It took me a long time to get used to the idea of criticising my Pope. It doesn't come naturally to a Catholic with orthodox views and it is natural that people will come around to the idea at different paces, dependent on a multitude of factors. I take it as Praetorian's principal point that Mallet is also slowly undergoing this process of seeing the penny drop. Your accusation seems very harsh.
It seems very difficult to explain or understand Pope Francis. Confusion seems to be the best word for it. As their philosophy inherently permits them, in humpty-dumptyish fashion and as they have no fear of God or Hell, to tell lies and half-truths, the liberals have been best able to take advantage for spinning Pope Francis to their own ends. But where Pope Francis sits on any position, if he does for very long at all, is not easy to discern. As Padraig says, his sanity might be in question. Likewise his cognitive ability to grasp many of the complex issues he asserts his opinions on. His personal history points to a man who may never have been suitable for promotion beyond that of 'loose canon'. That he made the papacy is more a reflection of the state of the Church than the character of Pope Francis. It is a trait of flawed bureaucracies (and are there any that are unflawed?) to appoint people to their level of inability. With Pope Francis the bureaucrats have excelled themselves. One thing is certain-the whitening is being scrubbed cleanly from the sepulcher.
Pope attempts to justify in-flight wedding by saying couple had marriage prep eight years ago https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/p...ight-wedding-by-saying-couple-had-marriage-pr
So we now have the Holy Father 'ranting' do we! What a sad reflection of the state of internet commentary on our Holy Father! For those who would prefer to actually read what Francis has said on the matter, I copy a couple of paragraphs from his message: Communication is part of God’s plan for us and an essential way to experience fellowship. Made in the image and likeness of our Creator, we are able to express and share all that is true, good, and beautiful. We are able to describe our own experiences and the world around us, and thus to create historical memory and the understanding of events. But when we yield to our own pride and selfishness, we can also distort the way we use our ability to communicate. This can be seen from the earliest times, in the biblical stories of Cain and Abel and the Tower of Babel (cf. Gen 4:4-16; 11:1-9). The capacity to twist the truth is symptomatic of our condition, both as individuals and communities. On the other hand, when we are faithful to God’s plan, communication becomes an effective expression of our responsible search for truth and our pursuit of goodness. In today’s fast-changing world of communications and digital systems, we are witnessing the spread of what has come to be known as “fake news”. This calls for reflection, which is why I have decided to return in this World Communications Day Message to the issue of truth, which was raised time and time again by my predecessors, beginning with Pope Paul VI, whose 1972 Message took as its theme: “Social Communications at the Service of Truth”. In this way, I would like to contribute to our shared commitment to stemming the spread of fake news and to rediscovering the dignity of journalism and the personal responsibility of journalists to communicate the truth. http://www.vaticannews.va/en/pope/n...s-day-message-2018-truth-journalism-fake.html
Yes, I am not sure how much his mental state is a mitigating factor or not. I thing the key factor in psychcology is functionally, in if people can get things done. Agree of disagree with him I don;t think that there is any doubt he can get things done. But the key thing with him appears to be this constant thread of rage, this huge stream of anger that appears to run right through his life right back to his earliest years. This in its turn leads to an impulsiveness a rashness in words and actions that appears baffling to the outsider. In addition to this , maybe part of it this huge need for affirmation for people to agree with him to praise him. Apparently even the drivers, , the servants, the soldiers, what have you are terrified of his volcanic mood swings. This is not normal. In a phrase, a loose cannon.
Yeah well here is some fake news from PF himself... Consider these words by which His Holiness, preaching in Italian, commented on the Gospel incident: "We know what Jesus did on that occasion. Instead of returning home with his family, he stayed in Jerusalem, in the Temple, provoking great suffering (provocando una grande pena) to Mary and Joseph, who were unable to find him. For this little 'escapade' (questa 'scappatella'), Jesus probably had to ask forgiveness (dovette chiedere scusa) of his parents. The Gospel doesn’t say this, but I believe that we can presume it."
Well, the Pope's comments on that incident are interesting. Yes, the incident will have been a great suffering for Mary and Joseph but I believe Francis may be mistaken about Jesus asking forgiveness of his parents. For the benefit of those who haven't shackled themselves into thinking that the Poem of the Man-God is not from the Holy Spirit, here is the Lord's commentary on this incident: Let us go back, far back. Let us go back to the Temple where I, a twelve year old boy, am disputing. Nay, let us go back to the roads which take one to Jerusalem and from Jerusalem to the Temple. See Mary's distress, when She realised, after the groups of men and women had gathered together, that I was not with Joseph. She does not reproach Her spouse bitterly. Every woman would have done that. You do so for much less, forgetting that man is still the head of the family. But the pain that appears on Mary's face pierces Joseph's heart more than any bitter reproach. Mary does not give vent to dramatic outbursts. You do so for much less because you love to be noticed and pitied. But Her repressed sorrow is so obvious: She starts trembling, Her face turns pale, Her eyes are wide open and thus She arouses pity more than any outburst of tears and cries. She is no longer tired or hungry. And yet the journey was a long one and She has not taken any food for so many hours! But She leaves everything: the bed She was preparing and the food which was ready to be handed out. And She goes back. It is night, it is dark. It does not matter. Every step takes Her back to Jerusalem. She stops the caravans and pilgrims and questions them. Joseph follows Her and helps Her. A long day's walk back to Jerusalem and then the feverish search in town. Where, where can Her Jesus be? And by God's provision for many hours She will not know where to look for Me. To look for a child in the Temple does not make sense. What could a child be doing in the Temple? At most, if he had got lost in town and his little steps had brought him back there, he would have cried for his mother and thus would have attracted the attention of people and of the priests, who would have taken the necessary steps to find the parents by means of announcements left at the gates. But there was no announcement. No one in town knew anything of this Child. Beautiful? Blond? Strong? There are so many like that! It is too little to enable anyone to say: “I saw Him. He was there or there!” Then, after three days, the symbol of three other days of future anguish, Mary, exhausted, enters the Temple, walks along the yards and the halls. Nothing. She runs, the poor Mother, whenever She hears the voice of a child. Even the bleating of the lambs give Her the impression that She hears Her Creature weeping and looking for Her. But Jesus is not weeping. He is teaching. All of a sudden, from beyond the barrier of a large group of people, She hears His voice saying: “These stones will vibrate…” She endeavours to make Her way through the crowd, and succeeds after much effort. There is Her Son, standing in the midst of the doctors with His arms stretched out. Mary is the Prudent Virgin. But this time anxiety overcomes prudence. It is a hurricane that demolishes everything. She runs to Her Son, embraces Him, lifting Him off the stool and putting Him down on the ground and She exclaims: “Oh! Why have You done this to us? For three days we have been looking for You. Your Mummy is dying with pain, Son. Your father is exhausted with fatigue. Why, Jesus?” You do not ask “why” of Him Who knows. “Why” He behaved in a certain way. You do not ask those with a vocation “why” they leave everything to follow the voice of God. I was Wisdom and I knew. I was “called” to a mission and I was fulfilling it. Above the earthly father and mother there is God, the Divine Father. His interests are above ours, His affections are superior to everything else. And I tell My Mother. I finish teaching the doctors with the lesson to Mary, the Queen of doctors. And She has never forgotten it. The sun began to shine again in Her heart now that She had Me, humble and obedient, beside Her, but My words are deeply rooted in Her mind. There will be much sunshine and many clouds will gather in the sky during the next twenty-one years I will still be on the earth. And great joys and many tears will alternate in Her heart during the next twenty-one years. But never again will She ask: “My Son, why have You done this to us?” Oh, insolent men, learn your lesson
How are you able to discern when Pope Francis might be mistaken, as in this case (as you yourself assert) and when he is not? The only measure I know is the deposit of Faith handed down from Christ Himself and His Apostles, from Tradition, from the Fathers and Doctors and contained within the solemn and universal, ordinary Magisterium.
The Pope has regularised an irregular situation, which is a good thing. Unfortunately, he has chosen irregular means to do so. Irregularity does not tend to beget regularity. This example will tend to induce more irregular situations.
If indeed, as the pope say's, the couple was prepped for marriage 8 years ago, then they have more culpability to their grave sin of fornication/co-habitation and it should have been clear to the pope that they needed more marriage preparation and the sacrament of penance before he should have ever married them. It is trivializing and sensationalizing the sacrament of marriage and this is not the will of God.
Yes, it always seems that such discernments are heavily dosed with regular human reactions/from only the material world's assessment....as if the mind of Christ was not constantly connected to the Mind of the Father and His Divine Will....even when things appear strange to the defective human understanding. And if one would read the mystical framework of such examples within the writings of the Servant of God, Cora Evans, one is given an understanding of the reality of the Immaculate Heart of Mary and how her reactions to such human types of separation from loved ones were very different from the normal defective reactions of of those effected by the fall of the original parents. Actually she was always trying to learn, through the actions of her Son, that Mind of the Father within Him.....why she kept things within her heart as she learned more.
https://onepeterfive.com/operation-catechism-homo-heresy-makes-final-assault/ Operation Catechism: The Homo-Heresy Makes the Final Assault OnePeterFive January 24, 2018130 Comments by Andrea Zambrano Change the Catechism. If its doctrine does not coincide with the new desired orthodoxy concerning homosexuality, it will be better to adopt the solution of Alexander the Great, who with one stroke of his sword decided to untangle the Gordian knot in his own way: by cutting it in two. In the same way, in order to accept and definitively clear the way for homo-erotic practice, it is necessary to address the fundamentals, and from there everything will be easier. Now that an attitude of laxity and acceptance of homosexuality as a natural variant of human sexuality is becoming increasingly common, there remains only one small obstacle to adding a full affirmation of LGBT rights as an ingredient in the “Christian salsa” – to remove the Catechism of the Catholic Church, considered the last obstacle to be overcome. Thus the battle will now move to a doctrinal level, but everything must be prepared with an affected and reassuring language which only a certain attitude of clericalism knows how to do. Above all, there must first be sent forth pioneers who make themselves interpreters and spokesmen of this line of thought. A small group of theologians and priests, a few bishops and even so-called pastoral workers, who lead a solitary battle outside of all restraint [from the Magisterium], but who place themselves prominently in view in their dioceses, while the silent majority is dozing. The last shot, chronologically, is given to certain lay people, according to the precisely-ordered tapestry of the tearful cause. So reports Repubblica, telling the story of two parents who have accepted their lesbian daughter and have now joined the team put together by the Bishop of Civitavecchia, Luigi Marrucci, who himself belongs to the so-called Christian LGBT movement. “We were firmly convinced that homosexuality was a sin,” they say. And now? “We prayed and read the parable of the Prodigal Son, and we came to understand that Lord accepts all without judging. Martina is living in the truth and we love her as she is.” What truth are they speaking about? Certainly not the truth of the Gospel or the story of Sodom in the Bible nor the truth of the Catechism, to which they make a little peep towards the end of the story: “The problem is with the Catechism, which says that homosexuality is an intrinsically-disordered orientation.” Here we have found the stumbling stone. This is the key observation necessary in order to “finally” clear the way for the homo-heresy in a Catholic tone. In fact this interview did not just happen by chance, rather, it was initiated from afar. Above all, to affirm the incompatibility of the Catechism, i.e., Catholic doctrine, with the world as it is experienced to be, which would be a worldview based on immanent experience and thus not based on truths of the Divine Law. But so it is. Chronologically, [those who want a Catholic revolution] must now put in doubt the truth about homosexuality as taught by the Catechism, as Avvenire observed here with a well-laid out editorial by Luciano Moia: “There are those who, recognizing the Catholic Tradition contained in the Catechism, maintain the necessity of an affective life conducted in chastity. But there are also those, including bishops and theologians, who ask the Church to make a more profound reflection on the significance of sexuality, not excluding a [permissive] revision of moral theology.” Who is right in this flirtation with moral relativism? The latter group seems to understand. Look at how here they are laying the groundwork to consider the Catechism no longer untouchable, introducing the virus of revision, as if the truth about man and the divine plan for the human race was merely a social construct subject to changing opinions. After the Avvenire article [May 2017] a top-secret mini-council was held, in the course of which was laid the foundation, so to speak for the future dismantling of articles 2357, 2358, and 2359 of the Catechism of the Catholic Church, in which it says that “Basing itself on Sacred Scripture, which presents homosexual acts as acts of grave depravity, Tradition has always declared that “homosexual acts are intrinsically disordered.” The meeting was promoted by one of the Jesuits who has been most closely involved with the work of clearing the way for homosexuality, a certain Fr. Pino Piva, who for some time has been the most “listened to” – at least in Italy – among homosexuals who profess to be Catholic but who do not accept the way of chastity proposed by the Catechism and also by the 1986 Letter on the Pastoral Care of Homosexual Persons written by then-cardinal Joseph Ratzinger. This Fr. Piva, newly moved to the Jesuit house in Bologna, has been gathering together groups of LGBT Christians and those operators who have been working in recent years in various dioceses following specific agendas, always being very careful of course to make sure that there are no experiences of prayer offered by Courage or the group called “Lot” run by Luca di Tolve, which hold views on homosexuality faithfully in line with the Magisterium. Joining this little team is also a bishop, who has helped out at these meetings but without intervening. The meeting is open to LGBT believers and to priests who have joined them in undertaking the most “diverse” lifestyles, without any pretense of trying to correct them, but rather desiring to throw into the dragnet all of these experiences and approaches as a way of addressing the theme of homosexuality in the life of the Church. There is only one common denominator: being critical of the Catechism, now considered the principal obstacle to a full gay-friendly opening to homo-erotic practice. Expressions like “sin”? Old-fashioned. “Welcome”? Only if you accept homosexuality as a natural variation of sexuality. “Love”? Only as a jumble of feelings and not as a naturally-ordered plan desired by God. Little is known about what takes place at this meeting, but something came out on the blog of Fr. Mauro Leonardi, another promoter of the homo-erotic cause, who has been in the game for a long time, even to the point of interviewing Vladimir Luxuria [an Italian “transgender” celebrity who as a Communist politician was the first openly “transgender” member of Parliament in Europe] without discussing or questioning any of her [his??] thinking. Leonardi, who writes a widely-followed blog, has dropped some real zingers, such as this one: “If however, as is true for the large majority of homosexual persons, one is convinced that the homosexual condition is natural and desired by God, can the only response of the Church really be: ‘As long as you don’t adhere to the Catechism (and besides, the Catechism is not the Gospel) you cannot receive the Sacraments?’ Is it even possible to confess sins which one’s conscience does not believe to be sins?” In sum, once we have eliminated all objective data on human nature and the divine order, homosexuality is also nothing other than a matter of each person’s opinion. And as such it must be accepted and promoted. In fact, also quoting the bishop present at the Bologna meeting, Leonardi said, “I do not tell you to adhere to the Catechism. I say: the Church still does not have an answer.” It would be an objectively grave matter if a bishop was promoting the thesis of rebellion against the Catechism, which represents not a mere code of laws taken off the street but the normative architecture on which the Faith is based. And it would be just as disturbing if a bishop truly affirmed that the Church still does not have an answer. Because in reality there actually is an answer which displays a united charity and truth in a truly thrilling way with respect to chastity, to which homosexuals are also called, as the experience of Courage has demonstrated. But now the gauntlet has been thrown down and the crusade against the Catechism must go forward. How will they proceed? They have also been sharpening their weapons on this strategy: drawing their inspiration from the “revision” of the Catechism proposed by Pope Francis on the death penalty and his pronouncements about the past concerning [the teaching of the Church about] the abolition of slavery. Arguments which are completely different, but useful here to justify a method of dismantling [the Catechism] that can now be useful for the homo-erotic cause. Originally published in Italian at La Nuova Bussola Quotidiana. Translated by Giuseppe Pellegrino
"In sum, once we have eliminated all objective data on human nature and the divine order, homosexuality is also nothing other than a matter of each person’s opinion. And as such it must be accepted and promoted. In fact, also quoting the bishop present at the Bologna meeting, Leonardi said, “I do not tell you to adhere to the Catechism. I say: the Church still does not have an answer.” It goes even further than this however because science will tell us that it is from the start of ones life that it is ordered this way for them. Never mind that so very many men and women have had tendencies toward same sex attractions (not to mention those who have been molested or raped and know sex in this way) through their lives however knowing what is right and true they DENIED THEMSELVES for love of God. What unbridled insanity is being embraced by these Priests? How can they even call themselves this?
In one way, it would be a good thing for the pope to change the CCC, so there is no more ambiguity with what he say's and his minions spin for him. I don't think it would change many of his followers minds. After all, they are more just and compassionate then God himself as they are willing to allow what he won't, nor what his papal magisterium has taught with such rigidity, legalism as the Pharisees did .
The whole bloody (excuse me, but I'm cross) point of the Prodigal Son parable is that he repented. He didn't return as the rake and spendthrift he had been, but as one prepared to live as one of his father's servant staff. It is absurd to describe sodomy as natural. There is an order of attracting opposites built into the very fundamentals of matter. The proton and the electron attract, two protons will repel, likewise two electrons. The natural universe is also replete with complementary opposites. Hot and cold, light and dark, wet and dry and so on. Men and women are created, as we are told in the very first book of the Bible, to attract and complement one another as per the order of the universe. Not only do they complement one another in their masculine and feminine personalities, but their respective sexual organs are miraculously structured to fit each other perfectly and all this with the privilege of being able to partake in God's creation and beget children. And the sodomites have the nerve to insist that futilely expending their creative potential into the faecal channel, the human sewer, is equivalent. They want to make a sacrament of this. One can see why Our Lord said of satan that he was a liar and a murderer. No matter what these rebels do, it is futile. All they are manipulating is men. They cannot manipulate God, nor will they be able to take Heaven by force.
BINGO. They do truly believe that this act is an act of creation. They speak at length about it in some of the occult teachings. We are most certainly among wolves. We are instructed to be as wise as serpents and innocent as doves.
It brings such inner darkness to the soul that this vice is one of the sins that cries to heaven for justice. Please pray for the success of groups like Courage who do so much to bring our prodigal brothers & sisters into the light. https://couragerc.org/ The Five Goals were created by the members themselves, when Courage was founded. The goals are read at the start of each meeting and each member is called to practice them in daily life. Here are the Goals in their entirety. To live chaste lives in accordance with the Roman Catholic Church's teaching on homosexuality. ( Chastity ) To dedicate our entire lives to Christ through service to others, spiritual reading, prayer, meditation, individual spiritual direction, frequent attendance at Mass, and the frequent reception of the sacraments of Reconciliation and Holy Eucharist. (Prayer and Dedication) To foster a spirit of fellowship in which we may share with one another our thoughts and experiences, and so ensure that no one will have to face the problems of homosexuality alone. (Fellowship) To be mindful of the truth that chaste friendships are not only possible but necessary in a chaste Christian life; and to encourage one another in forming and sustaining these friendships. (Support) To live lives that may serve as good examples to others. (Good Example/Role Model)