The Vatican Has Fallen

Discussion in 'Church Critique' started by padraig, Dec 31, 2016.

  1. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    It’s one thing to be charitable, it’s another to be credulous.


    https://www-lifesitenews-com.cdn.ampproject.org/v/s/www.lifesitenews.com/mobile/news/cardinal-sarah-st.-john-paul-ii-forced-his-broken-body-to-kneel-for-communi

    Cardinal Sarah: St. John Paul II ‘forced his broken body to kneel’ before Eucharist | News | LifeSite
    News Catholic Church

    Cardinal Sarah: St. John Paul II ‘forced his broken body to kneel’ before Eucharist
    [​IMG]
    Claire Chretien

    Wed Jun 7, 2017 - 3:48 pm EST

    MILAN, Italy, June 7, 2017 (LifeSiteNews) – Catholics should follow Pope St. John Paul II's example of kneeling before the Blessed Sacrament, Cardinal Robert Sarah said, noting that the late pope knelt even until his last days.

    The cardinal also highlighted St. Teresa of Calcutta's reverence for the Eucharist, noting that she once said nothing brought her more sadness than Communion on the hand.

    Sarah spoke Tuesday at the 2017 Sacra Liturgica conference in Milan about "the beauty, appropriateness, and pastoral value" of receiving Holy Communion kneeling and on the tongue. Sarah is the Prefect for the Congregation for Divine Worship, essentially making him the Vatican's liturgy chief.

    The Catholic Church teaches that the Eucharist is the literal body, blood, soul, and divinity of Jesus Christ.

    "For if, as St Paul teaches, 'at the name of Jesus every knee should bow, in heaven and on earth and under the earth' (Phil. 2:10), how much more should we bend our knees when we come to receive the Lord himself in the most sublime and intimate act of Holy Communion!" said Sarah.

    "A disposition of reverence and of awe is absolutely necessary before all things liturgical, before the privileged divine encounter that the liturgical rites facilitate," Sarah explained.

    Of Pope St. John Paul II's respect for Jesus in the Eucharist, Sarah said:

    The whole of the life of Karol Wotyla was marked by a profound respect for the Blessed Eucharist. Much could be said, and much has been written about this. Today I simply ask you to recall that at the end of his life of service, a man in a body wracked with sickness, John Paul II could never sit in the presence of the Blessed Sacrament. He forced his broken body to kneel. He needed the help of others to bend his knees, and again to stand. What more profound testimony could he give to the reverence due to the Blessed Sacrament than this, right up until his very last days.

    He then quoted St. Teresa of Calcutta, an "exceptional nun, whose faith, holiness and total gift of her life to God and to the poor are world-renowned."

    St. Teresa "had absolute respect and worship for the Divine Body of Jesus Christ," said Sarah. He noted that "she touched daily the 'flesh' of Christ in the dilapidated bodies of the poorest of the poor," but "amazed and full of respectful veneration, she refrained from touching the transubstantiated Body of Christ."


    "These people demolish the Church and its profound nature," he continued. "A Christian does not fight anyone. A Christian has no enemy to defeat. Christ asks Peter to put his sword into his scabbard (cf. Mt 26: 52-53). This is the command of Christ to Peter, and it concerns every Christian worthy of the name."

     
  2. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    I’ve had severe sciatica and I’ve even been paralyzed. Not being able to kneel was a great suffering for me:


    https://onepeterfive.com/tears-joy-reparation/

    Tears of Joy, and of Reparation
    Dr. Brian Kopp July 5, 2016 31 Comments
    [​IMG]
    Editor’s note: in March, we shared the news with our readers that 1P5 contributor Dr. Brian Kopp had suffered a series of debilitating strokes that were, at the time, life-threatening. By God’s grace, Brian pulled through, and is making progress in his physical recovery. This is his first contribution since that time. Please pray for his continued healing.

    [​IMG]I went to my parish for the Traditional Latin Mass today. It was the first time I went there with a pair of forearm crutches instead of a walker, since multiple strokes in March, so I no longer needed to sit in the handicapped pew.

    I spent the whole Mass praying ardently for guidance from God and begging Our Lady to pray for me and lead me, given the circumstances with the Church and this pope on whether to stay quiet or what to do and what to say.

    I’ve been working on kneeling and genuflecting at PT for two weeks. I was finally able to walk up to Communion with crutches and, for the first time since early March, I was able (with a bit of help) to kneel to receive Our Lord in the Holy Eucharist.

    I started attending the TLM because 1) I wanted to kneel for the Eucharist and 2) I despised liturgical abuse and gravely mistrusted those priests who engaged in it. I don’t love Latin, and I had no attachment to that liturgy (though I do now, especially since I understand the theology of the sacrifice of the mass now given the immensely richer and deeper theology of the old liturgy.)

    The pastor stopped his usual walk from side to side to distribute the Eucharist to come to me, so I didn’t have to wait to receive in the kneeling position, the first time I had attempted to do so since March. Then he graciously helped me to stand up from the altar rail, making sure I was steady and had my footing and my crutches before moving on to continue distributing.

    When I got back to my pew and knelt in thanksgiving, tears of joy started streaming unbidden down my face. In March, I wasn’t sure if I would ever walk again, and I had just walked to the altar rail. And I knelt and got back up, something I never thought I’d be able to do again. I was thoroughly overjoyed and thankful; I’ve never experienced tears of joy and thanksgiving at Mass.

    Then something strange happened. My tears of joy melted into tears of sorrow, and I began weeping. For a very long time. Again, something that I’ve just never done at a Mass, and surely didn’t want to be doing at a TLM where moments before I had experienced rare tears of joy in thanksgiving.

    I just don’t cry at Mass, but in an instant I understood. While I had prayed earlier, earnestly, for guidance in the midst of this Church chaos, I realized our pope was making changes to allow those in irregular unions to have access to the Eucharist. While I was experiencing tears of joy at being able to kneel for the Holy Eucharist, at a Mass I started attending to escape liturgical abuse, we had a pope that regularly commits the liturgical abuse of not genuflecting at the Consecration, and not kneeling at Adoration. This despite abundant photos on the Internet of him kneeling to commit the liturgical abuse of washing Muslim women’s feet on Holy Thursday (before he changed the rules so his liturgical abuse became “licit.”)

    [​IMG]
    Pope Francis kisses the foot of a man during the foot-washing ritual at the Castelnuovo di Porto refugees center, some 30km (18, 6 miles) from Rome, Thursday, March 24, 2016. The pontiff washed and kissed the feet of Muslim, Orthodox, Hindu and Catholic refugees Thursday, declaring them children of the same God, in a gesture of welcome and brotherhood at a time when anti-Muslim and anti-immigrant sentiment has spiked following the Brussels attacks. (L’Osservatore Romano/Pool Photo via AP)

    These tears are shared by Our Lady that a priest, the pope, would ignore or disobey liturgical rubrics intended to give praise and glory to her Son’s Real Presence in the Eucharist, but desires to see us kneel before the presence of the poor.

    My prayers were answered today. A love for the Real Presence in the Eucharist must be accompanied by corrective words and actions for those who would profane it.

    My quadriceps are killing me tonight from kneeling at Mass for the first time since March, so, like every bit of suffering in this long process of strokes and recovery, I’ll actively accept that cross and offer it up to the Father, along with ardent prayers and continued fasting, for our Holy Father and his conversion to defending and preaching orthodoxy and orthopraxis.

    But I fear many more tears of reparation will be shed in the weeks and months ahead.
     
  3. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    You do not know it is not a great suffering for Pope Francis...
    Perhaps it is. Neither of us know.
    And that is my point.
     
    earthtoangels and Rose like this.
  4. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    Bless you Brian, you are a good man!
     
    BrianK, Carol55 and Mac like this.
  5. dcana

    dcana Principalities

    Thank you both, Brian and Praetorian, for your responses. Thank you especially Brian for sharing your struggles and blessings with us. I'm sure God is doing so much good in the world in response to your generous offering. I fear to say anything more on this matter, not knowing the details with certainty, other than to say that I don't believe not kneeling before Our Lord in the Blessed Sacrament, if one is physically able, is a "little thing".
     
    Last edited: Sep 26, 2017
  6. padraig

    padraig Powers

    I think it is like the shadow of the shadow of the shadow of the anti Christ. It is like one of those wonderful Vampire films were the poor guy wanders into Count Dracula's Castle and he knows something is wrong but can't quite put his finger on it. Meanwhile you are screaming at him to wake up and take notice.

    There still seems to be very good, loyal , learned and devout Catholics who defend what is going on in Rome. They are right in the heart of Dracula's Castle and think things are fine. Go figure.

    Dr Robert Moynihan has just sent a letter condemning the theologians who complained. I asked him for a point by point rebuttal. I will not hold my breath.

    The confusion continues. I feel the Lord calling me in prayer to a long period of fasting. I am trying to screw up the courage. If ever there was a time for fasting...

    [​IMG]
     
  7. padraig

    padraig Powers

    By the way if anyone wants to understand what is really going on in Rome I would encourage fasting and prayer rather than study alone as a path to doing so. This is what Jesus Himself did in the desert. Go..ask Jesus.
     
  8. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    I 100% agree. My apologies. It is very late here and I am very tired. My point was not to say that that in particular is a little thing, but that the more people "pick at" all of the various things the Pope (or anyone for that matter) does the more animosity builds up and that is not good.
     
    dcana, Booklady and earthtoangels like this.
  9. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    Add 2 + 2 together. It’s right in front of our eyes.

    •He encourages those in mortal sin to receive the Eucharist.
    •Even though it’s copiously documented that he can kneel when he wants to (“ecumenism”) he routinely as a habit does not genuflect or kneel in the Eucharistic Presence of Our Lord.

    It draws into question his very beliefs. It’s NOT uncharitable to point this out.
     
    Mac and SgCatholic like this.
  10. https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=1&v=nI5VZPwtI3s

    He kneels around an hour and twenty seven minutes and has trouble getting up.
     
    Praetorian, Mario and Carol55 like this.
  11. Don_D

    Don_D ¡Viva Cristo Rey!

    As someone who has trouble kneeling and at times can not without immense pain and falling over I can understand giving a bow when these times are on us. I can not judge anyone on these matters and I pray that nobody judges me simply because I look relatively young. Some illness waxes and wanes like mine. I was able to bow with knee to the ground this morning with little discomfort, however some days it is simply impossible no matter how much I want to and would be quite the spectacle if I tried.
     
  12. Yes, projecting intentions upon others is never a good thing. That's a no no! Wouldn't want it done to me....therefore...
     
    Carol55, Praetorian and Rose like this.
  13. Mario

    Mario Powers

    Thank you, any name you wish, it is obvious that Pope Francis painfully endured his one minute genuflection, and it took the assistance of two to bring him to his feet.

    Safe in the Refuge of the Immaculate Heart!
     
  14. padraig

    padraig Powers

    When I was in the Cistercians it was the tradition not to genuflect but to bow. They have been doing this for nearly a thousand years. I would be careful to read too much into little outward signs. For instance he might have some inner ear trouble that affects his balance or whatever. Also everyone has their own spirituality. I love sacramentals and my home is like a Holy Shop, but not everyone is big into this. Again the Fransicans love Holy pictures the Cistercians went in for plain and simple.

    [​IMG]Cistercian

    [​IMG]

    Franciscan
     
  15. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    Thank You ANYW,
    In an issue like this I think we should err on the side of caution and charity. The Pope obviously had a very difficult time genuflecting during Mass in the video you provided and required much assistance.
     
    any name you wish and Carol55 like this.
  16. Texas Mama of 2

    Texas Mama of 2 Archangels

    Padraig,

    I know this is totally unrelated to this thread, but I just wanted you to know that your photo of the Franciscan Monastery in D.C. brings back fond memories. I used to teach third grade at St. Veronica's Catholic School just a short drive away from there in Virginia and every year I would take my class for a spring field trip. We'd go to Mass and tour the replicas of the catacombs in the basement. On the other side of the church from the picture you posted is a life-size depiction of the Crucifixion. I was pleasantly surprised to see when we reached the top of the stairs that every one of my kids knelt down to pray with no prompting from me at all! It made me feel like maybe some of what I tried to teach them about reverence had actually sunk in. (y)

    Anyway, if you ever come across the pond, you really need to visit that beautiful place (and be our guest in Texas, too, of course!)... ;)
     
  17. Booklady

    Booklady Powers

    I too have that difficulty, that is why I so miss the Altar rail, one could with its help, be able to kneel, at least on one knee when receiving the Blessed Sacrament.
     
  18. Mac

    Mac "To Jesus, through Mary"

     
    gracia, Don_D and sunburst like this.
  19. padraig

    padraig Powers

    Yes I love Franciscan Churches.

    My fondest memory was of a time I used to go to a Poor Clare Convent near my home for early morning mass (it has since closed due to lack of vocations). The Chapel was samll but beautiful and all the congregants were older than me at the time, I knew them all by sight. I was surprised to see several young people kneeling right in front of me and so I paid more attention. They were in fact several of the visionaries from Medugorje who must have been touring Ireland at the time. I nearly fell of my seat.

    I hope we will meet one day one way or the other. :) In heaven or on Earth.
     
    Katfalls likes this.
  20. davidtlig

    davidtlig Guest

    Thank you, 'anyname', for spotting this particular video. I believe what has been captured within it is important to highlight. So I have extracted the section where Pope Francis kneels and also the few seconds at the start of the Creed where he is clearly informing Mgr Marini that he wished to kneel during the 'Et Incarnatus'. The video is below:

     
    any name you wish likes this.

Share This Page