The Vatican Has Fallen

Discussion in 'Church Critique' started by padraig, Dec 31, 2016.

  1. Dolours

    Dolours Guest


    Spare us the "Jesus ate with sinners" excuse to gloss over the fact that there is something seriously wrong in the leadership of the Church. Jesus ate with sinners. Neither Jesus nor John facilitated the promotion of sin as good. If it is wrong to host the conference in one Vatican owned property, it is equally wrong to host it in another Vatican owned property and giving the impression that it is not being accommodated on Vatican property is deceitful. Subterfuge and deceit are becoming synonymous with this papacy.
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Feb 3, 2018
  2. SgCatholic

    SgCatholic Guest

    This popped out at me when I read the article.
    I agree with you Dolours. They are trying to pull wool over people's eyes.
     
  3. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

    There could be more to that report than meets the eye. The legalisation of gay marriage has emboldened people who would force the Church in Ireland to accommodate all kinds of changes in Church teaching. The woman gives the impression that efforts to reach a compromise failed and names the Archbishop of Dublin and an Irish born Cardinal as the bad guys when the truth is that their conference will be held on Vatican territory. More pressure on Irish Bishops. And I have my doubts about Cardinal Farrell's role in it.
     
    BrianK and DeGaulle like this.
  4. I wasn't talking about Jesus eating with sinners, Dolours.
    I was talking about people who would be unhappy with whatever decision His Holiness made in this case.

    This woman has a following - a lot of people will be listening to hear what the Church has to say to her, and if she is sent away packing, the Church loses the opportunity to preach to those people.
    Angels don't need a shepherd, and sheep who are safe in the fold don't need to be found and brought home, but there are plenty of lost and straying sheep who do.
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Feb 3, 2018
  5. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

    What people? The crowd organising the conference got what they wanted with the Vatican's help. The Vatican is still hosting their gathering, will still be addressed by people pushing an agenda diametrically opposed to Catholic teaching, and the Church in Ireland will be under more pressure to submit to an agenda which is not of God. The people in the Vatican know full well who Mary McAleese is. They knew who she was when she studied for her degree in Theology in Rome and they knew who she was when she was a prominent voice in support of the gay marriage lobby in Ireland. And they knew what kind of agenda the organisers of that conference promote when the Superior General of the Jesuits addressed last year's conference after his statement about Satan being an invention by the early Christians. The whole thing stinks of yet another Vatican gimmick.

    I'm editing this to add that the only concern the Church hierarchy should have is whether or not they please God. If they do what pleases God (defend the Deposit of Faith and preach the Gospel in good times as well as bad), God will be on their side. With God on their side it matters not a jot who is against them.
     
  6. What people?
    That depends on who YOU mean by that question.

    The "people who will be listening to hear what the Church has to say" to McAleese are those who follow the liberal teachings that this woman promotes, Dolours.
    Some are agents of Satan, but many more are gay men and women and their parents and loved ones, REAL, HUMAN, HURTING PEOPLE with SOULS who are being deceived and led to hell.
    Those people need to hear a PASTOR speak the true doctrines of the Holy Church in LOVE, rather than the serpent's lies of the proponents of gay marriage, or the Pharisaical condemnation of those who have been so blessed as to have been spared this particular temptation; by giving this woman chance to speak and be rebutted, the Holy Father capitalizes on that opportunity to minister to them.

    If you mean the "people who would be unhappy with whatever decision the Pope made in this case", well, that's self explanatory.
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Feb 3, 2018
  7. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

    They hear pastors speak the true doctrines of the Holy Church in LOVE in their parishes and in their dioceses. They reject it because they reject Church teaching that real love means wanting a person to achieve everlasting happiness in the beatific vision and Jesus has told us that sodomy, like adultery and fornication, results in eternal death. That's a message they won't hear from the Superior General of the Jesuits who says that Scripture can't be trusted because the Apostles didn't have tape recorders and Satan is an early Christian construct. They won't hear that message from ANYONE in the Vatican because the Church under Pope Francis is promoting homosexual practices as just another lifestyle choice because people are "born that way". Sure, he said that the Church can't perform gay marriages but he hasn't ruled out conducting ceremonies called something other than sacramental marriages which is the thin end of the wedge being touted around the Church.

    It is not pharisaical to call sin what it is irrespective of the sin. All sorts of people are tempted in all sorts of ways. Only adulterers and homosexuals demand that the sins they are tempted to commit be called good. Sodomy is one of the sins that Jesus listed among others which will send us to hell. Is it pharisaical to call greed and theft a sin? If not, why not? Why doesn't the Vatican host conferences promoting masturbation as good and wholesome or is that another sin relegated to the archives in favour of pastoral practice?

    Everything about this supposed problem or inconvenience screams "manufactured".
     
    HeavenlyHosts, BrianK and Totus tuus like this.
  8. There are some people in the Church who are promoting that idea, Dolours, but Pope Francis is not one of them, and your statement that "he hasn't ruled out conducting ceremonies called something other than sacramental marriages" is untrue.
    What he said, was this :
    " Matrimony is between a man and a woman. This is the precise term. Let us call the same-sex union a “civil union.”
    He was correcting terminology, not legitimizing sin, and he wasn't talking about the CHURCH conducting ceremonies for civil unions either - he was talking about secular governments recognising them, and he said, quite correctly, that he and the church can't insert themselves "in the specific internal politics of a country.”
     
  9. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

    This is what's facing every parish in Ireland and every parish in the Western world thanks to the double speak emanating from people occupying influential hierarchical office: http://motheofgod.com/threads/st-michaels-athy.9722/

    What about the hurt inflicted on that man trying to raise his family in the Faith but forced out of his parish? The persecution has already begun here with the Government threatening to withdraw grants to Catholic marriage advisory agencies unless they are willing to provide the same service to homosexual couples. Catholic adoption agencies in England had to close rather than place children with same-sex adoptive parents.
     
    Don_D and Cynthia Raenette Gee like this.
  10. http://www.slate.com/blogs/outward/...rancis_support_gay_civil_unions_no_no_no.html


    Does Pope Francis Support Gay Civil Unions?
    By Tyler Lopez

    [​IMG]
    Pope Francis waves at the end of his weekly general audience on March 5, 2014.

    Photo by Andreas Solaro/AFP/Getty Images

    In an interview with Italian newspaper Corriere della Sera that appeared today, Pope Francis suggests that some forms of civil unions may be tolerated by the Catholic Church. The pope acknowledged “diverse situations of cohabitation,” focusing his response on government recognition of nonmarital relationships, for example, where one party may need access to health care. This is the latest in a wave of statements many interpret as the Vatican softening its stance on homosexuality. Don’t be fooled. Francis is not the first pro-gay pope.

    Pope Francis reinforced this impression in his response, when he said—-as he has always said—that “matrimony is between a man and a woman.” Despite the pope’s clear and consistent opposition to marriage equality, many media outlets broadcast misleading headlines, tantalizing the millions of liberal, gay-friendly, marriage-equality-supporting Catholics here in the United States. Earlier today, CNN’s homepage declared, “Pope opens door to same-sex unions.” Above a stock photo festooned with a rainbow flag, the Huffington Post said, “Pope Francis Suggests Gay Civil Unions May Be Tolerable.” Neither could be further from the truth.

    The pope’s statement could easily be interpreted to mean the extension of legal rights to a caregiver living with a terminally ill loved one. Some civil unions also allow widows who wish to form a new romantic partnership to keep Social Security survivor’s benefits. To give you an idea of how slow things are moving here, this represents progress: Church leaders previously suggested that widows should “have consecrated to God their remaining years in the unmarried state.” Being exceedingly careful not to issue any errant endorsements of a loving commitment between same-sex partners, the pope only suggests that the Vatican should examine and evaluate the circumstances of governmentally recognized relationships.

    Bigoted lawmakers in many U.S. jurisdictions used similar logic when drafting anti-marriage equality amendments during the mid-aughts. In 2006, focusing on the perceived illegitimacy of same-sex marriages, Virginia voters approved a referendum that prohibited the “[recognition of] a legal status for relationships of unmarried individuals that intends to approximate the design, qualities, significance, or effects of marriage.” In other words, lawmakers made sure that civil unions (including those entered into in other states) didn’t provide a backdoor method for recognizing same-sex partnerships. By denying the very legitimacy of certain relationships, one may also deny the legal rights associated with them. The Catholic Church uses the same logic today.

    When Pope Francis reiterated his opposition to same-sex adoption back in December, Slate’s Mark Joseph Stern outlined some theories for why so many were hailing the pontiff as a progressive hero. Stern suggested that liberal Catholics were simply “reviving the old urge for acceptance.” Apparently, the Vatican is fully aware of that desire, having installed a charismatic, tactful, and generally likable pope after the public relations disaster they now call their Pope Emeritus. The church needed a media darling, and it put one into place.

    While he may flub his words now and again, Francis’ message is consistent. He is quite capable of playing on popular sentiment in order to gain support. By acknowledging that gay people exist and are—wait for it—worthy of love, Pope Francis endeared himself to legions of followers who clung desperately to their faith through the Benedict years. By entertaining a discussion of gay rights—without ever endorsing them in any fashion—many see hope for acceptance of the LGBTQ community in the future. Upon close examination, though, the pope’s words are calculated, precise, and unforgiving. Same-sex families are not legitimate in the eyes of the Vatican. In the Catholic Church, gays—being humans—have inherent human rights. Gay rights, however, are not human rights.




    Tyler Lopez lives in Washington, D.C.
     
  11. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

    Heard it all before......the last time being the one about marriage being a lifelong union with only God can put asunder. If he truly believed what he claims to believe, he would clamp down on the German Bishops advocating for women priests, divorce and remarriage, and homosexual marriages. He also would forbid the appointment of abortion and contraceptive supporters to the Vatican dicastry on the family. He makes the balls for other people to fire while saying just enough to avoid revealing himself to be a material heretic. And if he truly believed that Satan is a real being rather than an early Christian construct, Fr. Sosa would no longer be the superior general of the Jesuits.
     
    SgCatholic, BrianK and HeavenlyHosts like this.
  12. Those are terrible things, Dolours, but you're blaming the wrong man. Pope Francis is not a proponent of gay marriage, and he never has been. To say otherwise is to slander him, and to slander the pope knowingly and on purpose is pretty close to a mortal sin.
     
  13. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

    See my earlier post. Pope Honorius 1 was anathemised posthumously for aiding and abetting heresy because he did nothing to stop the heretics spreading their errors. When it comes to enabling heretics, Honorius was only in the ha'penny place compared to Pope Francis.
     
    SgCatholic, HeavenlyHosts and BrianK like this.
  14. Sorry, Dolours - as they say in the Southern US, "that dog won't hunt." Those German Bishops and liberal bozos have been around for years. They didn't suddenly spring into being the day that Pope Francis was inaugurated. He hasn't aided or abetted them any more that his predecessors did.
     
  15. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

    He most certainly has, just as the St. Gallen Mafia helped get him elected. He has been promoting them since the early days of his papacy. He appoints them to influential positions. Praises them as "great theologians" while badmouthing orthodox prelates. If I have time later, I'll search out the report about the Belgian Cardinal hiding while parents protested against what was being taught to their children in Catholic schools. It was as near as makes no difference to child grooming. Although past the retirement age, Pope Francis personally invited him to participate in the Synod on the Family. Cardinal Paglia of the homo mural on the cathedral fame is another example. Then there's the American Jesuit appointed as a "consultor" to the Vatican's Communications Department. Too many. Far too many for it to be a coincidence.
     
    SgCatholic, Heidi, BrianK and 3 others like this.
  16. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

  17. Regardless, Pope Francis has done nothing to prove that he shares their views. He has reiterated church teaching on homosexuality and women in the priesthood, he is is Prolife and upholds traditional marriage. You say that he doesn't, but I'll believe you on the day that he actually says or does the things of which you constantly accuse him. Until then, it's just gossip.
     
  18. [​IMG]
    Misleading, like most memes.

    Sins of the flesh are minor when compared to spiritual sins - that's why pride is the worst sin, but they do more damage, because more people commit sins of the flesh. SO, Fatima and the Holy Father are both right, and Francis was not contradicting Fatima, as the authors of this meme try to deceive us into thinking.
     
  19. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

    So, when can we expect the Vatican to host a Pride conference. Oh, wait, I think the gay lobby have cornered the market on that. Then again, we have another Synod on the Family this year and Pope Francis has replaced a lot of Bishops. We've already had the lesbian couple displaying their rainbow colours on the promo literature for the World Meeting of Families. As a member of the Council of State, McAleese will be front and centre if the Pope shows up. No doubt accompanied by son and partner if he has one - to be enthusiastically applauded by the Vicar of Christ.
     
  20. By the way, that meme comes form a pseudo-Catholic site called The Wild Voice (the "Voice of Satan" is more like it!) whose authors suggest that Pope Francis is the False Prophet of the Antichrist, and which promotes "The Book of Truth", a compilation of the writings of an anonymous "seer and visionary from Europe called "Maria Divine Mercy":

    "WHO IS MARIA DIVINE MERCY?
    O
    n November 8, 2010 at 3:30 pm, an unknown visionary and seer from Europe by the name of Maria Divine Mercy (MDM) received the first of what are now well over a thousand messages and prophecies given from God the Father, His Son Jesus Christ and His Holy Mother in the Holy Spirit. These "New Prophecies reveal global events in the lead up to the Second Coming of Jesus Christ". Though Maria Divine Mercy had almost no knowledge of Holy Scripture before she began receiving these important messages, they contain many biblical references and concepts.
    These messages comprise The Book of Truth."
     

Share This Page