The Vatican Has Fallen

Discussion in 'Church Critique' started by padraig, Dec 31, 2016.

  1. maryrose

    maryrose Powers

    Sadly I know the majority of Catholics in my parish and extended family will have no problem with swallowing this change. It will all hinge on the Bishops and priests. I am not filled with confidence. Keep praying the rosary for them.
     
  2. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    http://www.onepeterfive.com/austrian-bishop-amoris-laetitia-fight-conflict/

    Austrian Bishop on Amoris Laetitia: “We Have To Fight This Conflict”
    Maike Hickson February 7, 2017 0 Comments
    [​IMG]


    Today, on 7 February 2017, the Austrian Auxiliary Bishop Andreas Laun of Salzburg has published on the Catholic website Kath.net a commentary on the current situation in the Church with regard to the papal document Amoris Laetitia and its cumulative effects. Bishop Laun speaks about a German priest who now works in Southern America, and who just wrote to him the following earnest words:

    Dear Andreas, while the questions concerning the remarried divorcees remain unanswered and vague – as the Holy Father does it currently – then there can soon come to pass the following absurd situation: a penitent [in the confessional] presents his situation – saying that he wishes to continue to live as husband and wife with his female partner – and he then demands absolution, with [a supporting] reference to the various bishops’ conferences and finally also to the pope himself; and then I [as a priest] say: “My conscience tells me that I cannot give you absolution even though the pope still keeps the question open; therefore, I cannot give absolution to you.” But, then, the other, with reference to the pope, insists upon receiving absolution as well as admittance to Holy Communion. Do I then have to change the formula of absolution and say: “The pope absolves you from your sins in the name of the Father and so on …?” For me, this is absolutely absurd! But is this not what it leads to? [my emphasis]

    To this passage Laun then comments, with these words: “I fear that in this question is contained a logic which one cannot escape.” He continues, as follows:

    There is no such thing as a double truth, and to some questions there is only one true answer – even when bishops and entire bishops’ conferences are giving contradictory answers. Some [answers] are true, others are certainly false. The four well-known cardinals who have presented their questions [dubia] to the pope might be well satisfied with the illustration of the problem as now presented here by this [German] priest from Southern America.

    With some more encouraging words, Bishop Laun explains to his readers that, as Catholics, we cannot avoid this fundamental conflict: “I fear that there is no way of avoiding it; this conflict has somehow to be fought and carried out – and this [is to be done] without a false compromise! One cannot sit it out.” [my emphasis] Laun adds, nor may one avoid this conflict by a mere “reference to obedience toward the pope,” since it is “about a self-evident Catholic matter,” namely: “The pope is infallible, but this charism is not to be understood and respected without also considering the carefully described limits [to that charism].” [my emphasis]

    The Austrian bishop then further describes some cases where a pope can, indeed, fall into error or be “a publicly recognizable sinner.” He continues, by saying: “The pope has the duty of being a father, and one may put questions to a good father, also critical ones!”

    Laun adds that, in the past, popes have certainly committed some grave errors. For example, “one pope had even thought to have found, in a volcano, the entrance to hell.” The Austrian prelate explains: “No Catholic is bound – in the face of such a mishap – to give up his reason. One may chuckle, one may contradict, yes, one may even resist if the judgment of one’s [well-formed] conscience clearly says something different.” Sometimes, says Laun, it is of course better to be silent in the face of a pope’s mistake. This, however, is – according to Laun – not the case with our current conflict. One may not “put to rest” this disputed question. “It is about the Church, it is about people and their personal relationship with God, and it is, by the way, also about image of the Catholic Church to those who are ‘outside.’” Laun concludes with the following words:

    There is a duty-bound obedience toward the pope and the authority of the Church; sometimes there exists in this Church the right – and sometimes the duty – to speak freely! It is undisputed that it can be difficult to unite both aspects under one hat. Faith and reason have to collaborate! This, too, is truly Catholic!

    Bishop Laun is to be commended for his Catholic witness here and for his insistence upon a clarification amidst the confusions stemming from Pope Francis and his Apostolic Exhortation, Amoris Laetitia. Even in a 23 December 2016 interview with OnePeterFive, Laun had already himself publicly expressed his deep sympathy and agreement with the Four Cardinals and their expressed dubia with regard to Amoris Laetitia.

    It is important, moreover, that Bishop Laun should now raise the problems of conscience which faithful and orthodox Catholic priests are now facing in the Church, especially with regard to the Seal of the Confessional. For, if a priest refuses absolution to an impenitent adulterer, he might soon be accused by that penitent of not going along with the new rules in the Church. A grave problem then arises for a priest, who may not at all even defend himself, inasmuch as he is strictly bound to be silent in accord with the Seal of Confession – as Saint John Nepomucene – a martyr to the Sacrament of Penance – was to exemplify. This actual and potentially increasing conflict might then also indirectly, yet subversively, turn out to be not only an attack on the Seal of Confession, but also an undercutting of the sacred trust in the priesthood itself.
     
    AED likes this.
  3. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    http://www.catholicculture.org/commentary/otn.cfm?ID=1202

    A Burke-Bannon conspiracy against Pope Francis? Nonsense!
    By Phil Lawler (bio - articles - email) | Feb 07, 2017

    An influential American political activist, the adviser to a controversial new President, conspires with a Catholic cardinal against the Pope. That sounds like the makings of a great story, doesn’t it? No wonder the New York Timesgave it such prominence! No wonder so many other media outlets are picking up the theme.

    Just one problem. It’s baloney.

    Actually the unmaking of this promising conspiracy theory can be found right in the story by reporter Jason Horowitz—if you look for it carefully. Yes, Steve Bannon met with Cardinal Raymond Burke during a trip to the Vatican. But that meeting took place in April 2014. That was before Bannon joined the Trump campaign team—indeed before there was a Trump presidential campaign. It was before the publication of Amoris Laetitia, before the dubia.

    At the time, Bannon was an executive for an upstart news service. Raised as a Catholic (although his current practice is a matter of some conjecture), he was keenly interested in religious affairs. As a conservative American visiting Rome, he was naturally interested in talking to an American cardinal known for his conservative views. No doubt they discussed some common interests; very likely they found that they shared mutual friends. But any suggestion that this meeting was the start of a grand conspiracy against the Holy Father is foolish.

    Pope Francis has become a focus of division within the Catholic Church, especially in recent months, for reasons that have nothing to do with Steve Bannon, much less Donald Trump. It was not Bannon who tried to rig the Synod of Bishops; Breitbart did not publish Amoris Laetitia. The Pope’s public denunciations of the Roman Curia began before Bannon’s 2014 visit, as did his attacks on the “doctors of the law.”

    Has criticism of Pope Francis become more pronounced recently? Yes, certainly. But that criticism is centered on a matter of Catholic doctrine—the teachings on marriage and the Eucharist—rather than on the political issues that are Bannon’s primary interest. (And by the way, the thrice-divorced White House aide is not likely to share Cardinal Burke’s determination to preserve the indissolubility of the marital bond.)

    American journalists tend to view all religious issues through political lenses, and consequently their view is distorted. No doubt Bannon sees possibilities for collaboration with some of the Pope’s internal critics; seeking out such alliances is, after all, a major part of his role as a political strategist. But insofar as he succeeds, he will be exploiting the divisions within the Church, not creating them.
     
  4. Mario

    Mario Powers

    Fatima,

    Is is frightening when considering that similar applications could be applied to other commandments. Lord have mercy!

    Safe in the Refuge of the Immaculate Heart!
     
    Fatima likes this.
  5. Mario

    Mario Powers

    Please expand the part of BrianK's above post which I've brought forward, so you can see what I've highlighted.

    In the last two years, I have had to make a canonical and conscience-abiding stand regarding a different issue in my own diocese. Those in authority over me have reluctantly supported my position. I say reluctantly because periodically they inquire if I have perhaps changed my view. So yes, this conflict has somehow to be fought and carried out – and this [is to be done] without a false compromise!

    Below is one of my all time favorite movies. It is allowed to remain on YouTube, I think, because they have sped it up somewhat. Please go to the interrogation scene at 1:14:00. It lasts but 4 minutes. It pertains to the issue at hand, but also at the 1:16:22-42 section it has one of the funniest lines in the movie. And we could all do with a bit of humor these days!:)



    "Will you come with me for fellowship...":LOL::ROFLMAO:

    Safe in the Barque of Peter!
     
    Last edited: Feb 8, 2017
    sunburst, Mac, Fatima and 1 other person like this.
  6. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    Link?
     
  7. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    Mac likes this.
  8. Mario

    Mario Powers

    Hmmmm? Hide and go seek!:LOL: It is there now, Brian.

    Safe in the Refuge of the Immaculate Heart!
     
    BrianK likes this.
  9. Jarg

    Jarg Archangels

    Richard 67, thank you for sharing this sermon:

    .

    It is the best piece of spiritual advice I have listened to in the current tribulation of the Church. I really hope everyone in this forum has a chance to listen to it.

    Antonio Socci just published a piece that is also calling to restrain and pointing to Cardinal Caffarra's last interview as the right tone and form for any criticism of the pope or AL or other bishops/cardinals. Indeed we are after all bound by the 4th commandment with regards to our Holy Father and our bishop, so we shall remain "in" no matter what and allow God to have the last word, not us. As the sermon above mentioned, we shall continue to pray for the pope and the church.

    That said, I think we should stay informed of what is happening without falling into scandalization (trying hard not to;-)) and without loosing hope. As the mentioned sermon says no else but our Lord will have the last say, this is all about Him! We just need to be patient and continue to pray and abandon ourselves and these disturbing events in Him, through the hands of OUR Mother.

    Here is the last news from an italian priest (sorry, it's in italian):

    https://anonimidellacroce.wordpress...a-marta-sullintercomunione-di-fra-cristoforo/

    He is reporting from his source in Santa Marta that the pope's next move is reform the liturgy with an ecumenical goal. He wants an liturgy that is not in conflict with the protestants so that the mass can be celebrated in communion with all protestant denominations. This may require changing the words of the consecration, we will see...
     
    sunburst and Mario like this.
  10. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    http://www.catholicherald.co.uk/com...is-teaching-but-they-can-damage-church-unity/

    The Maltese bishops cannot alter St John Paul II’s teaching – but they can damage Church unity
    Fr Alexander Lucie-Smith•Monday, 23 Jan 2017
    [​IMG]
    St John Paul II (CNS)
    John Paul II's Familiaris Consortio was clear on the matter - and in line with Church teaching

    The Maltese bishops’ conference has published a set of “Criteria for the Application of Chapter VIII of Amoris Laetitia”. The Criteria have not met with a positive reception in many quarters, as Edward Pentin observes in the National Catholic Register.

    The Criteria are problematic, to say the least. Firstly, they say – claiming to follow Amoris Laetitia – that if “a separated or divorced person who is living in a new relationship manages, with an informed and enlightened conscience, to acknowledge and believe that he or she are at peace with God, he or she cannot be precluded from participating in the sacraments of Reconciliation and the Eucharist.” In other words, the Maltese Criteria make explicit something that is only hinted at in Amoris Laetitia; moreover, the Criteria give permission for something that is specifically forbidden in Familiaris Consortio, the very clear teaching of St John Paul II, not to mention the very clear teaching of the Church up to now.

    Has Familiaris Consortio been abrogated? Has the Church changed her teaching? Has there been a change not just of pastoral practice, but of doctrine itself?

    My answer to that question is as follows. No Episcopal Conference can abrogate the teaching of Familiaris Consortio, let alone the constant teaching of the Church until now. In other words, faced with a choice between the teaching of St John Paul II, and the reasoning contained in these Criteria, one must go with the saint.

    Secondly, and perhaps more seriously, we are faced with an ecclesial problem. The Bishops of Poland, along with other bishops round the world, have issued criteria of their own which contradict the Maltese Criteria. Now the Maltese bishops and the Polish bishops are in communion with each other, and all other Catholic Bishops round the world. This is an essential fact of Catholicism and the communion of the Church. The trouble is, with the Maltese bishops now issuing these Criteria, it becomes harder to argue the truth of Catholicity to a non-Catholic, and it becomes harder for Catholics in the Church such as myself to believe in Catholicity. Frankly, I am struggling here to see how the faith as proclaimed in Krakow is the same faith as that proclaimed in Victoria, Gozo.

    Thirdly, these criteria introduce a very serious theological problem. What does it mean when the bishops write: “a separated or divorced person who is living in a new relationship manages, with an informed and enlightened conscience, to acknowledge and believe that he or she are at peace with God”? Isn’t this precisely what my moral theology professors at the Gregorian University in Rome warned me of when I was a student there? Namely that no man or woman can be a judge and jury in his or her own case? That we cannot ever practice self-absolution? And above all that morality is a matter of objective truth, not subjective feeling?

    Many people have in the past judged themselves to be a peace with God when they were anything but, because, quite simply, the conscience, which is a judgment, can and does make mistakes. It is this subjective turn that is most disturbing about the entire document.

    Finally, it might be worthwhile to remember that the bishops gathered in Synod in Rome did not vote for the divorced and remarried to be admitted to Holy Communion. This document not only goes beyond what is written in Amoris Laetitia, it goes far beyond anything authorised by the Synod.

    In a short article I cannot offer a solution to the pastoral problem posed by those living in second unions. But one thing seems certain to me: the solution is not the one that is advanced in these Criteria.

    The Episcopal Conference of the Maltese Islands consists of two bishops: ipso facto that must make it the smallest (or joint smallest) conference in the world. Larger conferences will surely find it harder to reach consensus. Perhaps the Maltese Criteria are being advanced as a model for other conferences. If so, the reception they have received should make everyone pause and consider.
     
    sunburst likes this.
  11. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    http://www.catholicherald.co.uk/new...he-church-because-there-is-a-growing-problem/

    Bishop Egan: pray for the Church because there is a ‘growing problem’
    Dan Hitchens•Wednesday, 8 Feb 2017
    [​IMG]
    Bishop Egan (mazur/catholicnews.org.uk)
    Bishop Egan said priests had asked whether they should obey the Pope or their bishop

    Bishop Philip Egan of Portsmouth has said there is a “growing problem” in the Church and called for prayer.

    After a meeting with his diocesan council of priests, Bishop Egan tweeted that the question had arisen of whether to obey one’s bishop or the Pope. He replied: “I’d say Both!”

    However, the bishop added: “But there’s a growing problem: let’s pray for the Church.”

    Council of Priests yesterday: Whom do we obey, the bishop or the pope? I'd say Both! But there's a growing problem: let's pray 4 the Church

    — Bishop Philip Egan (@BishopEgan) 2:58 AM - 8 Feb 2017
    The council is a group of about 15-20 priests of the diocese. The Catholic Herald understands that a member of the group asked the bishop about obedience with reference to the question of Communion for the remarried.

    In his pastoral letter on Amoris Laetitia, written last April, Bishop Egan wrote: “Does the Pope say the divorced and civilly remarried may now be readmitted to Holy Communion? No.

    “What he says is that instead they need a good priest to reach out to them, to accompany them, to help them discern their situation before the Lord and to enable them to develop, to change and to take their proper place in the Church’s life and mission.”

    Bishop Egan said that Amoris Laetitia was consistent with the teaching of Pope St John Paul II, Pope Benedict XVI, and canon law, which have all upheld the Church’s traditional teaching on Communion.

    However, the bishops’ conferences of Malta and Germany have recently issued guidelines which contradict the teaching. They have claimed the Pope’s support.
     
  12. djmoforegon

    djmoforegon Powers

    Jarg, I agree with you about the video. It restored my peace in spades. I just need to watch it once a week.
     
  13. DivineMercy

    DivineMercy Archangels

    Bishop Schneider in Mexico City, posted this morning. Really good:

     
  14. padraig

    padraig Powers

    Sigh, sigh, sigh
     
  15. padraig

    padraig Powers

    Much need for prayer and Sacrifice. Much , much prayer. It looks to me like the Third Secret of Fatima has come to pass.



    [​IMG]
     
  16. Julia

    Julia Immaculate Heart of Mary, pray for us.

    I notice in different posts Padraig very angry about something. I have avoided reading too much on the confusing news coming out from the hierarchy/media because it leaves me drained and lacking in peace to be honest.

    I do like the post above reminding us of how Blessed Mother advised us to respond. And the last two Medjugorje messages were really confirmation for what Blessed Mother said at Fatima.

    We just have to say the Rosary, and try and make at least little sacrifices in order to feel at peace on our journey through life, if we truly want to serve Our Lord.

    Michael Voris seems to tell it like it is, and I can only take him in bite size pieces to be honest.
     
    HeavenlyHosts likes this.
  17. Fatima

    Fatima Powers

    Praying the rosary daily will give everyone the courage to stand against apostasy in these times. I think this may be the only thing that will keep the faithful, faithful. But one must ask for this gift of remaining faithful to the unchanging truths of God, lest you fall. We are seeing it all around us now.
     
    Beth B and HeavenlyHosts like this.
  18. padraig

    padraig Powers

    No Julia a great rage for the House of God fills me

    I demand a Holy Fire on the Vatican


    I go before the Mother of God and the Holy Angels for immediate retribution

    Psalm 69:9

    for zeal for your house consumes me, and the insults of those who insult you fall on me.

    I request immediate retribution
     
  19. padraig

    padraig Powers

    I request immediate retribution

    I request immediate retributiion on the Vatican
     
  20. padraig

    padraig Powers

    2 Kings 1:10

    Elijah Denounces Ahaziah
    …9Then the king sent to him a captain of fifty with his fifty. And he went up to him, and behold, he was sitting on the top of the hill. And he said to him, "O man of God, the king says, 'Come down.'" 10Elijah replied to the captain of fifty, "If I am a man of God, let fire come down from heaven and consume you and your fifty." Then fire came down from heaven and consumed him and his fifty. 11So he again sent to him another captain of fifty with his fifty. And he said to him, "O man of God, thus says the king, 'Come down quickly.'"…New Americ

    May God Judge between them and me


    may your judgement be swift dear Lord


    [​IMG]
     
    Last edited: Feb 8, 2017

Share This Page