It's not a joke this time. https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/p...pope-francis-faith-is-different-rome-has-been Pro-life Anglican theologian asks: Is the Pope Catholic? BIRMINGHAM, Alabama, November 17, 2017 (LifeSiteNews) — The time has come to question whether Pope Francis is a liberal Protestant, a noted Anglican theologian said in a recent essay. Orthodox Anglicans and other Protestants hoping to resist “the apostasies of liberal Christianity” have for decades counted on Rome and the Catholic Church for moral and theological support, said Gerald McDermott. “Most of us recognized that we were really fighting the sexual revolution, which had co-opted and corrupted the Episcopal Church and its parent across the pond,” he wrote. “First it was the sanctity of life and euthanasia. Then it was homosexual practice. Now it is gay marriage and transgender ideology.” Under Popes John Paul II and Benedict XVI, he said, non-Catholics arguing moral theology could look for “learned and compelling arguments coming out of Rome” and say, “The oldest and largest part of the Body of Christ agrees with us, and it does so with remarkable sophistication.” But not now. “Those of us who continue to fight for orthodoxy, in dogmatic as well as moral theology, miss those days when there was a clear beacon shining from across the Tiber,” stated McDermott. “For now, it seems, Rome itself has been infiltrated by the sexual revolution. The center is not holding.” The Anglican Chair of Divinity at Samford University’s Beeson Divinity School opened his First Things column with the rhetorical question, “Is the pope Catholic?” “For at least a century,” continued McDermott, “this was the way we Anglicans joked about anything that seemed too obvious to state. Now we must ask in seriousness whether the pope is a liberal Protestant.” As Beeson’s Anglican Professor of Divinity, McDermott teaches in the subjects of history and doctrine. He has written extensively on Theology, and taught for 26 years at Virginia’s Roanoke College in Salem, Virginia, before coming to Beeson at Birmingham, Alabama’s Samford University. He is also an Anglican priest. In his essay, McDermott cited the USCCB’s recent controversial dismissal of Father Thomas Weinandy as its theological adviser after Weinandy’s letter to Pope Francis expressing concerns over his pontificate was made public. McDermott proposed that Weinandy having offered thoughts critical of the pope was an ancillary concern in the basis for the U.S. Bishops’ swift and illuminating rebukeof Weinandy’s letter. “As an outsider, I can’t help but wonder whether the pope and the USCCB were particularly provoked by Weinandy’s suggestion that Jesus had allowed this controversy in order “to manifest just how weak is the faith of many within the Church, even among too many of her bishops,” he pondered. McDermott listed several “alarming statements and suggestions in Amoris Laetitia” that had been pointed out by Father Weinandy and other Catholics. He also detailed numerous specific, clear examples of how “Francis had caused many to question his fidelity to that tradition” even before the pope’s contentious exhortation in March 2016. “Catholics will have to make up their own minds,” he said, “but I’ll admit I have questions about the faith of Pope Francis, which seems, if not weak, at least different from that of the Catholic tradition.” “I take no pleasure in Rome’s travails,” McDermott said. In his conclusion, he rejected succumbing to despair in the current darkness and held up the theologian dismissed by USCCB, both as example of courage and virtue and a reminder that the Lord is always at work. “Though we are dismayed, we must not despair,” said McDermott. “For the brave and principled stand made by Tom Weinandy reminds us that God raises up prophetic lights when dark days come to his Church.”
The fact of the matter is right now, traditional/orthodox catholics are being persecuted in their own church by PF. Good luck on uniting Christianity with this pope, remember all the excitement?
The air is clearer since that ban was introduced, especially on foggy nights. Actually, I think the law only applies to coal because logs are still being sold. Correct me if I'm wrong, but doesn't the ban on selling ordinary coal only apply in the cities? I had a relative in a nursing home near the Curragh and I recall visiting him on a foggy evening not long after the ban was introduced. There was a remarkable difference between the air here and there. Here it was the usual damp fog whereas there it was dense and smoggy. I get the impression that this climate change debate is being manipulated by two opposing power hungry groups. It appears to be a struggle for dominance between the old mega rich oil money and the new mega rich tech giants and their celebrity mouthpieces. The rest of us are caught in the middle. Very likely neither side is telling the whole, unvarnished truth and neither side has humanity's interests at stake. Whichever side wins, the poor will still be poor, the 1% will still be in control and the people in the middle will foot the bill for whatever they decide is good for the great unwashed. I wish that the Pope hadn't chosen a side in this battle, hitching the Church's wagon to people who would deny the very existence of God and have fought the Church tooth and nail on just about every moral issue imaginable. He gave them the one thing they lacked - moral authority and he appears to be willing to destroy the Church in his quest to win their approval. Prudence demands that we care for our environment, are not wasteful, and do what we can to help people and nations in need. If we all did that, including the mega rich climate change alarmists, the world would be a better place for everyone. At this stage, I don't care whether the Pope is stepping outside his remit by making man-made climate change a Dogma of the Church - apparently the only Dogma he is willing to defend. He has spoken out of both sides of his mouth so often where Church teaching is concerned that I take everything he says with a grain of salt. Funny how the climate change alarmists don't use video conferencing to discuss their plans for the world. Shoulder rubbing, photo ops and back slapping must matter more to them than their carbon footprint.
Now that I somewhat have my equilibrium back I'll post this most "charitable" and "considered" offering of basically personal opinions by the sheep....oops, er, I meant "shepherds". Prayers! Trump-Bashing Cardinals Hailed as Peacemakers and Bridge-Builders BNN by THOMAS D. WILLIAMS, PH.D.18 Nov 20171,229 A new article in Catholic media praises the two cardinals most conspicuous for their vocal criticism of President Trump as champions of a “culture of encounter.” In his November 17 essay for Crux, “Tobin and Cupich: Battling the bullies; creating a culture of encounter,” Christopher White holds up Cardinals Joseph Tobin and Blase Cupich as two of the most effective Catholic leaders for overcoming divisions and bringing people together. “Tobin and Cupich both told Crux that first and foremost, they’re committed to Francis’s call to build a ‘culture of encounter’ as a defining part of their pastoral ministry,” White writes. Yet the culture of encounter they envision seems to exclude the 52 percent of Catholics who voted for Donald Trump, who is anathema to the two prelates who have been labeledas “shills” of the Democratic party. As Breitbart News reported last summer, Cardinal Joseph Tobin, the archbishop of Newark, slammed President Trump in an interview with a French Catholic newspaper, saying he appeals to the “dark side of Americans.” In his interview with La Croix, Cardinal Tobin said that the current climate of insecurity “has caused an exaggerated patriotism in the United States,” suggesting that Trump plays on Americans’ fears and desires to see America “great again.” “I think President Trump appeals to the dark side of Americans,” Tobin said. “He speaks to fears, to insecurities.” Tobin later called Trump “malicious” for his decision to hand the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) legislation over to the U.S. Congress. “The bishops must beware of him, because he tells them that he will be against abortion, that he won’t force them to pay for contraception, and in return, he asks for silence concerning his disrespectful remarks toward others or on the deportation of migrants. It’s dangerous,” Tobin said. “We, American Catholics, are a Church of migrants. We have always pleaded their cause,” he said. Cardinal Blase Cupich, the progressive Archbishop of Chicago, has been similarly critical of President Trump and blasted him for his executive order putting a moratorium on new migrants from terror-exporting countries, calling it a “dark moment in U.S. history.” In a lengthy statement released last January, Cardinal Cupich said the executive order “is contrary to both Catholic and American values” and called the president’s decision “rushed, chaotic, cruel and oblivious to the realities that will produce enduring security for the United States.” The cardinal called Trump’s prudential judgment on the refugee matter a repetition of “disastrous decisions of the past.” Cupich has a history of alienating conservatives by his close alignment with the Democratic party, and raised eyebrows when he suggested a divine mandate for comprehensive immigration reform, saying it is on God’s “agenda.” As bishop of Spokane, Washington, Cupich discouraged priests and seminarians from praying outside Planned Parenthood abortion clinics, urging them to avoid confrontation that could contribute to a “polarizing” environment over the issue of abortion. After the release of damning videos allegedly showing Planned Parenthood officials negotiating the sale of aborted baby parts, Cupich notoriously equated abortion with other social ills such as unemployment and the death penalty, suggesting that people should be just as appalled by a broken immigration system as they are by the gruesome ripping apart of unborn children and the sale of their organs. This unfortunate error led to a temperate, though public, rebuke from the redoubtable archbishop of Philadelphia, Charles J. Chaput. “The deliberate killing of innocent life is a uniquely wicked act,” Chaput wrote. “No amount of contextualizing or deflecting our attention to other issues can obscure that.” How these two cardinals are building a culture of encounter, especially with the half of the nation whose agenda differs from theirs, is not exactly clear. In last November’s election, Catholics favored Donald Trump by seven percentage points, the highest margin for a Republican candidate since the turn of the millennium. As a group, 52 percent of Catholics voted for Mr. Trump, while only 45 percent voted for Mrs. Clinton, according to the Pew Research Center. The victory for Trump among Catholics represented a significant five percent shift away from the Democratic Party in the four years since 2012. For now, the “inclusive” Church of Cardinals Tobin and Cupich seems to include everyone but conservatives. http://www.breitbart.com/big-govern...cardinals-hailed-peacemakers-bridge-builders/
Oh, BTW, is there a difference between this C. Tobin/C Cupich "culture of encounter" building and, say, um, "Antifa" for one example?
What I particularly enjoy is how they all get to these cutting edge conferences often on private jets how is that working for the environment? Not to mention the CO2 expelled by endless discussions dialogues and general hot air!!!!
Actually acid rain is caused by coal burning power plants. We used to live near one and you could see the sky turn yellow with sulphur going up high into the sky going east for hundreds of miles, to rain acid from the sky poisoning our freshwater lakes. With emission controls and clean coal our lakes are getting clean again. We do need to be responsible for taking care of our environment, recycling and cleaning up. We have recycling centers and use them . In one community where I used to live, the gigantic mountain landfill was turned into a huge ski hill, Riverview Highlands, (the locals call it Mt. Trashmore ). You don't see any litter near us and that is a good thing. Have you noticed the phrase global warming has been replaced by the term climate change . . .being aware of deforestation, building homes in swamps etc. is a good thing. To try and regulate our earth is a lofty goal although various countries are trying to control weather, look up HAARP. I think the Pope is right that we have to be good stewards of our earth. We can always do better . . .
I 100% agree with you that we need to be good stewards. I think the danger here is that ecology is being turned into a replacement for God. A kind of Gaia worship is spreading globally, even if on a subconscious level to many. Have you seen the Canadian Catholic Mass that was played out over the airwaves on Sundays that sang a hymn to Gaia? Ugh. St. Francis for example was a lover of nature and I am sure he would not have thought littering etc. was good in any way, but he never put the things of the world above God. That is the danger here. One human soul is of more value than all of creation. The environmental movement tries to upend that and make man appear to be a cancer on the environment that must be eliminated. In essence it puts the creation above the creator. It is a subtle, subversive evil, taking a seeming good and twisting it. Inverting things as evil always tries to do.
I attempted to read Laudato Si. I actually got to about halfway. It could have been condensed to a few pages. One thing impressed me within the verbosity and that was Pope Francis' integration of mankind in general and the endangered unborn child in particular into the 'environment' and their need for protection and good stewardship just like the rest. At least this was a calling out of those extremists who would classify Man as a toxic parasite deserving of eradication (oddly, these people never seem to display practical leadership). Perhaps, Pope Francis is attempting to seize 'ownership' of the environmental movement from this ideology. This would be laudable, to a degree, despite his crude demonisation of the sceptical. Only to a degree, because hitching the Church to a prudential worldview that may very well turn out to be errant carries other risks. ***************************************************************************************** Having slept over my brief debate with Dolours, who astutely questioned the possible underlying motives of a significant sector of the denial side-the wealthy fossil fuel industry with its own questions of cui bono, I awoke with the thought that, since our first parents, aspiration for knowledge has been rather hazardous. Since Galileo and Francis Bacon, mankind has pursued science positivistically and to the exclusion of God. This has led, in our own time, to at least two possible threats to the very existence of human, and even all, life on the planet. Nobody doubts the threat of nuclear annihilation (coincidentally, I'm smack in the middle of reading A Canticle For Leibowitz) and the threat of climatic catastrophe certainly has to be considered. I think that no matter what scientific or technological course we pursue that, if it excludes God and His accompanying moral guidance as a fundamental first principle, we are going to wander from one hazard to another. We need, like Walter Miller's book, to return to the spirit of Albert Magnus, not to mention his star pupil.
Therefore God gave them up in the desires of their hearts to impurity for the dishonoring of their bodies with one another. 25They exchanged the truth of God for a lie, and worshiped and served created things rather than the Creator, who is forever worthy of praise! Amen. 26For this reason God gave them over to dishonorable passions. Even their women exchanged natural relations for unnatural ones.… Romans 1:25
Well said DeGaulle. Well said. That is the essence of the question. And it really does all go back to the serpent in the garden. “”You can be like gods.....” wanting to be God instead of humbly worshiping God. Science cut loose from scriptural truth and morality is devilish. I read Canticle for Leibowitz. Years ago. Maybe it is time to read it again.
Very well put. It is so sad what has happened in science with it adopting a spirit of atheism. It didn't need to be that way. I have always thought of science as an amazing study of God's creation. In effect I thought of God as the greatest scientist. Creating an intricate and vast universe with galaxies seemingly beyond number and a whole system of physics and laws to govern it. It is interesting that in the series of revelations reported by Bruno Cornacchiola there is a warning against the seductive lures of science or something to that effect. I forget the exact wording. That stuck out to me and I have been pondering it.
Like any tool, science must be used responsibly. Science represents the physical, chemical and biological laws of God-they cannot be isolated from His moral laws. The awe that one feels with certain types of scientific discovery is apt, as one gets a tiny hint at how God works. Unfortunately, man tends to get carried away with his miniscule discoveries.
One of the most interesting things in the Bible is the creation story and certain phrases used in it like "Tohu wa-bohu". These seem to imply that the creation was not only a creation, but also a refurbishment or re-creation of a damaged or destroyed universe. I have always wondered if those phrases referred to the war of the rebel angels and if it in fact played out in the material universe destroying parts or all of it. I would love to know the answers to questions like this someday...
With the help of God, we all will. Has anyone here read Wolfgang Smith? For example, his book 'Ancient Wisdom and Modern Misconceptions'? He describes Genesis not as a myth, but as very plausibly real, arguing the relativity of time and the concept of the Earth emerging six thousand years ago from the event-horizon of a white hole. Ironically, given the dumb self-certainty of materialists, he presents a plausible case for the non-reality of the physical universe (take note, he is not denying corporeal reality itself). He makes a very convincing argument for a return to the Aristotelian/Thomist conception of the Universe, linking it with the world-view being advanced by the cutting edge of quantum physics. He is also very interesting regarding the non-viability of Darwinism beneath the harsh light of modern information theory. Smith is no dullard, graduating in Physics, Mathematics and Philosophy at the tender age of eighteen, an age when the likes of Dawkins was most likely filling out his university application form. One can speculate about that war of the angels. Smith poses a plausible creation of the Earth six thousand years ago (having been suspended in the event-horizon of a white hole, where time is stopped, for the duration), while the rest of the universe could be the thirteen billion years old she is estimated to be, allowing plenty of time for that cherubic catastrophe to wreak its damage. Of course, Einstein proved that spacetime is relative, so estimates could be completely wrong. To think some scientists imagine they can produce a 'theory of everything', but we really know little beyond what has been Revealed.