THE SYNOD 2015

Discussion in 'The Signs of the Times' started by Blue Horizon, Aug 4, 2015.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. miker

    miker Powers

    So wait it dangerous to question a video produced by some Polish group that I've never heard of before but it's ok for others to question the Holy Father.? You prove my point then, the rhetorical question on this extremely serious matter that many here are saying could lead to schism is at best poor judgement and at worst designed to position their perspective. As with other posts here, I'm fine with whatever position you want to take, but can we at least be intellectually honest and state your position clearly. The rhetorical question is merely Imo a cowardly way to say the Pope is leading us into this crisis. Very similarly to the cowardly Pentin article saying the synod is rigged. Again, rigged by who? The inferences are quite clear. It's time for people to clearly state positions rather than these passive aggressive innuendos. Have a peaceful night.
     
    Last edited: Sep 12, 2015
    Blue Horizon likes this.
  2. Joe Crozier

    Joe Crozier Guest

    Hi Fallen Saint
    I have been through the whole divorce/annulment process ratified by two tribunals and an Italian Canon Lawyer associated with Rota. I also submitted all my evidence to traditionalist priests and a traditional cardinal for consideration after my annulment had been granted knowing that they would be hardest on me and I could be sure of its validity. I never wanted to be divorced but the church would not consider annulment until I was divorced. If the law of God over-rides the law of man the Church should have given primary consideration to the sacrament rather than the legal document. I felt I was forced to go through a divorce first so that my status could be ratified. My case would not even have been considered until I had a decree nisi. When Thomas more was asked his attitude to earthly power he said he was "The king's good servant but God's first." In my experience I felt this principle lost out to expediency. If the church had examined my circumstances and decided an annulment was not possible I would never have gone through with a divorce. You can't imagine the pain of divorce FS. Jesus tells us that God hates it and so do I. The only ground for my divorce was irreconcilable differences. This of course is not grounds for annulment but it was given primary consideration by the church insofar as they would not proceed without it. It may be that this aspect of the annulment process will still not be revisited but I am happy the rest is being given attention. My heart goes out to those facing this ordeal and if the way can be made easier without compromise of the truth then it has to be a good thing. I am sure, from His own words, that God does not want us to be over-burdened with bureaucracy. I love my church and I love women and am free to marry again in the Church it but I am no spring chicken and getting set in my ways and will probably follow St Paul's suggestion that it's best to stay single. I have never been confused - just conflicted. For the record, I am almost positive God will not send me to hell. The "almost" keeps me humble and I am certain he will have mercy on my soul. I have the nine first Fridays and the five first Saturdays behind that conviction and I always carry my Garabandal relics with me. Our Lady promised that those who carried the objects kissed by Her at Garabandal would do their purgatory on earth. I feel I am doing mine. And that's fine. May God bless you abundantly and may He also have mercy on your soul.
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Sep 12, 2015
  3. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    We obviously disagree on the nature of Pentin's article. Frankly I have a hard time giving any credibility whatsoever to someone who attacks Pentin in such a manner.

    Pentin and these prelates are not alone in their general or specific concerns.


    Pope Attacked Over Motu Proprio; Cardinal Kasper Reasserts His Proposal
    Excerpt:
    "The dossier, which speaks of “unsettling developments”, argues that Francis “circumvented” the regulated process for changing legislation for the universal Church. Instead, the papal commission that drafted the motu proprio had been ordered to keep silent throughout the drafting process, probably to avoid the reforms being thwarted by the CDF and others in the curia.

    "The Register has learned via other sources that this decision and others are effectively isolating the CDF and that the Pope is steadily making their work superfluous.

    The report also voices concern that the motu proprio will lead to a flood of annulments and that from now on, couples would be able to simply exit their Catholic marriage without a problem."​
    Read more: http://www.ncregister.com/blog/edwa...-kasper-reasserts-his-proposal/#ixzz3lTlGQtCz
     
  4. miker

    miker Powers


    Why is it hard Brian? I'm not saying he is wrong or right. I think I'm asking a fair question. If something is rigged , it generally is done with either the full or tacit consent of the person who benefits from the rigging. Right? Or is he saying, no, this is a group of independents who are trying to sway the outcome? If the latter us what he thinks, then I would say the word "rigged" is a poor choice.

    And btw, I have no problem or question with your credibility. I'm sorry that you have a problem mine.

    Have a good evening and may the peace if Christ be with your spirit.
     
  5. kathy k

    kathy k Guest

    I was praying with scripture today, and this is what I read. May this teaching resonate in our hearts!
     
    josephite likes this.
  6. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    Your use of the word "cowardly" towards the prelates and journalists trying to warn the Faithful of the agendas going into this synod is offensive and uncalled for. Those defending the Faith are not cowards.

    At this point no one can prove who is ultimately behind the obvious synod agenda, so to keep insisting that others make conjectures in that regard is wrongheaded and to label their attempts to defend the Faith in the meantime as passive aggressive is offensive.
     
  7. miker

    miker Powers

    Peace to you Brian.
     
  8. josephite

    josephite Powers

    God is not changeable.

    God Is, Was and always Will be.

    God The Blessed Trinity is Holy, Omnipotent and Immortal and He is the same Yesterday, Today and Always.

    Gods Mercy and for that matter His Justice, does not change.

    We know that the Church teachings have become clearer as time progresses, this is the action of the Holy Spirit within the Church.

    Take for example the Doctrine of Our Lady's Immaculate Conception, which was made a dogma of the church in 1854, this does not mean, however, that before 1854, Mary was not the Immaculate Conception. Its just that the Church was inspired by the Holy Spirit at that time of this great truth.

    God's Mercy does not change.

    We are only men, with mans knowledge and can only know a small part while here on earth but all will be revealed when we are in Heaven.
     
    Last edited: Sep 14, 2015
    PotatoSack and kathy k like this.
  9. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    Et cum spiritu tuo.
     
    miker likes this.
  10. Joe Crozier

    Joe Crozier Guest

    Et cum spiritu all of us :)
     
    miker and BrianK like this.
  11. Mario

    Mario Powers

    Yes, Brian, it was rhetorical for sure!

    Safe in the Barque of Peter!
     
  12. kathy k

    kathy k Guest

    My question is this: who has time for rhetorical questions in the midst of this great spiritual battle? Let's hit our knees and rattle those beads!!!
     
    PotatoSack and miker like this.
  13. fallen saint

    fallen saint Baby steps :)

    Aloysius,

    You did everything right...by knowing what the church asked, you were obedient. That is a wonderful grace. Some people are not as advanced spiritually to understand all the rules and ramifications. In your heart and your correct intent, you have followed the rules of the church...which is the rules of God. Basto was saying how come in todays world divorced couples would get a pass...but those that lived 50 years ago wouldn't. My response was God is Perfect Justice and will decide accordingly. The moment we pass, God will judge us. Even if we broke rules of the church...there are interior motives (knowledge, intent, ones heart) that only God can Judge. I guess the big issue is that the more God has blessed you...the more that is expected from you. But even before that...one has to accept the blessings.

    These conversation are really complicated but at the end of the day God will judge.

    May God Bless you and your family.

    Brother al

    The closer we get to God...the little sins of everyday life become greater.

     
    PotatoSack, miker and Joe Crozier like this.
  14. Joe Crozier

    Joe Crozier Guest

    In the world of nature there is no such thing as poison. The only thing that makes a substance poison is the dose. In the world of martial arts true masters do not think about their next move, it is part of the master's nature and is expressed as such without thinking. Time can be a poison in battle so it must be used in the appropriate dose and form to avoid this presentation. In the realm of Spirit rhetorical questions are the food of the soul. They are asked in the face of mystery during prayer and meditation which is of course a form of prayer. Through, with and in the response to these questions our spirits live and move and have our being, the true Nature to which we aspire which is Eternal. But without the rhetorical question, which does not expect an answer, there is no starting point and therefore no progress. Without questioning mystery in this way we cannot be open to The Truth and so the battle can never be won. But with God all things are possible. Rhetorical questions run through the fields of battle and lead us to victory. When we say Maranatha we are not commanding Gods presence but humbly asking if He will grace us with His Love if He will accept our surrender. We do not need an answer to this because we already know, in faith, the answer. And thus we know the next move which is always closer to Him. And that is the best place to be in battle. So in my ever so humble opinion:rolleyes: we better keep those rhetorical questions going.
    (And no I have not been on the whakky baccy)
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Sep 12, 2015
    BrianK likes this.
  15. fallen saint

    fallen saint Baby steps :)

    :)

    That post will take years to fully comprehend but that is the beauty of contemplation.

    Brother al

     
  16. kathy k

    kathy k Guest

    Soldiers in battle who distract themselves with rhetorical questions are sitting ducks!
     
  17. Joe Crozier

    Joe Crozier Guest

    In a way I was actually agreeing with you Kathy. There is no better way to contemplate and question mystery than the rosary. Its like loading your gun or sharpening your sword. The bullets and the blade stay with you through the battle but they don't require thought. They don't require an answer. Neither do they distract. They empower the soldier but every time they strike flesh bone or metal they are tested....they ask a question... how strong was the blow, how well placed etc etc. In fact we have been told that when things are at their worst the rosary will be our only weapon. It's ok Kathy I know what I am saying. But I am not saying that I know. I believe the time for that is yet to come. I understand what you are saying. As for sitting ducks. They would definitely distract me. Now do I like Peking duck or canard a l'orange best. By the time i got the answer to that I wouldn't need food:ROFLMAO: St Michael would be dragging me through the gates and asking why i hadn't listened to Kathy and kept my mind on the job.
     
    josephite likes this.
  18. Blue Horizon

    Blue Horizon Guest

    That handsome Saruman guy gets around Mac.
     
  19. Blue Horizon

    Blue Horizon Guest

    Thats what I was thinking too Aviso.
     
  20. Blue Horizon

    Blue Horizon Guest

    Lets keep things in perspective P.
    We are talking about the Synod - not the end of time.
    I wasn't aware the CCC meant any more than that?
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page