The Vatican Has Fallen

Discussion in 'Church Critique' started by padraig, Dec 31, 2016.

  1. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

    Yes, you put yourself in the same category as Fr. Martin. I merely pointed it out. Have you attended any LGBT masses yet? That should earn you your very own papal commendation.

    The priest said he always intended to publish the letter. He prayed to God for a sign as to whether he should go ahead with his plan. God gave him the sign. Now, either the priest hid his intentions from God or God encouraged him to do something which according to you could lead to his damnation. Which is it? God led the priest to endanger his immortal soul? God didn't know that the priest would publish the letter? The priest hid his intentions from God and God gave him the sign not knowing his real intentions which would lead to his damnation? Of course, you wouldn't be the first defender of Pope Francis who believes that Jesus didn't know the future. Neither would you be the first to claim that God would want someone to sin.

    Why don't you address the contents of the letter? Evidently, God considered it worth writing or the priest wouldn't have received the sign he asked for.
     
  2. davidtlig

    davidtlig Guest

    You have missed the fact that the 'sign' may have indicated to Fr Weinandy that he was correct to write the letter but it certainly didn't indicate he should make it public.

    ​
     
  3. Joe Crozier

    Joe Crozier Guest

    Its late and I am tired Dolours. This is all your stuff, not mine. So now you are letting people think that I attend LGTB masses. Nice. I will not fight you. I take the injuries you inflict on me and ask God to bless you one hundred fold in return. May He grant your best wishes (not your worst ones which may cause my damnation Ha ha) and show you a better way.

    Once again I have momentarily lost focus on the raison d'etre for my presence here. It is to defend the truth as I have been given to understand it and in so doing to defend my Pope however poor my ability. I became over concerned that, because of the replies coming from you and Mac and Brian I may be less able to help others see the truth, that I may become less credible. That is not my concern. God will take care of that. And I hope Padraig will take not that I have not retaliated.

    A friend in America has a first class relic of St Margaret Mary Alocoque. She recently sent me several items that had been touched to that relic. Margaret Mary had a severe allergy to cheese. Her superior, knowing this, still insisted that she ate it. It made her horribly ill and caused terrible pain but she ate it in obedience every day for eight years. She also suffered great humiliation at the hands of her sisters. God assured her that He could do his best work through the weakest of creatures. Through this suffering she grew ever closer to God and was granted the visions and ecstasies with which we are so familiar and was a conduit for Universal Devotion to the Sacred Heart of Jesus. She suffered much opposition in the cause of this devotion but God assured her He would overcome all adversity. People thought the worst of Margaret Mary but it did not matter. She became a saint. I could never attain her virtue but I do ask for her help and intercession not only for my enemies but also for Pope Francis and for myself.
     
  4. Joe Crozier

    Joe Crozier Guest

    Thank you David. I was beginning to feel very alone. I made that very point early on in the piece but of course it was ignored. God bless you.
     
  5. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

    No, I didn't miss anything. The priest always intended to publish the letter. He prayed to God for a sign. God gave him the sign. He got no sign saying write the letter but don't publish it. You and Joe are adding a condition to the sign given by God whereas God added no conditions when he gave the sign.
     
    SgCatholic likes this.
  6. davidtlig

    davidtlig Guest

    Hardly worth responding to as Emmett may well have preferred making some changes (what writer doesn't?) but I'm quite sure he hasn't suddenly decided that the substance of the letter was wrong and that he now had become a follower of Brian's line of thought!! No, the article was a good response to all the stuff coming out against the Pope although it was too long. That's why I much prefer Fr Strynkowski succinct response to Fr Weinandy's letter.
     
    Joe Crozier likes this.
  7. Joe Crozier

    Joe Crozier Guest

    One mistake you have missed Dolours is that I thought Fr Weinandy was a 90 year old man. Oops. Aplogies Fr.
     
  8. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

    No, Joe, I'm not letting anyone think you attend LGBT masses. I asked whether you had attended any. Why would you consider that to be a problem? Aren't you good with the Pope's favourite clerics who promote the LGBT agenda?

    If you are so concerned about the truth, why add a condition to the sign God gave the priest when God added no such condition?

    If you want to be canonised, do as Martin Luther did and call the Pope the antichrist. He was condemned by a Church Council but is being celebrated with a stamp and a statue in the Vatican. Considering no Pope or Council has condemned you, the least you can expect is canonisation.

    Why don't you advocate for abortion on demand? You'll be guaranteed a place on a Pontificatal academy and they'll give you a platform to push your agenda. Now, living a holy life or being imprisoned by a dictator could get you a tongue lashing and public ridicule from the Pope a la the treatment meted out to Cardinal Sarah, so unless you mend your ways there's no chance anyone will be praying for St. Joe's intercession.
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Nov 5, 2017
  9. davidtlig

    davidtlig Guest

    His 'sign' was to write the letter. His decision to make it public came much later. Read what the priest said:

    I was praying about the present state of the Church and the anxieties I had about the present Pontificate. I was beseeching Jesus and Mary, St. Peter and all of the saintly popes who are buried there to do something to rectify the confusion and turmoil within the Church today, a chaos and an uncertainty that I felt Pope Francis had himself caused. I was also pondering whether or not I should write and publish something expressing my concerns and anxiety.

    On the following Wednesday afternoon, at the conclusion of my meeting, I went again to St. Peter’s and prayed in the same manner. That night I could not get to sleep, which is very unusual for me. It was due to all that was on my mind pertaining to the Church and Pope Francis.

    At 1:15 AM I got up and went outside for short time. When I went back to my room, I said to the Lord: “If you want me to write something, you have to give me a clear sign. This is what the sign must be. Tomorrow morning I am going to Saint Mary Major’s to pray and then I am going to Saint John Lateran. After that I am coming back to Saint Peter’s to have lunch with a seminary friend of mine. During that interval, I must meet someone that I know but have not seen in a very long time and would never expect to see in Rome at this time. That person cannot be from the United States, Canada or Great Britain. Moreover, that person has to say to me in the course of our conversation, ‘Keep up the good writing’.”

    The next morning I did all of the above and by the time I met my seminarian friend for lunch what I had asked the Lord the following night was no longer in the forefront of my mind.

    However, towards the end of the meal an archbishop appeared between two parked cars right in front of our table (we were sitting outside). I had not seen him for over twenty years, long before he became an archbishop. We recognized one another immediately. What made his appearance even more unusual was that, because of his recent personal circumstances, I would never have expected to see him in Rome or anywhere else, other than in his own archdiocese. (He was from none of the above mentioned countries.) We spoke about his coming to Rome and caught up on what we were doing. I then introduced him to my seminarian friend. He said to my friend that we had met a long time ago and that he had, at that time, just finished reading my book on the immutability of God and the Incarnation. He told my friend that it was an excellent book, that it helped him sort out the issue, and that my friend should read the book. Then he turned to me and said: “Keep up the good writing.”

    I could hardly believe that this just happened in a matter of a few minutes. But there was no longer any doubt in my mind that Jesus wanted me to write something. I also think it significant that it was an Archbishop that Jesus used. I considered it an apostolic mandate.​
     
  10. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

    Tut-tut, David. He prayed asking God whether he should write and publish something. He said that it was always his intention to publish the letter.
     
    SgCatholic and HeavenlyHosts like this.
  11. Joe Crozier

    Joe Crozier Guest

    Dolours
    I am sure you meant me, not David in the about retort.
    Enough is enough - I have family to think about - for their sake I ask Padraig to stop your abuse.
     
  12. davidtlig

    davidtlig Guest

    Apologies, Dolours, you are quite right. I need to read things more closely :)

    I do wonder, however, about the actual timescale as his account of 'the sign' was written much later of course.
     
  13. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    Dolours is NOT guilty of abuse here. She is perfectly lucid and within her rights to ask the questions she has. Stop this passive aggressive nonsense with playing the victim card. No one here buys your false martyr complex. You’ve played this card too many times.
     
  14. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    Answer the substance of his letter to the pope and stop trying to change the subject by finding fault with him publishing the letter, which simply does NOT exist.
     
    SgCatholic likes this.
  15. davidtlig

    davidtlig Guest

    Ok, but the best response is that from Mgr Strynkowski which I will quote here as Joe originally posted the letter just as a link. I couldn't improve on this response:

    An open letter to Father Weinandy, from his predecessor, on ‘Amoris Laetitia’ and Pope Francis

    Dear Father Weinandy,

    You may remember me as your predecessor as executive director of the Secretariat for Christian Doctrine at the U.S.C.C.B. You replaced me in January 2005.

    I am writing this open letter to you in response to your open letter to Pope Francis in which you address what you describe as a “chronic confusion” that seems to mark his pontificate.

    According to Sandro Magister’s introduction to your letter, you had asked Jesus for a sign as to whether you should write your letter, you received that sign and thus “no longer had any doubt that Jesus wanted me to write….” I cannot enter into the subjective conditions that inspired you to write, but I need to note that “Amoris Laetitia,”toward which you express great concern, was the fruit of two synods and broad consultation throughout the church, is widely recognized as an act of ordinary Magisterium, and thus enjoys presumption as having been guided by the Spirit of the Lord.

    Your first concern is centered on Chapter 8 of “Amoris Laetitia.” You maintain that the Holy Father’s “guidance at times seems intentionally ambiguous.” I believe that the vast majority of bishops and theologians do not agree. The pope does indeed open the door to the possibility that some divorced and civilly remarried Catholics can be admitted to the sacraments after careful discernment. Rocco Buttiglione, one of the foremost interpreters of the teaching of St. John Paul II, sees no contradiction, but rather continuity between “Familiaris Consortio”and “Amoris Laetitia.” And most recently Cardinal Gerhard Müller stated that there are conditions which open the way for those in second marriages to receive sacraments.

    Your second concern is that the pope’s manner “seems to demean the importance of Church doctrine.” I would note, first of all, that the Holy Father’s homilies, based on the Gospel, call us to a discipleship that is rigorous and uncompromising. Second, I interpret his criticism of those who make doctrine an ideology as a challenge for us to never isolate doctrine from its source in the mercy of God revealed in Jesus Christ.

    Your third concern is the Holy Father’s “choice of some bishops, men who seem not merely open to those who hold views counter to Christian belief but who support and even defend them.” Unless you are willing to name these bishops and the views counter to Christian belief that supposedly they tolerate, this remains a gratuitous assertion and damages the unity of the church.

    Your fourth concern is the pope’s encouragement of a “‘synodality’ that allows and promotes various doctrinal and moral options within the Church.” Here, again in an open letter to the pope, it would have been more responsible to specify what these various options have been. To do anything less is to foster suspicion of bishops and theologians by some circles in the church.

    Your fifth concern is that bishops feel that the pope is not open to criticism and indeed resents it. What is your source for this? Indeed, there has been much criticism of the pope, but he has remained silent. I am not aware of anything that he has said in public to indicate that he resents criticism.

    Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, as Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, urged that dissent from ordinary Magisterium should be disclosed privately to church authority—see “Donum Veritatis” (No. 30). In a world and even an ecclesial environment of sound bites and facile partisanship, that becomes even wiser advice.

    Fraternally yours in Christ,

    Msgr. John Strynkowski

    https://www.americamagazine.org/fai...-predecessor-amoris-laetitia-and-pope-francis

    ​
     
  16. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

    Yes, I was responding to alternate posts from you and David. I did edit my post to correct the names.

    Joe, I didn't engage in conversation with you until you starting talking about a good priest bringing damnation upon himself for doing his sacred duty by the faithful whom God has entrusted to all priests. That his superiors have failed in their duty as shepherds doesn't remove his duty to defend the faith by letting the faithful know that they need to be aware that even apostles can preach a different Gospel.

    The post of yours which prompted me to respond was particularly vile in its inference.
     
    SgCatholic and BrianK like this.
  17. Joe Crozier

    Joe Crozier Guest

    Et tu brute
     
  18. Mac

    Mac "To Jesus, through Mary"

    ''Joe and David may go now''


    [​IMG]​
     
  19. Joe Crozier

    Joe Crozier Guest

    Already I have received emails about the abuse I am getting here. Others have recognized it. Dolours is out of line and so are you Brian. There is nothing false about my charges of abuse. There was nothing vile in my original or follow up posts post except your interpretation and extrapolations Dolours. I am not playing the victim. I am the victim. I am being victimised and my good name and that of my family who have defended life and the faith for generations is being dragged through the mud. I have been assured by Padraig that I am entitled to my opinion. It is you Brian who has overplayed his hand and it is a heavy hand as usual.
     
  20. Joe Crozier

    Joe Crozier Guest

    Hi David
    I have a response from Emmett about Brians comment but have promised not to drag him into this abuse. He has given me permission to quote him.
    “Hi Joe
    I said that about my last arrticle because I didn’t know that it was going to be published straight away. I regretted lumping Cardinal Burke in with the authors of the Filial Correction, and a few other minor errors. But obviously this is my overall stance on the issue.”
     
    davidtlig likes this.

Share This Page