Although I wouldn't agree with everything he says, this report from Michael Matt sums up what was wrong with the summit from the outset:
I watched it, Beth, and it was short. They referred again to the Communists having had a place in St. Gallen to train recruits for the priesthood. Does anyone know exactly where McCarrick spent that year in Switzerland? At first people said that he stayed in a monastery in St. Gallen. Then, when it was established that there has been no monastery in St. Gallen since long before McCarrick went there, James Grein said that the monastery wasn't in the Canton of St. Gallen. Where was it? If it was a monastery what religious order did it belong to? It can't have been the Jesuits because they were banned from Switzerland and were only allowed back in when the Swiss amended their Constitution in the 1970's to comply with conditions for entering the European Union.
Just to clarify. The benign motivation would be the moving of a perpetrator to where he could be observed and would have less opportunity to transgress. Personally, I would think it more prudent to call the relevant police and let the justice professionals sort it out.
Feb. 25, 2019 | http://www.ncregister.com/daily-news/the-vatican-abuse-meeting-analysis The Vatican Abuse Meeting: Passing the McCarrick Test ANALYSIS: By its end, the Vatican summit felt incomplete, with scant mention made of the root cause and other aspects of abuse. Matthew Bunson In his opening address to the “Meeting on the Protection of Minors in the Church” on Feb. 21, Pope Francis placed before the assembly — and himself — a very clear task: “The holy People of God look to us and expect from us not simple and predictable condemnations, but concrete and effective measures to be undertaken. We need to be concrete.” It was a stern demand and a high bar going forward. By the end of the gathering, Catholics were still angry and victims lamented what they described as yet another missed opportunity. ‘An All-Out Battle’ Over the four days of the Vatican summit, from Feb. 21-24, nine different speakers addressed different aspects of the sex-abuse crisis. All of the speakers were, for the vast majority of Catholics and the wider world, merely a prelude to the most important voice of the summit: Pope Francis, in his much-anticipated final speech at the end of the Mass on Feb. 24 in the sumptuous Sala Regia, in the Apostolic Palace. The speech will be remembered by many less for what was said than what was not said. On a vast international stage, the Pope did not offer an apology to the victims. Nor, as was also the case throughout the summit, did he address all of the dark roots of the crisis. His final address was unquestionably a risk. Having decided apparently that the apology offered the previous evening during a penitential service sufficed for a global audience and that victims had long been saying that more than mere apologies and words were needed, the Holy Father demurred from a formal apology and appealed directly for a global campaign to eradicate child abuse in all of its forms. “I make a heartfelt appeal,” he said, “for an all-out battle against the abuse of minors, both sexually and in other areas, on the part of all authorities and individuals, for we are dealing with abominable crimes that must be erased from the face of the earth.” While the Pope declared that sex abuse is “all the more grave and scandalous in the Church,” he sought to raise the issue of this terrible scourge to a worldwide phenomenon not limited to the boundaries of Catholicism. He urged the world “to work together to eradicate this evil from the body of our humanity by adopting every necessary measure already in force on the international level and ecclesial levels.” That was followed by eight points derived in part from the World Health Organization and various international bodies, as well as the Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors. They included formation, reviewing guidelines by episcopal conferences, accompaniment of the abused, the digital world and sexual tourism. These are worthy goals, and the Pope is absolutely correct that this horror is a global plague that impacts hundreds of millions of children. The challenge comes with the logical question from many in the media as to whether it is appropriate for Pope Francis to call for a universal crusade until he has first put his own Catholic house in order. And as the meeting would indicate, that essential task is still far from being realized. The McCarrick Test It was a bold call, but it also marked a striking departure from the topics and direction of the rest of the summit, with its stated focus on the sex-abuse crisis within the Church. The result was that the Pope’s final address overshadowed all of the other speakers, rather than affirming and summarizing what they had said. This was a pity, because some of the speeches were quite effective or showed flashes of a way forward that might truly benefit the Church in a time of deep trauma. As was needed, the meeting touched on the role of bishops and looked for ways to hold them accountable and responsible for crimes of abuse or cover-up. This might have been an opportunity to begin a reflection on the identity of the bishop in the life of the Church and in light of the Second Vatican Council and collegiality. Unfortunately, such means of building toward authentic reform and renewal were caught up in the still-hazy concept of synodality that wormed its way into virtually every speech during the meeting and that continues to obscure more than illuminate as it comes into even more aggressive currency in this pontificate. Nevertheless, Cardinal Blase Cupich’s speech on the second day of the meeting presented a possible path for bishops’ conferences around the world, especially the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, which had been denied the right to debate and vote on a set of proposals for holding bishops accountable by the Holy See at their meeting last November. The proposal included 12 procedural points that might serve as the foundation by bishops’ conferences — in particular the USCCB — for crafting effective norms to prevent further crimes from abuser bishops or bishops who are guilty of negligence or cover-up. Such proposals, and indeed virtually every effort at serious reform, must now include what might be called the “McCarrick Test.” At the news conference on Feb. 22, longtime CNN Vatican reporter Delia Gallagher pointed out to Cardinal Cupich of Chicago and Cardinal Seán O’Malley of Boston that in 2002 the American cardinals were in Rome working to implement a zero-tolerance policy, and the main figure in that endeavor was then-Cardinal Theodore McCarrick. Why, she asked, should the American people trust them again? Mr. Theodore McCarrick, former archbishop of Washington, D.C., and once a powerful cardinal, was laicized only days before the start of the summit, after one of the most horrendous scandals in American Catholic history. He loomed large at the Vatican summit, and after any speech that proposed new procedures and norms, reporters and Catholic faithful could ask: Will this prevent a new McCarrick? The test assumes greater significance as Catholics await the release of all relevant documents pertaining to his case and answering who knew what about him and when. Until that happens, questions remain about both the commitment to promised transparency and the seriousness of rooting out current abusers and those who help shield them, most so among the ranks of the bishops. The Survivors Unanswered questions are nothing new to the very large number of survivors of abuse. To its credit, the summit strove to have their voices heard, their testimonies placed squarely before the bishops and the Pope himself. It was horrifying testimony. One statement came from a woman who was raped by a priest starting when she was just 11 years old; the abuse continued for five years. “Engraved in my eyes, ears, nose, body and soul are all the times he immobilized me, the child, with superhuman strength,” said the anonymous woman. “I desensitized myself: I held my breath; I came out of my body; I searched desperately for a window to look out of, waiting for it all to end.” The survivors could derive some comfort from the words of the women speakers throughout the meeting. Valentina Alazraki, a journalist and mother, spoke bluntly to the bishops. “You may be certain,” she said, “that for journalists, mothers, families and the entire society, the abuse of minors is one of the main causes of anguish. The abuse of minors, the devastation of their lives, of their families’ lives, worry us. We believe such abuse is one of the most reprehensible crimes.” After listening to the speakers and to Pope Francis, the survivors, however, seemed generally unsatisfied with the results. Going Forward By its end, the Vatican summit felt incomplete — perhaps because scant mention was made of the root cause of abuse, save for allusions to clericalism and abuse of power. There was no attention to other aspects, including predatory homosexuality in the seminaries, the demolition of the moral life by the sexual revolution and the practical abandonment of the Church’s teaching on chastity. While it was a start, many have to ask if the meeting achieved Pope Francis’ stated goal of concrete action. The hard road now lies ahead: of finding value where possible in its deliberations. The U.S. bishops must now start with the proposals and forge norms that will pass the McCarrick test, not to mention canonical, legal and theological threats and ramifications. Circle June on the calendar: That is when the bishops gather for their spring meeting. No institutional, procedural, canonical or administrative processes, however, will prove truly effective or lasting unless we have authentic renewal in faith and the sacraments, praying for good and holy shepherds, and exhorting them to speak and act with boldness. The road ahead is treacherous. As Nigerian Sister Veronica Openibo, of the Society of the Holy Child Jesus, told the bishops this week, “We must acknowledge that our mediocrity, hypocrisy and complacency have brought us to this disgraceful and scandalous place we find ourselves as a Church. We pause to pray: Lord, have mercy on us!” Edited to add: There are some very good comments posted on this article, very similar to those we express here on MOG.
So apparently you can say the Pope doesn't need to adhere to Scripture and Tradition, but you can't plagiarize. No plagiarism goes too far today's Church! Fr. Rosica has resigned some of his posts due to serial plagiarism. https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/b...il&utm_term=0_12387f0e3e-9f2b1a0621-402206493
There are some good comments in the following two articles also. Feb. 25, 2019 | http://www.ncregister.com/daily-new...-include-new-child-protection-law-for-vatican Abuse Summit Follow-Up to Include New Child-Protection Law for Vatican Pope Francis will soon issue a motu proprio ‘on the protection of minors and vulnerable persons.’ Hannah Brockhaus/CNA Feb. 25, 2019 | http://www.ncregister.com/daily-new...can-abuse-summit-intensify-the-dallas-charter Head of US Bishops After Vatican Abuse Summit: ‘Intensify the Dallas Charter’ ‘There is an urgency in the voice of the survivors to which we must always respond,’ he said. Catholic News Agency ... “There is an urgency in the voice of the survivors to which we must always respond,” he [Cardinal Daniel DiNardo, president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops] said, adding, “I am also aware that our next steps can be a solid foundation from which to serve also seminarians, religious women and all those who might live under the threat of sexual abuse or the abuse of power.” ... ************************************************************************************************************************************************************** As Pope Francis hosts summit on abuse, a N.J. priest speaks publicly about how McCarrick allegedly ruined his life By Michelle Boorstein | February 23, 2019 at 3:38 PM | https://www.washingtonpost.com/amph...75324&__twitter_impression=true&noredirect=on https://twitter.com/Bishopoftyler/status/1099851511629316097 https://www.spectator.co.uk/2019/02...ngerprints-of-the-popes-closest-advisors/amp/
Continuing Controversies and Unanswered Questions Robert Royal | https://www.thecatholicthing.org/2019/02/23/continuing-controversies-and-unanswered-questions/ Saturday, February 23, 2019 Synods and other Vatican gabfests used to be quite placid – even boring – affairs. St. John Paul II, before becoming pope, is reported to have worked on one of his books during some such event – and slept at another during his pontificate. One cannot help but yearn wistfully, at times, for the days of such dusty and distant events when every Vatican meeting now seems to bring up the deep tensions within the Church. Friday’s sessions did so yet again, though you had to find your way into all that by reading between the lines. The two morning speakers, Cardinal Oswald Gracias of India and Cardinal Blase Cupich of Chicago, are both close confidants of the pope’s. Both were appointed by Francis to the group of four organizers of the summit on the Protection of Minors. So it was no surprise that they both stuck closely to themes that have long been a central part of the Bergoglio papacy. Gracias spoke first under the general subject of collegiality among bishops. There was nothing wrong – technically – and a good deal right with what he said, which began with reflections involving spiritual renewal and translation of that spirit into new attitudes among clergy and laity alike. But like many Catholic prelates, including the Holy Father, he also leaned too heavily, in my judgment, on inequities of power – the clericalism gambit – which I believe betrays a wish to make the abuse crisis into more about social justice than personal sin. In fact, some here have asked whether power disparities in violence against children is going to be the next big push – after the environment and immigration – of Vatican social doctrine. As I grew frustrated myself listening to Cardinal Gracias, I tried to imagine how I would react if I were a victim, or a relative of a victim, hearing this parade of big words: accountability, responsibility, collegiality, synodality, clericalism, discernment, universality, particularity – even humility. I think I’d want to stand up and shout: “Fine, but please: save all that for some other day, on your own time. Since we’re here, too, and the whole world is watching, tell us, in simple words, if you please, what are you – you ‘collegial’ brothers – specifically now, going to DO. Where’s the ‘concreteness’ everyone was talking about yesterday?” There’s really little need at this point for anyone to argue that we need a new attitude towards clerical sex abuse – including the malfeasance or nonfeasance of bishops themselves. Church figures only show themselves to be terminally self-involved every time that, expressions of concern for victims notwithstanding, they speaks as if denial of the problem is rampant and they are the voice of awakening. We’ve had a number of stories lately about the Vatican’s own unwillingness to hold malefactors truly accountable out of what seems a false sense of mercy. And given the recent reports that Cardinal Gracias ignored cases of abuse in his own diocese just a few years ago, his calls for humility and openness about admitting mistakes were welcome. (Though you have to wonder whether victims and their families might have viewed them in a more jaundiced – not to say cynical – way.) Cardinal Cupich’s session – under the aegis of “synodality,” a concept hastily introduced last year at the end of the Synod on Youth – was peppered with similarly high-flying rhetoric about “orienting all proposed reforms in synodality,” “penetrating discernment,” “rejecting a clerical worldview” that caused abuse, a “reciprocal exchange of collegial knowledge,” and other Bergoglianisms. On the one hand, Cupich tried to frame proper responses to the abuse crisis in the emotional terms of the Pietà, the holy image of a loving mother holding her wounded child – a striking image of what the Church could be for the abused. On the other, there were lists of three of this, four of that, and a repeated caution that merely “changing structures” is not enough. * True enough, but even changing structures, for many of us, would be a good – a real – start. Let it be noted, in fairness, even if it does not lead to any effective action, that Cupich ended with no fewer than twelve suggestions about how to hold a bishop accountable. These included structural and procedural changes that he elsewhere played down. A quick, first impression is that he was repeating and spelling out the “metropolitan” model that he offered at the U.S. bishops’ meeting last November. That model had clearly been worked out in advance in collaboration with the Vatican and prepared to be delivered as an alternative, as soon as Cardinal Daniel DiNardo announced that Pope Francis had essentially frozen the model the American bishops intended to vote on. Nevertheless, a large part of this speech was crafted to address the problem of wayward bishops– the very subject that Cupich and others said would be a distraction from the main focus of the summit, which is the protection of minors. Indeed, he claimed (in the language of pop psychology) of giving them “a voice.” It will take time to parse out the specific implications of these dozen suggestions; we’ll need to hear from the canonists and lay experts with actual experience of trying to hold bishops accountable. And there remains the problem of what to do when the failures and corruption reach into high offices of the Vatican itself. But at a very superficial level, it at least affirms that individual bishops’ conferences – respecting both the universality of Church norms but also applying them in their specific cultures and circumstances – are being told they can hold their members accountable. No doubt that will be done well in some places, badly in others. But the present writer never believed that we could hope for anything much more than opening up such spaces for action. The bishops now seem to have approval from Rome to act as they see fit in their circumstances; it will be interesting to see – when push comes to shove – whether they will be allowed to really do it. Meanwhile, Catholic and secular journalists here have been doing yeoman’s work that deserves attention. At yesterday’s press briefing, they put Cardinals and others on the spot: One asked Boston Cardinal Sean O’Malley when we’d see the real meat – the actual rules by which bishops would be held accountable. He replied that he’d been “assured” by the pope that it will be “soon.” Another asked a basic question: how many bishops have been removed globally? Answer: no one currently knows. A third pointed out that she had been in the press room in 2002 when then-Cardinal Theodore McCarrick assured everyone that the Americans would practice zero tolerance and had the situation well in hand. After that hypocritical act, are we supposed to believe everything being said now? Still another added – in a question to Cardinal Cupich – that Cardinals McCarrick and Bernard Law were “metropolitans” back in the day. So what happens when the metropolitan in Cupich’s system is himself a problem? Cupich stated that there are notes on that in his longer text and several possible solutions. Finally, a woman, conceding that homosexuality per se does not necessarily lead to abuse, asked how can we continue to ignore the gay networks in various countries that have enabled or protected abusers? And how about McCarrick – did anyone in the hierarchy have a talk with him about his actions? And are there investigations happening into how he was able to do what he did? (Cupich and O’Malley said they’ve “been told” yes.) Good questions all. We now await good answers, and not only in words. *Image: Flanked by Fr. Federico Lombardi, former director of the Press Office of the Holy See, and Cardinal Blase Cupich of Chicago, Pope Francis prays during the opening of the second day of a Vatican’s conference on dealing with sex abuse by priests. [Giuseppe Lami/Pool Photo via AP]
Robert Royal is being rather generous. The whole summit was a sham and an embarrassment. They couldn't even answer basic questions from the journalists - in this regard Cupich was the most pathetic -- It was a paper glossy sham to buy time and look like they are doing something when in effect zilch has changed -- How many problems in the church can you blame on clericalism? How about blaming sin? What about putting on sackcloth and ashes begging the victims and God for forgiveness and mercy?
The summit's message is that the UN decides what is sin and that civil law determines whether the sin is mortal or venial. The entire focus of this papacy is to transfer papal authority to bishops. That's why "synodality" and "collegiality" are the buzz words. The Germans want Catholicism to be turned into a loose confederation of national churches, copying Protestantism. Pope Francis wants his successors to have no authority whatsoever outside of Rome. And most other Bishops are hedging their bets. Some of them have supernatural faith but it's clear that the "some" are very few. Scripture tells us that fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom. God gave us ten Commandments. The UN issued guidelines. That our hierarchy has reached a stage where they look to the UN for guidelines on morality tells us all we need to know about them.
garabandal, I suppose that Mr. Royal is trying to be constructive but he may have actually wanted to write a shorter piece with just your sentiments, "The whole summit was a sham and an embarrassment." I especially like that he highlighted all of those good questions from journalists which were asked at the summit's press conferences. Mr. Royal feels these questions should still be answered and also acted upon. Maybe you'll like the following article from Msgr. Charles Pope a little better. *** Feb. 25, 2019 Why the Summit Fell Flat, and What Might Happen Next The refusal to consider vulnerable adults and homosexuality in the discussion is a severe blow to credibility. Msgr. Charles Pope I respectfully offer here a brief reflection on the recent summit in Rome on sexual abuse by clergy (“The Protection of Minors in the Church”). To be clear, I was not in attendance nor was I able to follow the proceedings closely, even to the extent that they were publicly accessible. I welcome corrections and comments on my impressions. That said, count me among those who are disappointed in the content and conclusions of the summit. Earlier in February I wrote of my hopes for the gathering, describing what I thought was necessary for credibility to be restored to the Church. I highlighted three things I deemed essential: The summit must focus on more than the sexual abuse of minors by clergy — it must also address the sexual abuse of vulnerable or subordinate adults. The summit must speak to the link between homosexuality and sexual abuse by clergy. The summit must establish a way forward to establishing greater accountability for bishops. Of the three areas, only the last was addressed at all. Regarding the first point, the summit’s very title (“The Protection of Minors in the Church”) and agenda limited the focus to the sexual abuse of minors. Not only is the abuse of minors egregious, it is criminal, and must be met with the strongest penalties. However, as the Theodore McCarrick case illustrates, the problem is more widespread than the abuse of minors. His abuse of at least two underage boys was preceded by many complaints. Even more widespread were the rumors of his sexual harassment of seminarians and younger priests. As has been well documented, even though many prelates in this country and in Rome knew of his behavior, there was little correction. Further, the restrictions that were finally placed upon him were largely ignored. His status as an active player in crucial Church matters, including international diplomacy and the advancement of men in the episcopacy, was effectively restored. A tremendous opportunity to restore credibility to the Church was missed in failing to review and criticize the structures and decisions that allowed Theodore McCarrick to advance, failing to identify and call to account those responsible for it, and failing to discuss specific credible charges related to the overall sexual abuse crisis in any substantial way. Regarding the second point, the silence—even outright refusal to discuss—the clear connection between the sexual abuse crisis and active homosexuality in the priesthood is a severe blow to credibility. That Cardinal Blase Cupich, a key organizer of the summit, denies a causal relationship between homosexual clergy and the fact that more than 80 percent of the victims have been post-pubescent males is not credible to most Catholics. There is simply no logical basis for such a claim, except perhaps among LBGTQ ideologues. While this should not be used to rationalize the demonization of all people suffering from same-sex attraction, neither should we miss the opportunity to assess the data honestly and develop sane policies in response. In less politically-charged moments, Pope Francis has said as much. A summit purporting to address the sexual abuse of minors that ignores the high correlation between homosexual attraction and sexual abuse by clergy has no more credibility than a summit on lung cancer that ignores the link to smoking. Not only does this glaring omission strain the credibility of the conference, it makes its deliberations and conclusions seem largely irrelevant. It is only on the final point (a way forward to ensuring greater accountability among the bishops) that I see something substantial. Cardinal Cupich, in his address to the attendees, set forth a concrete procedure for the investigation of charges against bishops. The proposal involves a more local system that uses metropolitans (regional archbishops) to oversee the bishops within their purview. These metropolitans would collaborate with laity and other clergy to establish review boards; this is similar to the system already in use in the United States for investigating charges against priests. I am not a canon lawyer and leave that sort of commentary to others more qualified than I, but it seems to me that the proposal has several good points. First, it would restore more local accountability to bishops. Second, it would replace the current system — in which every bishop who is the ordinary of a diocese answers directly to the pope — which has proved unwieldy. Third, it would respect the divine constitution of the Church as hierarchal while also including the lay faithful for the sake of transparency. If this proposed procedure can be implemented and made accessible, it will improve the accountability of bishops and permit the faithful an opportunity to air their concerns. It remains to be seen how well the system will work and how faithfully it will be implemented, but it is the one substantial result to emerge from the summit. While not surprised at the outcome of the summit, I am disappointed. It hardly merited the intervention of the Pope and Rome that suppressed the votes and actions of the U.S. bishops on this topic at their meeting in November. The Catholic faithful are justified in being dismayed at the lackluster results coming from this much-trumpeted gathering. In the days and weeks to come, we will see whether there will be a fiery response from the faithful or, as some Church leaders seem to hope, the storm just blows over. I would ask any Church leader who is so hoping to ponder the sound of church doors and consider the likelihood that they will be opening more as people exit than as they enter. Lying low and waiting for the storm to pass ignores the damage it leaves behind — the victims, to be sure, but also a dispirited laity who no longer find credibility in many of their leaders. Simply advising God’s people not to leave Jesus just because of a few Judases does not remove the obligation of us who lead the Church to preach the truth boldly, refute error, and discipline those who dissent or stubbornly persist in sin. God will hold us accountable one day for the ministry He has given us. Collectively, we clergy have too often failed God’s people. We’ve put them in a very difficult position. It is a tribute to many of them that they have persevered for so long. They have learned to look beyond our human faults and still find Christ—but we shouldn’t make it so hard for them to do so. Help us, Lord. Save us. Have mercy on us, and keep us all by your grace!
This really gets to me. So nothing that came out of this summit justified suppressing the planned voting and actions of the US bishops last November. As someone here said, it was probably done to prevent all the sordid details about McCarrick from coming out into the open.
Here is Robert Royal's last article about the summit. In it he mentions the recent "Russian Winds" that fatally hit part of Rome*, it almost sounds foretelling. *https://www.stltoday.com/news/world...cle_89534469-3a71-5947-af87-040f52b68556.html After the Summit Robert Royal | https://www.thecatholicthing.org/2019/02/26/after-the-summit/ Tuesday, February 26, 2019 Friends: With this column, Dr. Royal completes his coverage of the Vatican summit on “The Protection of Minors in the Church.” As he writes below, the real challenges for bishops all over the world begin now: “Reform of the kind we need – however much anger and frustration we are going to feel in the meantime – is going to be a long-term project in which we are all going to have to assume new responsibilities.” To catch up on all his reports from Rome, click here. Or go to EVENTS above and choose VATICAN ABUSE SUMMIT from the drop-down menu. Great winds – the venti russi (“Russian Winds”) – blew through Rome the last day of the summit on the protection of minors. They knocked down branches and toppled trees, killing several people. Many Catholics around the world – to judge from my correspondents – were also hoping that some great winds or flaming fire from the Holy Spirit would sweep through the Vatican and, in Old Testament fashion, carry away the timeservers and corrupt prelates who have given us Theodore McCarrick and his ilk. But God sent no such extraordinary manifestations to the rescue. And though possibilities for reform now exist, they are modest and still fundamentally inadequate to facing some hard facts. Reform of the kind we need – however much anger and frustration we are going to feel in the meantime – is going to be a long-term project in which we are all going to have to assume new responsibilities. All the more reason not to be swept away by emotions, but to maintain targeted, reasoned pressure on Rome and everywhere else in the Church. We’ve been told that stronger procedures, investigations, documents – maybe even files on McCarrick – are forthcoming. But we know how easy it is for such things to give the impression of action without really doing anything. They need sharp scrutiny for years to come. Priests and laity have succeeded in reforming Rome in the past, and we can do it again if we work at it. But first, a candid reckoning of the last few days. The summit suffered from self-inflicted weaknesses from the outset. To identify the main culprit as “abuse of power,” i.e., clericalism, was to adopt a Marxist understanding of the world as primarily constituted by power relations. It’s also one of the logical results of ideological manipulation, however, carried out earlier by promoters of the sexual revolution. For decades, we were told that rape is not about sex but power (sex per se is always to be defended). But if a priest beats up a young person, that’s violence – and abuse of power. When he rapes a young person, it’s violence and abuse of power, but also lust, pride, and the whole set of mortal sins. There’s little evidence that we use these categories and think like Catholics, even in the Church, anymore. The pope gave closing remarks on Sunday. Every Catholic should read those carefully. (English version here) The first half describes child abuse of various kinds, not in the Church, but in global terms. What he said was, in its way, true: most abuse occurs in families, as well as in schools, sports organizations, etc. And, yes, there are children soldiers, children working in virtual slavery, children refugees, children exploited online and in sexual tourism – as he says – the list goes on and on. But this again shifts the focus: this time from the Church to a “global problem.” Pope Francis cited reports of the World Health Organization and other groups – a sociological perspective. But we already have WHO and many institutions that work on those problems. The Church has enough to do right now to police itself. Was there no one to tell Pope Francis that his approach, at this specific moment, gives the impression – not of sophistication and the Church’s awareness of the state of the world – but that he and those around him aren’t sufficiently focused on their own responsibilities? And that he’s hardly in a position to lead a global crusade when he hasn’t even cleaned up his own house? Or that the most fervent Catholics pay attention to what he says, are not dumb, and know a distraction when they see one? * He outlined eight points. Forget points 7 and 8 – sexual tourism and digital sex. Both bad to be sure, but not the Church’s main business. What of the other six? Here are excerpts from the first two: The protection of children. The primary goal of every measure must be to protect the little ones and prevent them from falling victim to any form of psychological and physical abuse. Consequently, a change of mentality is needed to combat a defensive and reactive approach to protecting the institution and to pursue, wholeheartedly and decisively, the good of the community by giving priority to the victims of abuse in every sense. [Emphasis added.] Impeccable seriousness. Here I would reaffirm that “the Church will spare no effort to do all that is necessary to bring to justice whosoever has committed such crimes. The Church will never seek to hush up or not take seriously any case.” [Emphasis in original.] Okay, change attitude and hold everyone accountable. But the pope himself has at least two or three well-documented cases pending (Bishop Zanchetta and the school for the deaf in Argentina, in addition to questions about McCarrick and other higher ups) in which he failed to take action when abuse was brought to his attention. Archbishop Viganò, in my judgment, went too far in places, but he called on the pope to give a good example by admitting his own mistakes. That would set a standard and show that he meant what he said in the passages above. Pope Francis admitted he “was part of the problem” in the Chile fiasco last year. If he were now to take this (from point 3) seriously, it might do some good: “Self-accusation is the beginning of wisdom and bound to the holy fear of God: learning how to accuse ourselves, as individuals, as institutions, as a society. For we must not fall into the trap of blaming others, which is a step towards the ‘alibi’ that separates us from reality.” The other points are the usual pledges of better formation in seminaries, further strengthening of guidelines in bishops’ conferences, and “accompaniment” of victims. Nothing wrong there – but nothing very earth shattering either. And one large subject gets no mention. Pope Francis has spoken out forcefully in the past about the problem of homosexuality in the clergy. He’s even gone so far as to suggest that if there’s the slightest suspicion that seminarians have unruly homosexual tendencies, bishops should not ordain them (which surprised the gay lobbies that earlier thought him a friend). So was it dealing with the full truth of the current problem within the Church not even to mention the element of homosexual predation – to sidestep the greater problem, if we’re going to be quoting statistics – and by focusing on “minors,” making it appear that the problem is abuse of young children and not basically homosexual grooming? And isn’t it undeniable at this point that there were and are “gay” networks of mutual cover-up, not least in Rome, even at the very highest levels? The Vatican could have done something to regain trust last week and restore a degree of confidence in the leaders of the Church around the world. As I’ve mentioned here before, I believe there are some reforms now in play and a slight opening for bishops in various nations who want to do the right thing. But the summit did not confront the more painful problems. And therefore has left numbers of Catholics in doubt whether Church leaders are willing to suffer the even more painful experiences needed to reach real solutions. *Image: Vincenzo Pinto/pool photo via AP
My husband is a quiet man who says very little and he said, “they did not do anything except sit around and watch videos” He’s pretty disgusted, as am I.
'Pay, pray and obey' must become '...pray and obey (The Lord)'. When bishoping stops being a lucrative career choice, the likes of these will hit the road.
How a “Hidden Stigmatic” Can Help Our Embattled Priests Posted by John Grondelski on Friday Feb 22nd, 2019 at 7:03 PM “Priests are turning away from me toward worldly illusions. ... I want the hearts of pure priests.” Sr. Wanda Boniszewska (1907-2003) was a Polish nun of the Congregation of the Sisters of the Angels, who offered herself for the sanctification of priests. Beginning in the 1930s, she bore the stigmata. From 1950-58, she was held in a Soviet prison camp in the Urals. She was then repatriated to Poland. She died March 2, 2003 in Konstanciń, a suburb of Warsaw. I learned of Sr. Wanda shortly after her death when I read Ukryta stygmatyczka (“The Hidden Stigmatic”), a book by the late Father Jan Pryszmont. With limited experience in the theology of spirituality and learning that Father Pryszmont lived perhaps 15 minutes away from me in Warsaw, I paid him a visit. I’m told Pryszmont was her confessor. I had heard of him as a professor at the Academy of Catholic Theology (now the Stefan Cardinal Wyszyński University) in Warsaw. Boniszewska and Pryszmont had apparently met in Vilnius. Lithuania’s forcible incorporation into the Soviet Union and Sr. Wanda’s being a Polish nun both contributed to her internment. But that’s another story. Pryszmont showed me her massive (600 page) spiritual diary, a typed manuscript of which he preserved, and shared with me some photographs of Sr. Wanda’s stigmata. I also noted that the preface to his book had been written by Henryk Cardinal Gułbinowicz, the Archbishop of Wrocław, who knew Sr. Wanda from his youth. While I understood that discussion of the case about her sanctity still remains only preliminary, the fact that a seminary/university professor and a cardinal archbishop took it seriously gave me cause to look at it that way, too. What has impressed me most about Sr. Wanda was her mystical experience of suffering, which she offered in reparation for priestly sins and to deepen priestly holiness. In some sense, helping priests was the charism of her order: the Congregation of the Angels had been founded in Vilnius in 1889 to assist priests in pastoral work in places where that work was impeded. Nineteenth-century Vilnius was part of the Russian Empire. But Sr. Wanda’s experiences were of a whole other dimension. At the direction of her then confessor, Fr. Czesław Barwicki, Sr. Wanda noted on April 22, 1941, how she had accepted Christ’s call that she suffer for priests: “The sufferings come to me for the infidelity of those who are called to their particular Divine services—for example, priests and members of male and female religious orders—and for their giving scandal to others. … My sufferings for priests and for religious orders dates from Holy Thursday 1934, but they were not constant. Only in 1935 did the Most Beloved One desire constant suffering for priests. The sufferings were painful, [but] more so spiritual. In successive stages, I experienced the whole of Christ’s Passion on my body. ... The Most Beloved One Himself put those persons who needed support before the eyes of my soul, giving [me] to understand the state of their souls and what was most displeasing to Him in them…” Sr. Wanda recorded what she understood as mystical revelations to her. Many of them were about priests and what Christ wanted of priests. Here are some, translated for the first time by me: “You give me nothing. You are my property. Live my life. You have no right to live the life of the world. A constant cross and the Eucharist—that is your life. … In Holy Mass, it is not you but I, you are ministers of grace, do not sully me with sins. Do not defile my tabernacle, [for] I dwell in you. I have a right to you. You do not see me, but you feel my presence. Everything you do flows from the Eucharistic cross. I chose a dwelling place not on the cross nor in the tabernacle nor in the host but in you.” “I want your love. I demand the summit of highest perfection from religious priests, and you are ice.” “I want your love. I want your total giving, a truly obedient self-giving as I gave myself on the cross. I want to pour out my desire on priests; I want them also to desire.” “Priests are turning away from me toward worldly illusions. They are tearing themselves out of my heart.” “Why do I remain in the tabernacle, for whom? At whose voice do I come? I am obedient. I want the hearts of pure priests.” “Everyone whom I loved, I enlightened. Now I demand of them sacrifice.” “Routine faith, you lack love for the Beloved; hearts divided toward false Lovers, a false attachment to worldly things, an ignoring of poverty, administering [goods] without the superior’s knowledge, you have no self-denial, a lack of humility, a wasting of graces. ... I am not the king of their hearts but a beggar. My love is not satiated.” “A priest is the salt of the earth. A priest is the sun of earthly souls. A priest is not his own property. He is mine. I alone only have a right to him.” A priest “must constantly drown in my love, in sacrifice unto destruction. He must constantly die to himself, as I die for souls, so as to open heaven for them. He must have a strong and unshakeable faith, resistant to storms, with his trust and strength in the cross. A priest should be according to my mind and desire.” “I want to remove those weeds from priestly hearts; otherwise, I cannot be the Gardener. I cannot sow virtues, I cannot … reap a harvest ... The priest is the property of God. He is to bring thousands behind him. Otherwise, St. Peter will not let him into heaven.” And, attributing this to the Blessed Mother: “I gave the Son of God to the world. I born all the insults the world gave him in my suffering soul. Today, each bishop and each priest is my son. From them I bear a double suffering.” Sr. Wanda has a very strong “clerical” perspective – she is acutely aware of the dignity of the priesthood that comes from being an alter Christus. The priest is “another Christ” and that for Sr. Wanda, far from being any excuse for self-exaltation, was the basis upon which a priest needed in humility to understand the dignity of his vocation. Noblesse oblige. Sr. Wanda was also acutely aware of God’s abiding love for His priests: “Do not think, O priestly soul, I would leave you. My love in the Eucharist is burning, constantly burning, especially for you. O priest, only on the cross will you persevere, you will persevere in me. … I am better than you think. I am a father above all fathers.” As we look upon the scandal, filth, and devastation that the clerical sexual abuse scandals has been wreaked on the Church in the United States, especially in 2002 and 2018-19, it’s time we realized that this assault on priestly dignity and its consequent compromise of ecclesiastical authority demands supernatural intervention. At the very least, priests should take to heart what Sr. Wanda recorded as Jesus’ messages about the state of the priesthood. If Vatican II taught us anything, it taught us about the call to holiness, a call about which we have been lax. I would also suggest that we might ask Sr. Wanda’s prayers for the purification of the Church in our country. She has a nexus to our land: her father had spent some time in the United States and, according to Fr. Pryszmont, was able with his American earnings to buy farmland in Europe. Let us ask her prayers that the American presbyterate emerge from the current crisis with a deep and unshakeable awareness that each and every one of its members is “not his own” (1 Corinthians 6:19-20) but Christ’s and Christ’s alone. http://m.ncregister.com/blog/grondelski/could-this-hidden-stigmatic-be-an-intercessor-for-our-crisis
My husband and I are torn right now. The Archdiocesan Appeal (appall) is underway. “Apostolic Administrator Wuerl” has a presence still. He’s still in residence in the diocese. I feel very torn between wanting to make our usual donation and just not giving anything. My husband does not want to give, so I think we’ll just pass it up right now. We know a great priest in the Order of the Trinitarians. They help the persecuted Catholics worldwide. We might just give to that order. Btw, McCarrick has been defrocked but it is my understanding that he is still residing Kansas. Isn’t he supposed to stop being funded by the Church?
Feb. 26, 2019 Cardinal Brandmüller: Silence on Homosexuality in Church Cries Out to Be Broken The German cardinal, who co-signed a letter urging bishops attending the Vatican summit on protection of minors in the Church to uphold moral doctrine, says he was ‘very disappointed’ by the meeting but continues to hope in divine providence. Edward Pentin | http://www.ncregister.com/blog/edwa...on-homosexuality-in-church-cries-out-to-be-br On the eve of the Vatican meeting on child protection in the Church, Cardinal Walter Brandmüller and Cardinal Raymond Burke sent an open letter to the bishops attending the meeting to end their silence on moral corruption in the Church and return to upholding the divine and natural law. The two cardinals, who also signed the 2016 dubia seeking clarification from Pope Francis on his moral teaching, argued that the abuse crisis is only part of a wider and much deeper problem that owes itself to a society openly calling into question an absolute moral law, and Church leaders who have “gone away from the truth of the Gospel.” “A decisive act now is urgent and necessary,” the cardinals wrote, and called for an end to the “plague of the homosexual agenda” in the Church, organized networks of protection, and a “climate of complicity and a conspiracy of silence.” In a Feb. 25 interview with the Register, Cardinal Brandmüller, who is president emeritus of the Pontifical Committee for Historical Sciences, spoke of his disappointment with the meeting, especially that it ignored many of the concerns raised in their letter. Nevertheless, he said, “we live in hope and trust in divine Providence.” Your Eminence, what is your reaction to the meeting? Some complained that the root causes weren’t properly discussed, the concerns in your letter such as the crisis of faith and doctrinal laxity. We are very disappointed. Do you think the homosexual issue was deliberately avoided? Absolutely, and this is a silence which cries out to be broken, because therein lies the real problem. Do you think the summit addressed any of your concerns, a crisis of faith and doctrinal problems? We’ve said all that needs to be said. It all depends on what will be done now, but the silence about homosexuality is a real problem. We have written our letter as observers from the outside; neither Cardinal Burke nor myself are involved. Why do you think the crisis of faith, upholding moral doctrine, reforming the appointment of bishops and mechanisms that allowed McCarrick to happen were not discussed? Discussing the problem of homosexuality would have become dangerous for them, because it’s evident there is a network of homosexuals within the Vatican. That’s the problem, there’s no question. Cardinal Blase Cupich of Chicago, a member of the preparatory committee for the meeting, said such networks of protection were only a hypothesis that needed to be proven. How can you prove them? Only through personal experience. How can this issue be overcome, this battle be won? They are part of the machine, so how can you exclude them? It’s a terrible problem. How much of the problem is due to a collapse in moral doctrine in the Church do you think? The lack of moral doctrine: That’s the root, and it’s an old problem. In the late 1960s early 1970s, the teaching of morals at the [Pontifical] Gregorian University [in Rome] was heretical. Why then? I don’t know why, but that was the time of [dissenting] lecturers: [Jesuit Father Josef] Fuchs, [Father Bernard] Häring, and [Father Charles] Curran. They were offering their teaching, the boys listened to these lectures, and then began practicing [homosexuality]. The North American College at that time was a center of homosexuality. And yet this isn’t new, as St. Peter Damian’s witness reminds us? They didn’t realize the summit began on his feast day. How can this conspiracy of silence be broken? That’s your work as journalists. But what can be done when exposing these scandals rarely results in concrete consequences or punitive measures, or any sanction or accountability? Continue. That’s the only possibility. I can only say continue. Be strong, decisive, and clear. What did you think of the silent protest just before the summit, calling for a break in the wall of silence among Church leaders on moral doctrine? Everyone is authorized to express his opinion, and this was a good protest. We live in hope and trust in divine Providence *** Edited to add: I hope that you don't mind that I have added a link to Edward Pentin's latest article about the Vatican summit. Feb. 27, 2019 Vatican Summit Promises Course Change on Sexual Abuse, Concrete Actions Pending The 114 episcopal conference presidents taking part in the Feb. 21-24 gathering mostly welcomed the meeting’s outcome and the rare opportunity to discuss face-to-face these issues from a global perspective. Edward Pentin | http://www.ncregister.com/daily-new...-change-on-sexual-abuse-concrete-actions-pend