Padraig, I was thinking the same thing, a Lutheran Church inside the walls? it sounds like they wanted to created some confusion with that name. It is definitely outside the walls of the Vatican...https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St_Paul's_Within_the_Walls .
The Indefectibility of the Church A Response to the Defenders of the Filial Correction EMMETT O’REGAN In the ongoing debate surrounding the authority of Amoris laetitia, a key issue has arisen, centering around whether or not the Divine assistance of the Holy Spirit is offered towards the successors of St. Peter to protect them from erring in matters pertaining to faith and morals even in the non-definitive teachings of the ordinary Magisterium. Some of the defenders of Pope Francis in this issue, such as Stephen Walford, argue forcibly that such Divine assistance is indeed given in the non-definitive, non-infallible teachings of the ordinary Magisterium (I). The opponents of Pope Francis’ reforms argue that this position is a logical fallacy, since the exercise of papal infallibility is limited to the extraordinary Magisterium and the ordinary and Universal Magisterium. They argue that if the Roman Pontiff cannot err in matters of faith and morals in the non-definitive teachings of the ordinary Magisterium, this would mean that he is infallible even in this respect (II). Christopher Ferrara has mockingly referred to this idea as the “fallible infallible Magisterium” (III). Such an idea is obviously untrue, since the non-definitive teachings of the ordinary Magisterium are non-infallible in nature. In response, some conservatively minded Catholics have asserted that the claim to protection from error in faith and morals by way of Divine assistance falls into the category of ultramontanism, and the conclusion is then made that the pope actually can teach error in faith and morals by way of his ordinary Magisterium. Such a scenario is a very serious matter, since it would mean that the pope is in effect capable of binding the faithful to heresy in the ordinary Magisterium. In the following article, I hope to be able to demonstrate that the protection from error in faith and morals offered towards the ordinary Magisterium through the Divine assistance of the Holy Spirit does not stem from the gift of infallibility, but is instead an essential corollary of the dogma of the indefectibility of the Church. the rest of the long article is at: http://www.lastampa.it/2017/11/04/v...the-church-8zC1PmLEWxcP7xBt4jHRtN/pagina.html
Emmett really regrets submitting that DRAFT to la Stampa. In hindsight he says he wishes they hadn’t published it. He realizes the serious errors in it now. (Yes, I still talk to him on Facebook occasionally.)
Here is another interesting article from Steven O'Reilly, https://romalocutaest.com/2017/10/31/cardinal-muller-the-dubia-and-the-formal-correction/ . I have included the final 2 paragraphs below: Cardinal Muller, the Dubia and the Formal Correction Posted on October 31, 2017 by Steven O'Reilly ... What the Muller’s essay suggests to me is that the Cardinal – as he did with his suggestion for a ‘theological disputation’ over Amoris Laetitia between both sides (see here) – is attempting to create middle ground for a resolution of the debate over Amoris Laetitia. My take on Muller’s attempt is, he has not found that hoped for middle ground – he has instead wandered waist deep into muddled ground. Cardinal Muller believes (assumes?) Pope Francis really holds the positions described in his essay as the “orthodox sense” of Amoris Laetitia – that, or he hopes to give the Pope a face-saving means to back down (by suggesting the answers to him). However, nearly everyone has answered the five Dubia by now – theologians like Buttiglione, Cardinals like Schonborn, and even piano players like Walford, etc. All but Pope Francis. The Pope’s silence with regard to the Maltese and German communion guidelines for the divorced and remarried suggests, at least on its face, that Cardinal Muller’s assumptions are wrong – i.e., the Pope’s silence does not even appear consistent with Cardinal Muller’s position on AL 305 (n. 351). That is why the Church needs the Pope to clarify his position – not his surrogates and not Cardinal Muller. Whereas before I had thought Cardinal Muller might join in and support a Formal Correction, it now seems rather evident he will sit it out. Let us pray Pope Francis remembers the Lord’s words to Peter: “Simon, Simon, behold Satan hath desired to have you, that he may sift you like wheat. But I have prayed for thee, that thy faith fail not: and thou being once converted, confirm thy brethren” (Luke 22:31-32).
Ousted Fr. Weinandy Explains Why He Wrote the Pope Father Weinandy himself has explained his inspiration for writing the letter to the Holy Father. Published Wednesday in L'Espresso under Vaticanista Sandro Magister's column, the ousted Franciscan began: "Last May I was in Rome for an International Theological Commission meeting," going further to explain that he had been "praying about the present state of the Church and the anxieties I had about the present Pontificate." "I was beseeching Jesus and Mary, St. Peter and all of the saintly popes who are buried there to do something to rectify the confusion and turmoil within the Church today, a chaos and an uncertainty that I felt Pope Francis had himself caused," he continued. "I was also pondering whether or not I should write and publish something expressing my concerns and anxiety." He awoke the following night at 1:15 in the morning and went for a brief walk outside. On returning, he prayed to God: If you want me to write something, you have to give me a clear sign. This is what the sign must be. Tomorrow morning I am going to Saint Mary Major's to pray and then I am going to Saint John Lateran. After that I am coming back to Saint Peter's to have lunch with a seminary friend of mine. During that interval, I must meet someone that I know but have not seen in a very long time and would never expect to see in Rome at this time. That person cannot be from the United States, Canada or Great Britain. Moreover, that person has to say to me in the course of our conversation, "Keep up the good writing." He did all of the above the next day, and then met up with a seminarian friend for lunch. By that time he was no longer thinking about his prayer from the night before. However, towards the end of the meal an archbishop appeared between two parked cars right in front of our table (we were sitting outside). I had not seen him for over twenty years, long before he became an archbishop. We recognized one another immediately. What made his appearance even more unusual was that, because of his recent personal circumstances, I would never have expected to see him in Rome or anywhere else, other than in his own archdiocese. (He was from none of the above mentioned countries.) We spoke about his coming to Rome and caught up on what we were doing. I then introduced him to my seminarian friend. He said to my friend that we had met a long time ago and that he had, at that time, just finished reading my book on the immutability of God and the Incarnation. He told my friend that it was an excellent book, that it helped him sort out the issue, and that my friend should read the book. Then he turned to me and said: “Keep up the good writing.” In spite of his shock over the clear sign, he knew what he must do. "But there was no longer any doubt in my mind that Jesus wanted me to write something," Weinandy wrote. "I also think it significant that it was an Archbishop that Jesus used. I considered it an apostolic mandate." God bless Father Weinandy for discerning the will of God and following through with his answer to his prayer.
An ‘ecumenical Mass’ is impossible, says German cardinal by Nick Hallett posted Friday, 3 Nov 2017 Cardinal Rainer Woelki of Cologne (CNS photo/Sascha Steinbach, EPA) Cardinal Woelki said there is 'no basis' for such a service as Catholics and Protestants do not agree on the Eucharist Catholics and Protestants do not have enough in common to celebrate a so-called ‘ecumenical Mass’, a German cardinal has said. Cardinal Rainer Maria Woelki of Cologne said there is “no basis” for such a service because the denominations “do not agree on the central issues” around the Eucharist. The cardinal explained in the Kölner Express that for Catholics, the Eucharist is not just a common meal; it is the true Body and Blood of Christ in the transubstantiated gifts of bread and wine. Protestants do not have this understanding. The Real Presence is an “incontrovertible certainty” for Catholics, he said. As long as these differences exist, there can be no “common supper”. Cardinal Woelki’s comments come as rumours circulate in the media that Vatican officials are secretly preparing an ‘ecumenical Mass’ that Catholics and Protestants can jointly celebrate. The Australian reported that the Vatican has failed to deny the story, although one unnamed source said they did not believe the rumours, and added that it would be impossible for Catholics to receive Communion at such a service. The Mass would supposedly include prayers, readings from scripture and a common Communion, but the Catholic and Protestant clergy would pray the words of consecration silently, the paper said. In an article for First Things, Marco Tosatti raised the prospect of such a Mass. “Though never officially announced, a committee reporting directly to Pope Francis has been working on this liturgy for some time,” he claimed. “Certainly this topic is within the jurisdiction of the Congregation for Divine Worship, but Cardinal Sarah (the head of the Congregation) has not officially been informed of the committee’s existence. “According to good sources, Sarah’s secretary, Arthur Roche—who holds positions opposite to those of Benedict XVI and Sarah—is involved, as is Piero Marini".
Hi Fatima I notice you have not included the last paragraph which covers the controversy of the matter. I believe that Fr Weinandy did discern God’s will that he should write to the pope. But in the last paragraph he states that he had always intended to go public with it. (See the link to L’Espresso above.) Neither Jesus nor the Archbishop appear to have given him that mandate. I suspect Fr Weinandy knew that going public went against Church protocol. But he had already made up his mind to “publish and be damned.” I pray and hope this will not be his end after having given his life in service to the Church. I believe he is 90. I hope he lives to see and enjoy the wonderful changes in the life of the Church which are just around the corner. Sure, we have to go through a great deal of suffering before those changes come to pass and many will find that in the worst of Tribulation their spirit may be willing but the flesh weak - especially the flesh of a 90 year old. I hope and pray that Fr Weinandy, if he lives, survives the The Warning well for the sake of his life of consecrated service. In Akita Our Lady warned that the devil will especially go after consecrated souls. I do not know what motivated Fr Weinandy to go public but it is clear to me from his own witness that this ‘ mandate’ came from himself.
Did it ever occur to you he was visited by the God of surprises Joe? Why are you all of a sudden a legalist? You must read from your hero...https://www.catholicnewsagency.com/news/for-pope-francis-legalism-makes-christians-stupid-59175
No Mac - my dad, RIP, was the lawyer. And as you know, not all lawyers are legalists. Not the good ones anyway and as you know St Pope John Paul II conferred two knighthoods on dad for his service to The Faith. The God of surprises may have visited me with this understanding about Fr Weinandy’s letter. And The Holy Father is not my hero - he is my Pope. Respect. It’s too early and too dangerous in my return for jokes and jibes. And anyway you totally outclass me in that ring. God Bless.
"The God of surprises may have visited me with this understanding about Fr Weinandy’s letter. And The Holy Father is not my hero - he is my Pope. Respect. It’s too early and too dangerous in my return for jokes and jibes. And anyway you totally outclass me in that ring. God Bless." I needed someone in my corner and dad was as good as anyone.
Mac - since you ask - The homily today was excellent - all about the gospel to call no man father. Fathers were on my mind. Abba God and Dad and the likes of good fathers like yourself and Fr Weinandy. Only Our Father in heaven is perfect. Thank you for publishing the words of Pope Francis,
What a despicable, mean spirited post. To suggest that Jesus didn't know that the priest intended publishing the letter is the kind of nonsense I would expect from that odious Fr. Martin who claims that Jesus had to learn from the Canaanite woman that he wasn't sent just for the Jews. Implying that Jesus can't see the future appears to be a trend among Pope Francis idolators.
Hi Dolours I am sorry that you see fit to cast me in this light and to put me in the same category as Fr Martin. Of course Jesus can see the future but he does not stop us making mistakes. In fact his ability to foresee our mistakes makes Him suffer twice as much - in the foresight and in the execution of error. God bless you Joe
Well, I didn't put you in the same category as Fr. Martin. You did that yourself. You are suggesting that the man lied to God in prayer. How low do you intend to go with this? You're already down in the gutter.
Hi Dolours "I would expect from that odious Fr. Martin" these are your words, Dolours. Where did I suggest that Fr Weinandy lied to God. I simply repeated his statement "So giving it considerable thought and after writing many drafts, I decided to write Pope Francis directly about my concerns. However, I always intended to make it public ...."
Dear Dolours. "Of course Jesus can see the future but he does not stop us making mistakes. In fact his ability to foresee our mistakes makes Him suffer twice as much - in the foresight and in the execution of error." I fear your comments are making Jesus suffer. Forget about me. Think about Him. God bless you and guide you.