Editor-in-Chief of Catholic Herald Resigns After Blasting 'Garbage' Synod, 'Feeble' Bishops and Scandal-Plagued Pope Francis The editor-in-chief of the Catholic Herald announced last week that he is parting ways with the weekly paper because he and “the new owners" “do not agree on the future direction of the company.” Damian Thompson made the announcement on Twitter following his recent hard-hitting appearance on EWTN's "The World Over" in which he made a number of highly critical remarks about the the Vatican's Amazon Synod working document (which he called "garbage"), the cowardly Catholic bishops of the United Kingdom and the United States, and the scandal-plagued pope who refuses to answer any questions about any the clerical abuse scandals currently rocking the Vatican. In a subsequent tweet, Thompson announced that he will be doing weekly podcasts for The Spectator, where he is an assistant editor. "This will be a truly dynamic religion podcast – I’m very excited about it," he wrote. In May of this year, former media mogul Conrad Black offloaded his 47.5 percent holding of the Catholic Herald in equal shares to ex-Tory MP Brooks Newmark and publisher William Cash, according to the Daily Mail. Luxury hotelier Rocco Forte reportedly owns the controlling interest in the weekly periodical. In his "first tweet as a free man," Thompson declared that the "corrupt pope" is "deeply implicated in terrible scandals." The next day, he added that the pope should be investigated. During his freewheeling interview with EWTN's Raymond Arroyo on June 27, Thompson didn't hold back in criticizing the bishops of England and Wales after their deafening silence during a recent abortion controversy in Great Britain. A British court last month ruled that a mentally challenged woman must be forced to have an abortion against her will and the religious beliefs of her family. While the controversy was raging, the Catholic Herald implored the bishops to speak out. On June 24, an appeals court in London overruled the lower court's shocking decision to force the woman to have an abortion -- but no thanks to the Catholic bishops who stayed mute throughout the ordeal. "All weekend, I waited for the Catholic bishops of England and Wales to say something ... and nothing was said," Thompson told Arroyo. "I sat there reading the Twitter feed of the Catholic Church of England and Wales and all weekend there were just sort of PC witterings on this and that subjects," he complained. The British journalist explained how the Catholic Herald had encouraged the bishops to speak up, "emphasizing how horrified Catholics were throughout the world." He said they finally got a feeble and unmemorable statement from auxiliary Bishop John Sherrington of the Diocese of Westminster condemning the "sad and distressing situation." To emphasize the impression the Bishop's weak statement made on the faithful, Thompson cited a colleague mocking the response on Twitter. Thompson pointed out that the tepid statement lacked "the righteous anger" one would expect in the face of such an outrageous injustice, noting that a non-Catholic neighbor had actually wept when she'd heard that a judge had sentenced an unborn baby to death. "If non-Catholics who aren't completely pro-life were that horrified, where was the horror from the English bishops?" Thompson asked plaintively. "And actually, where were the celebrations when this murder -- this execution -- was overruled by the Court of Appeals?" he added. Thompson complained that the bishops once again missed an opportunity to "rock the boat," and move the nation's needle to a more pro-life position. "The fact that our bishops [including U.S. Bishops] are not leading public opinion on this is a betrayal of their orders and a betrayal of their identity as Christians and their identity as shepherds," Thompson charged. Arroyo then asked the journalist for his opinion on Cardinal Walter Brandmüller's assessment of the controversial "working document" for the upcoming Amazon Synod, which is being held in Rome this October. In a scathing statement, the German cardinal wrote that the Synod must be rejected, calling it "heretical" and "in parts apostasy." The Vatican working document raises the possibility of ordaining married men in an effort to provide greater access to the sacraments in the remote areas of the Amazon. Thompson called Brandmüller's statement "incredibly powerful and well written," adding that he particularly appreciated Brandmüller's impression that the document seemed to view the forests of the Amazon region "as a special source of divine revelation." He then ridiculed the document, calling it "garbage" that reads like "a sort of PC Disney production like Avatar written by an octogenarian European socialist -- 'Tell us, oh wise ones, what the spirits of the forests are telling us!'" Thompson went on to condemn what he called the Vatican's "patronizing liberal sanctification of indigenous religion," singling out the document's main author Bishop Erwin Kräutler. Citing LifeSite News' Maike Hickson, Thompson noted incredulously that Kräutler has actually come out against criminalizing infanticide in indigenous cultures because “here, in the name of human rights and under the pretext of suppressing infanticide, a broad ethnocide, a cultural murder, is being installed.” "If that means anything, it means something very sinister," Thompson said. "To be using this bit of the world as a laboratory for religious experimentation beggars belief," he added later. "My personal message about the Amazon Synod is 'CANCEL IT NOW.'" Arroyo then moved on to a clerical abuse scandal that has roiled the Vatican all year involving Gustavo Zanchetta, the former bishop of Orán, Argentina. According to reports, Pope Francis helped Zanchetta find a top administrative job at the Holy See amid credible allegations of sexual misconduct against him. The Vatican has insisted that it never received any accusation of sexual abuse against Bishop Zanchetta until well after the pope created a job for him inside the dicastery of the Roman Curia. But former vicar general of Orán, Father Juan José Manzano, told the Associated Press in January that the Vatican had evidence of Zanchetta’s moral turpitude in 2015 — way before he resigned as bishop of Orán. Now, an Argentine judge has granted the accused sexual predator permission to leave the country and find refuge in Rome. "Why would the Vatican permit him to come into their midst?" Arroyo asked Thompson. (cont'd below)
(cont'd from above) "There are so many questions one could ask about a range of unsavory characters who seem to find sanctuary in the Vatican," the journalist lamented. "The case of Bishop Zanchetta, of course, is the most notorious of all of them." While he was the archbishop and cardinal of Buenos Aires, Argentina, Pope Francis faced numerous serious accusations of covering up priestly abuse, although he has insisted that sexual abuse never happened in his diocese. In one case, Francis (then-Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio) reportedly attempted to at first cover-up and then minimize a scandal involving a bishop who was caught en flagrante with a 23-year-old male chauffeur. Thompson described a conversation he'd recently had with an unnamed cardinal about the pope's involvement in a mounting number of cover-ups. "I said, 'these are cases in which really serious questions about decisions made by the Holy Father need to be answered and he's refusing to answer them,'" he told Arroyo, adding that it was the cardinal's responsibility to ask those questions. Thompson said that although the cardinal has not asked the questions and likely won't, "I did notice that he didn't put up a single word of defense of current advisers to the Holy Father, to put it diplomatically." The writer later suggested on Twitter that the cardinal in question was Cardinal Vincent Nichols, archbishop of Westminster and president of the Catholic Bishops' Conference of England and Wales. Thompson told Arroyo that the Zanchetta scandal is "deeply troubling" and that the message to the faithful seems to be "this is none of your business." "It's the same message that was sent when the horrible -- now dead -- Cardinal Danneels tried to cover up incestuous child abuse and then was invited to a Synod on the family," Thompson added incredulously. After the infamous Cardinal Danneels died last March, Pope Francis hailed him as a "dedicated Catholic pastor" -- quite a stretch of the imagination considering his pastoral history. In 2015, Danneels, the archbishop emeritus of Brussels, confessed to being part of the radical “St. Gallen Mafia,” which opposed Benedict XVI. According to the National Catholic Register, he also once wrote a letter to the Belgium government expressing his support for same-sex marriage legislation. The cardinal is already known for having once advised the king of Belgium to sign an abortion law in 1990, for telling a victim of clerical sex abuse to keep quiet, and for refusing to forbid pornographic, “educational” materials being used in Belgian Catholic schools. In 2010, Danneels advised the nephew of his good friend Bishop Roger Vangheluwe not to go public with an accusation of sexual abuse against his uncle. After the nephew told Danneels that his friend had molested him for thirteen years, the cardinal advised the young man “not to make a lot of noise" about the abuse he endured because Vangheluwe was scheduled to retire in a year anyway. "It would be better that you wait," Danneels reportedly advised the nephew, while also urging him to forgive his uncle. The nephew reportedly recorded the conversation and subsequently released a videotape to the press. Thompson found it difficult to express his disgust with the Vatican's behavior in the face of so many scandals "close to the Holy Father." "It's hard to sum up the message in polite words so I won't try," he said sadly. https://pjmedia.com/faith/editor-in...ble-bishops-and-scandal-plagued-pope-francis/
Gravest Crisis in 2,000 Years of Church History Antonio Socci on the Pan-Amazon Synod and the Francis pontificate https://www.churchmilitant.com/news...hurch-that-goes-out-is-goingoutof-catholicism by Antonio Socci • ChurchMilitant.com • July 9, 2019 With the Vatican document for the Synod on the Amazon, the Bergoglian pontificate now has its official manifesto of the extreme left, based on “surreal socialism.” In addition to Trump and Salvini, Brazilian President Bolsonaro is now among its enemies, all three of them emblems of the hated Western civilization of peoples of the Judeo-Christian tradition which does not deny its roots and identity. This Vatican Instrumentum Laboris, writes José Antonio Ureta, "represents the total opening of the doors of the Magisterium to 'Indian theology' and to 'eco-theology,' two Latin American derivatives of liberation theology, whose cheerleaders, after the collapse of the Soviet Union and the failure of 'real socialism,' now attribute the historic role of revolutionary force to the indigenous peoples and to nature, in a Marxist key.”" It's the total opening of the doors of the Magisterium to 'Indian theology' and to 'eco-theology.'Tweet Among Catholics there is confusion. It seems that the "Church that goes out" that Bergoglio wanted is truly going out — going out of Catholicism. Cardinal Walter Brandmüller — a personal friend of Benedict XVI — is a distinguished historian of the Church, and yet he has not hesitated to use the strongest terms to speak out against this Instrumentum Laboris: "heretical" and "apostate." Brandmüller speaks of the Synod as "an aggressive intrusion into the purely secular affairs of State and society in Brazil." He then condemns the theological absurdities of the document (in contrast to the texts of the Second Vatican Council) and the "anti-rational rejection of 'Western' culture which emphasizes the importance of reason." Such a Vatican Instrumentum, the cardinal thunders, "makes the synod of bishops and ultimately the Pope responsible for a grave violation of the depositum fidei, which has the consequence of the self-destruction of the Church or the changing of the Corpus Christi mysticum into a secular NGO with an ecological-social-psychological purpose." The prelate concludes "forcefully" that the Vatican document "contradicts the binding teaching of the Church on decisive points and thus it must be qualified as heretical. Given that here even the fact of divine revelation is called into question, or misunderstood, one must also speak, in addition, of apostasy." This "constitutes an attack on the foundations of faith ... and therefore must be rejected with the utmost firmness." The position of the cardinal, who is a close friend of Benedict XVI, is the position of Catholics. And one may also assume that this position is shared above all by Papa Ratzinger, who for years defended the Faith of the Church from the liberation theology and from all of its derivatives which today fill the Vatican document. Despite a thousand pressures placed on him to do so, the Bergoglian court never obtained from Benedict XVI a refutation of the four cardinals of the Dubia (one of which was Brandmüller himself). Nor did it ever obtain a refutation of Abp. Carlo Maria Viganò, author of a historic testimony concerning the Vatican scandals. Rather, in April Papa Ratzinger published his own testimony — specifically addressing the scandals — which offers reflections in line with the viewpoint of the aforementioned dubia cardinals and also offers Benedict's own contribution. And we can also say that Ratzinger's document already anticipated the Vatican document on the Amazon. In fact, it condemns every attempt to replace the Church of Christ by creating "another Church, invented by us," because it is a church that — instead of concerning itself with the salvation of man – concerns itself with politics, the economy,and ecology (according to worldly ideologies), is “an experiment that has already been tried and failed.” This text of Benedict has now been published in a volume by Cantagalli together with other texts of Bergoglio on the problem of the scandals, and the clerical choir is now singing the praises of this editorial work as a sign of the harmony that supposedly exists between the two popes. But what harmony? Certain sections of the Bergoglian camp reacted violently last April when Benedict XVI announced the publication of his “notes.” There were those who suggested that they were not his own. Furthermore, Bergoglio was very careful not to spread the document, which had already been given to him by Benedict XVI, at the [February] Vatican summit on the scandals for which it was written. Now instead, Francis contributes to this book with his writings in order to make people forget his failures in this area (highlighted by Archbishop Viganò). Bergoglio is taking shelter behind the authority of Benedict XVI. But it is enough to read the two texts to understand the two opposing positions. Papa Ratzinger in these years has a dramatic task. On the one hand he must ward off all of the Bergoglian pulls which would carry the Church outside the bounds of Catholic doctrine (and his very presence is a deterrent which “admonishes” the Argentine). On the other hand, he must encourage those Catholics who are bewildered by the present disaster (including bishops and cardinals) and he must invite them to defend the faith of the Church while avoiding the production of irreparable ruptures. The signals he gives are always discreet, but clear and comforting. Not only by means of powerful interventions like the document he issued last April, but also by recalling that he – that is, the pope – is there and Catholics should not feel that they are orphans. The latest (truly beautiful) book which Ratzinger has published, “Per Amore,” does not carry on its cover the title “Pope Emeritus” but the firm signature “Benedetto PP XVI.” These initials “PP” stand for “Pastor Pastorum” (or Pater Patrum), which is the title and prerogative of the reigning pontiff. This is the umpteenth little sign of the dramatic situation of the Apostolic See, which cannot (yet) be clarified, but which confirms what Benedict XVI said in his final audience on February 27, 2013: “The “always” is also a “for ever” – there can no longer be a return to the private sphere. My decision to resign the active exercise of the ministry does not revoke this.” In several of his recent letters – like his November 23, 2017, letter to Cardinal Brandmuller, in which he shows that he is very concerned about the situation of the present Church – Benedict XVI concludes by writing: “With my Apostolic blessing.” But only the reigning pontiff can give the Apostolic blessing (directly or by delegating others). If Benedict was no longer pope, doing so would be committing an abuse. Moreover, many other signs should make one stop and reflect. Not only his dress, his name, his title, his coat of arms. Bergoglio himself calls him “Holiness” (because he is officially called “His Holiness Benedict XVI.”) For the last six years — in Bergoglian circles — they have wanted to obtain from Benedict XVI a declaration in which he says that he no longer has anything to do with the papacy, and that he is only a bishop. But Benedict does not say these words. A journalist from Corriere della Sera has now written that anonymous people (in unspecified circumstances) are said to have heard Benedict say, "The Pope is one, Francis." But this same journalist recently had the chance to meet Ratzinger and ask him questions, and Benedict XVI did not ever say this phrase to him. Benedict is central in the Church today.Tweet The thought of Benedict XVI is best expressed above all by the words of his right-hand man, Archbishop Georg Gaenswein, who said at an historic conference at the Gregorian University: Before and after his resignation, Benedict understood and understands his task as participation in such a "Petrine ministry." He has left the papal throne and yet, with the step made on February 11, 2013, he has not at all abandoned this ministry. Instead, he has complemented the personal office with a collegial and synodal dimension, as a quasi-shared ministry. ... This is why Benedict XVI has not given up either his name, or the white cassock. This is why the correct name by which to address him even today is “Your Holiness"; ... He has not abandoned the office of Peter — something which would be entirely impossible for him to do following his irrevocable acceptance of the office in April 2005. Gaenswein spoke of a "pontificate of exception." There are those who believe that by a mysterious design of Divine Providence, the Church is being subjected to a very harsh trial, its own Good Friday, but that the presence of Benedict guarantees that She will not be shipwrecked. Certainly Benedict is central in the Church today. And one day everything will become clearer. First published in Libero on July 1, 2019. Antonio Socci is the author of The Secret of Benedict XVI (Angelico Press, 2019). For more information click here. Translated by Giuseppe Pellegrino
Antonio, my beloved Benedict is a frail and imperfect man. I love his wisdom, but it is most probable that Francis will outlive Benedict. Do not say that Benedict guarantees that the Church will not be shipwrecked. Jesus Christ alone is the anchor. 1Cor 3: 11 For no other foundation can any one lay than that which is laid, which is Jesus Christ. Jesus will save the Church, but if He chooses any human instrument to assist Him it will most likely be Our Lady! When Peter walked on the water and faltered due to lack of faith, it was Jesus who reached out to rescue! When my son, Patrick, celebrated Holy Mass at St. Peter's this May, he celebrated Ad orientem. In front of him was this painting of that very scene! Safe in the Barque of Peter!
Benedictine theologian calls Amazon Synod working doc ‘biodegradable Christianity’ in searing new critique Diane Montagna | https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/b...gradable-christianity-in-searing-new-critique ROME, July 10, 2019 (LifeSiteNews) — A Benedictine theologian has joined the chorus of voices criticizing the working document of the upcoming Synod of Bishops on the Amazon, calling it “biodegradable Christianity.” In an analysis published by Italian journalist Aldo Maria Valli on July 2, Dom Giulio Meiattini, a monk of the abbey of Madonna della Scala in the southern Italian province of Bari, said the Instrumentum laboris proposes and contains nothing less than a “reversal” of the “very idea of Church and Christian faith.” “The Person of Christ and His Gospel disappear; they are literally swallowed up by the lush tropical forest” of repetitious reflection on ecology and sociology, Dom Meiattini writes. “In reading this hymn to the Amazonian paradise on earth,” the Italian monk adds, “it is difficult to understand how and why this portion of humanity needs faith in the Incarnation.” Commenting on the document’s focus on the Amazon as an “epiphanic” source of revelation, Dom Meiattini says the apostolic, scriptural, and liturgical tradition of the Church “are covered by vines and tropical molds or sunk in marshy quicksand.” Yet he notes that the authors of the document do not seem “concerned at all about giving theological and scriptural plausibility to what they say.” Praising German Cardinal Walter Brandmüller’s recent critique of the working document, Dom Meiattini said “it’s hard to blame him” for calling it “heretical.” But, he adds, “more than heresy, we should speak of apostasy.” The Instrumentum laboris “is not a Christian document,” the Benedictine theologian insists. “Let this be clearly stated: a few biblical quotations inserted as the title to several paragraphs, or the use of words like ‘Church’, ‘conversion’ and ‘pastoral,’ are not enough to guarantee the evangelical character of a text.” The working document for the synod on the Amazon, he says, represents an “abandonment of the biblical faith for something different, with only a counterfeit label of Christianity. A bit like products bearing the EU [European Union] mark that are manufactured in China.” In his analysis, Dom Meiattini also claims that the working document’s fascination with the “world of the primitive,” i.e. the “childhood of mankind,” betrays an infantile regression. “After the attempts of the flower children, what is now being proposed is a cultural model which is ecologically more sustainable and as minimally neurotic as possible: life brought back to its beginnings, to bows and arrows, to shamanic healing rituals,” he writes. He further argues that we should not underestimate the connection between such infantile regression and “homo and trans ideology” which is founded on the idea of spontaneous self-determination coupled with a rejection of reason. However, according to the Benedictine theologian, the most interesting aspect of the document is that “things become clearer, compared to the previous ambiguous formulations that were supported by erroneous quotations of St. Thomas in order to be able to claim that everything was ‘completely Thomistic.’” “Here it is clear that St. Thomas has nothing to do with it,” he writes, adding it is equally clear “that the Bible has nothing to do with it either. If there is still something Christian in this Instrumentum laboris, i.e., a few words and expressions here and there, there is no need to worry: it is undoubtedly biodegradable!” Here below is an English translation of Dom Giulio Meiattini’s commentary on the Instrumentum laboris. The original Italian may be read here. *** Promoting a biodegradable Christianity For some time now, we have known or imagined that the Synod on the Amazon would hold some surprises and create further reason for division. At first, it seemed that perhaps the thorniest issue to arise at the synod would concern married clergy. It must be said that the publication of the Instrumentum laboris has far exceeded these expectations and the liveliest imagination. The document, in fact, points towards a much more ambitious and radical goal. It is the most daring move that could be conceived and attempted by the secretariat of a synod of the Catholic Church. The document proposes and contains nothing less than a reversal ab imis fundamentis [in its deepest foundations] of the very idea of Church and Christian faith. Diluting Christianity: wine turned into water I say “Christian” and not “Catholic” with good reason, because in fact the method and contents of this text, which is full of repetition and quite cumbersome, have actually liquidated the fundamental elements of Christianity. Naturally, the operation is carried out with the usual system, which I have pointed out on other occasions: not by denying but by keeping silent, not by contradicting but by diluting. In this way, the reader can also be favorably impressed by all the interesting reflections on ecology, ethnology, health and sanitation and sociology that it contains, and many of which are in themselves also right. But in the midst of these lush and redundant empirical analyses, which say nothing new and which a specialist could say in a better and more substantiated manner, the Person of Christ and His Gospel disappear; they are literally swallowed up by the lush tropical forest. The relationship between faith and culture should be illustrated using the classical Christology expressed by the first ecumenical councils, which affirm the transcendence of the divine Person of the Word with respect to the human nature that it sustains, assumes and transforms, not vice versa. The Instrumentum laboris expresses, in fact, in its general logic, a completely inverted conception that no longer conforms to Christological orthodoxy. In reading this hymn to the Amazonian paradise on earth (which is presented as a new Eden of innocence and communal and cosmic harmony without stain, except those brought by Western civilization; cf. n. 103), it is difficult to understand how and why this portion of humanity needs faith in the Incarnation. The myth of the great Amazonian river as the source of life replaces the great Christological and Paschal image of the river that flows from the Temple (according to the prophet Ezekiel) and that “brings life and heals wherever it flows.” Instead of asking how the proclamation of the Gospel can be brought to these peoples, and how the living water of Christ can heal and bring life to the lives of these peoples, it is taken for granted that they already live, thanks to their ancestral traditions, in an Edenic condition by which, if anything, the Church must allow herself to be converted. It is said several times that the Church must take on “an Amazonian face,”but the document does not understand whether, and how, the Amazon can or should assume a Christian face, and whether this is desirable or not. continued...
continued from above... The Instrumentum laboris expresses opinions which some may like, but it is not a Christian document. Let this be clearly stated. A few biblical quotations inserted as the title of several paragraphs, or the use of words like “Church”, “conversion” and “pastoral,” are not enough to guarantee the evangelical character of a text. They look like protective screens, but the Word of the living God does not constitute the foundation and inspiration on which the document is built. By way of example, consider Part I, Chapter 1, which is dedicated to the theme of life. The title is inspired by John 10:10: “I have come that they may have life and have it in abundance.” It would seem to be an excellent starting point. But what follows never says what this life that Jesus came to bring consists in, nor that John speaks of “eternal life” and that this life is the same Trinitarian life given by the Holy Spirit. In commenting on this verse from the Gospel of John, the text is content to illustrate Amazonian biodiversity and the rich hydrography of the Amazon basin, and to praise the “good life” of the indigenous people, which — an astonishing discovery — “means understanding the centrality of the relational-transcendent character of human beings and creation and includes ‘doing good’” (n. 13). Of course, it is not clear whether the Cross of Christ and his Resurrection are still necessary for the sort of “good living” that is here being presented as a model. The Cross is mentioned only twice, and it is understood that it never refers to the redemptive Cross of Christ, but to the “history of the Cross and Resurrection” which consists in the Church’s solidarity with the struggles of indigenous peoples in the defense of the territory (n. 33-34; 145). The removal of the scriptural principle: apostasy, rather than heresy Cardinal Brandmüller, in his widely circulated commentary on the Instrumentum laboris, states in no uncertain terms that the document is heretical. It’s hard to blame him. But one thing must be noted to better understand the type of “heresy” we are dealing with. Church history teaches us that heresies normally develop out of a controversial interpretation of scriptural texts. The heretic always believes that he is giving a more correct interpretation of Scripture, whose authority he does not question. Therefore, it was to the sound of biblical quotations that controversies were generally fed. In other words, from Arius to Luther and beyond, the assumption that united orthodoxy and heresy, Catholics and non-Catholics, beyond all division, has always been the undisputed authority of Sacred Scripture, recognized as the inspired word, and to whose scrutiny every teaching and every theology had to submit. But there is no longer any detectable trace of this scriptural premise in the Instrumentum laboris for the Pan-Amazon synod. The authors of the document are not worried at all about giving theological and scriptural plausibility to what they say; it seems that, to them, the only “theological locus” (venerable terminology dating back to the illustrious Melchior Cano) is the “territory” or the “cry of the poor.” We read: “Territory is a theological place where faith is lived, and also a particular source of God’s revelation: epiphanic places where the reserve of life and wisdom for the planet is manifested, a life and wisdom that speak of God” (n. 19; cf. 144; 126e). Of course, it is not said anywhere that Scripture and the Liturgy, within the great apostolic and ecclesial tradition, by order of importance, are the first theological places from which all other possible minor loci theologicimust be verified, nor are they used as primary sources. Dei Verbumand Sacrosanctum concilium are covered by vines and tropical molds or sunk in marshy quicksand. This is a phenomenon that must not escape us, because it is the most important indicator that allows us to grasp the true nature of the deviation or “paradigm shift” that the Instrumentum laboris introduces. In modern times there have already been illustrious precedents of a removal of the scriptural principle in favor of the primacy of other entities. The so-called liberal theology from the 19th century onwards, in the Protestant sphere, was basically an attempt to justify Christianity (or its cultural relics), in the face of the multiple criticisms of modern culture, reducing it “within the limits of reason alone” or to a particularly high form of unsurpassed ethics or leading it back to universal religious sentiment. Faith and the Church were reduced to their universal comprehensibility through a process of rational homologation. The key words and concepts of Christianity remained, but their meaning was completely secularized. This removal of the scriptural principle was the consequence of the new confrontation that Christianity had to sustain: no longer through internal divisions, but with a rationality emancipated from revelation, which could only accept what was within its parameters. This anthropological dilution of Christianity into ethics or reason or religious sentiment (which was felt in Catholic circles with the modernist crisis) no longer considers Scripture as a theological locus. It is the great Christian “symbols” (the Church, worship, the cross and the resurrection, moral norms, etc.), now extrapolated from their original ground, but still living by inertia in European civilization, that must find some justification and reinterpretation. A great thinker like Ernst Troeltsch could thus argue, on rational bases, that the Christian religion represented the highest form of universal morality and religiosity. But nothing more than this! Central dogmas thereby became “myths” to be overcome in a universally acceptable “logos.” Bultman’s demythologization was one of the most famous variants of this homologation of faith in an existential dimension that is easily digestible. It is in the light of this history (which has not yet ended) that a phenomenon such as the Instrumentum laboris on the Amazon should be considered. It is the dilution of Christianity to anthropology, or rather to ecology to be precise, in order to give it again a semblance of acceptability in the United Nations assembly and in environmentalist, post-modern, anti-Western and biodegradable naturalist thinking. That is why Cardinal Brandmüller’s diagnosis is correct, but immediately adding, as he himself does, that more than heresy we should speak of apostasy. The removal of the scriptural principle (which is like saying the renunciation of theology and mission), the abdication of a reading of the phenomena and mission of the Church in the light of the Word of God, replacing it with the uncontaminated and mythical “theological locus” of the environment, of territory and of the poor (as if all this were immune to original sin, and therefore a “pure word” of God that can do without the two Testaments), is equivalent to the abandonment of the ground of faith, which for Paul and the Apostolic Church comes from listening to the kerygma and not from the “ecological conversion” to the territory (an expression that is repeated nine times in the text). The Apostolic Church, and the one that followed, transmitted the proclamation of Christ the Son of God who died and rose for sins. That is why it was missionary. But there is no trace of this proclamation in our document. Here, therefore, we are not faced with a variant, albeit heterodox or heretical, of Christianity, but with a phenomenon of abandonment of the biblical faith for something different, with only a counterfeit label of Christianity. A bit like products bearing the EU [European Union] mark that are manufactured in China. I will say more. The great representatives of theological liberalism to whom I have referred at least kept Christianity in a privileged position: it remained for them the highest expression of the human ethos or religion of humanity. In their own way, “they could not but call themselves Christians.” In the new mythical reduction presented by the pre-synodal document, something more radical happens: this privileged position is lost. It seems that the Church now has the sole task of protecting what good the Amazonian people already possess. Therefore, that high vision of Christianity as the most evolved religion or, if you like, as man fully realized, also disappears. Here the problem of true religion no longer has any reason to exist. Nor does the question of the true God whom religions venerate. In fact, we read: “Insincere openness to the other, just like a corporatist attitude, that reserve salvation exclusively for one’s own creed, are destructive of that very creed.” (n. 39). As if to say: believe what you want, you are saved all the same. We had already read something like this in the Abu Dhabi document. Evidently it was not a slip of the tongue! The cultural phenomenon: an infantile regression Having ascertained this, there is another fact to be noted, equally important and of considerable proportions, concerning the cultural operation underway here (given that we can now only deal with culture and no longer with Christian theology). The interesting thing is that what is privileged in the Instrumentum laboris is no longer the adult logos that illuminated and dissolved the mythos of the infantile and primitive eras of humanity, including the Judeo-Christian “myth,” as happened in the interpretation of liberal theology and in all the enlightened or positivistic reductions of Christianity, such as that of Kant, Lessing, Hegel, Bultman and so on. Now the fascination with the emancipated adult age, as the “age of reason” which has guided much of modernity has dissolved for the westernized world; it has lost its appeal. continued...
continued from above... Taking its place once again is much-despised mythos, the world of the primitive; in short, the childhood of mankind, the good savage with his ancestral animistic wisdom (which the sad homo technologicus envies, but without really knowing what it is). After criticizing and eliminating the “myth,” even the biblical one, as a remnant of the infantile age of humanity, and consequently desacralizing the ritual practices of the Church (which is accused of a magical and superstitious mentality), now an attempt is being made to replace the void produced (more than deforestation!) by resorting to the shamanic myths and rituals of the indigenous Amazon, to a pre-Christian repertoire, so that they become the new paradigm in which to water down the true wine of the uniqueness of Christ. One cannot but notice that, from the psycho-cultural point of view, this is a classic phenomenon of post-modern infantile regression typical of the Western world, which no longer aspires to the adult age of enlightenment or positivistic memory. It’s too demanding or too boring to be an adult. Enough with pure and absolute reason, enough with the fatigue of the concept. Better to be carefree and instinctive like children, simple and spontaneous like them. Not the age of reason, but of dream and play. Too bad that this childish aspiration camouflages, behind the enchanting innocence of the puer, the deepest nihilism. Recall that the Nietzschean Superman, who decrees the end of the logos, has the appearance of a child; he is innocent in his playing (beyond good and evil) with the wheel of eternal return. The child mentioned in Friedrich Nietzsche’s novel, Thus Spoke Zarathustra, for those who do not know it, is Dionysus, “Dionysus against the Crucified”! The pagan myth replaces the Christian God. Today, what is childish fascinates, because it impersonates an innocent and irresponsible instinct that the adult cannot allow himself. Let such diagnoses not seem excessive. Rather, note the strange and fatal attraction between Westerners with their decadent bad conscience, disappointed by the longed-for emancipated adult age (which soon turned into unwanted old age) and lost childhood, the land of gold, which cannot be found except in the pre-civilized tribal cultures, since we have also robbed our techno-children of their childhood. The myth of the uncontaminated, the neopagan naturalism of childlike innocence of the natives is an entirely western and post-modern regression. Where can we find salvation from hyper-technology? How can we escape an increasingly less manageable urbanization? How can we heal the wounds of increasingly fragmented relationships? After the attempts of the flower children, what is now being proposed is a cultural model which is ecologically more sustainable and as minimally neurotic as possible: life brought back to its beginnings, to bows and arrows, to shamanic healing rituals. A new beginning! Today everyone wants to have a new beginning, or another chance, as they say. The other possibility for westernized man is to turn to those who have remained at the beginning for millennia. This is the new myth presented by Instrumentum laboris, an excellent example of this post-modern infantile regression, a real complex or syndrome of European origin, even if it is cloaked in love for the peripheries and anti-Westernism. Like all regressions, this one too is not fully self-aware, otherwise it would be ashamed. Instead, it is said openly with impressive naivety, imagining it is doing prophetic work. But usually prophecy is “outdated.” The boring pages of the Instrumentum laboris are a smoothie blended with obvious things; it is suitable, in fact, for children (or perhaps for old people without teeth who are stammering again). I don’t think too many explanations are needed to understand that this aspiration to infantile neoteny, a kind of lack of distinction potentially open to any possibility of totipotent “self-determination” (for this reason representative of Nietzsche’s desire for power), goes magnificently well with a homologating culture that tries to promote the delay of sexual differentiation (a necessary phase for access to adulthood), remaining in prepubescent indeterminacy. Homo and trans ideology are related to this secret nostalgia for the fusional beginnings that bind one to the mother, a need instinctively felt by the post-modern western alogical and anomical world. The fact that it is now called “Mother Earth” (another beloved expression in the Instrumentum laboris, used six times compared to only one reference to God as father) and Mother Nature matters little. Unfortunately, however, the Amazon described in the pre-synodal document is not real, except marginally: it is a construction of Western make-believe searching for substitute myths made to measure, after liquidating its own, especially the Christian narrative. In singing the wonders of the Amazonian territory, the document betrays an endless naivety. The writers should have reread at least a few pages of Leopardi on Mother Nature, so as not to be seduced in such a blatant way by the sirens of Rousseau. Conclusions: Biodegradable Christianity The objections I made to the postulates of Evangelii gaudium (especially to the first: the superiority of time over space) pointed to the theoretical weakness of that pastoral program, which already showed a certain tendency to remove the role of logos (also scriptural) in favor of reality (considered superior to the idea), renouncing in substance the mediation of theology in the name of the immediacy of practice (initiate processes). My criticism of Amoris laetitia focused on highlighting the reduction of what is specifically Christian (summed up in sacramental life) to universal morality, in line with the currents of theological liberalism previously mentioned. It seems to me that the Instrumentum laboris for the upcoming synod on the Amazon represents a coherent maturation of these premises. The reduction of the sacraments to morals is now being replaced by the exaltation of indigenous “good living” (naturist morals, more than natural), the choice of the people as a “mythical category” and of the people’s myths in place of the biblical narrative. Above all, the preference given to the environment (territory-space) over history (time), also because indigenous peoples have no history and live in a cyclical time or (in some cases) are devoid of the concept of time. Yet we were told the opposite! The most interesting aspect is that, in this document, things become clearer, compared to the previous ambiguous formulations that were supported by erroneous quotations of St. Thomas in order to be able to claim that everything was “completely Thomistic.” Here it is clear that St. Thomas has nothing to do with it, and as has been said, the Bible has nothing to do with it either. If there is still something Christian in this Instrumentum laboris, i.e., a few words and expressions here and there, there is no need to worry: it is undoubtedly biodegradable! Dom Giulio Meiattini, OSB
Dom Meiattini has a lot of fun with this critique. Anyone who was instrumental in putting together this pre-synodal document (Instrumentum Laboris), has been sent back to grade school and should be licking their wounds. With satire and irony the good Dom has demolished a document that is suppose to serve as a springboard for theological innovation. Dom Meiattini rightly demonstrates it's a springboard only deserving a leap into the garbage dump! If the synod fathers ignore the fact that this devious agenda has been exposed and still attempt to push it through by ignoring the opposition , then what we previously feared was an attack on the Faith, will be proven correct beyond a doubt. As the good Dom says: Here, therefore, we are not faced with a variant, albeit heterodox or heretical, of Christianity, but with a phenomenon of abandonment of the biblical faith for something different, with only a counterfeit label of Christianity. And if the synod fathers do push through their agenda, such a desperate move will show they are of the devil and the only weapon at their disposal is raw power. My friends, this synod is a defining moment. Will the bishops make a definitive move toward repentance and turn back to Jesus Christ, or will they continue decisively down the path toward perdition and attempt to drag the Church down with them? Eph 5: 6 Let no one deceive you with empty words, for it is because of these things that the wrath of God comes upon the sons of disobedience. 7 Therefore do not associate with them, 8 for once you were darkness, but now you are light in the Lord; walk as children of light 9 (for the fruit of light is found in all that is good and right and true), 10 and try to learn what is pleasing to the Lord. 11 Take no part in the unfruitful works of darkness, but instead expose them. Safe in the Barque of Peter!
Jul. 12, 2019 | http://www.ncregister.com/daily-new...es-in-france-shock-faithful-prompt-reflection Rise in Crimes Against Churches in France Shock Faithful, Prompt Reflection The Conference of French Bishops said there were 228 “violent anti-Christian acts” from January to March 2019. Catholic News Agency PARIS - Vandalism, theft, arson and other increasing attacks on churches in France have led to debates about their causes, amid shock to the community, questions bout the perpetrators, and debates over what the attacks might mean about French culture and the place of Christianity. “Those downplaying the vandalism, which include most leading newspapers and politicians, point to evidence that the attacks are the small-bore crimes of small-time miscreants. Those concerned that the attacks pose a more serious threat expressly dismiss that perspective,” American journalist and author Richard Bernstein has said in an essay for RealClearInvestigations titled “Anti-Christian Attacks in France Quietly Quadrupled. Why?” Bernstein sees merit in both perspectives, putting them in the context of pressing French questions about populism, national identity, immigration, tradition, authority, and power. At the same time, he acknowledges the deep concern of Christian communities which suffer such attacks and vandalism, even when they are not “hate crimes” properly speaking. “Still, even if many anti-Christian acts are not hate crimes intended to intimidate a community of believers, the fact is that there are a large number of attacks on Christian sites that are sacred to many people,” he said. “Communities are shocked and made to feel vulnerable, in part by the sense that the incidents have proliferated so dramatically over the past few years, and they are taking place in virtually every corner of France: urban and rural areas, large towns and small villages alike.” The Conference of French Bishops said there were 228 “violent anti-Christian acts” from January to March 2019. In 2018, French police reported 129 thefts and 877 incidents of vandalism at Catholic sites, mostly churches and cemeteries. The French Minister of the Interior counted slightly fewer numbers of anti-Christian incidents that year. Such attacks quadrupled in number from 2008 to 2019. While France has suffered more attacks than any other country in Europe, their numbers have increased across Europe. Some leaders downplay the attacks. “We do not want to develop a discourse of persecution,” Archbishop Georges Pontier of Marseile, the head of the French Bishops Conference, told the magazine Le Point. “We do not wish to complain.” In June vandals toppled more than 100 tombstones in the main Catholic cemetery in Toulouse. The incident received little national press coverage, but locals too did not want to give it attention. In Normandy in 2016, two men who professed allegiance to the Islamic State group murdered Father Jacques Hamel while he was celebrating Mass. That same year in Paris, police thwarted Muslim extremists who attempted to blow up a car near the Cathedral of Notre-Dame. Some feared anti-Christian sentiment was behind another Islamic State group sympathizer’s gun and knife attack on a Christmas market in Strasbourg in 2018. The backdrop of these and other major terrorist incidents have heightened fears that Christians would be more directly targeted. The April 15 fire at the Cathedral of Notre-Dame shocked the world as the 19th-century roof and spire were destroyed, though the structure was saved from collapse. As soon as the fire was reported, social media influencers and others with no presence on the scene spread speculation, rumors and even hoaxes claiming that the fire was an act of terrorism. Anonymous internet accounts as well as right-wing activists, nationalists, and white supremacists used the event to fan anti-Muslim sentiment, NBC News reported in April. In June investigators said they had been unable to determine the cause and there was no evidence the fire was intentional. They said they would consider the possibility of negligence, including electrical malfunction or a poorly extinguished cigarette, as a cause for the fire. Vandalism and attacks on Christian churches often appear to lack any organized coordination or shared motives. Earlier this year, when six churches were set on fire or vandalized in one week, the perpetrators of one incident were two youths. The perpetrator in another was a 35-year-old homeless man. Of identified perpetrators of anti-Christian attacks, more than 60 percent are minors. Many perpetrators “appear to be disaffected young people, or the psychologically disturbed or homeless, rather than members of organized groups advancing a political agenda,” Bernstein said. “Virtually none of the reported attacks have been against people; they are all against buildings, cemeteries or other physical objects,” he added. About 60% of vandalism incidents involved graffiti like satanic inscriptions, anarchist symbols, swastikas, or nationalist or neo-Nazi slogans. In Bernstein’s view, this “would seem to represent a kind of ugly desperate social fringe than a general growth of anti-Christian hatred.” For Bernstein, the evidence shows attacks by Muslims “account for a small fraction of anti-Christian crimes.” The French government itself downplays anti-Christian actions for fear of stoking anti-Muslim reaction and retaliation, though there have not been any known incidents of retaliation. While some commentators wonder why attacks on other groups draw more attention than attacks on Christians, Bernstein attributes this to the relative historical security of Catholics, especially in comparisons to Jews who were persecuted by French collaborators with Nazis in the Second World War. Philosopher and cultural commentator Pierre Manent suggested that many churches are targets of opportunity, telling Bernstein, “This vandalism is drawn to Christian sites because they're less defended and present little risk, and there are a lot of them.” Church attendance has declined and the scandals about sexual abuse of young people and children by clergy make the Church “seem a weak and easy target,” Bernstein said. Jean-Francois Colosimo, a historian and theologian who is general director of the Editions du Cerf publishing house, said it is not “Christianophobia” but “a loss of the sense of the sacred” that is to blame. Bernstein’s essay cited an attack in the southwest France town of Lauvar. Two teenage boys sneaked into the town’s 700-year-old Cathedral of St. Alain, set the altar on fire, turned a crucifix upside down, threw another crucifix into the nearby river, and deformed a statue of Christ. Mayor of Lauvar Bernard Carayon told Bernstein the attack was far different than misbehavior like bathroom graffiti. He blamed “Christianophobia.” “The two boys who set fire to the altar and defaced the statue of Christ weren't just drunk; they carried out their attack purposefully, taking their time, and then, after they left to tell their friends what they'd done, they went back inside, no doubt to check the results,” the mayor said, contending that the Catholic Church had wrongly prioritized inter-religious dialogue and working “to avoid conflict.” There has been vandalism and theft at the church, its pastor, Father Joseph Dequick said, but the police do not distinguish which is which. This means it is difficult to distinguish criminal theft from vandalism based in hostility to the Church. “But when somebody turns a cross upside down, that's an anti-Christian expression,” he said. “That represents a society that no longer transmits respect for values. It's a loss of the sense of the sacred. It's consumerism. Young people can do whatever they want now, have whatever they want. Where are the limits? Where are the parents?” According to the priest, professions of atheism are fashionable and there is “a mood against the Church, against faith” “The media are anti-Catholic. There a discourse against the Church. In France, in particular, there's an anti-clerical feeling that goes back a long time,” the priest told Bernstein. “It’s not so much a religious argument as a political one. It's a reaction against the moral limitations that the Church represents.” Manent told Bernstein there is a cultural attitude that the Church is “an obstacle to contemporary life,” and this attitude “nourishes a certain hostility.” *** Edited to add: Chile removes statute of limitations on sex abuse cases ... The new law, which passed the Chilean Congress July 6, ensures that there will be no time limit in prosecuting cases “regarding the kidnapping or abduction of a minor, as well as the torture, unlawful coercion or cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment and all that occurs during an act of rape, carnal access to a minor, statutory rape or other sexual offenses.” The law also allows victims to take civil action against people or institutions that aided in covering up sex abuse crimes. “From now on, time will no longer be an accomplice of the abusers, nor an ally of impunity,” said Chilean President Sebastian Pinero as he signed the legislation July 11. “From now on, the responsibility of those who abuse our children will be irrevocable, just as the pain they caused our children is irrevocable.” ... Although the new law is not retroactive, advocates say it is a major step forward and expressed hope that lawmakers can revise the law in the future for survivors who have been unable to seek justice due to prior limitations... 7/12/2019
I hate to say it but this Amazon synod sounds like something the Antichrist would do "change the substance of the sacraments". I'm not calling anyone the Antichrist right now because this is only a review of the working document but this is what many including myself suspected might happen at the time of the Warning. Iow, God will give humankind an opportunity to put itself back on track including those who had input to the working document for this synod. "But here there is only great confusion, and the center of everything is not Jesus Christ but themselves, their human ideas for saving the world." Cardinal Gerhard Müller. The following article has been Google translated from Italian to English, therefore there may be errors. In addition, I took screen shots of the translation because it is much easier but this link will take you to the translated article if you prefer to read it that way https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=it&tl=en&u=http://lanuovabq.it/it/sinodo-amazzonia-un-pretesto-per-cambiare-la-chiesa# The original article is here http://lanuovabq.it/it/sinodo-amazzonia-un-pretesto-per-cambiare-la-chiesa#
Cardinal Müller: Vatican Amazon Document Contains Heresy and Stupidity 'That Has Nothing to Do with Christianity' Cardinal Gerhard Müller has joined his German colleague Cardinal Walter Brandmüller in condemning the Vatican's much-debated working document for the upcoming Synod of the Amazon in the strongest possible terms, calling it a work of not only heresy, but of stupidity. The conservative cardinal has been ringing alarm bells about the controversial Oct. 6-27 synod, warning that its stealth purpose is to modify the Church’s teaching on sexual morality and open its doors to "eco-theology." This Vatican Instrumentum Laboris (or working document) "represents the total opening of the doors of the Magisterium to 'Indian theology' and to 'eco-theology,' two Latin American derivatives of liberation theology, whose cheerleaders, after the collapse of the Soviet Union and the failure of 'real socialism,' now attribute the historic role of revolutionary force to the indigenous peoples and to nature, in a Marxist key,”" Chilean author José Antonio Ureta recently opined. Former editor-in-chief of The Catholic Herald Damian Thompson bluntly called the document "garbage." In his interview with the Catholic journal Gridatelo Dai Tetti, Müller seemed to concur, saying the document has "an ideological vision that has nothing to do with Christianity." "The Synod of the Amazon is a pretext to change the Church, and the fact that it is done in Rome wants to emphasize the beginning of a new Church," said Müller, former prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. The German prelate said that supporters of the pope have already attacked him and others for criticizing the document in an effort to squelch their criticism. But the Instrumentum Laboris, he pointed out, "has no magisterial value," therefore "only ignorant people can say that those who criticize him are an enemy of the Pope." Müller continued: Unfortunately this is their trick to avoid any critical dialogue, if try to make an objection you are immediately labeled as an enemy of the Pope. Clarification more than appropriate because the text of theInstrumentum Laborisit is disconcerting in describing the Amazon and the peoples who inhabit it as a model for all humanity, an example of harmony with nature, a perfect synthesis of what is meant by integral ecology. It is a document that presents an idyllic picture of the Amazon, including indigenous religions, so much so as to render Christianity useless, if not for the "political" support it can give to keep these peoples unspoiled and defend them from predators that want to bring development and "steal" resources. The cardinal added the pope and his allies "want to save the world according to their idea, perhaps using some elements of Scripture," but their ideas are "profane" and "have nothing to do with Revelation." Not surprisingly, although we are talking about Revelation, Creation, sacraments, relations with the world, almost no reference is made to the texts of the Second Vatican Council which define these aspects: Dei Verbum, Lumen Gentium, Gaudium et Spes. There is no mention of the root of human dignity, of the universality of salvation, of the Church as the sacrament of salvation. There are only profane ideas, which can also be discussed, but they have nothing to do with Revelation. He cited one section of the document where it speaks of "a broad and necessary field of dialogue between the spiritualities, the creeds and the Amazonian religions that requires a friendly approach to the different cultures." The sincere openness to the other, as well as a corporate attitude that reserves salvation exclusively for one's own belief, are destructive of that very creed. They treat our Creed as if it were our European opinion. But the Creed is the Revelation of God in Jesus Christ, who lives in the Church. There are no other beliefs. Instead, there are other philosophical beliefs or mythological expressions, but no one has ever dared to say, for example, that Plato's Wisdom is a form of God's revelation. In the creation of the world, God manifests only his existence, his being a point of reference of conscience, of natural law, but there is no other revelation outside of Jesus Christ. The concept of Lógos spermatikòs (the "seeds of the Word"), taken up by the Second Vatican Council, does not mean that Revelation in Jesus Christ exists in all cultures independently of Jesus Christ. As if Jesus were just one of these elements of Revelation. When asked whether he agreed with Cardinal Brandmüller's assessment that the document is a work of "heresy," Müller replied: "Heresy? Not only that, it is also stupidity. The heretic knows the Catholic doctrine and contradicts it. But here there is only a great deal of confusion, and the center of everything is not Jesus Christ but themselves, their ideas for saving the world." In the document the "cosmovision" of indigenous peoples is a model of integral ecology, which would be a conception in which spirits and deities act "with and in the territory, with and in relation to nature." Müller explained why "cosmovision" is incompatible with church doctrine. The "cosmovision" is a materialistic conception, similar to that of Marxism, in the end we can do what we want. But we believe in Creation, matter is the form of the essence of nature, we cannot do what we want. Creation is for the glorification of God but it is also a challenge for us, called to collaborate with God's saving will for all men. Our task is not to preserve nature as it is, but we have the responsibility for the progress of humanity, in education, in social justice, for peace. This is why Catholics build schools, hospitals, this is also the mission of the Church. Nature cannot be idealized as if the Amazon were an area of Paradise, because nature is not always loving towards man. In the Amazon there are predators, there are infections, diseases. And even these children, these young people are entitled to a good education, to benefit from modern medicine. One cannot idealize, as is done in the synodal document, only traditional medicine. He also blasted the document's hippy-drippy language, such as "ecological conversion" and "mother earth." "We must absolutely reject expressions such as "ecological conversion," Müller argued. "There is only conversion to the Lord, and as a consequence, there is also the good of nature." We cannot make ecologicalism a new religion, here we are in a pantheistic conception, which must be rejected. Pantheism is not just a theory about God but also contempt for man. God who identifies himself with nature is not a person. God the creator instead created us in His image and likeness. In prayer we have a relationship with a God who listens to us, who understands what we mean, not a mysticism in which we can dissolve personal identity. He continued: Our mother is a person, not the Earth. And our mother in faith is Mary. The Church is also described as a mother, as the bride of Jesus Christ. But these words must not be inflated. It is one thing to have respect for all the elements of this world, another to idealize or deify them. This identification of God with nature is a form of atheism, because God is independent of nature. They totally ignore the Creation. (cont'd below)
(cont'd from above) Müller also felt strongly about the document's critique of anthropocentrism -- the view that human beings are the most important entity in the universe -- calling it "a heresy against human dignity." "It is an absurd idea, to pretend that God is not anthropocentric," he argued. "Man is the center of Creation, and Jesus became man, he did not plant himself." This is a heresy against human dignity. On the contrary, the Church must emphasize anthropocentrism, because God created man in his image and likeness. Man's life is infinitely more worthy than the life of any animal. Today there is already a reversal of this principle: if a lion is killed in Africa it is a world drama, but here children are killed in the womb of the mother and all is well. Stalin also argued that this centrality should be removed from human dignity; so he could call so many men to build a canal and make them die for the sake of future generations. Here is what these ideologies are for, to make some dominate over all others. But God is anthropocentric, the Incarnation is anthropocentric. The rejection of anthropocentrism comes only from a hatred of oneself and other men. Another concept promoted in the Instrumentum Laboris is the idea of inculturation, which it closely associated with the Incarnation, or "the Word was made flesh." According to Church doctrine, Jesus Christ, the second person of the Trinity, was both "truly God and truly man." He was conceived in the womb of a woman, the Virgin Mary, thus, the divine nature of the Son was united but not mixed with human nature. Inculturation is the adaption of Christian liturgy to mostly non-Christian, cultures. The fact that the document apparently uses the words interchangeably bothered the cardinal immensely. "Using the Incarnation almost as a synonym for inculturation is the first mystification," he fretted. The Incarnation is a unique, unrepeatable event, it is the Word that is embodied in Jesus Christ. God did not incarnate in the Jewish religion, he did not incarnate in Jerusalem. Jesus Christ is unique. It is a fundamental point, because the sacraments depend on the Incarnation, they are the presence of the incarnate Word. Certain terms that are central to Christianity cannot be abused. Let us return to inculturation: from the synodal document we understand that we must adopt all the beliefs of indigenous peoples, their rituals and their customs. A reference is also made to how early Christianity was inculturated in the Greek world. And it is said that as we did then we must do today with the Amazon people. But the Catholic Church has never accepted the Greek and Roman myths. On the contrary, he rejected a civilization that despised men with slavery, rejected the imperialist culture of Rome or the typical pederasty of the Greeks. The Church's reference was to the thinking of Greek culture, which had come to recognize elements that paved the way for Christianity. Aristotle did not invent the ten categories: they already exist in being, he discovered them. As it happens in modern science: it is not something that concerns only the West, but rather the discovery of some structures and mechanisms that exist in nature. The same applies to Roman law, which is not any arbitrary system. Instead, it is the discovery of some legal principles, which the Romans found in the nature of a community. Certainly other cultures have not had this depth. But we do not live in Greek culture, Christianity has totally transformed Greek and Roman culture. Certain pagan myths can have a pedagogical dimension towards Christianity but they are not elements that found Christianity. Perhaps the most controversial aspect of the Instrumentum Laboris is its rereading of the sacraments, especially with regard to sacred orders, under the pretext that there are few priests in such remote areas. Müller complained that the approach "has nothing to do with Christianity." "The Revelation of God in Christ becomes present in the sacraments, and the Church has no authority to change the substance of the sacraments," he argued. "These are not some rituals that we like, and the priesthood is not a sociological category to create a relationship in the community." Any cultural system has its rituals and its symbols, but the sacraments are means of divine grace, so we can change neither content nor substance. Nor can we change the rite when this rite is constituted by Christ himself. We cannot do baptism with any liquid, we do it with natural water. At the Last Supper Jesus Christ did not take any drink or food, he took grape wine and wheat bread. When asked who he meant when he referred to those "who want to change the Church," Müller said it wasn't any one person or group of people, but a "system" comprised willfully blind people who believe they are improving the church, but are in fact destroying it. "We want to adapt to the world: marriage, celibacy, women priests, everything must be changed in the conviction that in this way there will be a new springtime for the Church," he explained. "They do not see that instead they destroy the Church, they are like blind men who fall into the pit. But if someone says something, he is immediately marginalized, branded as an enemy of the Pope." https://pjmedia.com/faith/cardinal-...ity-that-has-nothing-to-do-with-christianity/
The judge who ordered the abortion will stand before the just judge someday.. How sad for her........
Bless Mr. Thompson! Praying that more catholic journalist have the guts this good man has demonstrated! Sad...too few do. Sin of omission. ACCOUNTABILITY Before God will followed for all of us.
They really are driving us to the point of schism. Why? It's as if they want to force the issue. I can only think this haste--this ungodly haste--comes from the fact that the enemy knows his time is short.
It's always nice to read articles like this. L to R: Archbishop Fulton Sheen and Cardinal John Henry Newman (Sheen Foundation and public domain) Jul. 12, 2019 | http://www.ncregister.com/daily-new...xamples-of-john-henry-newman-and-fulton-sheen Cardinal Newman and Archbishop Sheen, Pray for Your Suffering Church! EDITORIAL: These famed holy, humble men stayed firmly anchored to Christ through a life of prayer, the sacraments and devoted service to the needy. The Editors What is the Church if not the assembly of all the saints?” asks the Catechism of the Catholic Church (479). This luminous truth has been dimmed amid a yearlong parade of scandal that continues to exert a powerful gravitational force on many Catholics, tempting them to leave the Body of Christ as the flood of revelations seems too much to bear. All the more reason, then, to welcome a summer of saints. We celebrate Pope Francis’ announcement that Blessed Cardinal John Henry Newman will be canonized with four others Oct. 13, and we rejoice in the Pope’s formal approval of a miracle attributed to the intercession of Venerable Archbishop Fulton Sheen, paving the way for his beatification. The date had not been announced at press time. Courageous and prescient in their reading of the signs of the times, these two Church leaders employed their extraordinary gifts to transmit the faith, serve the faithful, and condemn moral relativism and other powerful ideologies that erode religious belief and practice. And though many prominent evangelists have been corrupted by their celebrity, these famed holy, humble men stayed firmly anchored to Christ through a life of prayer, the sacraments and devoted service to the needy. Born in London in 1801, Newman rose to become one of the most influential Anglican clergyman of his time, as the chief organizer of the Oxford Movement. He sought to deepen the Catholic elements of the Church of England, but his writings eventually crossed a line, and he was censured. He soon converted to Catholicism in 1845 and was ordained a priest two years later. Entering the Church during a time of intense anti-Catholic animus in Britain, he knew what his conversion would mean and was not deterred — even his sister turned her back on him. “I have my mission,” he wrote, saying that God “has not created me for naught. I shall do good; I shall do his work. I shall be an angel of peace, a preacher of truth in my own place … if I do but keep his commandments and serve him in my calling” (Meditations and Devotions, 301-2). The author of some of the most important Catholic texts in the English language, Newman had intellectual gifts that were matched by his charitable service to the poor in the city of Birmingham — a legacy that brought 15,000 mourners to his funeral in 1890. During his homily at the 2010 Mass that marked Newman’s beatification, Pope Benedict XVI singled out his writings and sermons on the Christian call to holiness through an ever-deepening relationship with the Lord. “Cardinal Newman’s motto, Cor ad cor loquitur, or ‘Heart speaks unto heart,’ gives us an insight into his understanding of the Christian life as a call to holiness, experienced as the profound desire of the human heart to enter into intimate communion with the heart of God. He reminds us that faithfulness to prayer gradually transforms us into the divine likeness,” said the Pope. Benedict also highlighted the relevance of Newman’s writings on the “relationship between faith and reason” and the “need for a broadly based and wide-ranging approach to education.” Newman’s conception of education embraced an integrated vision of Christian life in which faith and reason work in unison and students absorb the lessons of history that confirm the need for inconvenient moral truths that protect a universal common good. An authentic Catholic education, he believed, would help prepare the faithful for a coming age of apostacy and persecution, when their courage and fortitude would be tested to the breaking point. As Newman himself put it: “I want a laity, not arrogant, not rash in speech, not disputatious, but men who know their religion, who enter into it, who know just where they stand, who know what they hold and what they do not, who know their creed so well that they can give an account of it, who know so much of history that they can defend it” (The Present Position of Catholics in England, ix, 390). Fulton Sheen was born in El Paso, Illinois, in 1895, almost a century after Cardinal Newman’s birth. Still, he shared both the British Catholic’s alarm at the steady encroachment of moral relativism and his commitment to prayer and charity. “Only those who live by faith really know what is happening in the world,” said Sheen. After his ordination in 1919, he taught at The Catholic University of America and led the Society for the Propagation of the Faith. His talents as an author and speaker were quickly recognized, and his popular television show, Life Is Worth Living, brought him national fame in the 1950s and 1960s. In 1966, he was named bishop of Rochester, New York. Bishop Sheen used his national pulpit on television to warn against the totalitarian lie of communism. Likewise, he spoke out against the rise of a therapeutic culture. Modern psychology, he argued, had downplayed personal responsibility and resisted moral judgments. While some contend America “is suffering from intolerance — it is not,” Sheen tartly observed. “It is suffering from tolerance. Tolerance of right and wrong, truth and error, virtue and evil, Christ and chaos. Our country is not nearly so overrun with the bigoted as it is overrun with the broadminded.” His acute guidance to fellow priests was equally spot-on. “The only defense against acedia, against the tragic loss of divine reality, is a daily renewal of faith in Christ,” he wrote in one book, The Priest Is Not His Own. “The priest who has not kept near the fires of the tabernacle can strike no sparks from the pulpit.” The televangelist followed his own advice and began his day with an hour before the Eucharist. Members of his New York household have also recalled his many acts of charity. After finding a man on the street who suffered from leprosy, for example, Sheen organized medical treatment and other assistance, and then he invited the man for weekly Friday night dinners. His ability to make such commitments reflected a striking simplicity of life. But it was also the fruit of his deep relationship with the Lord, the servant of the servants, who suffered and died for the salvation of the world. “We have a God,” said Archbishop Sheen, “who stumbled to his throne.” Those words are a fitting reminder today for a suffering Church, in need of forgiveness, healing and greater faith in the Risen Lord, to take heart in the witness of the triumph of God. We must celebrate the causes of these two holy priests who, despite temptations and challenges equal to those we encounter today, made their earthly pilgrimages a light for others. Blessed John Henry Newman and Archbishop Fulton Sheen, intercede for us.
I had a slight crisis of Faith last night thinking of the terrible state the Church is in. I just thoguh in a kind of weary despair, how could I be shackled to all this stuff? It is so rotten. I felt like just walking away from it all. I was very surprised by this. I thought my Faith was like a rock. After all I go to mass everyday, confession every week. Prayer cosntantly and fast. But still I felt me Faith wobbling quite a lot. It was pride really that caused me to think my Faith was rock like. Altough I do have a kind of half excuse in that things are really, really dark and grim. Thank the Good Lord I prayed over it and got the grace to get back o ncourse again. But I am reminded of a verse in the Book of the Apocalypse that speaks of God intervening , 'Lest even the just be lost'. It suddenly wa sborne home to me what a huge, hugetrail of Faith all this is. It's not a big trial I think mostly to those who don;t take their Faith seriously because well they couldn't care less anyway. But for those who do care and really are paying attention it really, really is a huge trial. I think we really are in the midst of the most intense purifying fire. That the Good Lord is really cleansing His Church of Fat right to its very bone, right to its very foundations. This is a work of the Lord and awesome to behold. It reminded me anyway how utterly repedant we are on God's grace. It humbled my pride at least a little bit which is always a good thing. But my experience indicated to me that perhaps there won;t be too many Catholics left after all this. Not too many at all, one way of the other.
I think this way all time. It is unsettling. You think you are following the prescription for Heaven, Mass, confession, prayer, Eucharist, etc and it gives you comfort that you have checked all the boxes. And it is sincere. But often I have a bucket of icy water poured on my face and I realize that doubts and worry creep in. Now especially I have doubts with everything that is going on. And then I don't have doubts. But I think we need to persevere, with God's help, until the end, our end. We need to stay the course. I ask everyday for the grace to persevere through this. I worry sometimes I won't but ask anyway.