Hi Brian, God Bless you, as you know you are Great, between us only, some told me that you are thinking that Saint John Paul's II Consecration of Russia in 1984 was valid, please would you be kind to confirm it to me or not, thank you.
No, I've never said that. I think it had positive salutary effects, and probably averted a world war at the time, but it did NOT fulfill the requirements of Fatima for the Consecration of Russia in my opinion.
http://www.catholicworldreport.com/Item/5346/a_malta_laetitia.aspx A Malta Laetitia Except: Finally, it must be emphasized (again), that Saint John Paul II had addressed all of this decades ago. In Veritatis Splendor, he explained: Certain currents of modern thought have gone so far as to exalt freedom to such an extent that it becomes an absolute, which would then be the source of values. This is the direction taken by doctrines which have lost the sense of the transcendent or which are explicitly atheist. The individual conscience is accorded the status of a supreme tribunal of moral judgment which hands down categorical and infallible decisions about good and evil. To the affirmation that one has a duty to follow one's conscience is unduly added the affirmation that one's moral judgment is true merely by the fact that it has its origin in the conscience. But in this way the inescapable claims of truth disappear, yielding their place to a criterion of sincerity, authenticity and "being at peace with oneself", so much so that some have come to adopt a radically subjectivistic conception of moral judgment. As is immediately evident, the crisis of truth is not unconnected with this development. Once the idea of a universal truth about the good, knowable by human reason, is lost, inevitably the notion of conscience also changes. Conscience is no longer considered in its primordial reality as an act of a person's intelligence, the function of which is to apply the universal knowledge of the good in a specific situation and thus to express a judgment about the right conduct to be chosen here and now. Instead, there is a tendency to grant to the individual conscience the prerogative of independently determining the criteria of good and evil and then acting accordingly. Such an outlook is quite congenial to an individualist ethic, wherein each individual is faced with his own truth, different from the truth of others. Taken to its extreme consequences, this individualism leads to a denial of the very idea of human nature. (par. 32, emphasis added) Yes, a crisis of truth. Again and again, it is clear to me that this pontificate is working to undermine and dismantle key aspects of the teaching of Saint John Paul II. As one correspondent, well-versed in the writings of John Paul II and the current situation, recently wrote to me: "It is one thing for Pope Francis to have canonized Saint John Paul II ... but was this a case of 'promote to remove' (promoveatur ut amoveatur)? Yes, let us honor him with canonization but disregard his teachings..." And, again, it must be emphasized that what John Paul II taught on these matters is in complete accord with two thousand years of Tradition and practice. The current papacy of sentimentality has produced confusion and conflict. As Cardinal Caffera states in a recent interview, "Only a blind man can deny that there is great confusion in the Church.” The clarity that Cardinal Müller speaks of so strongly is not just lacking, it seems to be absent altogether. There are directly competing interpretations of Amoris Laetitia: some by "conservative" prelates who refer to the perennial teachings of the Church and some are by progressive bishops who refer only to Amoris Laetitia and are published in the Vatican newspaper. The Pope's Exhortation may not always be clear, but his intentions and goals are increasingly so.
People who welcome this change though are called Modernists. Modernism is a condemned heresy so it doesn't matter what they think. Those who hold the faith as it has always been are in the right. You are right, this does affect us. A lot. This is something that will affect the entire basis of our faith. Most of the sacraments are involved, whether there are objective truths, etc. The entire Church foundation. It is not a small matter at all. I am not an expert on Arianism. Here is the wiki link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arianism I only know bits and pieces. I have been meaning to read a book on it myself. Someone here recently read one (I think DeGaulle) perhaps he can recommend one. I don't imagine this crisis will go on for too long. You can't logically have 2 sets of sins, where something is an objective mortal sin in one diocese but not in the next. Catholic means universal. Meaning we all believe the same things. It doesn't vary from region to region. "And if a house be divided against itself, that house cannot stand." -Mark 3:25
He's knocked the knees out from under the foundations of her moral theology, and now he's taking aim at her liturgy, reversing Pope Benedict's "reform of the reform." Its widely feared that next he'll go after Summorum Pontificum. http://abcnews.go.com/Health/wireStory/pope-extends-overhaul-vaticans-liturgy-department-44779282 Pope Extends Overhaul of Vatican's Liturgy Department Pope Francis is extending his controversial overhaul of the Vatican's liturgy department, adding a host of new advisers after an initial shake-up removed some leading conservative cardinals. The 17 new advisers named Saturday include priests, laymen and two women. The experts in liturgy and theology join 27 cardinals and bishops named as full members in October. That reshuffling removed tradition-minded cardinals Raymond Burke and George Pell from the roster, although other conservatives were kept on. The office is responsible for ensuring Masses and other sacraments are celebrated around the world according to Vatican standards. It is headed by Guinea's conservative Cardinal Robert Sarah. In July, the Vatican publicly reprimanded Sarah for urging priests to celebrate Mass facing away from the congregation, as was done in the pre-Vatican II-style Mass.
Peace at any price is too high a price to pay. Most people in my family, both immediate and extended, do speak out. If the individual (s) insist upon going their own way relatives, including parents, haven't attended weddings of those who
http://rorate-caeli.blogspot.com/2017/01/motu-proprio-under-threat.html?m=1 Motu Proprio under Threat: Traditionalists must make so much noise no one would dare touch Summorum Pontificum Don't touch me - Noli me tangere This from the latest blog post by Italian vaticanist Sandro Magister (along with Marco Tosatti, the top vaticanist in the current pontificate): There are those who fear that after the demolition of “Liturgiam Authenticam,” the next objective, of this or another commission, will be the correction of “Summorum Pontificum,” the document with which Benedict XVI liberalized the celebration of the Mass in the ancient rite. The time to agitate is now: Traditionalists around the world must make clear the motu proprio Summorum Pontificum (which was not an act of "mercy," but a mere recognition of justice and logic) cannot be touched.
cont. (hit something that sent my message before complete)... Though these individuals are not treated with any contempt neither do they receive affirmation. Those who have taken the route of standing for Catholic teaching are ridiculed or get the silent treatment but don't back down and call something evil a good. In every family in which peace at any price has been in play every marriage thereafter has been irregular and even increasingly irregular. Life is short but eternity is not. Is anything at all in this world worth going to hell for?
Thanks, Praetorian, for your patience. The statement from Malta has me more concerned about this than I had been because I would never have put Malta in the same category as Austria or Belgium. What I know about the Arian heresy is that the reigning Pope along with the majority of bishops believed it and that the Pope only recanted on his deathbed. I suspect that our Bishops will issue something along the lines of Rome or Buenos Aires. The more orthodox among the bishops and priests will hold out in practice for as long as they can but I doubt that they will be able to withstand the pressure from the homosexual lobby which will likely be ramped up during and after the next Synod. Do you think that we are headed towards the Minor Chastisement? I fear that we are, and that things will get an awful lot worse before we are brought back to the narrow road. There's a question or two that I had been meaning to post about the prophecy of St. Francis of Assisi but had hesitated for fear of being accused of attacking Pope Francis' legitimacy. I might go ahead and raise them anyway but not on this thread. Thanks again for helping me get my head around this.
A lot of parishes now Julia have a Jewish Rabbi in and a recreation of the Jewish Passover Meal for Holy Week. It brings it all alive.
I too think the statement from Malta was a huge opening of the floodgates. It is my opinion that Dioceses were sticking their toes in the water before. Presumably to test the reaction. Now that there is no backlash from the Maltese declaration that conscience is king, everyone is free to do whatever they like. Personally I think this is worse than the Arian heresy already just because of the state of the Church. There is little to no catechesis. No one even knows the faith. In the Arian crisis 90% of the hierarchy abandoned the faith but they were brought back by the common sense faithful who didn't abandon what they were taught. Who is there in the Church today to save it? Just a remnant of far flung believers. It is too far gone from the rot that has set in the past half century. That is why we need Our Lady to do it for us. It is past saving by Earthly means. My personal belief is that we have just entered or are about to enter the Chastisement proper. It is my opinion that things will get absolutely horrible. If we think things are bad now, shortly we will look back on this as the good ole days of unity and tranquility. That is why I keep encouraging everyone to do their First Fridays and First Saturdays now, while it is easy. I would think that if this is the Passion of the Church then it will be worse than at any other period in history. I think between 2017 and 2029 the Church will fall apart and seemingly disappear. Though it truly never will. Believers in the true teachings of Christ will be hounded, treated as schismatics and heretics, excommunicated, etc. They may need to hold secret masses, who knows for sure? Again I state that this scenario is my informed, but personal opinion. I could easily be wrong. It would seem to me though that all of the things that need to happen will take longer than just a few years.
Even the liberal Crux knows the confusion can no longer be denied: https://cruxnow.com/global-church/2017/01/14/cardinal-says-blind-man-deny-confusion-caused-pope/ Cardinal says ‘only blind man’ could deny confusion caused by Pope Excerpt. ...Out of respect for the pope, Caffarra said, the four cardinals acted first in private, and only when they had the “certainty” Francis did not intend to respond, he said, did they make the decision to go public. According to Caffarra, the four cardinals decided to act based on requests from ordinary Catholics. “Many faithful began to be scandalized,” he said, “almost as if we were acting like the dogs that didn’t bark mentioned by the Prophet. That’s what’s behind those two pages.” Caffarra insisted that it’s “false and calumnious” to describe the questions the four cardinals submitted to Pope Francis, technically known as dubia, as an act of disloyalty. “I can be obedient to the teaching of the pope if I know what the pope teaches in matters of faith and Christian life,” he said. “But that’s exactly the problem - on some fundamental points it’s hard to understand what the pope is teaching, as the conflict among bishops demonstrates.” Caffarra vigorously denied that the four cardinals have created division by putting questions to the pope. “The division that already exists in the church is the cause of the letter, not its effect,” he said.
Yes, I too will not turn away. I will continue to sound the fire alarm, and try to pull out (save) people trapped in that fire. I believe it is the duty of every faithful Catholic to do the same.
Yes, sad,sad, sad times. Truly terrible. I am glad my parents are not alive to see them. It would have broken their hearts.
Things are going to get worse, I think. Unimaginably worse. I am just writing this to cheer you all up.
Yet in the middle of all this dread and confusion there is one aspect that did not exist before: the internet. In recent years the net has been the best means of bringing orthodox Catholics together, whereas before they often felt alone or scattered and ineffectual in getting their views heard. United, we have more weight and can't be made to just go away. Take the case of Deacon Nick Donnelly whose website Protect the Pope had a good following (often highlighting abuses in the Church) until his bishop pulled the plug on it. I really thought that this 'silencing' was the end of his presence on the net but I saw recently that Deacon Donnelly has resurfaced, writing for EWTN. And there is EWTN itself which of now has a strong orthodox voice and a global reach. Yes this could all change, but the truth is out - and orthodox voices are better organised and more articulate. For all the people who post on MOG a lot more lurk here. The old strategy of divide and conquer with added smoke and mirrors won't work any more. Before the internet, how many of us would have learned about the ramifications of AL and the dubia, other than what the Catholic press was willing and/or able to tell us? Much of the Catholic press is operated by various dioceses - none would have enabled the kind of comment and questioning that we see on the net. True, it takes discernment to filter out the 'green ink brigade' who flourish all over the net, but we have more of a voice than ever before.
Excellent point Clare! If it weren't for the internet I probably wouldn't know about any of this. For all the evil that spews across it, the internet is a great blessing to the faithful in this confusing time. Indeed I would say it is almost necessary. Many of us have had to become armchair canon lawyers and armchair theologians. It is a job I do not really like doing but it has become necessary to guard my faith from error in these times.
Excellent, I'm glad you pointed that out. I knew I recognized the deacon's name but I didn't remember why. Now it makes sense. I missed his blog.
It is interesting Julia that you were taught that all including Judas were included in the first Eucharist. This is actually the first time I have ever heard this. I was always taught since I was a child that Judas left before Jesus gave his body and blood at the Last Supper. It's too bad that apparently there are widespread differences of catechisis, instead of One that should be