The Vatican Has Fallen

Discussion in 'Church Critique' started by padraig, Dec 31, 2016.

  1. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    IMO no apologies are necessary. You are articulating what many (most?) of us are thinking and either are too timid, deferential or tongue tied to express out loud.
     
    Tanker, sunburst, SgCatholic and 3 others like this.
  2. Carol55

    Carol55 Ave Maria

    Another article from Steven O'Reilly...

    https://romalocutaest.com/2017/11/1...ction-turn-slowly-but-grind-exceedingly-fine/

    The Wheels of the Formal Correction turn slowly, but grind exceedingly fine
    Posted on November 15, 2017 by Steven O'Reilly

    November 14, 2017 (Steven O’Reilly) – The latest chapter in the crisis over Amoris Laetitia is Edward Pentin’s recent interview of Cardinal Burke. The interview may be found in the online National Catholic Register (see “Cardinal Burke Addresses the ‘Dubia’ One Year After Their Publication” published November 14, 2017). Below the headline, briefly summarizing the interview, the article’s teaser reads (emphasis added):

    In wishing to honor two recently deceased cardinals, the American Cardinal makes a final plea to the Holy Father for clarity, saying the “grave” situation is “continually worsening” and that it is “urgent” the Pope “confirm his brothers in the faith.”​

    While I see no direct use of the words “final plea” by Cardinal Burke in the quoted material, he responded “yes” when asked if he were making a “final plea.” That there was no question, comment or mention in the interview regarding a “formal correction” confirms to me that the correction has been in the hands of the Pope for some period of time already, possibly weeks – and thus, the Pope has already been privately “corrected” or “warned” (see The Coming Storm).

    As reported by Vatican Radio, the Pope recently sent video-taped comments to a conference on Amoris Laetitia organized by the Office for Pastoral Care of the Family of the Italian Bishops’ Conference (see Pope sends video message to CEI conference on Amoris laetitia). The conference theme was: The Gospel of Love between Conscience and Norm. While there was no mention by the Pope of the Dubia, the “correction” or communion for the divorced and remarried in these comments, there was also no hint of the Pope correcting erroneous opinions either. Now, I do not know who were the speakers or what topics this conference specifically addressed with regard to Amoris Laetitia, but on the surface its theme (i.e., “The Gospel of Love between Conscience and Norm”) suggests a tension between the two (conscience vs. the “norm”), one where none can exist. The conscience must conform to the Truth.

    So, in the context of these papal comments and Cardinal Burke’s interview, I think that possibly there is a bit of a public back and forth going on, in fact if not intent. Something akin to a game of ping-pong. Back in October, Cardinal Burke visited a relic of St. Thomas More (see Cardinal Burke’s visit to relic of the head of St. Thomas More: a “Heads up” to Pope Francis?) to pray, but the visit might have also served as a symbolic and public signal to the Pope to ‘get on with it already’ and address the “formal correction” before it becomes a public warning. The Pope’s comments to the Italian bishops conference above seem to suggest the Pope’s mind is set on a ‘steady-as-you-go’ course, i.e., he has decided to ignore the correction. Cardinal Burke’s interview, in turn, seems a response, a “final plea” to Pope Francis, i.e., ‘don’t ignore us, we are serious – the formal correction will go public.’

    Of course, I could be wrong with this bit of speculation, and the timing is simply a coincidence. Though there was no mention of a “formal correction” in the interview, this seems to be by design. Cardinal Burke’s answer to the interview questions indicate he has not given up on the necessity of a formal correction, as long as the Pope leaves the matter without clarification (again from the interview, emphasis added):

    “It is evident that some of Amoris Laetitia’s indications regarding essential aspects of the faith and of the practice of the Christian life have received various interpretations that are divergent and at times incompatible with each other. This incontestable fact confirms that these indications are ambivalent, permitting a variety of readings, many of which are in contrast to Catholic doctrine. The questions we Cardinals have raised thus regard what exactly the Holy Father has taught and how his teaching harmonizes with the deposit of the faith, given that the magisterium “is not above the word of God, but serves it, teaching only what has been handed on, listening to it devoutly, guarding it scrupulously and explaining it faithfully in accord with a divine commission and with the help of the Holy Spirit, it draws from this one deposit of faith everything which it presents for belief as divinely revealed” (Vatican Council II, Dogmatic Constitution Dei Verbum, n. 10).”​

    What has the “Pope taught and how does it harmonize with the deposit of the faith”? That is, of course, the central question because as Cardinal Burke states, it is as an “incontestable fact” that Amoris Laetitia‘s “indications are ambivalent” and permit a “variety of readings,” i.e., a nice way of saying Amoris Laetitia is open to both orthodox and heretical interpretations. Thus, what we may be looking at – as many commentators have noted for some time – is something akin to the case of Pope Honorius (see Why the Case of Pope Honorius Matters, Mr. Alt), who was posthumously anathematized for favoring heresy. If the Pope were to clarify his view, this might prevent the crisis from growing worse – as it very much has the potential to do.

    Some may be impatient that the “formal correction” is moving ahead not by leaps and bounds but, painstakingly, inch by inch. As I’ve said before, as one who has been impatient at times as well on this question, I think it unfair to be so. By acting with necessary and methodical patience over the past year or so, the Dubia Cardinals will have demonstrated – by the time the “formal correction” goes public – that any accusation that they acted rashly is a lie. Rather, their patience will stand in favorable contrast to the Pope’s own silence. In the meantime, Catholics need to continue praying and supporting the remaining Dubia Cardinals. Have patience, and fear not: ‘the wheels of a Formal Correction turn slowly, but grind exceedingly fine.’

    Let us also pray that Pope Francis remembers the Lord’s words to Peter: “Simon, Simon, behold Satan hath desired to have you, that he may sift you like wheat. But I have prayed for thee, that thy faith fail not: and thou being once converted, confirm thy brethren” (Luke 22:31-32).
     
    sunburst, SgCatholic, gracia and 2 others like this.
  3. davidtlig

    davidtlig Guest

    At the risk of causing another gasket to blow, Dolours, your distress is apparent in your recent posts and so may I just suggest, in the gentlest possible way, that there is a solution to that distress.

    It is to consider a fundamental change in your thought processes. To stop for a moment, or longer, and reflect on whether you just might be misunderstanding things. That you just might be misunderstanding Pope Francis and the mass of clergy who support him. That you just might be misunderstanding even the faith that you obviously hold dear.

    If you were able to make that change in humility, the Lord would be able to lead you to peace.
     
    Jeanne likes this.
  4. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    No apologies necessary Dolours,
    I didn't take any offense.
    But thank you anyway. (y)

    It is a horribly confusing and upsetting time in the Church. Probably the worst in it's history. I'm just trying to keep everyone on an even keel here. It is easy in these situations to feel like going off the rails. Though I may not show it much thanks to being able to revise my posts before posting, I am as upset on the inside as you and many others are. I think and sometimes write some very uncharitable things, luckily with the aid of this format I can curb myself before posting. At least most of the time ;)
     
  5. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    I mean no disrespect David, but you are totally lost, at least it appears so from what you post. I feel very badly for you. I think there is much good in you and you have many gifts to offer, but you are being deceived.

    Being humble and accepting apostasy in the Church are not the same thing.

    I would put forth that it is you who must seriously take a look at what is going on and rethink your positions for the good of your eternal soul.

    I am sorry to be so blunt. I do not like to do that, but for the good of your soul I feel compelled to warn you. Apologies again, I do not mean to come across as rude.
     
    sunburst, SgCatholic, Light and 3 others like this.
  6. HeavenlyHosts

    HeavenlyHosts Powers

    Well said
     
  7. HeavenlyHosts

    HeavenlyHosts Powers

    I thought I saw a gasket go airborne across the big pond:D
     
    sunburst and sterph like this.
  8. HeavenlyHosts

    HeavenlyHosts Powers

    Good article from Steven O'Reilly
    Thank you Carol55
     
    Carol55 likes this.
  9. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    Thanks for a good laugh David. We need quality gallows humor at a time of mass apostasy!
     
    sunburst, maryrose and Malachi like this.
  10. Mario

    Mario Powers

    Words quoted from Cardinal Burke:

    “It is evident that some of Amoris Laetitia’s indications regarding essential aspects of the faith and of the practice of the Christian life have received various interpretations that are divergent and at times incompatible with each other.

    Example 1 Archbishop Chaput: “Ground Zero is this: For Christians, sexual intimacy outside a valid marriage can never be morally legitimate. And it’s the Church that determines what a valid marriage is.

    Example 2 Maltese bishops: ...in the Archdiocese of Malta and the Diocese of Gozo issued guidelines on Friday permitting access to the Eucharist for Catholics living in objective sin who “with an informed and enlightened conscience ... acknowledge and believe that he or she are at peace with God.”

    Whether you are David or Dolours, the two above interpretations are divergent and...incompatible with each other.

    As Catholics, when approaching to receive the Holy Eucharist, we should with heartfelt conviction submit to all that Jesus teaches, not just transubstantiation. Above, Examples 1 and 2 are at odds. This situation is reprehensible. The Holy Father is remiss in not clearly addressing those who do not conform to Church teaching. He should publicly rebuke one or the other.

    We can argue until we are blue in the face, but it is the Holy Pontiff's responsibility to maintain unity and not allow division. He is allowing this rift to continue to the detriment of the Church.:mad: If he concurs with the Maltese bishops then let him notify Chaput to desist.

    The Church cannot have it both ways. Waiting for opposition to fade away won't cut the mustard. If David and Dolours agree with such murkiness, then this whole discussion will never enjoy a finale.:rolleyes:

    I repeat, Pope Francis is allowing the fence-sitting and division. Because of this, I pray for his soul.:notworthy::cry:

    Safe in the Barque of Peter!
     
    Last edited: Nov 15, 2017
    Booklady, SgCatholic, gracia and 3 others like this.
  11. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    A good summation of the current state of affairs.

    This sad reality is that this situation will resolve itself in one way or the other whether the Pope does anything or not.

    It is like a nuclear reactor going into meltdown. Standing by and watching it is not an answer.
    As the old saying goes making no decision is still making a choice.
     
  12. Carol55

    Carol55 Ave Maria

    Mario and HeavenlyHosts like this.
  13. Mario

    Mario Powers

    Yes, Praetorian, you remind me of the words of Paul.

    2Cor 1: 17 Was I vacillating when I wanted to do this? Do I make my plans like a worldly man, ready to say Yes and No at once? 18 As surely as God is faithful, our word to you has not been Yes and No. 19 For the Son of God, Jesus Christ, whom we preached among you, Silva'nus and Timothy and I, was not Yes and No; but in him it is always Yes.
     
    Booklady, Julia, BrianK and 1 other person like this.
  14. Carol55

    Carol55 Ave Maria

    In this article, Steven O'Reilly points out what Mario has pointed out in his post above - that there are two interpretations of AL and both cannot be true.

    In addition, Steven Reilly points out something similar to what Praetorian pointed out in his post above when he states the following,

    Thus, having had one such pope, perhaps Mr. Alt will understand (in light of his own Amoris Laetitia article) that the potential relevance of Honorius to the current crisis is not whether Honorius was a monothelite heretic, but whether it is possible – and just as damaging – for a pope to favor heresy through negligence and silence – and to even “add fuel” to the “wicked assertions” of heretics.​

    So how do we tell Pope Francis that he may be following in the footsteps of Pope Honorius...

    Chris Ferrara stated something similar also,

    Did Saint Francis predict the coming of Pope Francis? That is not for us to judge, although the Church may well issue a judgment of Francis like that of the posthumous anathema of Honorius I. Would Saint Francis have been horrified by the words and deeds of the Pope who has presumed to take his name? That question answers itself. https://remnantnewspaper.com/web/in...m/3541-did-saint-francis-predict-pope-francis
    ​
    PS- I'm just catching up on the Pope Francis/Pope Honorius connection, sorry about that.
     
    Last edited: Nov 15, 2017
    Booklady and SgCatholic like this.
  15. Julia

    Julia Immaculate Heart of Mary, pray for us.

    @Carol55. I have made purple and underlined one line from your post that worried me. And I am certain someone like Cardinal Burke would already have connected the dots with the same conclusions. Indeed I suspect a lot of Cardinals and Bishops and Priests would already have done the same. But charity and humility must be upheld. If they get the courage to say anything at all. Sigh.

    Father Weinandy has offered himself as the lamb to be slain in this and we need to pray very much God sustain him through to the bitter end. But Cardinal Burke is the soul I am praying for to get the help of Holy Spirit, and see this through to a good conclusion. Cardinal Burke is the soul I believe has the God given authority to make whatever moves and or judgements required to bring an end to the AL confusion. We need to pray very much for Cardinal Burke.

    I love your posts Carol, and your amazing ability to research and share. Just worried about that one liner. Peace.
     
    Last edited: Nov 15, 2017
    Booklady, AED and Carol55 like this.
  16. AED

    AED Powers

    Michael Voris has an excellent Vortex on this subject. He blames media for this papalotry we are seeing. He cites some horrific popes in the past and although they did not promote heresies they were a terrible scandal. I agree SG deserves a better answer. I think she is brave to write letters and speak out. Perhaps God has given her the grace to do this. I wish I had a better answer. When all this started I was filled with horror and I wasn’t shy in saying so. In my case God brought me up short. The anger was not misplaced but publicly decrying the Pope was not right—for me. My confessor confirmed that. He told me God is permitting this. It is part of the purification. It will not be allowed to stand and that we must pray. I have tried to do so. It is not easy. I get so furious and so discouraged. At one point I told the Lord “I don’t know how to pray for this Pope. I don’t have the words. You know. I don’t .” So I just started commending him to the Immaculate Heart. I trust her to sort it out. But it is so very hard.
    I think we all need to vent about this without breaking charity. Vent we must or we explode but I guess we”musnt let the sun go down on our anger.” I for one totally get where SG is coming from and Brian and others. I just need for my own soul to take a different path.
     
  17. Carol55

    Carol55 Ave Maria

    Julia,

    Thank you, I love your posts also. I hope that I have maintained both charity and humility. That one liner is out of concern for the Pope and for the Church. If I was in the Pope's shoes, I would want to know the possible gravity of the situation that I was in. I honestly can't imagine being in his shoes and I know that I don't come at all close to his holiness that would enable me to be in his shoes (plus I'm a girl ;)).

    You are correct, we need to pray for Cardinal Burke, Father Weinandy and all of the clergy and we need to continue to pray for Pope Francis.

    We need to pray for the world. I think that the Church's current situation is due to many factors.

    Father Hunwicke briefly wrote about this possible connection also, http://liturgicalnotes.blogspot.com/2017/09/pope-honorius-i.html .
     
    sterph likes this.
  18. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    I must chime in with the others. Lots of good links and thoughts Carol. I am currently slogging my way through the Pope Honorious article.
     
    gracia and Carol55 like this.
  19. BrianK

    BrianK Guest


    UNCHARITABLE? DIVISIVE? STRIDENT?
    Recovering the Art of Christian Polemics

    http://www.newoxfordreview.org/article.jsp?did=1002-mills
    October 2002
    By David Mills

    David Mills is a Senior Editor of Touchstone: A Magazine of Mere Christianity.

    Most well-read Christians know the two most famous stories of the early Church's approach to dialogue. St. Polycarp tells us that the apostle John once went to the public bath in Ephesus and found inside a Gnostic teacher named Cerinthus. John ran out crying, "Let us fly, lest even the bath-house fall down, because Cerinthus, the enemy of the truth, is within."

    Polycarp himself once met the heretic Marcion walking down the street. Marcion hated the creator-God of the Hebrews, and to get rid of Him had tossed out the Old Testament and much of the New and rewrote the bits he kept. Marcion asked Polycarp, "Do you know me?" and Polycarp answered, "I do know you. You are the firstborn of Satan."

    Their Reason

    By and large, modern Christians do not speak like this, though we have teachers as hostile to the Faith as Cerinthus and Marcion. Many of them speak with the authority of chairs in theology and of "reverend" before their name, and publish books the vulnerable, the naïve, and the gullible read and believe. These teachers are just as dangerous to peoples' souls as the great heretics of the first centuries, but we do not speak of our heretics as the great saints spoke of theirs.

    This is almost as true of conservative or traditional Christians as of "centrists" and liberals. (The "centrist," I have always thought, is usually just a liberal in slow motion.) You will make a conservative group wince by calling someone a heretic, so well have we all been trained by the dominant dislike of such clear but dividing judgments. "Heretic" is a perfectly objective term, describing a particular relation to Christian doctrine, freely chosen, but almost every Christian will hear it as a vulgar term of abuse.

    St. John and St. Polycarp spoke the way they did because every word matters when you are talking about Jesus. One word is true, and another word, which may be a very similar word, is false. The right word leads to Jesus, the wrong word leads away from Him. Jesus is of one being with the Father, not of like being. He is the Son of the Father, not a son of the Father. He is begotten, not made.

    Therefore those who say the wrong words, and keep saying them after the authorities have corrected them, proclaim a Jesus who does not exist, and thereby endanger the souls of men who want to meet Him. The Jesuses they present almost always look a lot like the real Jesus, especially to those who do not know Him very well.

    And they are usually very good spokesmen for the Jesus they've invented. Men of this sort are almost always compelling teachers, who offer a Jesus designed to be what many of their hearers expect or want. The successful heretic knows how to design his product to sell in the religious market, and many people will like his Jesus a lot more than the real one.

    People who are so good at offering the world a fake Jesus must be rebuked and corrected by those, pastors and writers particularly, who have the gifts to do so. They will sometimes have to speak a hard word, in the mode of St. John or St. Polycarp. They will sometimes have to explain that Smith is wrong and that Jones is a false teacher and that Wilson is an enemy of the Faith.

    This is a way they minister to those placed within their care. The writer is his readers' shepherd for as long as they read his work, whether or not he wants to be. Both pastor and writer speak mainly to lead their sheep to water and grass, but they will also speak to guard them from the wolves, to make sure that the sheep live long enough to reach the water and the grass. They know that many of their sheep will not recognize a wolf on sight, and left on their own might invite the wolf home to dinner, only to find, too late, that they are the main course.

    Because the pastor or writer wants his sheep to get to the water and grass whole and unharmed, he must teach them about wolves, and point out as many wolves as he can. It is the job God has given him to do. It comes with the gifts God has given him.

    All Obvious

    This is all, to a traditional Christian mind, obvious. But as soon as you try it, you will find yourself criticized, even in conservative Christian circles. You will find yourself called unkind, arrogant, and uncharitable; or divisive, troublemaking, and an impediment to mission; or harsh and strident; or simple-minded. You will be accused of sins against the person (the first set of charges), sins against the community (the second), sins against manners (the third), and sins against reason (the fourth).

    You will hear this not only from the sentimental and the wooly-minded, who dislike polemics on principle, but from people who agree that Christians must write against error though they themselves shrink from the actual battle. This type will tell you that while Wilson is indeed an enemy of the Faith, you should have waited before writing against him (waited for what is almost never made clear), or treated his errors in a less combative way, or stressed the good work he is doing rather than the bad, or tried harder to find some common ground.

    You may be told that you attract more flies with honey than vinegar. I have been told this more than once, by men who thought they were being profound or wise, or something. They did not make the distinction, basic and essential to pastoral judgment, between someone who must be corrected and someone who must be rebuked.

    They assume that all such discourse must be aimed at the conversion of the heretic, and that the only way to convert him is to speak nicely to him. They have no good reason, in Scripture or in the example of the Fathers, for this idea.

    Your critic may well be right in this or that case, but I have noticed that despite his theoretical approval for polemics you never find him writing polemically, except against the easiest of targets. In the last two decades you could find many Episcopalians speaking against the former Bishop of Newark, John Spong, a man of such extreme views that they risked nothing in attacking him, and then walking about as if they had done something daring and important.

    While they wrote against Spong, they would not contest less obvious but for that reason much more dangerous errors, while privately admitting that those were just as bad as his. The more tactful skepticism of the mainstream liberals they left unrebuked, in effect telling their people that these ideas were all right. They were in the basement shooting fish in a barrel, but would not go outside to face the tiger who was hunting people by night.

    The Christian must sometimes speak against the enemies of the Faith, but he will suffer abuse for doing so. He must say the hard word when almost everyone he knows wants him to say the soft and easy word. Yet the hard word is sometimes the godly word -- even if it appears to others (including one's friends) as "harsh" or "divisive" or "simple-minded."

    Looking back to the speech of our Lord and the earliest Christians may make pastors and writers feel better about doing their duty. Their words show that to say the hard word when needed is only to say what we must say, and what our Lord wants us to say. We know at least that we are doing as the Fathers would have done.

    Of course we must speak the hard word in a way right for our time. Words that worked in one age may not work in another. I suspect that calling the semi-Marcionites of the Jesus Seminar "firstborn of Satan" would be simply misunderstood by everyone, because too few people believe in Satan to take the words seriously. The rhetorical style of the Fathers' day called for a harsher speech than ours, so that the same phrases sound worse today than they did then.

    But choosing the right hard word is a matter both of the speaker's craft and of his growth in holiness, so that he knows what God would have him say and knows how to say it well. He will know when to correct and when to rebuke and know how to do both so that the object might, if he has ears to hear, hear and change. We know that it is hard to speak the hard word rightly, but that is not an excuse for failing to speak strongly when strong words are needed.


    Con't
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Nov 16, 2017
    DeGaulle and sunburst like this.
  20. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    The Apostolic Style

    The early Christians did not believe in "dialogue." They were not open to questions when the answers had already been given. They did not think a claim to teach a new doctrine was simply a disagreement among friends or an argument within the family or an opportunity for an enriching dialogue or a stage in our mutual search for truth. They felt no need to talk with heretics as if the heretic had something to contribute to the community. They would have broken up many a modern church meeting.

    They spoke as St. Polycarp had spoken to Marcion whenever they needed to. Such, wrote St. Irenaeus, "was the horror which the apostles and their disciples had against holding even verbal communication with any corrupters of the truth." They felt horror, not discomfort or distaste.

    In fact, the Fathers often said that those in error spoke for Satan. The heretic was not only on the wrong side, he was on the side of evil. We tend to think of heresies as miscalculations, as simple and innocent mistakes, but the Fathers saw them as a willful turning from the light. We think of the heretic as if he had accidentally bounced a check because he made a mistake balancing his checkbook. They thought of him as one who had shaken his fist at God and thumbed his nose at the Church.

    St. Irenaeus described Marcion as one who "spoke as with the mouth of the devil." He spoke of Marcion and his peers as "malignant-minded people," examples of "an abyss of madness and of blasphemy against Christ." He and his peers are to "be recognized as agents of Satan by all those who worship God…who has prepared eternal fire for every kind of apostasy."

    St. Vincent of Lerins said: "We may be assured beyond doubt, when we find people alleging passages from the apostles or prophets against the Catholic faith, that the devil speaks through their mouths." (Vincent, you may remember, was the one who defined the Catholic faith as "that faith which has been believed everywhere, always, and by all.")

    This is the way the earliest Christian saints regularly spoke of those who spoke of Jesus in the wrong way -- which is to say, spoke of a Jesus other than the one described in the Scriptures, inventing for their own (evil) purposes a Jesus other than the one who was born of the Virgin Mary, died on the Cross, and rose again on the third day. It was the real Jesus or nothing.

    The Fathers knew, as we do not seem to, how attractive were the alternatives and what harm they would bring to their victims' lives. They knew that the heretics were playing a very clever con game on the unsuspecting, who might well lose all that they had. They knew that they had to step in forcefully, not least because no one who has been conned likes to admit it.

    Is This Christ-like?

    Here the average American Christian starts squirming in his chair. Is this Christ-like? he will ask. Presumably Cerinthus and Marcion meant well. And even if they didn't, you don't convert someone by calling him the enemy of truth or the firstborn of Satan in public. Is this the way to talk to people for whom Jesus died?

    In this case, I think, the early Christians had a much better idea of what is Christ-like than does the average modern Christian. Jesus was (and is) not "nice." He would not be a safe guest to invite to a suburban dinner party. He was not always affirming and inclusive, and He was unpredictably direct.

    His love for mankind did not stop Him from speaking bluntly to the men He loved, and speaking in a way that sounds brutal to our ears, and probably did to theirs as well. Take the famous example of His talk with the scribes and Pharisees in Matthew 23: First, He called them "white-washed tombs." They were, He said, beautiful on the outside but inside full of rotting bodies and "all uncleanness." If He were speaking today, He might compare them to one of those old stone sewage treatment plants, built in a neo-Gothic style to look like a church or a castle. He would tell them, in public, "You may look like Chartres Cathedral on the outside, but on the inside you're full of excrement."

    Second, He called them "serpents, [the] brood of vipers." In our terms, He was calling them "poisonous little vermin." In that culture, the term had the same emotional impact as calling someone a "Nazi" today. For one thing, calling them serpents tied them to the first recorded serpent, the one who tempted Eve in the Garden. He was saying that these exceedingly religious men were in fact doing the devil's work.

    He said this to their faces, and in front of others. You can find in the Gospels several other examples of Jesus' speaking to hostile listeners in the same way. But -- this is the crucial point -- He was not speaking this way to insult them. He was speaking this way to get their attention and make them see the truth, so that they would change their lives and turn to Him. If they were insulted, as they usually seem to have been (and I would have been too), that only proves that they did not know who was speaking to them. Whatever God says to you, it is, by definition, not insulting.

    The scribes and Pharisees were men He would die for in just a few months. But He would also tell them the truth about themselves, in language they could not ignore, and force them to a decision to repent and follow Him, or not. No one, I trust, would have told Jesus that you catch more flies with honey than vinegar.

    Speaking as the Lord

    So when the early Christians called a man like Marcion "the firstborn of Satan," they were in fact speaking charitably and speaking as our Lord might have spoken to him. To identify his master was an act of kindness to him, offered that he might see himself as he really is and repent. This was the only chance he had to escape his master and to avoid sharing his master's end in Hell.

    When they called such a man "the firstborn of Satan," they were also being kind to those he might fool. Marcion was good at what he did, and to "dialogue" with him would only make the vulnerable take him more seriously. They had to be sure that the people listening understood what Marcion was and what he was doing.

    In fighting over words the Fathers knew themselves to be fighting for human souls. They were forced to confront people who got the words wrong, who often knew exactly what they were doing and were very adept at deceit. By speaking the wrong words about Jesus, the heretics were in great danger of being among those who say, "Lord, Lord," but to whom the Lord says, "I never knew you. Depart from me" (Mt. 7:23). Jesus would not know them because they had refused to know Him.

    To help both the heretic and the people he might fool, the Fathers needed to sound the alarm, and it needed to sound like an alarm. A few years ago someone invented an alarm clock that played ocean sounds instead of buzzing, and whoever bought the clock was late to work the next day.

    The early Christians could not take the chance that their alarm would not wake up people who needed to wake up. In these matters, the house was on fire but many of the people slept as if drugged, and only the most blaring of alarms would drag them out of sleep.

    It would not do to say, "Our brother Marcion has raised some very serious questions for us, and we are deeply grateful to him for doing so. We want to thank him for modeling a way of engaging these very complex problems that we are all struggling with, and for giving us some very creative answers. We have learned a great deal from him. However, after a lot of intense and fruitful discussion, we feel that some of his answers are not fully in accord with the Church's teaching, but we hope he will continue this very enriching dialogue."

    By telling the truth about Marcion and telling people whose servant he was, St. Polycarp, St. Irenaeus, and the others showed their love for those tempted to follow him. The picture of Jesus that Marcion had drawn looked enough like the real Jesus to fool some people, but it was not really a picture of Jesus at all. Marcion was leading people away from God into what St. Irenaeus had called "an abyss of madness and of blasphemy."

    Think of what staid newspapers have said about companies that poisoned the water in a neighborhood and then let people live there without warning them. Irenaeus, and all the other early Christians, knew that spiritual poison was much deadlier, and that is why they spoke as they did.


    Con't
     
    David Healy likes this.

Share This Page