For your discernment. About the BIG, permanent SIGN: 26.7.1981 My sweet angels, even if I were to leave the sign, many people will not believe. 27.7.1981 Then we questioned her on the subject of the sign, and the Gospa answered: Await, it will not be for long. If I will leave you a sign, I will still appear to you. 27.8.1981 We asked her with respect to the sign, and she said:Very soon, I promise you. 4.9.1981 To Ivan in the seminary:The sign will be given at the endofthe apparitions. 7.9.1981 Be converted all of you who are still there. The sign will come when you will be converted. 31.8.1982 The great sign has been granted. It will appear independently of the conversion of the people. 25.4.1983 Message received by Jelena, these last days: Be converted! It will be too late when the sign comes. Gospa will/will not appear after the sign. The sign will come before/after/independently the conversion. Which one of these alternatives she meant? Can’t she decide? Doesn’t she know what to do? She said also that the sign will come “soon”, “very soon, I promise”, “will not be long”. First she is not sure if she will leave the sign, later on she would etc. One more thing: 29.9.1981 How long will you stay with us? As long as you will want me to, my angels. – We’ve been taught that she will not appear after all 6 visionaries have received 10 secrets. Can you ever imagine that our Dear Mother, the Mother of Our Lord Jesus Christ wouldn’t know what to do and when! That she would contradict herself and give false promises! Never. Ever. (Source: http://www.medjugorje.eu/messages/. Click year 1981 and make a search. Thank you!)
Some of the messages above were taken from Ivan's diary and are personal to him. Remember the visionaries needed to undergo the process of conversion themselves, as in the early days of 1981 all was new to them. Some of the messages above were public messages for the world calling the world to conversion one last time. Then there is the difference between private apparitions and public apparitions. Our Lady's apparitions and messages of the 2nd and 25th are public apparitions (with messages) for the world. Other apparitions we might call private apparitions which three of the seers still receive daily. With regard to time - soon in heaven is relative - 1981 is actually not that long ago to even to some of us on the forum who were born well before that. We have had this discussion on the forum before with regard to time. A generation on earth is a blink in heaven. Our Lady calls this time the time of grace that is the time of conversion. The world has been warned and called back to God. Jesus revealed to St Faustina too that this is the time of Divine Mercy. But after this time of mercy comes Justice and Punishment. The first two secrets are 'warnings' to the world calling the world to repentance and preparing the world for the Permanent Sign which is the Third Secret of Medjugorje. This sign will be a confirmation that our Lady has indeed been appearing at Medjugorje & also a sign for unbelievers (but some will not even believe after the permanent sign). After the 3rd secret there will be little time for conversion because the remaining secrets are punishments for the the sins of the world. And conversion is a process that takes time on the most part so in a sense it will be too late to convert after the permanent sign unless one is given special graces of course. What this means effectively that the time for conversion is really until the permanent sign. After that comes tribulations with the tenth secrest being a particularly strong punishment for the world. From what you have posted above seems that after the Permanent sign our Lady will still appear to some of the visionaries (private) but may not be giving public (public apparitions) messages on the 2nd and the 25th. So the age of public messages may end with the 3rd secret.
I refer to my above post. It may be that our Lady will still continue to appear privately to the seers even after the secrets have begun. There is so much we don't know about the 'secrets' precisely because they are secrets. We know most about the Permanent Sign (which is the 3rd secret).
In the case of alleged apparitions of Medjugorje and other recognized apparitions are always the case of private apparitions. Public apparition would be if everyone present saw Our Lady, and this has never happened. So all this is in the church theological doctrine are considered as private apparitions, regardless of whether the message is for an individual or for the world. Greetings
True. I was trying to get across the difference between the apparitions that produce 'public' messages for the world (2nd for unbelievers & 25th for the 'world') and those everyday apparitions that three of the seers receive. So it is my clumsy language that is at fault.