The Vatican Has Fallen

Discussion in 'Church Critique' started by padraig, Dec 31, 2016.

  1. DeGaulle

    DeGaulle Powers

    Maybe Cardinal Newman did get it wrong. I don't actually think so, because Newman was faithful to Christ, not Pope Francis. Anyway, I have faith in Christ, not in Newman, nor Bergoglio. You seem to me very close, on the basis of your posting, to be giving Francis precedence over Christ. Humans are nothing, literally. They are created out of nothing and that's all they are without the Word. Put your faith in any human being, and you put it in nothing. Nothing. Any human being who seeks to mould Christ in their own image for the sake of ease or popularity or politics is only heading down the broad highway.

    Those grave obligations you stress leave no room for the intolerance of adultery or perversity, but instead imply an immediate condemnation by any faithful pontiff of those who would propagate such ideals of Hell. Tell me why Pope Francis gushes over a still fanatical proponent of abortion while mocking those who dedicate themselves to saying the rosary. Tell me why he seeks to create a whole new sin ex nihilo of objecting to invasive 'immigration' in contradiction to his saintly predecessor, John Paul II, the Great, who spoke of the necessity of control. Tell me why those who advocate blessings for sodomy marriage are tolerated, but those who condemn antiChristian hedonism are condemned. Do you really think Christ would echo Bergoglio? Answer me that (I have answered your questions).
     
  2. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

    As predicted, the homily at today's Mass was all about living our faith by welcoming migrants. The epistle which specifically warns against fornication was completely ignored. We get this at Mass week in, week out as though the priests think that people attending Mass are forming migrant hunting lynch mobs and the Church is desperately trying to quell our murderous intent. I don't know what planet they are living on. I'm also absolutely sickened by their evidently low opinion of their parishioners.

    What is staring these priests in the face and what they choose to ignore is that almost everybody lines up for Communion but hardly anyone goes to Confession; that sex before marriage is the norm; that few of the parents in the pews and none of the priests at Mass ever warn their teenage offspring that fornication is a sin; that many of the people in the pews most likely voted to legalise gay marriage and just as many are likely to vote for abortion. Despite that stark reality and much, much more, not least Catholics' failure to believe in the Real Presence, the homily was about migration. Maybe the priest connected with others in the pews but I felt completely detached as though I were watching a scene from a boring movie.

    Come to think of it, he did mention the Epistle at the end when he somehow managed to remind us that our bodies being temples of the Holy Spirit means that we should welcome migrants.

    And they wonder why the churches are half empty?
     
    Byron, josephite, SgCatholic and 6 others like this.
  3. Blizzard

    Blizzard thy kingdom come

  4. DeGaulle

    DeGaulle Powers

    2. and 3., being devoid of Original Sin, will never let you down. But you know that very well, already. All that is corrupted by Original Sin...well, I know, from my own deeds, what they are capable of.

    The Pope is not micromanaged, he has the gift of Free Will that has been given to us all. Peter did not find himself tongue-tied or lost for words when presented with the moral choice of support or denial for His Lord. Despite having intimate personal acquaintance and knowledge of Jesus Christ for three years, despite having heard His words and witnessed His deeds (and those of the Father and the Holy Ghost) for the duration of that period (of which the rest of us are aware only of a fraction), despite having realised His true identity for much of this time, Peter still let Him down. How could one put any faith in any other mere human being on the throne of Peter, except to the degree that they did nothing but affirm what has always been true? Which is exactly what is contained in their job description. By definition, they are retainers, not innovators. For to require innovation would necessarily imply that Christ had provided us with an inadequate Revelation, one that would not cover all the problems and situations of all times and places. To take this view is to deny the omniscience of God. It is to obligate us to believe that God requires us human beings to fix His own shoddy workmanship. This adds blasphemy to all the other evils. Anyone that expects us to swallow that can get away with themselves.
     
    Last edited: Jan 14, 2018
    josephite, Don_D and AED like this.
  5. DeGaulle

    DeGaulle Powers

    Very few of these migrants seem to share the view that bodies are the temples of the Holy Spirit. I suspect most propagators of this insanity are atheists. No true believer in the Gospel could be so foolish. We are told to love our enemies, but this has extended in the past to killing them for their own good. It never meant accepting or honouring their heathen, and ultimately satanic, worldview. One was always meant to love the enemy but hate his errors. Obviously, if the country was being swarmed by hordes of Phillipino immigrants, eager to work and assimilate in our society, most of us would be delighted, knowing they would improve the moral stance of our country. Instead, we are supposed to encourage the immigration of those who mostly offer nothing to our economy, instead parasitising our social welfare system, and who professedly hate our religion and dedicatedly seek to overwhelm us, if necessary by force.
     
    josephite, Don_D, AED and 3 others like this.
  6. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    Cardinal Newman would not agree with David. His name is simply being invoked to attempt to bring some gravitas to an otherwise hopeless argument. I have absolutely no problem with development of doctrine at all. No good Catholic should. It is one of the Church's missions.

    For example Pope St. John Paul II developed the doctrine on the divorced and so-called "remarried" when he wrote Familiaris Consortio. In it he laid down, in totally clear terms, that the civilly divorced and so-called "remarried" could only receive Holy Communion if they lived as brother and sister and this was meant only for the good of the children.

    Here is the difference between a development of doctrine and a break from doctrine:

    Example A.
    Pope Francis could develop the previous teachings further by saying something to the effect that, in addition to what Pope St. John Paul II said, the couples would not need to separate as soon as the child was an adult if the child has a mental or physical difficulty that might require longer care. This would need to be done with the guidance of a priest. That is true development.

    Example B.
    What Pope Francis cannot do is say what Pope Saint John Paul II is wrong and so-called divorced and remarried couples can now continue having sex (read that commit adultery) while staying together. That would be contrary to what Pope St. John Paul II clearly taught and a break in the Magisterium. A Pope cannot simply do whatever he wishes. It must always be in continuity with everything that has been taught before. That is official Magisterial Teaching and always has been.

    Example A would be development that is in continuity with the official Magisterial Teachings Of Pope St. John Paul II and everything that has gone before since Christ.

    Example B is a break from official Magisterial Teaching and is something alien to Catholic thought.
     
    Last edited: Jan 14, 2018
  7. DeGaulle

    DeGaulle Powers

    I would only add that Pope John Paul II and all his predecessors who promoted the same theology were only correct to the degree that they agreed with the teaching of Christ. These Truths did not come from the opinion of any mere man, not even one as great as Karol Wojtyla, but only from Jesus Christ. Only that which implicitly and explicitly comes wholly and entirely from Our Lord is what can be believed. It is our job to be His image and echo, nothing, not even a smidgin, more. His teaching is complete and immutable. Were there anything else to be said, He would have said it. In modern jargon, that makes me a fundamentalist. The only way to be.
     
  8. HeavenlyHosts

    HeavenlyHosts Powers

    When I think of the martyrs from the Reformation, and St. Maximilian Kolbe, that helps me.
    Dolours, our church is very often as you have described, except today our deacon mentioned to us as he said his sermon that we will soon be receiving the Body and Blood of Christ (after his sermon).....It was almost like God and Blessed Mother read my mind, that I wanted to hear about the Blessed Sacrament more...however, Dolours, I agree, people line up for Holy Communion and then you wonder if they have been to Confession.
    The holiness is dwindling.
     
  9. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    This is the perennial teaching of Catholicism. Its quite easy to see that, in contrast to the clear teaching here, AL does NOT and CANNOT constitute development of doctrine!!!

    http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/c..._doc_19980101_ratzinger-comm-divorced_en.html
    Reception of Holy Communion by divorced and remarried, Card. Joseph Ratzinger, 1998
    CONGREGATION FOR THE DOCTRINE OF THE FAITH

    CONCERNING SOME OBJECTIONS TO THE CHURCH'S TEACHING
    ON THE RECEPTION OF HOLY COMMUNION
    BY DIVORCED AND REMARRIED MEMBERS OF THE FAITHFUL
    [1]

    Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger

    The Letter of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith of 14 September 1994 concerning the reception of Holy Communion by divorced and remarried members of the faithful was met with a very lively response across wide sections of the Church. Along with many positive reactions, more than a few critical voices were also heard. The fundamental objections against the teaching and practice of the Church are outlined below in simplified form.

    Several of the more significant objections – principally, the reference to the supposedly more flexible practice of the Church Fathers which would be the inspiration for the practice of the Eastern Churches separated from Rome, as well as the allusion to the traditional principles of epicheia and of aequitas canonica – were studied in-depth by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. Articles by Professors Pelland, Marcuzzi and Rodriguez Luño[1], among others, were developed in the course of this study. The main conclusions of the research, which suggest the direction of an answer to the objections, will be briefly summarized here.

    1. Some maintain that several passages of the New Testament suggest that the words of Jesus on the indissolubility of marriage allow for a flexible application and cannot be classified in a strictly legal sense.

    Several exegetes point out critically that with regard to the indissolubility of marriage, the Magisterium cites almost exclusively one pericope – namely, Mk. 10:11-12 – and does not sufficiently take into account other passages from the Gospel of Matthew and the First Letter to Corinthians. They claim that these biblical passages speak of a certain exception to the Lord’s words about the indissolubility of marriage, notably in the case of porneia (Mt. 5:32; 19:9) and in the case of separation because of the faith (1 Cor. 7:12-16). They hold that these texts should be an indication that, already in apostolic times, Christians in difficult situations had known a flexible application of the words of Jesus.

    In replying to this objection, one notes that magisterial documents do not intend to present the biblical foundations of the teachings on marriage in a complete and exhaustive way. They entrust this important task to competent experts. The Magisterium emphasizes, however, that the teaching of the Church on the indissolubility of marriage is faithful to the words of Jesus. Jesus clearly identifies the Old Testament practice of divorce as a consequence of the hardness of the human heart. He refers – over and above the law – to the beginning of creation, to the will of the Creator, and summarizes his teaching with the words: “Therefore what God has joined together, no human being must separate,” (Mk. 10:9). With the coming of the Redeemer, marriage is therefore restored to its original form intended at creation and is wrested away from human arbitrariness – above all from the whim of the husband, since for wives there really was no possibility of divorce. Jesus’ words on the indissolubility of marriage overcome the old order of the law with the new order of faith and grace. Only in this way can marriage fully become a God-given vocation to love and human dignity and the sign of the unconditional covenant of divine love, i.e., a sacrament (cf. Eph. 5:32).

    The possibility of separation, which Paul discusses in 1 Cor. 7, regards marriage between a Christian and a non-baptized person. Later theological reflection has clarified that only marriages between baptized persons are a sacrament in the strict sense of the word, and that absolute indissolubility holds only for those marriages falling within the scope of Christian faith. So-called “natural marriage” has its dignity from the order of creation and is therefore oriented toward indissolubility, but it can be dissolved under certain circumstances because of a higher good – which in this case is faith. This is how systematic theology correctly classified St. Paul’s reference as the privilegium paulinum, that is, the possibility of dissolving a non-sacramental marriage for the good of the faith. The indissolubility of a truly sacramental marriage remains safeguarded; it is not therefore an exception to the word of the Lord. We will come back to this later.

    Extensive literature exists regarding the correct understanding of the porneia clauses, with many differing and even conflicting hypotheses. There is no unanimity among exegetes on this point. Many maintain that it refers to invalid marital unions, not to an exception to the indissolubility of marriage. In any case, the Church cannot construct her doctrine and praxis on uncertain exegetical hypotheses. She must adhere to the clear teaching of Christ.

    2. Others object that the patristic tradition leaves room for a more varied praxis, which would be more equitable in difficult situations; furthermore, the Catholic Church could learn from the principle of “economy” employed by Eastern Churches separated from Rome.

    It is claimed that the current Magisterium relies on only one strand of the patristic tradition, and not on the whole legacy of the ancient Church. Although the Fathers clearly held fast to the doctrinal principle of the indissolubility of marriage, some of them tolerated a certain flexibility on the pastoral level with regard to difficult individual cases. On this basis Eastern Churches separated from Rome later developed alongside the principle of akribia, fidelity to revealed truth, that of oikonomia, benevolent leniency in difficult situations. Without renouncing the doctrine of the indissolubility of marriage, in some cases they permit a second and even a third marriage, which is distinct, however, from the sacramental first marriage and is marked by a penitential character. Some say that this practice has never been explicitly condemned by the Catholic Church. They claim that the 1980 Synod of Bishops proposed to study this tradition thoroughly, in order to allow the mercy of God to be more resplendent.

    Father Pelland’s study points out the direction in which the answers to these questions can be sought. Naturally, for the interpretation of individual patristic texts, the work of historians is necessary. Because of the difficult textual issues involved, controversies will not be lacking in the future. Theologically, one must affirm the following:

    a. There exists a clear consensus among the Fathers regarding the indissolubility of marriage. Since it derives from the will of the Lord, the Church has no authority over it. For this reason, from the outset Christian marriage was distinct from marriage in Roman society, even though in the first centuries there did not yet exist any canonical system. The Church in the time of the Fathers clearly excluded divorce and remarriage, precisely out of faithful obedience to the New Testament.

    b. In the Church at the time of the Fathers, divorced and remarried members of the faithful were never officially admitted to Holy Communion after a time of penance. It is true, however, that the Church did not always rigorously revoke concessions in certain territories, even when they were identified as not in agreement with her doctrine and discipline. It also seems true that individual Fathers, Leo the Great being among them, sought pastoral solutions for rare borderline cases.

    c. This led to two opposing developments:

    - In the Imperial Church after Constantine, with the ever stronger interplay between Church and State, a greater flexibility and readiness for compromise in difficult marital situations was sought. Up until the Gregorian reform, a similar tendency was present in Gallic and Germanic lands. In the Eastern churches separated from Rome, this development progressed farther in the second millennium and led to an increasingly more liberal praxis. Today in some of these churches there are numerous grounds for divorce, even a theology of divorce, which is in no way compatible with Jesus’ words regarding the indissolubility of marriage. Without fail, this problem must be addressed in ecumenical dialogue.

    - In the West, on account of the Gregorian reform, the original concept of the Church Fathers was recovered. This development came to its conclusion at the Council of Trent and was once again expressed as a doctrine of the Church at the Second Vatican Council.

    On doctrinal grounds, the praxis of the Eastern churches separated from Rome cannot be taken up by the Catholic Church, as it is the result of a complex historical process, an increasingly liberal – and thus more and more removed from the words of the Lord – interpretation of several obscure patristic texts which were significantly influenced by civil law. Furthermore, the claim is incorrect that the Church simply tolerated such a praxis. Admittedly, the Council of Trent did not pronounce any explicit condemnation. The medieval canonists, however, consistently spoke of the praxis as improper. Furthermore, there is evidence that groups of Orthodox believers who became Catholic had to sign a profession of faith with an explicit reference to the impossibility of a second marriage.
     
  10. BrianK

    BrianK Guest



    3. Many propose to allow exceptions to the Church’s norm on the basis of the traditional principles of epikeia and aequitas canonica.

    Certain marriage cases, it is said, cannot be handled in the external forum. Some claim that the Church should not simply rely on juridical norms, but on the contrary ought to respect and tolerate the conscience of the individual. They say that theological notions of epikeia and aequitas canonica could serve to justify, from moral theology as well as juridically, a decision of conscience at variance from the general norm. Especially regarding the question of receiving the sacraments, they claim that the Church should take some steps forward and not just issue prohibitions to the faithful.

    The contributions made by Professor Marcuzzi and Professor Rodríguez Luño throw light on his complex problem. To this end, there are three areas of inquiry which clearly need to be distinguished from each other:

    a. Epikeia and aequitas canonica exist in the sphere of human and purely ecclesiastical norms of great significance, but cannot be applied to those norms over which the Church has no discretionary authority. The indissoluble nature of marriage is one of these norms which goes back to Christ Himself and is thus identified as a norm of divine law. The Church cannot sanction pastoral practices - for example, sacramental pastoral practices - which contradict the clear instruction of the Lord.

    In other words, if the prior marriage of two divorced and remarried members of the faithful was valid, under no circumstances can their new union be considered lawful and therefore reception of the sacraments is intrinsically impossible. The conscience of the individual is bound to this norm without exception.[2]

    b. However the Church has the authority to clarify those conditions which must be fulfilled for a marriage to be considered indissoluble according to the sense of Jesus' teaching. In line with the Pauline assertion in 1 Cor. 7, she established that only two baptized Christians can enter into a sacramental marriage. She developed the legal concept of the Pauline privilege and the Petrine privilege. With reference to the porneia clauses in Matthew and in Acts 15:20, the impediments to marriage were established. Furthermore, grounds for the nullity of marriage were identified with ever greater clarity, and the procedural system was developed in greater detail. All of this contributed to delineating and articulating more precisely the concept of the indissolubility of marriage. One can say that, in this way, the Western Church also made allowance for the principle of oikonomia, but without touching the indissolubility of marriage as such. The further juridical development of the 1983 Code of Canon Law was in this same direction, granting probative force to the declarations of the parties. Therefore, according to experts in this area, it seems that cases in which an invalid marriage cannot be shown to be such by the procedural are practically excluded.

    Since marriage has a fundamental public ecclesial character and the axiom applies that nemo iudex in propria causa (no one is judge in his own case), marital cases must be resolved in the external forum. If divorced and remarried members of the faithful believe that their prior marriage was invalid, they are thereby obligated to appeal to the competent marriage tribunal so that the question will be examined objectively and under all available juridical possibilities.

    c. Admittedly, it cannot be excluded that mistakes occur in marriage cases. In some parts of the Church, well-functioning marriage tribunals still do not exist. Occasionally, such cases last an excessive amount of time. Once in a while they conclude with questionable decisions. Here it seems that the application of epikeia in the internal forum is not automatically excluded from the outset. This is implied in the 1994 letter of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, in which it was stated that new canonical ways of demonstrating nullity should exclude “as far as possible” every divergence from the truth verifiable in the judicial process (cf. No. 9). Some theologians are of the opinion that the faithful ought to adhere strictly even in the internal forum to juridical decisions which they believe to be false. Others maintain that exceptions are possible here in the internal forum, because the juridical forum does not deal with norms of divine law, but rather with norms of ecclesiastical law. This question, however, demands further study and clarification. Admittedly, the conditions for asserting an exception would need to be clarified very precisely, in order to avoid arbitrariness and to safeguard the public character of marriage, removing it from subjective decisions.

    4. Some accuse the current Magisterium of reversing the doctrinal development of the Council and of substituting a pre-conciliar view of marriage.

    Some theologians claim that at the new magisterial documents having to do with questions of marriage are based on a naturalistic, legalistic concept of marriage. Attention is given to the contract between the spouses and to the ius in corpus. It is claimed that the Council overturned this static understanding and described marriage in a more personalistic way as a covenant of love and life. Thus it would have opened up possibilities for resolving difficult situations more humanely. Thinking further along this line, some scholars pose the question of whether or not one could speak of the death of the marriage, if the personal bond of love between the spouses no longer exists. Others resurrect the old question of whether or not the Pope would have the capability of dissolving marriage in such cases.

    Yet anyone who attentively reads the more recent statements of the Church will note that their central assertions are based on Gaudium et spes and that they further develop the teaching contained therein in a thoroughly personalist line, in the direction indicated by the Council. However, it is inappropriate to set up a contradiction between the personalist and juridical views of marriage. The Council did not break with the traditional concept of marriage, but on the contrary developed it further. When, for example, it is continually pointed out that the Council substituted the broader and theologically more profound concept of covenant for the strictly legal concept of contract, one must not forget that within covenant, the element of contract is also contained and indeed placed within a broader perspective. The fact that marriage reaches well beyond the purely juridical realm into the depths of humanity and into the mystery of the divine, has always been indicated by the word “sacrament,” although often it has not been pondered with the same clarity which the Council gave to these aspects. Law is not everything, but it is an indispensable part, one dimension of the whole. Marriage without a juridical dimension which integrates it into the whole fabric of society and the Church simply does not exist. If the post-Conciliar revision of canon law included the realm of marriage, this is not a betrayal of the Council, but the implementation of its mandate.

    If the Church were to accept the theory that a marriage is dead when the two spouses no longer love one another, then she would thereby sanction divorce and would uphold the indissolubility of marriage only in word, and no longer in fact. Therefore, the opinion that the Pope could potentially dissolve a consummated sacramental marriage, which has been irrevocably broken, must be considered erroneous. Such a marriage cannot be dissolved by anyone. At their wedding, the spouses promise to be faithful to each other until death.

    Further study is required, however, concerning the question of whether non-believing Christians – baptized persons who never or who no longer believe in God – can truly enter into a sacramental marriage. In other words, it needs to be clarified whether every marriage between two baptized persons is ipso facto a sacramental marriage. In fact, the Code states that only a “valid” marriage between baptized persons is at the same time a sacrament (cf. CIC, can. 1055, § 2). Faith belongs to the essence of the sacrament; what remains to be clarified is the juridical question of what evidence of the “absence of faith” would have as a consequence that the sacrament does not come into being.[3]
     
  11. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    5. Many argue that the position of the Church on the question of divorced and remarried faithful is overly legalistic and not pastoral.

    A series of critical objections against the doctrine and praxis of the Church pertain to questions of a pastoral nature. Some say, for example, that the language used in the ecclesial documents is too legalistic, that the rigidity of law prevails over an understanding of dramatic human situations. They claim that the human person of today is no longer able to understand such language, that Jesus would have had an open ear for the needs of people, particularly for those on the margins of society. They say that the Church, on the other hand, presents herself like a judge who excludes wounded people from the sacraments and from certain public responsibilities.

    One can readily admit that the Magisterium’s manner of expression does not seem very easy to understand at times. It needs to be translated by preachers and catechists into a language which relates to people and to their respective cultural environments. The essential content of the Church’s teaching, however, must be upheld in this process. It must not be watered down on allegedly pastoral grounds, because it communicates the revealed truth.

    Certainly, it is difficult to make the demands of the Gospel understandable to secularized people. But this pastoral difficulty must not lead to compromises with the truth. In his Encyclical Veritatis splendor, John Paul II clearly rejected so-called pastoral solutions which stand in opposition to the statements of the Magisterium (cf. ibid. 56).

    Furthermore, concerning the position of the Magisterium as regards the question of divorced and remarried members of the faithful, it must be stressed that the more recent documents of the Church bring together the demands of truth with those of love in a very balanced way. If at times in the past, love shone forth too little in the explanation of the truth, so today the danger is great that in the name of love, truth is either to be silenced or compromised. Assuredly, the word of truth can be painful and uncomfortable. But it is the way to holiness, to peace, and to inner freedom. A pastoral approach which truly wants to help the people concerned must always be grounded in the truth. In the end, only the truth can be pastoral. “Then you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free” (Jn. 8:32).

    [1] This text reproduces the third part of Cardinal Ratzinger’s Introduction to Volume 17 of the series produced by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, entitled “Documenti e Studi”, On the Pastoral Care of the Divorced and Remarried, LEV, Vatican City 1998, pp. 20-29. Footnotes have been added.

    [2] Cf. Angel Rodríguez Luño, L’epicheia nella cura pastorale dei fedeli divorziati risposati, ibid., pp. 75-87; Piero Giorgio Marcuzzi, S.D.B., Applicazione di "aequitas et epikeia" ai contenuti della Lettera della Congregazione per la Dottrina della Fede del 14 settembre 1994, ibid., pp. 88-98; Gilles Pelland, S.J., La pratica della Chiesa antica relativa ai fedeli divorziati risposati, ibid., pp. 99-131.

    [3] On this matter the norm referred to by John Paul II in his Apostolic Letter Familiaris consortio, no. 84, is quite valuable: “Reconciliation in the sacrament of Penance which would open the way to the Eucharist, can only be granted to those who, repenting of having broken the sign of the Covenant and of fidelity to Christ, are sincerely ready to undertake a way of life that is no longer in contradiction to the indissolubility of marriage. This means, in practice, that when, for serious reasons, such as for example the children's upbringing, a man and a woman cannot satisfy the obligation to separate, they ‘take on themselves the duty to live in complete continence, that is, by abstinence from the acts proper to married couples.’” See also the Apostolic Letter of Benedict XVI, Sacramentum caritatis, n. 29.

    [4] During the meeting with clergy in the Diocese of Aosta, which took place 25 July 2005, Pope Benedict XVI spoke of this difficult question: “ those who were married in the Church for the sake of tradition but were not truly believers, and who later find themselves in a new and invalid marriage and subsequently convert, discover faith and feel excluded from the Sacrament, are in a particularly painful situation. This really is a cause of great suffering and when I was Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, I invited various Bishops’ Conferences and experts to study this problem: a sacrament celebrated without faith. Whether, in fact, a moment of invalidity could be discovered here because the Sacrament was found to be lacking a fundamental dimension, I do not dare to say. I personally thought so, but from the discussions we had I realized that it is a highly complex problem and ought to be studied further. But given these people's painful plight, it must be studied further.”
     
    Praetorian likes this.
  12. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

    Sometimes I attend Mass in neighbouring parishes or in the city centre. It really doesn't make much difference where I go to Mass and it doesn't make much difference what are the scriptural readings at the Mass. With very rare exceptions, the homily will be about one of two topics: welcome migrants or give to the poor. It's enough to turn anyone against migrants and giving to the poor.

    Today we were reminded that the Holy Family fled to Egypt. The priest omitted the little detail that the Holy Family's stay in Egypt was temporary, that they didn't expect the Egyptians to house them, provide them with free health care, educate Jesus, and give them social welfare benefits while the Egyptians were struggling to house, feed and clothe their own children. Ditto for the hackneyed "Irish people emigrated too".

    As to "giving to the poor", in addition to our taxes and social welfare contributions, we have two collections at Mass for the support of our priests as well as the planned giving (envelope/bank standing order) collections for maintaining the parish buildings. At Christmas there's a giving tree in the church for two charities and a collection box beside the crib for another charity. We also get people collecting for charities at the church gate although this has eased off in recent years. SVP collect inside the church grounds once per month. Imagine trying to support a family and being subjected to a weekly guilt trip about not being charitable enough. Sometimes it feels like Sunday Mass is a weekly NGO event.

    That said, I feel sorry for priests who went through years of formation to end up as glorified social workers and fundraisers. I don't know whether they are following orders from on high, but surely they learned more than that in seminary. If they did, they aren't sharing their knowledge.
     
  13. Fatima

    Fatima Powers

    Same here. Today we got the same homily as every Sunday before Martin Luther King day. It was all about Rosa Parks and how great of a spiritual leader MLK was. Every week is a homily on the poor no matter what the scripture readings are. Last week on the Epiphany of our Lord, we got the same sermon as every year, because supposedly the US bishops made the second Sunday after Christmas "migrant Sunday", so we heard how necessary it is to support illegal immigration.
     
    Last edited: Jan 15, 2018
    Praetorian and HeavenlyHosts like this.
  14. AED

    AED Powers

    I think I am blessed in my parish. The homily was on the gospel straight up. “Come and see” and he went from there. Very nice gentle sermon about taking Jesus up on Hisoffer to “come and see.” Not dramatic but nice.
     
  15. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    http://wdtprs.com/blog/2018/01/vide...-interview-about-amoris-laetitia-controversy/

    VIDEO Bp. Athanasius Schneider interview about “Amoris laetitia” Controversy
    Posted on 14 January 2018 by Fr. John Zuhlsdorf

    His Excellency, Bishop Athanasius Schneider, gave an interview on French TV about Pope Francis and the Amoris laetitia controversy that is tearing apart of the unity of the Church in many spheres. The video is available. There are English subtitles.

    He hits hard those ecclesiastics who want a “Gospel without the sixth commandment”.

    “They use tactics and evil means, such as “ruses, deceptions, masterful rhetoric and dialectics, and even the tactic of intimidation and moral violence in order to attain their goal of admitting so-called “remarried” divorces to Holy Communion” without the latter fulfilling the condition of living in perfect continence…”.

    “It is not only a risk of schism, but a certain kind of schism already exists in the Church. … “We are witnessing today a strange form of schism. Externally, numerous ecclesiastics safeguard formal unity with the pope, at times for the good of their own career or out of a kind of papolatry. And at the same time they have broken their ties with Christ, the Truth, and with Christ, the true head of the Church. On the other hand there are ecclesiastics who are denounced as schismatics despite the fact they live in canonical peace with the pope and remain faithful to Christ, the Truth by assiduously promoting His Gospel of Truth. It is evident that those who are internally the true schismatics, in relation to Christ, make use of calumnies for the sole purpose of silencing the voice of Truth, by absurdly projecting their own state of internal schism on those ecclesiastics who, regardless of praise of rebuke, defend the divine truths. In fact, as Sacred Scripture says, the word of Divine Truth is not bound. Even if a number of high-ranking officials in the Church today temporarily obscure the truth of the doctrine of marriage and its perennial discipline, this doctrine and discipline will always remain unchangeable in the Church because the Church is not a human foundation, but a divine one.”

    He compares the present controversy to the Arian controversy of the 4th c. Church.

    UPDATE:

    I just found another video with Bp. Schneider. He spoke at the “Catholic Identity Conference” last October 2017. Apparently the video was posted only yesterday, 13 Jan 2018. It only has 1530 views as I repost it, so it must be pretty recently added to YouTube. This is the same conference at which Ed Pentin gave his terrific talk. HERE

    His theme: The crisis of faith in the world today.
     
    DivineMercy, Praetorian and Carol55 like this.
  16. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

    It's a real turnoff and the constant preaching to people who are relatively poor about giving to the poor only serves to feed the perception that the Church is all about money.

    And all that talk about poor migrant families is belied by the evidence of the types of new homes being built here. There are lots of apartment blocks which appear more suited to singles or couples than for raising families. They don't look like places conducive to fostering a sense of community. I get the sense that we are being sold a pup with all this talk about poor families needing a safe place to live. We don't know the real reason behind the push for the open borders and citizenship of the world. I suspect that the main beneficiaries will be big corporations.
     
  17. dcana

    dcana Principalities

    Exactly the same for me, and the homily was given by the retired deacon who was in charge of the "Justice and Peace" ministry in the parish, so I was pleasantly surprised.
     
    Praetorian likes this.
  18. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    I only watched the first video so far, but that is pretty damning stuff.
    Though he speaks with a soft voice, his words are anything but.
    The Schismatiques apparently are already afoot, but not from the quarter some would have us believe.
     
    Last edited: Jan 15, 2018
    BrianK and Dolours like this.
  19. dcana

    dcana Principalities

    Wow. Bp. Schneider is a truly courageous man who does not mince words. It is so refreshing to see at least one ecclesiastic courageously sticking his neck out and standing up for the truth, come what may. I hope and pray our next pope will be like him. May God bless and protect this servant of his.
     
  20. Don_D

    Don_D ¡Viva Cristo Rey!

    Yes, us as well. The Homily was a continuation of the one started last week speaking about the younger generations and the great challenges that they and we as parents face together. A great conversation after Mass with our children results from this.

    I am going on a bit of a rant here. The state that I live in is a destination for many illegal immigrants and most of our cities have declared themselves as sanctuary cities. Meaning, the state will take no action against them in any way regarding their citizenship. We have good state provided benefits etc. Even going so far as to not cooperate with Federal officials if they wish to send them back home.
    This has gone on here for so many decades. When I was young, I picked up a summer job sheering and maintaining Christmas trees for the largest tree producer in the state. I was one of two citizens employed on my crew, the rest were Mexican nationals here illegally, spoke no English and were pad locked into the back of a windowless cargo vehicle and taken from job to job like cattle. Not by me, I would have quit. I was angry but also felt very badly for them. They were not paid anything near the regular rate we were and because of this lived together in squalid conditions not easily changed due to their status. I also understood that they were filling the jobs of about 25 Americans and the company I worked for was cheating everyone including the government.
    People love to take the side of the underdog. Myself included. What they don't seem to realize is that by doing this in these situations they are supporting businesses who have no ethics or values when it comes to basic human rights, dignity, and justice. It is purely profit all the time. I know it is not like this in all circumstances but it is this way a very great deal of the time. I also worked for the largest nation wide temp staffing companies and had the Keys to the Kingdom there as their lead database admin and developer.
    We supplied temps to Amazon and other massive corporations like Smithfield packing. The temp workers (Illegals in a great many cases) would rarely be moved to permanent full time status and some were employed only on a daily basis at both employers for over 10 years while I was there. No raises outside the random minimum wage increase, benefits, or guarantee of fair employment practices. Ever. No future. Right where they want them.
    The liberal politicians love this racket, it gives them incentive to secure votes by raises to the minimum wage to a "living wage" which equates to $15.00 per hour in one of the most expensive areas to live in the nation while guaranteeing cheap labor and undercuts labor laws designed to protect the people. Temps can be sent home for any reason and have very little legal protections. Lining the pockets of the rich. Guaranteeing their voter base and further destroying the pillars of a just and equitable society for its citizens as well as the middle class.
    All this in one of the most liberal states in the nation. It made me sick. What is even worse is when you come to the conclusion that party lines make no difference on this issue and that both sides participate in it to the hilt. I am convinced it is one of the biggest reasons why both the GOP and the DNC worked so well together to try to stop Trumps election.
     

Share This Page