Hi David, Have you read this book? I am wondering if it would help one to understand this situation better.
No, I haven't read the book. Personally, I don't have any concerns with AL especially after reading and listening to explanations and clarifications on its more controversial aspects.
Yes, I have gathered that you don't in your conversations with others. Even after reading AL however, and then the many opinions on it I do not understand it in the context of it not contradicting the past teachings of the Church and even Christ himself. I have prayed about this as well. Hoping that I might see something or understand something which has been hidden to me. Thanks for posting the article, I will likely pick up this book.
Interestingly enough, I’ve met this author. She’s been to our TLM a number of times. https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/breaking-three-bishops-call-popes-reading-of-amoris-laetitia-alien-to-catho BREAKING: Three Bishops call Pope’s reading of Amoris Laetitia “alien” to Catholic faith Diane Montagna Bishop Athenasius Schneider addressing the 2017 Rome Life Forum Steve Jalsevac/LifeSite ROME, January 2, 2018 (LifeSiteNews) — Three bishops have spoken out against the “current rampant confusion” brought about by Pope Francis’ interpretation of Amoris Laetitia, calling it “alien” to the Catholic faith and “a means of spreading the ‘plague of divorce’” in the Church. Bishop Athanasius Schneider, auxiliary of Astana, Kazakhstan, Archbishop Tomash Peta, Metropolitan of Astana, and Archbishop Jan Pawel Lenga of Karaganda, Kazakhstan issued a Profession of the immutable truths about sacramental marriage on December 31 as a “service of charity in truth” to the Church of today and to the Pope. The bishops took the decision to make a “public and unequivocal profession of the truth” regarding the Church’s teaching on the indissolubility of marriage because they say they “are not allowed to be silent.” As Catholic bishops charged with defending and promoting the Catholic faith and common discipline, they say they have a “grave responsibility” and “duty before the faithful” who expect from them “a public and unequivocal profession of the truth and the immutable discipline of the Church regarding the indissolubility of marriage.” They note that after the publication of Pope Francis’ document on the family, Amoris Laetitia, various bishops and bishops’ conferences have issued norms allowing some civilly remarried divorcees, not living in sexual continence, to receive the sacraments of Penance and Holy Communion. They point out that these various hierarchical authorities (Germany, Malta, and Buenos Aires, although they do not cite them by name), have also received approval “even from the supreme authority of the Church.” Last month Pope Francis decided to formally declare the Buenos Aires bishops’ interpretation of Amoris Laetitia “authentic magisterium.” The spread of these ecclesiastically approved pastoral norms “has caused a considerable and ever increasing confusion among the faithful and the clergy” and are “a means of spreading the ‘plague of divorce’” in the Church, the Kazakhstan bishops write. “Our Lord and Redeemer Jesus Christ solemnly reaffirmed God’s will regarding the absolute prohibition of divorce,” they recall, and the Church has always preserved and faithfully transmitted both in her doctrine and sacramental discipline “the crystalline teaching of Christ” concerning the indissolubility of marriage. “Because of the vital importance that the doctrine and discipline of marriage and the Eucharist constitute, the Church is obliged to speak with the same voice. The pastoral norms regarding the indissolubility of marriage must not, therefore, be contradicted between one diocese and another, between one country and another.” “Since the time of the Apostles,” the bishops explain, “the Church has observed this principle as St. Irenaeus of Lyons testifies”: “The Church, though spread throughout the world to the ends of the earth, having received the faith from the Apostles and their disciples, preserves this preaching and this faith with care and, as if she inhabits a single house, believes in the same identical way, as if she had only one soul and only one heart, and preaches the truth of the faith, teaches it and transmits it in a unanimous voice, as if she had only one mouth” (Adversus haereses, I, 10, 2). They further recall Pope John Paul II’s warning that the confusion sown in the consciences of the faithful by different “opinions and teachings” would diminish the “true sense of sin, almost to the point of eliminating it.” Pope John Paul II erected St. Mary in Astana in 1999 and promoted it to an archdiocese on May 17, 2003, appointing Polish-born Tomash Peta as its archbishop. At the Ordinary Synod on the Family in 2015, Archbishop Peta, who attended as the delegate of Kazakhstan, began his brief intervention with the words Blessed Pope Paul VI pronounced in 1972: “From some crack the smoke of Satan has entered the temple of God.” He then told the Synod Fathers who were assembled: “I am convinced that these were prophetic words of the holy pope, the author of Humanae vitae. During the Synod last year [in 2014], ‘the smoke of Satan’ was trying to enter the aula of Paul VI.” The archbishop added: “Unfortunately, one can still perceive the smell of this ‘infernal smoke’ in some items of the Instrumentum Laboris and also in the interventions of some synod fathers this year.” [Read the intervention here.] In the Profession, (provided in full below) Bishop Athanasius Schneider, along with Archbishops Peta and Lenga, reiterate for the faithful seven immutable truths about the sacrament of marriage, and “in the spirit of St. John the Baptist, of St. John Fisher, of St. Thomas More, of Blessed Laura Vicuña and of numerous known and unknown confessors and martyrs of the indissolubility of marriage” affirm: It is not licit (non licet) to justify, approve, or legitimize either directly or indirectly divorce and a non-conjugal stable sexual relationship through the sacramental discipline of the admission of so-called “divorced and remarried” to Holy Communion, in this case a discipline alien to the entire Tradition of the Catholic and Apostolic faith. Read the full text of the Profession of the immutable truths about sacramental marriage here.
Not a single person mentioned is the Pope or the Cardinals who submitted the dubia. The author of the book has no authority. Cardinal Muller wasn't permitted to answer the dubia when, as Prefect of the CDF, his opinion would have carried more weight than it does now. Every Bishop who has issued guidelines claims the guidelines are in line with what AL intends to teach yet the guidelines vary from diocese to diocese. Only the Pope can answer the dubia and only the Cardinals who raised them can say that they have been answered and the doubts dispelled.
Maybe you forgot to add that this is just your opinion, Dolours? Cardinal Muller clearly disagrees with you - "I am convinced that he has dispelled the doubts of the cardinals and many Catholics who feared that in "Amoris Laetitia" a substantial alteration of the doctrine of faith had taken place both on the valid and fruitful way of receiving Holy Communion as well as on the indissolubility of a marriage validly contracted between baptized. "
Poor Cardinal Mulller. He is a a very good man I belief and very learned, but also very, very innocent. Not an altogether uncommon combination.
What Dolours said is logical, clearly deductible from the facts. Nobody but Pope Francis, the official author of AL, can answer the questions put to him alone about it and nobody but those who have posed the questions can claim satisfaction with the (so far non-existent) answers. That is more than mere opinion-there is no other construct one can put on the situation. What Cardinal Muller says is clear opinion, as demonstrated by the use of the expression "I am convinced...".
Cardinal Muller: "...the confessor should not disturb the conscience of the penitent in good faith before they have grown in faith and in the knowledge of Christian doctrine to the point of being able to recognize their sin and formulate the intention of no longer committing it." This is crucial. I was worried and distracted (not a novelty) about this interview by the Cardinal during my prayers last night and it came to me that ignorance does exclude one from sin, but once the veil of ignorance is lifted, one has no further excuse. I think this is what the Cardinal is saying in the sentence above, although in a technical sense intended for trained confessors. I, a mere ignorant layman, interpret the first half of the sentence as a caution to confessors to not 'jump the gun' and frighten off the (objective) adulterer, a prospective convert or revert, before he or she has come to understand their situation. Others here may be more able to tease out the details.
Is this really the case re. the confessional that the priest has to pussy foot around sin? How often Padre Pio disturbed consciences!! When consciences are disturbed this can lead to repentance which leads to salvation. Seems to me the truth is the truth at all times! One leads the penitent to the truth as Jesus did with compassion. Anyone else uneasy about the cardinal's statement? I stand open to correction as I am a mere lay person but I don't believe Padre Pio would agree with the good Cardinal either. But then again Padre Pio was unique.
Let's take an example. A person in the confessional admits to using contraception. They do not believe that it is a particularly grave sin since in sinful secular society it is common place and promoted as a right. The priest illicits from the penitent that the form of contraception is the oral contraceptive pill. The priest enlightens the penitent that such contraceptives are abortifacient. Now having an informed conscience the penitent can repent of the sin of using abortifacient contracception and make reparation. Hopefully the priest shakes the conscience of the penitent in this case by teaching the truth in charity. The priest has a duty to inform and teach in such cases despite the fact that the truth might upset the penitent.
Padre Pio is the perfect exemplar. A very great saint. Someone once asked him if he was not afraid of frightening people off? To which he replied, 'The good ones always come back'.
In Padre Pio's time, people were far better cathechised, to say the least. A good formation was the common thing, rather than the rare exception. Many nowadays are absolutely clueless about even the most basic aspects of religion. If a priest is too blunt and the prospective penitent never comes back, what has been achieved? I understand your reservations and share them to some extent, but if priests are to be fishers of men, it may be they need to be easy on the line at first bite, rather than tugging too vigorously lest the prey escape, in order to successfully and finally lure in the catch. It's like evangelising pagans, now. Would the great missionaries have converted so many millions if they had jumped in gung-ho over the centuries? The modern pagans may need some of this patience, also. Remember, if an adulterer goes to confession, they are already making a big step in the right direction. It would be tragic to frighten them off at this point by prematurely using concepts they have absolutely no proper understanding of, whatsoever. A Hell-fire statement at the start might drag some over the line, but what of those who aren't quite ready and are discouraged, maybe to the point of despair? Don't forget, many have been brainwashed with notions of universal salvation from all types of sources. It may not be possible to correct such malformations in a short timespan. I do stress my word above, 'prematurely', because it is absolutely imperative that the penitent be directed to Truth as quickly as they are able to comprehend. Really, we need the opinion of an experienced, orthodox confessor, but I'm not going to shoot down Cardinal Muller just yet.
I 100% agree. As I went down through the last several posts I was going to write something similar until I came across your post. Padre Pio lived in a different time than we do. He was most likely hearing confessions from faithful Catholics who grew up catechized and understood the faith. Today we live in a post-Christian era, though it is sad to say. Many may not even know what constitutes a mortal or venial sin. In fact they may not even know those terms! Imagine that? A Catholic who doesn't know those terms? What a sad state the Church is in. I would also think Padre Pio was not always yelling at penitents. These stories we hear make good stories, but it doesn't mean they are the "norm" for his confessions. It is also possible he had the Grace to read souls and so may very well have known the inner intent of the people in the confessional. Remember many of us here may come across as "fire and brimstone", but I am sure most of us would be gentle to a soul attempting to return to the faith no matter if they were and adulterer, thief, or whatever. Hopefully we would give them firm, but gentle counsel.
I'd be willing to wager that most of those penitents that Padre Pio shouted at were very regular attendants at confession and maybe knew the law all too well, enough to twist it too far in their own favour. I can imagine him losing patience with someone trying to deceive him and deceiving themselves in the process. I do wish to make clear, if it isn't already, that one of the points of my comment about Cardinal Muller is that I consider that he is subtly implying, that despite all the patience a priest might deploy to a penitent, it would never be permissible for a priest to consent to the penitent taking the Eucharist while in a state of active adultery. I believe he means that the priest would endeavour to gently dissuade the penitent from this until things were 'sorted out'.
It's sounding more and more like no one individual wants the "split" to be placed on his shoulders while they are going through a kind of agony of trying to keep all those plates spinning on a growing number of sticks by themselves alone!
One author's take: John Zmirak: Pope Francis Talks Like ‘Angry’ ‘South American Politician’ Pushing ‘Anti-American Worldview’ with ‘Hysterical Leftist Agitprop’ ..... Describing the pope as “angry” and “not exceptionally bright,” Zmirak cast the pope’s politics as supportive of furthering global convergence of governance: [Pope Francis] talks a good game about humility in discourse and openness, but that’s a bit like when Venezuela speaks about people’s democracy. It seems to be an empty slogan for a very angry, not exceptionally bright or subtle South American politician who happens to have found himself in a position with a huge bully pulpit which allows him to express an anti-American, anti-free market, really anti-Western worldview that seems to make a fetish out of poverty and loves the idea of global government overruling the wishes of voters. Pope Francis’ “open borders” advocacy for the admission of economic migrants and ostensible refugees, said Zmirak, is solely targeted at America and Europe. The pope’s use of biblical anecdotes towards this end, he added, amounts to the use of “hysterical leftist agitprop”: .....He seems to want open borders for Western countries. He never talks about Mexico needing to let in everybody for El Salvador. No, it’s the United States that doesn’t have a right to have borders. Europe doesn’t have a right to have borders. The most shocking thing, back in 2013, he went to the city of Lampedusa in Sicily, a little town, a little place, it is so overwhelmed with economic migrants from North Africa that the migrants now outnumber the residents of the city. He gave a talk in 2013 where he compared Europeans who didn’t want to accept Muslim migrants, he compared them to Cain who killed his brother in the Garden of Eden and Herod who slaughtered the children of Bethlehem. This is not rational discourse. This is not theology. This is hysterical leftist agitprop of the kind that you read in Venezuelan government newspapers. ..... “It’s not his Church, it’s Jesus Christ’s Church,” said Zmirak of the pope’s use of the papacy. “The Church doesn’t exist as a service agency to the papacy; it’s the other way around.” Zmirak is the author of the new Politically Incorrect Guide to Catholicism. http://www.breitbart.com/radio/2018...n-worldview-with-hysterical-leftist-agitprop/
Good reflection. I think a good priest can discern the sincerity and knowledge level of the penitent. The new young priests I have met are very orthodox but very sensitive to how they present it. A good thing I think with so many “pagan” Catholics.