The Vatican Has Fallen

Discussion in 'Church Critique' started by padraig, Dec 31, 2016.

  1. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    http://magister.blogautore.espresso...iss-slap-at-cardinal-sarah-behind-the-scenes/

    Francis's Slap At Cardinal Sarah. Behind the Scenes
    26 ott
    [​IMG]

    > Italiano
    > English
    > Español
    > Français

    > All the articles of Settimo Cielo in English

    *

    The letter with which Francis recently contradicted and humiliated Cardinal Robert Sarah, prefect of the congregation for divine worship, is the latest proof of how this pope exercises his magisterium.

    When Francis wants to introduce innovations, he never does so in clear and distinct words. He prefers to open discussions, to set “processes” in motion, within which the innovations are gradually affirmed.

    The most glaring example is “Amoris Laetitia,” for which contrasting interpretations and applications are in fact given, with entire episcopates lining up on one or the other side.

    And when he is asked for clarification, he refuses. As in the case of the five “dubia” submitted to him by four cardinals, not deemed worthy of so much as a reply.

    But when a cardinal like Sarah, an authority by role and responsibilities, weighs in to give a papal motu proprio on the liturgy the only interpretation he sees as correct and therefore to be implemented by the congregation of which he is prefect, Francis does not remain silent but reacts with harshness, in defense of those passages of the motu prorio - which in effect are anything but clear - that contain the liberalizations dear to him.

    This is just what has happened in recent days.

    Let’s recapitulate. On September 9 Francis publishes the motu proprio “Magnum Principium” concerning the adaptations and translations into contemporary languages of the liturgical texts of the Latin Church.

    In defining the role of the congregation for divine worship concerning the adaptations and translations of the liturgical texts prepared by the national episcopal conferences and submitted for the approval of the Holy See, the motu proprio distinguishes between “recognitio” and “confirmatio,” between review and confirmation.

    But the distinction is by no means explained with clarity. And in fact, two sides took shape immediately among the experts.

    There are those who maintain that the “recognitio,” meaning the advance review by Rome, concerns only the adaptations, while for the translations the Holy See need give simply a “confirmatio,” its approval.

    And there are those who instead maintain that on the translations as well Rome must carry out a careful review, before approving them.

    In effect, this is what was done before and it is why various new translations of the missals have had a troubled life - like those of the United States, Great Britain, and Ireland - or are still waiting for approval from Rome: like those of France, Italy, and Germany.

    In particular, the new translation of the missal in German was an object of criticism by Benedict XVI himself, who in 2012 wrote a letter to his fellow countrymen bishops to convince them to translate with more fidelity the words of Jesus at the last supper, at the moment of consecration:

    > Vatican Diary / "For many" or "for all"? The right answer is the first

    Getting back to the motu proprio “Magnum Principium,” it must be noted that when this was drafted it was kept in the dark from Cardinal Sarah, prefect of a dicastery whose middle management has long been rowing against him.

    On September 30, Sarah wrote to Pope Francis a letter of thanks accompanied by a detailed “Commentaire”, aimed at a correct interpretation and application of the motu proprio, one that was rather restrictive concerning its multi-purpose formulations.

    In Sarah’s judgment, “recognitio” and “confirmatio” are in reality “synonymous” or in any case “interchangeable at the level of responsibility of the Holy See,” whose task of reviewing translations before approving them remains intact.

    A couple of weeks later the cardinal’s “Commentaire” appeared on various websites, leading to the conclusion - given the position of the author of the “Commentaire” - that in Rome the congregation for divine worship would act according to its guidelines.

    And this greatly irritated Pope Francis, who on October 15 signed a letter harshly repudiating Cardinal Sarah.

    A letter in which the pope assigns the national episcopal conferences the liberty and authority to decide on translations themselves, on the sole condition of the final “confirmatio” from the Vatican congregation.

    And in any case - the pope writes - without any “spirit of ‘imposition’ on the episcopal conferences of a given translation made by the dicastery” in Rome, even for “significant” liturgical texts like the “sacramental formulas, the Credo, the Pater noster.”

    The conclusion of the pope’s letter to the cardinal is barbed with venom:

    “Considering that the ‘Commentaire’ in question has been published on a number of websites, and erroneously attributed to your person, I graciously ask you to see to it that this response of mine be released on the same sites as well as being sent to all the Episcopal Conferences, to the Members and Advisors of this Dicastery.”

    There is an abyss between this letter from Francis and the warm words of esteem expressed in writing to Cardinal Sarah a few months ago by “pope emeritus” Benedict XVI. Who said he was sure that with Sarah “the liturgy is in good hands,” and therefore “we should be grateful to Pope Francis for appointing such a spiritual teacher as head of the congregation that is responsible for the celebration of the liturgy in the Church.”

    Needless to say, the object of the clash between Francis and Cardinal Sarah is not a marginal one, but touches the foundations of the Church’s life, according to the ancient maxim: “Lex orandi, lex credendi.”

    Because the “process” that Francis wants to set in motion is precisely that of changing, through a devolution of liturgical adaptations and translations to the national Churches, the overall structure of the Catholic Church, turning it into a federation of national Churches endowed with extensive autonomy, “including genuine doctrinal authority.”

    These last words come from “Evangelii Gaudium,” the agenda-setting text of Francis’s pontificate.

    These words too were enigmatic when they were published in 2013. But now a bit less so.

    (English translation by Matthew Sherry, Ballwin, Missouri, U.S.A.)
     
    DeGaulle and sunburst like this.
  2. Byron

    Byron Powers

    Which is why Pope Francis of all people should never have spoken about communism in that way. He knows better. Peace comes to me in believing Pope Francis is the Pope who witnesses the Warning. He is a weak and conflictive Pope, who is being used by God. When the seers prophesied that the entire world would be under communism they weren't kidding.
     
    sunburst, gracia and padraig like this.
  3. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

    He shouldn't be giving interviews to atheists. There's lots he shouldn't be doing but he doesn't care. Sometimes I wonder whether God is listening to our prayers. We got a sneaky, deceitful politician at the very time we needed an honest shepherd.
     
    padraig and sterph like this.
  4. Byron

    Byron Powers

    Things must get worse...
     
  5. DeGaulle

    DeGaulle Powers

    We may be getting the shepherd we deserve. God is providing no easy answers, because there aren't any. The answer Our Lord gave us when He walked the earth was The Cross. The formula hasn't changed.
     
  6. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

    Y'know, I have a bit of a cheek moaning about Pope Francis. At the time of the Conclave, he was the kind of Pope I prayed for. God is surely teaching me to be careful what I pray for. Lesson learned. My apologies to God and to everyone suffering through this pontificate.
     
  7. CrewDog

    CrewDog Archangels

    YUP!! The Vatican inviting Guv Moonbeam to expound on Climate Change in Rome is "The Cherry on Top of the Sundae"!! Did we really need any more SIGNS? Maybe some folks do 'cause The Lord keeps sending them. One day the period of SIGNS will end. The Lord is running this Op so I don't worry about what be happening in Rome.
    My take on all this is my usual! Get Yourself, Family, Friends, Neighborhood, Parish and Community PREPARED as best you can .... using your God Given Faith, Skills, Common Sense and "Stuff"! Grass Roots Survival has always been the way Humanity has "managed" through History!!

    GOD SAVE ALL HERE!!
     
  8. djmoforegon

    djmoforegon Powers

    Ha!:LOL:
     
  9. Fatima

    Fatima Powers

    The "Pope is being used by God" or God's adversary? I don's see clergy or laity getting better because of Pope Francis, I see them becoming more radical and emboldened in their evil scheme's contrary to church teachings.
     
    Mary's child, SgCatholic and DeGaulle like this.
  10. sunburst

    sunburst Powers

    Good point Fatima, but which is it?
    We do know all that is taking place will in the end accomplish His Will
    We are in the good hands of Our Lady of Grace
     
  11. DeGaulle

    DeGaulle Powers

    Could it be that many who always felt this way in their hearts now perceive they are being given licence to bring their views out into the open? In other words, is the abscess being lanced and are we seeing the evil ugliness that was already well established and internalised? Maybe I am just desperately clutching at straws.
     
    djmoforegon and Mary's child like this.
  12. AED

    AED Powers

    I just go back to the words of my confessor when "Amoris Laetitia" was first promulgated. He told me God is permitting this and it is part of the purification. It will not be allowed to stand but we must pray. I think God is going to bring a reckoning upon the prelates priests and people who "preferred darkness to the light". (I pray that I am always choosing The Light.) But the waiting hoping and praying is very hard. It is an offering in itself.
     
  13. garabandal

    garabandal Powers


    I think you are spot on here DeGaulle. The poison must first be lanced from the boil before healing.
     
  14. garabandal

    garabandal Powers

    An example of the sickness of apostasy within the Church is the Association of Catholic Priests (Ireland).

    http://www.associationofcatholicpriests.ie/

    They love Pope Francis as they think he supports their agenda.

    The ACP are out in the open with no one to correct them leading many people astray and to perdition. But they do not believe in Hell of course.

    The Bishops are silent -- they turn a blind eye. Why? Because the ACP contains probably 50% of the clergy in Ireland.

    So the problem is really, really bad. If the ACP are representative of half of the current clergy then the church in Ireland is as a dung-hill ready to collapse.

    We are still fortunate in Ireland to have many good priests thank God but things cannot go on for much longer - something is going to give --

    I do not have an agenda against ACP - I pray for the conversion of the priests who are in this apostate organisation.

    They do no believe much of what the church teaches nor do they believe in judgement. To them that is a medieval myth.

    The ACP are so radical that they make Martin Luther look like a Catholic!
     
    David Healy, AED and DeGaulle like this.
  15. DeGaulle

    DeGaulle Powers

    If we're going to be landed with national churches, will it be possible for myself, living here in Ireland, to apply for membership of the Polish Church? Since Pope Francis wishes to globalise and eliminate borders, how can he possibly object to my multicultural aspirations?

    What would be the meaning of a national church in a world devoid of nations? Have Pope Francis and his 2+2=5 supporters any grasp of logic whatever?

    [Given the actions of the Protestants during the 'Reformation', we should remember the instigator as 'Martin Looter'].
     
    Last edited: Oct 28, 2017
    AED likes this.
  16. Mary's child

    Mary's child Powers

    Yes it feels like we started out with a good sturdy rope that is being slowly sawed off and we are now hanging by a thread. :eek:
     
    AED and DeGaulle like this.
  17. DeGaulle

    DeGaulle Powers

    I suppose we can be thankful if it's only 50%. Of that portion, we may hope that a lot might be impressionable or merely not too bright. I can certainly say that the priests in my own area seem orthodox enough, at least the ones I have been to confession to. I don't recall hearing any heterodox sermons but also certainly I hear little about Hell and damnation. I don't know if that represents a disbelief in these things on their part or a fear that mentioning such disagreeable subjects might frighten people away. The irony is that it is this discomfort with hard truths that has been the real cause of apostasy-all too many suspect that the clergy are lukewarm, at best, in their own faith. The understandable consequence of such suspicions is loss of faith among many of the laity.
     
    David Healy, AED and Mario like this.
  18. DeGaulle

    DeGaulle Powers

    It will turn out that we are on the right end of the rope!
     
    AED and Mary's child like this.
  19. Mary's child

    Mary's child Powers

    Yes and thank God for holding out his hand to catch us. :)
     
    DeGaulle, AED and Mario like this.
  20. Cardinal Müller rebukes Italian bishop for calling Protestant Reformation ‘event of the Holy Spirit’

    ROME, October 25, 2017 (LifeSiteNews) – Cardinal Gerhard Müller has rebuked the secretary-general of the Italian Episcopal Conference for claiming that the Protestant Reformation was an “event of the Holy Spirit.”

    It is “unacceptable to assert that Luther's reform ‘was an event of the Holy Spirit,’" wrote Cardinal Müller, the former prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, in a recent article published in the Italian newspaper La Nuova Bussola Quotidiana. (LifeSite provides a full English translation of the cardinal's article here.)

    "On the contrary, it was against the Holy Spirit. Because the Holy Spirit helps the Church to maintain her continuity through the Church’s magisterium, above all in the service of the Petrine ministry: on Peter has Jesus founded His Church (Mt 16:18), which is 'the Church of the living God, the pillar and bulwark of the truth' (1 Tim 3:15)," the cardinal wrote.

    “The Holy Spirit does not contradict Himself,” added Müller.

    Müller’s rebuke was directed to a verbatim quote of the secretary-general of the Italian Episcopal Conference, Bishop Nunzio Galantino, who spoke on the topic October 19 at the Pontifical University of the Lateran.

    https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/c...ian-bishop-for-calling-protestant-reformation
     
    djmoforegon and DeGaulle like this.

Share This Page