I have always been struck by the intense emotion in John 11:33: 'He groaned in the Spirit and was troubled.' I found the interpretation that this was a reaction to the unbelief of those around him unsatisfactory. Further reading and research (with Claude's help) The Greek verb used here is 'ἐμβριμάομαι' (embrimaomai), which appears five times in the New Testament. See next post. In classical Greek, this word does not primarily mean a mournful groan. It literally describes the snorting of a horse and carries strong connotations of indignation, anger or stern agitation. In his landmark essay 'The Emotional Life of Our Lord' (1912, Princeton Theological Review), B.B. Warfield argued extensively that the word conveys wrathful indignation — not at the mourners, but at death as the great enemy of mankind and the consequence of sin. According to Warfield, the scene depicts Christ as a warrior facing his adversary. This interpretation is supported by the context: Jesus is standing at a tomb, about to confront and reverse death. The emotional register is not that of passive grief, but of active, holy anger at what death does to human beings. Warfield observed that the Gospels consistently depict Jesus as being genuinely and deeply emotional — never stoic or detached — and that these emotions almost always precede action rather than being a substitute for it. The feeling drives the deed. What is distinctive about John 11 is the combination of embrimaomai ('the forceful, almost angry agitation') with edakrysen ('Jesus wept' — the shortest verse in the Bible), which occur within a few verses of each other. This pairing of fierce inner agitation and outward tears is unique and suggests that something of enormous significance is being brought to the tomb. I had never realised the preliminary state in that way before. (Warfield's text is available in various formats via the web.)
In most miracle "stories" of the Bible (new and old Testament) this emotional or physical nearness/contact from either sides can be found: Jesus sighs, makes mud, touches, roof taken off, hem touched... In their book "Miracula – Wunderheilungen im Mittelalter: Eine historisch-psychologische Annäherung" (2003), Maria Wittmer-Butsch and Constanze Rendtel examine roughly 450 miracle reports from the 13th to 16th centuries. They apply an interdisciplinary approach that combines historical analysis with depth psychology to understand how medieval people experienced and processed healing. The main thesis is that there is a positive linear correlation between the affective involvement of the sick person and their healing outcome — operationalised through the concept of Leidensdruck (suffering pressure), by which "Affektpunkte" (affect points) were assigned based on illness type and duration. It is the broader claim that high affective investment is positively correlated with healing outcomes. In many contemporary miracle stories a similar pattern can be found: relics or images put on the body, even if unconscious persons, often very intense emotions. In the daily miracle (Saints of the day thread) contributions sometimes these instances are recorded. Matthew 15:30-31 (NLT): Crowds brought the lame, blind, crippled, and mute to Jesus, laying them at his feet, and he healed them all, causing the crowd to praise God. So even today more miracles than we perhaps assume are happening - hopefully.
Why relics in these miracles? The charisma of hierognosis: Hierognosis is a supernatural gift given to certain mystics which consists of the ability to discern blessed or consecrated objects from those which are not blessed, such as whether or not a Host has been consecrated, whether a relic is authentic or not, or whether an object such as a crucifix or a rosary has been blessed by a priest. Additionally, the gift often extends to the discernment of the presence of a good or evil spirit, including especially the recognition of items that are cursed, and even the ability to find lost or hidden objects and holy relics. In a very broad definition, Hierognosis is the ability to recognize immediately any person, place, or thing that is holy, blessed or consecrated, and to distinguish it from those things that are not. https://www.mysticsofthechurch.com/2017/07/hierognosis-mystical-ability-to.html?m=1 So these relics or images carry something not perceived by ordinary people, but this something could be working in extreme situations, even in unconscious persons. Thoughts?
You can find many miracles approved by the Consulta Medica Vatican City via this site and search form.
