Cardinal Marx Opens the Door to Blessing Homosexual Unions Maike Hickson February 3, 2018 Today, 3 February, Cardinal Reinhard Marx — the President of the German Bishops’ Conference — suggests a further opening with regard to the idea of establishing a blessing from the German Catholic Church to be given to homosexual couples. In an interview with the Bavarian radio station Bayerischer Rundfunk BR, Cardinal Marx refers to Pope Francis’ call of accompanying people more closely in their individual lives, and Marx calls for more pastoral care for homosexuals. When asked about the question of a blessing for homosexual couples, Marx thus proposes “that we be pastorally closer to those [such as homosexuals] who are also in need of that pastoral care and who also desire it.” He continues, saying: There we also have to give encouragement that the priests and pastoral caretakers also give words of encouragement to the people in concrete situations. I really do not see there any problems. Another question is how this would be done publicly, in a liturgical form, that is where one has to be reticent and also reflect upon that in a good way. When asked whether he could imagine such a blessing for homosexual couples, Cardinal Marx answers: “There are no general solutions; I do not consider it [such a general solution] to be right, because it is about the pastoral care for individuals.” These are cases “where we do not have a rule,” he explains. “And that does not mean that there is nothing happening.” Cardinal Marx adds: This I really have to leave up to the local pastor and the accompaniment of that person. One can think about this in a dialogue — and right now, there is taking place such a discussion [raised by the Vice President of the German Bishops’ Conference, Bishop Franz-Josef Bode] — that is to say, about how we could deal with this matter, but I would say I would leave this strongly in the hands of the local pastor, in a very concrete situation, and not to demand rules in this matter. There are things that cannot be regulated. With these still somewhat vague words (which seem to be a characteristic of Cardinal Marx’ public speech) — and in light of a more decentralized approach — Cardinal Marx opened up to the idea of priests giving, in certain individual cases, a blessing to homosexual couples. These words come in the wake of a recent call for such a blessing as proposed by the Vice-President of the German Bishops’ Conference, Bishop Franz-Josef Bode. He said in January of 2018, when discussing the idea of a blessing of homosexual couples: “We have to reflect upon the question as to how to assess in a differentiated manner a relationship between two homosexual persons.” “Is there not so much positive and good and right so that we have to be more just?” Moreover, Cardinal Marx had recently claimed that it is hard to determine whether someone is living in the state of mortal sin. He applied this question also to homosexual couples. He also called for “a respect for a decision made in freedom” and for one’s “conscience.” Mathias von Gersdorff — German pro-life activist and book author — comments today on Cardinal Marx’s proposal of more private individual blessings of homosexual couples with the following words: That is nothing but a fig leaf. When it is acceptable to bless homosexual couples in individual cases, then that means that (practiced) homosexuality is no obstacle any more. In the wake of these prominent and high-ranking encouragements with respect to homosexual couples, a German diocese now proposes even more concrete steps for the establishment of an official liturgical blessing for homosexual couples. With the explicit encouragement of the Bishop of the Diocese of Limburg, Johannes zu Eltz — a high-ranking priest, canon, and Dean of the City of Frankfurt (with a responsibility for around 150,000 souls) — has now made a public proposal to have a “theologically justified blessing” for those couples who are either homosexual, “remarried,” or who for other reasons do not feel “sufficiently worthy” for the Sacrament of Matrimony. Zu Eltz now proposes a “liturgical celebration” that “omits the exchange of rings or the utterance of a marital vow.” Rather, one could, “with respect for a reliable partnership,” ask for God’s blessing “for a successful future of something that already exists.”
Why is anyone surprised? Gay marriage and acceptance of divorce were always the aim of Amoris Laetitia. We're now members of a Church established in 2013.
Dolours, They are not forthcoming, they are not honest and as a result, they are creating confusion and division. It is sickening.
It's very, very sad to see this destruction of Christ's Church. Death by a thousand heresies. Those of you in the US who live near an FSSP parish should be down on your knees thanking God. At least the FFSP priests won't be saying "tut-tut, that's terrible" when they see faithful priests being assaulted or even dragged off to prison for "hate crimes" as they head off to the pride parade to preach about Marshmallow Man Jesus. Unfortunately, a lot of priests and especially a lot of the Apostles' successors wouldn't be out of place in a Monty Python sketch about the gay Jesus and the Apostle he loved.
So, Cynthia's honest and sound defence of Pope Francis has been found to be unacceptable on the forum! She behaved perfectly courteously with everyone but her direct and perfectly accurate assessment of the situation regarding Pope Francis has been deemed to be unacceptable. It's apparently fine to not only call the Pope a heretic but to insist that all members subscribe to this view! I presume I will be next to be removed from the forum but I would just like to point out that I will not be removing myself. If I'm gone it is because I've been removed.
As I said to Cynthia, There are NO schismatics or sedevacantists here! No one is "slandering" the pope here, is "dishonest" or "dishonorable"! And it will not be tolerated when you insult MOG forum members by implying otherwise. If you think she behaved “perfectly courteously and accurately” then you agree with her assessment that MOG members are all of the above. It’s past time for you to go.
How do you bless a homosexual union? Is this the fake compassion of PF? Is this what Mark Mallet calls PF "field hospital"? Who is getting healed here? PF"s "field hospital" is more like a soul crematorium!
I disagree about member Cynthia behaving courteously with everyone. She may have done so with you, but not with several members here. For a person who just joined this Forum, who clearly had not spent time reading the position of everyone here over several years, Cynthia's posts were at times aggressive and uncharitable towards members here. She came here with an agenda, and at times with the desire to "flame" and troll members here. I agree with BrianK's actions, there is a distinct difference between courteously discussing an issue and trolling. Prayers for everyone's peace here, and especially for Cynthia.
Please refrain from crude condemnations about declarations of heresy. There has been a clear and conscientious policy among the members to carefully define and distinguish the various forms of heresy and to meticulously avoid considered condemnations of formal heresy, while attributions of material heresy have been based on sound documentation from respected sources and founded in a careful comparison with the Magisterial teaching of the Church. The matter of heresy, which Pope Francis is very careful in avoiding, is not fundamental. What is fundamental is the smokescreen of confusion he has laid, with his accompanying permissiveness of multiplying heresies by others. By his fruits you shall know him. And look at the fruits: blessing sodomy; sacriligious communion; suppression of various orders whose crime is to embrace pre-60's traditions; an apparent imminent betrayal of the brave and loyal Catholics of China; insults to those Catholics who merely hold the line of countless generations before them; promotion and protection of individuals with a documented history of facilitating child abuse; awards and conratulations to prominent abortionists; sticking his nose into matters of international politics and economics in which he has no special authority nor expertise. Yet, you come on here and attribute the worst of motives to our responses, while arrogantly refusing, at least in my time on this forum, to even debate a single issue in detail or even answer one straight question. Here's one more-do you think it is acceptable for Pope Francis to permit the discussion (never mind the actual practice) of blessing homosexual unions by bishops under his authority?
They're pushing, pushing now, to see how far they can get, how much they can get away with. I doubt they have any limits. Many German bishops seem only concerned with pulling in as much money as possible via their church tax. By the look of some of them, living the high life is their only religion. I've heard that some priests in Germany wouldn't give a dying man the last rites if he was known not to pay the tax. If true, who's being rigid? Is this having to pay tax to get to Heaven not the ultimate in neo-Pelagianism? What's Jesus Christ going to say to such bishops and priests?
Is anyone familiar with Bella Dodd and her admission that the communists placed men in catholic seminaries posing as having sincere and genuine vocations? This was done in the hope that such men would seek every opportunity during their “career” in the Church to cause as much damage as possible to the Church. Some of these ‘plants’ were even expected to, in time, reach quite elevated positions within the Church hierarchy where naturally they would wield greater power and could undermine, corrupt, damage, demoralise, confuse and wreck the Church all the more. Such clerics would appear outwardly to be genuine, loyal, God-fearing Catholics but in reality, in secret they were filled with a hatred of Christ. We do not know which clerics are those planted by the enemies of Christ. I personally have no idea who they were/are and would not, in any case, in charity point the finger at anyone without proof. I may have my suspicions but I keep that to myself. Coming right out with a radical attack on, or dismissal of perennial Catholic doctrine or teaching would be a dangerous move. Much better to speak with forked tongue and merely propose a “dialogue”. There are many Judas’s in today’s church. The Lord is allowing this to happen - “what you must do, do quickly” - these puffed up, pompous serpentine princes of the Church think they are so clever as they sneak and grovel to their paymasters for their 30 pieces of silver, the modern day Sanhedrin composed of the left wing liberal media, cultural Marxist infested academia, globalists, oligarchs, elites in their think tanks, bought and paid for politicians etc. These Judas priests, referring to no one in particular, will no doubt be feted for a time, while they are useful, cheered and applauded at conferences, book launches, receptions and junkets. They will receive their 30 pieces. And then, once the deed is done and their Master has been betrayed, they will be discarded and shunned for the stupid, traitorous snakes they are. Because even the very Devil himself holds them in contempt. Just as the Sanhedrin did Judas. But it will be too late. Like Judas they too shall rue the day they were born. Better they repent now or else burn in Hell for eternity.
Could this be the reason the Pope had Cardinal Sarah issue a correction about the statement attributed to him on liturgical translations? Here's a reminder: http://www.praytellblog.com/index.p...ancis-corrects-cardinal-sarah-on-translation/ I know nothing about that blog. It popped up in my search results but skimming over the comments beneath some of the articles, I get the impression that it appeals to more liberal Catholics.
Forgive me for being dim, but I can't see the connection. That episode seems to me more like a strike at St Pope John Paul and then Cardinal Ratzinger.
That is a great summary of a very likely phenomenon, which would explain very much, and a fine description of the fate that awaits these wretches. I don't think that the 'sleeper' concept is confined to the Church. I suspect that they are prevalent in political parties, some now in very high office, in educational institutes and all the other branches of the modern-day Sanhedrin that you describe. There certainly seems to be a coordinated and simultaneous eruption of these poisons. The errors of Russia. Ironically, Russia and her former satellites seem to have developed an immune response, but the disease has mutated to one far worse in its westerly transmission.
The way things are going makes it seem that the ‘institutional’ Church, its pope, bishops, are no longer the “Katechon” that restrains the mistery of lawlessness ( 2 Thessalonians 2). It seems to rather tolerate if not help that mistery. Newman spoke about this risk of widespread infidelity in the future Church as the the specific to our times, in his “Infidelity of the Future” 1873 sermon: “The special peril of the time before us is the spread of that plague of infidelity, that the Apostles and our Lord Himself have predicted as the worst calamity of the last times of the Church. And at least a shadow, a typical image of the last times is coming over the world.”1 In a mysterious way the abdication of pope Benedict exposes that mystery of iniquity, that is, the infidelity inside the Church. It’s almost like Rome has become the ‘locus’ of that mystery. So consider the possible fate of Rome: “Consider how far you have fallen! Repent and do the things you did at first. If you do not repent, I will come to you and remove your lampstand from its place.” Revelation 2:5 To end on a positive note on what our response to all this should be: “The greater the darkness, the more complete our trust should be.” (St Faustina Kowalska, Diary, n 357)