The Vatican Has Fallen

Discussion in 'Church Critique' started by padraig, Dec 31, 2016.

  1. Julia

    Julia Immaculate Heart of Mary, pray for us.

    Don_D, I take it you are in the USA. I believe there are slave labourers in the UK as well. But they fly under the radar, and people do not know who they are.

    Slavery has not gone away, so I often wonder why ex Africans decendants make such a fuss about the slave trade. local white people were sold into slavery too in the past. God help people caught in this cruel existence. Sorry! off topic.
     
  2. Don_D

    Don_D ¡Viva Cristo Rey!

    Yes I believe this as well Julia, I am indeed in the US and President Trump I think in some way is bringing light to this very issue with all this hoopla in the media fueling rumors about hearsay of him referring to Haiti in a demeaning way. The truth of the matter and what a great many of us share in is this common problem which has no boundaries and is alive and well in all nations as well as keenly taken advantage of by those in positions of power and great self interest.

    Refugees and immigrants trade one set of problems for another in many cases. The Jews and their slavery come to mind. Although I am sure that in many of those instances it is a worthy trade off from the strife of war and the hopelessness of nations such as Mexico. Truth be told however, I don't think anyone wishes to leave their homelands and families behind.
    I think that this is a related topic BTW, since we hear about it from the Vatican and seemingly as well in a great many Parishes.
     
  3. davidtlig

    davidtlig Guest

    Thank you for this clear statement of belief. My reference to Newman was purely to illustrate that development of doctrine could not be dismissed as other posters seemed to be attempting.

    Whether Cardinal Newman would be a supporter of Pope Francis is, of course, something we cannot know although we will each have our own firm opinions!

    ​
     
  4. Fatima

    Fatima Powers

    WRONG! Newman knew that doctrine cannot change and that is what Pope Francis is proposing. The constant magisterial teachings of the faith assures us of this. He as his followers can spin there take on Sodomy, Adultery, Fornication, Co-habitation, lewd pornographic paintings and statues and every other sexual sin that they believe is "development", but those who know the teachings from God, through Christ Jesus and through his constant teachings of the magesterium must stick with what has been handed down unchanged, lest judgement be upon them.

    If what he is proposing is not change, he would have held a synod or a council to discuss the principles he is trying to apply as development. No, he reaches out to his like minded friends in the hierarchy to do his bidding for him and apply his ambiguity of his doctrine to be spread throughout the sinful world who applauds him for doing so.
     
    Last edited: Jan 15, 2018
  5. Fatima

    Fatima Powers

    Well, I can tell you in my church most of the 'givers' and long time members in our church have left. The Hispanic part of the church has grown tremendously, but not allot of money flows through them and the church is hurting financially
     
  6. SgCatholic

    SgCatholic Guest

    Found this really good article on a website that member sunburst posted a link to on another thread. (Emphasis in bold is mine).

    http://padreperegrino.org/2018/01/12/unbroken/
    DOCTRINE: WHY WE CAN’T CRACK
    2018-01-12 FATHER DAVID NIX


    A young priest with whom I was once a seminarian is now on Facebook like me. About a year ago, he posted the account of how he asked an old priest if young priests would save the Church. The old priest said “No, Jesus will save His Church,” or something like that. Of course, this post had a ton of “likes.” For one, it seemed so humble for a young priest to admit that we young priests would not “save” the Church. Secondly, it tapped our modern Catholic desire to prove to Protestants that we only look to for Jesus for salvation.

    Both are true, and I have no problem with either motivating factor for a lot of “likes” for that. But it diverts readers from the fact that God always sends real saints in the flesh like St. Catherine of Siena to fix real crises in the Church. When we all sit back and say “Don’t worry, Jesus is going to take care of it” (as everyone always tells me), well, that sounds very trusting and even saintly, but it is not Catholic. It misses the teaching of the Mystical Body of Christ, namely, that from the very beginnings of Christianity, Christ came first in the head (the Incarnation as Jesus Christ) and then in the body (His saints and martyrs.) See here what the Holy Spirit teaches about His own Catholic Church as the Mystical Body of Christ:

    “And [Christ] is the head of the body, the Church. He is the beginning, the firstborn from the dead, that in everything He might be preeminent. For in Him all the fullness of God was pleased to dwell, and through him to reconcile to himself all things, whether on earth or in heaven, making peace by the blood of his cross…Now I rejoice in my sufferings for your sake, and in my flesh I am filling up what is lacking in Christ’s afflictions for the sake of his body, that is, the Church, of which I became a minister according to the stewardship from God that was given to me for you, to make the word of God fully known, the mystery hidden for ages and generations but now revealed to his saints.”—Col 1:18-20, 23.

    Notice two things from that quote:

    1) The Apostle Paul was so confident that he was a living and real extension of Christ in the world that Paul could go so far as to say under inspiration of the Holy Ghost: “Now I rejoice in my sufferings for your sake, and in my flesh I am filling up what is lacking in Christ’s afflictions for the sake of His body, that is, the Church.”—Col 1:23. So what is lacking in Christ’s sufferings? Nothing except my participation. Christ’s sacrifice on the cross was 100% propitiatory, of course. Evangelical Protestants and Catholics agree on this. But what most people miss in this quote is my participation in Christ’s redemptive act lived in the world in 2018 can actually be missing. And when we don’t participate in the sufferings of Christ, the Church enters a crisis. Now we have the greatest crisis of faith ever seen in the Catholic Church, but if we take the Bible literally, it is because we in the Mystical Body want Christ without the Cross. It’s right there in Col 1:23.

    2) Jesus is the head of the Mystical Body of Christ, but “Christ” includes the whole body of every baptized member, down to the smallest. Every time the littlest one suffers, it is still Christ suffering, as when we saw Jesus say to Saul while the latter was persecuting the Church: “And falling to the ground, he heard a voice saying to him, ‘Saul, Saul, why are you persecuting me?’ And he said, ‘Who are you, Lord?’ And he said, ‘I am Jesus.’”—Acts 9:4-5a. In fact, St. Augustine went so far as to say: “If by Christ you mean both head and body, the sufferings of Christ are only in Christ.” Re-read that quote from St. Augustine a few times and let it sink in to get the Catholic idea of how we are all cells in the Mystical Body of Christ and that Jesus is the head and Mary is the neck (the mediatrix of all graces.) An understanding of the redemptive suffering of the Mystical Body of Christ was inadvertently captured in X-Men: Days of Future Past. Professor X says: “It’s not their pain you’re afraid of. It’s yours, Charles. And as frightening as it can be, that pain will make you stronger. If you allow yourself to feel it, embrace it, it will make you more powerful than you ever imagined. It’s the greatest gift we have: to bear their pain without breaking. And it comes from the most human part of us: hope. Charles, we need you to hope again.”


    Think how a modern Protestant or a modern Catholic would think it extremely arrogant if a modern pastor were to now claim that only Christ lived in that pastor: “I have been crucified with Christ. It is no longer I who live, but Christ who lives in me. And the life I now live in the flesh I live by faith in the Son of God, who loved me and gave Himself for me.”—Gal 2:20. But this is how the saving act of Christ continues on in the Church, by acting as loving and as bold as Christ in all our vocations. It is not to keep kowtowing backwards in doctrine for the sake of being “pastoral” that the Church will continue in the West.

    We need a lesson from the East, from the Coptic Catholics and Chaldean Catholics and other Christians who balk at the threats of Muslims to abandon Christ, taking the knife the throat before capitulating to false-ecumenism.

    [​IMG]

    St. Augustine taught something very profound on the mysteries of Christ’s Ascension and Pentecost. He wrote this: “And He [Christ] departed from our sight that we might return to our heart and find Him there. For He departed, and behold, He is here.”–St. Augustine. What St. Augustine means is that Christ went up at the Ascension, but He is now found on earth in His people after baptism and Pentecost. Thus, Christ saving the Church will happen through saints on earth, not a Protestant idea of a non-incarnate mystical body of Jesus just magically making things better at an emotional level. That idea is not Catholic. It’s not even Scriptural.

    This is why St. Teresa of Avila wrote: “Christ has no hands but yours.” This includes the hands of bloggers. So, in a doctrinal crisis in the Church, it matters that no one ever capitulate on doctrine, no matter how high the price. The first Great Commandment (love God) comes before and flows into the second Great Commandment (love others.) That means that we must love God before neighbor. We must say the right thing, of course in charity, but always regardless of what we guess to be the unintended negative consequences at the pastoral level.

    Without this rather-reckless philosophy, Jesus never would have made the Pharisees angry enough to crucify him. When Peter put Jesus’ own awesome ministry of teaching and miracles above of the cross, Peter was called a “Satan.” So also, we who work for the Catholic Church (cleric and lay alike) must do the right thing, regardless of consequences even at the ecclesial level. We can all be masters of our own deceit on what it means to be people-pleasing under the pretext of “pastoral.” We can all trick ourselves to say that cracking on doctrine for the sake of being pastoral will save souls.

    It never will!

    Even an elementary look at Church History would suggest that God is inspiring would-be saints to end this current crisis in the Church, but they/we are not responding to grace. Of course, I can not prove this, which is why it is only a footnote. The other option is that we are under such a heavy punishment from God for abortion and contraception and sacriligious communions that we are left “with no prophet” to guide us. This would be a sign of the Great Apostasy already upon us, so the first option is obviously a bit more cheerful, namely, that priests and bishops are not responding to the graces of boldness to end this crisis of modernism.


    The end doesn’t justify the means, and this includes sins of omission. If I fail to speak up for the truth in charity in a crisis in the Church for the sake of keeping the peace or keeping people in my pews or pleasing other clerics…I am sinning. I am literally sinning and harming the two primary missions of the Church: 1) The glory of God. 2) The salvation of souls.

    Christ’s attitude to the Pharisees is all we need to assure us of this. Was it worth Christ angering the Pharisees that led to their jealousy that ended His ministry? Yes. We would never have the salvation of the cross if Christ had calculated in His sacred humanity the perfect way of pleasing everyone. Of course, the Son of God would never do this, but just realize you are called to be as bold if we take Catholic Ecclesiology to the extent of how St. Paul and St. Augustine saw the Mystical Body of Christ on earth.

    Or really any saint: Christ has no hands but yours. This means writing the truth when it is not popular. You are making a difference. Priests, this means preaching the truth, even if it means losing your jobs. You can never commit a sin of omission for the sake of a future good, for the end doesn’t justify the means. Why can I write this so confidently?

    Because I very much believe deep in my heart: God is always faithful.

    [​IMG]
     
  7. Mario

    Mario Powers

    :cry::cry::cry:
     
    Carol55 likes this.
  8. davidtlig

    davidtlig Guest

    Precisely what the 'WRONG!' is referring to in Fatima's post is unclear but as I only referred to the development of doctrine in my post then I must assume he rejects the whole of the Blessed John Henry Newman's thoughts on the matter.

    And while doing so, he must also ditch Pope Benedict's fairly recent (2015) words on the topic of justification and faith:

    Can it be said that on this point, in recent decades, there has been a kind of “development of dogma” that the Catechism should definitely take into account?

    Benedict XVI: There is no doubt that on this point we are faced with a profound evolution of dogma. While the fathers and theologians of the Middle Ages could still be of the opinion that, essentially, the whole human race had become Catholic and that paganism existed now only on the margins, the discovery of the New World at the beginning of the modern era radically changed perspectives. In the second half of the last century it has been fully affirmed the understanding that God cannot let go to perdition all the unbaptized and that even a purely natural happiness for them does not represent a real answer to the question of human existence. If it is true that the great missionaries of the 16th century were still convinced that those who are not baptized are forever lost – and this explains their missionary commitment – in the Catholic Church after the Second Vatican Council that conviction was finally abandoned.

    http://www.catholicworldreport.com/...edict-xvis-recent-rare-and-lengthy-interview/​
     
    jerry likes this.
  9. HeavenlyHosts

    HeavenlyHosts Powers

    SgCatholic
    Responding to your post with the article:
    Very idealistic with no real practical suggestions
    We are back to Square One: what can we as lay
    people actually do that we are not doing already
    By following Our Lady’s directives?
     
    Carol55 likes this.
  10. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    You're welcome.
    As to what Cardinal Newman would think of what is being proposed I am fairly certain he would be absolutely horrified.
     
  11. Fatima

    Fatima Powers

    'Evolution of dogma' does not mean change. For instance, when the dogma of Mary's Immaculate Conception or her Assumption, it was never rejected by the Church and it was developed through what the Church had always proclaimed in its ordinary magisterial teaching. The adultery that Pope Francis and his minions are preaching has never been taught in its ordinary magisterial teachings for 2000 years and it goes 180 degrees from what popes (especially St,. Pope John Paul and Pope Benedict) taught recently within the development of doctrine . What Pope Francis is teaching is a new teaching and does not flow from anything but hell. If I am wrong, please show me any pope who has even indicated that giving Holy Eucharist to those in adultery and/or Sodomy is legit.
     
    SgCatholic, Dolours and HeavenlyHosts like this.
  12. Don_D

    Don_D ¡Viva Cristo Rey!

    This is an incredibly broad brush to be painting with.
     
  13. davidtlig

    davidtlig Guest

    That's quite a statement and worthy of being highlighted!

    But that's a statement I don't even understand!

    ​
     
  14. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    This:
    'Evolution of dogma' does not mean change.

    Should read:
    'Evolution of dogma' cannot mean contradiction.

    I am sure that is what Fatima meant and I am sure all three of us would agree that is true.
     
    padraig and Dolours like this.
  15. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

    If there are a lot of Hispanics giving a little money, there shouldn't be a shortage of money. That's how the Church survived and prospered here - poor people gave a little and gave more when they could afford more. I sometimes notice Americans refer to monetary support for the Church as "tithing". I reckon that term is never used here because back in the day a tithe was a Government tax imposed on all citizens, irrespective of religion, to support the Anglican Church.

    I know that in my previous posts I give the impression that I resent giving to the poor but that isn't what concerns me about the constant banging on about migrants and money. It's the almost complete abandonment of all other Church teaching that bothers me. It is also unfair to the people in the pews who are already contributing extra to compensate for the social justice warrior types who aren't at every Sunday Mass when the basket is being passed but are great at determining how, where and when the money should be spent. A lot of this guilt tripping of pensioners in the pews is engineered by very wealthy people sitting on boards of international organisations like the UN - people who would deny that Jesus ever existed but see the Catholic Church as a useful tool to promote their globalist agendas.
     
  16. Booklady

    Booklady Powers

    Dolours, I agree with what you said above. It seems like the Catholic Church has indeed become a tool for the U.N. to push an agenda that is diametrically opposed to Catholicism.
     
  17. Fatima

    Fatima Powers

    From the book Defending the Papacy by Father Morrissey with Imprimatur from Christendom Publications. A book I picked up in the early 1980's when dissent was becoming popular and routine with many theologians, especially among the Jesuits. In the book I quote below (Defending the Papacy), along with its two companion books, (The Crisis of Dissent) and (What Can The Faithful Do?), were instrumental in my formation in doctrine and church discipline 35 years ago. All doctrine comes from Christ and the Church Herself adds nothing new. Following is what the official Church has taught on the subject.

    The Development of Doctrine

    Vatican 1
    For the doctrine of the faith, which God revealed has not been handed down as a philosophic invention to the human mind to be perfected, but has been entrusted as a divine deposit to the Spouse of Christ, to be faithfully guarded and infallibly interpreted, Hence, also, that understanding of its sacred dogmas must be perpetually retained, which Holy Mother Church has once declared; and there must never be recession from that meaning under the specious name of deeper understanding. 'Therefore...let the understanding, the knowledge and wisdom on individuals as of all, of one man as of the whole Church, grow and progress strongly with the passage of the ages and the centuries; but let it be solely in its own genus, namely in the same dogma, with the same sense and the same understanding'.

    Vatican II
    The Tradition that comes from the apostles makes progress in the Church, with the help of the Holy Spirit. There is a growth in insight into the realities and words that are being passed on. This comes about in various ways. It comes through the contemplative and study of believers who ponder these things in their hearts (Lk, 2:19 and 51). It comes from the intimate sense of spiritual realities which they experience. And it comes from the preaching of those who have received, along with the right of succession in the episcopate, the sure charism of truth. Thus, as the centuries go by, the Church is always advancing towards the plenitude of divine truth, until eventually the words of God are fulfilled in her.....

    Sacred Tradition and Sacred Scripture make up a single sacred deposit of the Word of God, which, is entrusted to the Church. By adhering to it the entire hold people, united to its pastors, remains always faithful to the teaching of the apostles, to the brotherhood, to the breaking of bread and prayers (Acts 2:42 Greek). So, in maintaining, practicing and professing the faith that has been handed on there should be a remarkable harmony between the bishops and the faithful.

    But, the task of giving an authentic interpretation of the Word of God, whether in its written form or in the form of Tradition, has been entrusted to the living teaching office of the Church alone. Its authority in this matter is exercised in the name of Jesus Christ. Yet this Magisterium is not superior to the Word of God, but is its servant. It teachings only what has been handed on to it. At the divine command and with the help of the Holy Spirit, it listens to this devotedly, guards it with dedication and expounds it faithfully. All that it proposes for belief as being divinely revealed is drawn from this single deposit of faith.
    (Chapter 2, Dogmatic Constitution on Divine Revelation)

    In the quotation from Vatican 1, it should be noted that the last sentence is itself a quote. Vatican I is making its own statement that was originally made in the 5th century by St. Vincent of Lerins. In recent years, with full knowledge of the way some Catholics have falsely used "development" as an excuse for rejecting doctrine, the church has emphasized Saint Vincent's teaching o this matter by taking a extensive quotation from him and making it a part of the Divine Office-the official prayer of the Church that all priests are expected to pray. Therefore, since both Vatican I and the current Church have gone out of their way to highlight St. Vincent on this question, let us look at the full statement that appea4rs in the Divine Office.

    Saint Vincent of Lerins (Died in 445 )
    "Is there to be no development of religion in the Church of Christ? Certainly, there is to be development and on the largest scale. Who can be so grudging to men, so full of hate for God, as to try to prevent it? But it must truly be development of the faith, not alteration of the faith. Development means that each thing expands to be itself, while alteration means that a thing is changed form one thing into another.

    The understanding, knowledge and wisdom of one and all, of individuals as well as of the whole Church, out then to make great a vigorous progress with the passing of the ages and the centuries, but only along its own line of development, that is, with the same doctrine, the same meaning and the same import.

    The religion of souls should follow the law of development of bodies. Though bodies develop and unfold their component parts with the passing of the years, they always remain what they were. There is a great difference between the flower of childhood and the maturity of age, but the who become old are the very same people who were once young. Though the condition and appearance of one and the same individual may change, it is one and the same nature, one and the same person.

    The tiny members of unweaned children and the grown members of young men are still the same members. Men have the same number of limbs as children. Whatever develops at a later age was already present in the seminal form; there is nothing new in old age that was not already latent in childhood.

    There is no doubt, then, that the legitimate and correct rule of development, the established and wonderful order of growth, is this: in older people the fullness of years always bring to completion those members and forms that wisdom of the Creator fashioned beforehand in their earlier years.

    If, however, the human form were to turn into some shape that did not belong to its own nature, or even if something were added to the some of its members or subtracted from it, the whole body would necessarily perish or become grotesque or at least be enfeebled. In the same way, the doctrine of the Christian religion should properly follow these laws of development, that is, by becoming firmer over the years, more ample in the course of time, more exalted as it advances in age.

    In ancient times our ancestors sowed the good seed in the harvest field of the Church. It would be very wrong and unfitting if we, their descendants, were to reap, not the genuine wheat of truth but the intrusive growth of error.

    On the contrary, what is right and fitting is this: there should be no inconsistency between first and last, but we should reap true doctrine from the growth of true teaching, so that when, in the course of time, those first sowings yield an increase it may flourish and be tended in our day also".

    Applicability to Church Doctrine

    The following statement can be made about the Church
    1. Permanence: The Church does not add anything new.
    2. Development: However, under the guidance of the Holy Spirit, the Church develops (or makes explicit) what was always present in an undeveloped or implicit way.
    3. Human ability: God works through human beings, not against them. He wants us to employee the talents given to us. As applied to development, this means that the Church can be helped to grow in understanding by the ability and experience of her members. (This presumes of course, that such human ability is being used in the service of God's Word and not to create dissention within the Church or to substitute the gifted person's individual views for the teaching Jesus. If this latter is the case, then the Church suffers rather than benefits).
    4. Concentration: Not everything is developed at once. In God's plan, each age of the Church concentrates on certain aspects of the Divine Revelation, leaving to succeeding ages the development of other parts.
    5. Interconnection of Doctrine: Because the teachings of Jesus are related to each other, a development in understanding of one doctrine will also give the Church additional insight into a number of other doctrines. Thus, every step forward by the Church creates a situation in which further advances in understanding are possible.
    6. 6. Intuition: Like the solver of a puzzle, the Church can sometimes experience a sudden leap forward in understanding an unexpected advance that was not the result of any logical process.
    7. The Need for a Way to Settle Controversy and The Need to Arrive at the Truth (The Two Roles of Authority): With respect to development, the Church's "magisterium," the authority of the Pope and of the bishops united with the Pope, fulfills two important functions. First, it has a disciplinary role. Authority provides the order within the Church that is necessary for the process of development to take place. Without the proper order, confusion could never be dispelled and disputes could never be resolved. Second, authority has a doctrinal role. Acting under the guidance and protection of the Holy Spirit, Church authorities can guarantee the truth of a development in understanding. Without such a guarantee, there would be no way of knowing whether a development was true of false, whether the people of God were deepening their knowledge of the teachings of Jesus or leading themselves farther and father away.
     
    Last edited: Jan 15, 2018
  18. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

    So the days of blaming errant bishops and priests are over. The Pope who promotes contraception, sodomy, adultery, fornication and abortion is finally being recognised for what he is - a man who calls evil good and good evil.

    No doubt he put in a little phone call to whomever dishes out the St. Gregory medal to reward that evil Dutch politician who is crowing about her medal being the Pope's appreciation of her involvement in the slaughter of innocent babies and the celebration of sodomy. http://www.lepantoinstitute.org/pop...rchitect-safe-abortion-fund-pontifical-honor/

    The woman's Archibishop said he had nothing to do with it. The modern day version of Herod had met the Pope to discuss their climate change/population control agenda. I wish someone could explain to me how any believing Catholic can muster up any respect for such an evil man.

    Yes, and the award given to the Dutch abortion promoter and fundraiser is an example of how far up the chain of command the rot has infected Christ's Church. Ms Ploumen is a Catholic after the Pope's heart - she likes to make a mess, particularly at holy Mass https://incaelo.wordpress.com/2010/02/25/separation-of-church-and-state-but-only-when-it-suits-us/
     
  19. maryrose

    maryrose Powers

    [QUOlours, post: 197442, member: 4707"]So the days of blaming errant bishops and priests are over. The Pope who promotes contraception, sodomy, adultery, fornication and abortion is finally being recognised for what he is - a man who calls evil good and good evil.

    No doubt he put in a little phone call to whomever dishes out the St. Gregory medal to reward that evil Dutch politician who is crowing about her medal being the Pope's appreciation of her involvement in the slaughter of innocent babies and the celebration of sodomy. http://www.lepantoinstitute.org/pop...rchitect-safe-abortion-fund-pontifical-honor/

    The woman's Archibishop said he had nothing to do with it. The modern day version of Herod had met the Pope to discuss their climate change/population control agenda. I wish someone could explain to me how any believing Catholic can muster up any respect for such an evil man.


    Yes, and the award given to the Dutch abortion promoter and fundraiser is an example of how far up the chain of command the rot has infected Christ's Church. Ms Ploumen is a Catholic after the Pope's heart - she likes to make a mess, particularly at holy Mass https://incaelo.wordpress.com/2010/02/25/separation-of-church-and-state-but-only-when-it-suits-us/[/QUOTE]
    this whold
     

Share This Page