Thank you for that Praetorian. Well, if one considers what Pope Francis has told us back in 2016, that the large majority of Catholic Sacramental marriages are invalid simply because the couple can not be expected to understand the concept of a life long commitment or the consequence of responsibility or accountability for breaking their vow then maybe this too is interpreted in another way? By this logic, then all one would have to do would be to claim that they had a bad catechism and have no idea that they were entering a lifelong commitment and viola their marriage was never Sacramental right? The fight truly is about marriage and the family on all fronts just as Our Blessed Mother told us. Both within and outside the Church.
Two things that I find extremely reassuring in all of this are that Our Lord told us that the gates of Hell would never prevail against the Church and also that Our Blessed Mother told us exactly what this fight would be over and how it would end. All these things in between must surely be a fire which purifies us and brings us closer to Our Lord.
Yes but one thing I feel in real awe about is the startling confusion and doubt which is pretty well everywhere. High and Low. It is rather like walking across the most beautiful polished wooden floor and suddenly finding it is totally rotten and eaten by termites and that there is a danger of falling on right through it. It has been more than a little shock to the system. I find myself again and again having to go to the Lord in prayer over all this to see where the truth lies. It dodn't used to be like this. If something came from the Vatican I used to just take it for granted it was 100% I never questioned for a moment. Now I test everything.
It is confusing. Having come into the Church during all this has been hard at times precisely because of this. I have had tremendous doubts. It has weighed on my mind and I think it is deliberately to keep people at bay from the Truth. I take such great comfort in the Sacraments and the mysteries of Faith. I wonder how the battle will be won and if we will be here to see it and rejoice. What a great honor that would be if my heart does not give out first.
View attachment 7265 Thank God for Cardinal Burke. It's gotten to a point where, frankly, sometimes I fear for his life. He's now probably the greatest stumbling block to the implementation of the modernist agenda in the Catholic church. https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/cardinal-burke-church-doesnt-need-to-apologize-for-its-teaching Because apparently this is where they want to take her: https://remnantnewspaper.com/web/in...on-vatican-will-greenlight-gay-unions-in-2018
Well , Don, there is no such thing as an accident with God. He knew before the dawn of time that you would be drawn into His Own True Church at this time of a Great Storm. So , since He loves you with an infinite love He intends this for your spiritual welfare. Perhaps He knew if you found your spiritual sea legs in the storm you would grow even deeper in the Faith. But these are very,very difficult times, there is no doubt about it.
I don't believe that they will take us down the track of Homosexual 'weddings'. Not because they are not capable of it but because it would lead to immediate schism removed a lot of their wealth and power and it is not the truth that they love but the money and the power.
I notice Our Lady saying the same thing in apparitions lately, she warns people to convert before it is too late. I used to assume by that that she meant before the fullness of the chastisement falls upon us when they might die. But lately I wonder if she meant that people should convert because a time is fast approaching when conversion to the Church might be very problematic. That they need to find their spiritual sea legs quickly because finding their sea legs in the fullness of the storm might be very problematic. That they might attach themselves to a portion of the ship that will very quickly sink into hell.
Yes, and I can tell you that my conversion was not easy or straight forward and that the first church I attended after 6 months and multiple times contacting them made no effort to contact me except to send me tithing envelopes which they still do to this day. I was not impressed. It is a modernist Church and I thank God for the Church in the town next to us having Faithful Catholics who called me and helped me along the path to entrance to the Church. The last thing on their minds were my tithes. I honestly wondered at one point for quite a time if the Church actually wanted people to join it. Also, God lets our hearts harden to Him and to the Truth as a consequence to our sin. Will there be anyone who will have the Faith to accept the Truth of God and His Church? I think that this is the crux of it. God is always calling people but especially now to His Church. Very few are swimming to the ship and entering it. I feel very fortunate, as stormy as it is to have found refuge in it. I am lashing myself to the bow.
Happy your on God's team and part of this forum, Don. Your insight of someone who previously was on the outside looking in helps give us a different perspective.
Vatican Insider has published another article by Stephen Walford in defence of Pope Francis. Rather than post the whole article (which is inevitably, lengthy), I copy just a few paragraphs that I find hitting the mark as I see things. Anyone familiar with EWTN over the years will know of its faithfulness to the magisterium of the Pope. Mother Angelica its founder was a great servant of the Lord and taught obedience to the Pope as an essential aspect of Catholic life. However anyone who has followed Raymond Arroyo’s “The World Over” in the past several years will by now be all too familiar with its disgraceful attitude toward Pope Francis and the deliberate attempt to frame his papacy as a rupture from the past. Take for instance Fr Gerald Murray, a canon lawyer from the Archdiocese of New York who stated on the 28th September 2017 edition that adultery is always a mortal sin “we cannot go by moral theology which minimises the gravity of that offence.” Fr Murray either doesn’t know what is taught in the Catechism, Veritatis Splendor, and various documents of the CDF [1]or he is choosing to ignore them creating a false magisterium that rejects the authentic magisterium in relation to moral theology, mortal sin and subjective guilt. The question is: if he does know these teachings (it has been pointed out to him), why give the false impression to every soul in these situations that they are definitely in mortal sin? Is that the Christian way of charity and mercy? In that same episode, Dr Joseph Shaw, secretary of the correctio filialis was interviewed. He stated “ultimately what we want is an exercise of the papal magisterium.” Since the revelation in early December that the Buenos Aires guidelines are now fully magisterial, Dr Shaw has moved the goalposts to decide for himself what is and isn’t magisterial; the Oxford University lecturer basing this decision in part on the idea that the “guidelines are not entirely clear.” This reeks of a protestant mentality unfortunately. For EWTN, questions should be asked as to why defenders of Pope Francis and his magisterium are not invited on to explain carefully what Pope Francis has done and why. There is a very real danger that far from feeding Catholics spiritual nourishment, they are potentially creating a new conservative Catholicism that veers towards a schismatic stance through its false and harmful narrative. .................... Loyalty to the Holy Father and obedience to his magisterium has always been central to a spiritual life pleasing to God. To place oneself outside that requirement is not only defying the Successor of St Peter, but God himself. To also claim one need not submit “intellect and will” to this non-infallible teaching because one is still unsure as to what the Pope has taught or changed, is simply an untenable position to hold now. Pope Francis was asked directly in April 2016 the question: has sacramental discipline changed for the divorced and remarried? And his answer was yes. Since then, he has given the Church a document (the Buenos Aries guidelines) which obviously represents for him the way a discernment process should work for those not only who feel their first marriage was invalid but cannot prove it, but also those who for other reasons cannot live as brother and sister but who hope to reach that point through the grace of God, and an application of the law of gradualness. Let us not let Satan tempt us any longer into deciding for ourselves what is authentic Catholic teaching, but let us open our hearts to the truth that Tradition is alive, and with the constant help of the Holy Spirit, the Church can bring forth things both new and old (cf. Matt.13: 52). In this way, souls can be encouraged to draw close to Jesus, and the Lord’s spiritual field hospital can work more effectively. In order for unity to prevail in the Church, the time for false arguments and a manufactured “confusion” must pass; and this can only be achieved by clinging to the barque of Peter. Let us pray earnestly that God instils in our hearts the desire for this grace. http://www.lastampa.it/2018/01/04/v...dissenters-lGWxh795fjt5DHh7Wx74WP/pagina.html
I'm afraid our fear, not disrespect, towards our Pope Francis consists of much more than the topic of divorce. His alliance with leftists in an economic level is disconcerting. His lack of clear stance towards the magisterium on many other issues is another problem that baffles most. Even his points toward immigrants is just plain contradictory.
Euthanasia Emma Bonino and abortion Eating a meal and entertainment in Church And on and on Where is the Holy and the mystical
David, Wow, La Stampa is still calling Stephen Walford a theologian. What are Stephen Walford's credentials again? In addition to interviewing Dr. Robert Shaw about the Filial Correction and Cardinal Burke about the dubia, Raymond Arroyo has interviewed Cardinal Walter Kasper in a 2 part interview about this subject but I guess Mr. Walford missed those episodes. Also, I am certain that Mr. Arroyo would be willing to interview anyone the Vatican would like him to but so far, it appears, the Vatican has wanted to say very little about this since the dubia was made public. IMHO, Mr. Walford is blaming the wrong people for causing confusion and he doesn't see how he himself is adding to the confusion. It's very sad that Mr. Walford is clouding the situation. The crux of the matter is that the Pope has not answered the dubia in over a year and as a result, things have gotten worse for the Church. That's the bottom line.
Stephen is a propagandist, a mud slinger. Mother Angelica would have eaten him for breakfast. I cannot take the man seriously.
It is quite tiresome to hear the same old arguments that have been rebutted time and time again being presented as something new. This article is complete garbage. The whole premise is wrong and is supported by bogus reasoning. EWTN is constant, it is the Vatican that has not remained so. We were blessed by having saint as a pope not 30 years ago, whose CDF chief went on to be the next pope who wrote: https://www.catholicnewsagency.com/...ivorced-and-remarried-members-of-the-faithful "5. The doctrine and discipline of the Church in this matter, are amply presented in the post-conciliar period in the Apostolic Exhortation Familiaris Consortio. The Exhortation, among other things, reminds pastors that out of luve for the truth they are obliged to discern carefully the different situations and exhorts them to encourage the participation of the divorced and remarried in the various events in the life of the Church. At the same time it confirms and indicates the reasons for the constant and universal practice, "founded on Sacred Scripture, of not admitting the divorced and remarried to Holy Communion"(9). The structure of the Exhortation and the tenor of its words give clearly to understand that this practice, which is presented as binding, cannot be modified because of different situations." Case closed. Period. Full stop.
I doubt whether Mr Walford missed the interviews that Arroyo did with Kasper. They were very good interviews because Arroyo (who is clearly critical of the Kasper approach) really challenged the Cardinal in his questions. But both parts of the interview were followed by Mr Arroyo and his little 2 man panel criticizing and undermining virtually everything the Cardinal had said. There was simply no need to do this as Mr Arroyo's questioning of Kasper had been challenging enough. I realize that Pope Francis' critics will have enjoyed the comments by Arroyo's panel more than listening to Kasper himself but the decision to follow the interview with a totally critical discussion of it without anyone there to defend the Cardinal's position is an illustration of Walford's complaint about the current EWTN approach.
David, I don't think that anyone is really enjoying any of this. I find your comments to be a bit disrespectful to men who truly care about the Church. If Stephen Walford is aware about EWTN's interview of Cardinal Kasper on this subject then the following from Mr. Walford is a lie, "For EWTN, questions should be asked as to why defenders of Pope Francis and his magisterium are not invited on to explain carefully what Pope Francis has done and why." I preferred to give Mr. Walford the benefit of the doubt that he was unaware of the 2-part interview or the following more recent interview with Cardinal Muller, In addition, if Raymond Arroyo, Father Murray and Robert Royal agreed with everything every interviewer stated that would be biased. IMHO, EWTN is a fair news program, it has been in the past and it has continued to be, from what I have seen. I also think that Padraig may be correct about Stephen Walford and I think we are best to distance ourselves from him and his opinions.