pastoral views the license and confidence to come into the light and expose their previously hidden darkness. In recognizing this darkness, the Church will humbly need to renew herself, and so continue to grow in holiness.'


     
    Last edited: Nov 6, 2017
    little me, Mac and BrianK like this.
  11. josephite

    josephite Powers


    The Little creature that followed God


    When God had made the earth and sky,

    The flowers and the trees.

    He made all the animals

    And all the birds and bees.


    And when His work was finished

    Not one was quite the same

    He said “I’ll walk this earth of mine

    And give each one a name”.


    And so He travelled land and sea,

    And everywhere He went

    A little creature followed Him

    Till all his strength was spent.


    When all were named upon the earth

    And in the sky and sea

    The little creature said “Dear Lord,

    There’s no name left for me”.


    The Father smiled and softly said

    “I’ve left you till the end….

    I’ve turned My own name back to front

    And called you Dog, my friend.”
     
    Byron, padraig, Booklady and 4 others like this.
  12. garabandal

    garabandal Powers

    G.K. Chesterton once prophesied: “The next great heresy is going to be simply an attack on morality; and especially on sexual morality.”

    The primary cause of the sexual and cultural revolution is ideological. Our Lady of Fatima has said that Russia’s errors would spread all over the world. It was first done under a violent form, classical Marxism, by killing tens of millions. Now it’s being done mostly by cultural Marxism. There is continuity from Lenin’s sex revolution, through Gramsci and the Frankfurt school, to the current-day gay-rights and gender ideology.

    Let us defend the church's traditional teaching on sexual morality against the cultural Marxists inside and outside of the Church.

    To be pure, to remain pure, can only come at a price, the price of knowing God and loving him enough to do his will. He will always give us the strength we need to keep purity as something as beautiful for him (Mother Teresa)
     
    Last edited: Nov 6, 2017
  13. garabandal

    garabandal Powers

  14. AED

    AED Powers

    GK Chesterton is as always prescient.
     
    Byron and Booklady like this.
  15. AED

    AED Powers

  16. SgCatholic

    SgCatholic Guest

    AED likes this.
  17. josephite

    josephite Powers

    Very well said DeGaulle!


    Pope Francis is quite an enigma and as a (currently conflicted) Catholic I do so wish that my Pope is good. After all the recent horrors, it is further confusing to see Pope Francis come down decisively on the side of Benedict and the ever-professed eschatological Truth of the Catholic Church in opposition to the Universalists. If one supports 'for many', it is an acceptance of the realities of Sin and its possible consequence, Damnation. It means a belief in Free Will and Judgement.

    Given the implicit and explicit formal importance of this event, which certainly contradicts the hearsay evidence of some of his alleged eschatological statements that we have received from that atheist he talks to, I think we should disregard all so-called information from that particular latter source.

    I don't know what to make of Pope Francis. Sometimes, I fear he may be wicked. On the other hand, he may simply be incompetent and be a puppet of the wolves. I've no doubt he is surrounded by those who are at best universalist or worse, atheist, or at worst, satanic. Yet he himself is a professed believer in a personal Devil and on the evidence above a believer that we may fall into the latter's traps and finish up in Hell. In that context, the notorious "who am I to judge" takes on a different interpretation, as it is an acknowledgement of deferment to Another's Judgement, not a denial of judgement per se.

    My head is spinning.



    My sentiments too!
     
  18. Carol55

    Carol55 Ave Maria

    DeGaulle,

    Thank you for posting this and for sharing your thoughts. I agree with what you stated but I also have this awful feeling that something quite awful is going to be proposed.

    It is like the constant threats coming from North Korea, I feel that eventually something awful is going to happen but I am not certain exactly when it will happen.

    In regards to the Church we have scripture which confirms that something awful is definitely going to happen in relation to the sacrifice of the mass. Whether or not this happens during the current pontificate is yet to be seen. From prophecy it appears that this particular something awful won't happen until the time of the AC. Since I believe that there will be an era of peace prior to the reign of the AC, I think that this particular something awful may be proposed during this pontificate but it will not in fact happen during this pontificate.
     
    DivineMercy, AED, DeGaulle and 2 others like this.
  19. Marie-Lou

    Marie-Lou Guest


    I rarely post on the forum now as it has become very negative with regard Pope Francis and I know everyone is allowed their own opinion and we can all get dragged into a situation where we feel we must get our own point across. I was genuinely delighted to see Joe back but a bit like Fallen Saint I got lost and couldn’t even face reading the ongoing disputes. However can I just say with regard to Martin Luther
    He was not without error and problematic in many ways. the church would not pronounce such a harsh judgement on him because he genuinely sought reform from the corruption which was rife in the 16th century church- the abuse of indulgences and the abuse of the doctrine of purgatory. Pope St John Paul II , Pope Benedict and Pope Francis have all spoken kindly of Luther. The tragic division of the Church of Jesus Christ is the result of the sinfulness of many- not only one man. The ultimate assessment of that situation and legacy must be left to God Almighty alone. thankfully we are not In the same circumstances as 500 years ago and should work towards healing and unity in the Body of Christ. I think it most unfortunate that it tends to be advocates of our Pope who are thrown off the forum and feel must be extremely cautious on how they answer a post or if they feel it best to avoid saying anything and yet those who are against Pope Francis can post what info they choose and I am not entirely sure that it is always accurate and then refuse to cooperate any longer on the forum if someone in favour of our Pope continues to be allowed to partcipate. I know we will never change each other’s views but there is a sense that the forum could easily go down the route of being run like a dictatorship and I don’t believe anyone would genuinely want that.
     
    davidtlig likes this.

Share This Page