I am so thankful to God that he has allowed me to see this purging of the chaff. I posted an article on a new thread that 84% of Catholics do not believe in hell, the devil or sin!!! 4 our of 5 Catholics...
This is true DeGaulle. Pope Francis has spoken enough against doctrines of the faith that it makes it easier to speak to others about agenda to change the face of the Church and its teachings.
For my part, I know what the Church teaching are in the area of doctrine (faith and morals) and I know that they can never change. This is clear in our Catholic faith, but unfortunately we are living in a time where 85% of Catholics don't even know their faith (including most clergy, so it seems). For those that know their faith, they should no longer be in the dark as to Pope Francis' agenda, which is so opposed to our Catholic faith that he has to try and hide it with ambiguity. I know how this works, as my last 5 pastors have used the same tactic for 3 decades.
Horrible but not shocking. They have been fed pablum for so long they cannot digest meat. They don't even realize what has been taken from them. They Re pleased to be cutting edge "spiritual" but not religious. I see this among acquaintances here. They would probably stare at you like you had two heads if you dared to suggest that the road to hell is broad and easy to find and many are heading there. The road that leads to life is narrow and hard and few are Finding it. Just not in their lexicon I guess.
Still, how much blame is to be laid at their door when they have received no proper instruction and have been subjected to a barrage of antiChristian propaganda all their lives, not to mention hearing very senior princes of the Church pontificating about all being saved?
Power tends to corrupt. A good many politicians have become negligent and greedy seeking to serve themselves rather than those who elected them. They have become arrogant and haughty while the ordinary people suffer. Some entrusted to be Shepherds of God’s people have become ravening wolves caring little for the flock. Instead living comfortably in luxury failing in their sworn duty to God and man. We can all however fall short, very short in what we are called to do by God. Some admittedly more than others. But none of us are entirely innocent and blameless sadly. God loves His people. But how much longer will He let this situation continue? I think very shortly we will all see in dramatic fashion the outcome of this. God longs for us all to come back to Him as the loving Father He is. He is slow to anger and would rather not have to use the rod. But He WILL use it, probably by His permissive will rather than directly in order to call mankind to its senses. God’s aim is our eternal welfare ultimately not our temporal. His chief aim is to see us in heaven with Him. How many times did God permit disaster to befall Israel when they strayed from Him? He only permits this for our good. We are VERY close now. Very. May God help us all. Praised be Jesus and Mary.
The ones I know believe salvation is in social justice only. Feeding the poor, going to Mexico giving them water there and once again when they sneak across the border. They believe in the liberation theology, which Pope Francis promoted while in Argentina. They despise commandments. It is pure humanism. This is what they believe in and work towards. God to them is way abstract. Every homily is a story on things like Michael Angelo, or some other social justice figure that they look up to. The only Pope I ever him them quote is Francis.
Our Lord condensed The Law to two commandments. The first, and primary, one is that we love God with everything we've got. The second is that we love our neighbour as ourselves. This seems to have changed to: The first, that we love ourselves with everything we've got. The second, that we abstractly love some vaguely oppressed people at no personal cost to our own interests. They seem to have lost any awareness of personal death.
What many if not most of the baptized, including clergy, forget is the part of the bible that read's, "IF YOU LOVE ME KEEP MY COMMANDMENTS". For the progressives/liberals/social justice minded baptized they only want a God of charity for the poor. I am convinced they like to have the poor as it is their only cover for feeling good about themselves. Commandments are RIGID and they want flexibility to do what they want and give lip service to the poor. There is a reason Jesus said, "the poor you will always have" and "seek first the kingdom of heaven".
The gospel today Jesus was asked by the Pharisees what was the greatest commandment - love of God came first and love of neighbour second. Two heads of a coin. You cannot have one without the other.
Yet those two command's need great clarification today. Some would say the corporal works of mercy are all that is needed to love neighbor. A few others would say, the spiritual works of mercy is a higher order of love for thy neighbor. But what do the progressives think loving God is all about? It is clear to me that love of God is not worship and practicing his commandments, but social justice/humanism. I would like to be in an area where I had a traditional pastor, but I am not and have not for over 3 decades. But, because I live in progressive USA, where humanism is the greatest virtue, I have allot of experience knowing how these minds think. I figured it out one day and I have sat through at least 1,500 social justice homilies , but through the grace of God I am still Catholic in practice, though I can't say as much for 1/2 my children .
Cardinal Sarah spoke in his recent book, 'God or Nothing' of his upbringing in Guinea. It was undeniably what he described as one of poverty, but he had no complaints about it. He and his community had sufficient water, food and shelter. They also had a wonderful social interaction between almost everyone in the village and were all quite contented. The Cardinal considered this poverty a good rather than an evil, having enough of the basics to get by, but not enough to distract or create anxiety. What he considered an evil was utter destitution, which he described as not having the basics of clean water, sufficient food and adequate shelter. We must do our utmost to ensure that as few as possible are denied these necessities, but is it likely that beyond that we enter the politics of envy and the abandonment of personal responsibility? It seems that absolute destitution is unlikely in a country as wealthy as the United States unless achieved by some personal character flaws, such as extreme sloth, irresponsible drug use, drinking, gambling and so forth. These latter are more likely to be aided by a concentration of the Spiritual Works of Mercy. I sympathise with your worries about your children, the same situation being the main focus of my own prayers. We just have to remember that God loves our children much more than even we do and to keep on keeping on with the prayers.
Amen. Keep on keeping on with the prayers for our children. For their conversion, and/or for their perseverance in grace.
It is a paradox that the morecomfort we have the harder it is to make room for God. Like Jesus’ words about the rich man entering heaven. By history’sstandards we ofthe west are wealthy indeed. And look how cluttered our souls become. Our children absorb the culture of “stuff” even when we try to limit it. “Oh if I can just have this I will be happy...”. Surely God will deal mercifully with these poor lost young people. I pray every moment of every day for my own children and grandchildren. And I will join with your prayers as well.
Communion to the remarried, Müller: “There can be mitigating factors in guilt” An excerpt from the introductory essay to Rocco Buttiglione’s book “Risposte amichevoli ai critici di Amoris laetitiaˮ “It is possible that the tension between the objective status of the “second” marriage and subjective guilt could open the way” to the sacraments “through a pastoral discernment in an internal forum” Pubblicato il 30/10/2017 GERHARD CARD. MÜLLER VATICAN CITY With the apostolic exhortation Amoris Laetitia, Pope Francis, relying on the two Synods of Bishops on the family of 2014 and 2015, attempted to give both a theological and pastoral response of the Church to the challenges of our time. In this way, he wanted to offer his maternal support in order to overcome the crisis of marriage and family in the light of the Gospel of Christ. Generally speaking, this comprehensive document of nine chapters and 325 articles has been welcomed in a positive way. It is to be hoped that many newlyweds and all young couples, who prepare for the holy sacrament of marriage, will allow themselves to be introduced into its broad spirit, deep doctrinal considerations and spiritual references. The success of marriage and the family paves the way for the future of the Church of God and human society. What is regrettable, is the bitter controversy that has developed on chapter 8, entitled “Accompanying, discerning and integrating weakness” (art. 291/312). The question of whether the “divorced and civilly remarried” - a problematic connotation from the dogmatic and canonical point of view - can have access to communion, even though a valid sacramental marriage still exists, in some particularly qualified cases or even generally, has been falsely elevated to the rank of decisive question of Catholicism and of measure of ideological comparison in order to decide whether one is conservative or liberal, favorable or against the Pope. The Pope instead believes that, more important than the pastoral care of failures, is the pastoral effort to strengthen marriages and thus to prevent their breakdown. (AL 307). From the point of view of the new evangelization, then, it seems that the effort to ensure that all baptized people participate, on Sundays and feasts of precept, in the celebration of the Eucharist is still much more important than the problem of the possibility of receiving communion in a legitimate and valid way from a limited group of Catholics with an uncertain marital situation. Instead of defining one’s own Catholic faith through belonging to an ideological field, the problem is actually that of fidelity to the revealed word of God, which is handed down in the confession of the Church. Instead, polarizing theses are confronted with each other in a way that threatens the unity of the Church. While on the one hand the correctness of the Pope’s faith, who is the supreme master of Christianity, is questioned, on the other hand, others seize the opportunity to boast about the Pope’s consent to a radical paradigm shift in the moral and sacramental theology that they desire. We are witnessing a paradoxical reversal of the fronts. The theologians who boast of being liberal-progressives who previously, for example on the occasion of the encyclical Humanae Vitae, radically questioned the Magisterium of the Pope, now raise any of his phrases, which they like, almost to the rank of a dogma. Other theologians, who feel obliged to adhere strictly to the Magisterium, now examine a document of the Magisterium according to the rules of the academic method, as if it were their student’s thesis. continued....
continued.... […] In the midst of these schismatic temptations and this dogmatic confusion which is very dangerous for the unity of the Church, which is founded on the truth of Revelation, Rocco Buttiglione, as an authentic Catholic of proven competence in the field of moral theology, offers, with the articles and essays collected in this volume, a clear and convincing answer. This is not about Amoris Laetitia’soverall reception, but only about the interpretation of some controversial passages in chapter 8. On the basis of the classical criteria of Catholic theology, he offers a reasoned and not controversial answer to the cardinals’ five dubia. He shows that the heavy reproach of Josef Seifert, Buttiglione’s friend and companion of many years of struggles, to the Pope, who says that the Pope does not present correctly the theses of the right doctrine or that he even passes them under silence, does not correspond to the reality of the facts. Seifert’s thesis is similar to the “correctio filialis” text signed by 62 Catholics (24-09-2017). In this difficult situation of the Church, I gladly accepted Professor Buttiglione’s invitation to write an introduction to this book. I hope to contribute in this way to restoring peace in the Church. In fact, we must all be jointly committed to supporting the understanding of the sacrament of marriage and to offering theological and spiritual help so that marriage and family can be lived “in the joy of love” even in an unfavorable ideological climate. Buttiglione’s thesis makes two fundamental statements, to which I agree with full conviction: 1- The dogmatic doctrines and pastoral exhortations of chapter 8 of Amoris Laetitia can and must be understood in the orthodox sense. 2- Amoris Laetitia does not imply any magisterial shift towards an ethics of the situation and therefore there is no contradiction with the encyclical Veritatis Splendor of Pope John Paul II. We refer here to the theory that subjective conscience could, in consideration of its interests and its particular situations, put itself in place of the objective norm of the natural moral law and of the truths of supernatural revelation (in particular that on the objective effectiveness of the sacraments). In this way, the doctrine of the existence of an intrinsice malum and objectively bad behavior would become obsolete. The doctrine of Veritatis splendor remains valid (art. 56;79) also with respect to Amoris Laetitia (art. 303) for which there are absolute moral norms to which there is no exception (cf. dubium n. 3;5 of the cardinals). […] It is evident that Amoris laetitia (art. 300-305) does not teach and does not propose to believe in a binding way that the Christian in a condition of a present and habitual mortal sin can receive absolution and communion without repentance for their sins and without formulating the intention of not sinning any more, in contrast with what Familiaris consortio (art. 84), Reconciliatio et poenitentia (art. 34) and Sacramentum caritatis (Art. 29) (cf. dubium n. 1 of the cardinals) say. […] The formal element of sin is the departure from God and his holy will, but there are different levels of gravity depending on the type of sin. Spirit’s sins can be more serious than flesh’s sins. Spiritual pride and avarice introduce into religious and moral life a more profound disorder than impurity resulting from human weakness. The apostasy of faith, the denial of the divinity of Christ weighs more than theft and adultery; adultery among married people weighs more than among the unmarried and, the adultery of the faithful, who know God’s will, weighs more than that of the unbelievers (cf. Thomas Aquinas, th. S. I-II q. 73; II-II q). Moreover, for the imputabilty of guilt in God’s judgment, one must consider subjective factors such as full knowledge and deliberate consent in the serious lack of respect for God’s commandments, which has as a consequence the loss of sanctifying grace and of the ability of faith to become effective in charity (cf. Thomas Aquinas S. th. II-II, q. 10 a. 3 ad 3). This does not mean, however, that now Amoris laetitia art. 302 supports, in contrast to Veritatis splendor 81, that, due to mitigating circumstances, an objectively bad act can become subjectively good (it is dubium n. 4 of the cardinals). The action in itself bad (the sexual relationship with a partner who is not the legitimate spouse) does not become subjectively good due to circumstances. In the assessment of guilt, however, there may be mitigating circumstances and the ancillary elements of an irregular cohabitation similar to marriage can also be presented before God in their ethical value in the overall assessment of judgment (for example, the care for children in common, which is a duty deriving from natural law). An accurate analysis shows that the Pope in Amoris laetitia has not proposed any doctrine to be believed in a binding way that is in open or implicit contradiction to the clear doctrine of the Sacred Scripture and to the dogmas defined by the Church on the sacraments of marriage, penance and Eucharist. On the contrary, the doctrine of the faith on the internal and external indissolubility of sacramental marriage is confirmed with respect to all the other forms that “radically contradict it”(AL 292) and this doctrine is put at the basis of the questions concerning the pastoral attitude to be held with persons in relationships similar to marriage. Even when some constitutive elements of marriage are found in cohabitations that resemble marriage, however, the sinful transgression against other constitutive elements of marriage and against marriage as a whole, is not good. Contradiction with goodness can never become part of it, or the beginning of a journey towards the fulfillment of God’s holy and sanctifying will. Nowhere is it said that a baptized in a condition of mortal sin is allowed to receive Holy Communion and thus receives in fact its effect as a Communion of spiritual life with Christ. The sinner consciously and voluntarily opposes to the love for God the latch (obex) of grave sin. Even when it is said “that no one can be condemned forever” this must be understood from the point of view of care, that never surrenders, for the eternal salvation of sinner rather than as a categorical denial of the possibility of an eternal condemnation which, however, presupposes voluntary obstinacy in sin. There are sins in the categories of the Church that exclude themselves from the Kingdom of God (1 Cor. 6,9-11) but only until the sinner opposes their forgiveness and rejects the grace of repentance and conversion. The Church, however, in her maternal concern, does not renounce any person who is a pilgrim on this earth and leaves the final judgment to God, the only who knows the thoughts of hearts. The Church’s task is preaching of conversion and faith and the sacramental mediation of grace that justifies, sanctifies and heals. For God says, “I do not enjoy the death of the wicked, but that the wicked desist from their conduct and live” (Ez. 33:11). continued....