https://onepeterfive.com/fool-me-twice-francis-scalfari-and-our-response-to-papal-media/ Fool Me Twice: Francis, Scalfari, and Our Response to Papal Media Excerpt: The Credibility Question This is the big one, particularly when it comes to Eugenio Scalfari interviews. But that’s certainly not the only time it comes up. This argument essentially amounts to a game of who are you going to believe, Person X, or the POPE?!? Every time someone who has met with Pope Francis speaks to the media about what he told them — and it’s invariably something controversial — we hear that they can’t be trusted. “It’s second-hand information,” they tell us. “We shouldn’t believe this unless we hear it from Pope Francis himself.” Other than the fact that most of these people are sincerely grateful for whatever the pope said to them and have nothing to gain by lying in general, many of them consider themselves his friends – as does Eugenio Scalfari. What kind of person lies about their friend and intentionally damages their reputation if they value the friendship? And what about the fact that these people are saying things about Francis that they believe to be positive attributes? I’ve covered this here and here. The fact is that Francis is a very, very shrewd man. His Argentinian friends “describe him as a ‘chess player,’ one whose every day is ‘perfectly organized,’ in which ‘each and every step has been thought out.'” He has been described elsewhere admiringly as “a master tactician” who has made moves “to outflank various groups and people that continue to oppose many of his initiatives”. If Francis is, as so much evidence now indicates, sympathetic to the agenda to give communion to the divorced and remarried, he must proceed cautiously, but with determination. This would explain why he stacked the deck at the Synod with cardinals who align themselves with the Kasper proposal. It would shed light on the evidence of Synod manipulation. It would make sense of why he rebuffed the 13 cardinals who expressed their concerns. It would help us to understand the noises he’s making about a decentralized, synodal Church. It would explain why he cautioned against a “hermeneutic of conspiracy” and lashed out at those who sought to uphold doctrine within the Synod (which caused some to misconstrue the event as a “conservative victory“). Francis’ strategic gifts would also explain his preference for using surrogates to advance his most controversial ideas into the public forum. If one understands the strictures on a pope — placed there in large part by the expectations of the faithful, to say nothing of the Holy Spirit — one could certainly see how a man who has been elected to the papacy and wants more drastic change than his position would reasonably allow would benefit from sending his stalking horses into the global media by means of those with whom he has private conversations. The irresistible urge to talk to the press about some exciting or controversial thing the pope has said to a person is sufficient motivation for them to break their silence, but one can only assume that Francis does not discourage this. It’s not hard to imagine him, with a wink and a smile, reminding those individuals with whom he has shared such delicious unorthodoxies that he’s here to ¡Hagan lío!, and wouldn’t complain if somehow the media got wind of the story – all unofficially, por supuesto. Which brings us back to Scalfari. After two years and multiple — inevitably controversial — interviews, one would think that Pope Francis would steer clear of the curious old atheist editor of La Repubblica, particularly since it has long since been disclosed that when Scalfari quotes a person, he’s reconstructing their interview from memory – hardly a credible journalistic practice. In March of this year, LifeSiteNews editor John-Henry Westen succinctly summed up the legacy of the Scalfari interviews thus far: Eugenio Scalfari, the famed atheist, has published a fourth article on a new interview with Pope Francis. The controversial anti-Catholic’s previous ‘interviews’ with Pope Francis were published also on the Vatican’s website and listed as official interviews with the pope. However, an October 2013 interview created a firestorm after which the Vatican pulled the interview from their site and Scalfari admitted that his writings are reconstructions from memory, as he does not use a recorder or take notes. That interview had Pope Francis saying that the “most serious” evils are “youth unemployment and the loneliness of the old.” Vatican spokesman Fr. Federico Lombardi said at the time: “One may consider the interview to be reliable in a general sense but not word for word. This is not an official text of the Holy Father.” The most recent interview, published March 15, is no exception. In it Scalfari has the pope denying hell. The article says: “What happens to that lost soul? Will it be punished? And how? The response of Francis is distinct and clear: there is no punishment, but the annihilation of that soul. All the others will participate in the beatitude of living in the presence of the Father. The souls that are annihilated will not take part in that banquet; with the death of the body their journey is finished.” The text does not have quotation marks around any of the statements attributed to the Holy Father. Moreover, the Vatican has not published this latest interview on their website. Fr. Thomas Rosica, English-language assistant to the Holy See Press Office, told LifeSiteNews, “All official, final texts of the Holy Father are found on the Vatican website,” and since they were never published by the Holy See Press Office they “should not be considered official texts.” They were, said Fr. Rosica, “private discussions that took place and were never recorded by the journalist.” “Mr. Scalfari reconstructed the interviews from memory,” Father Rosica added. There’s that plausible deniability again. Like so much else with this papacy, we are perpetually left to discern what about Pope Francis is true and what is false. This growing sense of mistrust toward him whom we should be able to look for clarity and guidance grows wearisome, especially when the reports of disconcerting papal opinions grow in number, with never a word of correction from the Holy Father himself, and are left with only the vague, half-hearted denials fielded from the Holy See Press Office to console us. Scalfari’s unreliability is a matter of perspective. He is reliably atheist. He has been reliably anti-Catholic. He is reliably committed to his own way of conducting interviews and then reconstructing them from memory – as Fr. Lombardi said in the statement quoted above, those who have “followed the preceding events and work in Italy know the way Scalfari writes and knows these things well.” Then why dear reader, it is so inexcusable that Pope Francis has given to Scalfari a total of five (by our count) such interviews – particularly when the first one was so blatantly controversial and sparked such scandal and backlash among the faithful. And despite persistent denials that these interviews accurately represent the mind of Pope Francis, we would do well to remember a very important concession made by Fr. Lombardi after the very first one was published: Pressed by reporters on the reliability of the direct quotations, Lombardi said during an Oct. 2 briefing that the text accurately captured the “sense” of what the pope had said, and that if Francis felt his thought had been “gravely misrepresented,” he would have said so. This, it seems, is the rhetorical smoking gun. Pope Francis reads what Scalfari writes about him (La Repubblica is his favorite newspaper and he reads it every day) and does not feel that he has been “gravely misrepresented” by any of Scalfari’s reconstructions. In fact, some of those interviews seem to make recurring appearances on the Vatican website, and some have been published in an official anthology of the pope’s conversations with journalists. What reasonable person could believe that Pope Francis feels any disdain for the way Scalfari represents his opinions in La Repubblica? Where is the evidence that having been burned before, he has made an effort not to be misrepresented again? Five interviews over two years. As someone wrote elsewhere today, “Once is a mistake; several times is a preference.” There’s an old saying that bears repeating here: “Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me.” Interpret these interviews however you want, fellow Catholics. I will not to join you in playing the fool.
OK, Brian, I was trying to give him the benefit of the doubt on the communist stuff but can you make sense of what he's saying here: “It it has been said many times and my response has always been that, if anything, it is the communists who think like Christians. Christ spoke of a society where the poor, the weak and the marginalized have the right to decide. Not demagogues, not Barabbas, but the people, the poor, whether they have faith in a transcendent God or not. It is they who must help to achieve equality and freedom”. It's the usual Pope Francis clap-trap and refusal to preach the Gospel truth as though he's ashamed of it. At the same time it isn't an endorsement of communist ideology which would include atheism. While there's plenty of evidence to suggest that Pope Francis is contemptuous of Catholicism, he seems to hold some kind of belief in God even if he thinks that Jesus was just a revolutionary. Then again, maybe his talk about God is just a cover for atheism. The Cardinals should be ashamed of themselves for electing him.
Yes we can't condemn a Pope on hear say. But I wonder if that is why Pope Francis choose Scalafari in the first place? As a kind of stalking horse to try out his ideas on the public and to see how they went down? A very Jesuitical kind of procedure. In either case I think it is a bad way for a Pope to do buisness, flying kites like this. A kind of back door way of saying things that is not suitable for a Christian let alone a Pope. I am afraid now that things are going to get very,very much worse before they get better. I used to hope the Hierarchy might step in and correct things, but I now see that this is never going to happen. If they had been going to they would ahve by now. God and only God can save us by Direct Intervention. I was shown Pope Francis in a great rage the other day in prayer. He was quite a sight to behold. He certainly knows how to let himself go. I can see why he has the Vatican in terror. I worry when I witness someone letting go in a rage like that, I worry very,very much indeed; there was something not natural about it. I can loose my temper myself from time to time. Most of us can. But that is not the same thing as flying into an utter, complete, ranting, rage. Hitler used to do this , so did Stalin. Not a good sign at all. Always bad. But coming from someone with absolute power? No it should not happen. It is a form of bullying.
No. But the Church, and that includes every member of its Body, must be as diligent as possible in collecting evidence for the prosecution. Uncorroborated hearsay evidence would not be admissable in a civil court. Procedures in the Church, particularly in the case of a pope, must be at least as impeccable. A professed atheist is quite likely to have his own agenda running hostile to that of the Church. He may be twisting the words of Pope Francis or even lying outright. Don't get me wrong, please, I am also shocked and depressed that the Pope gives so much time and credibility to this man and even more that he neglects to refute him, but it is not good enough evidence to take a case against him, either by the Church or in coming to a decisive conclusion about him in our own personal views. Sadly, Pope Francis himself continues to provide us with evidence of a much higher quality. I would be far more concerned about the recent words reportedly right out of his own mouth which seem to condone 'universalism' (and which apparently contradicts what Scalfari said he said about the 'annihilation' of some souls a while back). My head is beginning to hurt!
Mine too, thanks DeGaulle for this is message, we must be prudent as you say in our evidence. Praying for all here as we humbly seek the truth within the scope God has given us through prayer, penance, fasting.
Think maybe it's because he once studied to be a Jesuit??? It probably wouldn't occur to this bunch that the now universal horrendous sin cries out within nature itself for justice!! And his perfect, still, title: Gov. "Moonbeam"! ’Vatican Invites Governor Jerry Brown to Give Keynote Address on ‘Climate Change The Pontifical Academy of Sciences has invited California governor Jerry Brown to deliver a keynote address in their upcoming meeting on climate change to be held in the Vatican. The Nov. 2-4 Vatican workshop titled “Health of People, Health of Planet and our Responsibility: Climate Change, Air Pollution and Health” will attempt to link up the health risks posed by air pollution with anthropogenic climate change driven by carbon emissions. This is not the first time the Vatican has offered a platform to the contentious California governor from which to proclaim his views on global warming. Invited to speak at a similar Vatican event in 2015, Jerry Brown, a darling of Planned Parenthood, railed against climate-change skeptics, calling them well-financed “troglodytes” who are determined to “bamboozle” the gullible. The Vatican hosted 10 U.S. Democrat mayors as well as Governor Jerry Brown of California at its event, while no Republicans were present. At the conclusion of the event, Brown joined the other politicians in signing a declaration stating that “human-induced climate change is a scientific reality, and its effective control is a moral imperative for humanity.” In his address, Brown said that climate change is “the biggest threat of our time” after nuclear annihilation. “If we don’t annihilate ourselves with nuclear bombs then it’s climate change,” he said. http://www.breitbart.com/big-govern...wn-to-give-keynote-address-on-climate-change/
Is that Mater Dei in Irving? I’m moving with my husband and 5 kids to the area along with my sister, her husband and infant in December and we were all planning on going there
Yes, Divine Mercy, that's the one! We'll be so very happy to have you! We just became parishioners last month and we really love everything about it. We live in Dallas, but it's only about a twenty minute drive from our house. We'd love to meet you and your family, as well as your sister and hers, when you get here. Just private message me and we can exchange phone numbers, if you like. We'd be happy to show you around town!
Might as well have Al Gore fly his personal gas guzzling, ozone eliminating jet over to the Vatican to speak on climate change as he has been doing all over the world for the past 20 years, while pocketing millions in his bank account for promoting his nonsense.
https://gloria.tv/article/KHzJMBTbH69s3uwQAAPvruZ6k Francis Suffers Temper Fit Because Of Polish Bishops The document of the Polish Bishops’ Conference which corrects the heresies contained in Amoris Laetitia has been published before its ratification by the bishops. Referring to excellent sources, Marco Tosatti writes on his blog (October 19) that this has caused “in the reigning Pontiff one of his not unprecedented or unusual accesses of bad mood.” Tosatti also confirms that the president of the Bishops’ Conference was convoked to the nunciature in Warsaw and threatened with papal retaliation for the document. Pointing to Francis’ Twitter message of October 19, “Let yourself be guided by the tenderness of God so that you may transform the world with your faith” Tosatti adds, “A bit surreal, isn’t it?”
The Poles are a tough crowd. They've had to endure Nazis invading from the West and Communists doing so from the East, all at the same time. You can be sure they haven't forgotten Stalin's hoary old comment, but quite true nonetheless, that the Pope has no divisions.
They will also recall Pope St John Paul the Great and the fact that he was a very, very different kettle of fish than Pope Francis. It's true, people loosing their tempers and threatening them will be so much nuts to them.
The Vatican can make fools out of themselves with this lunacy as much as they want, it doesn't matter a dot in the grand scheme of things. The world won't be ended by global warming or any other man-made phenomenon, no matter how hard we try. It will end when Jesus Christ decides to come again. It is the meddling with the Apostolic Truth of Christ's Church that presents the real difficulty. That is what may result in no faith on Earth when that Second Coming arrives.
Pope Encourages Young US Immigrants to Keep Dreaming https://www.newsmax.com/newsfront/eu-rel-vatican-us/2017/10/26/id/822362/