THE SYNOD 2015

Discussion in 'The Signs of the Times' started by Blue Horizon, Aug 4, 2015.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Infant Jesus of Prague

    Infant Jesus of Prague The More you Honor Me The More I will Bless Thee

    As a friend told me, they paid 800 bucks and waited 2years for the Church to say your marriage is annulled....
    I have NO worries of the Church teaching in the future... same same

    by same same ...I do mean it will be in Harmony with Christs teaching
     
  2. Basto

    Basto Guest

    Aviso[/quote]

    I don’t know what to think about this…

    In my understanding, in this Year of Mercy, the Church should be more concerned about making it easier the annulments of many marriage annulments. Did I make sense? We need a Church promoting the reunification of the couples.

    As far as I know, the marriage annulment can only be used in some very restricted situations where there is no single doubt, however small, about the conditions for its application. The number of cases should be so small that wouldn’t need any of this worry. However everybody knows, sometimes by witnessing cases happening with our own relatives or friends, that this procedure has been abusively used in many situations. Some couples take this canonical procedure to get actually divorced without being. Sometimes, to make sure that this clean divorce is approved, they bring up false statements, juggling or even slander. Well, we can cheat the priest but not God.

    In these cases, the marriage annulment is much worse than a divorce, a secure gateway to hell. These are the people who most need “easier procedures” to get back to their sacramental marriage in communion with God. That’s not complicated to understand but it’s quite a heavy cross to carry. With the grace of God nothing is impossible.

    So why does His Holiness bring up that? I don’t know, maybe “because of your [our] hardness of heart”.
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Sep 9, 2015
  3. Blue Horizon

    Blue Horizon Guest

    Pope Francis's New Criteria for Judging when a Marriage is invalid:
    "In his attached “procedural rules,” Francis gives examples of when a bishop might be able to decide an annulment on his own authority...included in those examples:
    (a) when there was a clear lacking of faith on the part of one of the persons consenting to the marriage
    (b) when one person was in another undisclosed relationship at the time of marriage
    (c) when one party procured an abortion."

    http://vaticaninsider.lastampa.it/en/the-vatican/detail/articolo/francesco-francis-francisco-43223/

    This is ground-breaking for remarried Catholics who are faithful to the Church in every other aspect of their lives but have been failed by current Marriage Tribunal rigidities/technicalities which would not take things like the above into account.

    This will allow them to regularise a co-habitation which they have always felt was not adultery because they (rightly) believed their first "marriage" fairly clearly never was.

    Obviously this is not a denial of the indissolubility of marriage.
    Nor is it an arbitrary judgement as objective evidence will be required.
    Surely we can all be happy and realise our fears are unjustified re conspiracies of a heretical Pope Francis and Synod 2015?

    The "lack of faith" criterion is very theologically interesting. To date it was held that the mere fact of baptism was all that was needed to transform a natural marriage into an indissoluble sacramental bond.

    Prophecy Fulfilled!
    Forgive me the vanity of observing my "prophecy" of 6/8/2015 here on MOG appears today fulfilled:
    "I would "prophesy" that in not too long ... (4) Those Catholics who married together validly but did not actually believe... we're not sacramentally married. This marriage can therefore be dissolved at a later time." http://motheofgod.com/threads/the-synod-2015.7762/page-3#post-94912

    Mind you, this was a possibility Cardinal Ratzinger suggested back in 1990 in a little known publication. He suggested other aids for helping those let down by Marriage Tribunals as well...these may be worth discussing further as some of the Synod Fathers (yes including Cardinal Kasper) seem to be doing.
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Sep 9, 2015
    davidtlig and Joe Crozier like this.
  4. little me

    little me Archangels

    "(a) when there was a clear lacking of faith on the part of one of the persons consenting to the marriage"
    Well, this can apply to everyone and anyone who has ever been married. Don't we all lack faith?
     
    Praetorian likes this.
  5. Blue Horizon

    Blue Horizon Guest

    Sometimes the world is dark because we're wearing dark glasses.

    We all know what is meant here LM.
    This new Canon has not dropped from a theologically clear blue sky but has a history.
    The history began with Cardinal Ratzinger around 1990. Even in 2005 he publicly stated the following:

    "Another priest raised the topic of Communion for the faithful who are divorced and remarried. The Holy Father answered him as follows:
    We all know that this is a particularly painful problem for people who live in situations in which they are excluded from Eucharistic Communion, and naturally for the priests who desire to help these people love the Church and love Christ. This is a problem.


    None of us has a ready-made formula, also because situations always differ. I would say that those who were married in the Church for the sake of tradition but were not truly believers, and who later find themselves in a new and invalid marriage and subsequently convert, discover faith and feel excluded from the Sacrament, are in a particularly painful situation. This really is a cause of great suffering and when I was Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, I invited various Bishops' Conferences and experts to study this problem: a sacrament celebrated without faith. Whether, in fact, a moment of invalidity could be discovered here because the Sacrament was found to be lacking a fundamental dimension, I do not dare to say. I personally thought so, but from the discussions we had I realized that it is a highly-complex problem and ought to be studied further. But given these people's painful plight, it must be studied further. "

    https://w2.vatican.va/content/bened...ts/hf_ben-xvi_spe_20050725_diocesi-aosta.html

    Well...the call was taken up by Pope Francis who had an expert panel study this issue just as Pope Benedict suggested. And now at last we have the fruit of it, thanks be to God!
    But for you this seems to be a cause of misery rather than joy (esp for the persons Pope Benedict describes above). Lets not be curmudgeons :) .

    " Is it not lawful for me to do what I wish with what is my own? Or is your eye envious because I am generous?' "So the last shall be first, and the first last." "
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Sep 9, 2015
    Mario likes this.
  6. Aviso

    Aviso Guest

     
    Mac, Basto and BrianK like this.
  7. Blue Horizon

    Blue Horizon Guest

    Aviso I would take these sort of Chicken-Lichen videos with a grain of (Epsom) salt.

    The first few minutes, for me, made clear the emotionally and intellectually conflicted nature of the clip.
    "The Church has experienced more than one big crisis in its history,
    For 2000 years the Church has been lashed by numerous gales but has always overcome difficulties, conspiracies and betrayals."


    Yes, perfectly true, that is why we believe the Holy Spirit is with Peter and the Church and we should not worry about the 2015 Synod.
    Yet this allegedly Catholic author goes on to ask: "Will it be the same this time?"

    If you accept the first then why ask the rhetorical question?
    Its simply nonsensical and seems less than honest fear-mongering.

    Lots of strawmen raised and (rightly) condemned.
    Unfortunately these irrelevent strawmen are not what the Synod is being asked to consider from what I can see.

    Really, its about the irrational fears of the clip's author than what is actually happening at the moment.
    There is no move to attack the indissolubility of marriage on the part of Cardinal Kasper or Pope Francis.
    Lets get a grip people.
     
  8. Aviso

    Aviso Guest

    Cardinal Burke had grave reservations on the same annulment proposals Pope Francis just enshrined :

    “In the present moment when the attacks on matrimony and on the family even within the Church seem the most ferocious,” he said, “it is the Church who must show to the whole of society the truth in all its richness and thus the beauty and the richness of the truth about marriage.”

    “The Synod Fathers and all faithful Christians must be willing to suffer,” he added, “to honor and foster Holy matrimony.”

    He warned that “confusion and error on holy matrimony” are being “sown by Satan in society and in the Church.” Marriage, he said is “under a ferocious and diabolical attack.”

    Read more :
    https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/c...rvations-on-the-same-annulment-proposals-pope


    Aviso
     
  9. Basto

    Basto Guest

    This could be the background picture displayed on the wall of the room where the October’s Synod is going to be. Everybody likes Caravaggio, but I don't think so... I don’t know what’s wrong with this picture, it just doesn’t match, does it?

    [​IMG]
     
    Mac likes this.
  10. miker

    miker Powers

    I certainly respect this Cardinal and for that matter any Cardinal expressing their thoughts and concerns. I hope this can be done in a way that leads to the right result and respects all, including the charism of the Papacy. Not that Cardinal Burke has control over what others say and do, but please take a few moments to read some of the comments made to the article. I've copied in a few below and again are these representative of all "traditionalists" or "conservatives"? I don't know. But, these comments are IMO very egregious and at a minimum disrespectful of not just the Pope as a Man, but also his office. So, while I don't question that Cardinal Burke can dissent and have a strongly held position, I question the wisdom of going and being public in this criticism. And to be fair and not a hypocrite, I disagree and place at the feet of a Cardinal Kaspar the same criticism of going public. My mother used to say, we fight as a family behind closed doors but to the outside world, we show unity. It's ashame and perhaps the sin of pride to air this out publically. Here are comments that I think are awful and quite frankly have been ignited a bit by the public airing of disagreements:

    "This man Jorge Bergoglio occupying the office of Pope of the Catholic Church is proving to be dishonest, as well as everything else problematic about his papacy."

    "Two things here: 1) Cardinal Burke speaks the truth, and, 2) We won't have to wait for the upcoming Synod to know that there will be a schism; it's already here! God help us!"

    "God bless Cardinal Burke for standing up for Traditional Catholic doctrine and morality, Burke should be Pope!"

    "Can't wait for the Pope's visit to Philly where he can deliver more of, oh let's call it something today's world understands, where he can celebrate sustainable families and marriage justice, global unions and the ecology of love. Don't know what I'm talking about? Eh, eh. This is Churchspeak, 2015."

    These being said about the validly elected Supreme Pontiff! Troubling indeed
     
  11. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    Miker, I agree with you that a sitting pontiff should be shown all respect possible even by those who disagree with his decisions. I especially didn't care for #1 which seems to imply he isn't even Pope by discarding his Papal name. Can I ask you though where they came from? From the way your post was worded it looked like they were part of the article Aviso cited, but I went to the link and did not see them.
     
  12. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    There are a lot of good comments below that article besides the selected ones above that seem negative. Click the blue bar at the bottom of the article that has the quote balloon emblem on it to read comments
    https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/c...rvations-on-the-same-annulment-proposals-pope
     
  13. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    BrianK likes this.
  14. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    Having looked closer at the article comments now, it seems the ones you posted are in the minority. There will always be people posting outrageous things, especially on an anonymous forum. I would definitely not say this is how all traditionalists feel, I consider myself one, but there is a vein of it in the community.

    I think the schism comment you cited is right on, not that I am encouraging schism. The Church is fractured now in more than one way. Some cracks are bigger than others. On the "right" we have the sedevacantists, SSPX, African and Eastern Churches, and assorted priests littered throughout the Church. On the "left" you have the German block and other Northern European countries, along with another littering of priests throughout the Church. It is a mess. In the words of Pope Paul VI, the church is committing an "auto-demolotion" of itself.

    Unfortunately I think it is going to come into the open no matter what the Pope decides. If he maintains things as they are the Germans and company may break with Rome. If he changes things he may lose the Poles and Eastern Churches. Both factions have more than hinted at this, though the threat of using the word "schism" wasn't used in the open to my knowledge. This is a dangers acknowledged just last week by Cardinal Muller, head of the CDF.

    I have my own personal feelings about the Pope's decisions, but as the sitting Pontiff his post demands respect, so I do the best I can to give it to him. People may discuss his public proclamations, but it should be in a manner of decency and charity. He should be afforded all of the courtesy possible. I wouldn't want the job in a million years. he probably has ten million demons sitting on him all of the time. I am having enough trouble working out my own tiny salvation. It says in Philippians we are to "work out our salvation with fear and trembling". In these times that is more than just an idle quote.
     
    miker likes this.
  15. Blue Horizon

    Blue Horizon Guest

    OK lets cast a critical eye over this sensationalist headline from this somewhat tabloid website.

    1. Cardinal Burke was NOT here reacting to Pope Francis's recent changes to Canon Law on Marriage Tribunals.
    2. Cardinal Burke in this article does NOT appear to have said "I have grave reservations". Those are the words of the sensationalist reporter it seems.

    Lets move on folks, nothing new to see here (n)(n)(n).
    Our more anxious members need to get a grip please.
     
  16. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    Does anyone know if Cardinals Burke, Pell and the other conservatives who were at the synod last year are going to be there this year? I forget the names of the others but there was a small group of 5 or so who were the main defenders of current Church teaching. It was my understanding they played a pivotal role in putting the brakes on some of the more radical ideas.

    I found a list of attendees, but I didn't see them listed.

    https://www.futurechurch.org/justic...015/2015-family-synod-delegates-and-attendees
     
  17. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    I see Auxiliary Bishop Athanasius Schneider and Cardinal Napier on the list, but no Cardinal Muller
     
  18. I believe that Cardinal Burke holding the current position that he does is not automatically included in this upcoming Synod as in 2014. He now needs to be personally invited by the Pope to attend and with statements rather early on in this Pope's time in office by C. Burke that the Church is "rudderless" under him one could have reason to doubt that endorsement!
     
  19. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    This is one of the most important videos regarding the Synod produced till this date. It is well worth watching.
     
    Praetorian and Mac like this.
  20. davidtlig

    davidtlig Guest

    The video is certainly an excellent presentation of the 'traditionalist' position. There is no doubt that the Church has many problems but the traditionalist position is fundamentally flawed because it ignores, or downplays, the teaching leadership and authority of the Pope and it also ignores (or even denies!) the biggest rescue plan (or one of the biggest) from God for our age - the coming of Our Lady in an overwhelmingly powerful way in Medjugorje for the past 30 years.
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page