There are some speculating the Warning is going to happen this year, even though March and much of April has passed, and the Warning is due to happen a little while before the April Miracle. And others say the Warning will happen in 2022. But, there's a simple consideration showing the Miracle can happen at earliest in 2024. 1) The Miracle will happen in April only. 2) It will happen or or between 8th to 16th. 3) It will happen on a specific day, Thursday. 4) That Thursday will not be Holy Thursday. [Most of us agree with those 4 points, I think. But, it's mentioned here anyway: "A miracle is to occur in Garabandal within 12 months after the Warning... It will be on a Thursday at 8:30 p.m. on a feast-day of a martyred Saint for the Eucharist ...( not a feast-day of Our Lady or Our Lord) ... it will happen in the month of April... between the 7th and the 17th of the month but not the 7th or the 17th" http://www.garabandal.org/miracle.shtml] Then, https://www.calendardate.com/maundy_thursday_2022.htm "Maundy Thursday for the year 2022 is celebrated/ observed on Thursday, April 14th." 5) The Miracle will happen in an even year. 6) But, in 2022, April 14th is Holy Thursday. 7) April 14 therefore cannot be the Miracle 8) But April 7th, 2022 would be too early. 9) And April 21st, 2022 is then too late. 10) Therefore, the Miracle is not in 2022. So God and Our Lady have given us some simple clues to the Mystery by which, putting it all together, we can exclude certain years imo. In 2024, Holy Thursday is in March, so the timeframe remains completely open and that year is possible. Question: If the Miracle is to come only in April 2024, doesn't that mean the Warning, at very earliest (even if someone wants to say it is not necessarily in the same calendar year in the Miracle) can come by May 2023? Certain recent private revelations suggest there will be only about 6 weeks from the Warning to Miracle and the Warning will thus be in the last week of February or the first week of March. But even leaving that aside, are there still any reasons to expect the Warning will happen e.g. later this year 2020? Thoughts? God Bless.