The Arroyo interview with Cardinal Muller is excellent and not 'disfigured' (as I see it ) by splitting it into two and adding critical commentary after both parts.
David, You may not like EWTN's interview with Cardinal Kasper but I don't think that the interview was "disfigured". IMHO, some of Stephen Walford's writings appear to be "disfigured". What is "disfigured" about analyzing the comments of a person who agreed to an interview? On the other hand writing articles under the title of theologian when you have no degree in the field and stating untruths about EWTN, does appear to be "disfigured".
Did a quick search on the man's credentials (60 seconds of my life I'll never get back). He wrote two books, is married with five children and plays the piano. Strange that hw was granted a 45-minute private interview with the current pope who apparently is too busy to receive the dubia cardinals. https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/p...ience-to-writer-who-accuses-dubia-cardinals-o
Raymond Arroyo, Father Murray and Robert Royal are all good and loyal Catholics. There is absolutely nothing wrong with them discussing the interview that Mr. Arroyo gave. This is standard practice in news programming and has been for decades. Just because they are Catholic and do not agree with the "innovations" you seem so fond of promoting is no reason to attempt to dismiss them. In addition as far as credentials go, any one of them stacks up far better that Mr. Walford.
I don't mean to be nasty but I find Stephen Walford a real pain. May God forgive me but I do. He was a pain when he was on the forum too. I must pray for him and for myself. Worse the guy is all over the place. There is no escaping him. I must take the dogs for a walk and pray for him. Sigh. He doesn't make it easy.
If the Vatican is relying on Walford as a hitman for AL then they truly are in trouble. With all due respect to Walford he is a light-wight. In over his head.
Mr. Walford is indeed an intelligent man and he does have some knowledge of theology. The trouble is that this is the sort of thing where a little knowledge can be a dangerous thing when you are not adequately trained. I have learned this by being forced to study theology as well as canon law in the past few years as many of us have. There have been many times I have been swayed by cogent sounding arguments only to discover that the writer left out one very important point that makes their argument so much straw. It is a shame that Mr. Walford is using his obvious God-given gifts in this way. Luckily for us he is so long winded and dry most people will lose interest in reading what he has written and turn to more entertaining fare, such as a stereo instruction booklet
Annulments are so easy to get nowadays. Anyone who finds Christian faith and truly loves God and wants reconciliation would go down the annulment path. And if that didn't work they would live as brother and sister proof of their love of God. But now the new novelty (or rather old protestant novelty) is that one's conscience becomes the sole arbiter of what is good or evil. It is possible that the penitent may be convinced in conscience, and with good reasons, of the invalidity of the first marriage even though they cannot offer canonical proof. Go to any prison and most inmates will tell you they are innocent or victims of circumstances. Not guilty. The way of the Christian is mea culpa. My fault, my fault, my grievous fault. For if we truly love Christ we will embrace the cross that He gives and surrender to the Divine Will. And if that means living as brother and sister so be it. God gives the necessary graces (unless of course you believe in the 'new novelty' that the sex instinct is so powerful that the grace of God is incapable of helping the poor sinner overcome his habits). What good is it if a man were to gain another spouse yet forfeit his soul?
Amoris Laeitia is also a unique encyclical obsessed with sex, sexuality and sex education. It must remembered that the tradition of the church has always been to use the phrase conjugal love. The novelty of AL was to use secularized language to describe the marriage act. AL is indeed a 'crude' document and an embarrassing misrepresentation of conjugal love. This divine gift includes sexuality: “Do not refuse one another” (1 Cor 7:5). ‘True love between husband and wife’ (49) involves mutual self-giving, includes and integrates the sexual and affective dimensions, in accordance with God’s plan (cf. 48-49)”. Sexual union, lovingly experienced and sanctified by the sacrament, is in turn a path of growth in the life of grace for the couple. Those words give meaning to the sexual relationship and free it from ambiguity. Marriage is firstly an “intimate partnership of life and love”80 which is a good for the spouses themselves,81 while sexuality is “ordered to the conjugal love of man and woman” Why then should we not pause to speak of feelings and sexuality in marriage? 150. All this brings us to the sexual dimension of marriage. God himself created sexuality, which is a marvellous gift to his creatures. Sexual desire is not something to be looked down upon, and “and there can be no attempt whatsoever to call into question its necessity” Sexuality is not a means of gratification or entertainment; it is an interpersonal language wherein the other is taken seriously, in his or her sacred and inviolable dignity In this context, the erotic appears as a specifically human manifestation of sexuality. A healthy sexual desire, albeit closely joined to a pursuit of pleasure, always involves a sense of wonder, and for that very reason can humanize the impulses. The acts proper to the sexual union of husband and wife correspond to the nature of sexuality as willed by God when they take place in “a manner which is truly human Sexuality is inseparably at the service of this conjugal friendship, for it is meant to aid the fulfilment of the other. All the same, the rejection of distortions of sexuality and eroticism should never lead us to a disparagement or neglect of sexuality and eros in themselves. The procreative meaning of sexuality, the language of the body, and the signs of love shown throughout married life, all become an “uninterrupted continuity of liturgical language” and “conjugal life becomes in a certain sense liturgical” Hence the need for a chapter on --- The need for sex education!! Says it all really!
Amoris Laetitia Church News Featured Maike Hickson January 3, 2018 107 Comments https://onepeterfive.com/cardinal-brandmuller-dubia-answered/ Cardinal Brandmüller on How the Dubia Should be Answered In a new 30 December interview with Armin Schwibach, the Rome Correspondent of the Austrian Catholic website Kath.net, German Cardinal Walter Brandmüller — one of the signatories of the dubia concerning Pope Francis’ document Amoris Laetitia — has again repeated the five questions of the dubia that were submitted to the pope over a year ago and proceeds to explain how, and implicitly why, they must be answered in accordance with the moral teaching of the Catholic Church. The German prelate sums up the five dubia as follows: "1.) Can a person who is bound by an existing sacramental bond and who now lives with a new partner in a marital relationship (AL, no 305; footnote 351) receive, in certain cases, “absolution and Communion”? 2.) Are there absolute moral commandments, respectively, interdicts, which are binding without exception and under all circumstances (such as the killing of an innocent person)? 3.) Is it still true that someone who lives continuously in the state of adultery finds himself, objectively, in the state of grave sin? 4.) Are there situations in life which mitigate the moral responsibility to such an extent that an immoral act (here: adultery) can thereby be morally excused, or even justified? 5.) Can a personal decision of conscience permit exceptions from the absolute interdiction of intrinsically immoral acts? Brandmüller then proceeds to explain how these five questions should be answered in light of the Church’s moral teaching: "As you see, these [five] questions are pertaining to the foundations of the Faith and of the [Church’s] moral teaching. According to those [foundations], the questions 1, 4, and 5 should be clearly answered with “No,” and the questions 2 and 3 with “Yes.” The astute observer might notice that the answers to the summarized dubia proposed by Brandmüller are somewhat different than those commonly circulating in the English-speaking world, which are often phrased as “No, Yes, Yes, Yes, Yes”. This discrepancy, however, is merely a matter of formulation. To avoid confusion, a brief explanation seems appropriate. Whereas, for example, in our own analysis of the five dubia the moral question was phrased such that it had to be answered in the affirmative on points 4 & 5, Brandmüller posits the same basic questions in such a way that they must be answered in the negative; i.e, “5. Does the Church’s teaching that an appeal to conscience cannot overcome absolute moral norms still hold true?” vs. “5. Can a personal decision of conscience permit exceptions from the absolute interdiction of intrinsically immoral acts?” The answer in the first case would be “yes,” the answer in the second would be “no,” but the same moral principle is being stated in both cases. It is not the first time in recent months that Cardinal Brandmüller has spoken out on this issue. In October of 2017, he made strong remarks concerning those who claim that there might be exceptions with regard to adulterers and their possible access to the sacraments: "[H]e who claims that one may enter a new relationship while one’s own lawful wife is still alive is excommunicated because this is an erroneous teaching, a heresy. Whoever does make such a claim [is excommunicated]. […] Thus, if someone thinks he can contradict the defined Dogma of a General Council [e.g., Council of Trent], then that is indeed quite vehement. Exactly that is what one calls heresy – and that means exclusion from the Church – because one has left the common foundation of Faith. [emphasis added] In the new interview, Schwibach also touches upon the matter of the recent praise of Martin Luther as it has been expressed by different prelates in Rome. For Cardinal Brandmüller, Martin Luther — while starting out with some reasonable concerns and criticisms — wound up not wanting to reform the Church, but to change her. However, “the Church of Jesus Christ can and shall always become ‘different’, that is to say, more perfect.” In quoting a Protestant Church historian, Franz Lau, Brandmüller shows that Luther wanted a “radical revolt.” Luther intended specifically – as expressed in his own text addressed “To the Nobility of the German Nation” – to tear down three walls. As the German cardinals explains: "For him [Luther], the first wall was the priesthood based on the holy ordination; the second was the Magisterium of the Church based on the Mission given by Jesus Christ; the third was the existence of the papacy. That these three ‘walls’ have a firm biblical foundation, did not interest the angry Augustinian monk. Now that he has torn down all these three walls, Luther sees that the whole edifice of the papal Church has collapsed. To state that this total destruction is a “work of the Holy Ghost” is a thoroughly bizarre claim which can only be explained with the plain and simple ignorance of historical texts and facts – an ignorance which is more than astonishing for a bishop. [emphasis added] A specific reference is being made here to Bishop Nunzio Galantino who had recently made such an erroneous statement about and praise for Martin Luther in October of 2017. (Galantino has been the Secretary-General of the Italian Bishops’ Conference since December of 2013.) Beside this debate concerning the role of Martin Luther, Cardinal Brandmüller also discusses the current claim that man may chose his sexual orientation and may change it if desired. The prelate calls such an attitude a “nearly perverse revolt against the order of creation, against the nature of man as willed and created by God.” He adds: “To act against it [created nature] means the self-destruction of man. It would be a deceptive downplaying.” Brandmüller continues, saying: "It is indeed highly worrisome that the ideological confusion goes so far that one thinks one can carry subjectivism to extremes. That would then be the “No” to one’s own createdness and to the Creator. Man on the throne of God! A grotesque, absurd, and apocalyptic idea. When discussing the question as to whether the Church should approach with an indulgent attitude those who are at her peripheries, leaving and allowing them to remain in the state they find themselves to be in, Cardinal Brandmüller makes it clear that “Jesus Christ Himself did not preach: ‘stay where you are’; rather, He said: ‘Convert and believe in the Gospels!’” The German cardinal, a Church historian and former President of the Pontifical Committee for Historical Sciences, then criticizes the Church’s current lack of missionary zeal to help these people when he says: "That one exhausts oneself with struggles within the Catholic Church, rather than being concerned about the eternal salvation of the many [outside], shows a shocking lack of spiritual vitality of the Catholics in our days. Leaving the readers with some encouraging words, the cardinal adds: “The Lord was and is still in the boat, even if He seems to be sleeping.”
IMPORTANT: Bishop Athanasius Schneider interview with Rorate Caeli on "Profession of the Immutable Truths", communion for "divorced and remarried" Bishop Athanasius Schneider -- auxiliary of Astana, Kazakhstan, and one of the original three drafters of this week's Profession of the Immutable Truths in response to Amoris Laetitia and Pope Francis' official approval granting Holy Communion to some "divorced and remarried" Catholics -- participated in an interview with Rorate Caeli after the document's release. You can read more on the original document here. We urge all Catholic media and blogs to run this interview in full -- but please reference Rorate Caeli as the source. RORATE CAELI (RC): Your Excellency has personally been out in front in terms of restoration of the traditional liturgy for many years. Now Your Excellency, Archbishop Peta and Archbishop Lenga have come out publicly, and forcibly, in defense of marriage in the aftermath of Amoris Laetitia. Why did the three of you decide now was the time to respond? BISHOP ATHANASIUS SCHNEIDER (BAS): After the publication of Amoris Laetitia, several bishops and Bishops’ Conferences started to issue “pastoral” norms regarding the so-called “divorced and remarried”. One has to say that, for a Catholic, there is no divorce because a valid sacramental bond of a ratified and consumed marriage is absolutely indissoluble and even the bond of a natural marriage is per se indissoluble as well. Furthermore, for a Catholic, there is only one valid marriage being his legitimate spouse still alive. Therefore, one cannot speak of a “re-marriage” in this case. The expression “divorced and remarried” is consequently deceptive and misleading. Since this expression is commonly known, we use it only in quotation marks and with the previous remark “so-called”. The mentioned pastoral norms regarding the so- called “divorced and remarried” -- norms masked with a rhetoric bordering on sophism -- foresee ultimately the admittance of the “divorced and remarried” to Holy Communion without the requirement of the indispensable and Divinely established condition that they may not violate their sacred marriage bond through their habitual sexual relationship with a person who is not their legitimate spouse. A certain peak has reached in this process of implicit recognition of divorce in the life of the Church, when Pope Francis ordered to publish in the Acta Apostolicae Sedis, his letter of approval of similar norms which issued the bishops of the Pastoral Region of Buenos Aires. This act was followed by a declaration that this papal approval would belong to the authentic Magisterium of the Church. In view of such pastoral norms which contradict Divine Revelation with its absolute disapproval of divorce and contradict also the teaching and sacramental practice of the infallible Ordinary and Universal Magisterium of the Church, we were forced by our conscience, as successors of the Apostles, to raise our voice and to reiterate the immutable doctrine and practice of the Church regarding the indissolubility of the sacramental marriage. RC: Has the Kazakh conference officially released an interpretation of Amoris Laetitia? Do they plan to do so, or does this letter mean that the conference believes Amoris Laetitia cannot be understood in an orthodox way or is in any way compatible with the Catechism and with Scripture and Tradition? BAS: The text of the “Profession of truths” is not a document of the Bishop’s Conference of Kazakhstan, but a document only of those bishops who signed it. Our Bishop’s Conference considered it not necessary to issue pastoral norms as an interpretation of AL. Even though in our society the plague of divorce is widespread, a consequence of 70 years of Communist materialism, and we have also in our parishes cases of so-called “divorced and remarried”, yet the same “divorced and remarried” would not dare to ask to be admitted to Holy Communion, since the awareness and conscience of sin is, thanks be to God, very deep routed in the souls, and even in the civil society. In our country people commit sin as elsewhere, but our people still acknowledge that sin is sin, and therefore for such sinners there is hope for conversion and Divine mercy. It would be for our people -- and even for the so-called “divorced and remarried” among them -- a kind of blasphemy to demand access to Holy Communion while continuing to cohabitate with a person who is not their legitimate spouse. Therefore, our Bishops’ Conference did not see the necessity to issue relevant norms. RC: We’ve had the famous dubia sent to the Pope and a filial correction – mostly by laymen – sent as well. Neither have garnered a response. However, many feel Francis has already responded in a sense, when he officially endorsed the Buenos Aires bishops’ apparently heretical instruction to the divorced, remarried and still cohabitating. Should we still expect anything more from Francis on this matter? BAS: The Buenos Aires bishops’ instructions do not express directly a heresy. Yet they allow, in individual cases, “divorced and remarried” people to receive Holy Communion in spite of the fact that they do not want to stop sexual relationships with their non-conjugal partner. In this case the mentioned pastoral instructions deny in practice, and hence indirectly, the Divinely revealed truth of the indissolubility of marriage. The sad circumstance is that the Pope approved such instructions. By this way the Pope gave, in my opinion, directly an answer to the first point and indirectly to the four other points of the dubia. We can only expect through our appeals, prayers and sacrifices, that Pope Francis may answer in a most unequivocal manner to the five points of the dubia according to the relevant teaching of the Ordinary and Universal infallible Magisterium.
continued from above... RC: The threat to the Faithful has been clear, not only since Amoris Laetitia was promulgated, but just from the discussions alone at the synods. The confusion it has all caused cannot be questioned. However, much like the usefulness of Humanae Vitae was lessoned due to how long it took for it to be published, is all this now too late to stop the damage, especially when the Pope has now officially given permission for some divorced and remarried to receive Holy Communion? BAS: We have to bear in mind that the Church is not in our hands, and not even in the hands of the Pope, but in the almighty hands of Christ, and therefore we cannot say that all this is now too late to stop the damage. We can also apply the following affirmation of Saint Paul to our situation inside the Church: “Where sin increased, grace abounded all the more” (Rom. 5:20). God had permitted this current extraordinary doctrinal and moral confusion in the Church for the aim that, after this crisis, the truth will shine brighter and the Church will become spiritually more beautiful, especially in the married couples, in the families and in the popes. RC: We have heard now, for over a year, that a formal correction coming from the cardinals is imminent, yet nothing has happened. What do you believe is the hold up? BAS: In the face of the current temporal and partial eclipse of the function of the Papal Magisterium concerning concretely the defense and practical enforcement of the indissolubility the marriage, the members of the episcopal and of the cardinalitial colleges have to assist the Pope in this Magisterial duty through public professions of the immutable truths which the Ordinary and Universal Magisterium -- that means what all the Popes and the entire episcopate during all times - have taught concerning the doctrine and the sacramental practice of the marriage. RC: If a formal correction is made by a number of cardinals, and Francis continues to officially approve of bishops’ conferences giving Holy Communion to some divorced and remarried, then what? BAS: There exists the following principle of the traditional Catholic doctrine since the first centuries: “Prima sedes a nemine iudicatur”, i.e., the first episcopal chair in the Church (the chair of the Pope) cannot be judged by anybody. When bishops remind the Pope respectfully of the immutable truth and discipline of the church, they don’t judge hereby the first chair of the Church, instead they behave themselves as colleagues and brothers of the Pope. The attitude of the bishops towards the Pope has to be collegial, fraternal, not servile and always supernaturally respectful, as it stressed the Second Vatican Council (especially in the documents Lumen gentium and Christus Dominus). One has to continue to profess the immutable faith and pray still more for the Pope and, then, only God can intervene and He will do this unquestionably. RC: For the typical Catholic, who goes to Mass but maybe doesn’t follow the politics of the Church like Rorate readers do, the casual Catholics whom hear the Supreme Pontiff saying numerous confusing things over the past few years, things that appear contrary (hopefully) to what they’ve been taught their entire lives, what does Your Excellency say to them? And how do serious Catholics push back when, at every turn, they’re asked by modernists if they think they’re “more Catholic than the Pope”? BAS: First, these faithful have to continue to read and study the immutable Catechism, and especially the great doctrinal documents of the Church. Such documents are theme here, e.g., the Decrees of the Councils of Trent about the sacraments; the encyclicals Pascendi from Pius X.; Casti connubii from Pius XI; Humani generis from Pius XII; Humanae vitae from Paul VI; the Credo of the People of God from Paul VI; the encyclical Veritatis splendor from John Paul II; and his Apostolic Exhortation Familiaris consortio. These documents do not reflect a personal and short-lived meaning of a Pope or of a pastoral synod. Instead, these documents reflect and reproduce the infallible Ordinary and Universal Magisterium of the Church. Second, they have to bear in mind that the Pope is not the creator of the truth, of the faith and of the sacramental discipline of the Church. The Pope and the entire Magisterium “is not above the Word of God, but serves it, teaching only what has been handed on” (Second Vatican Council, Dei Verbum, 10). The First Vatican Council taught that the charism of the ministry of the successors of Peter “does not mean that they might make known some new doctrine, but that, by the assistance of the Holy Spirit, they might religiously guard and faithfully expound the revelation or deposit of faith transmitted by the apostles” (Pastor aeternus, chap. 4). Third, the Pope cannot be the focal point of the daily life of the faith of a Catholic faithful. The focal point must instead be Christ. Otherwise, we become victims of an insane pope-centrism or of a kind of popalatry, an attitude which is alien to the tradition of the Apostles, of the Church Fathers and of the greater tradition of the Church. The so called “ultramontanism” of the 19th and 20th centuries reached its peak in our days and created an insane pope-centrism and popolatry. To mention just an example: There had been in Rome in the end of the 19th century a famous Monsignor who led different pilgrim groups to the Papal audiences. Before he let them enter to see and hear the Pope, he said to them: “Listen carefully to the infallible words which will come out of the mouth of the Vicar of Christ”. Surely such an attitude is a pure caricature of the Petrine ministry and contrary to the doctrine of the Church. Nevertheless, even in our days, not so few Catholics, priests and bishops show substantially the same caricatural attitude towards the sacred ministry of the successor of Peter. The true attitude towards the Pope according to the Catholic tradition has to be always with sane moderation, with intelligence, with logic, with common sense, with the spirit of faith and of course, also, with heartfelt devotion. Yet there has to be a balanced synthesis of all these characteristics. We hope that after the current crisis the Church will reach a more balanced and sane attitude towards the person of the Pope and toward his sacred and indispensable ministry in the Church. Amoris Laetitia, Communion for "Remarried" Divorcees, Schneider, The Bergoglio Pontificate By Adfero. at Thursday, January 04, 2018 https://rorate-caeli.blogspot.com/2018/01/important-bishop-athanasius-schneider.html#more
This next "article" is good also IMHO, https://rorate-caeli.blogspot.com/2018/01/for-record-benedict-xvis-letter-to.html#more Happy Belated Birthday Cardinal Müller! For the Record: Full translation of Benedict XVI letter of support to Müller after dismissal by Francis -- plus: Ratzinger explains the liturgical revolution A happy 2018 to all our readers! Full translation below: Your Eminence, dear Confrere Your seventieth birthday is approaching and even if I’m no longer able to write a true scientific contribution to the miscellany that will be dedicated to you on this occasion, I’d like nonetheless to participate with some words of greeting and gratitude. Twenty two years have now gone by since you gave me a copy of your Katholische Dogmatik für Studium und Praxis der Theologie, in March 1995. For me this was an encouraging sign that also in the Post-Council theological generation there were thinkers with the courage to devote themselves ‘to the whole’, in presenting what the faith of the Church is in its unity and completeness. In fact, just as the exploration of detail is important, no less important is that the faith of the Church appear in its internal unity and entirety and that in the end the simplicity of the faith emerges through all the complex theological reflections; since the sensation that the Church is overloaded with a burden of incomprehensible things, which in the end may interest only the specialists, is the main obstacle in saying ‘yes’ to the God Who in Jesus Christ is speaking to us. In my view, one does not become a great theologian by the fact that he is able to tackle minute and difficult details, but by the fact that he is able to present the ultimate unity and simplicity of the faith. Your Dogmatik in one volume however, pertained to me even for an autobiographical reason. Karl Rahner had presented in the first volume of his writings a project for a renewed construction of dogmatics, which he had worked on along with Hans Urs Von Balthasar. This obviously awoke in all of us an incredible thirst to see this schema filled with contents and completed. The desire for a Rahner-Balthasar signed dogmatics, which arose on this occasion, ran into an editorial problem. Erich Wewel had convinced Father Bernard Häring in the 50s to write a manual of moral theology which after its publication became a great success. Then the editor had this idea: that also in dogmatics something similar should be done and that it would perhaps be necessary for such a work to be written in a single volume by one person only. Obviously he turned to Karl Rahaner asking him to write this book. However, Rahner was at that time involved in so many undertakings that he thought he would not be able to correspond to such a grand enterprise. Strangely he advised the editor to ask me, who at that time, at the beginning of my journey, was teaching fundamental dogmatics and theology at Frisinga. Yet even I, despite being at the beginning [of my vocation] was involved in many undertakings and did not feel capable of writing such a daunting work in acceptable time. So I then asked if I could involve a collaborator – my friend, Father Alois Grillmeier. As far as possible I worked on the project and met Father Grillmeier several times for extensive consultations. However, the Second Vatican Council required all my energies, as well as having to think in a new way about all the traditional exposition of the doctrine and faith of the Church. In 1977, when I was named Archbishop of Freising- Munich. it was clear that I could no longer think of such an enterprise. In 1995 when your book reached my hands, I unexpectedly saw that what had previously been desired by my generation but was not possible to carry out, had been achieved by a theologian of the successive generation. Then I got to know you personally, when the German Episcopal Conference proposed you as a member of the International Theological Commission. In this you distinguished yourself above all for your wealth of knowledge and your faithfulness to the faith of the Church which poured forth from you. In 2012, when Cardinal Levada left his office as Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith on grounds of age, you seemed, after some reflection, the most suitable bishop to hold this office. In 1981 when I accepted this office, Archbishop Hamer - the then Secretary for the Doctrine of the Faith - explained to me that the prefect did not necessarily need to be a theologian, but a sage, who in tackling theological questions would not make specific valuations, but would discern what to do for that [particular] time in the Church. The theological competence would rather be found in the secretary who guides the Consulta, that is, the meeting of experts who together give an accurate scientific judgment. Yet in similar way to politics, the theologians don’t make the final decision, but rather the sages, who know the scientific aspects and along with these, are able to envisage the entire life of a grand community. During the years I held office, I sought to live up to this criteria. Whether this was achieved may be judged by others. In the confused times in which we are living, the whole scientific theological competence and wisdom of he who must make the final decisions seem to me of vital importance. For example, I think that things might have gone differently in the Liturgical Reform if the words of the experts had not been the last ones, but if, apart from them, a wisdom capable of recognizing the limits of a “simple” scholar’s approach had passed judgment. [added emphasis] During your Roman years you always undertook to act not only as a scholar, but as a sage, like a father of the Church. You defended the clear traditions of the faith, yet along the lines of Pope Francis, you sought to understand how they can be lived today. Pope Paul VI wanted the great offices of the Curia – that of the Prefect and the Secretary - to be assigned always only for five years, in this way guarding the Pope’s freedom and the flexibility of the work of the Curia. In the meantime, your five-year contract in the Congregation for the Doctrine of the faith has expired. Thus you no longer have a specific charge, yet a priest and above all a bishop and cardinal, never retires. For this reason you can and will be able to serve the faith publically also in the future, starting from the heart of your sacerdotal mission and theological charism. We are all happy that with your great and profound responsibility, in addition to the speaking gifts given to you, you will also be present in the future struggles of our time for the correct understanding of ‘being man and being Christian’ May the Lord sustain you. Finally, I would again like to express a very personal thank-you. As Bishop of Regensburg you founded the Pope Benedict XVI Institute - which guided by one of your pupils – is carrying out truly commendable work in maintaining publically present my theological work in all its scope. May the Lord reward you for your efforts. At the Vatican, in the Monastery Mater Ecclesiae On the Feast of St.Ignatius of Loyola, 2017 Yours, Benedict XVI [Translation: Contibutor Francesca Romana] Benedict Pope Emeritus, Müller By Francesca Romana at Tuesday, January 02, 2018
I love Bishop Schneider - he has a truly Catholic world view and I quote him here: and even the bond of a natural marriage is per se indissoluble as well. Christ then elevated natural marriage to the supernatural level by making it a sacrament of His love.
Thank you so much for posting this. EWTN is a bright light in Dark Times. I look forward to watching this so much.
With all due respect, the issue is not nearly that simple. Is Pope Benedict XVI also in error? This is from a document originally published in 1998, that Pope Benedict XVI rereleased in 2011, during his papacy. (Emphasis mine.) CONGREGATION FOR THE DOCTRINE OF THE FAITH CONCERNING SOME OBJECTIONS TO THE CHURCH'S TEACHING ON THE RECEPTION OF HOLY COMMUNION BY DIVORCED AND REMARRIED MEMBERS OF THE FAITHFUL [1] Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger ... 3. Many propose to allow exceptions to the Church’s norm on the basis of the traditional principles of epikeia and aequitas canonica. Certain marriage cases, it is said, cannot be handled in the external forum. Some claim that the Church should not simply rely on juridical norms, but on the contrary ought to respect and tolerate the conscience of the individual. They say that theological notions of epikeia and aequitas canonica could serve to justify, from moral theology as well as juridically, a decision of conscience at variance from the general norm. Especially regarding the question of receiving the sacraments, they claim that the Church should take some steps forward and not just issue prohibitions to the faithful. The contributions made by Professor Marcuzzi and Professor Rodríguez Luño throw light on this complex problem. To this end, there are three areas of inquiry which clearly need to be distinguished from each other: a. Epikeia and aequitas canonica exist in the sphere of human and purely ecclesiastical norms of great significance, but cannot be applied to those norms over which the Church has no discretionary authority. The indissoluble nature of marriage is one of these norms which goes back to Christ Himself and is thus identified as a norm of divine law. The Church cannot sanction pastoral practices - for example, sacramental pastoral practices - which contradict the clear instruction of the Lord. In other words, if the prior marriage of two divorced and remarried members of the faithful was valid, under no circumstances can their new union be considered lawful and therefore reception of the sacraments is intrinsically impossible. The conscience of the individual is bound to this norm without exception.[2] b. However the Church has the authority to clarify those conditions which must be fulfilled for a marriage to be considered indissoluble according to the sense of Jesus' teaching. In line with the Pauline assertion in 1 Cor. 7, she established that only two baptized Christians can enter into a sacramental marriage. She developed the legal concept of the Pauline privilege and the Petrine privilege. With reference to the porneia clauses in Matthew and in Acts 15:20, the impediments to marriage were established. Furthermore, grounds for the nullity of marriage were identified with ever greater clarity, and the procedural system was developed in greater detail. All of this contributed to delineating and articulating more precisely the concept of the indissolubility of marriage. One can say that, in this way, the Western Church also made allowance for the principle of oikonomia, but without touching the indissolubility of marriage as such. The further juridical development of the 1983 Code of Canon Law was in this same direction, granting probative force to the declarations of the parties. Therefore, according to experts in this area, it seems that cases in which an invalid marriage cannot be shown to be such by the procedural are practically excluded. Since marriage has a fundamental public ecclesial character and the axiom applies that nemo iudex in propria causa (no one is judge in his own case), marital cases must be resolved in the external forum. If divorced and remarried members of the faithful believe that their prior marriage was invalid, they are thereby obligated to appeal to the competent marriage tribunal so that the question will be examined objectively and under all available juridical possibilities. c. Admittedly, it cannot be excluded that mistakes occur in marriage cases. In some parts of the Church, well-functioning marriage tribunals still do not exist. Occasionally, such cases last an excessive amount of time. Once in a while they conclude with questionable decisions. Here it seems that the application of epikeia in the internal forum is not automatically excluded from the outset. This is implied in the 1994 letter of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, in which it was stated that new canonical ways of demonstrating nullity should exclude “as far as possible” every divergence from the truth verifiable in the judicial process (cf. No. 9). Some theologians are of the opinion that the faithful ought to adhere strictly even in the internal forum to juridical decisions which they believe to be false. Others maintain that exceptions are possible here in the internal forum, because the juridical forum does not deal with norms of divine law, but rather with norms of ecclesiastical law. This question, however, demands further study and clarification. Admittedly, the conditions for asserting an exception would need to be clarified very precisely, in order to avoid arbitrariness and to safeguard the public character of marriage, removing it from subjective decisions. http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/c..._doc_19980101_ratzinger-comm-divorced_en.html Term EPIKEIA Definition A liberal interpretation of law in instances not provided by the letter of the law. It presupposes sincerity in wanting to observe the law, and interprets the mind of the lawgiver in supplying his presumed intent to include a situation that is not covered by the law. It favors the liberty of the interpreter without contradicting the express will of the lawgiver. (Etym. Greek epieikes reasonable.) https://www.catholicculture.org/culture/library/dictionary/index.cfm?id=33347
Again, with respect, the issue is not that simple. The document you are quoting to say the case is closed is the exact same document Pope Benedict XVI references when he says, in effect, that the case is still open: c. Admittedly, it cannot be excluded that mistakes occur in marriage cases. In some parts of the Church, well-functioning marriage tribunals still do not exist. Occasionally, such cases last an excessive amount of time. Once in a while they conclude with questionable decisions. Here it seems that the application of epikeia in the internal forum is not automatically excluded from the outset. This is implied in the 1994 letter of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, in which it was stated that new canonical ways of demonstrating nullity should exclude “as far as possible” every divergence from the truth verifiable in the judicial process (cf. No. 9). Some theologians are of the opinion that the faithful ought to adhere strictly even in the internal forum to juridical decisions which they believe to be false. Others maintain that exceptions are possible here in the internal forum, because the juridical forum does not deal with norms of divine law, but rather with norms of ecclesiastical law. This question, however, demands further study and clarification. Admittedly, the conditions for asserting an exception would need to be clarified very precisely, in order to avoid arbitrariness and to safeguard the public character of marriage, removing it from subjective decisions. http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/c..._doc_19980101_ratzinger-comm-divorced_en.html http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/c...oc_14091994_rec-holy-comm-by-divorced_en.html