We have posters like Davidtlg (and others) who are in favor of the pope, so it is NOT just a matter of opposing someone who is in favor of the pope. We’ve also recently deleted the account of a poster who was extremely critical of this pope, for that matter. Joe was literally abusive in ways you’ll never see or understand, but the effects of his presence were uniformly disruptive and chaotic to MOG. He is a well meaning and probably good hearted soul but the way he went about prosecuting his case was too disruptive and at times vicious to let him stay. Padraig gave him many chances to return and change the way he went about trying to “favor the pope” but unfortunately he wasn’t willing to change his passive-aggressive and troll-like behavior. There are lots of internet sites, blogs and forums where he is free to post his brand of “favoring the pope” but this is a private forum and “rights to free speech” end where they violate the forum owner’s explicit guidelines and the rights of fellow forum members to be free of severely disruptive and abusive behavior.
I really know it can all become very sensitive especially when you so strongly sit on one side of the fence or the other However I believe we all are trying to do the right thing as per our own conscience and Please God with strong faith and love for one another we all make it to a blessed eternity where we can look back on all of this together and instead of irritating one another embrace each other when God’s plan becomes clearer to us all. I can almost imagine a wee Mother of God forum room waiting for us all to meet up and laugh at ourselves, Padraig may have an easier time governing us all on the other side
One of my last private messages to Joe only a week ago was that he and I may well meet again face to face after the Chastisement or Warning. After all he is only a 3hr drive from me.[or 7 day walk] Joes reply was ''May God make it so''. Amen.
Ah Mac, please God we do all meet after the warning and chastisement, though I’m worried, will I be anywhere near prepared. despite good intentions I fail miserably everyday.
From this story: This is EVIL, telling children that it's ok to have sexual congress with adults is not what our Church should be doing. They should be teaching the Catechism of the Roman Catholic Church. What has happened to these German clerics? Don't they read the Gospel of our Lord? The Commandments? Sin? There's no diversity of ideas about sin, Bishop Koch, Sin is Bad. This is madness, utter madness. Much prayer for all of our priests, bishops, cardinals and Pope.
In fact the the Father did contact the Pope privately ; it was only after this was ignored that he went public.
I only wish I could wish it all away or pretend it is not happening. Sadly, not. Satan is not simply the Father of Lies, he is the Father of the Half Truth. The Half Truth being far more dangerous than the outright lie.
Carol, I am under no illusions. Awful things are happening and worse, God forbid, is probably going to. I'm just trying to apportion the responsibility in my head and I can't help trying to give our Pope the benefit of the doubt when the opportunity arises. This is really painful. As Catholics, we all have a special veneration for the Pope and it is most difficult to accept that he might be the primary generator of the current antinomianism. Despite my above post, I still haven't ruled out this possibility.
Honestly the one thing that steadies me is the truth that God has permitted this. The words of Malachi in Sundsy’s First reading give chills. It describes a chastisementvof the priests and the high priest—in our time the high priest is the Pope. God calls them out on their unbelief and their corruption. I have to believe we are undergoing a purification that is so intense that it can sometimes feel like physical pain. And that God is going to sort it out and restore His Church. We have to put in the full armor of God and hold up the shield of faith. Hold our ground and stand fast in the evil day.
By Dr. Jeff Mirus | Oct 27, 2017 Remember the famous proof formulated by the great Catholic apologist Hilaire Belloc: The Catholic Church is an institution I am bound to hold divine—but for unbelievers a proof of its divinity might be found in the fact that no merely human institution conducted with such knavish imbecility would have lasted a fortnight. When it comes to Catholic affairs, no conspiracy theories are needed. Such theories simply give solace to people who are unwilling to accept the tensions Our Lord permits in the Church and in Catholic life as a whole. These tensions, when they do not come from external assault, are the result of the very real sins of the Church’s members in combination with misunderstandings, personality differences, deficiencies of various kinds, differing priorities, and conflicting prudential judgments. The Church could not have been established with human members, let alone sinners, unless such tensions were permitted. Moreover, “loophole” and “conspiracy” theories only serve to weaken the Church further than she is already weakened by the necessary elements of her constitution. Indeed, such theories often lead to serious sins, including their own brands of heresy and schism. What we call the lunatic fringe is made up of people who refuse to tolerate the level of confusion they are asked to endure by their Lord and Savior—a Lord and Savior who permits nothing to happen to anyone that cannot be used for the soul’s good. It is precisely this desire to escape the suffering occasioned by human confusion that has ever been the hallmark of the lunatic fringe. Such a desire is not illegitimate, surely, but like every other human desire, it must be carefully restrained and channeled for the glory of God. Things will likely get worse before they get better. Moreover, at another time they will get worse in some other way before they get better. Why should we borrow trouble? Therefore I urge everyone: Do not respond to the lure of the absurd. We Catholics have a plethora of common, garden variety explanations for all of our trials, not least the confusion within ourselves. And we also have a treasure trove of spiritual remedies for each trial. http://www.catholicculture.org/commentary/the-city-gates.cfm?id=1515
Padraig, I wish I was certain of so many things! I am only certain of one thing..... I am an unworthy servant of Our Lord Jesus who suffered and died for me. And I think it is this fact that keeps me questioning my capability to judge the motives of others correctly. I don't trust my ability to discern accurately and so I constantly pray for this gift. Please pray for me in this regard.
https://catholicstrength.com/2017/11/02/why-amoris-laetitia-is-much-worse-than-originally-thought/ WHY AMORIS LAETITIA IS MUCH WORSE THAN ORIGINALLY THOUGHT November 2, 2017 “I am not speaking only of the divorced and remarried, but of everyone, in whatever situation they find themselves.” (Pope Francis) From the beginning the controversy regarding Amoris Laetitia has been portrayed as being limited to whether a divorced and civilly remarried Catholic might be permitted, in certain circumstances, to receive Holy Communion. The purpose of this note is to demonstrate that the reach of Amoris Laetiti goes well beyond just the divorced and remarried. In fact, in the controversial Chapter 8 of Amoris Laetitia Pope Francis quite clearly states that the type of mercy being advocated is not just for the divorced and remarried but for everyone “in whatever situation.” He states: 297. It is a matter of reaching out to everyone, of needing to help each person find his or her proper way of participating in the ecclesial community and thus to experience being touched by an “unmerited, unconditional and gratuitous” mercy. No one can be condemned for ever, because that is not the logic of the Gospel! Here I am not speaking only of the divorced and remarried, but of everyone, in whatever situation they find themselves. And this group of “everyone” is referenced in no. 297 with respect to a person who is in “objective sin,” and the example of a couple “living together” (cohabitating) is given, and elsewhere in Chapter 8 there is the generalized use of the term “irregular situations.” In short, the formula of mercy presented in Amoris Laetitia, which permits in concrete circumstances a subjective approval of objective mortal sin, can be claimed by everyone in whatever situation. Here is the very troubling passage from Amoris Laetitia (no. 301) which clearly suggests that a person can be in a “concrete situation” where he has no choice but to live in mortal sin (and is thus justified in remaining in his objectively sinful condition even though he knows the rule): 301. For an adequate understanding of the possibility and need of special discernment in certain “irregular” situations, one thing must always be taken into account, lest anyone think that the demands of the Gospel are in any way being compromised. The Church possesses a solid body of reflection concerning mitigating factors and situations. Hence it is can no longer simply be said that all those in any “irregular” situation are living in a state of mortal sin and are deprived of sanctifying grace. More is involved here than mere ignorance of the rule. A subject may know full well the rule, yet have great difficulty in understanding “its inherent values”, or be in a concrete situation which does not allow him or her to act differently and decide otherwise without further sin. Amoris Laetitia, no. 303, contains another very controversial statement made by Pope Francis, stating that a person can come to the realization that God wills him to stay in his sinful condition. It reads, in pertinent part: “Yet conscience can do more than recognize that a given situation does not correspond objectively to the overall demands of the Gospel. It can also recognize with sincerity and honesty what for now is the most generous response which can be given to God, and come to see with a certain moral security that it is what God himself is asking amid the concrete complexity of one’s limits, while yet not fully the objective ideal. In any event, let us recall that this discernment is dynamic; it must remain ever open to new stages of growth and to new decisions which can enable the ideal to be more fully realized.” In his great encyclical on Catholic morality, Veritatis Splendor, Saint Pope John Paul II specifically foresaw and rejected the type of argument put forth in Amoris Laetia (303) quoted above. He stated very clearly that “It would be a very serious error … to conclude that the Church’s teaching is essentially only an “ideal” which must then be adapted, proportioned, graduated to the so-called concrete possibilities of man.” (VS 103) Still further, Saint John Paul II stated: “circumstances or intentions can never transform an act intrinsically evil by virtue of its object into an act “subjectively” good or defensible as a choice.” (VS 81) Pope John Paul II explained in Veritatis Splendor the clear Catholic teaching that an intrinsically evil act cannot be creatively transformed into something willed by God under concrete circumstances (the suggestion put forth in AL 303 and 301). “The negative moral precepts, those prohibiting certain concrete actions or kinds of behavior as intrinsically evil, do not allow for any legitimate exception. They do not leave room, in any morally acceptable way, for the “creativity” of any contrary determination whatsoever.” (Veritatis Splendor 67) “The negative precepts of the natural law are universally valid. They oblige each and every individual, always and in every circumstance. It is a matter of prohibitions which forbid a given action semper et pro semper, without exception.” (VS 52) By trying to claim that an intrinsically evil act like adultery, fornication or other “irregular union” may be the most generous response a person can give to God at a certain moment in his life, Pope Francis has embraced situation ethics and has strayed far from the firm and authentic foundations of Catholic morality. Pope John Paul II had already warned that such an argument is clearly erroneous. CONCLUSION: Amoris Laetitia therefore opens the door to the justification of any type of mortal sin because it is specifically for “everyone” in “all situations.” For example, why would a married gay couple not be able to claim under the rationale of Amoris that their union is the best response they can make given their concrete situation. Thus, when Dr. Joseph Seifert referred to Amoris Laetitia as a “theological atomic bomb” which in essence would blow up Catholic morality, making all Catholic morality essentially optional, his opinion was not mere hyperbole. Amoris Laetitia has created quite a mess for those who teach moral theology. One could forcefully argue it is the greatest threat to Catholic morality the Church has ever encountered. Thomas L. Mulcahy, M.A., J.D.
*Didn't a Cardinal offer a similar piece of advice to Napolean? Bonaparte is long gone, while we keep stumbling on. And there's Julian of Norwich: "Our Lord God shewed that a deed shall be done, and Himself shall do it, and I shall do nothing but sin, and my sin shall not hinder His Goodness working. ... It behoved that there should be sin; but all shall be well, and all shall be well, and all manner of thing shall be well (to be precise, this was never intended in a universalist sense). Finally, who exactly is being implied as the 'lunatic fringe'?
Amoris Laetitia could even be accused of adopting a materialist-determinist philosophy of being in which Free Will plays no part, but rather people are merely mechanistic products of their own environment, unaccountable functions of their hormonal desires with no more real responsibility for their actions than a tree that is impelled to sway in the wind. This is the atheistic rabbit hole down which many Protestants were led by extreme Predestinationism during the so-called Enlightenment. A man is either a sinner who must take responsibility for his sins or he is a mindless automaton. There is no other option. One must distinguish Mercy from the mere denial of the very existence of Sin. Mercy presupposes Sin. AL seems to be veering very close to Excusing Sin. "Ah, sure that's alright, really. No harm done. In the long run, what does it matter?"
Müller, Buttiglione and the “confusion” of those criticizing the Pope Pubblicato il 07/11/2017 ANDREA TORNIELLI VATICAN CITY Professor Rocco Buttiglione’s new book “Friendly answers to Amoris laetitia’s critics (Edizioni Ares, in bookshop since November 10) - and above all the introductory essay written by Cardinal Gerhard Ludwig Müller seem to have sown a certain confusion among the liveliest critics of Pope Francis. To realize this, we only need to start from the latest article published on Sandro Magister’s blog, which in the title warns us that “the dubia are more alive than ever ”. And that “Müller adds one of his own”. Actually, it is hard to understand in the text exactly what Müller’s new doubt would be. It is well understood, instead, that the cardinal demolishes the first doubt of the cardinals (and consequently all the others). According to Magister “the cardinal proposes - explicitly - a single case of possible access to communion by a Catholic who has passed to a new union and with their first spouse still alive. It’s the case when the first marriage, though celebrated in church, is to be considered invalid due to the absence of faith or other essential requirements at the time of the celebration, but such invalidity “cannot be canonically proven”. Let’s leave aside the fact that Cardinal Müller also considers other cases of diminished responsibility – one just need to read the preface to Buttiglione’s book. Let us therefore limit ourselves to this only case recognized by Magister. Not only does the author of the blog “Settimo cielo” recognize that the cardinal considers this case as acceptable, but it seems that he too considers it acceptable. And he even says that this thesis had already been proposed by Joseph Ratzinger. We then have at least one case in which it is legitimate to give communion to remarried divorcees. It’s a “completely traditional” case, Magister tells us. This is not entirely true, as traditionally, a disciplinary prohibition existed on this issue. But one can be excused from the disciplinary prohibition, which can be eventually diminished or removed. At this point, however, the first and fundamental doubt of the four cardinals (Carlo Caffarra, Raymond Leo Burke, Walter Brandmüller and Joachim Meisner) has been clearly overcome. For the sake of completeness, we shall recall the text of dubia number 1: “It is asked whether, following the affirmations of Amoris Laetitia (300-305), it has now become possible to grant absolution in the sacrament of penance and thus to admit to holy Communion a person who, while bound by a valid marital bond, lives together with a different person more uxorio without fulfilling the conditions provided for by Familiaris Consortio, 84, and subsequently reaffirmed by Reconciliatio et Paenitentia, 34, and Sacramentum Caritatis, 29. Can the expression “in certain cases” found in Note 351 (305) of the exhortation Amoris Laetitia be applied to divorced persons who are in a new union and who continue to live more uxorio?” The answer, according to Müller (and at this point, we must consider for Magister as well) is, yes: there is at least one case in which this can be lawful. If there is at least one case in which this is legitimate, then the accusation of heresy made against the Pope by the signatories of the “Correctio filialis” is false, and those who have signed it have slandered the Successor of Peter. Francis in the exhortation does not specify in which cases admission to the sacraments can be lawful. It simply says, “in certain cases”. Those that are now accepted by Magister - which by the way, are not all the ones mentioned by Müller - are more than enough. continued.....
continued.... Let’s try to see how the first doubt of the cardinals would be reformulated in the light of Magister’s admissions, “ It is asked whether, following the affirmations of Amoris Laetitia (300-305), it has now become possible to grant absolution in the sacrament of penance and thus to admit to holy Communion a person who, while bound by a valid marital bond, lives together with a different person more uxorio without fulfilling the conditions provided for by Familiaris Consortio, 84, and subsequently reaffirmed by Reconciliatio et Paenitentia, 34, and Sacramentum Caritatis, 29. Can the expression “in certain cases” found in Note 351 (305) of the exhortation Amoris Laetitia be applied to divorced persons who are in a new union and who continue to live more uxorio”, unless they are firmly convinced in conscience that their marriage is invalid, even if they are unable to offer canonical proof of it? ”. Let’s now turn to the theses supported by Professor Roberto de Mattei on the website “ Corrispondenza Romana”. Only now, i.e. after the release of Buttiglione’s articles, did de Mattei admit the existence of non-imputability. And in fact, today he supports that the “complete or partial non-imputability is limited to rare cases such as drunkenness, dementia, mental illness, hypnosis, sleep or sleep awakening. In these cases, the conditions of the free act are lacking, because it is not possible for the person to dominate the acts of their intellect or will”. We should point out, that actually, as Buttiglione has repeatedly pointed out, there is not only a lack of imputability but also reduced responsibility as a result of mitigating circumstances: a case that is much more frequent and that can downsize a mortal sin to venial sin. Let’s limit ourselves, however, only to the non-imputability aspect that de Matteis included in his definition: there are some cases in which the sacraments can be granted because in them guilt is not attributable. De Mattei insists that these cases are few in number, although at a superficial glance, neurosis, psychosis, depression and other mental illnesses seem to involve an increasing number of patients in our time. But the Pope never said that these cases were numerous. The question, however, is not whether the cases are few or many. The issue is that at least some cases exist, and therefore it is not understood on which basis the orthodoxy of “Amoris Laetitia” can be questioned, or even go as far as to affirm - as all the signatories of the” Correctio filialis” do - that the Pope “sustains heresies”. Let’s see now how the first of the Cardinals’ dubia would be reformulated also in the light of Professor de Mattei’s rethinking, “It is asked whether, following the affirmations of Amoris Laetitia (300-305), it has now become possible to grant absolution in the sacrament of penance and thus to admit to holy Communion a person who, while bound by a valid marital bond, lives together with a different person more uxorio without fulfilling the conditions provided for by Familiaris Consortio, 84, and subsequently reaffirmed by Reconciliatio et Paenitentia, 34, and Sacramentum Caritatis, 29. Can the expression “in certain cases” found in Note 351 (305) of the exhortation Amoris Laetitia be applied to divorced persons who are in a new union and who continue to live more uxorio”, unless they are firmly convinced in conscience that their marriage is invalid, even if they are unable to offer canonical proof of it, and also excluding cases of non- imputability in which the conditions of the free act are lacking, because it is not possible for the person to dominate the acts of their intellect or will ?”. Is it all? Still not. We cannot fail to mention what the signatories of the now famous act of subsidiary correction have written. They decided to write in Latin, but the solemnity of Cicero’s language is not enough to disguise the inconsistency of their argument , “Christifidelis qui, divortium civile a sponsa legitima consecutus, matrimonium civile (sponsa vivente) cum alia contraxit; quique cum ea more uxorio vivit; quique cum plena intelligentia naturae actus sui et voluntatis propriae pleno ad actum consensu eligit in hoc rerum statu manere: non necessarie mortaliter peccare dicendus est, et gratiam sanctificantem accipere et in caritate crescere potest”. Which means, “Christians who have obtained a civil divorce from the spouse to whom they are validly married and have contracted a civil marriage with some other person during the lifetime of their spouse, who live more uxorio with their civil partner, and who choose to remain in this state with full knowledge of the nature of their act and full consent of the will to that act, are not necessarily in a state of mortal sin, and can receive sanctifying grace and grow in charity”. But does Pope Francis really tell us that you can live without sin with a woman who is not your wife by doing so “with full knowledge and deliberate consent”? It is useless to mention here the many passages in which the Pope speaks of mitigating circumstances deriving precisely from the absence of “full knowledge and deliberate consent” (cf. numbers 301-303 of Amoris laetitia). Here is the latest version of the first dubia of the cardinals, reworded with the further revision proposed by the signatories of the “Correctio filialis ”, “It is asked whether, following the affirmations of Amoris Laetitia (300-305), it has now become possible to grant absolution in the sacrament of penance and thus to admit to holy Communion a person who, while bound by a valid marital bond, lives together with a different person more uxorio without fulfilling the conditions provided for by Familiaris Consortio, 84, and subsequently reaffirmed by Reconciliatio et Paenitentia, 34, and Sacramentum Caritatis, 29. Can the expression “in certain cases” found in Note 351 (305) of the exhortation Amoris Laetitia be applied to divorced persons who are in a new union and who continue to live more uxorio”, unless they are firmly convinced in conscience that their marriage is invalid, even if they are unable to offer canonical proof of it, and also excluding cases of non- imputability in which the conditions of the free act are lacking, because it is not possible for the person to dominate the acts of their intellect or will, and except in cases where there is a lack of full knowledge and deliberate consent?”. At this point, including in the dubium the exceptions represented by the cases 1) of marital invalidity considered in conscience even if not canonically provable, 2) of non- imputability in which the person’s dominion on the acts of their intellect and will is missing, and 3) of the analogous case of lack of full knowledge and deliberate consent, we have finally “reached” the positions supported by Rocco Buttiglione. Actually, we have reached those directly affirmed by the Pope. In the end, we even went beyond “Amoris Laetitia”, which merely said that perhaps in some cases one could even think of giving those who find themselves in certain situations the support of the sacraments, without however falling into any casuistry. Although they have had to radically change their positions, the Pope’s critics continue their work but, to do so they are forced to attribute to him affirmations that he has clearly never supported. Finally, it is not excluded that “Amoris Laetitia” may have transformed itself, at least for some, in an opportunity to vent feelings accumulated for a long time against the Second Vatican Council and against the Popes of the Council, all of them. The pretext, however, has been chosen badly, as demonstrated by what has happened in recent days with the “corrections” to which correctors have been forced. Too many have entitled themselves with the authority of Saint Athanasius. Too many want to drag the alleged “heretics” in front of their self-constituted tribunal, to the point of accusing even the Pope of heresy. Too many are causing unceasing confusion in their self-referential media circles and then say that today in the Church “there is confusion”. http://www.lastampa.it/2017/11/07/v...g-the-pope-PpxFQoXlPfNiV4WFzk8koJ/pagina.html
We are in the worst crisis in the history of the Church. One that Our Lady warned us about at Fatima and Akita were Cardinal will be in opposition to Cardinal and Bishop to Bishop. Where the Church is thrown into diabolical disorientation . Little wonder if our Leaders falter we might feel lost.