The Vatican Has Fallen

Discussion in 'Church Critique' started by padraig, Dec 31, 2016.

  1. garabandal

    garabandal Powers

    Pope Francis is only one Pope. The papacy is more than one Pope.

    Like all the rest he will die and a new Pope will be elected.

    The confusion generated in his pontificate may have to be addressed by his successor, perhaps we are even heading for a new council that
    will finally confront the errors caused by the misapplication of much of the Vatican II teachings by progressive elements.

    God has allowed the confusion for a reason - we need to fix our eyes on heaven above and not get mired in the mud down here.

    We are called to be saints down here so that we will get to heaven above. That is our calling. The call to sanctity.
     
    Byron, AED, sterph and 7 others like this.
  2. DeGaulle

    DeGaulle Powers

    Great post. We are really sunk if we start dismissing people like Cardinal Muller and Mark Mallett, who have questioned no dogma or doctrine. It is counterproductive to go to war over differences in tactics. I admire both Cardinals Burke and Muller-they are both good Catholics, doing their best via different methods. In the long run, we don't know for certain which tactics will prove more successful. There is no point blaming this papacy for all the ills of the Church. Those ills were already there, but maybe it is for the best that Pope Francis is giving the heretics within the confidence to come out into the open. It is always better to know your enemy.
     
    Light, Sam, AED and 5 others like this.
  3. sunburst

    sunburst Powers

     
    SgCatholic, AED and Praetorian like this.
  4. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    I think that right now God is using a lot of different people in a lot of different ways. I really don't doubt that as things progress Mark will come to face the awful truth of the situation. My guess is that God is using Mark to speak more to faithful "centrist" Catholics. People who may not be at the place that many of us are.

    I remember once Fr. Malachi Martin was asked why he didn't just come out in his books and say everything that was explicitly wrong with the Church. His answer was interesting. He said something to the effect that it was it was for the care of souls. He said sometimes if you come right out and explain the state of the Church to the average person on the street, you could crush their faith. In other words, people sometimes need to be led along slowly to the truth for their own good. Jumping in all at once can have the opposite effect to what is intended. It can be too shocking to some. His advice was point them in the right direction and they will find the truth if they care to look for it.
     
    sterph, AED, DeGaulle and 3 others like this.
  5. Carol55

    Carol55 Ave Maria

    Praetorian, I think that this is very true and through the process of finding the truth we learn how to deal with the falsehoods the way that we should, so "we don't throw the baby out with the bathwater". I never used that expression before but I believe that it applies here.
     
    sterph, AED and Praetorian like this.
  6. Carol55

    Carol55 Ave Maria

    Aviso and Brian,

    I happened to be reading a current post on Deacon John's blog today and I came across a post of his in which he mentions Father Bebie and then I recalled your discussion here. I found a link to the book if you are interested, Warning Booklet The Warning by Father Philip Bebie, C.P. (52 page booklet), Link to pdf version .

    http://www.godswarning.com/
    http://whatisgarabandal.blogspot.com/2017/

    Deacon John's latest post includes a review of Edward Kelly's new book about Garabandal which sounds very good, imho, "A Walk to Garabandal: A Journey of Happiness and Hope" - https://www.amazon.com/Walk-Garabandal-Journey-Happiness-Hope/dp/154428165X .

    Aviso, I would love to hear your opinion of Father Bebie's booklet if you have time, I think others here would be interested also. Thank you.
    Brian, Thank you for raising my attention to this.
     
    sunburst likes this.
  7. Don_D

    Don_D ¡Viva Cristo Rey!

    Yes, also when we think that we discover truth (outside being told it) we are much more apt to take it fully to heart and our faith is strengthened. As well as our curiosity peaked leading to more study and introspection.
     
    sunburst, AED and Praetorian like this.
  8. Dean

    Dean Archangels

    Thank you Dolours!!! I couldn't agree more. I love reading his writing, he writes well. But he could 100% make the point in 1/3 of the words he does, and I for one would read it a lot more frequently!




    you
     
    Dolours and Malachi like this.
  9. AED

    AED Powers

    So right! Good reminder.
     
  10. AED

    AED Powers

    This is so true. In my early years as a revert I was way too blunt. God set me straight.
     
  11. SgCatholic

    SgCatholic Guest

    I think this is true with my family members. They are shocked that I say such 'bad' things about the state of our Church, the pope and some of the (wayward) hierarchy. They are simply not ready and do not want to hear it. :(
     
    AED likes this.
  12. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    Yes, we have to remember that most people have no idea what is going on. I went to Thanksgiving dinner at my brother's house and the subject of what was going on in the Church came up. He said something to the effect of "Well he's the Pope and we have to do whatever he says". Sadly most Catholics think this is true. My brother is actually smart and fairly well versed compared to the average person in the pew. He is a lector and so attends classes and other similar functions. I set him straight, but most people have no clue.
     
    HeavenlyHosts, AED, DeGaulle and 2 others like this.
  13. Don_D

    Don_D ¡Viva Cristo Rey!

    https://www.thenewamerican.com/usne...obe-soros-obama-clinton-conspiracy-at-vatican

    Catholics Ask Trump to Probe Soros-Obama-Clinton Conspiracy at Vatican

    Did billionaire speculator George Soros, President Barack Obama, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, Vice President Joe Biden, and Obama/Clinton adviser John Podesta conspire to overthrow the conservative Pope Benedict XVI and replace him with a radical, Pope Francis? Did they use America’s intelligence agencies, and our nation’s diplomatic machinery, political muscle, and financial power to coerce and blackmail “regime change” in the Roman Catholic Church?

    Far from being some wild conspiracy theory, there is sound prima facie evidence to indicate that this is a serious effort to expose a political scandal of the highest order, involving flagrant, criminal abuse of power at the top levels of the U.S. government. A group of respected Catholic lay leaders have sent a letter to President Donald Trump urging him to launch an official investigation into the activities of the above mentioned individuals (and others) who appear to have been involved in this alleged Vatican coup. They cite eight specific questions they seek to have answered concerning suspect events that led to the resignation of Pope Benedict, the first such papal abdication in 700 years.
     
    SgCatholic likes this.
  14. Don_D

    Don_D ¡Viva Cristo Rey!

    “Specifically, we have reason to believe that a Vatican ‘regime change’ was engineered by the Obama administration,” say the petitioners, in their January 20 letter to President Trump. The five signatories to the letter, first published in the Catholic newspaper/weblog, The Remnant, are: Lieutenant Colonel David L. Sonnier, US Army (Retired); Michael J. Matt, editor of The Remnant: Christopher A. Ferrara, author, attorney, and president of the American Catholic Lawyers Association, Inc.; Chris Jackson, Catholics4Trump.com; and, Elizabeth Yore, Esq., Founder of YoreChildren.


    “We were alarmed to discover,” their letter notes, “that, during the third year of the first term of the Obama administration your previous opponent, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, and other government officials with whom she associated proposed a Catholic ‘revolution’ in which the final demise of what was left of the Catholic Church in America would be realized.” The letter includes footnote links that take the reader to documents and news stories underscoring their charges and pointed questions. It first directs attention to the Soros-Clinton-Podesta e-mails disclosed last year by WikiLeaks, in which Podesta and other “progressives” discussed ending the “middle ages dictatorship” in the Catholic Church. Regarding the e-mails in question, The New American reported last October:

    Podesta, a longtime Clinton adviser/confidante and hand-picked top activist for left-wing funder George Soros, revealed in a 2011 e-mail that he and other activists were working to effect a “Catholic Spring” revolution within the Catholic Church, an obvious reference to the disastrous “Arab Spring” coups organized that same year by the Obama-Clinton-Soros team that destabilized the Middle East and brought radical Islamist regimes and terrorist groups to power in the region. The Podesta e-mail is a response to another Soros-funded radical — Sandy Newman, founder of the “progressive” Voices for Progress. Newman had written to Podesta seeking advice on the best way to “plant the seeds of the revolution” in the Catholic Church, which he described as a “middle ages [sic] dictatorship.” The issue that appeared to be the cause of Newman’s e-mail was opposition by U.S. Catholic Bishops to the federally mandated contraceptive coverage in ObamaCare.

    In their letter to President Trump, the concerned Catholics write: “Approximately a year after this e-mail discussion, which was never intended to be made public, we find that Pope Benedict XVI abdicated under highly unusual circumstances and was replaced by a pope whose apparent mission is to provide a spiritual component to the radical ideological agenda of the international left. The Pontificate of Pope Francis has subsequently called into question its own legitimacy on a multitude of occasions.”

    “We remain puzzled by the behavior of this ideologically charged Pope, whose mission seems to be one of advancing secular agendas of the left rather than guiding the Catholic Church in Her sacred mission,” they say, expressing the thoughts, undoubtedly, of innumerable Catholics worldwide. “It is simply not the proper role of a Pope to be involved in politics to the point that he is considered to be the leader of the international left.”
     
    SgCatholic likes this.
  15. Don_D

    Don_D ¡Viva Cristo Rey!

    The Catholic quintet began their missive to President Trump with the famous quote attributed to French historian Alexis de Tocqueville: “America is great because she is good. If America ceases to be good, America will cease to be great.”

    “While we share your stated goal for America,” they write, “we believe that the path to ‘greatness’ is for America to be ‘good’ again, to paraphrase de Tocqueville. We understand that good character cannot be forced on people, but the opportunity to live our lives as good Catholics has been made increasingly difficult by what appears to be a collusion between a hostile United States government and a pope who seems to hold as much ill will towards followers of perennial Catholic teachings as he seems to hold toward yourself.”

    They continue:

    With all of this in mind, and wishing the best for our country as well as for Catholics worldwide, we believe it to be the responsibility of loyal and informed United States Catholics to petition you to authorize an investigation into the following questions:

    - To what end was the National Security Agency monitoring the conclave that elected Pope Francis?

    - What other covert operations were carried out by US government operatives concerning the resignation of Pope Benedict or the conclave that elected Pope Francis?

    - Did US government operatives have contact with the “Cardinal Danneels Mafia”?

    - International monetary transactions with the Vatican were suspended during the last few days prior to the resignation of Pope Benedict. Were any U.S. Government agencies involved in this?

    - Why were international monetary transactions resumed on February 12, 2013, the day after Benedict XVI announced his resignation? Was this pure coincidence?

    - What actions, if any, were actually taken by John Podesta, Hillary Clinton, and others tied to the Obama administration who were involved in the discussion proposing the fomenting of a “Catholic Spring”?

    - What was the purpose and nature of the secret meeting between Vice President Joseph Biden and Pope Benedict XVI at the Vatican on or about June 3, 2011?

    - What roles were played by George Soros and other international financiers who may be currently residing in United States territory?

    It is likely that very few Americans, including American Catholics, are aware of these matters, in the slightest degree. Although the WikiLeaks, DCLeaks, and Snowden revelations have made most of this planet’s inhabitants aware that the NSA routinely (and illegally) has scooped up billions of phone calls, e-mails, and text messages, very little media coverage has focused on the revelations concerning the NSA spying on Pope Benedict and the cardinals of the conclave that elected Pope Francis in 2013 (see here and here).

    Architects of Subversion

    What about the secret “Cardinal Danneels Mafia” referred to above? According to the Catholic blogspot Rorate Caeli, “The election of Jorge Bergoglio was the fruit of secret meetings that cardinals and bishops, organized by Carlo Maria Martini, held for years at St. Gall in Switzerland." That is the claim of Jürgen Mettepenningen and Karim Schelkens, the authors of a recently published authorized biography of the Belgian Cardinal Godfried Danneels, who refer to the group of cardinals and bishops as the "Mafia-club."

    Cardinal Danneels himself, in a video recorded for the book, admits to taking part in the secret club of cardinals that were in opposition to Joseph Ratzinger (Pope Benedict). He refers to it as “a Mafia club whose name was St. Gall.” In addition to Danneels, this “Mafia club” reportedly included Cardinal Carlo Maria Martini, Dutch bishop Adriaan Van Luyn, German cardinals Walter Kasper and Karl Lehman, the Italian cardinal Achille Silvestrini, Britain’s Cardinal Basil Hume, and other liberal-left churchmen. Cardinal Danneels, a Belgian, has long been viewed as a key subversive in the Church prelature for undermining traditional Catholic teaching against abortion, homosexuality, and “gay marriage,” as well as for his efforts to protect pedophiles in the clergy.
     
  16. Don_D

    Don_D ¡Viva Cristo Rey!

    One name not mentioned in the recent letter of concerned Catholics to President Trump, but certain to surface as a key culprit in any substantive investigation, is former chairman of Goldman Sachs International Peter Sutherland. Mr. Sutherland, an Insider’s Insider among the globalist banking establishment, was brought in to help “reform” the Vatican Bank, which was akin to putting Dracula in charge of the blood bank.

    Like Joseph Biden, Jerry Brown, and Nancy Pelosi, Sutherland is a prominent political figure who is regularly described in media accounts as a “practicing Catholic,” which means he wears his religion when it is expedient to do so. As attorney general of Ireland, Sutherland helped to scuttle that Catholic country’s legal restrictions on abortion and favored the “LGBT rights” movement. He has served as a commissioner of the European Union and headed the Global Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) and the World Trade Organization (WTO).

    Here are some of his other globalist credentials, as previously in The New American:

    • He is a regular attendee and former Steering Committee member of the ultra-secretive, ultra-elite Bilderberg Group;

    • he was European chairman of the Trilateral Commission;

    • he is past chairman of British Petroleum (BP);

    • he is honorary president of the Transatlantic Policy Network (TPN), one of the principal corporatist insider organizations promoting EU-U.S. merger through the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP);

    • as a top Eurocrat, he played a lead role in destroying national sovereignty by replacing national currencies (and national monetary control) with the euro, as well as engineering the “borderless Europe,” which the current migrant crisis is now proving to have been so destructive.

    For the past decade, as the United Nations special representative for International Migration, Sutherland has been a key architect, along with George Soros, Barack Obama, Hillary Clinton, and other globalists of the global scheme that has flooded Europe with the disastrous tsunami of Muslim migrants. (Their plans, which called for a similar migration deluge for the United States, got started under President Obama, but have been scuttled by the election of President Trump.)

    The investigation that the concerned Catholics are requesting of President Trump should be of interest to more than just Catholics. Peter Sutherland, George Soros, and the world government movement they represent will, if successful, wreak unimaginable havoc and devastation upon the entire planet. The investigation — and prosecutions — cannot begin too soon.
     
  17. SgCatholic

    SgCatholic Guest

    I thought this has been posted before but I can't seem to find the thread.
     
    Carol55 likes this.
  18. Don_D

    Don_D ¡Viva Cristo Rey!

    Im sure it was, I just thought it was an interesting read after the year has passed and we have seen more come to fruition both inside and outside the Church.
     
    SgCatholic and Carol55 like this.
  19. SgCatholic

    SgCatholic Guest

    Sorry Don, I should have myself more clear. My intention in searching for that earlier post was to find out whether any further developments on the matter had been revealed and discussed on that thread. I can't rely on my now poor memory. :unsure:
    I didn't mean to insinuate that you should not be posting it again.

    So, do you know if the Trump administration has done anything about it?
     
  20. Jarg

    Jarg Archangels

    Here is the link to part 3 of Michale O’Brien ongoing essay - you can also access part two and one from the link. It is worth a read so far, deeply related to many discussions in the forum and the shape the reality within and without the Church is taking.

    https://www.lifesitenews.com/opinio...-is-preparing-the-way-for-antichrist-to-arise

    Editor’s Note: The following is the third part of an in-depth essay by author and painter Michael D. O’Brien on the coming Great Apostasy. We are publishing it over five days, and then will provide a link to the full text. The first part is here, and the second part here.

    November 29, 2017 (LifeSiteNews) – The Catechism of the Catholic Church defines heresy as an “obstinate post-baptismal denial of some truth which must be believed with divine and Catholic faith, or it is likewise an obstinate doubt concerning the same; apostasy is the total repudiation of the Christian faith.”1

    Let there be no mistake about it: The spreading apostasy in our times has been caused only in part by the unprecedented power of secular forces brought against us. Its root cause is to be found in the heresies that have spread among us, a new kind of Phariseeism that would empty the Faith of its power and meaning, creating a psychological/spiritual milieu in which the spirit of anti-Christ is able to increasingly control men’s perceptions, thoughts, and emotional lives. It is this that makes it now possible for the actual “Man of Sin,” the Antichrist himself, to arise.

    The overwhelmingly dominant problem within the Church of the West at this time of history is a Phariseeism that is connected to corrupt moral theology and disordered ecclesiology, whereby false teachers make people believe that they are the righteous, even if sinning in terms of sexual morality, or by teaching that such sin is not grave sin and is no impediment to reception of the sacraments. They feel self-justified by their belief in a new Gospel of social justice—and a very selective social justice it is—reducing the fullness of the Gospels to a false either/or choice: you are either a liberal dissident (“loving, compassionate”) or you are a Pharisee (a “dour legalist"). They make their peace with personal sin because they believe they are fulfilling the Gospel imperatives by helping the poor. And whenever their own hypocrisies and compromises with personal sin and error are questioned, they simply shoot the messenger, pointing the finger at anyone who stands in opposition to their agendas, demonizing the voice of truth by superficial comparisons to the legalistic Pharisees of the Gospels. The fact is, the new Pharisee not only neglects the “weightier matters,” he so often actively undermines them, and in the worst cases contributes to the death of the innocent. He does it, O most grievous of ironies, by appealing to mercy.

    Thus, in the growing confusion in which we are all immersed, there is need for sober reflection on what, precisely, Jesus was rebuking in his interactions with the Pharisees of his times. The pertinent passages are to be found in Matthew 23: 1-39; Mark 7: 1-13; Mark 12: 35-40; Luke 11: 37-54; Luke 20: 45-47 (see also John 9: 1-41).

    In each of these, Christ is, above all, confronting the Pharisees’ hypocrisy—their outward appearance of virtue, their inner corruption, greed and evil thoughts. (Matt 23: 27-28; Luke 12:1). They lay heavy burdens on man while neglecting the weightier matters of total fidelity to God. These hard sayings of Jesus can be properly understood only in their fullest context:

    ‘And one of the scribes came up and heard them disputing with one another, and seeing that he answered them well, asked him, “Which commandment is the first of all?” Jesus answered, “The first is, ‘Hear, O Israel: the Lord our God, the Lord is one; and you shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your mind, and with all your strength.’ The second is this, ‘You shall love your neighbor as yourself.’ There is no other commandment greater than these.” (Mark 12: 28-31).

    Jesus is clearly teaching that truly loving one’s neighbor is founded on total fidelity to the divine commandments. Without that context, the supposed righteousness of the old Pharisee degenerates into legalism without love. Equally, without that context, the supposed compassion of the new Pharisee tends to degenerate into superficial sentiment, self-indulgence and presumption. If love is not founded on total fidelity to God’s commandments, it is soon truncated and fosters short-range kindnesses that breed long-range cruelties. In Mark 7: 1-13, Jesus chastises the Pharisees for their disregard for God’s commandments, while they quibble over man-made fine points of their laws; for example, their allowing a person to neglect the basic needs of his aged parents because he has made a donation to the Temple treasury. In Matthew 23: 15, Jesus says that they make their converts twice as fit for hell as they are. In Luke 17: 3-4, he says, “If your brother sins, rebuke him; and if he repents, forgive him. And if he sins against you seven times in one day and returns to you seven times saying, ‘I repent,’ you must forgive him.” In John 8: 2-11, where Jesus meets the woman caught in adultery, the Pharisees would have condemned her and stoned her to death. After Jesus has shamed their consciences and blocked their evil intent, he says to the woman, “Neither do I condemn you. Go and do not sin again.”

    In these and numerous other examples in the New Testament, building upon the Old Testament, Jesus does not shy away from rebuking sinners, again and again calling them to repentance, for he knew that repentance is the precondition for receiving mercy, liberating us from slavery to sin. It is the truth that will set us free, says the Lord.

    The old Pharisees were very much preoccupied with the minutiae of the Law and its observance. They were quick to judge the weak and to condemn all those who fell short of their exacting standards. They were generally heartless, lacking in mercy. Moreover, they themselves were “whited sepulchers,” teaching the Mosaic Law and its elaborate derivatives but inwardly corrupt. And the end-fruit of their blindness was made manifest when they engineered the torture and execution of the Author of Life.

    In our own times, it is undeniable that vestiges of the old Phariseeism remain among believers. Leaping instantly to mind are stereotypical images, which is the result of two, perhaps three, generations of an unceasing refrain in the liberalized churches of the Western world. It proclaims that the only truly grave sin is “intolerance,” by which is meant making people feel uncomfortable about themselves. Hand in hand with this is the endless vilification of those who are doctrinally and liturgically correct, but supposedly inwardly lifeless.

    It goes without saying that pastors and laypeople who are doctrinally and liturgically correct but who lack charity and authentic missionary zeal are at risk of the “yeast of the Pharisees.” Yet any sincere Christian is vigilant about the potential for Phariseeism within himself, just as he is on guard against his temptations to sin. He knows that without the grace of Jesus he would be both the elder brother in the parable of the Prodigal Son, and the younger brother.

    Does the Lord not say to us all, if we would hear: “Beware, my children, of the danger faced by the ‘elder son’ in the parable of the Prodigal Son, for you run the risk of sliding into Phariseeism.”?

    And at the same time does he not cry out to each and every soul, “Repent of your sins! Come to me and live!” (Isaiah 55: 3-5; Ezekiel 33: 11; John 14: 6)?

    To be continued…
     
    Dolours, Mario, sunburst and 3 others like this.

Share This Page