I hope it will not appear I am bringing in a slightly discordant note, but Benedict did not really say what you have written here, Mario. Benedict did not refer to the Holy Spirit. To rephrase slightly Benedict's quote, the Pope Emeritus said - the Cardinal had defended the clear traditions of the faith and had tried to understand how they can be lived today as in the spirit of Pope Francis. We all need to look to the Holy Spirit to guide us to the truth and both Benedict and Francis follow that guidance of the Holy Spirit.
You don't know that. The Holy Spirit guides. Free will determines who follows the guidance and who doesn't.
And the "spirit of truth" cannot change, "I am the same yesterday, today and always". We know then that such things as adultery, co-habitation, contraception, sodomy etc... are all intrinsically contrary to the Divine Law and Divine Will. We also know then that Holy Communion cannot be given to any of these groups who are living in these grave sins. If Pope Francis could establish as much with all his various writings and talks, we would know this 'spirit of truth' working through him. Those in 'spirit of truth' clearly teach this truth, which does not confuse. For my part, I will continue to pray for him that he will humble himself and reiterate the unchanging spirit of truth to all God's flock and not give cause to confusion.
yes indeed, Dolours! But I hope I am allowed to post an opinion occasionally? I think you are familiar with the process of posting opinions.
Where has this phrase 'spirit of truth' come from, Fatima, that you discuss here? Benedict was speaking of 'the spirit of Pope Francis'.
Are you saying that the spirit of Pope Francis is not in the spirit of truth? Should they not be one and the same, especially when he speaks as the vicar of Christ? Even when he does not speak officially, his words spoken should always reflect the spirit of truth, right?
If Pope Francis in in his official writings does not clearly teach what has been handed on then he clearly is not speaking in the spirit of truth. He either needs to clarify that what he is saying is his personal opinion or whether it is within the spirit of truth that does not and cannot change. And, when he speaks in language in an official document that is outside the boundaries of what has been taught from Christ through his Church, then he is obliged in the spirit of truth to clarify, which he has refused to do when asked in good faith to do so by his fellow Cardinals. What is he afraid of? This is the spirit of Pope Francis that we know today.
I must have missed the part where you qualified your remark with "in my opinion", "I think", "I believe", "it appears to me" or even "clearly" which would indicate that you had arrived at a conclusion based on evidence you found convincing. Hope you are having a blessed Christmas season, David, and that God will bestow abundant graces on you and yours in 2018.
David, You are correct in that the Holy Spirit was not specifically referenced by Benedict. But then, your concluding sentence does infer that the spirit of Francis is guided by the Holy Spirit. In reference to the Holy Father, he has added magisterial weight to his approval of the Argentina bishops' interpretation of Amoris Letitia by publishing it in the Acta Apostolicae Sedis. And yet, the Pope has not weighed in on the interpretation of AL by the Maltese bishops which went even further by elevating private conscience above an informed conscience in determining access of the divorced and remarried to Holy Communion. To let this variation in orthopraxis to stand means that the disagreement over AL has not been definitively addressed. I believe orthodoxy and orthopraxis should be in harmony, so I still prayerfully ask the Holy Spirit to inspire Pope Francis to reestablish such a harmony which existed prior to AL and its aftermath. This is one area in which I believe the spirit of Pope Francis falls short. Perhaps you know when the introduction by Benedict was actually composed. That would prove beneficial to me. Safe in the Barque of Peter.
You have such a kind, gentle and completely irrefutable way of putting the facts. May I be so ever be so correct. So charitable. But the same time we are being sold a Bill of Goods. Make no mistake about it. A BILL OF GOODS a misrepresented, fraudulent, or defective article. Idioms. 3. sell someone a bill of goods, to defraud or deceive someone: He sold me a bill of goods about that used car.
Despite radical stylistic variation, you are both saying the same thing! Snakes come into all this somewhere, that's for certain. These kind of snakes are known to be spirits, too. Lord, "...lead us not into temptation, but deliver us from evil".
The book of essays honouring Cardinal Muller was published earlier this month. The introduction to the book written by Benedict was certainly written after the removal of Muller as head of the CDF so that means the Pope Emeritus wrote his introduction no earlier than July this year. It will more likely have been written not long before the publishing of the book. I will copy again here the quote I was highlighting from the Pope Emeritus because I believe it to be very significant in giving us a 'window' on Benedict's current view of Pope Francis. Benedict concluded his introduction by telling Müller, “You have defended the clear traditions of the faith, but in the spirit of Pope Francis you have tried to understand how they can be lived today.” https://cruxnow.com/vatican/2017/12...etired-pope-says-bishops-never-really-retire/
I would interpret the passage above in italics as a very diplomatic and veiled criticism of the present pope. It is imperative upon Joseph Ratzinger that he not be seen to blatantly attack Francis. The key word is 'clear', one that obviously cannot be applied to the policy of Pope Francis. The key clause is 'the clear traditions of the faith', that which Joseph Ratzinger is implying it is the clear duty of all to defend and for which he so praises Cardinal Muller. It is implicit in this statement that the status quo must remain essentially unaltered regardless of how one understands that these issues be lived currently. I, personally, am very grateful that Joseph Ratzinger has clarified this issue so well. I now await Pope Francis to do the same.
I agree this sentence is interesting. I would generally be inclined to be more in line with DeGaulle's interpretation. The Vatican is laden with politics and Pope Emeritus Benedict is diplomatic in the extreme. It is interesting that the quote in question has a big "but" in the middle of it, seemingly juxtaposing Pope Francis' position with the position of "defending the clear traditions of the faith". The sentence in question again: “You have defended the clear traditions of the faith, but in the spirit of Pope Francis you have tried to understand how they can be lived today.” Why is an "and" not used? Read again with an "and" inserted it seems much more harmonious: You have defended the clear traditions of the faith and in the spirit of Pope Francis you have tried to understand how they can be lived today. I would think Pope Benedict chooses his words carefully. One word makes all the difference. If anything I would see the sentence as written as somewhat troublesome if trying to make the case that Pope Emeritus Benedict somehow is supportive of what is going on. A "but" draws a distinction between the two halves of the sentence whereas and "and" would have brought them together. In the end though we can be guilty of over-analyzing anything.
I will attempt to answer Praetorian's question which is a good one. In a way, the quote from Benedict highlights the difficulty in keeping the traditions of the faith while, at the same time, applying them to modern day situations. And that is the reason Benedict uses the word 'but' instead of 'and'. The two things for which, in his quote, Benedict praises the Cardinal can seem to be in conflict. It is this apparent conflict which lies behind much of the antagonism between traditionalist and non traditionalist Catholics. But for anyone thinking that Benedict was, somehow, criticizing (however indirectly) Pope Francis, they need to also accept that he would have been criticizing the Cardinal at the same time. To illustrate this, let me copy the quote again but, this time, adding the word it is being suggested is really there in Benedict's mind: “You have defended the clear traditions of the faith, but in the (mistaken) spirit of Pope Francis you have tried to understand how they can be lived today.” If I were Cardinal Muller reading that sentence with that meaning I would feel rather aggrieved!
DeGaulle and Praetorian, both good and concise points on this sentence. I agree with Praetorian that Pope Emaritus Benedict always chooses his words carefully. I believe the "but" versus "and" inserted into the sentence was a clear choice of words. But I also believe that over analyzing the intent of Pope Emaritus Benedict could cause irreparable damage to our union with the Holy Catholic Church, so as DeGaulle states I too will wait for Pope Francis response. Prayers for all here, may we stand firm until our Lady gives the orders to advance forward.
I think this may be precisely what Pope Emeritus Benenedict may be implying but I may be wrong V but [bət] yet · nevertheless · nonetheless · even so · however · still · [more] used to indicate the impossibility of anything other than what is being stated: "one cannot but sympathize" · [more] used to introduce a response expressing a feeling such as surprise or anger: "but that's an incredible saving!" · [more] used after an expression of apology for what one is about to say: "I'm sorry, but I can't pay you"
I have not read any hierarchy, yet alone a pope, who has written more on relativism than Pope Benedict, prior to and after becoming pope. Why> I think he is wise beyond all telling. He knew the church and clergy were snuggling up to relativism decades ago. He warned it was the most harmful of all heresies and he foreseen it had already begun to infiltrate the hierarchy many years ago. He had clearly hit the nail on the head and we are seeing the ramifications of this with our current pope and those he is putting into high positions within the Vatican. No more old school absolutes with this papacy. Grey is their color along with the rainbow colors so it seems. Only God can turn the church around now. Pope's John Paul and Benedict tried hard through their writings and teachings, but it was to late and Benedict seen this and retired. Prophecy must now be fulfilled that both popes spoke of candidly.
Pope Benedict is in a very,very difficult position indeed. One mispoke word and he could well cause a schism at the moment. Poor man he must be in agony. But you may be sure if we know something is very wrong, he knows something is very wrong. He is after all arguably the greatest theologian of the last century.