THE SYNOD 2015

Discussion in 'The Signs of the Times' started by Blue Horizon, Aug 4, 2015.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Mac

    Mac "To Jesus, through Mary"

    [​IMG]
     
    BrianK likes this.
  2. little me

    little me Archangels

    Misery!!?? Seriously, BH, stop looking for negativity under every bush.
    What, in my post, exhibited misery?
    I was married at 23 and have now been married for 14 years. Did I understand marriage back then? No way! Did I lack faith? Oh yeah. Marriage cannot possibly be understood by being taught about it out of a book or even by spectating it. My point is/was that your faith GROWS in a marriage and most all people lack FULL faith when they get married, especially at a young age. Is my marriage, then, invalid? Not a chance.
     
    Last edited: Sep 11, 2015
    Mac, Praetorian and miker like this.
  3. davidtlig

    davidtlig Guest

    Well, Mac, someone has to present some kind of response to balance the traditionalist propaganda on this thread..:)
     
    Mac likes this.
  4. Mac

    Mac "To Jesus, through Mary"

    Balance is always good . I think?...[​IMG]
     
    Praetorian likes this.
  5. Blue Horizon

    Blue Horizon Guest

    Pope Francis finds a solution to a particular pastoral problem well recognised even by Cardinal Ratzinger in 1990...and instead of rejoicing or attempting to understand the history of the issue all you can say is "don't we all lack faith." Sheeez.
     
  6. Blue Horizon

    Blue Horizon Guest

    Balance Mac brings ... thinks he!
    [​IMG]
     
  7. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    Though I am one, I hate the term "Traditionalist", I like the old name we used to have, "Catholic". :)
     
  8. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    This was an excellent video. A very concise examination of where the Church is at this point in history. I didn't find it very traditionalist at all, pretty mainstream for a Polish production I think. This could be shown at any Church in Poland and they would most likely nod in agreement. Poland is one of the few countries where the faith hasn't been watered down as in other countries. The faith still plays an important part in peoples daily lives and politics. They are one of the last nations with laws against abortion, etc.

    There were some amazing lines in the film too. Cardinal Burke referring to the synod as "Cardinals opposing Cardinals" hearkening back to the message of Akita. I am sure this was not an accident.

    I hadn't realized Cardinal Marx of Germany had outright declared "We (the German Church) are not a branch of Rome." Defacto schism.
     
    Mac likes this.
  9. Andy3

    Andy3 Powers

    I really feel there are no winners in this process. No matter what the church decides it will upset many. I truly believe that many marriages since at least 1980, at least in the US are not valid marriages in the sense that both parties truly were committed to the faith and to the full understanding of the covenant they were making with God. I say this because look at the state of the church in the US since that time. It was sacramentalized but poorly catechized. I attended Catholic school but never truly knew the faith until just these past 3 years because I sought it out (by the grace of God who called me back). So the question I have, is this a problem with the individuals who got married or with the church who let them get married. The marriage industry in the US is big business and those who get married pretty much are looking towards the party and honeymoon versus the love and union with and before God. Do the many couples even pay attention to what is taking place during the service. How many were living in sin at the time of their marriage. How many went to confession before they got married. I know I did not. The priests who speak to couples before getting married should require so much more in my opinion. They should be tougher and be willing to say no to couples seeking marriage if they don't show a good understanding of their faith. Confession should be a requirement with the priest marrying the couple in my opinion. I still fell that many many marriages were never true marriages but that is just how I feel on the issue after going to many weddings myself and knowing many of the couples and their lifestyles. How could a marriage be valid if the couple was living together as husband and wife long prior to going down the aisle if they never confessed of their sins and came to their wedding clean from mortal sin. If one is in mortal sin on their wedding day how could their wedding be valid especially if they took communion in the state of mortal sin. Now maybe they did not know they were in this state and thus the dilemma of knowing the faith and commitment to God prior to getting married.
     
    Jonah, carpediemptf and MMM like this.
  10. CrewDog

    CrewDog Guest

    I'd like to think that the "Choice" the above ???? individual is displaying is "I choose life!!" I'm guessing it's not:mad:
    In fact that's a good way to really annoy the "Choice" Gang. Tell them when they ask: "Why Yes!! I'm pro-choice, "I CHOOSE LIFE!!!"

    GOD SAVE ALL HERE!!
     
    Mac and Andy3 like this.
  11. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    This is not the "traditionalist" position, it is the orthodox position. It's counterpart is the heterodox position.

    As such the orthodox position is not flawed, though many will attempt to call it such in the current Storm.
     
    Mario and Praetorian like this.
  12. MMM

    MMM Guest

    This reminds me of Jesus's Worker's in the Vinyard parable.

    Maybe it is the 6th, 9th or even the 11th hour and so Jesus has empowered His earthly servant to hire these late day workers and pay them the same wage as those who started at 9AM. Those that have been faithful all along are certainly going to be upset at divorced/remarried that get equal payment by a simpler way to rejoin the church fully. Not to mention how upset they may be at the foreman (I see as the pope) and the owner of the vineyard (I see as Jesus) for not giving them more or making it much easier for some to get into heaven even last minute. In this case mercy, forgiveness, reaccess to the sacrements in a way that just doesn't seem fair to those who stayed strong in faith longer term. Does God through His Pope not have the right to do these things to save souls? As Jesus stated " Are you envious because I am generous?"
     
  13. davidtlig

    davidtlig Guest

    It is certainly the position of many Catholics and was probably still my position 20 years ago. But I would now simply describe it as 'lacking', not flawed.
     
  14. Mac

    Mac "To Jesus, through Mary"

    [​IMG]Your moment will come soon enough BH.
     
  15. miker

    miker Powers

    I think you have raised a great point and question that has not yet been addressed. As you pointed out the video starts with correct statement that Church has faced many crises over its 2000 year history and survived. It's very revealing to me that the producers of this video then ask "will it survive this time". To me this demonstrates a lack of faith or understanding of Scripture which as we know says the Church will survive until Christ comes again. Since these are intelligent people, I must assume they know this, so it then leads to their using this statement to simply so discord.
     
  16. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    It is true that the Church will survive, but I think they mean "make it through the crisis in viable condition". There are many prophecies and even the CCC which states that the Church will "be put through a final trial" and will become so devastated it will appear to be wiped out. This final trial will be different from all of the others which the Church has made it through well enough in the end.
     
  17. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    Which is a very dangerous error on your part as well as other members here. The video's producers asked a rhetorical question, one not to be taken literally, yet you use it as a springboard to criticize them.
     
  18. miker

    miker Powers

    Not doubt there will be the final trial and the CCC says just as Christ did, the Church must endure it's passion as well. I personally do not see this happening at this point, but as Christ said, only the Father knows the hour when the end will come.
     
    josephite and Praetorian like this.
  19. Basto

    Basto Guest

    When we talk about marriage and family, we need a clear position from the Church coming out of this Synod, I suppose everybody agrees with that, two years of confusion are enough. But if the so called traditionalist faction is defeated because their conception of sin is too old (about 2000 years, by the way) and the new ideas from the merciful party become approved, how do we rescue the poor souls of those who died in mortal sin before 2015?

    This might be a silly question but we are not talking about a certain kind of little faults that can be purged with a few weeks marinating in the purgatory, we’re actually talking about an unmistakable mortal sin that led many people to hell during the centuries before these “beautiful” times of mercy. Is the devil becoming merciful as well and let you come back after a while toasting? Or are we about to abolish also that old fashion idea of hell as an eternal damnation? Just think about it…

    [​IMG]
    Anonymous artist, 16th century, Museu Nacional de Arte Antiga, Lisboa
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Sep 12, 2015
    Praetorian and little me like this.
  20. fallen saint

    fallen saint Baby steps :)

    Basto,

    The great question mark is intent/ones heart. We will never know who goes to hell and who does not. Not even the Church can tell us that...the church can lead us but each sinner is different. God is a perfect judge with perfect justice. He judges each soul uniquely therefore the church might guide but divine judgement is not up to us.

    Bottom line one should never divorce, but if you do, may God have mercy on your soul.

    Brother al

    Note: that is why its so difficult to declare sainthood...because one can only be judged by God.


     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page