The Vatican Has Fallen

Discussion in 'Church Critique' started by padraig, Dec 31, 2016.

  1. DeGaulle

    DeGaulle Powers

    Some of the Vatican is still standing yet (is this Cardinal Farrell one of Pope Francis' recent appointees?):


    https://www.independent.ie/irish-ne...speech-over-views-on-gay-rights-36558790.html


    Vatican blocks McAleese from giving keynote speech 'over views on gay rights'
    • Women’s conference forced to move from Vatican after Cardinal objects
    • Irish Cardinal forced major international conference to move as he 'objected to former president's views'
    • Dr McAleese due to address the '2018 Voices of Faith' conference on International Women's Day
    [​IMG] 1
    Former president Mary McAleese with son Justin
    Sarah MacDonald

    February 2 2018 2:30 AM



    An Irish Cardinal has forced a major international conference on women's rights to move from the Vatican as he objected to former president Mary McAleese, who is the keynote speaker at the event.

    Dublin-born Cardinal Kevin Farrell, who is overseeing the Vatican's preparations for the World Meeting of Families in Ireland in August, attempted to block Dr McAleese from addressing the '2018 Voices of Faith' conference, which will take place on International Women's Day on March 8.

    Correspondence seen by the Irish Independent reveals a stand-off occurred between the conference organisers and Cardinal Farrell over his withholding of approval not just for Dr McAleese but two other speakers as well.

    The Irish Independent understands that Dr McAleese's views on gay rights is the reason the prelate objected. She has previously spoken about how son Justin, as a devout young Catholic, was bullied because he was gay.

    She said that Justin went through "torture" when he discovered what his Church taught about homosexuality. Another conference speaker Ssenfuka Joanita Warry is a Catholic who campaigns for LGBT rights in Uganda and is herself gay.

    This is the first year the Vatican has withheld approval of any speakers for the annual 'Voices of Faith' gathering, which brings together high-profile international speakers to address issues of concern to women around the world.

    For the past four years, the conference has taken place within the Vatican. But this year's event ran into trouble with Cardinal Farrell, who heads up the Congregation for Laity, Family and Life and has taken up oversight of the conference.

    Chantal Götz, who is executive director of the Catholic philanthropic Fidel Götz Foundation and is the main organiser of the conference, took the decision to move the venue of 'Why Women Matter' from the Vatican to the Jesuit Aula in Rome rather than cave in to the Irish prelate's demands.

    "The list of speakers required approval from Cardinal Farrell," Ms Götz, who is based in Liechtenstein, told the Irish Independent. "He sent the list of names back to me with those names to which he gave permission. Mary McAleese and two others were not on it."

    In correspondence, Ms Götz described the Cardinal's failure to respond to her efforts to compromise and "barring" women's voices as "unacceptable".

    The Irish Independent understands that efforts were made to get Archbishop Diarmuid Martin of Dublin to intervene to help resolve the impasse but to no avail. She said unsuccessful efforts were made to get the cardinal to change his mind.


    Rather than exclude the three high-profile speakers from the conference, the organisers decided to move the conference to a venue outside the Vatican.

    "We realised it is crucial for us to bring voices that represent perspectives often not heard at the Vatican," Ms Götz said. She added that, as a non-Vatican entity, "ultimately, we did not see a reason why these women should have to go through an 'approval process' by anyone".

    She also highlighted that on his recent visit to Chile, Pope Francis told young people that "opinions often arrive to Rome filtered" and she said the women's event "aims to change that".

    Invitations have been sent to Pope Francis and a number of cardinals to attend the conference. A spokesperson for the Vatican told the Irish Independent the event was "not a Vatican conference" and suggested that questions should be directed to the organisers.
     
  2. jackzokay

    jackzokay Powers

    Thanks for highlighting this DeGaulle. Great post!

    There's life in the old dog yet!!
     
    sunburst, AED and DeGaulle like this.
  3. Blizzard

    Blizzard thy kingdom come


    The China Syndrome


    Robert Royal

    MONDAY, JANUARY 29, 2018

    In several decades of living in Washington, D.C., I’ve met my share of scamps and scalawags, fabulists and outright liars. It would take a modern Dante to determine which circle of Inferno each type of misbehavior merited. But of one thing, I am certain: at least in my own experience, I’ve never encountered more brazen and manipulative liars than Communist Chinese officials responsible for relations with religious believers.

    Which is what makes it so disturbing that last week reports surfaced that the Vatican asked two underground Chinese bishops, loyal to Rome, to step aside in order to allow two bishops of the Patriotic Church, submissive to the Communist regime, to take their places. That news drove the heroic 86-year-old former Cardinal of Hong Kong Joseph Zen to go to Rome without an appointment, stand outside the Casa Santa Marta, and ask to be allowed to present a letter from the underground believers – who are willing to resist despite personal costs – to Pope Francis. Reliable sources say the pope received the letter and promised to read it. (UPDATE: Cardinal Zen has published an account of these events this morning that confirms the basic story and adds that he is pessimistic about the line the Vatican is pursuing. In addition, he says that the government is cracking down on religious institutions, and starting February 1, “attendance to Mass in the underground will no longer be tolerated.”)


    Cardinal Zen has been energetic in warning about the unreliability of agreements with the Communists. (Rumors of an imminent agreement between China and the Vatican have been floating around for a couple of years now, without anything definite being revealed.) Asia News, a publication of the Vatican, itself reacted to last week’s news with a warning about substituting “illegitimate” bishops for “legitimate” ones. The ChiComs (as we used to call them during the Cold War) are smart and shrewd. They know how to manipulate Western values, in this case, “unifying” the churches, i.e., the religious inclination to think we can fix all problems with dialogue, building bridges, diplomatic arrangements.

    Meanwhile, China continues to cut crosses off church buildings, close some, dynamite still others. The New York Times reported just two weeks ago that China had destroyed the Golden Lampstand church – with 60,000 worshippers the largest evangelical community in the country. The reason: the large, conspicuous edifice had been “secretly” constructed, had failed to get official building permits, etc. These are the usual fig leaves of tyrannical regimes all over the world when they attack religion. I’ve heard top Chinese leaders blame local authorities for “excesses and errors,” but these seem to recur with a suspect regularity that no one seems to take steps to stop.

    The Chinese Communists studied the fall of the Soviet Union in 1989 and the liberation of the nations behind the Iron Curtain thanks to St. John Paul II, Ronald Reagan, Margaret Thatcher, and many others in the West who kept the pressure on Moscow. They appreciate the power of religion and clearly believe they can prevent Christianity from doing in China what it did in Poland and elsewhere. The tools are familiar: co-opt when you can, persecute and destroy when you can as well, and control information to make it appear you are simply asking for reasonable law and order within your borders.

    [​IMG]
    *
    From the regime’s point of view, there’s great need for all that. Most Chinese have a vague attachment to old folk religions. Maybe 15 percent are Buddhist and generally quiet – except in Tibet where resistance to Beijing remains alive. And then there are Christians, lots of them, if not a large percentage – yet. Reliable figures are hard to get, but 60 million (at a minimum) is a reasonable estimate. It’s safe to say that more Christians are in church on a Sunday morning in China than in all of Europe. And that despite potentially serious consequences for worshipping in “unapproved” congregations.

    Protestants probably make up around two-thirds of that number, but the Catholic Church, of course, has a stronger institutional structure. The Chinese are used to playing a long game. Given that Christianity is growing rapidly there, the regime will have a hard time if there are tens of millions more Christians who believe every human being is made in the image and likeness of God, meaning they possess human dignity and freedom.

    One of the common foreign-policy questions about China is precisely how Communist it is – and therefore whether it has in its very DNA the old Marxist drive to stamp out the “opium of the people,” i.e., religion. The economy is managed, but not wrecked along ideologically Marxist lines, as in the former Soviet Union and Eastern Europe. It’s not exactly capitalist, of course, but there’s some very serious innovation and entrepreneurship all the same. The heavy hand of the state is nonetheless quite evident, not least in the population control measures that even the Chinese now know will bring decades – at least – of trouble as their population ages. But is it a hard atheist system?

    I wrote about the history of Chinese persecution of religious believers in my book The Catholic Martyrs of the Twentieth Century. At the time, the Falun Gong, about 10 million people, were being ruthlessly persecuted by the Chinese because that basically traditional spiritual movement was “a threat to social stability.” And yet it was said then and now that there were numbers of Christians in the Chinese Communist Party as well.

    Whatever China’s ideological composition, the independence of the Church is something that many Christians fought and died for over centuries in the Christian countries of Europe. Independence from political regimes is crucial so that the Church can be free to carry out its spiritual mission, not only evangelizing people but working and speaking out, whatever regime it lives under, about justice and right order in society.

    The Vatican seems to be stumbling in its relations with a regime that we can be sure will not respect the freedom of the Church since it doesn’t respect the freedom and dignity of its own people. Vatican negotiators would do well to remember the lessons of the Communist Era in Europe, particularly Solzhenitsyn’s warning that we must fully understand the nature of Communist regimes and not give in to the illusion that the split between us and them “may be abolished through successful diplomatic negotiations.” Because the split is spiritual, deeply so, not political.



    *Image: Pope Francis and Chinese President Xi Jinping [photomontage by Jason Lee and Stefano Rellandini/Reuters]



    © 2018 The Catholic Thing. All rights reserved. For reprint rights, write to: info@frinstitute.orgThe Catholic Thing is a forum for intelligent Catholic commentary. Opinions expressed by writers are solely their own.

    [​IMG]
    Robert Royal
    Robert Royal is editor-in-chief of The Catholic Thing, and president of the Faith & Reason Institute in Washington, D.C. His most recent book is A Deeper Vision: The Catholic Intellectual Tradition in the Twentieth Century, published by Ignatius Press. The God That Did Not Fail: How Religion Built and Sustains the West, is now available in paperback from Encounter Books.

    https://www.thecatholicthing.org/2018/01/29/the-china-syndrome-3/
     
    Byron, Jarg, sunburst and 2 others like this.
  4. Blizzard

    Blizzard thy kingdom come

    My oh my how things have changed!

    Only 7 years ago this is how Pope Benedict responded to China conducting bishop ordination:

    Vatican City, Nov 24, 2010 / 11:59 am (CNA/EWTN News).- The Vatican has issued a sharply worded rebuke to China for ordaining a new bishop who was not appointed or approved by the Pope.

     
    DeGaulle and HeavenlyHosts like this.
  5. Blizzard

    Blizzard thy kingdom come

  6. davidtlig

    davidtlig Guest

    Parolin, “Why we are in dialogue with China”

    [​IMG]


    Pubblicato il 31/01/2018

    GIANNI VALENTE
    VATICAN CITY

    Eminence, what can you tell us about the dialogue between the Holy See and the People's Republic of China?

    "As it is well known, with the advent of "New China", there were, for the life of the Church in that great country, moments of serious contrasts and severe suffering. Since the eighties, however, contacts have been established between representatives of the Holy See and of People's China, who have known different seasons and alternating events. The Holy See has always maintained a pastoral approach, trying to overcome the contrasts and making itself available for a respectful and constructive dialogue with the civil authorities. Pope Benedict XVI well represented the spirit of this dialogue in his 2007 Letter to Chinese Catholics, "the solution to existing problems cannot be pursued via an ongoing conflict with the legitimate civil authorities " (n. 4). In Pope Francis’ pontificate, the ongoing negotiations move exactly along these lines: constructive openness to dialogue and fidelity to the genuine Tradition of the Church".

    What are the concrete expectations of the Holy See from this dialogue?

    "First of all, I would like to make a premise: in China, perhaps more than elsewhere, Catholics have been able to preserve, despite the many difficulties and sufferings, the authentic deposit of faith, keeping firmly the bond of hierarchical communion between the Bishops and the Successor of Peter, as a visible guarantee of faith itself. In fact, communion between the Bishop of Rome and all Catholic Bishops touches the heart of the Church's unity: it is not a private matter between the Pope and the Chinese Bishops or between the Apostolic See and civil authorities. Having said that, the main purpose of the Holy See in the ongoing dialogue is precisely that of safeguarding communion within the Church, in the wake of genuine Tradition and constant ecclesiastical discipline. You see, in China there are not two Churches, but two communities of faithful called to follow a gradual path of reconciliation towards unity. It is not, therefore, a matter of maintaining a perennial conflict between opposing principles and structures, but of finding realistic pastoral solutions that allow Catholics to live their faith and to continue together the work of evangelization in the specific Chinese context".

    The communion of which you have spoken calls into question the delicate issue of the episcopal appointments, which are stirring up much controversy. Will a potential agreement on this issue succeed in resolving the problems of the Church in China in a fair manner?

    "The Holy See knows and shares the serious sufferings endured by many Catholics in China and their generous witness to the Gospel. She knows that there are many problems for the life of the Church and that they cannot all be solved together. But, in this context, the question of the appointment of Bishops is crucial. On the other hand, we cannot forget that the freedom of the Church and the appointment of Bishops have always been recurring themes in the relations between the Holy See and the States. Certainly, the path started with China through the current contacts is gradual and still exposed to many unforeseen events, as well as new possible emergencies. No one can say in conscience that they have perfect solutions for all problems. Time and patience are needed to heal the many personal wounds inflicted on each other within the communities. Unfortunately, it is certain that there will still be misunderstandings, fatigue and suffering to be faced. But we all have confidence that, once the issue of the Episcopal appointments has been adequately considered, the remaining difficulties should no longer be such as to prevent Chinese Catholics from living in communion with each other and with the Pope. This is the important thing, so long-awaited and desired already by Saint John Paul II and Benedict XVI and today pursued with far-sightedness by Pope Francis".

    What is then the true attitude of the Holy See towards Chinese authorities?

    "It is important to reiterate this: in dialogue with China, the Holy See pursues a spiritual aim: to be and feel fully Catholic and, at the same time, authentically Chinese. With honesty and realism, the Church asks nothing but to profess her faith with more serenity, definitively ending a long period of contrasts, in order to give more room for greater trust and offer the positive contribution of Catholics to the good of Chinese society as a whole. Of course, many wounds are still open today. To treat them, we need to use the balm of mercy. And if someone is asked to make a sacrifice, small or great, it must be clear to everyone that this is not the price of a political exchange, but falls within the evangelical perspective of a greater good, the good of the Church of Christ. The hope is that, when God wills it, we won’t have to speak of "legitimate" and "illegitimate" Bishops, "clandestine" and "official" Bishops in the Church in China, but about meeting among brothers and sisters, learning the language of collaboration and communion again. Without this experience, how could the Church in China re-launch the journey of evangelization and bring to others the consolation of the Lord? If you are not ready to forgive, this means, unfortunately, that there are other interests to defend: but this is not an evangelical perspective".

    If this is the attitude, is there not the risk of erasing the past and present suffering by wiping the slate clean?

    "Quite the contrary. Many Chinese Christians, when they celebrate their martyrs who have suffered unjust trials and persecutions, remember that they have been able to rely on God, even in their fragile humanity. Now, the best way to honor this testimony and make it fruitful in the present, is to entrust the present life of Catholic communities in China to the Lord Jesus. But this cannot be done in a spiritualistic and disembodied way. This is done by choosing fidelity to the Successor of Peter, with a spirit of filial obedience, even when not everything appears immediately clear and understandable. About your question, it is not a matter of wiping the slate clean, ignoring or, almost magically erasing the painful path of so many faithful and pastors, but of investing the human and spiritual capital of so many trials to build a more serene and fraternal future, with the help of God. The Spirit who has so far guarded the faith of Chinese Catholics is the same Spirit who supports them today on the new path they have embarked upon".

    continued...
     
  7. davidtlig

    davidtlig Guest

    continued...

    Is there an advice, a particular request that the Apostolic See can address to the Chinese faithful at this moment? To those who are happy before potential new developments, but also to those who are confused or have objections?

    "I would like to say with great simplicity and clarity that the Church will never forget the past and present trials and sufferings of Chinese Catholics. All this is a great treasure for the universal Church. Therefore, to the Chinese Catholics I say with great fraternity: we are close to you, not only through prayer, but also through our daily commitment to accompany and support you on the path of full communion. We ask you, therefore, that no one should cling to the spirit of opposition to condemn his brother or use the past as an excuse to stir up new resentments and closures. On the contrary, we hope that each one will look with confidence at the future of the Church, beyond any human limit".

    Your Eminence, do you really believe that this is possible? What is your trust based on?

    "I am convinced of one thing. Trust is not the result of the strength of diplomacy or negotiations. Trust is based on the Lord who guides history. We trust that the Chinese faithful, thanks to their sense of faith, will know how to recognize that the action of the Holy See is animated by this trust, which does not respond to worldly logics. It is especially up to the pastors to help the faithful to recognize in the Pope's guidance the sure reference point for grasping God's plan in the present circumstances".

    Is the Pope informed of what his collaborators do in their contacts with the Chinese government?

    "Yes, the Holy Father personally follows current contacts with the authorities of the People's Republic of China. All his collaborators act in concert with him. No one takes private initiatives. Frankly, any other kind of reasoning seems to me to be out of place."

    In recent times, critical expressions have emerged, also within the Church, about the approach adopted by the Holy See in dialogue with the Chinese Authorities, judged by some as a true "surrender" for political reasons. What do you think?

    "I think, first of all, that in the Church there is a full right to disagree and to tell one's own criticisms, and that the Holy See has a moral duty to listen to them and to evaluate them carefully. I am also convinced that, among Christians, criticism should be directed at building communion and not at stirring up divisions. To be frank, I will tell you: I am also convinced that part of the suffering experienced by the Church in China is not so much due to the will of individuals as to the objective complexity of the situation. Therefore, it is legitimate to have different views over the most appropriate responses to the problems of the past and present. That is entirely reasonable. Having said that, I think that no personal point of view can be considered as an exclusive interpreter of what is good for Chinese Catholics. Therefore, the Holy See works to find a synthesis of truth and a practicable way to respond to the legitimate expectations of the faithful, inside and outside China. It takes greater humility and spirit of faith to discover together God's plan for the Church in China. It takes greater caution and moderation on the part of everyone in order not to fall into sterile polemics that hurt communion and rob our hope for a better future".

    What do you mean?

    "I mean that we are all called to distinguish more appropriately the spiritual and pastoral dimension from that of politics. Let us start, for example, with the words we use every day. Expressions such as power, betrayal, resistance, surrender, confrontation, failure, compromise, should make room for others, such as service, dialogue, mercy, forgiveness, reconciliation, collaboration, communion. If you are not prepared to change this approach, there is a serious problem: taht of thinking and acting only politically. In this regard, the Holy See hopes for everyone a sincere pastoral conversion inspired by the Gospel of mercy, in order to learn to welcome one another among brothers and sisters, as Pope Francis has often called for".

    What would you say to the Chinese leaders today?

    "Look, on this point I would like to refer again to Benedict XVI's words in his Letter to the Chinese Catholics. He teaches that the mission proper to the Church is not to change the structures or administration of the State, but to proclaim to mankind Christ, the Savior of the world, relying on the power of God. The Church in China does not want to replace the state, but wants to make a positive and serene contribution for the good of all. Therefore, the Holy See's message is a message of goodwill, with the hope of continuing the dialogue undertaken in order to contribute to the life of the Catholic Church in China, to the good of the Chinese people and to World peace".

    http://www.lastampa.it/2018/01/31/v...with-china-C8mlJsD0PDNsmsx7db6ZIJ/pagina.html
     
    Cynthia Raenette Gee likes this.
  8. padraig

    padraig Powers

    I am just curious David; is there anything at all, anything at all however slight that may cause you concern with either the Vatican or the Holy Father and their goings on at the moment or indeed at any point during the present Pontificate?

    Anything whatsoever? Go ahead, go for, rack your brain.:)

    Go ahead anything at all...
     
    HeavenlyHosts likes this.
  9. padraig

    padraig Powers

  10. davidtlig

    davidtlig Guest

    That's a fair question!

    In truth, I do not have any concerns about Francis as I see him behaving as Jesus would if he walked the earth today. But there are several things that I disagree with him about.

    First of all, Medjugorje. I am surprised by his personal opinion on the events there although I think I understand them.

    I do not 'buy' the current world view on climate change which the Pope seems to accept totally.

    I do think Francis has a natural affinity to socialism which I do not hold.

    I think he possibly underestimates the problems associated with mass migration but I'm very ready to accept that my position may not be what Jesus would want.

    I can't think of anything else! :)
     
  11. padraig

    padraig Powers

    God bless you for your honesty, David.:)

    What is really happening in China I believe is this:

    For the same reason the Vatican/ Pope Francis sold out the Right to Life Movement down a dirty river river, along with millions of unborn babies they are selling out millions of persecuted Chinese Catholics.; because it would not suit an agenda that seeks to Marry the Church to the world.

    Or, to put it another they just get in the road.

    The Chinese State and the Liberal Western Elites do suit and you can't marry the Church to the World unless you get along with new in-laws. The same reason they don't make much noise about Islamic extermination of Christians. Or call sexual perversion Evil. It would be inconvenient to do so..

    It's just as evil and ruthless as that. They don't suit the Big Idea..
     
    Last edited: Feb 2, 2018
  12. Luan Ribeiro

    Luan Ribeiro Powers

    I suppose that the bishops appointed by the state have an invalid teaching, or not?
     
  13. AED

    AED Powers

    Frightening. What saint/prophet warned of when”the Church and the world are one...” disaster would come?
     
  14. AED

    AED Powers

    They are controlled by the government. They teach what the state wishes and they permit what the state permits etc. and they don’t /can’t recognize the Holy Father as their authority. It is Henry VIII all over again.
     
  15. Jarg

    Jarg Archangels

    ...the Church will be full of those who accept compromises... (Akita)
     
  16. Carol55

    Carol55 Ave Maria

    AED, I'm not certain but I recalled the following:

    St. Methodius (4th century). "'A day will come when the enemies of Christ will boast of having conquered the whole world. They will say: 'Christians cannot escape now!' But a Great King will arise to fight the enemies of God. He will defeat them, and peace will be given to the world, and the Church will be freed from her anxieties."
    ​
    EDITED TO ADD: What you are thinking of could be in Yves Dupont's book, "Catholic Prophecy: The Coming Chastisement",
    http://ia802602.us.archive.org/6/items/CatholicProphecy/CatholicProphecy.pdf
     
    Last edited: Feb 2, 2018
    DivineMercy and AED like this.
  17. Blizzard

    Blizzard thy kingdom come

    View attachment 7402
     
  18. Carol55

    Carol55 Ave Maria

    Blizzard, What a wonderful memory that you have!

    The prophecy is in Dupont's book on page 36. Here is the entire prophecy along with Dupont's comments:

    43. St. Anthony of the Desert (4th century) [Disquisition CXIV]. "Men will surrender to the spirit of the age. They will say that if they had lived in our day, Faith would be simple and easy. But in their day, they will say, things are complex; the Church must be brought up to date and made meaningful to the day's problems. When the Church and the World are one, then those days are at hand. Because our Divine Master placed a barrier between His things and the things of the world." (Quoted in Voice of Fatima, January 23, 1968) .

    Conmment: Most prophecies quoted in this book are translations from other languages, viz., Latin, French, German, Italian, and other languages, as the case may be. Old prophecies like the one quoted above are translated from the Latin. Obviously, the choice of suitable words for rendering the original is a matter for the translator to decide. However, in this case, the words "up to date" and "meaningful" are a little surprising because they are precisely the words used by today's Progressives to justify their reckless innovations. If the rendering is absolutely correct, then St Anthony was remarkably perspicacious.
    ​
    PS - I think we should keep an eye on the following, http://www.ncregister.com/blog/edwa...ed-on-divisions-in-church-papal-infallibility . Brian posted this related article, https://remnantnewspaper.com/web/in...atch-rumors-mount-mysterious-roman-conference . I don't want to forget about this because it could be very critical.
     
    Don_D, Blizzard, AED and 1 other person like this.
  19. garabandal

    garabandal Powers

    This has made my day.

    McAleese has heterodox views on many issues.

    Thank God there is a Bishop who has some sense ---
     
    DeGaulle, AED and sterph like this.
  20. Jarg

    Jarg Archangels

    This quote is everywhere, but does anyone know an actual source for it? I mean a source that can withstand scrutiny.

    You mentioned the 'Dupont' book, and I wonder what is his source (or the source of Voice of Fatima). St Athanasius, friend of St Anthony wrote a biography about him, maybe it comes from there?
     
    Last edited: Feb 2, 2018
    Carol55 likes this.

Share This Page