THE SYNOD 2015

Discussion in 'The Signs of the Times' started by Blue Horizon, Aug 4, 2015.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Blue Horizon

    Blue Horizon Guest

    "He's the Pope, he can do that..."
    This doesn't sound Protestant to me.
     
  2. fallen saint

    fallen saint Baby steps :)

    I dont get it...so a few Cardinals tried to push their agenda. It sounds like some of the people on this forum. What you don't say is that they failed. Your big gripe is that they used the word "welcome" to homosexuals...what should they use "not welcome". The church was created for sinners.

    From the video...
    Garbage total garbage...your saying that the Pope is going to allow homosexuality...that is total joke. I'm glad they talk about African Cardinals holding our faith. And in the final report there is arguments...what brilliant reporting. You think there is arguments about final report. So, what if everything was included...Shows the Pope is not hiding anything, dumb dumb says there is a agenda. No agenda, the Holy Father just wants to say everything was discussed.

    From what i hear, some are saying, what i heard...a bunch of hogwash.

    I am getting tired of these arguments...

    I just wasted 15 minutes of my life...i am still waiting to see the rigging.

    Al
     
    Last edited: Sep 7, 2015
    Eamonn likes this.
  3. fallen saint

    fallen saint Baby steps :)

    Brian,
    You are starting to affect my spirituality...all this nonsense is taking me away from what is important...saving souls. I guess you have done your job...like Mac, maybe it is time for me to take a break from mog.

    Brother al
     
    josephite likes this.
  4. Aviso

    Aviso Guest

  5. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    This was a very interesting interview. I did not realize the book had the endorsement of Cardinal Napier who Pope Francis has named as one of the Presidents of the Synod this year.
     
  6. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    Fallen Saint I know this reply was not to me, but it had something in it we can forget when in the heat of debate and that is that many people read the forum and we need to be clear about what we say. So I wanted to clarify a few things. I made several posts stating that at times we can legitimately resist the Pope as taught by the doctors and saints of the Church. This is true, but it is not something to be taken lightly. For the record, I am not talking only about Pope Francis, but every Pope in the future as well. It is every Catholics duty in good faith to listen to what the Pope says and comply in the areas of faith and morals if he binds us by an Ex-Cathedra statement. He is protected by the Holy Spirit when he makes an Ex-Cathedra statement so he will not ever attempt to bind us to something that goes against what has already been defined by the Magisterium as infallible or against Tradition or Scripture.

    The only way a “Pope” might do this in the future is if he were an anti-pope. We have had them in the past and approved prophecy from the saints tells us that during this time there will be one again. I believe this occurs after the Russians invade and the Pope is forced to flee from Rome.

    We are not bound by every off-hand comment Popes make. Papal infallibility is very limited. He must first state he is saying something infallibly and that he is binding the faithful to it. Most Pope's never do this even once. Pope Francis never has.

    Anyway, I just wanted to make clear I am not endorsing any kind of rebellion against the Pope's office or that we because of our own personal opinions can overrule him in binding matters of faith or morals (Ex-Cathedra statements). We should give deep thought to what any Pope says to the faithful and comply with him even in small things he asks (specific prayers, etc) which are not binding as long as they don't go against previously infallibly defined Dogma. I feel compelled to state this as clearly as I can because evidently people were either not understanding my point or not understanding Church teaching yesterday when they were calling me a protestant heretic.
     
    Last edited: Sep 7, 2015
    Basto likes this.
  7. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    One last thing. Please everyone (myself included) as Padraig has mentioned before remember we are all real people here on the forum. When we say things we can cause people to have emotional reactions. When people were calling me a protestant heretic yesterday I was very upset all day. This perhaps even led to some poorly worded posts trying to defend myself. I may have even lashed out in return.

    One of the only things I have left in this world is my faith. I have lost almost everything else through tragic circumstances. I am newly coming back to the faith after 20 years away and I am attempting to be as loyal as I can. I am flawed and my arguments are not perfect, but they are the best I can put forth.

    When someone attacks my very Catholicism by saying I am outside the church, a protestant or a heretic as some do here in a very offhand way I take it very seriously and am very hurt by it. I am as guilty of discord as others. So in humility I ask forgiveness for any I have wronged and also ask others to think twice before they post personal attacks that are hurtful.
     
  8. miker

    miker Powers

    Im considering the same choice. As much as I would miss the forum, I'm very troubled- not by the issue raised, but the tone and the constant drum beat by some in multiple threads against the Pope. I struggle with why would a Cathoic even if they had doubts do something like this ? So, time to pray and then maybe time to go.
     
  9. davidtlig

    davidtlig Guest

    The problem with the video is that it gives a wonderful platform for the views of Edward Pentin! Although Mr Pentin points out that he puts a question mark at the end of the title of his book, suggesting he is merely providing 'the evidence', it is absolutely clear where he stands on the whole question.

    What is missing from the video is any real attempt to challenge Pentin's basic understanding. I have no doubt whatever that Pope Francis would present what happened at the Synod last year in a very different light. When reading Pentin's reports at the last Synod session, I was very conscious of him presenting things from a particular standpoint. This is fair enough but anyone thinking that the standpoint is totally accurate would be making a big mistake in my view. I wonder if EWTN have provided any programming on an alternative viewpoint?

    I am sure that in any large gathering like the Synod, the methods used to allow widespread and productive discussion will be open to criticism. What Catholics should feel confident about is that Pope Francis is most certainly at the helm in all of this and so they should remain totally positive about the eventual conclusions coming from the Synod.
     
  10. josephite

    josephite Powers

    The Holy Catholic Church is going through the crucifixion just as Her head [Jesus] has already passed.

    We will be assaulted from all sides, with no where to turn. We will have to carry this cross in public and be humiliated and scorned as Our Dear Lord was.

    We will fall three times during the way of the cross, but through Jesus's strength we will stand again on weak and blood drained legs with the cross held heavy on our shoulders to continue on and we will make it to the summit of Calvary with Our blessed Mother at our side, exhausted and weeping; Where we will be nailed to this cross and hung high for the world to despise.

    This is the Victory of Love!

    Please Brother Al and Miker, do not lose heart now, because I know I need you guys by my side through these final moments.

    God Bless Us All.
    Amen
     
    Praetorian, Basto and kathy k like this.
  11. Basto

    Basto Guest


    Nevertheless, when the Son of man cometh, shall he find faith on the earth? (Luke 18:8)

    If He came today, I’m sure He would be very pleased to find you healthy, Praetorian, between so much smoke of Satan coming from everywhere! It’s beautiful to see someone loving Jesus as much as you do Praetorian, with your heart but also with your mind and soul.
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Sep 7, 2015
  12. Basto

    Basto Guest


    Yes, the Truth, which is Jesus Christ Himself, has being judged, condemned and is on the way to the crucifixion. Like 2000 years ago, there are people crying for Him, some indifferent and some spitting at Him… But don’t worry too much, like once before "not one bone of Him will be broken." (19:36)
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Sep 7, 2015
    Praetorian likes this.
  13. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    I had never heard of Edward Pentin before yesterday, it is why I stayed out of the arguments about his article. I don't like to discuss that which I am not familiar. I am sure he has an agenda, but so does Cardinal Kaspar, Cardinal Burke, Pope Francis, etc. I don't mean anything nefarious by that, just that in “political” situations like this there are agendas galore.


    You said: “What Catholics should feel confident about is that Pope Francis is most certainly at the helm in all of this and so they should remain totally positive about the eventual conclusions coming from the Synod.”


    I really honestly wish I could have the confidence you have in things turning out well. By well I men no schism/no rupture with what the Church has always taught, etc. I am just worried. I am trying to put my faith in the Holy Spirit that all will turn out well. What truly is most worrisome though is that it seems the Holy Spirit has allowed the Church to be tried very harshly over the past several decades. There is a judgment in the old testament where God sends Israel bad leaders as a punishment. I am worried that right now The Holy Spirit is not sending us the leaders we want, but the leaders we deserve for our sins. I will try to stay positive and pray for the hierarchy though. May God guide the minds of the Clergy at the synod, but most importantly the mind of Pope Francis and keep him from error.
     
  14. Aviso

    Aviso Guest

  15. miker

    miker Powers

    Perhaps every sentence of this article is true. But I once again question the motivations behind it. Is it to clarify? Is it to help the millions of souls who are in sin or have committed great sin to find a path to God and mercy? Or is it to uphold the laws, the rituals, the canonical processes in and if themselves? Who knows the hearts and minds of these who write these articles and these who seek to highlight them here and in other forums? I can only say for me, and me alone, that I wonder will God say to a sinner who with all heart, mind, and soul seeks Him in this year of Mercy that sorry unfortunately, thus was not canonically valid so your still a sinner or excommunicated. I perhaps am not enlightened enough or know enough of the "rules" of the Church, but I think not. I will take this approach and I will rather encourage all, including family members who are in the very positionFrancis has highlighted to Be not afraid and approach God with full expectations of complete forgiveness.

    That is it now for me at least on this thread and any other that may pop up between now and October (if there is an. October:)) of what I now consider hostile threads toward the Vicar of Christ.

    Peace to you all.
     
  16. fallen saint

    fallen saint Baby steps :)

    Aviso,

    Maybe you should read Our Holy Fathers words. Miker pretty much said it all. Our Holy Father has stated don't focus on the letter of the law. Jesus said the same thing when He spoke to the jewish priests. The Holy Father is doing all he can to save souls. He wrote a simple letter asking the church to be merciful to sinners. And then some dumb-dumb says there MIGHT be canonical questions or errors. All the Pope wants to do is save as many souls as possible... before he is called up to Gods judgement. Do we even comprehend the burden he has chosen to carry. Some of us here take all this as a game. Our Holy Father is fighting a evil battle the best he can. This is truely a war against SATAN. And all someone can say is...i'm not positive its canonically correct.

    Its time for many of us to start focussing on the spiritual side of Gods calling. Its not easy but the battle is raging and people are helping the "created one" in this forum.


    Brother al
     
  17. CrewDog

    CrewDog Guest

  18. Fatima

    Fatima Powers

    I would not go so far as to say 'the Holy Catholic Church is going through the crucifixion', it is rather a purification and it is necessary. Apostasy through the ranks of the Church from Cardinals, Bishops, Priests and Religious has been going on for decades, ruining the very innocence of the baptized and it needs a cleaning. This is taking place now in the Church as well as globally in all countries. God is purifying us all and if you are to live through it, we must go through purgatory on earth. Best things we can do is pray so that we do not fall ourselves.
     
  19. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    http://wdtprs.com/blog/2015/09/rules-to-be-severely-changed-for-upcoming-synod-in-october/#comments
    Rules to be severely changed for upcoming Synod in October
    At Monday Vatican Andrea Gagliarducci has news about changes to be made in the procedure for the upcoming Synod in October.

    Last year the organizers of the Synod changed rules in order to more easily ram through their agenda. This year is no different. Look what they are going to do. My emphases:

    […]​

    Some well-informed people say that the 2015 Synod will be completely different from any other. First of all, a midterm report will not be released. Last year, the midterm report was completely revised by some of the Pope’s closest collaborators prior to its release, and the report resulted in many controversies. Even Cardinal Petr Erdo, the Synod’s General Relator, distanced himself from the report. But its release united the followers of the Church’s doctrine, who stood up against the Synod’s drift. They ultimately achieved an acceptable compromise for the Synod’s Final Report, which was filled with biblical references that had been lacking in the midterm report.​

    Avoiding the release of a midterm report would mean eliminating any possibility of discussion. The plan is for the Synod to carry out discussions mostly in “small groups” (circuli minores) without a general discussion. In the end, the reports of the small groups would be put in the Pope’s hands, and the Pope would then give a final address. No final report or post-synodal apostolic exhortation is foreseen at the moment, at least according to recent rumors. In this way the adapters hope to convince the Pope to employ vague language so they can eventually exploit his words.​

    […]​

    If they don’t have general discussion after small groups discussions, and if reports won’t be circulated to other groups, the members of Group A won’t know what members of Group B said. If the reports from the individual groups go straight to the Pope via the office that organizes the Synod…[​IMG]

    I direct the readership’s attention to Edward Pentin’s new ebook about last years Synod. There efforts to rig the last Synod to accomplish a pre-determined agenda.

    The Rigging of a Vatican Synod? An Investigation of Alleged Manipulation at the Extraordinary Synod on the Family
     
  20. Infant Jesus of Prague

    Infant Jesus of Prague The More you Honor Me The More I will Bless Thee

    On Good Friday, was the Good thiefs confession Cannonically correct??? Venerable Sheen said he stole Heaven, perhaps a Cannonical inquirey is needed....just sayin!;)
     
    hope, miker and fallen saint like this.
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page