I will link the most detailed explanations I could find from orthodox Catholic sources below, but there are many others as well. Also as I noted...
Thank you Josephite. I was very upset when I read what you wrote about my post. I worked hard on it to make sure everything was proper and correct...
Thank you Dolours. What you have stated here is correct. The consecration of Bishops is of such import that the Church has always been careful by...
I don't want to continue arguing this point. What I said is correct and it agrees with the Catechism entry you cited. The links I cited agree with...
This was obviously not a standard Mass. when God performs miracles He is acting outside of what is standard. Inner intention is important. This...
What I quoted was from sound sources and it was a complete teaching. Grabbing a quote out of context does not suffice to refute it. I would agree...
Not just saying the words aloud, but also having the inner intent. I posted the links earlier in the thread from the Catholic Encyclopedia and...
It could be both licit and valid.
Yes. Thank you Garabandal. This goes along with what I posted. The personal sinfulness of the minister does not affect the validity of the...
Thanks DeGaulle. I try very hard to post solid info in this confusing time. If anything I always err on the side of caution.
Just chill. (y) It is probably a moot point anyway since we most likely will not be able to get to a priest in the future if all this continues.
Dolours asked me to clarify what the Church taught on the subject. So I answered her. That's all. I'm truly sorry you found it uncomfortable. That...
My source was not one person, but the teaching of the Church. Though a man may be drawn away from the right path, the teaching of the Church as a...
I agree it is best not to sweat these things. It is jarring when one first learns the intention of the priest is necessary for any sacrament....
I have thought about this much as well, but as Don and AED pointed out getting too caught up in worrying about this or anything else can lead one...
Thank you very much AED. It took me an hour making my initial post last night because I wanted to triple-check to make sure everything I was...
Thank you both very much for the support! I try to be meticulously orthodox in everything I post and when I post Church teachings I always...
Exactly!
I was not stating my opinion. And I do take being called a heretic highly offensive.
Wow. Thanks.
I am highly surprised you would say this. What I posted was orthodox and I supported it with orthodox links. Your "Post of the year" was the most...
As I cited above this is not my idea. This is what the Church teaches, it is just that many are unaware of it. What I believe and the sede's don't...
Excuse me Josephite, but this is not heresy and it is not my "proposition". It is what the Church teaches. I am quite offended by the statement...
The scariest thing is not actually faithless priests at Masses that confect no sacrament. The scariest thing is bishops with no faith performing...
I note that I am no expert. This is merely my understanding in layman's terms: All sacraments require proper matter, form, and intention....
I think (I may be wrong on this) that there may have been some "pilot programs" before the Novus Ordo was fully released upon the world. These may...
Yes as far as I understand some theologians may disagree on this. That is why in my initial post I said some theologians, not all. If memory...
