(cont'd from above) Don Hanchon, an auxiliary bishop in Detroit, said he was surprised his images were featured on the group’s website and in brochures. Hanchon told the AP he might have sent in a donation, but the photograph “seems like I’m a big supporter, and that’s just not the truth.” Szoka died in 2014 and Burke could not be reached for comment. Perrone told an interviewer in 2013 that Opus Bono’s relationship with the Roman Catholic Church was deliberately arms-length. “The church benefits from what we’re doing but it doesn’t give it the support,” he said. “The whole point of this is to be a counterpoint to a movement which is also outside the church, a movement of dissent and against the priesthood.” But the group also presented itself as deeply entwined with the church, right down to its name, which means “work for the good of the priesthood.” “Use of the Latin, which is the official language of the Church, helps to identify OBS with the Catholic Church in Rome and the Papacy,” the group’s founding documents note. In addition to courting religious leaders, Opus Bono also has benefited from connections to wealthy U.S. Catholics. A radio network founded by Tom Monaghan, a billionaire Domino’s Pizza founder who later advised President Donald Trump’s 2016 campaign, interviewed Maher and Perrone and promoted Opus Bono’s work, according to archived Ave Maria Radio recordings. Monaghan’s Ave Maria Foundation also sponsored a community talk Maher gave at a Detroit hotel, according to the recordings. And a former chaplain at Florida-based Ave Maria School of Law, which Monaghan founded and on whose board he serves, was listed as an Opus Bono adviser on the group’s website. A spokesman for Monaghan declined to comment on Opus Bono. Joe Maher has said that Monaghan never made any direct donations to the group. In their four locations over 17 years — three of them in towns in rural Michigan — the group didn’t post signs. In 2005, in Oxford, Michigan, Opus Bono retrofitted one side of an old metal-casting facility adjacent to a high school for its headquarters. At noon, metal workers would halt their noisy work to let Opus Bono staffers observe Mass and sometimes join in prayer, two former employees of the group said. The group’s next move, in 2014, was 20 miles away to the village of Dryden. Local officials were puzzled when they heard Maher and Ferrara wanted to set up a Hollywood-style production studio in a dilapidated warehouse off Main Street — again facing an elementary school playground. Nothing was mentioned about priests. “They were very tight-lipped and never talked about anything having to do with priests,” said Gyrome Edwards, a building and zoning official in Dryden. “They were just trying to go unseen.” Each week inside the warehouse, office workers mailed out appeals to potential donors in envelopes featuring pictures of the pope. The letters inside, as well as postings on the group’s website, included testimonials describing the purported experiences of priests who’d faced desperate crises, including false accusations of sexual abuse. One testimonial from May 2018, for example, claimed that a “Father David” had been stalked by a mentally unbalanced parishioner who had accused him of sexual misconduct after he turned down her offers of gifts and money. “Even when a priest has done absolutely nothing wrong,” the testimonial asserted, “the Church will sometimes go to the nth degree, including subjecting some priests to unwarranted psychological trauma, and a very long wait to return to active ministry, all to appease a terribly aggressive accuser.” The testimonials, however, were misleading, an investigation by Michigan’s attorney general found. Opus Bono’s lawyers conceded to state investigators that Maher had concocted them by stitching together stories from various priests. The state’s investigation began after it was contacted by a once-loyal Opus Bono employee — Maher’s own daughter, Mary Rose, now 27. In February 2017, she wrote a letter to the state attorney general accusing the group of financial misconduct. “A simple investigation into the Michigan non-profit charity Opus Bono Sacerdotii would bring to light the millions of embezzled dollars, years of mail fraud, and the constant systemic abuse of donations,” she wrote. The tip landed on the desk of Assistant Attorney General William Bloomfield, a devout Catholic with a law degree from Ave Maria. The investigation lasted more than a year. Investigators concluded the group’s fundraising solicitations had been deceptive. They also found that Maher and Ferrara had violated state charity laws by using donated funds to cover such personal expenses as sushi lunches, chiropractor visits and power tools to work on their homes, according to a cease and desist order filed by Michigan’s attorney general. Over the years, as the group grew richer — financial records show donations increased from $73,000 in 2002 to $1.3 million in 2016 — Maher’s pay soared from $40,500 to $212,000. Ferrara’s rose from $16,300 to $316,000. “Maher and Ferrara took what they wanted, when they wanted it,” the attorney general’s office wrote, demanding repayment of more than $500,000. A former board member — J. Michael Carrigan, a former Smithsonian Institution director — said that whatever the co-founders paid themselves was only to reimburse the tens of thousands of dollars they spent out of their own pockets supporting priests in Opus Bono’s early days. Ultimately, Bloomfield oversaw a settlement last December that required Opus Bono to pay $10,000 to cover the costs of the state’s investigation and forced Ferrara and Maher from their jobs at the nonprofit. The group’s entire board of directors was replaced. Within weeks of the settlement, Bloomfield left his job at the attorney general’s office and took a job with the Catholic Diocese of Lansing, Michigan, as general counsel. Bloomfield said his work on the investigation did not represent a conflict of interest because Opus Bono is a nonprofit, separate from the church. But four years before Bloomfield began directing the state’s investigation of Opus Bono, he attended a service chanted by Perrone and the Assumption Grotto choir that moved him “to a deep and joyful praise of God,” he wrote on Facebook. Bloomfield told the AP his parents knew Perrone and that he had attended services at Assumption Grotto on occasion as a youth. Bloomfield also sells religious texts through his own imprint, Sacred Art Series, which sometimes can be found for sale at Assumption Grotto’s gift shop, a clerk said. Bloomfield said he has never sold books there directly, but added it’s possible that his mother, who served on a nonprofit board with Perrone, may have dropped off some copies. Despite the settlement, the story of Opus Bono continues to unfold. The Archdiocese of Detroit has asked the Vatican to review the sexual misconduct allegations against Father Perrone. Mary Rose Maher recently launched her own nonprofit group. She says the group will support survivors of sexual abuse, positioning it squarely in opposition to her father’s organization even as she adapts some of its tactics — offering shelter, legal representation and emotional and financial help. She is soliciting donations to build a “safe haven house” and raising money by selling tickets to a banquet that will be held at an as-yet-determined date. Her father, who was required by the state to never again run a nonprofit in Michigan, has launched a second nonprofit that seems to have the identical mission of helping priests in need. The new group is called Men of Melchizedek, a reference to an Old Testament figure who was thought to be both a king and a priest. It is registered in Indiana, but its website says its “principal office” is located in Michigan. The group lists Maher as its president. In a March letter to the Michigan attorney general, Maher’s attorney described him something akin to a case worker whose labors are “a corporal and spiritual work of mercy; it is how he practices his Catholic faith.” The letter said the new group will provide the same services as Opus Bono, but warned that “more vulnerable beneficiaries may be lost to suicide during the transition.” Both Opus Bono and Men of Melchizedek now list the same canon lawyer, the Rev. David Deibel, as their chairman. Deibel, Joe Maher and Maher’s attorneys did not return multiple messages from the AP. On its website, the new group promises “non-judgmental support and life-time accompaniment for our priest-clients who are so very much in need.” “We turn no priest away,” it says. https://apnews.com/abe2da0da2f648ad89dde483a92d3f19
US Bishop calls out brother bishops: ‘Deposit of faith has been fragmented and corrupted’ Lisa Bourne casti connubii, catholic, contraception, deposit of faith, diocese of tyler, humanae vitae, immorality, joseph strickland, paul xi, sexual morality, us catholic bishops July 22, 2019 (LifeSiteNews) -- Bishop Joseph Strickland of Tyler, Texas, spoke out on Twitter over the weekend about how the Catholic Church’s moral teaching on sexuality and the family has been broken and tainted of late, and he called for a return to the truth of that teaching by Catholic laity and bishops. He said: Bishop Strickland told LifeSiteNews his tweet was prompted by the upcoming anniversary of Humanae Vitae, and that he has been trying to tweet periodically on the themes contained in the document. The 51st anniversary of the landmark encyclical on contraception and human life promulgated by St. Pope Paul VI is July 25. The document upheld the Church’s teaching on immorality of contraception and is considered prophetic by many for its prediction of many social ills that have come to pass, such as marital infidelity, a general decline of morality, increased disrespect for women, and population control. “Our society is unraveling, especially with regard to marriage, family and sexual morality,” Strickland said. “This is all the more tragic because God has revealed the truth that we need to flourish in this world and share eternal life with Him after we depart this world.” The bishop acknowledged that he and all bishops share the same call to shepherd their respective flocks, and he said he feels as he could do more to promote what he called “our beautiful Catholic teachings on these topics.” “I’m sure some of my brothers have done a much better job,” he said, “but I think we all need to ask ourselves how we can share the truth more clearly and more powerfully.” The bishop had tweeted about Humanae Vitae last week, saying “It speaks of God’s glorious plan for marriage and it has been ignored for far too long.” “If you haven’t read it, please do so with a heart open to the truth,” he said. Learn more about Bishop Strickland’s views and past actions by visiting FaithfulShepherds.com. Click here. The day before his tweet on the fragmenting and corruption of the deposit of faith, Strickland tweeted about Pope Pius XI’s 1930 encyclical Casti Connubii, which affirmed the Catholic Church’s doctrine on marriage. “If only humanity had listened almost 100 years ago,” he said. “May people of faith read this teaching with open hearts today.” Strickland has given voice to the importance of the deposit of faith regularly in the past, whether on Twitter, in interviews, or from the floor of the USCCB General Assembly, including the promise bishops make to guard it upon their episcopal consecration. The deposit of faith, or depositum fidei, is the truth of God’s Revelation as expressed in Sacred Scripture, which is the inspired and written Word of God, and Sacred Tradition, which is the Word of God as taught and transmitted through the teaching authority of the Church. At a bishop’s consecration, he is asked, “Do you resolve to guard the deposit of faith, entire and incorrupt, as handed down by the Apostles and preserved in the Church everywhere and at all times?” At last fall’s U.S. Bishops’ meeting, Strickland challenged his fellow bishops whether they as a conference were all on the same page with regard to the immorality of homosexual activity, considering the Theodore McCarrick scandal and the fact that some dioceses allow presentations of LGBT activism. “It’s part of our deposit of faith that we believe homosexual activity is immoral,” Strickland said. “The people, those that we label ‘homosexual,’ are children of God, and they need our great care,” he added. “But to me that real care comes from acknowledging the sin, and the reality that all of us are sinners called from sin to virtue.” [Emphasis added.] “How did this happen,” Strickland asked of the McCarrick scandal, “if we really believe that what was going on was wrong?” “There seem to be questions about that,” said Bishop Strickland. “And I think we have to face that directly – Do we believe the doctrine of the Church, or not?” Strickland made the same comment with regard to abortion in June during an interview with LifeSiteNews. *** US bishop begins celebrating Sunday Mass ad orientem, encourages practice ‘throughout’ diocese Lisa Bourne | https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/u...ientem-encourages-practice-throughout-diocese ad orientem, catholic, diocese of gallup, james wall, mass, vatican ii July 26, 2019 ... Ad orientem worship had been the common orientation for the Mass for more than 1,500 years until Vatican II in the 1960s, when priests began to take it upon themselves to turn around to face the congregation. ... Wall also corrected the misconception that Mass celebrated ad orientem had been disallowed by the Second Vatican Council. “This is not accurate,” stated Wall, “as none of the conciliar documents even mention this.” “Additionally, a close reading of the rubrics of the Roman Missal will still show today that ad orientem is assumed to be the normal posture at Mass,” he explained, “they often describe the priest “turning to face the people,” which implies he is facing the altar before and after doing so.” ... *** FYI, https://twitter.com/cardinalrlburke
Now if only his nerve and courage might, by the grace of God, spread like wild fire throughout the U.S!!! I pray others both speak up and follow suit!
Opinion Why are America’s Jesuits going to bat for Communism? By Damian Thompson | July 29, 2019 | https://nypost.com/2019/07/29/why-are-americas-jesuits-going-to-bat-for-communism/ Russian marchers carry a portrait of Soviet leader Joseph Stalin during a Victory Day military parade . Shutterstock Last week, a New York-based magazine published a 3,000-word article about Communism that failed to mention the murder of 50 million people — the lowest possible estimate — by Communist regimes during the 20th century. The rambling essay didn’t once accuse Stalin’s Soviet Union, Mao’s China or Pol Pot’s Cambodia of killing anyone. Instead, it congratulated Communists for fighting the “violent capitalist economy” of the United States. You would assume that such squalid agitprop could appear only in a sectarian Marxist publication, or on a website run by clueless millennials who have never even heard of the gulag or the Cultural Revolution. But you would be wrong. The author, Dean Dettloff, is indeed a hardline Communist. He’s a young Canadian supporter of the Marxist-Leninist Party for Socialism and Liberation, which deplores China’s move away from Mao’s ideological purity and hates Gorbachev for destroying the Soviet Union. But who published him? America magazine, the century-old Jesuit periodical that is among the most influential Catholic publications in the United States. How can we explain this grotesque lapse of judgment? Dettloff isn’t some crazy freelancer who slipped his propaganda into the current issue of America when the editors weren’t paying sufficient attention. (As a magazine editor, I know this can happen.) Dettloff is America’s Toronto correspondent. For two years, he has been writing partisan dispatches for America, making excuses for Venezuela’s narco-dictator, Nicolás Maduro, glorifying the far-left thugs of the antifa movement and never missing an opportunity to depict the United States as the Great Satan of capitalism. “The United States is bad. It’s not good. It would be better if it didn’t exist, and someday, whether by the march of historical contingency or extinction, it won’t,” he tweeted on the Fourth of July, which he called “an abhorrent and perverse holiday that Christians have reasons to hate.” In an introduction to “Animal Farm” never published in his lifetime, George Orwell described the “servility” with which the “literary establishment have swallowed Russian propaganda.” But he was describing English Soviet apologists whose silence about the gulag was explained partly by the wartime alliance with Stalin against Hitler. Dettloff doesn’t even have that excuse. Nor, apparently, do his well-funded Jesuit editors. They are happy to whitewash and euphemize genocides — in which their fellow Jesuits perished — as “tragic mistakes.” Dettloff, and his editors by implication, reserve their anger for the “unbridled terrorism” of capitalism. God only know what Pope Francis makes of this. He remembers Soviet tyranny and has never defended it. As the Jesuit provincial in Argentina, he opposed liberation theology — a strand of Catholic thought, in vogue in Latin America in the 1960s, ’70s and ’80s, that sees the church’s primary mission not as the salvation of souls, but the liberation of the “oppressed” on earth (understood in Marxian terms). As a pontiff, however, he seems unconcerned by the crushing of religion in China, with which the Vatican has signed a concordat that grants the Chinese Communist Party a say in the selection of Catholic bishops. He has maintained a troubling silence on the herding of China’s Muslim Uighurs into concentration camps. But regardless of their views on Francis’ pontificate, American Catholics should be alarmed by Communist apologetics appearing in the pages of the country’s premier Jesuit journal. It’s of a piece with the preening naivety of countless millennial commentators, of whom Dettloff is an extreme example, who roll their eyes at any mention of Communist barbarism. An ideology drenched with the blood of Catholics — bishops, priests, nuns and laypeople — should never find a home in a journal devoted to the Catholic faith. Damian Thompson is associate editor of The Spectator. *** Polish priest attacked in sacristy during apparent robbery Hannah Brockhaus/CNA | 30 July, 2019 | https://catholicherald.co.uk/news/2...attacked-in-sacristy-during-apparent-robbery/ A Catholic priest was severely beaten in an attack by three men in the sacristy of St. John the Baptist church in Szczecin on Sunday, in what was reportedly an attempted robbery. Fr. Aleksander Ziejewski, 68, was attacked July 28 shortly before the 6 pm Mass. He had responded to a call for help from the sacristan, who said three men had entered the sacristy and were trying to take a chasuble, claiming they needed it to celebrate Mass, according to the priest. ... “We recommend offering [prayers for] the victims of this brutal beating, as well as praying for the conversion and repentance of the perpetrators,” the spokesman said. ...
Interesting development and something I’ve held for some time: There is only one way, in logic at least, for a Catholic to accept Vatican I on papal infallibility but reject a heretical declaration that seemingly meets the formal conditions of being ex cathedra. Given that a true pope is protected by the Holy Spirit from teaching an error ex cathedra, it follows that if a man, seemingly “pope,” were to teach something which denies or conflicts with a known truth of the Catholic Faith it must be either (1) the man thought to be “pope” was never a true pope to begin with, or (2) the man thought to be “pope” had, at some point in the past, already fallen through heresy or apostasy from the Petrine office. Those are the logical implications as I see them. Whether these are intended by the Cardinal or not with respect to Francis, in such a hypothetical scenario as he outlined, I cannot say. If this a fair analysis, it may suggest the Cardinal and at least a few others in the Sacred College are actively considering one of these options to be a real possibility in the case of Pope Francis. If nothing else, it certainly is a shot across the bow of Pope Francis. It does suggest, along with other statements from the likes of Cardinal Brandmuller, that some in the “resistance” are reaching the point where they can bend no more. So, after so many years, we may be reaching a decisive moment.
I have reached a horrific conclusion that the infiltration within the Church by the Freemasons and their weakling associates within the episcopate have reached a point where the next Papal election will not provide the desired reversal. The number of bishops sticking their necks out in an attempt to stem the tide are too few to rouse the fence sitters to join their ranks. Jesus, prepare our hearts for persecution and martyrdom. O Mary, conceived without sin pray for us who have recourse to you. When the day comes in which I must choose, give me the courage to remain faithful to the One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church. Let me remember the English martyrs of the 16th century, such as Thomas More, Cardinal John Fisher, Edmund Campion, Margaret Clitherow, and others who stood firm to the end. Mark 8: 38 For whoever is ashamed of Me and My words in this adulterous and sinful generation, the Son of Man will also be ashamed of him when He comes in the glory of His Father with the holy angels.
Fr. Z's Blog UPDATED – IMPORTANT – John Paul Institute 2.0 and the systematic purge of the last remaining “Wojtylians” Posted on 29 July 2019 by Fr. John Zuhlsdorf UPDATE 30 July 2019 Folks, this is a “big deal”. What’s being done to the John Paul II Institute is emblematic of what is happening – and is going to happen – in Rome and in the rest of the Church outside of Rome. It’s a signal from HQ to the sleeper cells: “It’s time to come out of hiding and STRIKE!” I will remind the readers that in January 2018, after Maurizio Chiodi (whom I mention below) gave his pro-contraception talk at the Jesuit-run Gregorian University, I described him as a “canary in the mineshaft”. With Kasper’s address and the two rigged Family Synods, to Amoris laetitia and Chiodi and the changes at the Pontifical Academy for Life etc. etc., we’ve been watching a brilliantly executed campaign of “creeping incrementalism”. They are patient, friends, and move slowly but inexorably toward their goals like a bone-crushing juggernaut. Bone by bone. Nothing too dramatic at the beginning, but inexorably forward with the conviction that potential opposition is too fragmented to make a difference. This is why I have often – as Michael Matt has too – called for a stop to the parochial posturing of some in the conservative and traditional side of life in the Church. Libs set aside their pet issues temporarily for the sake of combining forces and working for the overturning of the status quo. Ever wonder how libs, dems, feminists, LGBTSJs etc. seem to coddle even Islamic terror? The enemy of my enemy. See Andrew McCarthy on that [US HERE – UK HERE]. Conservatives tend to defend their tiny wrinkles of turf to the point that they couldn’t coordinate enough to run a bird cage, much less mount a strong offense. Pay attention to this one and gird your loins. See what I added, below. ___ Originally published Published on: Jul 29, 2019 When I was in the Theology section at the Pontifical Lateran University, I would see at the end one of the hallways the doors leading into the John Paul II Institute for Marriage and the Family, founded at the sainted Pope’s behest after Familiaris consortio by the eventual Cardinal (and one of the four Dubia brothers) Carlo Caffarra. It was a great institution which activated John Paul’s teachings. Francis renamed the place and gave it a new mission in 2017. Then he appointed new personnel to carry out that mission. Co-founder of the Sant’Egidio group and a postulator for the cause of Oscar Romero Archbp. Vincenzo Paglia reigns over the place now as Grand Chancellor of the Lateran. You might have read also about Paglia that there is a seemingly homo-erotic fresco image of him in a fresco (which he commissioned) in the cathedral of his former Diocese of Terni-Narni-Amelia. The President, now, is Pierangelo Sequeri. Part of the mission of the new team at the Institute seems to be part of an over-arching agenda: diminish the magisterial teachings of John Paul II. That’s, frankly, at the core of the Five Dubia of the Four Cardinals, among whom was Caffarra, probably the main author of the sumbitted Dubia. The question, dubia, center on affirmations in Familiaris consortio and Veritatis splendor. In any event, the now-former President of the JP Institute, Msgr Livio Melina, a tenured-professor of Moral Theology, was recently sacked from his teaching post. Also sacked, Stanslaw Gryiegel, a long-time friend of John Paul who in 2018 criticized those in the circle of Francis who were undermining the teachings of Humane vitae on contraception. You might recall that Maurizio Chiodi – a disciple of the infamous darling of the Fishwrap and Curran-types and Hell’s Bible, Bernard Häring – in a talk at the Gregorian (Jesuits) suggested that Amoria laetitia perhaps made artificial contraception acceptable. Chiodi was – incredibly – appointed to the Pontifical Academy for Life (headed by Paglia). It seems that the new statues of JPII Institute 2.0 make no reference to the teachings of JPII or to Humanae vitae. In Rome, it is said that Paglia and the “Pagliani” are conducting a purge of the last remaining “Wojtylians”. No joke. In the headline, below, Card. Scola, former head of the Lateran (when I was there) and therefore head of the JPII Institute says: “Purge” What’s next? Disappear people out of airplanes?
Dear Jesus, may in your Mercy keep us who seek you give us strength and courage to endure this avalanche.
The Vandals sack Rome….again Is there a red hat in Archbishop Vincenzo Paglia’s future? If so, it will be as a reward for knee-capping scholars of impeccable scholarly credentials and personal probity, deeply beloved by their students. George Weigel | July 29, 2019 | https://www.catholicworldreport.com/2019/07/29/the-vandals-sack-rome-again/ JPII Institute Students Publish Letter Expressing ‘Immense Concern’ Over New Statutes In a July 24 letter, the students call on the institute’s president and grand chancellor for clarity and a ‘timely response’ to their concerns but have yet to receive an answer. Edward Pentin | Jul. 30, 2019 | http://www.ncregister.com/blog/edwa...s-publish-letter-expressing-immense-concern-o When High Noon Strikes Elizabeth A. Mitchell | Saturday, July 27, 2019 | https://www.thecatholicthing.org/2019/07/27/when-high-noon-strikes/
Joan, Thank you. Once again, I credit Edward Pentin. I try to check his twitter posts often because they always seem to be very good. I especially like George Weigel's article in that group.
From Michael's newsletter: Dear Friends and family, The horrendous evil of sexual exploitation of the young by clerics has caused untold grief and loss of faith. In Abuse of Sexuality in the Catholic Church, the internationally acclaimed author and sociologist Gabriele Kuby examines in detail the roots of this ongoing crisis in the Church. Included in the book is the full 32-page text of my essay “The Scandals and the Shepherds,” in which I recount my personal experiences of abuse in a Catholic residential school, and reflect on the lessons we must learn from the current crisis. Also included are Pope Benedict XVI’s “The Church and the Scandal of Sexual Abuse” and Gerhard Cardinal Müller’s “Manifesto of Faith.” If you are interested in obtaining the book, it can be ordered from the publisher, Divine Providence Press at: https://www.divineprovidencepress.com/gabriele-kuby.html or at Amazon books: https://www.amazon.com/dp/0991583256?ref_=pe_3052080_397514860 My recently published book, The Family and the New Totalitarianism is also available at Divine Providence Press: https://www.divineprovidencepress.com/michael-d-obrien.html or at Amazon Books: https://www.amazon.com/Family-New-Totalitarianism-Michael-OBrien/dp/0991583264/ref=sr_1_1? In the heart of our souls we must love the Bride of Christ more than ever before, and suffer with her, as we stand firm in the midst of betrayals and humiliations, horrendous sins and heresies—our eyes on the true horizon, waiting for the Bridegroom’s return. Grace and peace be with you in our Saviour Jesus. He is near. Michael D. O’Brien
JPII Institute profs dismissed for interpreting Francis in line with Tradition? Former president speaks out Diane Montagna | https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/j...ne-with-tradition-former-president-speaks-out ROME, August 5, 2019 (LifeSiteNews) —Is Catholic thought still possible today? Or will those who seek to interpret Pope Francis’s pronouncements in line with his predecessors be persecuted solely for explaining the meaning of his words in harmony with Tradition? In his first interview since his dismissal from the restructured John Paul II Institute in Rome (see full text below), former president and chair of fundamental moral theology, Monsignor Livio Melina, has said the fate of the Institute will be “decisive for the Church,” and that what is at stake is not just the institute and legacy of John Paul II, but also the freedom to engage in “Catholic” thought. “If the decisions taken by Archbishop Paglia are not revoked, then what they are saying is: ‘The interpretation of the magisterium of Pope Francis in continuity with the previous Magisterium is intolerable in the Church,’” Msgr. Melina told the Italian daily La Verità on Aug. 3. In the interview, Melina responds to accusations levelled one day prior by journalist Luciano Moia of Avvenire, the official newspaper of the Italian Bishops Conference, that he and other prominent professors at the John Paul II Institute “corrected the Pope” by interpreting his words in continuity with Tradition. Readers will recall Moia’s name from his recent interview with controversial figure, Fr. Maurizio Chiodi, in which the Italian moral theologian (who has been invited to teach at the restructured John Paul II institute) said that it may be morally good for a person to remain in an active homosexual relationship in some circumstances. Interestingly, Moia claims in his Aug. 2 article that Msgr. Melina and the former chair of special moral theology, Fr. José Noriega, were removed not only for the reasons stated by institute chancellor, Archbishop Vincenzo Paglia, in his dismissal letter, but also for the content of their teaching, i.e. for “minimizing the scope of the change wanted by Pope Francis.” Moia accused Melina of seeking to “demolish the many points of originality present in Amoris Laetitia,” by suggesting that these new ideas have to be interpreted in light of Pope John Paul II’s encyclicals on the family, Familiaris Consortio, and the Church’s moral teaching, Veritatis Splendor. Painting Msgr. Melina as “a theologian correcting two Synods and a Pope,” Moia also criticized him for openly saying that “even after Amoris Laetitia, admitting the divorced and ‘remarried’ to Holy Communion outside the situations stipulated in Familiars Consortio 84, and Sacramentum Caritatis 29, goes against the discipline of the Church.” In his Aug. 3 response in La Verità, Melina suggested that Moia “offer arguments” rather than accusing him of “correcting” the Pope. Otherwise, he said, “what the accuser [Moia] is doing is absolutizing his own interpretation, as if it were the only obvious reading of the text.” According to Melina’s line of thought, the clash is therefore not between “bergoglians” and “wojtyłians” but between an ideological, revolutionary and totalitarian interpretation of Pope Francis’s thought, and simple “Catholic” thought which seeks to interpret his pronouncements within the whole of Tradition. In his Aug. 2 article, Moia also accused Msgr. Melina and other long-time professors, such as Polish philosopher and friend of John Paul II, Stanislaw Grygiel, and former institute vice-president, Fr. José Granados, of betraying the Gospel by putting doctrine before pastoral care. Dismissing Moia’s charge, Melina said that “this approach, which separates Christ the ‘Teacher’ from Christ the ‘Shepherd, as if there were two Jesuses, is quite common today.” He noted, however, that “the mercy of Jesus and his pastoral care passed by way of his doctrine, as Mark’s Gospel says: ‘He had compassion on them, because they were like sheep without a shepherd, and he began to teach them many things’ (Mk 6:33-34).” Melina described what has been done to various professors at the John Paul II Institute in Rome as a “conviction without a trial.” “There is a paradox in all of this,” he said. “Some dissenting theologians from Catholic moral theology, who clearly opposed the Magisterium, have been banned from teaching, but this happened after a regular trial.” “But what happened in the case of the professors of the John Paul II Institute?” Melina continued. “The accusation is not that of denying Catholic doctrine, but only of not following a particular interpretation of the Magisterium of Pope Francis.” “But, above all,” he said, “we have been deprived of our professorship without any possibility of defending ourselves, without us even having heard … what we are really accused of. The newspaper Avvenire had the merit of highlighting the real reasons for our dismissal, which had not been communicated to us, and thus unmasked the manoeuvre that is to be carried out at the Institute founded by St. John Paul II.” If Moia’s claim that Msgr. Melina and Fr. Noriega were dismissed because of the content of their teaching, and not solely for the reasons stated by Archbishop Paglia, it could well open up a Pandora’s box of legal problems for the Vatican. An informed source in Rome told LifeSite: “If Moia’s argument were right, and Melina was dismissed on account of the content of his teaching, then Melina should immediately be reinstated.” “If the grounds are indeed the content of his teaching, he would have the right to a process analogous to that of Charles Curran in the 1980s. Until the results of that trial are out, Msgr. Melina would have to be allowed to teach,” he said. In 1986, after due process, the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, headed by then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, stripped Father Curran of his right to teach theology at The Catholic University of America, for his obstinate and public dissent against a long line of moral teachings. The source also noted that “if Moia is right, and these are the grounds, then there will be a real scandal.” He explained: Moia is admitting that an obvious violation of academic freedom has taken place. Paglia and Sequeri, for their argumentation to work, would have to distance themselves radically from Moia and emphasize that they hold nothing against Melina’s teaching and agree with Melina that Moia is guilty of slander. If they side with Moia, instead, they openly admit a rampant violation of academic freedom. “Moia’s article is in a way rather revealing in that it shows the extent of the scandal,” he said. “It lays open that the reasons given for the dismissals of Melina and Noriega were just argumentative fig leaves to avoid having to go through a due process in order to dismiss Melina and Noriega, because such due process could never have led to their dismissal.” Here below we publish the official English translation of the full interview with Msgr. Melina which first appeared in edited form in La Verità. [Please click on the link above for the interview.] *** Amid JPII Institute controversy, Benedict XVI meets with recently dismissed professor August 5, 2019 | https://www.catholicnewsagency.com/...meets-with-recently-dismissed-professor-12168 *** Italians seek comfort from tarot cards, faith healers and spiritualists amid decade-long slump August 5, 2019 | https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/20...-healers-spiritualists/?WT.mc_id=tmg_share_tw
Here's praying that our individual Bishops stay focused on the True Magisterium! Clearly they need our prayers all the more, as well as St Peter's successor, our Pope Francis. GROAN