THE SYNOD 2015

Discussion in 'The Signs of the Times' started by Blue Horizon, Aug 4, 2015.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Joe Crozier

    Joe Crozier Guest

    Y
    You guys are priceless. Great stuff.
     
    Mac likes this.
  2. Mac

    Mac "To Jesus, through Mary"

    ''But yet the Son of man, when he cometh, shall he find, think you, faith on earth?''Jesus
     
  3. Joe Crozier

    Joe Crozier Guest

    N
    Not much true faith but there will be heeps of decoys.
     
  4. Joe Crozier

    Joe Crozier Guest

    Thank you for your tolerance, your patience and your kindness FS
     
  5. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    Actually we were talking about the bishops remarks in the documentary. It was they who made the allusions, not I.
     
  6. Blue Horizon

    Blue Horizon Guest

    You've lost me here sorry P.
     
  7. Basto

    Basto Guest

    "What Sister Lucia told me: Final Confrontation between the Lord and Satan will be over Family and Marriage." (Cardinal Caffara, 2008)

    Cardinal Burke said, last Tuesday, that the marriage is under “diabolical attack” by both modern culture and church insiders. In which side have I been during this confrontation? Or instead, I am just watching it from my sofa, while having a couple of beers and peanuts? Just think about it…

     
    Mac likes this.
  8. Blue Horizon

    Blue Horizon Guest

    Yes I think it is fairly clear that the content of Pope Francis's Motu Proprio was leaked to Cardinal B. well before its release date. Card. B's timing of his address 1 day beforehand was impeccable.

    And while allegedly speaking to the "Working Propositions" of July for the 2015 Oct Synod ... in fact he picked primarily points that were in Pope Francis's MPropio. Viz, mainly the streamlining the Annulment process, the bishop as tribunal judge (as opposed to delegated Canon Law experts) and "lack of faith" criterion.

    Card B is opposed to the changes suggested in the WP (paragraphs 114,115) initially, on practical/prudential grounds.
    (Presumably therefore he is not at all happy with the Motu Proprio without actually saying so.)

    But ultimately the video shows he is opposed on the grounds that the Church's tradition of Canon law is so well evolved wrt declarations of nullity that it cannot easily be improved upon.
    In fact, he asserts that only Canon Law experts can safely alter or administer this process for the better.
    Card B. all but states that the current Canonical tradition re process for nullity is of Divine Law/Utterance, like the Commandments, and therefore cannot be changed without offending God and justice.

    He does not believe most bishops are up to the job. They should not be directly involved in the Tribunal process (as Pope Francis insists esp for clear cut cases) as they are not Canon Law experts.

    Neither should Cardinals/bishops tinker with Tribunal law for the same reason.
    Card B. implies Pope Francis would be among them because Pastors too easily fall into a compassionate sentimentalism that Canon Lawyers presumably do not.
    Card B. is of course a Canon Lawyer.

    Card B. further asserts a Synod is not able to propose changes, that is not what Synods are for.
    A Synod is meant to assist the Pontiff with their counsel.

    In the end I get the overall impression that Card B. believes the Holy Spirit speaks infallibly through the Church's tradition of Canon Law and its experts rather than through the person of its pastors, esp the Supreme Pastor.

    That, if I read him correctly, is a disturbing position.
    Its what Jesus himself opposed in his dealings with the Scribes and Pharisees.
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Sep 16, 2015
    fallen saint likes this.
  9. davidtlig

    davidtlig Guest

    I think BH's summary of how Cardinal Burke and those who strongly support him view their responsibilities is very accurate. It is because of this that I increasingly think that the synod will be a watershed in the development of the Church.

    I think many traditionalists think that Pope Francis will not be able to resist their viewpoints because those viewpoints are so deeply ingrained in so many of the hierarchy. But I don't think Pope Francis will try to mollify the traditionalist position. I think he knows what needs to be done, whatever the opposition, and will do it regardless of the consequences.
     
    Advocate likes this.
  10. Bartimaeus

    Bartimaeus Archangels

    I don't have the time energy or inclination to monitor all that's going on - or even to read all of this thread, but I really appreciate this summary. God help us all stay true to Christ, especially our priests, bishops, cardinals.
     
  11. Blue Horizon

    Blue Horizon Guest

    I agree with your assessment of Pope Francis' determination David. He set out from the beginning not to be contained by the Vatican Apparatcek as Pope Benediction unfortunately was.

    This is even more clear in his interview yesterday with the Portuguese reporter.
    He knows that after Palm Sunday comes his unpopular Passion and he is ready for it.
    His peace is in his heart and that is all he seeks.
    He has set his face like flint...

    Whatever we may think about his decisions, this is a great man I feel. Not many are capable of facing ignomy fully and knowingly for following Christ's Holy Spirit.
     
    davidtlig likes this.
  12. MarysChild

    MarysChild Principalities

    Well, the new rules about annulments that Pope Francis has promulgated were nearly identical to the old rules followed experimentally in the 70's here in the USA which were widely viewed as a disaster to the point where annulment was seen by Americans as a euphemism for divorce that Catholics used to get around Christ's clear words. John Paul II put an end to those rules and instituted the rules we have had up until now.

    I also agree with what others have stated - if the Pope really believes that at least half of marriages are invalid, then he should be taking some major action to rectify that situation.
     
  13. Blue Horizon

    Blue Horizon Guest

    MC why would we think that Pope Francis and his panel of Canon Law experts are not aware of these past statistics? Most of us laity know these things.

    So it becomes heart issue doesn't it... I mean, why do we 2nd guess Pope Francis like this? It suggests we have already predefined he is either ignorant or malicious in approach.
    I don't have any good reason to believe he is either so I have assumed he has good reason to believe what you fear will not come to pass. And such a heart will lead us to find commentary on the Net to advise us why it is likely different this time.
     
  14. MarysChild

    MarysChild Principalities

    I was actually in favor of the annulment reforms before hearing that they had been tried before. The fact that they have been tried before and, by most accounts, failed, gives me pause though. I'm not against Pope Francis, but he certainly does know how to make me uncomfortable, with things like appointing Bishops Bonny, Danneels, Kasper, etc. to the Synod.

    Then again, I trust the Holy Spirit....at worst case, we've got a bad Pope, but the Church has had worse Popes and made it through. At best case, Pope Francis has some kind of gambit up his sleeve that I cannot follow.
     
    Blue Horizon and Krizevac like this.
  15. Basto

    Basto Guest

    There are people here confusing Demon Pazuzu with the Holy Spirit (what an offense to the Third Person of the Holy Trinity) and that’s very dangerous. There is only a way of dealing with this kind of demons, through pray and penance. Ask Saint John the Baptist, Saint John Fisher and Saint Thomas More to help you, otherwise you end up going for (Saint?) Kasperite and his “serene theology”.



    Romans, 16

    17 I urge you, brothers, be on your guard against the people who are out to stir up disagreements and bring up difficulties against the teaching which you learnt. Avoid them.18 People of that sort are servants not of our Lord Christ, but of their own greed; and with talk that sounds smooth and reasonable they deceive the minds of the unwary.19 Your obedience has become known to everyone, and I am very pleased with you for it; but I should want you to be learned only in what is good, and unsophisticated about all that is evil. God of peace will soon crush Satan under your feet. The grace of our Lord Jesus Christ be with you.

    [​IMG]
    Rembrandt, 1627
     
  16. padraig

    padraig Powers

  17. Aviso

    Aviso Guest

  18. Mac

    Mac "To Jesus, through Mary"

    Praetorian likes this.
  19. padraig

    padraig Powers

    :D:D
    There might be no one left standing.

    Sorry couldn't resist.
     
    Mac, fallen saint and Praetorian like this.
  20. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page