Medjugorje message Oct 25th

Discussion in 'Marian Apparitions' started by PotatoSack, Oct 27, 2014.

  1. ZMWT

    ZMWT New Member


    You have compared my explanation to a wrong reference in the Bible.

    My first reference is Revelation 16.16. I would like to read your analysis of the Croatian and Hebrew words as a comparison. So you don't offer any explanation for that verse?

    All right then. So let us now come to your Bible quote, Luke 11:15. It is true that both God himself and devil himself can perform acts that to us look like miracles. Their abilities are beyond our mind and skills. But then, we may be confused, as to who does what: it is that devil deceiving us, of God indeed healing us?

    One principle is crucial: devil can deceive, and God cannot. In the Bible, Jesus did many miracles, but in addition to that, all his other acts and teachings were impeccable. He was whole truth and nothing but truth. Christians and apostles followed Jesus because of his teachings and moral example, not because of his miracles. In other words, his miracles confirmed the truth of his words and acts.

    He was prophesied truth by the prophets of old, he was embodied truth, and he died for truth.

    That is the path Church follows. In case of faith and probable apparitions, miracles may support the truth, but they are not proving it. It is the whole context that matters — the context of truth. For example in Fatima in Portugal in 1917, the miracle of the sun was outstanding, but the truth of the messages and all tiny details about morals and doctrine of the Church were examined in great details, and only then it was approved.

    Apply the same principle to Medjugorje; if the so called apparition of Medjugorje were true and genuinely good, it would be morally and doctrinally impeccable in all its facets, from day one till now. No one would have any doubts. That apparition and all about it would uphold all truths Church stood for all these centuries.

    But it is not, as it was pointed out by bishops of Jugoslavia, even in mid-1980s. It is not supernatural (it is not from Heaven), and that was their very clear declaration about Medjugorje. That was their first warning.

    Now I only offer you more food for thought. I also tell you now, that the word Har-Magedo describes the shape of the temple in Medjugorje too, not only the name of the geographic place (see my other post here). So the word has two references at least. Third is the meaning of the word Podbrdo, which, conspicuously, also has Har and Magedo meanings in itself.

    Grab your dictionaries, open your Bibles. Study words, study the meaning.
    And think.
     
  2. Fatima

    Fatima Powers

    ZMWT, are you that much smarter then St. John Paul II and Blessed Mother Teresa of Calcutta who supported Medjugorje? Sometimes I wonder how a few people can claim something our saints in heaven could not. You can argue your points which ever way you want to spin your views, but I for one am not buying it. I will stick with the saints of our time who have supported the fruits of Medjugorje.
     
    Last edited: Nov 29, 2014
  3. Jon

    Jon Archangels

    I don't know many details about Medjugorje, as I never felt called to follow it. Therefore, I don't presume to make any informed discernment myself about it. However, I would think a discussion could be had in this regard without anger or belittlement of those that may want to have that discussion.

    At the same time, those that promote a negative discernment conclusion, personally, should be just as charitable in communicating or discussing.

    I would imagine articles like the following one could be found regarding most apparitions that still await church approval, or condemnation (and I guess I have never been a big fan of Catholic Herald publications). Nonetheless, it still represents a non-inflammatory way to discuss merits, fruits, etc. :

    http://www.catholicherald.co.uk/com...ating-what-the-devil-loves-most-disobedience/
     
    little me and Lily like this.
  4. Jon

    Jon Archangels

    I think Mark Mallet's published material has not been updated to include the 10/21/13 ban of public activities of the seers in the USA. Here is a portion of Mark's published statement:

    "THE VISIONARIES

    The Vatican, having taken authority over the apparitions, has not asked the visionaries to cease their activities. Thus, the visionaries are not in disobedience (their current bishop wants the manifestations and messages stopped immediately.)
    "

    http://www.markmallett.com/blog/medjugorje-just-the-facts-maam/


    As of October, 2013, the Vatican did ban the visionaries in the USA from public activities related to the apparitions (told them to cease in obedience to the bishop's 1991 declaration):

    [​IMG]
     
    little me likes this.
  5. lynnfiat

    lynnfiat Fiat Voluntas Tua

    How very sad for Our Blessed Mother that people do not believe that She is appearing in Medjugorje. We must judge by the fruits and there are so many that it is incredible - conversions, healings, and many many vocations. I happened to have been in Medjugorje during the war, and I can tell you for certain that Our Lady is appearing there, although for those who do not believe, anything I say could not convince you. Perhaps you should take a trip there and receive the Graces that so many have received for being there. I am so sorry you do not believe! It makes me so sad!
     
    hope and Fatima like this.

Share This Page