The Vatican Has Fallen

Discussion in 'Church Critique' started by padraig, Dec 31, 2016.

  1. Fatima

    Fatima Powers

    Once again, we have the liberal version of what 'love' is. Yet, it has nothing to do with obedience to the commandments as Jesus taught. Only in social justice. "If you love me, keep my commandments."[John 14:15], "If you keep my commandments, you shall abide in my love; as I also have kept my Father's commandments, and do abide in his love." [John 15:10], "Jesus answered, and said to him: If any one love me, he will keep my word, and my Father will love him, and we will come to him, and will make our abode with him.", "And by this we know that we have known him, if we keep his commandments." [1 John 2:3], "In this we know that we love the children of God: when we love God, and keep his commandments." [1 John 5:2],

    You get the idea. We cannot love our neighbor or God without keeping his commandments. The needs to be brought home to the progressive liberals who want a God without laws. A feel good theology. I have watched this progressive theology for 3 decades in my parish and they truly believe salvation is won through social justice only. Liberal love the 'either/or' thinking. It is either faith or morals, social justice or commandments, corporal works of mercy or spiritual works of mercy etc...... Hard to find a liberal who will embrace them all with the same level of conviction.

    Pope Francis \ Activities
    Pope at Angelus: We will be judged on love

    [​IMG]


    The Apostolic Palace, where Pope Francis addresses the crowds each week ahead of prayer of the Angelus. On Sunday, Pope Francis spoke about the last judgment, the subject of the day's Gosepl.

    26/11/2017 12:17
    SHARE:


    (Vatican Radio) In his Angelus address on Sunday, Pope Francis reflected on the last judgement, the subject of the day’s Gospel reading.

    He noted that this is the last Sunday of the liturgical year, the day on which the Church celebrates the Solemnity of Christ the King of the Universe. Christ’s kingship, he said, is one “of guidance and service, but it is also a kingship that at the end of time will be asserted in judgement.” The vision of the second coming of Christ, presented in the Gospel, introduces the final judgment, when all of humanity will appear before Him, and Jesus, exercising His authority, will separate one from another, “as the shepherd separates the sheep from the goats.”

    Pope Francis recalled the criteria that Jesus says will be the foundation of His judgment: “What you did for the least of my brothers, that you did on to me.” This sentence, the Pope said, “never fails to strike us, because it reveals to us” the end to which God is willing to go on account of His love for us. God goes so far as to identify Himself with us, not when we are “happy and healthy, but when we are in need.” Thus, the Pope said, “Jesus reveals the decisive criteria of His judgment, that is, the concrete love for our neighbour in difficulty.”

    Likewise, those who cursed, in the Gospel account, are judged for failing to aid their brothers and sisters in their need. Pope Francis repeated, “At the end of our life we will be judged on love, that is, on our concrete commitment to love and to serve Jesus in our smallest and most needy brothers.”

    The Holy Father reminds us that Jesus will come at the end of time to judge all nations; but He also “comes to us every day, in so many ways, and asks us to welcome Him.” The Pope concluded his reflection with the prayer that “the Virgin Mary might help us to encounter Him and to receive Him in His Word and in the Eucharist, and at the same time in our brothers and in our sisters who suffer hunger, illness, oppression, injustice. May our hearts be able to welcome Him in the ‘today’ of our life, so that we might be welcomed by Him into the eternity of His Kingdom of light and of peace.”
     
    Last edited: Nov 27, 2017
  2. Fatima

    Fatima Powers

    The Pope’s Fixation On Climate Change Endangers His Authority And Entrenches Poverty

    November 28, 2017

    At a time of feckless world leadership, this powerful religious leader chooses to push politically loaded climate orthodoxy instead of addressing legitimate problems. By Julie Kelly

    In a letter to world leaders gathered at a United Nations conference earlier this month in Germany, Pope Francis applauded their efforts to “counteract one of the most worrying phenomena our humanity is experiencing.” He warned the prestigious group against “falling into the trap of these four perverse attitudes: denial, indifference, resignation and trust in inadequate solutions.”

    So, what threats and perversions in this broken world was the pope referring to? The sickening, random attacks by murderous Islamic terrorists? Madmen acquiring destructive nuclear weapons? The living hell endured by millions of young girls around the world from prostitution, child marriage, weaponized gang rape, and female genital mutilation? Tyranny in North Korea, famine in the Sudan, oppression in Venezuela?

    No, the leader of the world’s Catholic flock was referring to climate change. His message was aimed at the 20,000 delegates attending the United Nations’ 23rd annual climate change conference in Bonn: “I would like to reaffirm my urgent call to renew dialogue on how we are building the future of the planet. We need an exchange that unites us all, because the environmental challenge we are experiencing, and its human roots, affects us all.” His holiness also cheered the 2015 Paris climate accord, which the Trump administration ditched last summer, and urged the group to move forward to achieve the pact’s goals.

    At a time of weak, feckless world leadership, it is sad, if not irresponsible, to have this powerful religious leader choose to push politically motivated climate orthodoxy rather than address legitimate problems in an unsafe world. Historically, the papacy has inspired non-Catholics and even non-Christians during perilous times. I cannot help but think of John O’Sullivan’s brilliant and moving book, “The President, the Pope, and the Prime Minister,” which touted the success of Pope John Paul II, Ronald Reagan, and Margaret Thatcher in vanquishing the Soviet Union. The contrast makes Pope Francis’s focus on human-caused climate change even more galling.

    Climate Change Is a Mask for Economic Control
    This week, Francis is in Myanmar and Bangladesh, two destitute nations reeling from a refugee crisis due to the religious persecution of minority Muslims, and where serious threats against the countries’ small Catholic population are increasing. Despite the myriad woes afflicting his poor flock, the pope will still waste time talking about global warming: “This visit is for spiritual causes, for highlighting peace and harmony,” the archbishop of Dhaka told the Washington Post. “But the Holy Father will also touch upon other very important issues that concern Bangladesh. The Rohingya crisis and climate change will come up prominently.” Holy moly.

    But it makes sense for a man who laments the evils of capitalism to advance the climate change agenda, which is rooted in Francis’s preferred collectivist-based economic system. Francis blames terrorism on “a world economy has at its center the god of money and not the person.” He rejects meritocracy and claims “the new capitalism gives a moral cloak to inequality.”

    In his view, the business man is evil, and the terrorist is a victim. That’s why climate change is the ideal cause for Francis: climate policies punish private industry, redistribute wealth globally, enact punitive taxes and harsh regulations, and minimize the role of technology. It is not about the environment or science; it is the late-twentieth-century model of how to impose socialism while looking like you really care about polar bears and sea levels.

    This Is an Unholy Obsession for Pope Francis
    Over his nearly five-year reign, Pope Francis has devoted an extraordinary amount of time and focus on manmade climate change. In 2015, a few months before Paris climate conference, the Vatican published “Laudato Si,” his encyclical about “care for our common home.” The paper is a lengthy rant against greed, industry, technology, and consumption, declaring that “never have we so hurt and mistreated our common home as we have in the last two hundred years.”

    Naomi Oreskes, a well-known environmental activist, wrote the report’s introduction and the pope was subsequently criticized for aligning with other leftists who support abortion, population control, and contraception, policies inimical to Catholic tenets.

    “Laudato Si” dismisses the reality that wealthy people in developed nations are typically far better stewards of nature than poor people in developing countries are: “A sober look at our world shows that the degree of human intervention, often in the service of business interests and consumerism, is actually making our earth less rich and beautiful.”

    The paper cautions against adopting beneficial technologies like genetically engineered crops and nuclear energy because it gives “those with the knowledge…an impressive dominance over the whole of humanity and the entire world.” During their meeting at the Vatican last May, Francis gave President Trump a signed copy of his encyclical. A few weeks later, Trump announced the United States would withdraw from the Paris climate agreement.

    So Is Inspecting Science a Moral, or Venial, Sin?
    In a world full of villains, Francis saves some of his harshest invective for climate “deniers.” Speaking to reporters last September from the papal plane—yes, an evil, fossil-fueled jumbo jet built and sold by greedy industrialists—Francis said climate deniers reminded him “of a phrase from the Old Testament, from the Psalm, ‘Man is stupid.’ When you don’t want to see, you don’t see.” He claimed, “history would judge” anyone who denies climate change is happening.

    Fossil fuel corporations are also on the pope’s naughty list. Citing “Laudato Si,” 40 Catholic institutions announced last month they would divest from fossil fuel interests, and other groups are expected to follow. In July 2016, the same month Islamic terrorists killed 86 people in Nice, 29 people in a Bangladeshi bakery, and 323 people in Baghdad shopping district, the pope called for a World Day of Prayer…for the planet.

    Most alarming about Francis’s climate advocacy is how it harms the same vulnerable people he wants to protect. In his letter to the Bonn delegates, Francis condemns the “strong links between combating climate change and poverty,” and cites that myth to promote a “low or zero-carbon model of economic development.” But that approach is precisely why hundreds of millions of poor people continue to live in poverty.

    It is not climate change that causes global poverty, but the absence of a reliable, affordable energy grid does. Bangladesh is one of the most energy-poor countries in the world; only 60 percent of Bangladeshis are connected to an electricity grid. Instead, Bangladeshis rely on “biofuels, such as wood, cow dung and agricultural residues [that] are collected mainly from the local environment and have become a traded commodity as cooking fuel as access to local biomass becomes ever more difficult. Inefficient, kerosene lamps are the most common sources of light.”

    Insisting that developing nations shun their troves of coal and natural gas resources to scale up wind, solar, and geothermal energy to avoid emitting carbon dioxide is literally keeping large swaths of the global South in the dark. People without electricity can’t work, grow food, access clean water, go to school, or get basic health care efficiently. Many more women die in childbirth, and mothers watch their children suffer from hunger and disease.

    The Vatican’s unholy alliance with climate activists, many of whom hold views hostile to Catholic doctrine, is extending that misery. That, not climate denial or indifference, is a real perversion the pope should worry about.

    Julie Kelly is a National Review Online contributor and food policy writer from Orland Park, Illinois. She's also been published in the Wall Street Journal, Chicago Tribune, Forbes, and The Hill.
     
    Pray4peace, SgCatholic and AED like this.
  3. DeGaulle

    DeGaulle Powers

    History can judge away. There's only one Judge that matters.
     
  4. Fatima

    Fatima Powers

    Cardinal Müller: They want me to head a group against the Pope, but I’m staying with the Pope. However, those who are complaining should be heard

    Excerpts from an interview conducted by Massimo Franco of Corriere della Sera:
    Chiesa e Post Concilio
    November 25, 2017
    [​IMG]



    “There is a front of traditionalist groups, just as there is with the progressivists, that would like to see me as head of a movement against the Pope. But I will never do this. I have served the Church with love for 40 years as a priest, 16 years as a university professor of dogmatic theology and 10 years as a diocesan bishop. I believe in the unity of the Church and I will not allow anyone to exploit my negative experiences of recent months. Church authorities, on the other hand, need to listen to those who have serious questions or justified complaints; not ignoring them, or worse, humiliating them. Otherwise, unwittingly, the risk of a slow separation that might lead to a schism may increase, from a disorientated and disillusioned part of the Catholic world. The history of Martin Luther’s Protestant Schism of 500 years ago, should teach us, above all, what errors to avoid.”

    “The Pope confided to me: ‘Some have told me anonymously that you are my enemy’ without explaining in what way” he recounts unhappily. “After 40 years at the service of the Church, I had to hear this: an absurdity set up by prattlers who instead of instilling worry in the Pope they would do better visiting a 'shrink'. A Catholic bishop and cardinal of the Holy Roman Church is by nature with the Holy Father. But, I believe, as Melchoir Cano, the 16th century theologian said, that the true friends are not those who flatter the Pope, but those who help him with the truth and theological, human competence.” In all the organizations of the world, delatores of this type serve only themselves.”
    “The tensions in the Church arise from the contrast between an extremist traditionalist front on some websites, and an equally exaggerated progressive front which today seeks to credit themselves as super-papists”
     
    Mary's child and DeGaulle like this.
  5. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

    Boy, does Mark Mallet go on and on and on and on.........

    I got half way through that before giving up. That he would expect anyone to swallow that Pope Paul Vl meant a small sedevacantist sect when talking about the Church being attacked by sin from within is simply ludicrous. The sin within the Church was priests not keeping their vows of celibacy and the child abuse which got so bad that the rug wasn't big enough to cover it. That plus the Jesuits who openly opposed Humane Vitae were far, far more damaging to the Church than a few dissenters from Vatican 11. I don't know whether Mark is being deliberately disingenuous or whether he is afraid that getting off the fence will result in a fall in readers of his blog, but he must be living on a different planet if he can't see that the smoke of Satan is choking the Vatican, our seminaries and our religious orders.

    I stopped reading at the part where he says that Pope Francis was both canonically and validly elected because no Bishop has said otherwise. Actually one retired Bishop has said that his election needs a second look. Certainly, no serving Bishop has questioned the validity of his election but then nobody who values his position would dare do so for fear of exile to outer Mongolia and at this stage at least one third of Bishops are Francis appointees. While we must accept that Francis is the valid Pope because there has been no investigation of the events leading up to the Conclave and the vast majority of Bishops accept that he is the valid Pope, there is no guarantee that his election won't be declared un-canonical or whatever is the correct term some time in the future should a proper investigation ever be conducted.
     
    Totus tuus, Don_D, Pray4peace and 5 others like this.
  6. picadillo

    picadillo Guest

    No one can accuse him of being a gatekeeper.
     
    Dolours likes this.
  7. AED

    AED Powers

    I used to read him quite regularly but right now not so much. He is sincere and faithful snd has sacrificed much to keep on with his mission but he doesn’t speak to me anymore. I just can’t get through the posts any more. I wish him well but if he is interpreting g the “smoke of Satan” in that way he is mistaken.
     
    picadillo, Dolours and Pray4peace like this.
  8. Fatima

    Fatima Powers

    Point is, all faithful who are not in schism must accept Pope Francis as our valid pope. Cardinal Muller said as much in a recent article. Mark has chosen to be faithful to our pope, as am I, and that means praying and sacrificing for him to the end. I would do no less for a child that has gone array and I do. One cannot live in a bubble, as if our salvation remains within a bubble. If we have a bad pope then our faith must pray and sacrifice for him, lest we loose our own soul for hardening of the heart. IMHO, Mark is that disciple we would all want on our team when the chips are down on anyone. He doesn't give up when the water is rocking and entering the boat. His faith is strong enough to remain with the lost and not despair. God bless Mark for his enduring faithfulness for lost souls. His faithfulness will save countless souls for eternity.
     
    AED, Sam, DeGaulle and 1 other person like this.
  9. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    I read the above article by Mark Mallett. I have always thought him a good Catholic and what seems to be a very fervent and dedicated person. I have to admit my experience with him is that his articles are often chocked full of excellent quotes and interesting information, but he always seems to be "off" a bit somehow. This latest article seems to be basically walking alongside Cardinal Muller in what he had to say in his latest interview.

    I thought the advice the clergyman gave Mark at the beginning of the article was very interesting, but reading the rest of the article I think the advice Mark was given is beyond him. At least at this point. He seems to have blinders on to what is happening. Like Cardinal Muller, it seems what is happening is outside of his worldview or comfort zone and so he does not accept the reality.

    Honestly I do not know why he chose to start off with the words from the clergyman at all, because he promptly turns his back on them and goes off on his own tangents.

    As I said he often seems to come close to the mark, but it is as if he is purposely aiming at something else. One example of this is his quoting the prophecy attributed to St. Francis. Though there are some questions as to it's authenticity, he seemingly accepts it as a true prophecy, but misses the whole point. A Pope could not deceive the Church if the faithful knew he was not canonically elected. It would seem obvious that the Pope who the prophecy speaks about is not generally known to be not canonically elected. Or that this is at least a strong possibility. He just bypasses that without a thought because it seems that it is beyond what his mind can accept.

    Note: I am not stating that Pope Francis is not canonically elected. That is not for me or any lay person to decide as I have stated many times. I am not even sure of the validity of the prophecy attributed to St. Francis.

    I am also not bashing Mark in any way. As I said I think he is a gifted man of great faith, but I think his articles are often lacking some insight.

    I think the article did raise a lot of good points.
    -One can break from the Church from the right or the left.
    -We do need to accept Pope Francis as Pope and pray for him.
    -Stay away from sedevacantism.
    Among other things.

    Perhaps I am wring in my critique here. I will say for some reason I have trouble making my way through his articles. They often seem unnecessarily tangential and unfocused to me. He is a good man though and I got some good tidbits from this article.
     
    Last edited: Nov 29, 2017
    AED and sunburst like this.
  10. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

    He was adopting the "I'm safe in the middle while those to the right and left of me are the problem" approach. He does bemoan the effect of modernism on the Church but in seeking people to blame on the other side, here's what he wrote (he was quoting Pope Benedict and not Pope Paul as I said in my earlier post):

    Years ago, I stumbled upon the writings of two “sedevacanists” (people who believe the seat of Peter is vacant). They generally see Pope St. Pius X as the last valid pontiff, and point to “heresies” and “errors”, especially from the Second Vatican Council, that they claim validate their arguments. I was horrified by what I read. The subtle twist of words; the tainted reasoning; the pulling of phrases out of context. Like the Pharisees of old, they justified their schism with the “letter of the law” and, worse, have drawn countless souls away from the Roman Catholic Church. In them, the words of Pope Benedict particularly ring true:

    …today we see it in truly terrifying form: the greatest persecution of the Church does not come from external enemies, but is born of sin within the Church. —POPE BENEDICT XVI, interview on flight to Lisbon, Portugal; LifeSiteNews, May 12th, 2010

    I point this out because the spirit, if not the arguments of these schismatics, are beginning to gain traction among some “conservative” Catholics who are increasingly disgruntled with the current papacy.
    ​

    He also uses the old excuse of the Pope being quoted out of context.

    Any of those sedevacantists could merit a Vatican postage stamp and a celebration of their rebellion some time in the future now that the precedent has been set.
     
    AED and Mac like this.
  11. SgCatholic

    SgCatholic Guest

    In response to that article. Mark's words in blue. My responses in black.

    He (the clergyman) looked at me intensely and said, “Mark, you have a lot of readers. If Pope Francis teaches error, you must break away and lead your flock in truth.”

    I am really happy to know that a clergyman told Mark this; that Mark must speak the truth because he has a large readership.

    The division within the Church that we are now seeing is not only being fuelled by “progressives” but also “traditionalists” who are becoming increasingly vocal against Pope Francis.

    The "traditionalists" are trying to save the laity from the heresies of Pope Francis' and his minions.

    (Mark quotes) Cardinal Mueller "Church authorities, on the other hand, need to listen to those who have serious questions or justified complaints; not ignoring them, or worse, humiliating them."
    Exactly why, when Pope Francis pointedly and stubbornly ignores the dubia and all other letters or appeals for dialogue, and insults the people who have serious questions about the way PF is leading the Church into apostasy, there needs to be more done than just saying we have to be faithful to Peter.

    Years ago, I stumbled upon the writings of two “sedevacanists” (people who believe the seat of Peter is vacant). They generally see Pope St. Pius X as the last valid pontiff, and point to “heresies” and “errors”, especially from the Second Vatican Council, that they claim validate their arguments. I was horrified by what I read. The subtle twist of words; the tainted reasoning; the pulling of phrases out of context. Like the Pharisees of old, they justified their schism with the “letter of the law” and, worse, have drawn countless souls away from the Roman Catholic Church. In them, the words of Pope Benedict particularly ring true:

    …today we see it in truly terrifying form: the greatest persecution of the Church does not come from external enemies, but is born of sin within the Church. —POPE BENEDICT XVI, interview on flight to Lisbon, Portugal; LifeSiteNews, May 12th, 2010

    I point this out because the spirit, if not the arguments of these schismatics, are beginning to gain traction among some “conservative” Catholics who are increasingly disgruntled with the current papacy.


    Who can deny the obvious rotten fruits of Vatican II?
    I am not a sedevacantist, but I don't have rose tinted glasses on. The truth is that the Church has been on an extremely steep decline in terms of its faith, most obvious since Vatican II and all its resultant modernist changes.
    Also I agree with Dolours here:
    There is no question that the pontificate of Francis is fraught with seeming contradictions and ambiguities. A great many of these, however, are clearly the result of the pontiff being taken out of context, misquoted, or interpreted through a “hermeneutic of suspicion” that automatically twists the meaning of his words.
    I am appalled that Mark is still using this indefensible argument of 'misquotes and misinterpretations' for the terrible words of Pope Francis.

    However, what cannot be denied is the present misappropriation of this Pope’s teaching in a pastoral context, as has happened with some bishop’s conferences.
    Misappropriation?
    How can Mark still believe that? As we all know, Pope Francis has affirmed that "there is no other interpretation" except what those bishops conferences concluded. Neither has Pope Francis admonished those who go ahead with those so-called 'misappropriations'. However, PF was so quick to publicly rebuke Cardinal Robert Sarah when he called for ad orientem worship last year and more recently when he said that all liturgy translations still have to be approved by his Congregation of Divine Worship.

    (cont'd below)
     
    Mac and sunburst like this.
  12. SgCatholic

    SgCatholic Guest

    What one of the more prominent Cardinals has stated emphatically, however, is that the dubia are not a pretext for schism.
    .........
    But part of a dialogue? We must, especially when truth is at stake.


    How does Mark propose that the dialogue happen, when PF has repeatedly refused to meet with the dubia cardinals?
    We all know that this is so hypocritical of PF because he has publicly said :
    "If there is one word that we should never tire of repeating, it is this: dialogue. We are called to promote a culture of dialogue by every possible means and thus to rebuild the fabric of society."


    A call for clarity and unity, however, has not put an end to various theories which contend that the papacy of Francis is invalid. Many concerned Catholics are grasping for answers as to why Pope Francis has appointed progressives, left the dubia unanswered, and “allowed” other oddities to emerge from the Vatican like support for “global warming” or a stamp to commemorate the Reformation. “This what Freemasons do,” a few have said, referring to the double-speak of that secret society that has been condemned by more than one pope. But unsubstantiated accusations like these are extremely dangerous because, suddenly, even the clear and profound teachings of Francis—and they are not few—are immediately cast into the darkness of suspicion and judgment.

    Unsubstantiated? Really? Is Mark saying these actions of PF never happened?


    And then there is the testimony of the progressive Cardinal Godfried Daneels of Belgium who claims to have been part of a “Mafia club” to oppose the election of Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger to the papacy, and to advance a reform of the Church to be headed by none other than Jorge Mario Bergoglio—now Pope Francis. The little clique was about 7-8 members. Did they somehow influence the election of Pope Francis too?

    Is this really beyond belief? That a small group can influence the majority? Especially when we know that Freemasons have infiltrated the Church right to the very top? Remember Alta Vendita? Bella Dodd's testimony?

    Here’s the thing: not a single Cardinal—including the outspoken Cardinal Raymond Burke or the courageous African Cardinals or any other orthodox members of that college—have even so much as hinted that something went awry.
    Dolours has said what I too believe:
    Seriously, why was there been no proper investigation after Cardinal Daneel's open boast?


    And so, in what seems a search for any reason to disqualify Francis, pundits continue to assert that Pope Benedict is still the legitimate pontiff. They claim that he resigned under pressure and duress, and therefore, he remains the Supreme Pontiff, while Bergoglio is an antipope, impostor, or false prophet.
    The problem with this is that Pope Benedict himself has repeatedly denounced those who voice this theory.
    So intent are some to dethrone Francis that they are willing to suggest that Pope Benedict is simply lying here—a virtual prisoner in the Vatican.


    Can we discard what Archbishop Ganswein said about the 'expansion of the Petrine Ministry'?
    Ignore the fact that Pope Benedict wants to be known as Pope Emeritus, not Cardinal Ratzinger? That he wears the papal white, lives within the confines of Vatican City?
    That he said 'the Petrine ministry is an 'always' and a 'forever'?
    That lightning struck St Peter's Basilica the very day Pope Benedict announced his resignation?
    That the Pope Emeritus recently said that 'the Barque of Peter is seemingly on the verge of capsizing'?
    That he also said 'in the end, God will win'?
    So who is winning now?


    But what about the prophecy of St. Francis of Assisi?
    …there will be very few Christians who will obey the true Sovereign Pontiff and the Roman Catholic Church with loyal hearts and perfect charity. At the time of this tribulation a man, not canonically elected, will be raised to the Pontificate, who, by his cunning, will endeavour to draw many into error and death. —Works of the Seraphic Father by R. Washbourne (1882), p. 250
    Since Pope Francis has been validly and canonically elected, this prophecy does not refer to him—plain and simple.


    See my earlier argument.

    And yet, I am inclined to say watch out! The signs of the times are everywhere indicating the rise of a false church—a false church that may very well see an anti-pope attempt to usurp the throne that Francis now validly holds…

    I think the false church is already here. As to the validity, see earlier argument.

    Do the Pope’s actions at times trouble you? Do his words confuse you? Do you disagree with some things he says on matters outside of faith and morals? Then pray harder for him. And those who are able to should approach the Holy Father with their concerns in a manner that is consistent with charity and does not itself created scandal. This does not make them or you a bad Catholic. Nor does it make you an enemy of the Pope.

    Yes, PF's actions and words are troubling. Very troubling.
    Mark still thinks approaching him is a solution! Really??

    When people go against a Pope who is teaching everything that the Church has always taught, then they are going against Christ himself who gave the keys to Peter. But when people are going against someone sitting on the throne of Peter who is doing everything he can to go against the 2000 years old teachings of the Magisterium and destroy the Church, are we not actually standing up for Christ?
     
    Totus tuus, AED, Mac and 1 other person like this.
  13. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

    Well, if that's what he was trying to say, he should get you to write his blog rather than rambling on and on.
     
    Don_D and Mac like this.
  14. Fatima

    Fatima Powers

    I think we are all in an awkward place, within the diabolical disorientation taking place. On one had we would all like to call out who we believe to be a heretic. On the other extreme many would like to take it all to prayer and trust that God has a plan for it all. Perhaps there are those in the middle who see what is going on and speak to it in a private setting, so as not to give undo scandal and later having to recant. Bottom line, there are those who are simply tired of the fight and want to call what they see, a spade as a spade. There are those on the other end of the spectrum that see our pope as a breath of fresh air to their definition of love and mercy, without laws. I have thought about leaving the battle and take it all to prayer, as others have done. Yet, at the same time, I am a fighter and want to stay abreast to where the battle is going. At some point, I know we will all enter the battle full out. There is a time for meekness and a time for battle. I see we are in a spiritual battle at this moment and it appears that the evil spirits are winning. As I see it, we can do little, but pray, study and do penance and hope to stay in the state of sanctifying grace. Jesus I Trust in You through it all.

    Lord, make me an instrument of your peace,
    Where there is hatred, let me sow love;
    where there is injury, pardon;
    where there is doubt, faith;
    where there is despair, hope;
    where there is darkness, light;
    where there is sadness, joy;

    O Divine Master, grant that I may not so much seek to be consoled as to console;
    to be understood as to understand;
    to be loved as to love.

    For it is in giving that we receive;
    it is in pardoning that we are pardoned;
    and it is in dying that we are born to eternal life.
     
    Last edited: Nov 29, 2017
    sterph likes this.
  15. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

    That's all well and good but how would Mark Mallet respond to the points made by SgCatholic? Declaring that Pope Francis is the valid Pope is a poor excuse for the harm he is doing to the Church. The default excuses of poor translations, context or bias don't cut it any more. It should be possible for a Pope to preach God's peace, love and mercy without undermining or fudging God's Truth and it isn't sedevacantism to say so.

    I should stress here that I'm not lumping Mark Mallet in with the likes of Frs. Martin or Spadaro who are a disgrace to the priesthood. Mark strikes me as a good, faithful Catholic trying his best to make sense of what's happening in the Church. He just isn't making any sense to me.
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Nov 29, 2017
    Totus tuus, AED, Mac and 1 other person like this.
  16. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    Sedevacantism is a danger, but it makes up a tiny portion of people who call themselves Catholic. They are literally just a few small churches.

    The greater apostasy is from those still calling themselves Catholic, but who support homosexuality, contraception, even abortion. These are the large swathes of people who still claim the name Catholic, but who have left the faith.

    The two sides of error upon which people are falling off of the Barque today is not even.

    If I had to guess and put numbers on it (And this is purely a guess) I would say it would be something like .01% sedevacantists vs. 50% or more of baptized "Catholics" in general apostasy.

    With the sedevacatists falling off the "right" side of the Barque and the rest off of the "left".
     
    Last edited: Nov 29, 2017
    Carol55, AED, Mac and 1 other person like this.
  17. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    In fact, not to get too frightening with the statistics, but someone on the forum posted a recent poll that showed that 9 out of 10 Catholics in America don't believe in Hell or something to that effect. That would mean approximately 90% of Catholics in the USA are in apostasy just over that one point, nevermind everything else you need to believe to be a Catholic. It is probably similar in Europe, if not worse in parts. Of course the Church in Asia and Africa are healthier, so the numbers aren't as bad globally, but it is still shocking.
     
    AED and Mac like this.
  18. Jarg

    Jarg Archangels

    https://www.lifesitenews.com/opinion/the-dawn-of-the-great-apostasy

    The dawn of the Great Apostasy

    An essay by Michael O’Brien (writer of Father Elijah)

    November 27, 2017 (LifeSiteNews) – As in every generation, the “near future” approaches, never quite materializing in ways we had imagined. Because of this, our perennial temptation is to dismiss the teleology of history, and the eschatology of revelation, as mental constructs produced by irrational fears or limited by enflamed analyses of contemporary situations, a cycle that is supposedly repeated without end, never delivering the promised omni-catastrophe. Even so, according to Christ in the Gospels and the Book of Revelation, and the letters of Sts. Peter, Paul, and John, and the Old Testament prophets, as well as the ecclesially approved private revelations that have increased in number and intensity for the past 150 years, the time is drawing near when all speculative scenarios will evaporate in the face of a real and ultimate peril for mankind. Then the future will become the present. Its prologue will be an apostasy unprecedented in scope. Indeed, day by day this apostasy spreads all around us. Its climax is the Day of the Lord, a day of fire.

    In a number of sermons, Blessed Cardinal John Henry Newman wrote prophetically about the near future that was looming in his own times:

    “I know that all times are perilous, and that in every time serious and anxious minds, alive to the honour of God and the needs of man, are apt to consider no times so perilous as their own. At all times the enemy of souls assaults with fury the Church which is their true Mother, and at least threatens and frightens when he fails in doing mischief. And all times have their special trials which others have not. And so far I will admit that there were certain specific dangers to Christians at certain other times, which do not exist in this time. Doubtless, but still admitting this, still I think that the trials which lie before us are such as would appall and make dizzy even such courageous hearts as St. Athanasius, St. Gregory I, or St. Gregory VII. And they would confess that dark as the prospect of their own day was to them severally, ours has a darkness different in kind from any that has been before it. The special peril of the time before us is the spread of that plague of infidelity, that the Apostles and our Lord Himself have predicted as the worst calamity of the last times of the Church. And at least a shadow, a typical image of the last times is coming over the world.1”

    Newman’s approach was conditioned partly by the context of the times he lived in and also by his understanding of the constant temptation of Christians, that is, to make compromises with the spiritus mundi. It was clear to him that the spirit of the world in his day was making ever greater advances against what remained of old Christendom. And in other sermons, he went farther, warning that the diabolic spirit was moving toward a final confrontation.2 Newman pointed out that eras of lukewarmness and laxity among the faithful had always been the prologue to persecutions, and that the ultimate persecution would be preceded by the greatest apostasy in the history of the Church.3 There had been, of course, other periods of apostasy and heresy, such as the Arian crisis, and severe as they were, they arose at a time of vastly diverse religious confusion when civilized man was still crawling up out of the fever swamps of paganism.

    And that is the difference between what has occurred in the past and what is occurring now across the entire Western world. A civilization that has known Christianity (and is now largely ignorant about how dark paganism can be) is choosing to go back down into the swamp, and all along the downward trajectory is calling it progress, proclaiming at every turn its tragically stunted concept of freedom and aggressively imposing it on everyone.

    That the revolution has so swiftly overturned the fundamental principles of civilization is one of its more ominous characteristics—principles recognized by any sane society. Needless to say, there are historical and sociological factors involved, such as the shattering of confidence in a benevolent God by two unthinkably destructive world wars, by the looming threat of nuclear war, by genocides, by the sexual revolution, and by the phenomenal growth of new media so powerful that it overwhelms consciousness, and hence conscience, making of the human will an instrument of its purpose—redefining not only the meaning of man but of Reality itself.

    To be continued…over the next five days
     
    sunburst, Dolours, AED and 2 others like this.
  19. Praetorian

    Praetorian Powers

    It is true, I have thought of this many times, we are living in pagan times. This is not a Christian culture anymore. You could call it post-Christian, but I think neo-pagan is more accurate. And it seems these neo-pagan times are worse than the first ones. We are living in the new Babylon. Eating, drinking, fornication, and perversion galore. In breadth and scope unseen in world history.
     
    Tanker, sterph, AED and 4 others like this.

Share This Page