The Vatican Has Fallen

Discussion in 'Church Critique' started by padraig, Dec 31, 2016.

  1. OPINION: NATHAN PHILLIPS’ ATTEMPT TO SHUT DOWN MASS NOTHING SHORT OF DIABOLICAL

    Just as it seemed we were settling into the waning phase of the Covington Catholic news cycle, a bombshell broke on Tuesday evening. The Catholic News Agency reported that Nathan Phillips, along with a group of approximately 20 demonstrators, attempted to force their way into the National Shrine Basilica in Washington, D.C. to shut down the Vigil Mass on Saturday evening while “playing drums and chanting.”

    If that’s the case, can we drop the pretense that the attack on the Covington teens has been anything short of diabolical?

    Phillips, the Omaha tribal elder who was all-but-canonized by secular progressives and media figures over the weekend for his “peaceful” confrontation with a group of Catholic students from Covington, Kentucky in Washington for the March for Life, led a raucous group of protestors in an effort to disrupt a Catholic Mass just 24 hours after the initial confrontation on the steps of the Lincoln Memorial.

    A guard who was working security at the Shrine told Catholic News Agency that Basilica staff were forced to “lock the doors and everything” to prevent the “angry” protestors from succeeding in shutting down the Mass. “It’s a house of worship, a place of prayer where people come to celebrate,” a security guard told CNA News. “All this anger is so against what we are all about here.”

    While progressives, journalists, celebrities and would-be “woke” conservative leaders were piling on the Covington Catholic kids for cheering, dancing, and smirking too much, the “hero” of the story — Nathan Phillips, the oh-so-wonderful Omaha tribal elder who could do no wrong — was setting religious tolerance and pluralism back centuries by attempting to deny hundreds of faithful Catholics their First Amendment right to freely exercise their faith.

    Thank God he failed.

    To say the least, this is an affront to our nation’s long history of cherishing the freedom of religion. America was founded upon the fundamental idea that all men have the right to worship their God freely, without interference. Phillips’ hateful stunt, perhaps channeling the anti-Christian id of the progressive movement, must be condemned forcefully as beyond the pale and out of bounds by both political leaders and media figures alike.

    Otherwise, our nation’s polarization will reach a point of no return as anti-Christian activists across the country will be emboldened and begin descending on churches en masse, knowing that their protests will be seen by at least part of the country as justified and righteous. At that point, we’re looking at sectarian conflict unlike anything this country has seen in recent history.

    A great deal of people gave Nathan Phillips the virtual equivalent of a bear-hug over the weekend, in large part because they hated the red-hatted pro-life kids he went out of his way to confront. It’s time for them to start walking that praise and adulation back. If the false accounts he provided to the media about his interaction with the Covington kids weren’t enough to convince, perhaps his would-be attempt to frighten and intimidate a church full of faithful Catholics will be.

    This is a pivotal moment in our culture and in our politics. Progressives must be made to either defend Phillips’ actions or condemn them. An attack on any faith group in their house of worship — Catholics, Protestants, Jews, Muslims, Sikhs, et al — is completely reprehensible and anti-American. If progressives find a way to justify Nathan Phillips’ outrageous — even diabolical — attack on Catholics attending Mass, then we are done here. There’s nothing left for us to talk about.

    https://dailycaller.com/2019/01/22/nathan-phillips-diabolical/
     
    Beth B, Tanker and HeavenlyHosts like this.
  2. We need more warriors like this. This power grab now for decades by the corrupt powers taking over the country has to be answered. It's time for those who want things to change to stand up and be counted. We should pray for this man and those who help him. He's a real bull dog and has had successes in defending the underdogs. This time he's apparently doing it for nothing. These types need to feel the pain they inflict on others....best place they feel is in their bank accounts.

    Atty. Robert Barnes on FOX and Friends: We’re Giving Major Media, Celebrities 48 Hours to Retract and Apologize to Covington Kids or Face Lawsuit (VIDEO)

    Barnes is giving major media and celebrities 48 hours to retract and apologize or face a lawsuit.

    MORE:

    https://www.thegatewaypundit.com/20...gize-to-covington-kids-or-face-lawsuit-video/
    ========================================================

    Interesting video about the man and how the law firm is modeled.....like the Swiss Guard!:

    https://www.barneslawllp.com/about/
     
    Beth B, Tanker, Carol55 and 1 other person like this.
  3. Hope he includes the local Bishop who defamed these boys and, unless he has just done so, hasn't apologized. Secular priests can have bank accounts, property, and stocks, etc. If he wants to identify with the globalists and defend these so called social justice hideous attacks on his own flock let him feel a little of what these families feel and correct himself, repent and make amends.
     
    Fatima, Tanker, djmoforegon and 2 others like this.
  4. DeGaulle

    DeGaulle Powers

    I'd be grateful for references to published unorthodox and undisclaimed material, written by Martin. I would ask you to take into consideration that, for example, many of the types of Jesus portrayed in a book like 'Jesus Now', might have been intended for illustrative purposes, for the sake of argument, rather than being endorsed by the author.

    The other material has been in the public space for many years. It has not been substantially corroborated. I am aware of them, and of the possibility that they could be true. Whatever the truth of these matters, it doesn't provide sufficient grounds, in my opinion, to obviate entirely the possibility that he might have been getting at the truth. It is just enough, in my opinion, to warrant the taking of copious grains of salt, which in itself is probably for the best given the nature of the subjects in question.

    There have always been flawed individuals who, in spite of them, achieved great good. Indeed, I'd take them to be the rule rather than the exception.

    However, I am grateful for your caution, because perhaps I might have been overly complacent about him. The same can be said of Dr Marshall's video. We must all be wary of putting our trust in any mere man.
     
  5. DeGaulle

    DeGaulle Powers

    Now, that's the spirit!
     
    djmoforegon likes this.
  6. Blizzard

    Blizzard thy kingdom come

    SteveD and DeGaulle like this.
  7. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    Steve is merely reading from one of the captions on the book jacket. I'm sure he hasn't read it. That is not what Fr. Martin is espousing in the book at all.

    This is how rumors get started!!!

    If someone is going to comment on a piece of writing, please at least have the courtesy to read it.
    Is that too much to ask?

    Fr. Martin is not denying the Second Coming. He is using a literary technique to point out to people that Jesus never left us. It's not like He is "gone" and He will return. He is here with us now. Ever present. Jesus Now. That is the entire meaning of the title. That is a far cry from denying the Second Coming of Christ, something that all Christians, Catholic or not, believe.

    My goodness. It's sad that I should even need to state this.
     
    Last edited: Jan 23, 2019
  8. AED

    AED Powers

    Thank you. True. True. True.
     
  9. Beth B

    Beth B Beth Marie

    DeGaulle likes this.
  10. Beth B

    Beth B Beth Marie


    I too wondered how they commented on it on the video without reading it....hopefully they are getting schooled on it and revise their position...if their opinion changes...

    Thank you...
     
    Praetorian likes this.
  11. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    Yes it is very shoddy research and people coming at something with an agenda plain and simple. It only took me some minimal research to check some of their "facts" and they were wrong on many things both with Fr. Martin and other things they commented on.
     
    Booklady, sterph and Beth B like this.
  12. Beth B

    Beth B Beth Marie


    You know, I suspected the same...but I didn’t do my homework on it. I questioned a lot of their assumptions.
    I think...think...they said that he might not have supported the papacy. I distinctly remembering Martin saying that although he felt the church organization was corrupt , that he fully supported the papacy...in the strongest terms. I’ve listened to most all of his interviews numerous times. He might not have been perfect, but I never had the feeling that he didn’t believe in what he said. It’s quite possible that he left the Jesuits because he could no longer embrace their agenda.
    I guess we’ll never know the whole truth...but I don’t think that interview was it. Not intentional, just not fully vetted. Good guys, but missed the mark I fear.
     
    Booklady and Praetorian like this.
  13. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    Yes Dr. Marshall and Tim said Fr. Martin was a sedevacantist, which is not in any way true. Fr. Martin stated several times during recorded interviews in the last years of his life (which was the time frame in which Dr. Marshall said he was a sedevacantist) that John Paul II was his Pope. If they had listened to any of his interviews they would have known this.

    One thing Fr. Martin did feel was that the Novus Ordo Mass was mostly invalid. He said it could be valid if done correctly, but that more often than not it was invalid due to defects introduced by the priests. His thought process (and I am not saying I agree with him here) was that it is better to go to a Mass that is illicit, but valid rather than one that is licit, but invalid. I think this is why he was somewhat forgiving of the sedevacantists. Though he did not agree with them on the vacancy of the Papacy, he knew they had valid sacraments, which they do. Valid, but illicit. He said something along the lines of "If you're thirsty go where there is water." Meaning better valid, but illicit Eucharist than no Eucharist. So that is something that I would say is a valid criticism of him, but not one that Dr. Marshall and Tim made. Simply put they misunderstood his position and the entire issue.
     
    Last edited: Jan 23, 2019
    Booklady, SgCatholic, Beth B and 2 others like this.
  14. It's not enough that the secular globalists/Dims keep working to eliminate our Constitutional freedoms like free speech, assembly, gun rights, et al, now we have this failure of a "pastor" making life even more difficult for these victims. The goal seems to me to be to force these children and their families out of this now well known Catholic institution and then be able to just return to the status quo of cheering on "social justice" w/o any connection to God's children. The Church reps here, right across the river from Cincy, OH, are truly embarrassing. The left's smoke of Satan's stench doesn't seem to bother this diocese leader. Once again, the kids are setting a much better example of faithfulness than the Bishop.

    Covington Catholic Bishop and School Administration — Who Threw the Kids Under the Bus — Now Barring Them From Speaking to Media to Defend Themselves

    The Bishop and school administration at Covington Catholic — that immediately threw these kids under the bus without full information — has now told students they cannot speak to the media to defend themselves.

    Neither the Diocese or school has apologized to the kids for believing leftist activist Nathan Phillips and the liberal media as they smeared the students. Both even apologized on their behalf and have not yet retracted it — even though the original narrative has been thoroughly debunked.

    The students claim that after some of the kids spoke to Fox News and other outlets, the Bishop informed the school that he doesn’t want them doing any more interviews. The school faculty agreed, claiming they are worried about their safety.

    While no punishment was made clear if they fail to comply, the students want to cooperate and plan to do so.

    Speaking to the Gateway Pundit over the weekend, the mother of one of the boys seen in the video said that they are demanding an apology from the Diocese for not protecting the kids.

    “Like I said, the Bishop here is literally victimizing the victims twice. They’ve already been victimized by the media, now they are being victimized again,” she added. “There is blood in the water and they are making it worse. They’re feeding the piranha frenzy from the liberal media. I just want people to understand that they need to wake up and stop believing the fake news and defend the kids.”

    The Gateway Pundit attempted to call Covington Catholic to ask about the media ban — but their main phone line “is not accepting calls at this time.”

    https://www.nextadvisor.com/credit_...382a49b2ae5cf54d0981a24a&pi_creativeid=457724
     
    Booklady, Carol55 and DeGaulle like this.
  15. DeGaulle

    DeGaulle Powers

    While I wish to be no apologist for this weak bishop and these pusillanimous school authorities, I deleted my knee-jerk, initial response, because such responses were part of the initial problem. Additionally, we must beware that media outlets with conservative views have their own agendas and might also wish to play things up (I don't mean to equate Gatewaypundit with the vile leftist media, but they're only human).

    We can't discount that things might now be going subjudice and people might have been cautioned not to make any statements that might prejudice a libel case.
     
    AED and Carol55 like this.
  16. djmoforegon

    djmoforegon Powers


    Oh for Pete's sake! I just unfollowed the OSV on Facebook for their politically correct take on the Covington story. Remember, Our Sunday Visitor's parent organization is the USCCB.

    [​IMG]


    Our Sunday Visitor
    2 hrs ·
    The image is striking: Nick Sandmann, a young white man wearing a red “Make America Great Again” hat, stands on the left, amid a crowd of his fellow students from Covington (Ky.) Catholic High School. On the right stands Nathan Phillips, a Native American whom The Washington Post describes as a “veteran in the indigenous rights movement.”

    In the middle — in the space between Sandmann’s and Phillips’s faces — stand all of us. Our personal reactions to that photo, and to the very short video clips that initially accompanied it, reveal just how caught up each of us is in the ephemera of politics, the 24-hour news cycle and social media. Those reactions tell us nothing, though, about what did or did not happen on the steps of the Lincoln Memorial on the afternoon of Jan. 18.

    [​IMG]
    OSV.COM

    Editorial: A thousand words
     
    Praetorian and DeGaulle like this.
  17. Well, all the Covington Bishop has to do in order for anyone in doubt about his current position as perhaps to have changed from his very public pronouncement against the sheep, then all he has to do is "bravely" make another public announcement. I don't feel that this is being somehow disrespectful since scripture itself outlines the right to make demands of those with power over others.....in that recommendation for the one demanding her case be heard by a rather inadequate judge: to keep him from his rest by annoying him until he is forced to rise to complete his duty, if only out of annoyance rather than being dutiful. And if the shepherd is to locate the lost sheep, in peril, and in whatever weather conditions at hand, he has to disregard a normal concern about keeping things copacetic, and go where the real demand is by those being attacked by such wolves of our time and who have the most right to be served. It almost looks like this particular "shepherd" is the lazy, compromised type who really wouldn't care all that much if the sheep in trouble found another pasture for protection where it would be a stranger. Very sad. The boys, by the report, are complying with the Bishop's order/request of them not to defend themselves via the media. Now he, as a good father, has to reward them with an equal response/example of humility and obedience to his own responsibilities.

    I can only imagine what these mothers must feel, whose families now are living in real fear for their lives....or just for the jeopardy that their children's future jobs/education opportunities are placed in now due to such lies and threats. Now they must also feel unprotected in their very spirit of trust in their Church.

    Nick Sandman:
    To be honest, I was startled and confused as to why he had approached me."

    He went on, "We had already been yelled at by another group of protestors, and when the second group approached I was worried that a situation was getting out of control where adults were attempting to provoke teenagers."

    "I believed that by remaining motionless and calm," Sandmann wrote, "I was helping to diffuse the situation. I realized everyone had cameras and that perhaps a group of adults was trying to provoke a group of teenagers into a larger conflict. I said a silent prayer that the situation would not get out of hand."

    Sandmann added, "I am a faithful Christian and practicing Catholic, and I always try to live up to the ideals my faith teaches me — to remain respectful of others, and to take no action that would lead to conflict or violence."



    Beware your Catholic school....if your child actually tries to put what he's been taught into practice he can be expelled by those who don't!
     
    Booklady, AED, Carol55 and 2 others like this.
  18. DeGaulle

    DeGaulle Powers

    Certainly, if this bishop hasn't realised that the Left has lost this absolutely and utterly, and if he still imagines that his best position is to continue to curry favour with it, he can only be a great fool or a great knave. This course can only obliterate whatever authority he might have left. The Left are unlikely to throw much money into his collection plates.
     
    earthtoangels likes this.
  19. djmoforegon

    djmoforegon Powers

    All of our children and grandchildren need our constant prayer to protect them from the onslaught of demonic attack. I can't even begin to comprehend the absolute pain and confusion that our culture is imposing on these kids. These folks sent their daughters off to college and they came back as "sons".

    http://www.ncregister.com/blog/sege...f8Icc_nYiQL74HJAucYSUF4#.XEirBx7kwlM.facebook

    [​IMG]

    [​IMG]
    BLOGS | JAN. 23, 2019
    Parents’ Nightmare: Daughters Come Home from College Identifying as Men
    Health plans at 86 colleges around the country cover cross-sex hormones and surgery.
    Marcia Segelstein
    In a recent piece for The Wall Street Journal called “When Your Daughter Defies Biology,”author Abigail Shrier described the plight of mothers whose daughters have come home from college with newly-grown mustaches and recently removed breasts.

    Shrier had been contacted by a mother whose daughter had some anxiety issues during her first semester at college. Along with some friends, her daughter “decided their angst had a fashionable cause: ‘gender dysphoria.’” Over the course of a year, she began a course of testosterone, shaved her head, and began to wear boys’ clothes.

    Shrier went on to interview 18 parents in the same situation, desperate to save their daughters, but unable to find allies. “Nearly every force in society is aligned against these parents: Churches scramble to rewrite their liturgies for greater ‘inclusiveness.’ Therapists and psychiatrists undermine parental authority with immediate affirmation of teens’ self-diagnoses,” Shrier writes. “Campus counselors happily refer students to clinics that dispense hormones on the first visit.”

    In fact, health plans at 86 colleges around the country, including most of the Ivy League schools, cover cross-sex hormones and surgery.

    Gender dysphoria is believing yourself to be the opposite gender from your biological sex. What these young women suffer from is rapid onset gender dysphoria, i.e., when such feelings manifest themselves suddenly — within days or weeks — without having been present in early youth. Shrier refers to sudden onset gender dysphoria as a social contagion — one that, like anorexia and bulimia, overwhelmingly affects girls.

    In an earlier piece for National Catholic Register called “Is Transgenderism in Teens Contagious?” I asked Dr. Michelle Cretella, executive director of the American College of Pediatricians whether ROGD in teens is contagious:

    Yes. Regarding transgender identification, social contagion is unleashed on teens via the internet, mainstream and social media, messaging in schools, peer pressure, and sadly, from the medical elites who propagandize gender ideology as science.

    For example, the American Academy of Pediatrics policy statement on the issue declares that all children, regardless of age, should be immediately affirmed in accordance with their self-proclaimed gender identity.

    As I write in my forthcoming book, Don’t Let the Culture Raise Your Kids, the influence of social media on young people — when it comes to gender ideology and so many other issues — can’t be underestimated. Shrier lists Reddit, Tumbler, Instagram, and YouTube as places where young women can find affirmation that “transitioning” is the answer to all their problems.

    At The American Conservative, Rod Dreher writes about a mother who went to speak to her seventh grade daughter’s guidance counselor when she started claiming to be a boy. The counselor advised her to “accept your son as he is.”

    The College Fix website wrote about this issue and received several emails from moms who described their ordeals.

    Here’s one mother’s tragic story:

    Our daughter went off to the college of her dreams. She seemed to do well her first year away. During her second year at college, she experienced a mental health breakdown. We received sketchy details of her struggles from her and a couple of her friends. There was no outreach from her college – due to privacy concerns. Following much pleading on our part, she came home for a visit. We were met with a very different visage upon picking her up at the airport. Her face was covered in acne, she sprouted an obvious mustache, her entire appearance was disheveled...Her voice was somewhat deeper, I might note here. She seemed very disturbed – not at all her old self. What was she like before this? No, not a tomboy as a child. She was an ambitious student, an animal lover, she loved to spend time in the kitchen baking. As for gender, she was typical (whatever that means). For her high school prom, she had her hair and makeup professionally styled...When our daughter was visiting, we asked her what was wrong. I inquired about the acne and mustache – that is not natural, I said. She insisted that she had always had a mustache. Not true. Before we knew what had hit us, she returned to her college. We discovered that she had obtained testosterone in the student clinic. And, she refused all contact with her family. Her college was complicit in all of this.

    Another mother tells her daughter’s story:

    She left for college in the fall of 2016 as a National Merit Scholar, all AP classes, involved in countless activities including bands, orchestra, theater, dance, literary magazine editor, starting women’s studies club, part time job… She honestly was on top of the world with so much potential. She also happened to be gender conforming. She had a significant merit scholarship at a well-respected east coast university in a large city. Sometime the second semester sophomore year things went horribly wrong… She called us in a deep voice stating she was transgender and had changed her name. She was unable to even think clearly around this issue and was obviously horribly confused. Within a week she completely severed ties in an email to us. No one in her immediate or extended family can believe what has happened. Within a year she had a double mastectomy. Our family is absolutely devastated by all of this.

    Another mother, responding to Dreher’s piece, asks for our prayers:

    You can’t imagine what it’s like to have the entire educational/med/psych/media world fighting against your parental values and common sense… If you’re not having to deal with such a thing, thank your God for that blessing. Be aware of what’s being taught in your schools. And say a prayer for the rest of us.
     
  20. BREAKING: Lawyer Representing Covington Kids Receives Bomb Threat After Giving Celebs and Journalists 48 Hour Notice to Retract or Face Lawsuits

    Robert Barnes, the lawyer representing several of the families from Covington Catholic High School, received a bomb threat on Wednesday afternoon.

    The threat comes after he gave 48 hour notice for celebrities, media outlets, politicians and journalists 48 hours to retract and apologize for any defamatory statements against the Covington kids or potentially be named in lawsuits next week.

    The threat was emailed and used the same deadline. It said, “I am coming to bomb your office. Get ready. 48 hours. Be ready.”

    Barnes told The Gateway Pundit that the threat “shows how dangerous the establishment press can be when it excites madness with libelous lies.”

    Barnes added that “if the goal was to deter me in helping these families, it had the opposite effect.”

    Appearing on Fox News, Barnes had thrown down the gauntlet saying, “because these are all private citizens and many of them minors and kids the law is that saying anything about them is libel. And you don’t have a defense of actual malice all you have to prove is negligence.”

    “So a lot of these journalists who have been saying false statements about these kids, false statements about the kids at the Lincoln Memorial, false statements about various photographs that are related to the school, slurring and libeling the entire school and all the alumnae of the school and all you have to prove is that they were negligent in doing so. At this standpoint at this point in time it is clear that anyone who continues to libel about these kids has done so illegally and can be sued for it,” Barnes continued.

    https://www.thegatewaypundit.com/20...s-48-hour-notice-to-retract-or-face-lawsuits/
     

Share This Page