Don't feel bad, I share your questions and I think they are reasonable and ones that any person has to ponder about Mr Grein's past, his family, and McCarrick's grooming as well. I spent some time online trying to figure out who his grandfather was and just don't have enough information to make a connection yet. I have been hoping that he would give another interview that would reveal an additional bit of information that one cold use to discover this. It seems that someone in his family was more deeply involved in this affair than he is either aware of or is disclosing IMO. This could of course be a completely innocent involvement that was taken advantage of but I am skeptical of that line of reasoning because all of this seems much more likely to have been very well planned and executed and began far prior to VII and the throwing open the windows etc of that time. I do believe Mr Grein. I think that it is easy to underestimate the control that abusers such as McCarrick held over Mr Grein if one has no experience with it. This is why; I witnessed someone grooming a young man this way when I was in my early 20's. The abuser was a close friend to me and was himself groomed and molested at a very young age by his neighbor. I confronted him threatening to call the police as well as tried to put a stop to the situation by speaking with the young mans parents and it was all for naught. The parents did not believe me and in fact encouraged the relationship and the Sheriff told me that unless the parents suspected something there was nothing they could do. The young man was 14, very impressionable, looked up to this guy who was in his early 20's and had been isolated slowly from both his friends and family when the abuse finally did take place. It became worse after the abuse was perpetrated and the young man was completely withdrawn from everyone. To the point that he actually defended his abuser. Mr Grein may well have intended to escape from this sort of situation by joining the Navy and trying to make a life for himself by getting away from both his parents and McCarrick but with the secrets he was carrying there is no way that he would build deep and lasting bonds with others. Especially other men which is vital. This I am sure led to loneliness and continued isolation on his part and is probably why when McCarrick reached out to him again he succumbed to his manipulations. One reason I believe Grein is due to how he describes the encounter. It seems these things always involves a tit for tat sort of payoff. He was taken to a baseball game and afforded seats a young man his age could never hope to afford etc, (a privileged event that makes him feel special) then he is probably given alcohol, taken somewhere and given more alcohol, finally he is mocked, humiliated, and abused. This is exactly the sort of behavior I witnessed minus the actual abuse of course. Also, given Grein's age and innocence he probably had some very deep guilt over any pleasure he had received in this abuse. I am sure that he buried this from everyone by remaining distanced and that it weighed heavily on his mind along with the humiliation he felt. He probably felt attracted to other men at that point knowing that it was gravely wrong. People that perpetrate these kind of crimes are simply the vilest of men because of the cunning involved and the total objectification of their victims. That he was a priest, then a bishop and was quickly promoted and became a cardinal only makes it that much more reprehensible. I share your misgivings about Mr Martin also. I think that he was a pawn in a publicized sort of disinformation campaign that was waged to deliberately confuse matters and buy time for the group of men who were hell bent on transforming the church into a new entity entirely.
What really gets me about all this abuse is that I was a young man in my 20's when I witnessed this sort of grooming behavior and clearly identified it before the actual abuse took place. I was never abused growing up but it was painfully obvious what was happening. Yet, we are told that such learned men as the church has in abundance, with the gifts of the Holy Spirit, who are the shepherds we rely on for Truth, who vow to look after us their sheep, and who were close to these situations and the men involved (some were even roommates!) say that they had not the faintest inkling that there was any sort of impropriety taking place. How can this be? It makes not one iota of sense to anyone with a rational mind and their head not fully buried in the sand.
https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/p...ts-in-private-pre-synod-study-meeting-in-rome PHOTO: Full list of participants in private pre-synod ‘study-meeting’ in Rome amazonian synod, pope francis, walter kasper ROME, June 26, 2019 (LifeSiteNews)— LifeSiteNews has obtained the list of participants in a private and unannounced Pre-Amazonian Synod “study-meeting,” held at a gated hilltop convent on the outskirts of Rome this week. A photograph of the full list of 30 participants, taken by this correspondent (see below), confirms that the three-day meeting included key German prelates and Vatican officials, some of whom support a relaxing in priestly celibacy in the Latin Church, and the idea of women priests. The list of participants, posted in the “Casa Nostra Signora Madre della Misericordia” where the meeting was held, includes the following names: Cardinal Claudio Hummes OFM, general relator of Amazonian Synod, President of REPAM (Germany-Brazil) Cardinal Pedro Barreto SJ, archbishop of Huancayo, vice president of REPAM (Peru) Cardinal Lorenzo Baldisseri, secretary general, Synod of Bishops (Italy) Cardinal Walter Kasper, president emeritus, Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity and close theological adviser to Pope Francis (Germany) Cardinal Christoph Schönborn, archbishop of Vienna, close theological adviser to Pope Francis (absent) (Austria) Bishop Erwin Kräutler, C.PP.S., emeritus of Xingu, Parà, member of pre-synodal council (Austria/Brazil) Bishop Franz-Josef Overbeck, bishop of Essen, Germany, president of Adveniat, episcopal humanitarian agency for Latin America (Germany) Father Michael Czerny SJ, co-secretary of Amazonian Synod (Canada) Patricia Gualinga, human rights activist of the Pueblo Kichwa de Sarayaku indigenous community (Ecuador) Sr. Alba Teresa Cediel Castillo, general councilor of the Missionary Congregation Mother Laura, expert on ethics and pedagogy (Colombia). Sr. Liliana Franco, of the Company of Mary Congregation, president of the Confederation of Latin American and Caribbean Religious (Colombia). Fr. Paolo Suess, liberation theology expert (Germany-Brazil) Fr. Victor Codina SJ, theologian (Spain-Bolivia) Fr. Fernando Roca Alcazar SJ, social anthropologists and ethnobotanist, Pontifical Catholic University (Peru) Fr. Pedro Hughes, Columban missionary, coordinator of REPAM (Ireland) Fr. Justino Sarmento Rezende, Salesian priest of the indigenous Tuyuca people (Brazil) Fr. Felipe Jaled Ali Modad Aguilar, SJ, Rector Parroquia, Bachajón Mission (Mexico) Fr. Agenor Brighenti, theologian, University of Louvain (Belgium) Fr. Paolo Garuti OP, professor of biblical theology, Pontifical University of St. Thomas Aquinas (Italy) Fr. Hubert Wolf, professor of theology and Church history, University of Munster (Germany) Prof. Myriam Wijlens, University of Erfurt (Germany) Prof. Peter Szabó, head of Institute of Canon Law, University of Budapest (Hungary) Prof. Serena Noceti, professor of systemic theology, Higher Institute of Religious Studies, Florence (Italy) Msgr. Josef Sayer, theologian, former chief executive, Misereor (Germany) Dina Guerra, program manager, Porticus, part of the heterodox Brenninkmeijer philanthropic organization helping to foster “human dignity, social justice and sustainability” (Germany-Netherlands). Mauricio López, executive secretary of REPAM (Ecuador). Bishop Eugenio Cotter, vicar apostolic of Pando, titular bishop of Tibiuca (Bolivia), member of pre-synodal council. Romina Gallegos, national coordinator, REPAM (Ecuador) Fr. Carlos Galli STD, close theological adviser to Pope Francis (Argentina) Miguel Cruz Moreno, indigenous peoples activist (Mexico) Unannounced meeting News of the unannounced meeting, along with a partial list of participants, came to light on June 25, through independent reports by respected Italian journalist Marco Tosatti, Edward Pentin of the National Catholic Register, and Maike Hickson of LifeSiteNews. In remarks to the Register, Vatican spokesman Alessandro Gisotti said the gathering was a “study meeting” of the Pan-Amazonian Ecclesial Network (REPAM). REPAM (The Pan-Amazonian Ecclesial Network) was set up in 2014 by the nine Churches of the Amazon region, Bolivia, Brazil, Colombia, Ecuador, French Guyana, Guyana, Peru, Surinam and Venezuela. “Inspired by Pope Francis and backed by the Latin American Bishops’ Conference, CELAM, it aims to “bring to the world’s attention the fragile situation of indigenous people in the Amazon and the critical importance of the Amazon biome to the planet — our common home.” Continued...
Gisotti also told the Register that participants included “ecclesial authorities, experts and representatives of the territory in view of the Synod on the Amazon,” but added that he was unable to give any details. “It’s a study meeting, not for the public,” he said, noting: “There will be others before the synod.” In subsequent comments to LifeSite, the Vatican spokesman confirmed that the meeting concluded on June 26. Not all pre-synod “study meetings” have been so private, however. In fact, a study seminar held in Rome on Feb. 25-27, 2019 — on the tail end of the Vatican abuse summit — was both pre-announced and widely publicized. It also drew controversy after one of its featured speakers suggested that the Vatican change the matter of the Eucharist from wheaten hosts to yuca in the Amazon. Key participants Key prelates among the participants are not known for their undying orthodoxy. Brazilian Cardinal Claudio Hummes, the general relator of the synod and president of REPAM, has for many years advocated a change in the discipline of priestly celibacy in the Latin Rite. A friend the Holy Father, Hummes gave him the inspiration to choose the name Francis. Walter Kasper, a close theological adviser to Pope Francis, recently said that if the conferences of the Amazon region agreed among themselves that married men could be priests, and proposed such a change to the Pope, the Holy Father “would in principle probably accept it.” In 2017, the French Catholic daily La Croix reported that “Cardinal Walter Kasper had told German media he believes Pope Francis favors ordaining married men of proven virtue (known by the Latin term, viri probati), but is also sure the pope wants to leave the decision up to individual bishops’ conferences.” Notable among the attendees was Austrian Bishop Emeritus Erwin Kräutler of the Territorial Prelature of Xingu in Brazil, whom Pope Francis appointed as an expert consultant to the synod. In his June 25 report, Edward Pentin noted that Kräutler has “argued for ordaining married men in the Amazon, and voiced his support for women priests. He is thought to have helped write the synod’s controversial working document published last week.” Also included was Bishop Franz-Josef Overbeck of Essen, Germany, head of the German bishops’ Latin America commission, which through its aid organization Adveniat provides significant financial and pastoral support to Latin America. Last month, Bishop Overbeck said the synod will lead the Church to a “point of no return,” and, thereafter, “nothing will be the same as it was,” Pentin noted. Cardinal Christoph Schönborn was unable to attend the meeting due to surgery for prostate cancer, his press spokesman, Michael Prüller told the Register. Growing concerns At the presentation of the synod’s controversial working document (Instrumentum laboris) on Monday, June 17, Cardinal Lorenzo Baldisseri, secretary general of the Synod of Bishops (who participated in the private meeting) said the upcoming Synod, titled “Amazonia, New Paths for the Church and for an Integral Ecology,” will be a time of “pastoral reflection, open to recognizing diversity” and “listening to the Amazonian reality with all its cultural and ecclesial facets.” Yet the working document, which will form the basis of discussion at the synod, has raised serious concerns over what many see as an overemphasis on listening to the Amazonian “voice,” a serving of a neo-pagan agenda, and a promotion of “so-called indigenist and ecological theology.” The working document has also been criticized for calling for an adaption of the “Eucharistic rite” to Amazonian culture, suggesting the ordaining “elders” with families to the priesthood, and proposing that an “official ministry” be conferred on women. It further suggests that it’s time to reconsider “the notion that the exercise of jurisdiction (power of government) must be linked in all areas (sacramental, judicial, administrative) and in a permanent way to the Sacrament of Holy Orders.” While the content of this week’s private gathering in Rome is unknown, papal biographer Austen Ivereigh said one of the purposes of the meeting was to prepare for the synod “a briefing on theological implications of ordaining married elders.” In his June 25 article, Pentin also noted that the “strong input” from German-speaking prelates and theologians “has led concerned observers to believe that the synod is a means of them imposing and implementing their own ideological agenda.” He noted that some find this “especially mystifying” given the “less-than-robust state of the Catholic Church in German-speaking countries and other Churches in Europe.” A source close to the Church in Germany told the Register that the Amazonian Synod is “not about rethinking things” as some have wished to portray it, but largely German theologians “activating old material.” The organizers, he said, “are getting old folders out of the cupboard and trying to implement the 1970s thinking within them.” In comments of a similar vein, Julio Lordo, a Peruvian journalist and author of “Liberation Theology, a life jacket for the poor made of lead” [Teologia della liberazione. Un salvagente di piombo per i poveri (Cantagalli, 2014)] told LifeSite last week that the “untold” backstory of the Amazon Synod is that it’s been decades in the making and is designed to “change the whole Church” according to “so-called indigenist and ecological theology.” “It is a whole revamping of the Church from an ‘Amazonian’ point of view, which is nothing else than the culmination of liberation theology.”
Please sign this petition to support Good Shepherd Cardinal Brandmuller, German Cardinal who signed the Dubia, who loves the Faith, and cares for the flock. 1000 was the original target for this petition, but it's already overshot that, in like 1 hour. Next target is 2500. If tens of thousands of Catholic Faithful take a more active role in holding bad Shepherds accountable, asking for them to be Anathematized and Excommunicated, and by giving good Shepherds every possible public support, then maybe, by the Grace of God, the tide will turn in the Church: https://lifepetitions.com/petition/...ndemning-amazon-synod-working-doc-as-apostasy PETITION: Support Cardinal who is condemning Amazon synod working doc as ‘apostasy’ 1,191 1 hour ago Cardinal Walter Brandmüller has condemned the working document (Instrumentum Laboris) of the upcoming 'Amazon Synod' as APOSTASY, i.e., total repudiation of the Christian faith. Please SIGN this petition now, as a demonstration of support both for Cardinal Brandmüller AND for the stand he is taking against heresy and apostasy at the highest levels of the Church. The Catechism of the Catholic Church (2089) defines "heresy" as: "The obstinate post-baptismal denial of some truth which must be believed with divine and catholic faith, or it is likewise an obstinate doubt concerning the same." And, the same paragraph (2089) goes on to define "apostasy" as: "The total repudiation of the Christian faith." "Heresy" and "Apostasy" are two words which should NEVER be used to describe any document which will be used to guide the work of an upcoming Synod of Bishops! And yet, Cardinal Brandmüller has just condemned the working document of the upcoming 'Amazon Synod' as both HERESY AND APOSTASY. Indeed, his stinging rebuke declares that this working document must be REJECTED! "The Instrumentum Laboris for the Amazon Synod constitutes an attack on the foundations of the Faith, and in a way that has not heretofore been thought possible. Thus it must be rejected with all decisiveness." In just under four pages (please click on the link below to read the statement in full), Cardinal Brandmüller critiques the faulty theology and philosophy which is at the heart of this working document. Specifically, the Cardinal takes issue with the working document’s "very positive assessment of natural religions, to include indigenous healing practices and the like, yes, even mythical-religious practices and forms of cults," adding that the very "notion of inculturation is here virtually being perverted." Cardinal Brandmüller then goes on to criticize the working document for pushing the "abolishment of celibacy" and introducing a path to "female priesthood": "It is impossible to conceal that the ‘synod’ is especially to help implement two most cherished projects that heretofore have never been implemented: namely, the abolishment of celibacy and the introduction of a female priesthood – starting first with female deacons. In any event, it is about ‘accepting the role, the leadership of the woman inside the Church’ (129a3). In a similar manner, there now ‘open up new spaces for the creation of new ministries, as this historic moment calls for it. It is time to listen to the voice of the Amazon region…’ (no. 43)" At the same time, the Cardinal reminds the world (and, the authors of the working document) how Pope John Paul II had already "stated with highest magisterial authority that it is not in the power of the Church to administer the Sacrament of Holy Orders to women." For all of these major affronts to the faith, Cardinal Brandmüller concludes his criticism by declaring: "It is to be stated now with insistence that the Instrumentum Laboris contradicts the binding teaching of the Church in decisive points and thus has to be qualified as heretical." "Inasmuch as even the fact of Divine Revelation is here being questioned, or misunderstood, one also now has to speak, additionally, of apostasy." In defense of the faith and in defense of the noble Cardinal, who is valiantly fighting for the faithful and on behalf of the Divine Redeemer, Himself, we now call on you to SIGN this petition. Please SIGN this petition if you REJECT heresy and apostasy! Thank you! FOR MORE INFORMATION: Cardinal Brandmüller's critique of the Instrumentum Laboris (working document) for the forthcoming Synod of Bishops (Amazon Synod) - https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/c...retical...apostasy-urges-bishops-to-reject-it Timeline Thu Jun 27, 2019 - 4:59 AM EST Petition Launched!"
Yep. Same here. Also had a First Communion catechist refer to the Body and Blood of Our Lord as a symbol. She was not pleased when I said very boldly (back when I had fortitude) " it is NOT a symbol. It is the REAL Body and Blood of Christ truly present on the altar. The children must be told the truth."
Sometimes what our deeper selves perceive and warn of seems preposterous to our ordinary worldly selves so we look away. I saw this in the early 80's when I knew of clerical abuse of seminarians and tried to speak of it. Very hostile reactions. My poor cousin experienced this in the seminary and left--thank God. So I had first hand knowledge. The dates of Bernardin's disturbing behavior go back to the early 50's so this is not something that began in the 70's but perhaps it accelerated by then.
Yes, I agree...things really are that bad...... Pray that we all have live in the grace to survive His Justice....because it is coming. Let us be ready.
I totally believe him... And I pity him. These devils can kill the soul...poor man is just hanging on. He needs our prayers...as well as the thousands of other victims,...some who will never go public.
Cardinal critiques Amazon synod working doc as ‘heretical…apostasy’, urges bishops to ‘reject’ it Maike Hickson | https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/c...retical...apostasy-urges-bishops-to-reject-it PETITION: Support Cardinal who is condemning Amazon synod working doc as ‘apostasy’. Sign the petition here. June 27, 2019 (LifeSiteNews) – Cardinal Walter Brandmüller, one of the two remaining dubia cardinals, issued today a strong critique of the Vatican’s working document (Instrumentum Laboris) for the upcoming Pan-Amazon Synod, calling it “heretical” and an “apostasy” from Divine Revelation. He called upon Church leaders to “reject” it with “all decisiveness.” “It is to be stated now with insistence that the Instrumentum Laboris contradicts the binding teaching of the Church in decisive points and thus has to be qualified as heretical,” the 90-year-old German prelate wrote in a document (read below) that was published simultaneously by LifeSiteNews and Austrian news website Kath.net. “Inasmuch as even the fact of Divine Revelation is here being questioned, or misunderstood, one also now has to speak, additionally, of apostasy,” Cardinal Brandmüller, who is a world renowned-scholar of church history, stated. The Catechism of the Catholic Church (2089) defines “heresy” as: “The obstinate post-baptismal denial of some truth which must be believed with divine and Catholic faith, or it is likewise an obstinate doubt concerning the same.” The same paragraph (2089) goes on to define “apostasy” as: “The total repudiation of the Christian faith.” The Cardinal said that the focus of having a synod in a region with a relatively small population, which is half the size of Mexico City, is “cause for suspicion concerning the true intentions” behind the meeting of Catholic bishops. He questioned why nearly three-quarters of the topics treated in the June 17 document, prepared for the October synod, are only marginally related to “the Gospels and the Church.” The Cardinal takes issue with the working document’s “very positive assessment of natural religions, including indigenous healing practices and the like, even mythical-religious practices and forms of cults,” adding that the very “notion of inculturation is perverted in the document.” Cardinal Brandmüller then goes on to criticize the working document for pushing the “abolishment of celibacy” and introducing a path to “female priesthood.” “It is impossible to conceal that the ‘synod’ intends to help implement two most cherished projects that heretofore have never been implemented: namely, the abolishment of celibacy and the introduction of a female priesthood – starting first with female deacons. In any event, it is about ‘accepting the role, the leadership of the woman inside the Church’ (129a3). In a similar manner, there now ‘open up new spaces for the creation of new ministries, as this historic moment calls for it. It is time to listen to the voice of the Amazon region…’ (no. 43),” he wrote. The Cardinal brought forward how Pope John Paul II had already “stated with highest magisterial authority that it is not in the power of the Church to administer the Sacrament of Holy Orders to women.” In his 1994 Apostolic Letter Ordinatio Sacerdotalis, John Paul II declared that the Church has "no authority whatsoever to confer priestly ordination on women and that this judgment is to be definitively held by all the Church's faithful." The German prelate went on to criticize the working document for its “direct attack on the hierarchical-sacramental constitution of the Church, when it is being asked as to whether it would not be opportune ‘to reconsider the notion that the exercise of jurisdiction (power of government) must be linked in all areas (sacramental, judicial, administrative) and in a permanent way to the Sacrament of Holy Orders’ (no. 127).” In conclusion, Brandmüller stated that “we are witnessing a new form of the classical Modernism of the early 20th century” in this document, which is linked with a false understanding of the development of dogma, which “is sharply opposed to the genuine Catholic understanding.” Thus, certain aspects of the working document have to be assessed as either “heretical,” or even as a form of “apostasy,” he stated. “The Instrumentum Laboris for the Amazon Synod constitutes an attack on the foundations of the Faith, and in a way that has not heretofore been thought possible. Thus it must be rejected with all decisiveness,” he added. LifeSiteNews has created a petition in support of Cardinal Brandmüller that can be found here. *** continued...
continued from above... A Critique of the Instrumentum Laboris for the Amazon Synod By Cardinal Walter Brandmüller June 27, 2019 Introduction It can truly cause astonishment that, in opposition to earlier assemblies, this time the Synod of Bishops is exclusively to deal with a region of the earth whose population is just half of that one of Mexico City, that is to say, 4 million. This is also a cause for suspicion concerning the true intentions which are to be implemented in a clandestine fashion. But one has to ask especially about the understanding of religion, of Christianity, and of the Church, which is the basis of the recently published Instrumentum Laboris. This shall be examined with the help of individual elements from the text. Why a Synod on this region? One has to ask in principle why a Synod of Bishops should deal with topics, which – as is now the case with ¾ of the Instrumentum Laboris – have, at the most, very little to do with the Gospels and the Church. Obviously, the Synod of Bishops with this document makes an aggressive intrusion into the purely worldly affairs of the state and society of Brazil. What do ecology, economy, and politics have to do with the mandate and mission of the Church? And more importantly: what professional expertise authorizes an ecclesial Synod of Bishops to make statements in these fields? Should the Synod of Bishops truly do this, this would be a stepping over boundaries and a clericalist presumption, which the state authorities would then have to reject. On Natural Religions and Inculturation Furthermore, throughout the whole Instrumentum Laboris can be found a very positive assessment of natural religions, to include indigenous healing practices and the like; yes, even mythical-religious practices and forms of cults. In the context of the call for harmony with nature, there is talk about the dialogue with the spirits (no. 75). It is not only the ideal of the “noble savage” as presented by Rousseau and the Enlightenment that is being contrasted with the decadent European. The line of thought in the Instrumentum goes further, up to the turn to the 20th century, ending in a pantheistic idolatry of nature. Hermann Claudius (1913) created the hymn of the Socialist Worker's Movement, “When we walk side by side...,” a stanza of which reads: “Birches' green and the green of seeds, how the old Mother Earth extends her full hands, with a pleading gesture, that man may become her own...” It is remarkable that this text was later copied into the songbook of the Hitler Youth, probably because it corresponded to the National-Socialist blood-and-soil myth. The ideological proximity with the Instrumentum is remarkable. The anti-rational rejection of the “western” culture which stresses the importance of reason is characteristic of the Instrumentum Laboris, which speaks in no. 44 of “Mother Earth” and of the “cry of the earth and of the peoples” (no. 101) respectively. Accordingly, the territory – that is to say, the forests of the Amazon region – is declared to be a locus theologicus, a special source of Divine Revelation. There are places of an epiphany where the planet's reserves of life and wisdom show themselves, which speak of God (no. 19). The anti-rational rejection of the “western” culture that stresses the importance of reason is characteristic of the Instrumentum Laboris. Meanwhile, the subsequent regression from Logos to Mythos is being raised to a criterion of that which the Instrumentum Laboris calls the inculturation of the Church. The result is a natural religion with a Christian masquerade. The notion of inculturation is perverted in the document, since it proposes the opposite of what the International Theological Commission had presented in 1988 and of what the Second Vatican Council's Decree on the Church's Missionary Activity, Ad Gentes, taught. On the Abolishment of Celibacy and the Introduction of a Female Priesthood It is impossible to conceal that the “synod” intends especially to help implement two most cherished projects that heretofore have never been implemented: namely, the abolishment of celibacy and the introduction of a female priesthood – starting first with female deacons. In any event, it is about “accepting the role, the leadership of the woman inside the Church” (129a3). In a similar manner, there now “open up new spaces for the creation of new ministries, as this historic moment calls for it. It is time to listen to the voice of the Amazon region...” (no. 43). But here the fact is omitted that, lastly, John Paul II also stated with highest magisterial authority that it is not in the power of the Church to administer the Sacrament of Holy Orders to women. Indeed, in two thousand years, the Church has never administered the Sacrament of Holy Orders to a woman. The demand which stands in direct opposition to this fact shows that the word “Church” is now being used purely as a sociological term on the part of the authors of the Instrumentum Laboris, thus implicitly denying the sacramental-hierarchical character of the Church. On Denying the Sacramental-Hierarchical Character of the Church In a similar manner – though expressed in passing – no. 127 contains a direct attack on the hierarchical-sacramental constitution of the Church, when it is being asked whether it would not be opportune “to reconsider the notion that the exercise of jurisdiction (power of government) must be linked in all areas (sacramental, judicial, administrative) and in a permanent way to the Sacrament of Holy Orders." (no. 127) From such an erroneious view stems (in no. 129) the call for the creation of new offices which correspond to the needs of the Amazonian peoples. The liturgy, the cult, however, is the field in which the ideology of a falsely understood inculturation finds its expression in an especially spectacular manner. Here, certain forms of the natural religions are positively adopted. The Instrumentum Laboris does not hold back from demanding that the “poor and simple peoples” may express “their (!) faith with the help of pictures, symbols, traditions, rites, and other sacraments” (!!) (no. 126e). This certainly does not correspond to the precepts of the Constitution “Sacrosanctum Concilium,” nor to the ones of the Decree on the Church's Missionary Activity, Ad Gentes, and it shows a purely horizontal understanding of liturgy. Conclusion Summa summarum: The Instrumentum Laboris burdens the Synod of Bishops, and finally the Pope, with a grave breach with the depositum fidei, which in its consequence means the self-destruction of the Church or the change of the Corpus Christi mysticum into a secular NGO with an ecological-social-psychological mandate. After these observations, of course there are questions: is there to be found, especially with regard to the sacramental-hierarchical structure of the Church, a decisive breach with the Apostolic Tradition as it is constitutive for the Church, or do the authors rather have a notion of the development of doctrine which is theologically presented in order to justify these above-mentioned breaches? This seems to be indeed the case. We are witnessing a new form of the classical Modernism of the early 20th century. At the time, starting with a decisively evolutionary approach, one presented the idea that, in accord with the continuous higher development of man, are found also higher levels of consciousness and of culture, whereby it can turn out that that which had been false yesterday, can be true today. This evolutionary dynamic then applies to religion, as well, that is to say, to the religious consciousness with its manifestations in doctrine and in cult – of course also in morality. However, the understanding of the development of dogma presupposed to this view is sharply opposed to the genuine Catholic understanding. The latter understands development of dogma and of Church, not as a change, but, rather, as an organic development of the subject which remains true to its own identity. That is what the two Vatican Councils teach us in their Constitutions “Dei Filius,” “Lumen Gentium,” and “Dei Verbum.” It is to be stated now with insistence that the Instrumentum Laboris contradicts the binding teaching of the Church in decisive points and thus has to be qualified as heretical. Inasmuch as even the fact of Divine Revelation is here being questioned, or misunderstood, one also now has to speak, additionally, of apostasy. This is even more justified in light of the fact that the Instrumentum Laboris uses a purely immanentist notion of religion and that it considers religion as the result and form of expression of man's own spiritual self-experience. The use of Christian words and notions cannot conceal that these are being merely used as empty words, despite their original meaning. The Instrumentum Laboris for the Amazon Synod constitutes an attack on the foundations of the Faith, and in a way that has not heretofore been thought possible. Thus it must be rejected with all decisiveness.
WINDSWEPT OR STRUCK BY LIGHTNING?? The Root Of A Crisis June 26, 2019 by sd Some may recall the Malachi Martin book on the Church called Windswept House — a brilliant title and one that plants itself smack in the middle of our time. “Windswept House describes a satanic ritual — the enthronement of Lucifer – taking place at Saint Paul’s Chapel inside Vatican City, on June 29, 1963,” notes Wikipedia. “The book gives a depiction of high-ranking churchmen, cardinals, archbishops and prelates of the Roman curia, taking oaths signed with their own blood, plotting to destroy the Church from within.” Got to be very careful with such stuff (windswept or lightningstruck?) “The author, long deceased, described the book as containing ‘real events and real people masked in the form of a novel,’ a device he refers to as ‘faction.’ According to Martin, 95% of events in the book are real, and 85% of the characters are real people.” .....MORE: https://spiritdailyblog.com/church/the-root-of-a-crisis
I wonder what Cupich would have been had he not gone into ministry. I also wonder if any of these people are getting nervous.
“The children must be told the truth." AMEN AED! No matter what, but especially on this! Good for you!!
Published on Jun 27, 2019 EDWARD PENTIN, Rome correspondent for The National Catholic Register reports on this week's study group on the Amazonian Synod that convened at the Vatican, Cardinal Walter Brandmüller's critique of the Synod's working document and more. DAMIAN THOMPSON, editor-in-chief of The Catholic Herald joins us with analysis of the recent controversy over a court ordered abortion in the UK and the major Catholic stories of the week. REGGIE LITTLEJOHN, president of Women's Rights Without Frontiers on the plight of girls and widows in Communist China and her testimony on the issue before the United Nations Human Rights Council. Edited to add: *** Jun. 27, 2019 Synod Doc is ‘Attack on the Foundations of the Faith,’ says Cardinal The instrumentum laboris “constitutes an attack on the foundations of the faith” in a way not thought possible before, says Cardinal Walter Brandmüller Edward Pentin | http://www.ncregister.com/blog/edwa...cument-is-attack-on-the-foundations-of-the-fa Cardinal Walter Brandmüller has firmly criticized the working document of the upcoming Amazonian Synod, saying “decisive points” are “heretical” and that it constitutes an “attack on the foundations of the faith.” In a June 27 commentary the president emeritus of the Pontifical Committee for Historical Sciences also said the document “burdens” the Synod of Bishops with a “grave breach” of the deposit of faith which he believes will either result in the Church’s “self-destruction,” or reduce her to a “secular NGO with an ecological-social-psychological mandate.” The German cardinal began his critique, published jointly at LifeSiteNews and Kathnet, by calling it “truly astonishing” that the synod, which takes place in Rome Oct. 6-27, deals exclusively with a region whose population is “just half that of Mexico City.” He added this leads to “suspicion concerning the true intentions” of the synod, “which are to be implemented in a clandestine fashion.” He also questioned the “understanding of religion, of Christianity, and of the Church” given the basis of the working document, called an instrumentum laboris, published June 17. Three-quarters of the lengthy text, he said, have “very little to do with the Gospels and the Church,” and he asserted it makes an “aggressive intrusion” into Brazil’s world and state affairs. “What do ecology, economy, and politics have to do with the mandate and mission of the Church?” he asked, and queried what “professional expertise” the synodal bishops have to make such statements. Cardinal Brandmüller then took to task the document’s “very positive assessment of natural religions,” saying it not only represents the discredited “ideal of the ‘noble savage’” presented by the 18th-century French philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau, but “goes further,” promoting a “pantheistic idolatry of nature.” It is an ideology close to one favored by the National Socialists and reminiscent of a text found in a Hitler Youth textbook, he said, and characterized it as an “anti-rational rejection of ‘western’ culture,” one that speaks of “Mother Earth” and the “cry of the earth and of the peoples.” He also denounced the idea found in the working document that the Amazonian territory is a “special source of Divine Revelation” and argued that it elevates “natural religion with a Christian masquerade.” The notion of inculturation is “perverted in the document,” he said, and is the “opposite” of what the Vatican and the Second Vatican Council have taught. Turning to the abolition of priestly celibacy and ordination of women as priests, he said the synod “especially intends” to help implement them. Quoting passages to buttress this assertion, he noted that the document omits Pope St. John Paul II’s definitive teaching that it is not in the Church’s power to ordain women. This demonstrates, the cardinal said, that the “Church” is being used as a “sociological term” by the working document’s authors, thus “implicitly denying the sacramental hierarchical character of the Church.” A “direct attack” on this character can be found in paragraph no. 127, he added, which asks that the “exercise of jurisdiction (power of government)” and its link with all areas, sacramental, judicial, administrative, be reconsidered in a “permanent way” to Holy Orders. He ascribes this passage to a “falsely understood inculturation” where certain forms of “natural religions are positively adopted.” Such inculturation, he said, “does not correspond” to the Second Vatican Council constitutions on the liturgy and missionary activity, but rather “shows a purely horizontal understanding of liturgy.” In conclusion, he expressed concern that the document represented a “grave breach with the depositum fidei” which if approved would mean the Church’s self-destruction or the “change of the Corpus Christi mysticum into a secular NGO.” He also asked if the authors intended a decisive breach with apostolic tradition or wished to favor a “development of doctrine.” Cardinal Brandmüller suspected it was the former, and asserted we are “witnessing a new form of the classical Modernism of the early 20th century.” But such an understanding of development is “sharply opposed” to “genuine” Catholic understanding, he said, adding that it "is to be emphatically stated that the instrumentum laboris contradicts the binding teaching of the Church on decisive points, and is therefore to be qualified as heretical.” “Inasmuch as even the fact of Divine Revelation is here being questioned, or misunderstood, one also now has to speak, additionally, of apostasy,” he added. The document uses “a purely immanentist notion of religion” he said, and that Christian words and notions are used “as empty words.” The instrumentum laboris “constitutes an attack on the foundations of the faith” in a way not thought possible before, he concluded. “It must therefore be firmly and decidedly rejected,” Cardinal Brandmüller said. *** May God bless and protect Cardinal Brandmüller. PETITION: Please support Cardinal Brandmüller who is condemning Amazon synod working doc as ‘apostasy’. Sign the petition here. TY! *** Related reading: Jun. 27, 2019 Amazon Synod Mission Abandoned? COMMENTARY: The footnotes to the synod’s working document indicate that it is at odds with how the Church — including Pope Francis — has traditionally taught about the mission. Father Raymond J. de Souza | http://www.ncregister.com/daily-news/amazon-synod-mission-abandoned Jun. 27, 2019 Evangelizing the Amazon and the Gift of Priestly Celibacy COMMENTARY: Will the proposed change in discipline lead to a holier clergy and a holier Church, or will it weaken the Church’s mission to evangelize and make saints of those in the Amazon and elsewhere? Fr. Roger Landry | http://www.ncregister.com/blog/fath...-the-amazon-and-the-gift-of-priestly-celibacy Fri Jun 28, 2019 - 11:09 am EST BREAKING: Pre-Amazon Synod private meeting calls for female diaconate, Vatican in attendance Diane Montagna | https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/a...ls-for-female-diaconate-vatican-in-attendance *** This interview is very good and they give an example why Cardinal Parolin* would not make a good pope, definitely not the "Angelic Pope" that is for sure. They also explain why most clergy do not encourage the study of the end times, it's too gloom and doom. Why would anyone want to think about dying? - Maybe because we are all going to die someday? *Ref. https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/v...immigration-politician-commends-italy-to-mary Italy's Catholic establishment faults Salvini for rosary Associated Press•May 20, 2019| https://news.yahoo.com/italys-catholic-establishment-faults-salvini-rosary-155059193.html ROME (AP) — Italian Interior Minister Matteo Salvini is defending his invocation of God at a political rally, after Italy's Catholic establishment criticized it as a cynical exploitation of faith ahead of European Parliament elections this weekend. Salvini brandished a rosary and entrusted Italy to the Virgin Mary at the Saturday rally, which featured a host of far-right European leaders. He spoke glowingly of St. John Paul II and retired Pope Benedict XVI for having tried to remind Europe of its Christian roots. The Vatican's secretary of state, Cardinal Pietro Parolin, said God was for everyone and "invoking him for yourself is always very dangerous." [ emphasis added] An Italian Jesuit close to Pope Francis, the Rev. Antonio Spadaro, denounced the use of the rosary at a political rally and invocation of God for political campaigning.
What is wrong with these people...he needs to be applauded! Pope Francis’s Jesuit friend is catholic? Really? Not!
Here we go.....again....I'm sure he stuck around to offer his personal services to care for those he then leaves to the efforts and responsibility of those he condemns. Perhaps he needs to get up to snuff on the entire crisis by meeting with the Angel mothers. Nice photo op w/ no drug or sex traffickers/cartels/gangs around to be seen. Activist Bishop Escorts Migrants Across U.S. Border from Mexico The bishop of El Paso, Texas, personally escorted a group of seven Latin American migrants who had previously been denied asylum in the United States across the border into the U.S. on Thursday, reports say. Bishop Mark Seitz accompanied a Cuban, a young man from El Salvador, and a family of five back across the bridge from Ciudad Juarez to the United States. Seitz told the online Catholic site Crux that the 9-year-old daughter of the family took his hand as they crossed the bridge, where these individuals “who never should have been returned in the first place” were met by border officials. Despite an exchange of “tense” words, the migrants were eventually all allowed entry back into the United States. Before embarking on the walk across the bridge from Mexico, Bishop Seitz offered an impassioned denunciation of the U.S. government’s immigration policies. “A government and society which view fleeing children and families as threats; a government which treats children in U.S. custody worse than animals; a government and society who turn their backs on pregnant mothers, babies and families and make them wait in Ciudad Juarez without a thought to the crushing consequences on this challenged city … This government and this society are not well,” Seitz told the crowd that had gathered. “We suffer from a life-threatening case of hardening of the heart. In a day when we prefer to think that prejudice and intolerance are problems of the past, we have found a new acceptable group to treat as less than human, to look down upon and to fear. And should they speak another language or are brown or black, well, it is that much easier to stigmatize them,” he said. Seitz said the policies reflected a “heart-sick government and society” in an apparent call for open borders to the United States. “Would we rather they die on the banks of the Rio Grande than trouble us with their presence?” he asked. “We Americans need our hearts checked. Our hearts have grown too cold and too hard and that bodes ill for the health of our nation,” he said. On Wednesday, Bishop Seitz said he intended to make a public demonstration at the border to shine a light on the “devastating consequences of inhumane border policies.” The Remain in Mexico program requires asylum seekers to wait in Mexico where “inhumane and unsafe conditions” often prevail, Crux noted. Curiously, in his speech, Bishop Seitz did not comment on how to improve the inhumane conditions for migrants in Mexico but limited his remarks to criticizing the United States. “Every day the U.S. is sending up to 300 asylum seekers to one of the most dangerous places in Mexico with nothing and no one to help them,” he said. “This deserves our attention and all our efforts to change this ill-thought policy.” The United States currently takes in an average of a million legal immigrants every year, the largest number of migrants received into any nation in the world by almost two to one over the next largest. The number of immigrants currently living in the country is approaching 45 million, more than three times as many as there were in 1980. https://www.breitbart.com/faith/201...corts-migrants-across-u-s-border-from-mexico/