I recently read a comment by a third party at Father Hunwicke's that it might be that we are lucky that Pope Francis is not more subtle and nuanced. A pontiff with the same views but who was more wary of trampling on opponents and more skilled at sneaking in change imperceptibly might have been more dangerous. Pope Francis is like a bull in a China shop.
I am sure your right. This particular weakness leaves one open to blackmail. That is why governments used to be careful to avoid having "diversity" in its intelligence services. Now of course it would be discrimination.
It wouldn't be just the homosexuals open to blackmail. Remember that priests take a vow of celibacy and religious take a vow of chastity. Any breach leaves them vulnerable to being outed irrespective of their sexual orientation or whether they repented, were absolved and turned their lives around. Church teaching means little to the agenda driven mercy mafia.
I think what is happening now in a strange way is a blessing. Yes it is terrible, but look how many souls are waking up. How many tepid souls are becoming fervent. This is what the Chastisement is for, to save those who can be saved. Let's be brutally honest, though we cannot ever know for sure, it is a very good guess that many, perhaps even most souls today are on the road to damnation. Before the 1960's the general populace at least knew the basics of religion and what was expected of them, even if they didn't always live up to it. Today how many "Catholics" support abortion, same sex marriage, etc.? Even if they aren't that bad, how many Catholics do their basic duties as a member of the Church? 15 minutes of prayer a day, confession, going to Church every Sunday, only receiving the Body and Blood of Our Lord worthily, believing in the Real Presence, making God the center of their lives, etc. It only takes one mortal sin to be damned forever. Even when God chastises it is merciful. The intent is not to pour out anger upon us, but to shake us into wakefulness. Much as when a good parent is driven to punishing their children. It is not because they enjoy it, but because they must do it for the child's own welfare.
Hmmmm.....but is this the new version that Fr. Amorth knew to have been severely weakened in its effect? The new version was put together without the expertise of those Exorcists with actual experience....in fact they were kept out of the official announcement of this version. I believe that he also felt or knew that the Latin itself had a real power over the evil spirits involved in the exorcism. And some of the potent prayers were dismissed and left out. It was then C. Ratzinger who kept open the permission for the old rite to be used while the "populist" version was being given general promotion. We see today the creation of a type of "tower of babel" when it comes to the various English translations offered for the liturgy.....now this! From a skeptic! US bishops publish English-language translation of exorcism ritual http://www.catholicherald.co.uk/new...lish-language-translation-of-exorcism-ritual/
This is huge, IMHO. https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/v...-of-communism-revealed-to-public-for-first-ti Vatican II’s lost condemnations of communism revealed to public for first time Matthew Cullinan Hoffman Shutterstock.com Follow Matthew Editor's note: The lost condemnations of communism prepared for the Second Vatican Council but later discarded and forgotten are now being made available to the public in an English translation for the first time by LifeSiteNews. The translations, by LifeSite's Matthew Cullinan Hoffman, are based on the drafts of documents contained in the official acts of the council’s preparatory commissions. The documents contain an extensive plan for a coordinated and global effort to counteract the influence of Marxism and communism worldwide and “shatter its audacity.” However, following the takeover of the council’s commissions by the ultra-liberal “Rhine group” bishops, the condemnations were discarded and all attempts to explicitly condemn communism and Marxism were rejected. Following the close of the council, the condemnations were confined to the volumes of the official acts of the council’s preparatory commissions, which are written almost entirely in Latin and have gathered dust on the shelves of research libraries for decades – until now. In the following report, Hoffman explains the texts and their significance. October 25, 2017 (LifeSiteNews.com) – In 1962, as millions of Catholics languished behind the iron curtain and the Soviet Union worked to spread atheistic communism throughout the world, the Second Vatican Council was preparing to deliver an historic condemnation of Marxist and communist ideology, one that would involve a global strategy for its defeat. Vatican II’s preparatory commissions had created three different statements that would condemn Marxism as an “exceedingly grave and universal danger” and communism as “a false religion without God” that seeks to “to subvert the foundations of Christian civilization.” They also envisioned a massive and highly-coordinated campaign to liberate mankind from communism and “shatter its audacity.” It would be a full-scale counterattack against what Fatima visionary Lúcia dos Santos called “the greatest heresy to appear at any time in the world,” which was “carrying its errors to the ends of the earth.” However, the documents were discarded in the early months of the Council when the liberal German, French, and Dutch-speaking bishops of the “Rhine group” out-maneuvered the conservative majority and took control of the commissions overseeing the council’s documents. They then rejected most of the preparatory schemas that had been issued to the council fathers, replacing them with schemas that generally avoided condemning the errors of the age. The schemas condemning communism and Marxism were never considered. What remained was only a timid critique of atheism in the document Gaudium et Spes, with an oblique reference in a footnote to previous condemnations to communism by the popes. The council’s plans to combat Marxism were almost entirely forgotten, filed away and ultimately published in their original Latin form in the official acts of the council, where they can be found gathering dust in research libraries throughout the world. In the years following the council, Marxism-inspired forms of “liberation theology” took hold among many Catholic clergy and theologians, particularly in Latin America. One such priest, the Argentinean Jesuit Jorge Bergoglio, initially resisted such influences, but began to ally himself with Marxism-inspired liberation theologians before being elected to the papacy in 2013. In a recent interview with Pope Francis, the leftist atheist journalist Eugenio Scalfari reports that he asked the pontiff: “So you yearn for a society where equality dominates. This, as you know, is the programme of Marxist socialism and then of communism. Are you therefore thinking of a Marxist type of society?” To which he says Francis replied, “It has been said many times and my response has always been that, if anything, it is the communists who think like Christians.” Francis has never denied nor repudiated the statement. Francis has also engaged in other gestures expressing sympathy for Marxism, including the acceptance of a hammer-sickle crucifix from Bolivia's Marxist president, Evo Morales, a gesture that caused much consternation in Latin America. He reportedly has requested help from Marxism-inspired liberation theologians such as Leonardo Boff in the composition of his encyclical letter Laudato Si’. Recently the Jesuit order elected a new Superior General, the Venezuelan Arturo Sosa Abascal, who has openly sought to reconcile Christianity with Marxism. Read the rest at the link
Fatima, I was just thinking about that. This was posted yesterday on "afterthewarning.com" My question/quandary pertains to what I have italicized. We (on this forum) know our beloved Church is deeply infiltrated with Freemasons. I recognize this means the Truth of Christ is found within the Catholic Church rather than outside among the many splinter groups. Yet, we also know there is and will be much confusion within our Church as well. Certainly some Priests are more liberal then others. Most of us have not memorized the Eucharistic prayers-proper Latin translation (I can't imagine the Pope giving a Bishop of any diocese permission to change on their own but how else will we temporarily lose the Presence of Christ in the Eucharist?). I read something recently on EWTN that made me question. Did anyone else see this? I'm looking for clarity, not to being an alarmist. 4541 - Message of Our Lady Queen of Peace, October 17, 2017 (Pedro Regis) Dear children, I ask you to keep the flame of faith burning in your hearts. Believe in the Gospel, the source of truth that guides you to Heaven. Value the Presence of My Jesus in the Eucharist. The Eucharist is your greatest treasure. Do not leave the Only Church of My Jesus. The devil will cause confusion and division in the House of God, but you can overcome him by being faithful to the True Magisterium of the Church of My Jesus. Sects exist in order to confuse and many will be contaminated by the mire of false doctrines. The Truth of My Jesus is kept intact only in the Catholic Church, which My Jesus will never abandon. Be faithful. Do not allow the enemy of God to take you away from the path of truth. Bend your knees in prayer and do not forget the great lessons of the past. Whoever remains faithful to the end will be saved. I am your Sorrowful Mother and I suffer for what comes to you. Courage. Your victory is in the Lord. This is the message I give you today in the name of the Most Holy Trinity. Thank you for having allowed Me to gather you here once more. I bless you, in the name of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit. Amen. Remain at peace.
Padraig Raymond Arroyo commentaries have the backing of a world recognized entity EWTN; he has tenure. Raymond is doing great work but Michael Voris has to get some applause because he did not hesitate to proceed with his program of getting the real information out to Catholics, despite the threats to his own private life. I much applaud him for that alone. God Bless
In fairness, Brian, wasn't Cardinal Ratzinger part of the Rhine group at Vatican 11? Didn't he co-write a book somewhat supportive of liberation theology? Granted, he eventually came to see its errors but as Pope he can't have been unaware of the shelved condemnations of Marxism yet he didn't see fit to dust them off and have them published in modern languages. I'm not convinced that Pope Francis has communist sympathies. I do believe that he abhors the kind of greedy capitalism prevalent in the world today. Maybe he is going overboard in an effort to correct any false impression that the Church has been too closely aligned with that kind of capitalism but that doesn't make him a Marxist or a fellow traveller.
I agree. I think this is the one and only reason why God is allowing what is taking place in the Church right now to happen. So it will be obvious when things are finally "set right" why things happened as they did. For there is nothing covered, that shall not be revealed: nor hidden, that shall not be known. -- Luke 12:2
This. This is God drawing greater good out of the evil He permits. Sometimes we don't see any whys and wherefores. In this case I think we can, at least to some extent. Well said, Praetorian.
We certainly shouldn't condemn Pope Francis on the word of an atheist. The Pope's political background is in Peronism, a populist left-wing movement not dissimilar to Italian Fascism (many in Argentina are, like Pope Francis himself, of Italian descent). This would still potentially, though not conclusively, make him a socialist. Pope Pius Xth and Pope Leo XIIIth both condemned socialism as being inimical to Catholicism.
I think we should be careful about putting labels on people. If he did lean towards Peronism, we don't really know whether he was an avid supporter or merely saw it as a lesser evil. Looking at the situation in Europe, I'm sure that there are devout Catholics voting for and supporting political parties that they would avoid if there were a more palatable choice available. I'm fairly sure that one of those Popes (possibly Pius X) also condemned some types of capitalism. Was it he who espoused subsidiarity? I wouldn't be so sure that the capitalism of multi-national corporations is what the Popes had in mind as a good alternative to socialism.
Really? To which he says Francis replied, “It has been said many times and my response has always been that, if anything, it is the communists who think like Christians.” Francis has never denied nor repudiated the statement.
Exactly. We can't conclusively label Pope Francis as a socialist. The Church's traditional view on capitalism and capitalists would approach Chesterton's: not enough of them. In other words, it is best that too much capital not find itself in the hands of too few people. Unfortunately, in the present world, there is an unprecedented, and increasing, concentration of wealth among a very small elite. In this context, it is understandable that Pope Francis would express disapproval, but he lacks the political, economic, philosophical and theological understanding of many of his papal predecessors. In fairness to him, I thought Pope Francis looked bewildered more than anything when Morales presented him with that monstrosity.
Brian, I refuse to take the word of an atheist to condemn a pope. Non-denial nor non-repudiation do not definitively constitute approval. The jury is still out.
In some ways, Brian, that comment isn't too far off the mark. Christianity always aimed to lift up the poor and downtrodden. One of the reasons communism tends to appeal to lukewarm Christians is that Christianity preaches the human person's innate dignity because we are made in the image and likeness of God and that we are all equal in God's sight. Communism uses and distorts that teaching to turn the vulnerable and downtrodden against Christianity. Sometimes we Christians, especially wealthy and powerful Christians, can be our own worst enemy when we don't practice what we preach.
https://onepeterfive.com/pope-communists-think-like-christians/ Pope: “It is the Communists Who Think Like Christians” Steve Skojec November 11, 2016 314 Comments During this week where Americans have been distracted by the unexpected upset of a presidential election that could very well change the course of our collective future, Pope Francis has been busy making political statements of his own. In yet another interview with Eugenio Scalfari (see our standard rebuttal to “you can’t trust Scalfari!” here), this exchange was reported to have taken place: You told me some time ago that the precept, “Love your neighbour as thyself” had to change, given the dark times that we are going through, and become “more than thyself.” So you yearn for a society where equality dominates. This, as you know, is the programme of Marxist socialism and then of communism. Are you therefore thinking of a Marxist type of society? “It it has been said many times and my response has always been that, if anything, it is the communists who think like Christians. Christ spoke of a society where the poor, the weak and the marginalized have the right to decide. Not demagogues, not Barabbas, but the people, the poor, whether they have faith in a transcendent God or not. It is they who must help to achieve equality and freedom”. [emphasis added] One of the most hotly contested criticism of Pope Francis is that he is ideologically aligned with Marxists. We’ve covered some of the connections before, so I won’t rehash them here. What seems fair to say is that this is the most direct admission yet that Francis identifies his program of social justice as something compatible with Communism – itself an intrinsic evil. Pope Francis receives a crucifix fashioned into a communist hammer and sickle from Bolivian president Evo Morales. Of course, this seems all of a piece. On the eve of the US Presidential election — which featured the most pro-abortion candidate for the presidency in this nation’s history — Francis was busy meeting with his friend Emma Bonino, Italy’s most famous and prolific abortionist. They got together to talk about the migrant crisis, something so close to his heart that he not only overlooks Bonino’s crimes and calls her one of Italy’s “greats”, he also used it to take a swipe at then presidential candidate (now president-elect) Donald Trump, saying: Christians should not give into the temptation to build walls, even in the face of “hateful and cowardly attacks,” a reference to global terrorism. “Dear Brothers and Sisters,” he said, “all walls fall.” When Francis was asked directly by Scalfari what he thinks of Trump, he responded: “I do not pass judgment on people and politicians, I simply want to understand the suffering that their approach causes the poor and excluded”. Today, the theme of migration arose yet again, as it was reported that Francis will infuse a refugee theme into the Vatican’s nativity display: Measuring an astounding 55 feet wide, the Nativity scene will feature 17 figures dressed in traditional Maltese attire as well as replica of a “luzzu,” a Maltese boat. The boat, the Vatican’s governing office said, “not only represents tradition – fish and life – but also, unfortunately, the realities of migrants who in those very waters sail on makeshift boats to Italy.” On matters that should, it seems, be at least as close to the heart of the pope as the plight of refugees, there have instead been bizarre developments over the past few days. Jan Bentz of LifeSiteNews reports that under new papally-approved statutes, members of the Pontifical Academy for Life “will no longer be required to sign a declaration that they uphold the Church’s pro-life teachings.” The Academy is also expanding its focus to protection of the environment. “The Academy has a task of a prevalently scientific nature, directed towards the promotion and defense of human life (cf. Vitae Mysterium, 4). In particular, it studies the various aspects that relate to the care of the dignity of the human person at the different ages of existence, mutual respect between genders and generations, the defense of the dignity of each single human being, the promotion of a quality of human life that integrates material and spiritual value, with a view to an authentic ‘human ecology’, which may help to recover the original balance of Creation between the human person and the entire universe (cf. Chirograph, 15 August 2016).” Bentz comments: The surprise is the inclusion of the word “gender” instead of the more specific and less loaded word “sex,” as well as the consideration of the quality of a human life in a dependent relation with the “entire universe.” This leaves the door open to all kinds of modern trends, such as elevating animal life to equal standing with human life, or putting the idea of a sociological gender before the natural sex of a person. At the same time, the ambiguous “original balance of Creation” is introduced, which needs further theological exposition in order not to be mistaken for a pagan idea of the cosmos. And in a new interview included in a book that collects Francis homilies and addresses from his time as the Archbishop of Buenos Aires from 1999 to 2013, Francis’ views on the Mass are brought to light: Asked about the liturgy, Pope Francis insisted the Mass reformed after the Second Vatican Council is here to stay and “to speak of a ‘reform of the reform’ is an error.” In authorizing regular use of the older Mass, now referred to as the “extraordinary form,” now-retired Pope Benedict XVI was “magnanimous” toward those attached to the old liturgy, he said. “But it is an exception.” Pope Francis told Father Spadaro he wonders why some young people, who were not raised with the old Latin Mass, nevertheless prefer it. “And I ask myself: Why so much rigidity? Dig, dig, this rigidity always hides something, insecurity or even something else. Rigidity is defensive. True love is not rigid.” The question of how closely Francis aligns himself with Communist ideology will no doubt continue to be debated. His priorities as the leader of the Catholic Church, however, have become increasingly clear.