The Vatican Has Fallen

Discussion in 'Church Critique' started by padraig, Dec 31, 2016.

  1. It's called speaking with a forked tongue.
     
    little me and Don_D like this.
  2. More "expert" advice (for the world and....the U.S./Trump) coming from Rome:

    Pope Francis: ‘Wars and Climate Change’ Are Root Causes of World Hunger and Migration

    Pope Francis addressed the FAO Monday on the question of world hunger, proposing that wars and climate change must be overcome in order to properly address the crisis of world hunger and immigration.
    “The relationship between hunger and migrations can only be addressed if we go to the root of the problem,” the Pope said at the headquarters of the Food and Agricultural Organization (FAO) in Rome. “In this regard, studies conducted by the United Nations, like many others conducted by civil organizations, agree that there are two major obstacles that must be overcome: conflicts and climate change.”

    The pontiff expressed his optimistic view that scientists have discovered how to contain climate change and require only the political will of world leaders.

    “Concerning climate change, we see its consequences every day,” Francis said. “Thanks to scientific knowledge, we know how to deal with the problem and the international community has also been preparing necessary legal instruments, such as, for example, the Paris Accord.”

    The Pope added that “unfortunately, some are distancing themselves” from the Paris agreement, in evident reference to the United States, since it is the only nation apart from Nicaragua and Syria not to adhere to the pact, and the only one to actually withdraw.

    Despite scientific knowledge on how to address the problem, “we see the reappearance of negligence regarding the delicate balance of ecosystems, the arrogance to manipulate and control the planet’s resources, and greed for profit,” Francis said.


    http://www.breitbart.com/national-s...re-root-causes-of-world-hunger-and-migration/
     
    picadillo likes this.
  3. I have never accepted that humans can materially alter earths climate.
    The so called scientific proof that they have done so is shot through with holes and contradictions.
    Most of the propaganda behind this is promoted by left wing activists with a hatred of human progress and technology.
    God put the earth there for mans benefit to be exploited for mans benefit.
    To imply that puny man can destroy Gods great creation or alter its climate radically appears to me blasphemous.

    Of course this does not stop the left wing lunatics from hopping about in a mad frenzy seeking to implement fraudulent carbon taxes and big government.
     
    picadillo, Tanker, sunburst and 2 others like this.
  4. Don_D

    Don_D ¡Viva Cristo Rey!

    Agreed, it is nothing but a ponzi scheme to transfer wealth and power away from those who have wielded it to those who long for it under the power of population control masochists. Using abortion and birth control as well as euthanasia. Manipulating science to control the population.

    Pope Francis's dogged insistence on supporting this charade was a big indicator to me of his allegiances. The US dropping out of the Paris accord gave me and many some hope. Also, the same people who are supporting this are those who are insisting that these nations affected by poverty saddle themselves to these Godless ideals for aid. Obama did this with the nations of South Africa for US aid. Thank God those days are over.
     
  5. Can a true pope adopt such outright and positive left wing political allegiences?
    I do not believe any true vicar of Christ can adopt political points of view of that kind because it fatally undermines the spiritual authority of the office.
    But as you know , two men living in the Vatican , each with the approval of the cardinals , utilise the title of " Pope".
    Ubi est Petrus?
     
  6. Don_D

    Don_D ¡Viva Cristo Rey!

    Yes, I was thinking about this dilemma this morning during my prayers.

    Is it OK to pray for both of them when we say our prayers for the Pope? I should hope so.

    The thing is that Pope Francis uses the idea of social activism for how we ought to help the poor. This I think is why he throws his weight behind these things such as the Paris accord. It bothered me from the start that he did this though because anyone with eyes to see knows that this is masquerading as something it is not.

    Surely he sees this.
     
  7. AED

    AED Powers

    Don I have pondered this since the conclave. I don't think we can underestimate the influence of Latin America on this Pope and perhaps especially Argentina. There are such political swamps there and such inequities. It was the home of liberation theology which basically translated Marx into catholic terminology. The aim was I suppose to address the poverty and savage oppression the poor endured and I am sure this milieu shaped his views. I pray he is naive in his allegiances and does what he does in ignorance of the dangers. But I do think he comes from a very very different place in more ways than geography.
     
    Don_D likes this.
  8. Fatima

    Fatima Powers

    The one thing Pope Francis in not is naive. He is as calculating of a leader as their has ever been. He chooses his words coded for a purpose and that purpose is to give his thumbs up to those he knows speaks his language, which is often opposed to Church teaching. This is clear now for anyone who has eye's to see and ears to hear with. This is what liberation theology is all about..... "making a mess". The past few pope's have condemned liberation theology and the current one embraces it. His support of it all is evident in how he rarely uses Christ and his teachings when he speaks on issues. Only when it fits his ideology in a twisted way, in a new way from traditional church teachings. Yet, contrary to what AT thinks, he is still pope until defined else-wise by the Cardinal's of the truth Church. Even Pedro Regis messages, as hard as they are on what is going on in the Church hierarchy, have not come close to suggesting Francis is not pope. Read his latest one posted.
     
    Last edited: Oct 16, 2017
    Mary's child, sunburst and Don_D like this.
  9. Fatima

    Fatima Powers

    Now the Catholic Church would disagree. Sin is the cause of war, climate change, hunger and every other evil of the day. All one has to do is read the Old Testament to see that the great flood and the cities of Sodom and Gomorrah being destroyed by sulfur and fire was the result of sin, not climate change. If the whole world got down on its knee's right now and repented, it is a guarantee of God's mercy and war and climate change would cease. Pope Francis wants to politicize everything, while not looking at the root of all evil is sin, especially the sin of apostasy from the truths that have always been taught since Moses gave the world the 10 commandments of God.
     
  10. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

    Do you think that Pope Francis believes in God? Sometimes I wonder. He mentions Christ when preaching to the choir or when it suits his political agenda. Atheists quote the bible at believers when it suits their political agenda. Atheists wrote Laudate Si.
     
  11. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    cruxnow.com
    Resigned pope creates 'multiplied and divided' authority, author says
    Claire Giangravè
    7-8 minutes
    In this Tuesday, Dec. 8, 2015 file photo, Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI, right, hugs Pope Francis in St. Peter's Basilica during the ceremony marking the start of the Holy Year, at the Vatican. (Credit: AP Photo/Gregorio Borgia, File.)

    ROME - Catholics have had to get used to a lot lately. The secularized state in the West has been progressively pushing faith to the margins, and Christians have been victims of persecutions around the globe. What’s more, the Church has had to come to terms with the fact that, for the fist time in history, there are currently two popes living in the Vatican.

    While many Catholics have easily adjusted to the dual existence of Pope Francis and Pope emeritus Benedict XVI, undeniably another portion cannot help but compare the two papacies, or even express a preference for one style over the other.

    Evidence can be found in the fact that the streaming service Netflix has begun filming a movie revolving around the two popes, starring Anthony Hopkins as Benedict, showing that, at least to the secular eye, a comparison between the two papacies can appeal to a large audience.

    While some might prefer Benedict’s orthodoxy and clear-cut doctrine, others might gravitate toward Francis’s pastoral and progressive approach, creating, according to one scholar, a new phenomenon within the Catholic Church.

    “Not even the French Revolution, the Capture of Rome and the Second Vatican Council (which created a still-existing rift within the Church) were able to destabilize the Western political institution,” journalist and scholar Fabrizio Grasso writes in his recent publication The Abdication.

    That is, until February 11, 2013.

    On that date, Pope Benedict XVI officially resigned from his position as pope, citing fatigue and old age. Countless essays, books, studies and analysis have been written since then, and Grasso is well aware that his contribution comes late in the game and in the midst of an infinite array of commentary.

    Yet Grasso does not focus on the resignation itself, which finds several precedents in ecclesiastical history, but rather on the fact that Benedict chose the title of Pope Emeritus, rather than Emeritus Bishop of Rome, creating what he perceives as a critical rupture within the Church.

    After all, Benedict continues to live in the Vatican, dresses in white and is referred to as “His Holiness,” making his resignation, according to Grasso, “incomparable to those of his predecessors.”

    “The ‘always’ is also a ‘forever’ - there can no longer be a return to the private sphere. My decision to resign the active exercise of the ministry does not revoke this,” Benedict said during his last general audience.

    “I no longer bear the power of office for the governance of the Church, but in the service of prayer I remain, so to speak, in the enclosure of Saint Peter,” he said.

    In order to try and understand the possible implications, Grasso quotes German Archbishop Georg Gänswein, who has had a privileged view of the two papacies since he serves as a Prefect of the Papal Household for Francis and as secretary for the retired pontiff Benedict. During a book presentation in May 2016, Gänswein opened up the possibility of an ‘expanded Petrine office’ with both a contemplative and active member.

    Gänswein pointed to a continuity between the two papacies in what he called a Ausnahmepontifikat, meaning an “exceptional pontificate.” Keeping these words in mind, Grasso asks whether the archbishop was implying “that to guide the Church and the papacy, one pope is not enough.”

    The writer’s reflections are heavily based on the German and Catholic political theorist Carl Schmitt and his Political Theology. Grasso borrows Schmitt’s definition of the “political,” defined as a choice that inevitably requires a juxtaposition between friend/enemy. This dichotomy fuels our political parties and debates, but, according to the author, it never managed to grab hold within the Church, thanks to the secular transmission of the papacy onto a single figure, the pope, who alone exercises sovereignty and authority.

    “Sovereignty and authority [were] paradoxically hit, and perhaps demolished, at least from a secular point of view, by Ratzinger’s abdication, which by enlarging the ministry to encompass one contemplative and one active member, has in fact divided and multiplied authority and sovereignty, which were undivided prerogatives of a single pontiff,” Grasso writes.

    According to the author, until February 11, 2013 “the pope was the last living representative of the medieval res publica christiana,” where the sacred and the temporal power were concentrated into a single role impervious to the ‘us v. them’ dynamic that fuels and fosters political debate in modern democracies.

    What the author describes in his book is an ‘internalization’ by the Catholic Church of a conflict, typical of the political realm, that had never existed before. This matter is more relevant since both pontiffs recognize each other’s authority and position, something that had never occurred in papal history.

    One objection that can be raised to the author’s self-defined “philosophizing,” is whether this division between the pope and the emeritus pope actually has any real relevance.

    “One only needs to look on the most popular search engine for the phrase Benedetto contro Francesco (Italian for “Benedict against Francis”) to be submerged by more than 500,000 results, and if one tries with ‘Benedict vs Francis,’ there are more than 400,000 results. Therefore, only between Italian and English there are almost one million links that intercept that conflict directly,” Grasso writes.

    The author admits that a large portion of those links could be considered trash, but he also points to a vast number of Catholic and secular news organizations and blogs that also promote the juxtaposition between the two popes, usually pointing to a preference. After all, Grasso writes, the resignation by Benedict was not only a historical event, but also a global media event, which no doubt influenced its overall perception.

    The book typically shies away from offering any possible tangible consequence of the double-pope paradox, but raises questions and possibilities going forward that could systemically change the millenarian power distributions within the Church.

    “Even for those with little imagination, it’s not hard to imagine a possible near future with more than one emeritus pope and, consequentially, an exclusive papal club, which could be no other than a proto-parliament of the Vatican State,” Grasso hypothesizes.

    It’s impossible to tell whether popes resigning will become a “thing,” and the implications of Benedict’s momentous resignation, and his role as emeritus pope, will be left for history to judge.
     
    Anthonys Truth. and Carol55 like this.
  12. Fatima

    Fatima Powers

    Yes, I believe he believes in a God, but it is a very abstract God, not a God of the 10 commandments. I know a bit about how liberal/progressive clergy think, as I have had them exclusively for 30 years now. They truly believe that all that is necessary is to advocate for the poor and salvation is through that alone. The commandments are suggestions to them. Advocating for the poor is essential for anyone who they can get to follow their social justice ideologies. To the progressives, the planet is a being with a soul. They do not advocate for the unborn child, as it is assumed another human being into this world will add to starvation and global pollutants. They use the poor, as Democrat's in the US have used the blacks. Keep them dumb and dependent and they will have them right where they need them. Dogma and doctrine get in the way of progressives. Objective truth is the enemy, as relativism is the choice of their utopia world. It is all about ism's, starting with modernism, communism, socialism, feminism and so on. In essence they want to be like God. They do not believe in hell nor fear of the Lord.
     
    Last edited: Oct 17, 2017
    picadillo and Heidi like this.
  13. Dolours

    Dolours Guest

    He strikes me as the passive aggressive type. I read an article written about his time with the Jesuits in Argentina - I think I posted a link to it on the forum but I can't find it now. At odds with his superiors for being a trouble maker, he had been sent to serve away from the hub in Buenos Aires. An observation by an American who had been in Argentina around that time summed up how he manages to manipulate people. The American said that it wasn't so much Fr. Bergoglio but his clique who were problematic. Fr. Bergoglio's superiors were shrewd enough to spot the problem and deal with it. Pity they didn't expel him. He kept his head down after that and rose through the ranks. Now we have Catholics telling us it's his clique who are the problem but the Pope is perfect. Leopards don't change their spots.

    Do you doubt now that he was behind Podesta's Catholic Spring? I don't and I have no doubt that as a Cardinal in Buenos Aires he came across Soros who owns half a million acres in Argentina.
     
    picadillo likes this.
  14. Christ did not die for the poor.
    Christ died for everybody.
    Bergoglio seeks to create schism in the church by pretending it is a church primarily for the poor.
    It is not, never has been, and such talk is divisive and contrary to the universal message of the Catholic Church.
     
  15. AED

    AED Powers

    One thing for sure. It is a big mess. Whatever inspires or drives him it is a MESS.
     
    Dolours likes this.
  16. You admit that Bergoglio is opposed to catholic teaching yet regard him as a valid Pope.
    How can any valid Pope be opposed to catholic teaching?
    There are two men using the title of Pope living in the Vatican City.
    I am certain that Benedict was canonically elected pope.
    I almost certain that Bergoglio was not.
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Oct 17, 2017
  17. AED

    AED Powers

    Utterly chilling.
     
  18. It is quite inconceivable that the person you describe could be the vicar of Christ.
    Yet for some unfathomable reason you believe the demon you describe is indeed the vicar of Christ.
     
  19. I have been arguing that case above as presented in the article you quote.
    I even went so far as to consider the notion of Pope and sub Pope.
    However as every catholic knows the papacy rests on one individual alone.
    It can be neither delegated or subdivided.
    Therefore the only answer to the current problem is the one I have been advocating all along.
    Ie Benedicts resignation was defective meaning he remains the pope.
     
  20. Fatima

    Fatima Powers

    It is quite simple really. It was a valid papal election. Not even the faithful Cardinal's deny this. Nor does the former Pope Benedict. Only those that are frustrated with the results and don't trust God has a plan.
     

Share This Page