What is even more horrifying to me is that the Church paid her. It did not fight it or even deeply investigate the claims at all. This brought even MORE shame on her family many years later, who is my family. I don't want to offend anyone here, I don't know how else to put this in a way which would not do so because we should all be truly and deeply offended by it. The Church leadership, in relation to how it has handled these molestation and sex scandal accusations in the past has acted much in the same way as a beaten woman. Horrified by her own crimes she does not respect herself but willingly accepts every beating which comes her way and justifies them in her own mind as being truly deserving of them. Until she is destroyed. They should be ashamed.
DeGaulle, This is a case of somebody looses either way, but... Years ago when I heard about the first case of a clergyman committing atrocities like these and it was covered up, my first instinct was to defend the Church. It seemed that everyone who wanted to take a shot at the Catholic Church came out of the wood work to do so. Now, after these scandals have lingered for as long as they have and the accusations of cover-ups, etc. I think it is better to air the dirty laundry and get it over with. At the very least, the Church needs to make an attempt to find the truth. I realize that there is a monetary issue but geez. With that said, I am sure that there are cases in which people are attempting to extort money by making false accusations but I believe that there is a total of four accusers in this case* and then there are these accusations against the bishop which the Pope states lack evidence. The Boston Globe article refers to Rev. Fernando Karadimas as Chile’s most notorious pedophile and it states the following in relation to Bishop Barros, Juan Carlos Claret, spokesman for a group of Osorno lay Catholics who have mounted a three-year campaign against Barros, questioned why Francis was now accusing the victims of slandering Barros when the Vatican was so convinced of their claims that it planned to remove him in 2014. ‘‘Isn’t the pastoral problem that we’re living (in Osorno) enough to get rid of him?’’ Claret asked. Do you know what is meant by pastoral problem in Osorno? It appears to be very suspicious imho. The author of this blog post, Bonald, raises some very good points but I think that he should be a little more concerned about finding out what the truth is. Imho, we as Catholics should be in search of the truth. Amen. *https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karadima_case
https://www.gloria.tv/article/4PoqsGQ6veabBBVQxaSku271s Absurd Justification, Vatican Calls Order Of St Gregory An Insult 8 hours ago Vatican officials believe that awarding the ruthless Dutch pro-abortion and pro-gay politician Lilianne Ploumen with the Pontifical Order of St Gregory the Great was meant as a “snub”, Edward Pentin writes on ncregister.com (January 22). A source told Pentin that Ploumen will not be installed as a Dame of the Order and the medal was meant as a “slight” because a government minister normally receives more distinguished decorations. Deacon Nick Donnelly asks on “Twitter” whether “they really expect us to believe this absurd justification” adding, "If Reinhard Heydrich visited Francis as a member of a diplomatic delegation would he be honoured with a papal award? Heydrich was the architect of the Holocaust.”
So it acheives what exactly? It demeans the awarding of the Pontifical Order of St Gregory the Great. Why would anyone want to intentionally demean this honor no matter where it ranks in the scheme of things? Was there some stigma associated to it beforehand? Nuts!
I would think that anyone with "THE GREAT" amended to their title would be a great great honor to be awarded a medal after them, let alone someone who gave so much to the poor.
I don't think the problem was the covering up, but the fact that they weren't dealt with. If the first cases had been immediately handed over to the secular arm and consequently defrocked if found guilty, this whole mess might have been nipped in the bud before the opportunists arrived. It is indisputable that an accused Catholic priest is guilty now until proven innocent. This standard is not applied by the media against other religions, teachers, sports coaches and so on, nor is there the same front-page circus of headlines, not to mention the ceaseless editorial attacks. If the Church attempts to question this narrative, perhaps even for the best of motives, it is immediately and very publicly attacked as being soft, at the very least, on abuse. Bonald is very reactionary in his views, which he would be the first to admit (and does, in the article itself), but it is in the interests of balance (and truth) that this side of the issue is expressed.
DeGaulle, Yes absolutely, that is what I meant by airing the dirty laundry - dealing with it. I also agree that Bonald made some very good points that needed to be stated. I still wonder what was meant by pastoral problems in regards to Bishop Barros, it appears that this is something in addition to these allegations related to the sex abuse case. The little that I do know about this case doesn't help me to understand why the Pope has handled it the way he has. Even if Pope Francis is correct that there is a lack of evidence in regards to Bishop Barros in the sex abuse case, it appears that the people there experienced other problems in the Bishop Barros' regard. The Pope did nothing to heal the people's wounds, instead he "spat" in their faces imho. He could have moved Bishop Barros out of Chile entirely, maybe to a lifetime of "penance and prayer" like Rev. Karadima or something other than making him a bishop of another diocese there. Possibly more information will come out in the future that will help me make sense of it all but right now it doesn't look that way. I found another article about this, it sounds like a botched plan to help heal the Chilean people'e wounds, Barros was told a similar exit strategy had been planned for two other Karadima-trained bishops, but was asked not to share the information, the pope wrote. He said the plan went awry when Barros named the two others in his letter stepping down as military bishop — a development that posed "a serious problem," and "blocked any eventual path, in the sense of offering a year of sabbatical," to remove the three from the eye of the storm roiling the Chilean church. https://www.ncronline.org/news/accountability/pope-letter-details-concern-over-chile-bishop I apologize if I am posting information that has been posted already on this thread. I don't think I am keeping up with all of the posts lately.
Reminds me a bit of when Obama, from the start, tried to set up a world of anger and division in which he was most comfortable with statements like "if 'they' bring a knife you bring a gun" when no one was even thinking about such things. So these types work to bring about a reality of anger in which they feel perhaps more comfortable due to their own personal makeup, which is not the reality for the most part. It's a kind of reflection of their own inner outlook of doom....so the world must also conform to that inner confusion. The complexity of the human condition MUST be able to be solved with simplistic and thus conforming tactics to the masses. It's a pretty self destructive approach. It's kind of ironic since being a Liberal is supposed to be about live and let live, but all I see is this constant fury with people who happen to disagree.
One of the things I notice these days from the media is how often people are angry. I was listening again to Fulton Sheen this morning. He mentioned that the original meaning of the word, 'Diabolical', from the Ancient Greek was to tear; to rend. Anger is what causes this tearing , this rending and so when I see anger and fury I tend to think of the diabolical. I notice this very often , for instance, in people who want to murder unborn babies. This huge anger. It's ironic when Liberalism is supposed to be all about , 'Live and let live'.
Cardinal Burke: It is a “source of anguish” to hear suggestions “that I would lead a schism” http://www.catholicworldreport.com/...-hear-suggestions-that-i-would-lead-a-schism/
Though I never agree with everything Mark Mallett writes in his articles, I generally agree with the main thrust of this one. We must accept that Pope Francis is the Pope and we must show charity when we can. It is very clear in what he writes, or more importantly what he doesn't write, that he is beginning to see more and more clearly. Not perfectly yet, but what one of us does? It is interesting to see how many references he makes to "bad Popes" the "alcoholic father" argument and the like. Certainly an awareness and acknowledgement of the situation is grabbing hold in his mind. I don't think he would have used this language a year ago. Though he states we must respect the Holy Father, he also seems to be clearly distancing himself from the fanboy club which I think he used to be much closer to (though I admit I am not a regular reader and perhaps I am wrong on this point). He shows extreme humility and charity, almost at times to the point of looking foolishly naive, but one cannot blame him. He is obviously trying to make sense of the current confusion and is searching for some way to make what is happening fall in line with Church Tradition. Straining to the limits of his knowledge and faith to do so. My personal opinion is that God has been slow in waking him up to the truth of the situation to bring along his readership to that truth as well. A group that I would guess is mostly comprised of faithful "centrist" Catholics who might have become scandalized if they were shown the whole truth all at once a year ago.
mmm .. I'm not so sure. I like Mark and count him as a friend... but I'm not so sure. I'd be inclined to be a lot more hard nosed about Pope Francis. A great deal more. You have to call them as you see them. Popes or not. Let's not go calling bitter; sweet. There's been lot of good Popes in the past, lot's of bad Popes too. I don't see him as lost and confused. I don't see him as lost and confused at all. Maybe that's not the way you're supposed to talk about Popes, but calling a spade a spade had become kind of a habit. Maybe I've read far too much history. My reading is he knows exactly what he's doing and that what he's doing is bad. I don't know if that maybe makes me a good Catholic or a bad Catholic, but I hope to the Good God it makes me an honest , straight talking Catholic.
It is clear that sides are being chosen (good or evil) and the diabolical will seem nice and cordial, that is until they see you don't agree with them, then they become filled with hatred and rage to anyone who does not accept their ideologies of darkness.
I have found few blogs of Mark Mallett's that I do not embrace. However, in his recent blog, "striking God's anointed one" Mark M fails to address the the manner in which the Pope is undermining the faith through others. He gives his associates a free hand to operate under his cover to gut the faith and the moral teachings of the Church. There are many verifiable examples of this and it is not in the spirit of truth or right judgement that he does so. Never the less, one must continue to pray that he wakes up and see's what his appeasement to many enemies of the truth are doing.
I must pray for him. Riding two horses at the same time must be a hard task. But you can't ride two horses forever. You have to get off the one and on the other at some point. I'm very fond of him but I must be honest, he could end up doing a lot of harm if he carries on with this much further. Loads of harm
Don't you love the way they stayed on message and stayed calm. Real troopers. He let the cat out if the bag at the end when they told him he needed Jesus.
I can't imagine Mark being hard nosed. It doesn't seem in his nature. I do see a mobility and progression of his thinking in the right direction though. Perhaps not as swift or complete as some of us here would like, but it seems in the right direction nonetheless. One point where I would disagree with you is guessing the Pope's inner motives. In charity we should not do this. We can have our strong and educated thoughts about the matter, but we honestly cannot know anyone's interior motives or how their mind is working. We do need to deal with the objective facts though. Whatever the motivations behind them, this is what we are dealing with: 1. The Church is in utter chaos and nothing productive seems to be being done about it. In fact if it were possible, it seems to be that the chaos is purposely being allowed to fester, even fostered. It almost seems as if everything that could be done to bring about disunity and chaos in the Church is being done. 2. Clarity of moral teaching is gone. 3. Unification of faith among believers is gone. 4. Heretics are being given a free voice to confuse the faithful and are even being promoted up through the ranks. The list could go on... In short the Church is disintegrating and I mean that in the literal sense of the word. Dis-Integrating. Losing it's integrity. There are now effectively two moral teachings in the Catholic Church. One says there are moral absolutes and one says there are not. One believes in the constancy of Church Teaching and one believes in Moral Relativism. These are very fundamental and HUGE differences. Both cannot be true, which means we are dealing with a true set of teachings and a false set of teachings. The above is a recipe for SCHISM. Not something I desire or promote, but understanding human nature this is a strong possibility. It is the prime mission of the Pope (every Pope) to preach the faith clearly, undiluted and unchanged, to the faithful and to guide them to salvation. Clearly there is confusion here. It must be addressed clearly and definitively.
Does anyone know what happened to the alleged "commission" or whatever that has been tasked with inventing the new liturgy? I had understood that this had already been going before it had ever received any notice in the media....I guess, rather in secrecy. Now it seemed that it was mainly those who could be classified in the conservative category that had been on the receiving end of the Pope's noticeable criticism and even rather simplistic labeling of them. The latest is that the Pope is ranting now against Fake News. "Fake News" has been the established label of the conservatives since they have been the targets of such. Sooooo, are there "handlers" of the Pope who have enlisted him to somehow try to play both sides against the middle in order to leave the thoughtful and trusting with their heads spinning.....in order to distract from what continues to be happening behind the curtain?