Those “conservatives lacking in Tradition” assessing Ratzinger on the Church’s doctrine Future Benedict XVI’s writings on the Council give some helpful insights on how to read the current ecclesial season: criticism towards Vatican II and the post-conciliar Popes shared by many of Francis’ accusers Pubblicato il 05/01/2018 ANDREA TORNIELLI VATICAN CITY Enrico Maria Radaelli’s book on Joseph Ratzinger’s theological thought, endorsed by the theologian Antonio Livi, in which it is argued that the future Benedict XVI and his work “Introduction to Christianity” have helped to spread and consolidate “modernist theology” with “its evident heretical drift”, contributes to lay out things clearly. It in fact confirms that many of the critics of the present pontificate do not only disapprove of the previous pontificates, but also challenge Vatican II Ecumenical Council. In the VII volume of Joseph Ratzinger’s Opera Omnia, published just over a year ago, which contains the writings of the future Pope from and on the Council, one can find some helpful insights on how to read not only the debate within Vatican II, but also the current ecclesial season. In the account that the young Bavarian theologian dedicates to the third period of the Council there are a few pages on the famous “Prior explanatory note”, the text added at the tail of the Apostolic Constitution Lumen Gentium, signed by Cardinal Pericles Felici, which explains the criteria with which the passages on episcopal collegiality, contested by a council minority as a possible downgrading of the authority of the Pontiff, should be read. Professor Ratzinger, who shows that he does not appreciate the “Prior Note”, writes that at the Council there were clearly two comparing options. On the one hand “a thought that starts from all the vastness of Christian Tradition, and on its grounds, tries to describe the constant breadth of ecclesial possibilities”. On the other “a purely systematic thought, which admits only the present juridical form of the Church as a criterion for her reflections, and therefore necessarily fears that any outside movement would mean “falling into emptiness”. The “conservatism” of this second option, according to Ratzinger, was rooted “in its extraneousness to history and therefore, in the end, in a “lack “ of Tradition, that is, of openness towards the whole of Christian history”. Future Benedict XVI’s description reverses, already at that time, the scheme according to which the Council was characterized by a conflict between “conservatives” worried about the possible “tears” from Tradition and “progressive” animated by modernist tendencies. For Ratzinger, the situation was the exact opposite: they were the so-called “progressive”, or at least “the predominant part of them” who worked for a “return to the breadth and richness of what was handed down”. Finding the sources of the long-awaited renewal right in the “intrinsic breadth proper to the Church”. Joseph Ratzinger wrote that “Tradition and Magisterium must always develop the seed contained in Scripture”. Because the Church, the Bride of Christ, is not a self-sustaining sacral entity, outside of time and space. She recognizes herself as a reality that walks through history, remaining dependent, step by step, on the working grace of Christ, “always in need of renewal”, placed “under the sign of weakness and sin”, and that for this, She “always needs the tenderness of God who forgives her”. What strikes in the words with which Ratzinger describes the two opposing positions in the Council, is the reference to a “purely systematic thought” which also seems to characterize many of today’s critics. A faith reduced to axioms, philosophical thought, rational demonstration that risks being disembodied and that becomes “purely systematic thought” used to assess no less than the Pope. http://www.lastampa.it/2018/01/05/v...s-doctrine-ICoeu1RMPxzdqQGCu8vOoO/pagina.html
I am not the one who said case closed, St. John Paul II did (and many, many, many other documents, saints, etc.). What you are quoting does not mean what you think it does. This is a document that is dealing with theological arguments against church teaching and practice of the church. As such, Cardinal Ratizinger posits that in cases where there isn't a competent tribunal authority that epikeia in the internal forum is not at the outset automatically excluded. As such it demands further study as how to deal with it and the conditions in asserting this exception would need to be clarified very precisely. AL is neither 1) very precise or 2) mainly concerned about cases in which there are no functioning tribunals. Please also note that just because something isn't automatically excluded, doesn't mean it will not be so after furthur study. Just look how many close calls there were with asteroids over the past few years that were at first at the outset not automatically excluded from being a direct hit. Church teaching has not, is not, and will not change. 2000 years of theologians studying and clarifying has not had that effect - so I wouldn't hold my breath counting on it now.
https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/b...ment-calling-popes-reading-of-amoris-laetitia BREAKING: Cardinal signs statement calling Pope’s reading of Amoris Laetitia ‘alien’ to Catholic faith Diane Montagna Cardinal Janis Pujats Aris Jansons / Flickr Follow Diane ROME, January 5, 2018 (LifeSiteNews) — Cardinal Janis Pujats, Archbishop Metropolitan of Riga, Latvia, has joined three bishops of Kazakhstan and two Italian archbishops in signing the “Profession of Immutable Truths about Sacramental Marriage,” LifeSite has confirmed. The addition of Cardinal Janis Pujats’ signature brings the number of signatories to six. Earlier this week, Bishop Athanasius Schneider, auxiliary of Astana, Kazakhstan, Archbishop Tomash Peta, Metropolitan of Astana, and Archbishop Jan Pawel Lenga of Karaganda, Kazakhstan issued a “public and unequivocal profession of the truth” regarding the Church’s teaching on the indissolubility of marriage as a “service of charity in truth” to the Church of today and to the Pope. READ MORE: Three bishops call Pope’s reading of Amoris Laetitia ‘alien’ to Catholic faith The statement of the Kazakh Ordinaries comes in response to Pope Francis’ and certain bishops’ interpretation of Amoris Laetitia to allow some “remarried” divorcees (without an annulment and not living in sexual continence) access to the Sacraments of Penance and Holy Communion. The bishops state that such a reading is causing “rampant confusion,” will spread “a plague of divorce” in the Church, and is “alien” to the Church’s entire faith and Tradition. The Latvian Cardinal’s adherence to the Profession comes after that of former U.S. nuncio Archbishop Carlo Maria Viganò, and Emeritus Archsbishop Luigi Negri of Ferrara-Comacchio in northern Italy. READ MORE: Archbishop explains why he signed profession affirming Church teaching on marriage Pujats attended the Theological Seminary in Riga, Latvia until it was closed by the Soviet Union in 1951. Two months later he was ordained in a secret ceremony by Archbishop Antonijs Springovičs. He was appointed Archbishop of Riga in 1991. On February 21, 1998 he was created a Cardinal by Pope John Paul II. His cardinalate was made public at the consistory on February 21, 2001. Cardinal Pujats was one of the cardinal electors who participated in the 2005 conclave that elected Pope Benedict XVI. He speaks Russian, Polish, Lithuanian, German and Latin in addition to his native Latvian.
http://magister.blogautore.espresso...al-of-the-jesuits-didnt-want-him-made-bishop/ The Bergoglio Mystery. Why the General of the Jesuits Didn't Want Him Made Bishop 05 gen A new book about Pope Francis is on the way, one that has already been making a stir, even before its scheduled release on February 26: > Lost Shepherd: How Pope Francis is Misleading His Flock The title sounds decidedly critical. But not from prejudice. The author of the book, Philip Lawler, is one of the most authoritative and balanced Catholic writers in the United States. He was editor of “Catholic World Report,” the news magazine of Ignatius Press, the publishing house founded by the Jesuit Joseph Fessio, a disciple of Joseph Ratzinger. And today he directs “Catholic World News.” He was born and raised in Boston. He is married and the father of seven children. In the initial phase of Francis’s pontificate, Lawler did not fail to appreciate its novelties. But now, as it turns out, he has come to see in him the “lost shepherd” of a flock sent out to wander. And he has developed this critical judgment on Jorge Mario Bergogio as pope in part through a careful reexamination of Bergoglio as a Jesuit and bishop in Argentina. Which is exactly what has been done by other biographers of the current pope, both for and against him: to reconstruct his Argentine journey, in order to obtain from this a better understanding of his activity as pope. * One striking example of this revisitation of Bergoglio’s Argentine phase is in the most recently published book about him: "The Dictator Pope," released as an e-book in Italian and in English at the end of last autumn by an anonymous author, likely a native English speaker, who conceals himself under the pseudonym of Marcantonio Colonna. One of the passages of “The Dictator Pope” that has raised the biggest uproar is the one in which the author lifts the veil on the judgment on Bergoglio written in 1991 by the superior general of the Society of Jesus, Peter Hans Kolvenbach (1928-2016) of the Netherlands, in the course of the secret consultations for and against the appointment of Bergoglio as auxiliary bishop of Buenos Aires. The pseudonymous Marcantonio Colonna writes: “The text of the report has never been made public, but the following account is given by a priest who had access to it before it disappeared from the Jesuit archive: Father Kolvenbach accused Bergoglio of a series of defects, ranging from habitual use of vulgar language to deviousness, disobedience concealed under a mask of humility, and lack of psychological balance; with a view to his suitability as a future bishop, the report pointed out that he had been a divisive figure as Provincial of his own order.” Too little and too vague. Beyond doubt, however, is the existence of a judgment on Bergoglio that the Vatican authorities requested from Kolvenbach in view of his appointment as bishop. Just as beyond doubt is the severe friction that existed between the ordinary Jesuit at the time and his superiors of the Society of Jesus, both in Argentina and in Rome. Abundant, solid, and concurrent information on this friction is provided by other biographies of Bergoglio, not suspect of preconceived hostilities, because they were written by authors very close to him or were even reviewed by him in the course of their composition. This latter is the case, in particular, with the volume “Aquel Francisco,” written by the Argentines Javier Cámara and Sebastián Pfaffen with the pope’s supervision, dedicated precisely to the years of Bergoglio’s greatest isolation within the society of Jesus. It does not cover up the fact that Jesuits who were opposed to him went so far as to circulate the rumor that Bergoglio had been sent into exile in Córdoba “because he was sick, crazy.” But it is completely silent on the judgment against his appointment as bishop written by Jesuit general Kolvenbach, whose name does not appear even once in the more than 300 pages of the book. Nor is there any news of the Kolvenbach report in what is so far the most exhaustive and “friendly” biography of Bergoglio, written by Austen Ivereigh of England: > The Great Reformer. Francis and the Making of a Radical Pope
Con’t But on the origin and context of that negative judgment of Kolvenbach, the information given by Ivereigh/Bergoglio is extensive and valuable. And it deserves to be reprised here. * Bergoglio himself referred to this friction with his Argentine confreres in the interview he granted to “La Civiltà Cattolica” and to other magazines of the Society of Jesus shortly after his election as pope: “My authoritarian and quick manner of making decisions led me to have serious problems and to be accused of being ultraconservative. But I have never been a right-winger.” In Argentina, in effect, the campaign against Bergoglio was led by the Jesuits of the Center for Research and Social Action, CIAS, made up “mostly,” Ivereigh notes, of “older, academic, upper-class” progressives irritated over the success of this Jesuit “from a lower-middle-class background, and not even a doctorate in theology,” who “privileged popular religiosity while neglecting the research centers”: a type of religiosity “very close to the people, to the poor,” but in their judgment “more Peronist than modern.” It was not enough to placate them that Bergoglio, in 1979, ended his term as provincial of the Argentine Jesuits. His leadership over a substantial portion of the Society was by no means diminished. On the contrary, Ivereigh writes, “he had more influence by the end of his time of rector than he had had as a provincial.” But precisely for this reason his opponents became more and more antagonistic. The criticisms of the CIAS and of others made their way to Rome, to the curia generalizia of the Society of Jesus, where the assistant for Latin America, José Fernández Castañeda, was also hostile to Bergoglio, and evidently they convinced the new superior general, Kolvenbach. Who in fact, in 1986, at the time of choosing the new head of the Argentine province, appointed none other than the candidate of the CIAS, Víctor Zorzín, who immediately took as his right-hand man “one of Bergoglio’s fiercest critics,” Ignacio García-Mata, who succeeded him. After this came a purge that Ivereigh compares with the “clash between the Peronists and anti-Peronists” of Argentina in the 1950’s, with the difference that now “the ‘gorilas’ [fanatical anti-Peronists] were in the CIAS, and the ‘pueblo’ was with Bergoglio and the others.” In short: “a cleansing, in which everything associated with the deposed regime was reversed.” And Bergoglio? In May of that same year of 1986, in agreement with the new provincial, Zorzín, he migrated to Germany, officially for a doctorate on Romano Guardini. But in December of the same year he was already on his way back home, to the rejoicing of his still numerous followers. Who in fact succeeded in electing none other than him as procurator of the Argentine province for a summit at the curia generalizia of Rome in September of 1987. The next year it was Kolvenbach who went to Argentina, for a meeting with the provincials of the continent. But he avoided meeting Bergoglio, in spite of the fact that he was staying very near by. Ivereigh writes: “Over the next two years, the province increasingly polarized and turned in on itself” and Bergoglio “was increasingly blamed for stirring this up.” He cites the minutes of the meetings of the provincial consultors: “In every one of them we spoke about him. It was a constant worry, what we were going to do with this man.” In 1990 they exiled Bergoglio to Córdoba, no longer with any position, and they sent his closest confreres abroad. But soon after came the miracle. The archbishop of Buenos Aires, Antonio Quarracino, asked Rome for none other than Bergoglio as his auxiliary bishop. And he got him. Ivereigh does not mention this. But it is here, in the secret consultations that precede the appointment of every new bishop, that Jesuit superior general Kolvenbach set down in writing his negative judgment on the appointment of Bergoglio. He was not heeded. But there is one episode immediately after the consecration of Bergoglio as bishop, in the summer of 1992, that shows how bitter the discord between the two remains. While waiting for his new residence to be prepared, Bergoglio was accommodated at the house of the Jesuit curia of Buenos Aires, where in the meantime his archenemy García-Mata had become provincial. Ivereigh writes: “But it wasn’t an easy relationship. Bergoglio blamed García-Mata for defaming him in a report the provincial had written to Rome - the report was secret, but one of the consultors had informed Bergoglio - while García-Mata felt threatened by Bergoglio’s popularity among the younger Jesuits.” The weeks went by and Bergoglio was for García-Mata an ever more “interfering” presence. Until on July 31, the feast of Saint Ignatius, the provincial hinted that he should leave. “But I’m very comfortable here,” Bergoglio answered. Ivereigh continues: “If he wanted him out, said Bergoglio, he should inform him formally. So García-Mata wrote to Father Kolvenbach, who backed the provincial, who left the general’s letter in Bergoglio’s room. García-Mata received a written response in return, in which Bergoglio gave the date of his departure.” Against this background one can understand why from them on, during his many trips to Rome, Bergoglio never set foot in the curia generalizia of the Jesuits, staying instead at the clerical residence on Via della Scrofa, nor did he ever speak with Kolvenbach. In order to be reconciled with the Society of Jesus, in short, the first Jesuit pope in history had to do nothing less than precisely that, be elected pope. But today we know about the preceding conflict almost exclusively from his point of view, mediated by his biographer friends. The point of view of the others, starting with the judgment of his general from a quarter of a century ago, is still to a large extent unknown to us.
I am afraid things are getting very,very scary out there; we must pray much for our poor Church. This doesn't look good.
This video is of course a year old, with the 'papal posse' already at work at that time endeavoring to undermine Pope Francis. I noted the earlier item from the onepeterfive website which has Cardinal Brandmüller informing us how and why the dubia needs to be answered. It is actually an illustration of the fact that the 'questions' were never a search for information at all but a criticism of AL. And that is the reason Pope Francis was never going to respond to it.
This is to imply that you read the hearts of men and can attribute bad intent to them. This is also what the Holy Father has done recently in suggesting that the Cardinals are led by the devil, that what they are doing is diabolical. I think generally speaking without supernatural graces that permit us to read the hearts and souls of men it is more reasonable and charitable to assume good intent to the Cardinals. As far as these Cardinals go I am very impressed with their Charity , Humility and Obedience. That goes for Raymond Arroyo and the Papal Posse. I just wish I could have a share in those virtues. I find myself grinding my teeth a lot at the moment.
Padraig, Thank you for posting this. Although it is a year old, I had never seen it before and ETWN's insight is still very helpful a year later. If anything it has shown me that I should not miss an episode of this informative news program. I just watched their latest edition from last night but it is not available to post yet to my knowledge, only the following trailer, Thank you again.
https://onepeterfive.com/three-bishops-join-voices-kazakhstan-statement/ Three More Bishops Join Their Voices to Kazakhstan Statement Steve Skojec January 5, 201810 Comments On December 30, the Feast of the Holy Family, three bishops from Kazakhstan — Tomash Peta, Metropolitan Archbishop of the archdiocese of Saint Mary in Astana, Jan Pawel Lenga, Archbishop-Bishop emeritus of Karaganda, and Athanasius Schneider, Auxiliary Bishop of the archdiocese of Saint Mary in Astana — issued a statement saying any change in sacramental discipline that would allow Catholic divorcees in new sexual unions to receive Holy Communion is “alien to the entire Tradition of the Catholic and Apostolic faith”. The statement was made public on January 2nd. In the intervening three days, three additional prelates have added their voices to the bishops of Kazakhstan. Archbishop Carlo Maria Viganò, who formerly served as apostolic Nuncio to the United States, along with Archbishop Luigi Negri, endorsed the Kazakhstani bishops’ statement on the day of its release. In a January 4 interview with La Nuova bussola (translated here by LifeSiteNews), Archbishop Negri explained why he signed the document: “There is confusion. It exists, and it’s serious. No reasonable person can deny this.” The Italian prelate took the matter further: Faced with the grave confusion in the Church regarding the issue of marriage, I believe it is necessary to put forward again the clarity of the traditional position. It seemed right to me to sign because the content of the [document’s] position is what I have widely presented over the past years — not only in recent months – at every step of the efforts I dedicated to the theme of the family, life, procreation, and the responsibility to educate and form young people. These are issues of absolute importance which the Catholic world as a whole does not seem to be very aware of. Today, news broke that Cardinal Janis Pujats, Archbishop Metropolitan of Riga, Latvia, has also placed his support behind the statement. The number of episcopal signatories of the statement now stands at six names, and it remains an open question whether more will join them in the coming days.
There’s a movement to undermine Catholic morality – Communion is just the start by Ed Condon http://www.catholicherald.co.uk/com...atholic-morality-communion-is-just-the-start/ posted Friday, 5 Jan 2018 Blessed Paul VI is pictured on copies of the Vatican's L'Osservatore Romano newspaper prior to his beatification Mass in 2014 (CNS) Modern-day Pharisees are trying to get round the Church's teaching on objective right and wrong. Their next target? Humanae Vitae I am going to risk a prediction: 2018 will be the year we see an end to the fighting over Amoris Laetitia. This might seem rather presumptuous, given that just this week five bishops have underscored the Church’s traditional teaching on the reception of Communion by the divorced and remarried. The bishops’ statement is a positive delight to read for its clarity of thought and expression – especially after some of the tortured sophistries we have had to endure of late. The document unflinchingly reminds us that some things are just wrong, and no amount of personal reflection or mitigating circumstances can change that. Seeming to address directly the various interpretations of that single contentious footnote in Amoris Laetitia (the one Pope Francis cannot remember), the five bishops quote St John Paul II: “The confusion created in the conscience of many faithful by the differences of opinions and teachings … about serious and delicate questions of Christian morals, ends up by diminishing the true sense of sin almost to the point of eliminating it.” This describes all too well the results, and I would say the intentions, of many of the opaque and tendentious “pastoral” guidelines which have followed Amoris Laetitia. The doctrinal errors in interpreting Amoris Laetitia are part of a serious movement afoot in the Church to undermine her clarity of thought and expression on the moral order, especially regarding marriage, sexuality and personal conscience. What drives this movement? Let’s be clear: it has nothing to do with helping divorced and remarried Catholics. Those of us who work in marriage tribunals, where canonists and priests have more contact with such couples on a daily basis than most working in bishops’ conferences have in a year, can tell you that the divorced and remarried are, in the vast majority of cases, desperately seeking clarity from the Church, not to be told to “do whatever they think is right.” Those so vocally opposing a “legalistic” approach, in which some things are objectively right or wrong, show themselves to be a peculiar kind of Pharisee. The law of the Church, including canon law, is made up of Divine Law, which no power on earth can change, and ecclesiastical law, which the Church promulgates on her own authority to better help the faithful understand their situation, live in accord with Divine Law and, ultimately, get to heaven. Contrast this with many of the “interpretations” of Amoris Laetitia which call for the divorced and remarried to be admitted to Communion, even if they are living as husband and wife. Some are arguing that canon law can be twisted to vindicate a person’s situation through their desire for it to be different, even if they have no intention to change it. Essentially, as long as someone wishes they were really married, or wishes they were able to live according to the truth that they are not, that is close enough. It is a nonsense solution which, even if it could technically be argued to satisfy ecclesiastical law (which it does not), would do nothing to change the Divine Law regarding the sinfulness of living with someone who isn’t your husband or wife as if they were. Those who think it could, do so from a dangerously flawed and warped legalistic mentality, one which thinks that the Church makes laws, and we get to heaven by following them. In fact, the Church uses law as a means of guiding us towards God’s truth, not reinventing it. Canon law is a tool, not a means of salvation. It is a light for our steps. Those using tortured philosophical and legal rationales to justify what the Church knows and says to be wrong are marking out a very different path, with a different destination. The push for a change, or “development,” in Church teaching regarding the divorced and remarried has much wider implications. The real goal is to spin the Church into an abdication of her objective and absolute moral authority, especially in the realm of human sexuality. The language of “personal conscience” is being used to dress up the grave evil of moral relativism. Those fighting for it are the remnant and inheritors of the liberal generation of the 60s and 70s. Which brings me to the reason I am predicting that the debates around Amoris Laetitia will come to an end in 2018. The reason is not that the Communion issue will be resolved, but that the faction will move on to their real agenda. This year will mark the 50th anniversary of the issuing of Humanae Vitae, Pope Paul VI’s affirmation of the dignity of human sexuality, and the intrinsic and unbreakable link between the unitive and procreative aspects of the sexual act. Last year the National Catholic Register’s Edward Pentin quoted a “well-respected Church figure” as telling him during the 2014 family synod: “Of course, you realise this is all about Humanae Vitae. That’s what I think they’re after. That is their goal.” Pentin says the current mood in Rome suggests his source knew what she was talking about. I have to agree with him: the efforts to “interpret” Amoris Laetitia and the Church’s teaching on the indissolubility of marriage will prove to have been a mere dress rehearsal for an all-out assault upon Pope Paul’s great encyclical. At the time of the cultural and sexual revolution, the Church spoke powerfully and prophetically against the inevitable consequences of what was happening. In the last half-century, Paul VI’s encyclical has proven ever more prescient and relevant. It is a bitterly comical irony that, just as wider society is beginning to wake up to the consequences of a sexual ethic based solely on consent and the pursuit of personal fulfilment, the Church is having to defend herself against those within who deny not just the Church’s teaching, but the last 50 years of history which have so convincingly vindicated it. __________________________________________________________________________ I'm not certain if the following had been posted already or if anyone would like to post it in it's entirety please do so, http://www.ncregister.com/blog/edwa...rofession-of-truth-about-sacramental-marriage The following is from this article, "Here below is the full text of the bishops' Profession of the Immutable Truths about Sacramental Marriage".
By the time I saw your post Jeanne, Frodo had pretty much answered in the vein I would have. I understand the confusion, but I am going to follow the clear and constant Teachings of the Church, the Council of Trent, Pope St. John Paul II and all of the other Saints, Popes and Doctors of the Church for the past 2000 years of Church history. As Frodo mentioned Amoris Laetitia and what has followed are anything but clear and so this does not fit into the possible theoretical loophole you were mentioning. In addition the fact remains that even if Amoris Laetitia were crystal clear and it taught that the divorced and remarried may receive Holy Communion, it would still be extremely problematic. In the case where a teaching document from a Pope contradicts a teaching document of equal Magisterial weight from an earlier Pope then the earlier one is always considered to be the correct one. In this case Amoris Laetitia and Familiaris Consortio are both Apostolic Exhortations. Amoris Laetitia is unclear and also appears to contradict Pope St. John Paul II's earlier clear teaching in Familiaris Consortio, so we must refer to the earlier document for the correct guidance. The Church does this as a safeguard in case confusing teachings emerge as has happened here.
I am posting a link below to an article written by Dr. Peters, a canon lawyer, responding to Stephen Walford's latest article. I do think Mr. Walford is very intelligent and shows some degree of "armchair" knowledge of canon law. This is however, as I stated earlier in this thread, quite different from actually being a trained professional. A little knowledge can be a dangerous thing and I think the article below makes that point abundantly clear. Apparently Mr. Walford has wandered into the deep end of the pool and he shouldn't have. https://canonlawblog.wordpress.com/...t-us-undercut-canon-915-and-what-it-protects/ Nooo, Canon 17 does not let us undercut Canon 915 and what it protects January 5, 2018 A professional knows the limits of his knowledge. An amateur does not know the limits of his knowledge. A dilettante does not know that there are any limits to his knowledge. Based on the biographical interview he granted to the Catholic Herald, it seems that Stephen Walford is a professional pianist and an amateur theologian (one’s dearth of formal education in a complex discipline being an obstacle, but not a complete bar, to one’s achieving some knowledge of at least some topics within that discipline), rather as I am a professional canonist and an amateur, I dunno, Latinist or woodwind player. Nothing wrong with being a professional, of course, or an amateur; but dilettantes are something else. If, having watched “Searching for Bobby Fisher” and knowing how the horsey moves, I started opining publicly on the Sicilian opening, what would I be? A dilettante. And chess, mind, is a little thing. Now, in regard to canon law, which Walford repeatedly invokes in the course of trashing as “dissenters” anyone who questions the text and certain applications of Amoris laetitia and its progeny, Walford is simply a dilettante unaware that most of his purported explanations of canon law have little or no connection to what the law really means—and sometimes, not even to what it says. And canon law, mind, not to mention the doctrine it works to protect, is a big thing. It is difficult to discuss law, of all things, with people who not know what it actually says. For an example of Walford’s misstating what the law (here, Canon 915) says, see his claim that “canon 915 refers to ‘obstinate’ and ‘persevering’ manifest grave sinners.” Of course, John Paul II’s Canon 915—aware that the Church cannot and does not judge souls or determine who is personally culpable for sin or if so by how much—does no such thing. Rather, this papal norm responds to objectively reckoned and publicly observable situations of sin and, in an unbroken line of practice going back to Scripture, directs ministers of holy Communion to withhold that most august Sacrament from persons who, by their public conduct, have placed themselves within the purview of the canon. Confusing “sinner” and “sin” is, I grant, quite common in this debateand even several ranking prelates seem to think that externally-made assessments of personal culpability (however that oxymoronic task is to be accomplished) are relevant to the operation of Canon 915. But what can I say that has not been said before? Treating “sinner” and “sin” as equivalents is something a professional would avoid, while an amateur, intrigued by the distinction once he saw it, would, hopefully, stop treating the terms as synonyms. It is not, however, Walford’s mistaking the plain text of Canon 915 that attracts my attention, but rather his attempt to explain what Canon 17—a norm little noticed in this debate, for good reason—means and allegedly how, by reading Pope Francis’ words in Amoris through in its light, “a path maybe opened to reception of Holy Communion” for divorced-and-remarried Catholics. As we are talking about canon law, I suggest we start with the canon. The whole canon. The article is continued at the link below: https://canonlawblog.wordpress.com/...t-us-undercut-canon-915-and-what-it-protects/ As many of these blog writer's put a lot of work into their writings I didn't want to post all of Dr. Peter's work here and would like to direct traffic to his website so if you are interested you can read the rest at the link.
Stephen Walford is out of his depth in this debate. He lacks the formal training in canon law and the intellectual rigour required to debate complex issues concerning church teaching. He is entitled to his opinion of course but would be better sticking to his area of expertise such as eschatological discourse.
Also for what it is worth, as much as I disagree with Mr. Walford and couldn't And yet it is so sad that he is the one that they are putting forth to front the debate against highly esteemed theologians like Spaemann, Seifert, etc. I guess you are forced to go with the best ya got.
http://whatisupwiththesynod.com/ind...aying-dissident-conservatives-attacking-pope/ And right on cue the toadies start braying… “Dissident conservatives attacking pope!…” Hilary WhiteJan 04, 2018 in He hates us! he really really hates us! Today we have a report from Tosatti, based on the anonymous blogger who claims inside sources (yes, this is actually how the “news” about the Vatican works) that Our Dear Leader has called a meeting of his media advisors to launch a campaign to discredit and smear the reputation of the three Kazakh bishops + 2 who dared to reiterate Catholic teaching in public and call for the pope to start doing his job. (Mercilessly forcing us all to learn how to spell “Kazakhstan.”) Church Militant has helpfully done a helpful thing on it in English, putting together some of the early responses to the call to arms. The report went on to summarize it as a “campaign of denigration” against the bishops, conducted through various media friendly to the Holy Father. The pope “has given carte blanche to his official and unofficial ‘press officers’ to start a ‘media campaign’ that denigrates opponents,” which will serve to “discredit” the bishops, causing them to “lose their credibility.” Here’s Marco’s original in Italian. And here’s the money quote from his source, “Anonimi delle Croce.” (No, I have no idea who he is.) My source in the Vatican told me that last night [Pope Francis] stayed in Santa Marta with several Vatican “press officers” and various “advisers” for a meeting on how to deal with this new and “unexpected” Correction from the Bishops of Astana. The source told me that [the pope] was furious. He went on a rampage — because he cannot stand any opposition. They heard him scream: “They will regret it! They will regret it bitterly!“ However we take these anonymous inside sources, certainly the picture of the paranoid pope, purple-faced and screaming for the heads of his enemies, is very much in keeping with what we already know about his character and governing methodology. And wasn’t our friend Massimo hot off the mark! Well done him. And coopting Benedict XVI into the discussion is clearly a mandated talking point. As we see here with Jesuit fellow traveller Thomas Reese I can tell you from my professional experience that in many cases the actual story is more or less irrelevant, and that the entire point of posting something is to get the headline out there. The purpose is to create a psychological connection, mostly subconscious, in the minds of ordinary readers “People who don’t like Amoris Laetitia = ‘dissidents’.” Ironically perhaps, it is these very people – who spent decades opposing John Paul II, Cardinal Ratzinger/Pope Benedict on these very questions – who made the concept of the theological “dissident” part of daily Catholic discussion. I think this one from Fr. Tom Reese SJ is especially entertaining since it was not really that long ago when the self-same Jesuit was called on the carpet and sacked from America magazine, the dissident Jesuit journal par excellence, because of his continual attacks on both Cardinal Ratzinger, as was, and perennial Catholic doctrine, especially on sexual morality… Sorry Tom, but the innernet never forgets. I’m becoming rather warmly disposed to Massimo, however, since he ‘s been so helpful. Alert readers will recall that Massimo Faggioli – FrancisRegime’s resident Jack Russel Terrier – is the one who recently admitted that the Catholicism of the post-Conciliar era is radically different from – and even opposed to – the Catholicism of the previous 1965 years. That it is, in short, an entirely new religion. It does help, I find, when one’s ideological opponents helpfully make one’s point for one. I should send him a Hershey’s Kiss or something for being so helpful. And it’s not like it’s something he only said once and then backed away from or avoided. No indeed; he brays it out to the Twittface world every chance he gets. But it’s Max Beans who has really taken the talking points and run with them.