I think Cardinal Muller thinks of himself as a, 'healer'. between , 'The two sides'. “Unfortunately,” Müller continues, “some people always take a ‘partisan’ view, for or against the Pope, as if the Church were a political party. My intervention is not meant to continue the polemics but to overcome them, and to speak about these issues theologically. It is not about being right at any cost, but about honoring revealed Truth.” I think in this he is assuming good intent. I am not sure good intent is present. It is not a question of , 'Taking sides', but of following what is the truth. I don;t think there is room for a middle way in this.
Bingo! I think there are a couple of things going on in his mind. Though this is just my personal take and I do not mean to speak for the interior musings of anyone, much less a prelate of the Church. What it seems to me from my observations is that Cardinal Muller is: A. Trying to avoid a schism. Many may not remember, but way back during the synods he was one of the first people to mention the very real danger of this. B. I think it may be beyond his mental landscape to imagine that any pope might put forward anything that goes against Church teaching. In one of the interviews he gave he made statements that to me verged on neo-ultramontanism. I think he is a good man and is doing what he considers the best to maintain the cohesion of the Church, the primacy of the papacy as he understands it, and maintain Church Tradition (with a capital "T"). The fact that what is happening may make all of these positions irreconcilable seems beyond the mental framework within which his mind operates. I am not saying that disparagingly. I have a lot of respect for this man. We are all made with different strengths and weaknesses and our minds have different ways of coping with situations. Perhaps the paradox of what is going on is impossible for him to reconcile.
Like many of us, he may be torn between loyalty to the papacy and the Truth at a time when the two seem to be in conflict. One must follow the Truth, but who among us wishes to be at odds with our Pope?
I included the comments which help clarify Cardinal Muller's statements, imo: http://www.praytellblog.com/index.p...-muller-goes-against-popes-magnum-principium/ Cardinal Muller Goes Against Pope’s Magnum Principium November 9, 2017 Editor Translation / New Missal The former prefect of the CDF Cardinal Muller has voiced reservations about Pope Francis’ Magnum principium, which gave national Bishops’ Conferences more freedom in translating liturgical texts. Translated from Passauer Neue Presse: Muller expresses reserve about giving bishops’ conferences more freedom in the translation of liturgical texts. The Cardinal says the liturgy should unite and not divide. “The last authority in cases of doubt cannot lie with bishops’ conferences.” Otherwise one could fear that the unity of the Catholic Church in faith, confession, and prayer would be destroyed. . . . The cardinal referred to experiences where bishops have brought in translators who watered down Biblical and other texts under the pretext of better comprehension. You can find the full report, in German, here 7 comments Fr. Jack Feehily says: November 9, 2017 at 9:57 am Methinks the esteemed cardinal is positioning himself for the next conclave. With Francis on “The Joy of Love” (will everyone please stop referring to this document by its Latin name), not so much with Francis on “The Great Principle”. This is not cynicism. Most Cardinals are not naive enough to suppose that leaving the results of conclaves to the Holy Spirit eliminates making known the kind of leader you might make if chosen. Reply Lee Fratantuono says: November 9, 2017 at 10:24 am I am genuinely confused. The title of this piece says Mueller is “against” Magnum Principium. Yet what the Cardinal actually said was that he had reservations about the document. Does having reservations constitute opposition? It seems the title casts Mueller in an adversarial role…and yet the man merely has reservations, questions, and concerns… Reply Rita Ferrone says: November 9, 2017 at 10:57 am I understand your question, Lee. The confusion arises because the source is a bit ambiguous. There are several possible ways to translate what Mueller said. In the body of our post, we went with a mild translation. But his comments can be seen as “going against” — as in “against the grain” — of the main idea of the motu proprio, which is that Episcopal Conferences have been given authority over translation. Google Translate offered a more adamant rendering: “The German Cardinal Gerhard Ludwig Müller does not believe that Pope Francis has granted more freedom to the national episcopal conferences in the translation of liturgical texts.” and renders the quote of him saying “The ultimate authority in the case of doubt cannot lie with the Episcopal Conferences.” I hope that what he really meant to do was to voice reservations, and not to contradict the motu proprio. But it could be read as an outright contradiction. Reply Charles Day says: November 9, 2017 at 11:01 am Caveat: I can’t read German. But, I agree that you can have ‘concerns’ without stating outright opposition. Unity is certainly a valid, maybe even a primary, goal. At the same time, without specific examples of a watered down translation that haas divided the Church, I can’t see that he is saying that happened. Clarity and comprehension are also worthy goals, and sacrificing those goals in the name of unity is unlikely to achieve unity. Reply Vic Romero says: November 9, 2017 at 12:55 pm The translation quoted in the post is not faithful to the original. 1. Original: “Kardinal Gerhard Ludwig Müller hat die Entscheidung des Papstes kritisiert, den nationalen Bischofskonferenzen bei der Übersetzung liturgischer Texte mehr Kompetenzen einzuräumen.” 2. Quoted in the post: “Muller expresses reserve about giving bishops’ conferences more freedom in the translation of liturgical texts. The Cardinal says the liturgy should unite and not divide.” 3. More faithful translation: “Cardinal Gerhard Ludwig Müller has criticized the Pope’s decision to give more powers to the national episcopal conferences when translating liturgical texts.” I could not find “The Cardinal says the liturgy should unite and not divide.”‘ in the original German. Did the translator add this sentence? Reply Rita Ferrone says: November 9, 2017 at 1:55 pm Hi Vic, It’s in the Thursday edition. Reply Anthony Ruff, OSB says: November 9, 2017 at 2:02 pm Hello all, Though it’s my month off, I did a quick translation of a report on the interview, not of the interview. My translation of that report is accurate, although where I had a decision to make I de-escalated things. Maybe I was over-correcting, but I didn’t want Pray Tell to be guilty of playing up the cardinal’s disagreement with the pope. Here’s the “unify, not divide” comment: “Die Liturgie vereint und darf nicht trennen und Gegensätze erzeugen.” The German report saying he is against Magnum Principium is an interpretation, to be sure. The interview as a whole supports that interpretation, for Mueller seems to think that the Vatican should determine translations and there should not be regional differences (contra Vatican II). awr Reply
I think it is actually evidence of Cardinal Muller's holiness that he has the perspective that he does. Holy people always attribute the best to others.
I happenend to be listening to the EWTN Mass today and was happy to hear a very courageous bishop from Poland, Andrezj Siemieniewski, give an unmistakeable clarification to those still straddling the line about the mess in the Vatican. He builds his case from the reading today and midway through his homily--kapow!! His gentle delivery did not hide the strong truth he delivered. EWTN reaches over 150 million homes in 144 countries.
When Father Joseph Ratzinger Predicted the Future of the Church ........We have no need of a Church that celebrates the cult of action in political prayers. It is utterly superfluous. Therefore, it will destroy itself. What will remain is the Church of Jesus Christ, the Church that believes in the God who has become man and promises us life beyond death. The kind of priest who is no more than a social worker can be replaced by the psychotherapist and other specialists; but the priest who is no specialist, who does not stand on the [sidelines], watching the game, giving official advice, but in the name of God places himself at the disposal of man, who is beside them in their sorrows, in their joys, in their hope and in their fear, such a priest will certainly be needed in the future. “Let us go a step farther. From the crisis of today the Church of tomorrow will emerge — a Church that has lost much. She will become small and will have to start afresh more or less from the beginning. She will no longer be able to inhabit many of the edifices she built in prosperity. As the number of her adherents diminishes, so it will lose many of her social privileges. In contrast to an earlier age, it will be seen much more as a voluntary society, entered only by free decision. As a small society, it will make much bigger demands on the initiative of her individual members. Undoubtedly it will discover new forms of ministry and will ordain to the priesthood approved Christians who pursue some profession. In many smaller congregations or in self-contained social groups, pastoral care will normally be provided in this fashion. Along-side this, the full-time ministry of the priesthood will be indispensable as formerly. But in all of the changes at which one might guess, the Church will find her essence afresh and with full conviction in that which was always at her center: faith in the triune God, in Jesus Christ, the Son of God made man, in the presence of the Spirit until the end of the world. In faith and prayer she will again recognize the sacraments as the worship of God and not as a subject for liturgical scholarship. https://aleteia.org/2016/06/13/when-cardinal-joseph-ratzinger-predicted-the-future-of-the-church/
I love the Church which Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI has described. This was the Church of the beginning, the church led by the early apostles, each apostle working in some profession, some tent makers, others fishermen, as it was meant to be.
An excellent homily. I suspect that what some may read into it is not at all what the bishop is intending (although I accept I may be wrong about this!) but the bishop's reference to the Church as a river flowing through history taking different directions but always flowing from its source, Jesus, is particularly helpful. He ends the homily with, "The Church, a teacher of truth, the teacher of truth and the Church appear to us today as a treasure house." When I read some of the posts on the forum I see the Church being viewed very differently.
Can you clarify, preferably with specific examples, who here has been viewing the Church as not 'a teacher of truth...'? As far as I can read, nearly everyone on here is anxious that there are those within the Church at present that contradict or are unclear with respect to certain truths that Christ Himself and His Church have always taught. Do you consider that the Maltese and Polish bishops are both simultaneously teaching the truth right now? If so, can you explain how this is so? Do you believe in the theory of non-contradiction? Perhaps you believe, with some in the Vatican, that 2+2 might, in some cases, equal not 4, but 5? I suggest you come clean with your insinuations of heresy or withdraw them immediately. To do otherwise is neither just nor honest.
A quite extraordinary response! There are plenty of accusations (or insinuations) of heresy on this forum but they don't come from me! Let me clarify what I stated. I quoted the words of the bishop: "The Church, a teacher of truth, the teacher of truth and the Church appear to us today as a treasure house." My subsequent comment was intended to express the view that some forum participants do not seem to view the Church as a "treasure house". Am I mistaken?
That piece in bold is, at best, 'mistaken'. Your assertion that "...I read some of the posts on the forum I see the Church being viewed very differently" refers back undifferentially to the sentence "The Church, a teacher of truth, the teacher of truth and the Church appear to us today as a treasure house", not merely the clause "as a treasure house". I am not impressed with attempts at deflection via exclamation marks and excitable adjectives about my response. My insinuation stands.
I fear you are wrong about us, David. We here on the forum do indeed view the Church as a teacher of Truth and as a treasure house. The Church was founded by Jesus Christ himself. How could we feel otherwise? We have not deviated from the 2000-years Magisterium. We do not hold heretical views. We have been expounding QUITE the opposite!
Fr Malachi Martin and Fr Charles Fiore impressed upon me to not confuse the little c catholic church with the big C Catholic church. I admit I have lost faith in the catholic church but not in the Catholic church. I can also say from personal connections that Archbishop Chaput can't stand PF. PF was a believer/follower of liberation theology when it was condemned by ST JP2. He was disobedient then and I believe he is anti-catholic now. What changed? The Holy Spirit? ...as it was in the beginning, is now, and ever shall be!
Pope Francis has critics of ‘substance’ who ‘can’t in justice be dismissed’: US archbishop Chaput Chaput said that “persons of fidelity and substance” who have criticized the exhortation AL for problems such as seemingly opening a door to the divorced and remarried to receive Holy Communion “can’t in justice — be dismissed.” https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/pope-francis-critics-cant-in-justice-be-dismissed-u.s.-archbishop
Garabandal, Thank you for posting this. I'm posting the entire article, it's too good not to and it's more evidence of the Holy Spirit at work, imho... Pope Francis has critics of ‘substance’ who ‘can’t in justice be dismissed’: US archbishop by Pete Baklinski TEXAS, November 10, 2017 (LifeSiteNews) -- The “obvious controversy” that surround’s Pope Francis’ exhortation on marriage and family Amoris Laetitia (Joy of Love) has “obscured much of the good in the document,” said Archbishop Charles Chaput of Philadelphia in an address on Wednesday. But despite “passages of great wisdom and beauty on marriage and on family life,” Chaput said that “persons of fidelity and substance” who have criticized the exhortation for problems such as seemingly opening a door to the divorced and remarried to receive Holy Communion “can’t in justice — be dismissed.” The Archbishop may have been referring to the four Dubia Cardinals and others, such as the signers of the Filial Correction and Father Thomas Weinandy. He made his remarks at the third annual National Assembly of Filipino Priests in Houston, Texas. Chaput said that the exhortation has created “pastoral challenges” regarding what it means for priests to accompany straying Catholics and to be merciful to them, especially when it comes to Catholic teaching on marriage and sexuality. “Ground Zero is this: For Christians, sexual intimacy outside a valid marriage can never be morally legitimate. And it’s the Church that determines what a valid marriage is,” he said. He said that the key for interpreting the exhortation comes from paragraph 2, which reads in part: “The thinking of pastors and theologians, if faithful to the Church, honest, realistic and creative, will help us achieve greater clarity” in addressing the issues that face today’s families. Commented Chaput: “The key words there are ‘if faithful to the Church.’ Fidelity to the received and constant wisdom of Catholic teaching is paramount.” The Archbishop said that his own guidelines on implementing the exhortation in his archdiocese were based on this key passage. Chaput’s guidelines, released July 2016, unequivocally state that divorced and civilly remarried Catholics may not receive Holy Communion unless they “refrain from sexual intimacy.” One of Pope Francis’ most outspoken American supporters, then-Cardinal-designate Kevin Farrell, slammed Chaput’s guidelines as causing “division.” As liberal interpretation swirl about, suggesting that the Church is weakening her teachings about marriage and sexuality under Pope Francis, the Archbishop said in his address to priest that Jesus makes it clear in the Gospels that a valid marriage cannot be broken. “Scripture’s clearest words about the indissolubility of marriage come from Jesus himself in Matthew 19. They can’t be softened, or reinterpreted, or contextualized. Christian marriage is a covenant between one man and one woman. When valid, it endures until the death of one or the other spouse. And our task as priests is to uphold and advance that truth as a message of liberation, even when it’s difficult,” he said. The way to proceed amidst “confusion,” said the Archbishop, is to interpret the document and it’s key terms so that it is “consistent with the magisterium of previous popes.” “Accompaniment” must be interpreted as guiding people “in the right direction – gently but also honestly, speaking the truth with love.” “It does no one any good if we ‘accompany’ someone over a cliff, or even worse, to a fatal separation from God. We can’t simply confirm people in their mistakes. Scripture is very clear about right and wrong sexual relationships and behavior. We’re very poor disciples if we lack the courage to speak the truth as the Church has always understood it,” he said. “Mercy,” which “depends on the existence of justice and truth,” must be interpreted as never excluding “careful moral reasoning about right and wrong,” he said. “Permanent truths exist about human nature, sexuality, behavior and relationships. Those truths apply to all of us, in all circumstances, and justice involves living according to those truths,” he added. “Marriage” must never be interpreted as “simply an ‘ideal’” — which “tends to open the door to excusing and then normalizing failure” — but as a “permanent, loving bond between a man and a woman open to new life.” “We need to fight for it, and not collapse – like so many other Christian communities — into the confusion of a society based on compromises, caveats and alibis. That’s the message we need to preach and teach,” he said. The Archbishop ended his talk by encouraging priests, that even though the Church of the faithful “will very likely be smaller, poorer, and empty of prestige,” they should not lose hope. “God doesn’t ask us to save the Church or fix the world. That’s in his hands. What he asks is much simpler and more important. He asks each of us as priests to be faithful, and to be his healing presence to his – and to our – people,” he said. “In the midst of confusion, he asks us to speak and live the truth. In the midst of conflict, he asks us to be peacemakers. In the midst of distress, he asks us to be sources of hope,” he added. Chaput said that no matter how “intractable or unfixable the problems of a marriage or family might be, the priest who listens and counsels with a spirit of mercy guided by truth is doing what God called him to do: to be the presence of God’s love in the world.” “There’s no greater mission of mercy than that, and no greater joy in the life of a priest,” he said.