Perhaps because he lasted in his job about five minutes after going public with is letter: https://cruxnow.com/church-in-the-u...ope-theologian-resigns-consultant-us-bishops/ After critical letter to pope, theologian resigns as consultant to U.S. bishops
Perhaps it is my imagination, but I was praying last night about these things and life in general and I heard the words, 'I t will all be ending soon...it will be beginning soon'. This filled me with joy and peace. Of course I always knew God had some plan for dealing with things but it gave me great joy to be reminded of it. God is in charge, He really, really is. Thank you Jesus. Thank you Mary. I have felt looking at the world and the Church around me like someone who has been waiting in a Dentist's Surgery for many years. I am glad that this phase of God's Plan draws to a close. Jeremiah 29:11 11 For I know the plans I have for you,” declares the Lord, “plans to prosper you and not to harm you, plans to give you hope and a future.
He did his duty. He told it straight. It appears that he resigned in the same manner as some people are 'suicided'.
What a powerful letter - I wonder if the Pope actually read it? Any chance he might be open to 'dialogue' with Fr Thomas?
This is certainly an interesting development. I don't see a problem with Fr Weinandy making his views known to the Pope. But I do see a big problem in his decision to go public with it. His excuse for doing that is: As to why he chose to go public, Weinandy said “the letter expresses the concerns of many more people than just me, ordinary people who’ve come to me with their questions and apprehensions,” and “I wanted them to know that I listened.” Hmm. I think a personal letter to those people telling them he had written to the Pope would have been more than sufficient!
No doubt his decision to resign was purely an act of his own free will, much like Pope Benedict's resignation. It was indeed a very powerful letter. The priest first took his problem to God, got his answer and proceeded to write a very honest, straightforward letter. The priest did his sacred duty. Sadly, we can't say the same for the Pope. I don't doubt for a second that the Pope read the letter and, with his customary bad manners, had an underling send a curt acknowledgement. I suppose the acknowledgement is an improvement unless it was advance notice of the priest's imminent "resignation". I suppose the priest was fortunate the response didn't come via the atheist journalist or some homosexual Jesuit who doesn't believe that sodomy is a sin.
It was Pope Francis himself who called for openness and frankness. I cannot recall the Italian word he used, but I'm sure there are others here who can supply it. Unfortunately, the definition of open and plain speaking seems to apply only to those who speak heresy or obscenity. The only reason for supporting the silencing of anyone is to wish to suppress their agenda. What part(s) of Father Weinandy's letter do you wish to see suppressed and for what reason? Would you also wish to see suppressed this Father James Martin and his 'otherly ordered' heresy and if you are not disturbed by the continued tolerance of it, perhaps you might explain why it is acceptable to display disobedience to the commands of God but not to even question those of the pope?
I remember a Facebook page with the name of Father Amorth who once shared Francisco's photo with the communist cross of Evo Morales, if Father Amorth was the owner of this page, then he was disappointed with Pope Francis
That is precisely why I have no problem with Fr Weinandy sending his letter to the Pope! Who is supporting the silencing of anyone? I consider that Fr. Weinandy writing his letter to the Pope is fine. There was no need to make it public. Making it public raises a question on Fr Weinandy's motivation but he was perfectly free to make it public. That was his decision.
In these grave times of confusion within the church, it is essential to have those with deep knowledge and theology of the faith speak to the confusion coming out of the Vatican. If it is Pope Francis causing this confusion then it is necessary to bring light to it. If Francis stands on sound footing in his many words and writings, then let him do so while defending it with sacred scripture and sacred tradition. Let him not hide behind his title, as if he is above reproach from his fellow clergymen who are obviously gravely concerned that the the very truths of the the faith are under assault. Pope Francis has not replied to the Dubia and other words he has spoken, because he knows he can't without digging himself deeper into confusion. Yet it is he that chooses this path. He has been using his office to hide behind teachings contrary to what has been handed on.
Exactly. See below: This morning we told you the story of Fr. Thomas Weinandy, a Capuchin friar who, after receiving what he believed was a sign from God, wrote a letter to Pope Francis — with obvious filial respect and love — in the hopes of bringing to his attention some of the more damaging effects of his papacy. Father Weinandy is a current member of the Vatican’s International Theological Commission, as well as the former chief of staff for the US Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) Committee on Doctrine. Apparently, he was still serving in the capacity of consultant to the USCCB, because today, after the publication of his letter, he was asked to resign. According to Carl E. Olson, Editor of Catholic World Report, Fr. Weinandy told him this morning that since the letter’s publication, he had “received many positive notes from theologians, priests, and lay people.” Nevertheless, “the USCCB asked him to resign from his current position as a consultant to the bishops,” and Fr. Weinandy has complied. As Olson notes, “In making such a request, the USCCB, it would appear, reinforces Fr. Weinandy’s very point about fearfulness and lack of transparency” as made in his letter. One diocesan priest who spoke with 1P5 on condition of anonymity said that he was certain Fr. Weinandy’s letter “drew consternation from several US Cardinals and Bishops”, particularly where the letter addressed how “faithful Catholics can only be disconcerted” by the pope’s choice of some bishops, “men who seem not merely open to those who hold views counter to Christian belief but who support and even defend them,” causing scandal to the faithful and weakening the sensus fidei. “There is no way” the priest told me, “that this remark didn’t directly sting Cardinal Cupich, Cardinal Tobin, Cardinal Ferrell, and Bishop McElroy in particular, as they have been busy supporting Father James Martin, S.J., and others like him. I would be very surprised if they were not directly behind Fr. Thomas Weinandy’s forced resignation.” More here: https://onepeterfive.com/dialogue-priest-who-wrote-letter-to-pope-asked-to-resign-from-usccb/
It´s all out in the open now, folks. That´s the good thing about the present crisis. Jesus Christ holding a compass? Conference on the rapprochement between the Church and Freemasonry (November 12 in Syracuse [Sicily – Ed.] with grand masters, a prelate, and the Bishop of Noto, whose logo depicted a disturbed Christ holding a compass, the symbol of Freemasonry. Letter to Tosatti: “I Fear We Are in the End Times” Marco Tosatti October 30, 2017 254 Comments 827 Shares transubstantiation is not a dogma,” then the surprising and disturbing public correction of Cardinal Sarah made by the Pope, and finally the conference on the rapprochement between the Church and Freemasonry (November 12 in Syracuse [Sicily – Ed.] with grand masters, a prelate, and the Bishop of Noto, whose logo depicted a disturbed Christ holding a compass, the symbol of Freemasonry. The poster for the upcoming conference of “rapproachement” between the Church & Freemasonry in Sicily. The title reads, “The Church and Freemasonry: So Close and Yet So Far” Certainly after the opinions expressed by Cardinal [Gianfranco] Ravasi [President of the Pontifical Council for Culture] about the need for a rapprochement with our “Masonic brothers” we shouldn’t be surprised, but Ravasi is Ravasi, when he is not speaking Aramaic and Ancient Greek, and it’s always possible that he said something without understanding what he really meant…. But I am now frightened above all by the rapid sequence of events, as if we were drawing close to a deadline (That of the vision of Leo XIII? Of the prophecies of La Salette? Of Saint Brigid? Of Our Lady of Akita? Of St. Vincent Ferrer?) What then should we expect will be the next move? Should we imagine that the next “rapprochement” will be with the tempting serpent of the book of Genesis to whom we ought to issue an apology, “justifying” his “good intentions” of bringing knowledge to Adam and Eve? Should we consequently reprove St. Michael the Archangel for having kicked him out of Paradise? Should we perhaps ask Mary Most Holy to apologize for having struck his head? Or even ask Jesus Himself to make an apology, for not having been open during the temptation in the desert to having a multicultural and pluralistic dialogue with Satan which would have been advantageous to them both? Dear Tosatti, you won’t believe it, but I am beginning to really be afraid. I have begun to pray once again the prayer of exorcism to St. Michael the Archangel written by Pope Leo XIII (recited at the end of Holy Mass until 1964 when it was unexplainably “deleted”). I ask myself if I will have the strength to take action without any assistance from my Holy Roman Catholic Apostolic Church, sensing rather that it sets itself daily more and more against the Gospels and the Truth that it taught me. The Cardinals and Bishops who still believe in the Truth of Christ had better do something quickly! I fear we are in the End Times, dear Tosatti. I am a “Big Shot” but terrified… Editor’s note: The above letter was originally published at Stilum Curae, the blog of Vatican-watcher Marco Tosatti, on October 29, 2017, and has been translated here for our readers with permission. It is the first we have heard of “the conference on the rapprochement between the Church and Freemasonry” coming up in November. Though we have reported to you in the past on “the opinions expressed by Cardinal [Gianfranco] Ravasi [President of the Pontifical Council for Culture] about the need for a rapprochement with our ‘Masonic brothers'”, we can appreciate the letter writer’s sarcasm when he says, “Ravasi is Ravasi, when he is not speaking Aramaic and Ancient Greek, and it’s always possible that he said something without understanding what he really meant….” In the context of the news of this upcoming “conference of rapprochement”, it seems opportune here to recall the relevant condemnation of Fremasonry made by Leo XIII in his encyclical letter Humanum Genus, published on April 20, 1884: 2.)… At this period, however, the partisans of evil seems to be combining together, and to be struggling with united vehemence, led on or assisted by that strongly organized and widespread association called the Freemasons. No longer making any secret of their purposes, they are now boldly rising up against God Himself. They are planning the destruction of holy Church publicly and openly, and this with the set purpose of utterly despoiling the nations of Christendom, if it were possible, of the blessings obtained for us through Jesus Christ our Saviour. Lamenting these evils, We are constrained by the charity which urges Our heart to cry out often to God: “For lo, Thy enemies have made a noise; and they that hate Thee have lifted up the head. They have taken a malicious counsel against Thy people, and they have consulted against Thy saints. They have said, ‘come, and let us destroy them, so that they be not a nation.'(2) 3.) At so urgent a crisis, when so fierce and sopressing an onslaught is made upon the Christian name, it is Our office to point out the danger, to mark who are the adversaries, and to the best of Our power to make head against their plans and devices, that those may not perish whose salvation is committed to Us, and that the kingdom of Jesus Christ entrusted to Our charge may not stand and remain whole, but may be enlarged by an ever-increasing growth throughout the world. https://onepeterfive.com/letter-to-tosatti-i-fear-we-are-in-the-end-times/
"the declarations by a theologian favored by the Pope (Andrea Grillo) who explains (without any correction by the Holy See) that “transubstantiation is not a dogma,” Italian Liturgist Alleged to be Working on Ecumenical Mass: “Transubstantiation is Not a Dogma” Steve Skojec October 28, 2017 401 Comments 2.2k Shares column at First Things, Italian journalist and veteran Vatican-watcher Marco Tosatti gave voice to what had previously been little more than a whispered rumor: that a group was at work, with Vatican knowledge and support, on a kind of interfaith liturgy: [T]here is the matter of the “Ecumenical Mass,” a liturgy designed to unite Catholics and Protestants around the Holy Table. Though never officially announced, a committee reporting directly to Pope Francis has been working on this liturgy for some time. Certainly this topic is within the jurisdiction of the Congregation for Divine Worship, but Cardinal Sarah has not officially been informed of the committee’s existence. According to good sources, Sarah’s secretary, Arthur Roche—who holds positions opposite to those of Benedict XVI and Sarah—is involved, as is Piero Marini, the right-hand man of Monsignor Bugnini, author of such noted works as La Chiesa in Iran and Novus Ordo Missae. Today, at his blog, Stilum Curae, Marco provides a bit more information on this story: I cannot help recalling a comment sent to me by a friend, even though it was made several months ago. It was made by a highly regarded unrestrained lay liturgist, Andrea Grillo, who is, according to what they tell me, involved in the work to create an ecumenical Mass. The comment is: “Transubstantiation is not a dogma, and as an explanation [of the Eucharist] it has its limits. For example, it contradicts metaphysics.” [emphasis added] I would like to understand then: have all those people who during the last two millennia have thought that in the host and in the wine [sic] there was truly the substance of the Body and Blood of Jesus – and those who still believe this now – have they been taken for a ride [by the Church]? Or, in a more benign hypothesis, were they victims of a false belief (to say nothing of Eucharistic miracles)? We are waiting with impatience to see where the work on the new ecumenical Mass will go, in order to go and put ourselves in line [for communion] at the closest Orthodox Church. Grillo’s comments about Transubstantiation appeared on his Facebook page: Continue here: https://onepeterfive.com/italian-li...nical-mass-transubstantiation-is-not-a-dogma/
It is happening quickly now. Pope Leo said "it is Our office to point out the danger" and following after him Pope St. Pius X also condemned Freemasonry. Now we see why.
Dean, Thank you for posting this. This is amazing, Capuchin Father Thomas Weinandy asked for a clear sign from God to write this letter to Pope Francis here and he received the sign, this is a miracle. https://cruxnow.com/vatican/2017/11/01/ex-bishops-doctrine-chief-says-darkness-coming-light-francis/ It appears that he dated his letter to Pope Francis July 31st, the Feast Day of St. Ignatius of Loyola, for two reasons: 1. Saint Ignatius of Loyola is the founder of the Pope’s Jesuit order. 2. Saint Ignatius of Loyola authored, Spiritual Exercises. The "presupposition" contained within this book is as follows, In order that both he who is giving the Spiritual Exercises, and he who is receiving them, may more help and benefit themselves, let it be presupposed that every good Christian is to be more ready to save his neighbor's proposition than to condemn it. If he cannot save it, let him inquire how he means it; and if he means it badly, let him correct him with charity. If that is not enough, let him seek all the suitable means to bring him to mean it well, and save himself. http://www.sacred-texts.com/chr/seil/seil06.htm Cardinal Daniel DiNardo pointed out the first piece of the Presupposition but he failed to mention what follows after the first sentence which I highlighted above. I think that Father Weinandy and the "Dubia Cardinals" have followed Saint Ignatius of Loyola's "presupposition" to his Spiritual Exercises well, imho. https://cruxnow.com/church-in-the-u...ope-theologian-resigns-consultant-us-bishops/ I see a lot of similarities between President Obama and Pope Francis, neither really want to clearly point out evil. They both give ambiguous direction which in turn is misinterpreted and can lead to destruction. For America, this could mean the destruction of our Constitution and for the Church, this could mean the destruction of our Doctrine . Basically, they are both sowing the seeds of confusion. Jack Welch had a quote in this regard, "Willingness to change is a strength, even if it means plunging part of the company into total confusion for a while." but Jack Welch was the CEO of GE. If America's Constitution changes, it is no longer America and if the Church's Doctrine changes, it is no longer the Church. Pat Buchanan warned about this back in 2013, 'There is a small problem with neutrality. As Trotsky observed, “You may not be interested in war, but war is interested in you.” For the church to absent itself from the culture war is to not to end that war, but to lose it.' http://www.rightwingwatch.org/post/buchanan-pope-francis-sowing-seeds-of-confusion/ . A final quote, from Father Weinandy's letter to Pope Francis, "Moreover, only where there is truth can there be authentic love, for truth is the light that sets women and men free from the blindness of sin, a darkness that kills the life of the soul. " Well done Father Weinandy and thank you!
When I noticed Padriag's Post and the painting the words "broad sunlit uplands" came to mind. These words from a speech made by W. Churchill after the fall of France in 1940. I found that speech and figured that Ol' Winston would probably not mind if I paraphrased it for "These-days"? So I did: With Signs of Biblical proportion upon us and the "clash of arms" sounding all around a great battle is, surly, about to begin. Upon this battle depends the survival of Christian civilization. Upon it depends our own life, and the long continuity of our institutions and our Church. The whole fury and might of the enemy must very soon be turned on us. Satan knows that he will have to break us in our homes, schools and communities or lose the war. If we can stand up to him, all of Humanity may be freed and the life of the world may move forward into broad, sunlit uplands. But if we fail, then the whole world, including all that we have known and cared for, will sink into the abyss of a new dark age made more sinister, and perhaps more protracted, by the lights of perverted science. Let us therefore brace ourselves to our duties, and so bear ourselves, that as we step into Eternity, men will still say, This was their finest hour. GOD SAVE ALL HERE!!
Thanks, Carol55 That was indeed a huge miraculous sign from God to go ahead with the letter Plus Fr W has a great prayer life He is for real